Slashdot Mirror


User: Colonel+Korn

Colonel+Korn's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
1,802
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 1,802

  1. Several Corrections from Someone in the Field on How Concrete Contributed To the Downfall of the Roman Empire · · Score: 5, Informative

    Let me correct several points, some of which have already been pointed out by other posters:

    1) Davies, who is an excellent scholar and shouldn't have to be associated with bizarre out of context fundamentally broken articles like the one linked from the summary, says that construction of public concrete buildings was a political tool used by Pompey and Julius in an escalating bid for political power. She points out that this was a factor in the end of the Roman REPUBLIC because Julius and later Augustus eventually collected enough power to bring about the establishment of the Roman EMPIRE. So while TFS, and indeed the terrible article in the ridiculously trashy "International Business Times," state that concrete led to the downfall of the empire, their source instead says that concrete was one of many factors that led to the FORMATION of the empire. In otherwords, TFS and TFA both state exactly the opposite of what the source stated.

    2) This statement about concrete contributing to the founding of the Roman Empire has been present in high school textbooks for at least a hundred years. It's not news.

    3) The real news that prompted the article is also misrepresented. French scholars recently published a paper pointing out that the level of lead in Roman drinking water wouldn't have had significant side effects. Both TFS and TFA state that the previous theory on the fall of the Roman Empire was that it was due to lead poisoning. This isn't even remotely accurate. Yes, crackpots have published claims that lead poisoning led to degenerate Romans. In no way has it ever, not even for a moment, been accepted by scholars as "the cause" of the Roman Empire's fall. There is no single cause of the fall of the Roman Empire. It wasn't an asteroid or aliens or disease - it lasted for a ridiculously long time and eventually fell apart over the course of about 1500 years. The number of scholars who believed that the Roman Empire "fell" because of lead poisoning was similar to the number of paleontologists who believe the dinosaurs died out because of Noah's flood.

    It's too bad that the simple debunking of this crackpot theory in the study published by the French team was reported in the International Business Times by such an unintelligent reporter, and even worse that Slashdot picked the story up without recognizing the inaccuracies that any 8 year old with a 100 IQ would be able to detect.

    A couple months ago Slashdot went through a transition. It became useless for awhile because every article was flooded with complaints about the new site design, but I think that there was a simultaneous shift toward poorer editing and lower quality story submissions. Maybe the cleverer Slashdot posters did what I have and mostly stopped paying attention. I've spent 10 years laughing at the people who post about how Slashdot declined since the good old days, but recent evidence shows that the decline is real and undoubtable. Perhaps the editors suffer from lead poisoning.

    Or concrete.

  2. Clarification on Google Announces Smart Contact Lens Project For Diabetics · · Score: 1

    Before anyone gets the idea that Google did meaningful research, know that the real science and technology here has been demonstrated in labs for 20 years. The quotation from Google in TFS makes it look like Google solved a "mystery" and did science, but what they did is normal Google work: they packaged other people's publicly funded and disclosed work, slapped patent protection on it, and commercialized it. To some people this is the heart of innovation, but whether or not you think it's impressive, at least recognize that Google did polishing and packaging here, not an iota of science.

  3. Re:is Google turning evil? on You're Only As Hirable As Your Google+ Circles · · Score: 1

    What you do is you delete both and switch to an email provider who is less insane and has a better idea what you want.

    I'd love to do so. To answer the GP, I think Google has been hellbent on being evil since it was founded. On the other hand, I'm lazy and I like the Gmail interface, plus the nearly instant push of new messages to my phone. Does anyone have a recommendation for a much more privacy-focused email provider with a Gmail-like interface (even better if it's like Gmail from a couple years ago) and two-factor authentication?

  4. Re:Slow scrolling... on Yahoo! Sports Redesign Sparks Controversy, Disdain From Users · · Score: 1

    The redesign isn't the worst I've seen, but damn it scrolls slow. There seems to be about a one second delay between me hitting my scroll wheel and the page actually responding. I didn't have this issue on the old player pages.

    The scrolling wouldn't even be that huge of an issue, but they have forced all the relevant information (stats) down below all of the pointless crap (I don't really care where Buster Posey was born). So now the first thing I have to do on their player pages is... scroll down to the bottom, which now takes forever.

    What type of education does it take to develop and design websites; highschool? GED?

    It's not just that they've added pointless crap above the useful info, but even if you scroll down to see the useful info it now requires about 2000 vertical pixels to do something as simple as see what's going on in a baseball game, which means constantly clunky scrolling. Even that might be justified if the lower information density made it less cluttered and easier to read, but with the pointless crap additions and the busy backgrounds, it's very difficult to quickly parse the data right in the middle of your screen.

    From an objective "how much time and effort does it take for me to get the information out of this page?" perspective, this is the worst redesign of any product I've ever seen, and I'm including non-computer products. In all of recorded history, I'm not aware of a bigger design mistake.

  5. Re:someone's gotta start the show on Silicon Valley's Loony Cheerleading Culture Is Out of Control · · Score: 2

    I think that much of the 90% failure rate has to be blamed on the venture firms, which are very reluctant to invest in any idea that isn't the 10th clone of an already highly visible and possibly successful idea. If you make the 100th photo sharing app with geotagging and integration with Facebook and it looks like it has a clean interface, you can probably find an investor. If you come up with a truly new concept you'll be met with blank stares and FUD based on the lack of a proven market.

  6. Re:Thanks Kovid! on Calibre Version 1.0 Released After 7 Years of Development · · Score: 5, Insightful

    So what? Nobody held a gun to his head and forced him to work on it.

    Sorry to feed the troll, but this one's amusing. I enjoy the implication that only work performed at the barrel of a firearm should be rewarded.

  7. Re:a result of eco-freaks on Wildfire Threatens Water and Power To San Francisco · · Score: 1

    Aa a result of the eco-freaks preventing natural fires for so long, then letting them go...they get what they deserve.

    Not this fire.

  8. Re:Some people are 0 miles away on Wildfire Threatens Water and Power To San Francisco · · Score: 1

    This fire is burning right next to actual people, not sure why we need to worry about SF 200 miles away. Actual people are right on the fire line in danger, they should be the ones reported on. I know this is a tech site and the bay is the tech center, but remember the firefighters and civilians that are actually on site, and not just experiencing a minor inconvenience.

    Thank you. This morning the visibility from my house at the edge of the evacuation zone was under 100 feet. I couldn't see the house across the street. The effect on SF is smaller than the effect on Groveland, Pine Mountain Lake, Tuolumne City, and even Reno.

    Another point that should be made is that SF is almost exactly 100 miles west, not 200. I wonder who came up with the 200 number and why it stuck. You know what's 200 miles east of SF? Nevada.

  9. Re:Not to worry, on Wildfire Threatens Water and Power To San Francisco · · Score: 1

    Rain is in the forcast for the area, it should put out the fire just before the mud-slides start.

    I know this is a joke post, but I'll reply since it's been modded +4 informative.

    No, rain hasn't been forecast in the area. Humidity during the day is around 20%.

    Also, no, there aren't mudslides in burnt areas in this part of the state. The soil and root systems are quite different from those in southern California.

  10. Re:What is it about the Nook? on Barnes & Noble Won't Give Up On the Nook · · Score: 2

    I have an older Kindle, and 2 Kobo's. I've never tried a Nook (can't recall ever seeing one in a store up here in Canada but the Kobo's can be found in lots of stores) so I can't tell if it's better or not. I don't tend to judge by features only, I like trying them out.

    A big selling point with me is there needs to be a button to turn the page and it has to be comfortable to hold with 1 hand while turning pages, something you can't really do with touch gestures to turn pages.

    Basically when I'm asking is, what does Nook bring to the table that the others do not?

    It's pretty similar to current Kindles, but the current 7" Nook HD (my wife has one) feels more comfortable than my equivalent7" Kindle Fire HD for long reading sessions for each of us thanks to a somewhat different curvature to the back. The other thing the Nook has is access to the Google app store, which I won't mention by name because then it sounds dumb.

  11. Re:No need for an expansion, Blizzard on Diablo 3 Expansion Announced: Reaper of Souls · · Score: 1

    You're already reaped my soul with Diablo 3. I had to Exile myself to repair the damage you've done to my soul.

    "legendary items will include unique ways to modify how your character functions" is one of the ~10 innovations that make Path of Exile so much better than D3, and given Blizzard's track record I'm confident that the D3 expansion implementation won't be nearly as interesting or fun as the feature it's cloning from PoE.

  12. Re:Only one thing is for sure... on Why the NSA Can't Replace 90% of Its System Administrators · · Score: 1, Flamebait

    Probably hundreds of thousands of people have worked for the NSA and only a small hand full of them have betrayed their country, stole secrets, and defected.

    Working for the NSA is a betrayal of country, so I think that 100% of those people have by definition earned your disapproval.

  13. Re: Here's the real problem on Studying the Slow Decay of a Laptop Battery For an Entire Year · · Score: 1

    Try that with a transmission and see if you get more than a 12 month warranty. New batteries might not have a massively longer warranty but given that they are still very new technology and the transmissions and engines are a century old, it begs the question of why they still can't provide a replacement product worthy of a better warranty?

    In my experience, replacement transmissions typically have lifetime warranties.

  14. Re:So basically surfing net while taking notes on Using Laptop To Take Notes Lowers Grades · · Score: 1

    Wonder if this study would still be the same if they were actually writing, but using a ipad or something. Digital notes. Or if the results would still be similar because the kicker is the fact that these people tend to wander off on to the interwebs

    It would have to be something with an active digitizer, like the Surface Pro, to allow comfortable handwritten notes. Even if you wear a gloves to fix the palm issue, iPad note taking with a capacitive stylus is pretty clunky and inaccurate.

  15. Functional Holster on Ask Slashdot: Is There a Good Device Holster? · · Score: 1
  16. Re:Actually I wouldn't be surprised. on Larry Ellison Believes Apple Is Doomed · · Score: 1

    Jobs also fought against apps on the iPhone, initially recruited John Sculley, and pushed the Lisa. He's not perfect.

    Another thing is that Apple historically has used a lot of plastic (ex. those jolly rancher iMacs, iPods, basically everything before the iPhone).

    iOS7 looks fine to me although I would agree that some of the icons look silly.

    He also fought viciously against the idea of a computer display ever being able to display more than one color and against arrow keys on keyboards.

  17. Re:pen and paper on Ask Slashdot: Best Software For Med-School Note-Taking? · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Totally agree, PENCIL + PAPER is the answer.

    Do you want to spend your time swapping between apps, waiting for apps to load, trying to draw with your laptop's touchpad, and otherwise concentrating on the technology rather than concentrating on the discussion?

    If you want to review your paper notes and make them digital at some point after class, that is up to you. But for simple flexibility and reliability, paper is the answer.

    Write on it. Draw on it. Re-use it in another class. Archive it. Paper does all the things asked for in the article.

    OneNote and a tablet with an active digitizer is searchable pencil and paper. It's not any more cumbersome than a notebook but it's far better for finding old notes.

  18. First Thing to Replace on Behind the Story of the iPhone's Default Text Tone · · Score: 2

    The first thing I did when I got an iPhone 5 was to replace this sound with the much subtler but more recognizable HTC Woodblock sound I've been using for several years. But now I call it Fakeblock for obvious reasons.

  19. Re:Economic Bonanza on How Much Should You Worry About an Arctic Methane Bomb? · · Score: 1

    Suppose the $60T estimate is right. Isn't that good? In a closed economy, income equals expenditure. Earth, for now, is a closed economy. Therefore, if we spend $60T on goods and services to deal with methane, then we will have $60T in income.

    That's the Broken Window Fallacy (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Broken_window_fallacy). However, if you believe that the majority of the world's endeavors are currently without value, then uniting the world behind a massive response to this sort of global change may be comparatively better, which points out one of the holes in the BWF.

  20. Re:Results replicated? on Hybrid Hard Drives Just Need 8GB of NAND · · Score: 1

    Have the results been independently replicated? Were details of the benchmarking methodology published anywhere?

    If you actually care, just look at Anandtech's reviews of hybrid drives. They're not as rosy as Seagate claims, but some of them benchmark decently in realistic workflow simulations.

  21. Re:Wrong choice on Hybrid Hard Drives Just Need 8GB of NAND · · Score: 1

    Yeah, but typical office PCs are already plenty fast for the things they typically do, so they aren't in need of a big boost. That's why PC manufacturers have been concentrating on making them smaller and cheaper rather than more powerful. It's those data sensitive applications that are atypical of office PCs that are the market for high performance drives.

    Besides, if you only need 9.5 GB of unique data per day, you're probably better off upgrading your RAM rather than your hard drive. The stuff you access most will get cached, and you'll have plenty of memory on the odd chance you ever do need to do something that requires a lot.

    Typical office PCs at Fortune 500 companies are incredibly sluggish because of the vast suite of security, update, and backup software running on them. The last time I got a new workstation I had a day where I got to use it before it got all of the corporate software. I booted in 20 seconds, loaded office documents in about 1 second, and felt no lag doing typical office computer stuff. With the corporate suite installed I have a 5 minute boot and simple tasks like opening Outlook or a Powerpoint file vary wildly in required duration, with a daily range of 1 second to 30 seconds. Sometimes it will take 5 seconds to show the results of a file search within a single directory.

    I have a coworker who just got the new version of the workstation, which is essentially the same but with an SSD, and even with all the corporate stuff it's faster than my workstation was when new.

  22. Re:640K on Hybrid Hard Drives Just Need 8GB of NAND · · Score: 1

    Nobody ever said Bill Gates ever said that.

    About a hundred Slashdot comments per week claim that Bill Gates said that.

  23. Re:Passwords have to be in the clear anyway on Chrome's Insane Password Security Strategy · · Score: 1

    Passwords have to be stored in a decryptable form, because the browser needs them decrypted to fill in the password fields or to respond to HTTP authentication responses. That means that any malware with access to the browser can get those passwords in decrypted form too. A master password doesn't help, the malware can just get the passwords after I've entered the master password to decrypt them for use (assuming it can't just get the master password when I enter it). The only thing encrypted password storage really protects against is someone with access to the physical storage media but not the running system, or essentially stolen mobile devices (phones or laptops). On those you probably shouldn't be storing passwords at all, because any reversible encryption is too easy to crack using off-line attacks with modern hardware.

    It's similar to my objection to the old "don't write down your passwords" thing: the risk of a remote attack against easy-to-remember passwords is much higher than the risk of an attacker physically getting into the locked drawer of my desk in the locked area of the secured and patrolled building my office is in, and if the attacker has gotten into the locked drawer in my desk I've got much bigger security worries and the attacker has much juicier targets he can go after.

    TFA doesn't seem concerned with malware. It seems to be based on the idea that normal people with physical access to your computer can steal your passwords. From that perspective I think it makes a good point. Probably something like 10-50% of browser users know how to look at the saved password list. If they try to retrieve those passwords on Chrome, they click a few times and write down the passwords. On Firefox, which offers a master password, they click a few times and then give up when they don't know that master password.

    The scope of this scenario is an order of magnitude greater than the most widespread malware infections.

  24. Re:Firefox is the same on Chrome's Insane Password Security Strategy · · Score: 1

    Firefox menu -> Preferences -> Security -> Saved Passwords -> Show Passwords

    Firefox: "Please enter the master password."

  25. Re:This is also the case on Firefox on Chrome's Insane Password Security Strategy · · Score: 1

    I know it has been discussed many times to password lock access to stored passwords, though because browsers are not user-specific, this has not been done.

    I'm sorry, but there is a dedicated area for my stuff -- on Windows it's Documents and Settings, and on UNIX it's the home directory. The actual program may not be user specific, but all operating systems have a "home" area specific to users. There are no valid technical reasons why this can't be made secure, other than either having no interest in doing it, or pandering to users who just want convenience.

    This is just a piss-poor implementation of security, and it's why I don't trust a browser to retain passwords for me, and never have. I rank it right up there with giving Facebook my password so they can log into my email and find friends -- not happening, because I don't trust them with my password.

    If this guy is the head of 'security' for Chrome, he's either incompetent at that, or Google as a general rule have a shitty idea about what security should be and he's of the opinion this is "good enough".

    But since Google mostly just wants to collect all of your data, it may not be of value to them to lock it down in any meaningful way.

    Google's response to everything is "no, we're doing it the best way." I find it best just to avoid talking to Googlers about their jobs.