Slashdot Mirror


User: Afforess

Afforess's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
243
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 243

  1. Re:Slippery Slope is a Logical Fallacy on Fluorescent Monkeys Cast Light On Human Disease · · Score: 1

    but to cry "logical fallacy" here is just an attempt to dismiss the objection without discussing its actual merits.

    I'm pretty sure that's what I did, right here:

    The error is that the Dr. David King equates changing monkeys to genetic engineering and then assumes that genetic engineering on other organisms, namely humans, is inevitable; since human genetic engineering is bad, then all genetic engineering MUST be bad.

  2. Re:Slippery Slope is a Logical Fallacy on Fluorescent Monkeys Cast Light On Human Disease · · Score: 1
    Please reread the

    Dr. David King equates

    part again. It isn't my argument, it's his. My point was that is doesn't make sense.

  3. Slippery Slope is a Logical Fallacy on Fluorescent Monkeys Cast Light On Human Disease · · Score: 2, Insightful

    We may find ourselves gradually drifting towards the genetic engineering of human beings

    This argument is correctly labeled as a "slippery slope" argument, but what the author fails to mention is that "slippery slope" arguments are part of a group of arguments known as logical fallacy's. The error is that the Dr. David King equates changing monkeys to genetic engineering and then assumes that genetic engineering on other organisms, namely humans, is inevitable; since human genetic engineering is bad, then all genetic engineering MUST be bad. This is illogical.

  4. Asimov on Robot Warfare Going Open Source · · Score: 5, Funny

    Quick, someone embed the three laws in the linux kernal.

  5. Re:Ethanol is just stupid on The Great Ethanol Scam · · Score: 4, Informative

    Umm, the American Ethanol Debacle is not a product of government

    Sure it is, the only reason the industry had a chance was because of big government subsidies. It was always a money loser, but the government saved them.

  6. Re:Ethanol is just stupid on The Great Ethanol Scam · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I wish the anti-government types would realize just how many free market failurs there out out there.

    The free market's whole point is to kill failures, so no doubt there is many. The parent's point was when the government leads a "helping" hand to failures that it only hurts consumers in the end.

  7. Re:Oh really? on In Istanbul, Cameras To Recognize 15,000 Faces/sec. · · Score: 1

    What about byzantine?

  8. Re:invention vs innovation on Microsoft Gaming Patents — Where They're Going · · Score: 1

    There is some support for your argument in history. The X-Ray machine, for example, was never patented. This allowed the device to be made easily and in great quantities and allowed for the widespread adoption of it.

  9. Re:Patenting away the competition on Microsoft Gaming Patents — Where They're Going · · Score: 2
    I don't know about you, but the wireless syncing and game support was much better than the Ipod's until the touch came out. Those were great features, but even the best products fail with terrible ads and marketing.

    It was just marketed poorly and could beat the Ipod's cool factor.

    Geek-cool or cool-people cool? Because, quite frankly, they're very different.

    Don't hurt yourself thinking about this question, I realize it's very difficult.

  10. Prior Art on Microsoft Gaming Patents — Where They're Going · · Score: 1

    patent 20080167127 covers switching a gaming console between various media, including television, video, music, and games

    Wow, that sounds just like a remote control.

  11. Re:including television on Microsoft Gaming Patents — Where They're Going · · Score: 1

    Or you could buy two monitors, watch TV on one, play on the other.

  12. Re:Patenting away the competition on Microsoft Gaming Patents — Where They're Going · · Score: 1

    The Zune isn't/wasn't a bad device, in fact it had features that Ipods lacked for many years. It was just marketed poorly and could beat the Ipod's cool factor.

  13. Password strength is meaningless. on Calculating Password Policy Strength Vs. Cracking · · Score: 1

    Who cares about password strength anyway? A four letter password is still stronger protection than most people give. The weak link in the chain is and always has been humans. I've found that the security questions to reset the password are easier than the password to crack. Either that or just wait for some Security Official to slip up and sell a hard drive with passwords and usernames on ebay.

  14. Re:Really Watson? Elementary? on Aspiring Massachusetts Teachers Fail In Math · · Score: 1

    The answer is D, obviously. I thought trick questions was an area that teachers had to excel in.

  15. Re:Stop it! on Virgin Media UK Pilots 200Mbps Broadband Speeds · · Score: 1

    you get throttled back to ISDN speeds for a few hours

    I wish I could be throttled to ISDN speeds, that's faster than my existing connection. Thank you AT&T.

  16. Re:Some crazy conspiracy? on Why Is Connectivity So Cheap In Stockholm? · · Score: 1

    It just goes to show the importance of moderation in all things. Moderation in regulation. Moderation in privatization.

    Moderation in Moderation?

  17. Re:Riiiight on Climate Engineering As US Policy? · · Score: 2, Insightful

    That's actually not a bad idea, considering that Venus is in many ways similar to earth. Venus's average temperature is 461 Celsius, so it would be ideal for testing the injection of micro-particles into the atmosphere.

  18. Re:Jurisdiction on Climate Engineering As US Policy? · · Score: 3, Interesting

    I would advise you to read Fallen Angels as you seem to have described the premise quite well. Of course, you did forget the ending.

  19. Re:1st Amendment? on Senator Proposes Nonprofit Status For Newspapers · · Score: 1

    Not really, because the assumption is that everyone deserves to be taxed. Not being taxed is the exception - it's a special privilege, and if you want that status, you are required to do certain things.

    Actually, taxation started the opposite way. The income tax was originally created to only tax the wealthiest .001% of the population. Those taxed were the exception, not the rule. It's only been the last 75 years or so that everyone else has been paying more taxes.

  20. Re:Why do you boot XP every morning? on Fastbooting Linux For Dummies? · · Score: 2

    Trees are sustainable though.

  21. Re:Pay $31M, Made $300M on Hitachi Fined $31 Million For LCD Price Fixing · · Score: 3, Insightful

    The best part, the new LCD screens will cost more because they have to cover "court costs." It's a lose-lose situation for consumers.

  22. My Mistake... on Microsoft Secret Prototype Phone Stolen · · Score: 0, Troll

    The thief is probably regretting his decision right this minute.

    Thief: "Sweet, I bagged another Iphone! Wait, what is this?
    M-Phone:"Welcome to Microsoft Windows Phone Edition. Please Wait."
    Thief: "NOOOO!" (The thief throws the phone in the 1st available dumpster)

  23. Re:Ok then... on Researchers Hack Biometric Faces · · Score: 1

    Everything is somewhat vulnerable, and a determined intruder with infinite resource will almost always find a way in.

    The point is facial recognition alone is so vulnerable! All you need is a cameraphone and a photo printer - and you can't revoke your face as your password either. At least with fingerprints you can get hacked nearly 10 times (on average) before it becomes a problem.

    Regular locks are SO vulnerable too. Why do we use them? Because it deters petty thieves. If I see $10 on the ground, I grab it. If I see it behind a locked locker door, I keep walking.

  24. Re:Environmental issues on Stimulus Could Kickstart US Battery Industry · · Score: 1

    But, would you like to pay $5 a AA battery? That's what the result would be. As much as we hate pollution and forced Chinese labor, we also hate high prices even more. Also, what would you do with Mexicans and Canadians smuggling batteries across the border. That's what will happen, like it or not.

  25. Re:Pretty Pictures with Little to No Functionality on Spiraling Skyscraper Farms For a Future Manhattan · · Score: 1

    You forget that farming pollutes too. Farms require the use of pesticides, herbicides, and fertilizer, all of which are toxic to humans.