Now, what happens if I "jailbreak" an Android phone, and flush the OS images (typically boot and userdata), e.g. with Cyanogenmod, Replicant, Ubuntu. Will I automatically unlock the carrier lock as well? Or is there a way to retain the carrier lock, and still install an OS of my choice?
This is why I will always come back to Slashdot. There will always be some guy, like yourself, delivering the most absurd, but at the same time spot on comment, managing to combine wit, insight, technical details, sarcasm, cynicism, and reality into a beautifully constructed one-liner (which, as you can see, I am not capable of), and make me laugh of loud! -- Congratulations! Keep 'em coming!
The term “intellectual property” is at best a catch-all to lump together disparate laws. Nonlawyers who hear one term applied to these various laws tend to assume they are based on a common principle and function similarly.
Nothing could be further from the case. These laws originated separately, evolved differently, cover different activities, have different rules, and raise different public policy issues.
So no, patent and copyright laws do not "overlap". (As for your first sentence, I'm not even sure what it means; "The need"? Right now I need a coffee, but that is certainly not based on any patent...)
It's easy to jump to knee-jerk conclusions about some arbitrary number which "feels small". Once you do the math, as the parent just did, it becomes clear that it is perfectly fine. In fact, writing 60 GB / day is for most home user a HUGE margin, so the drive should be able to last much longer than three years.
The GPL is based on copyright law. It is *not* predicated on any kind of patent law. Those are completely different laws, and it is important to know the difference, lest we get caught in the "intellectual property" mumbo jumbo.
Well, where my mate works, the access swipes are timestamped, registered, and stored. Access to the logs are restricted, but in HR related cases, they can look at when you came in, and where you walked.
After the disaster which is my current Dell 2709W (27", 1920x1200), I'll never buy Dell again.
Out of the box, about four years ago, it always had major overheating problems, which manifests itself as jitter on grey-tones (old style Windows 95 UI looks like a xmas tree). Then, in the last year, a vertical purple line 2-3 pixels wide has started to appear when I turn the screen on. It goes away after about 20 minutes. So yeah, probably bad caps.
Then, there is the f*** buttons. Almost every time I want to switch between input sources, the OSD menu times out before I can get to the right source. Just as often, the confirm button does not register the click, and I have to go all over again. F*** annoying! The old models, which had a dedicated physical button for input source was much better. I notice your U2711 has the same "fancy buttons", so it's a no-go for me.
Finally, it's the card-reader and USB hub; it doesn't work, or only works sometimes. No a big deal of course, but simply useless. However, this seems to be a rather consistent problem with Dell monitors. The same thing keeps happening to many of the 24" models at work.
Overall, I'm happy I got the monitor at the time I did, however, my next will be an Eizo, price be dammed.
The back of a pen is sufficient to point at something. No need to smear grease all over my screen. I've tried to wash it away, but it doesn't get properly clean; not like a pristine out-of-the box look anyway.
Thank you, finally somebody how understands me! Finger-prints all over the screen is disgusting.
And if they really have to point at something, it's far better to use the back of a pen, or similar. That way my view is not obstructed by half an arm.
Good read; thanks. However, you seem to be more of a half-empty than half-full type?
Only looking at your last paragraph, I'd see gold, if I was running a small-town computer shop, or in my university years again. Charge people $100-200 to fix up their computer by installing a GNU/Linux distribution. Or, if that's not interesting, exchange their old hardware, and re-sell that to somebody else. Maybe supplement the business with some courses.
(Just don't patent the business plan though; stories of people doing exactly that have been frequent over the last couple of years).
“Android is very different from the GNU/Linux operating system because it contains very little of GNU. Indeed, just about the only component in common between Android and GNU/Linux is Linux, the kernel. People who erroneously think “Linux” refers to the entire GNU/Linux combination get tied in knots by these facts, and make paradoxical statements such as “Android contains Linux, but it isn’t Linux”. If we avoid starting from the confusion, the situation is simple: Android contains Linux, but not GNU; thus, Android and GNU/Linux are mostly different.“
Linux has always been, and will always be just the kernel. Although the kernel is at the core of an operating system, it is not the complete OS. It sounds what you are looking for is the rest of the OS, typically the GNU tools. We can all save a lot of text and sweat by using the those three letters when discussing OS specific topics.
What you call it when talking to non-technical people does not matter that much. However, here on Slashdot everybody will understand "Android is not GNU/Linux".
I'm all with you, and keep seeing these things being used in places where there are much better tools for the job: Go to any tourist attraction these days, and you'll find people holding up their aluminium slabs to take pictures. Surely, if you can afford a trip around the world, you can also get a half-decent camera. Then there are the people who claim that writing e-mails, articles and even books is without effort on these things. The mind boggles.
As for niche use cases, I can think of a few: Once you get down to $50-100 range, they might make better picture frames than the dedicated devices for that purpose. For face-to-face survey-taking they work very well; think trade-show booth, or door-to-door questionnaires. An architect / building inspector recently mentioned that his tablet helped him is his job, so I'll have to take his word for it.
However, for John Doe, it's nothing but a fashion accessory at the moment. And as long as the iPad costs 5-10x times its competition, it will continue to be a show-off, just like bespoke suites, gold watches, and small-dick cars.
We need free and open source software now more than ever. The laws against installing any think you like on a tablet goes to show how backwards some people have this issue. We need free software to prove that there are a lot of alternative OSes out there, and that doing anything you like with the hardware you'd bought should be the law, as opposed to what is currently the case.
So, let's throw out the "pack of four", and build and use our own alternatives, whatever that might be. You bought the hardware; you own it.
Using the term GNU/Linux clarifies the topic, while stating "Android is Linux" makes it more confused. Just like a Boeing 777 is not a Rolls-Royce just because of its engines, so Android is not Linux. The kernel is of course a critical part of the OS, but it is not the only part.
You're absolutely right, a lot of this is due to the patent and copyright shenanigans of the major industry players. They commit fraud and treason against society in broad daylight. So if there was software "that is acceptable to the six major motion picture distributors", I would reject it on principle. Example: I have never, and will never, buy anything related to BluRay.
As for the tax software, I'm not quite sure what you get from the accounting firms. A list of loopholes? Just some slightly more friendly documentation than from the state? In the various countries that I have filled in taxes, the software I used was free of charge, and distributed by the national tax authority or city counsel. In one instance through a central web service where you would fill in and save the number online, and in another through cross-platform (Java) software, which also included a GNU/Linux installer. If I needed more help, I could certainly pay an accountant, however, even at a very moderate rate, I think I would incur a net loss.
Finally, for video games, I made an exception, and went for a console. That took a long time to reason about: Should I pay any of these companies at all, and if so, which one was the lesser of evil. In the end, I feel the choice between Microsoft and Sony was arbitrary. Neither company deserves a penny from me, and I would happily see both vanish. So maybe I made a mistake.
Well, what I wish for already exists, with millions of people benefiting and contributing to many thousand free and open source projects all over the world. If you were not aware of that, I'd suggest you download one of the common GNU/Linux distributions (it's for free), and give it a go. Try to apt-get, or similar, any application you'd like to use, and it will be installed within seconds, without any other action or transaction needed on your part. Even after nearly two decades, the efficiency and quality of the repositories blows me away every time. If I had to, I'd fight vigorously to protect that model, for others and for myself.
The Windows, OSX and Android ecosystems are infested with a culture of greed and egoism. Pay $10 for DVD-burning software, $15 for an archive program, $120 for anti-virus, $50 for an SSH client/server, $40 for a media player, and so on and so on.
If I can contribute to the community in some way, and get free and libre software in return, that seems like a much better deal for everybody. But by all means, if somebody wants to put energy into a distribution which mimics the money culture of Windows and OSX, all power to them. I'm just not interested.
> Lets just hope you can trust the ATM's that you use.
No, you cannot. I've lost count of how many times my cards have been skimmed and defrauded in various ways. Luckily, I have not taken any loss myself, but it is still a hassle to report, renew the cards, etc.
If you are really paranoid about these things, you'll have to use cash as you said, but go inside the bank to withdraw your money. On a regular basis, that's probably even more hassle, and also puts you at risk of being mugged.
As always, security is a trade-off and compromise between a whole set of different attack vectors vs. convenience and ease of use of the security measures. There is no way to make it perfect, and we will just have to continue updating the security systems and practises as new threads emerge. Also, the same solutions will not fit all; each will have to judge for himself what is the best combination of security vs. convenience.
Slashdot Mirror
They sure don't make the wooosh'es as they used back in the old day...
I know! Even I am not that grumpy. (but maybe his dog got murdered ten years ago)
Thanks for clarifying.
Now, what happens if I "jailbreak" an Android phone, and flush the OS images (typically boot and userdata), e.g. with Cyanogenmod, Replicant, Ubuntu. Will I automatically unlock the carrier lock as well? Or is there a way to retain the carrier lock, and still install an OS of my choice?
This is why I will always come back to Slashdot. There will always be some guy, like yourself, delivering the most absurd, but at the same time spot on comment, managing to combine wit, insight, technical details, sarcasm, cynicism, and reality into a beautifully constructed one-liner (which, as you can see, I am not capable of), and make me laugh of loud! -- Congratulations! Keep 'em coming!
Read and learn:
http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/not-ipr.html
The term “intellectual property” is at best a catch-all to lump together disparate laws. Nonlawyers who hear one term applied to these various laws tend to assume they are based on a common principle and function similarly.
Nothing could be further from the case. These laws originated separately, evolved differently, cover different activities, have different rules, and raise different public policy issues.
So no, patent and copyright laws do not "overlap". (As for your first sentence, I'm not even sure what it means; "The need"? Right now I need a coffee, but that is certainly not based on any patent...)
This should be modded up.
It's easy to jump to knee-jerk conclusions about some arbitrary number which "feels small". Once you do the math, as the parent just did, it becomes clear that it is perfectly fine. In fact, writing 60 GB / day is for most home user a HUGE margin, so the drive should be able to last much longer than three years.
The GPL is based on copyright law. It is *not* predicated on any kind of patent law. Those are completely different laws, and it is important to know the difference, lest we get caught in the "intellectual property" mumbo jumbo.
Installing Windows would be more like ripping out his memory banks?
> Voice input for things like setting timer names?
Yes, I can see how that goes:
- nineteen minutes, please
Starting ninety minute program...
OTA update started. Please to not shut down the own while this is in progress
Well, where my mate works, the access swipes are timestamped, registered, and stored. Access to the logs are restricted, but in HR related cases, they can look at when you came in, and where you walked.
After the disaster which is my current Dell 2709W (27", 1920x1200), I'll never buy Dell again.
Out of the box, about four years ago, it always had major overheating problems, which manifests itself as jitter on grey-tones (old style Windows 95 UI looks like a xmas tree). Then, in the last year, a vertical purple line 2-3 pixels wide has started to appear when I turn the screen on. It goes away after about 20 minutes. So yeah, probably bad caps.
Then, there is the f*** buttons. Almost every time I want to switch between input sources, the OSD menu times out before I can get to the right source. Just as often, the confirm button does not register the click, and I have to go all over again. F*** annoying! The old models, which had a dedicated physical button for input source was much better. I notice your U2711 has the same "fancy buttons", so it's a no-go for me.
Finally, it's the card-reader and USB hub; it doesn't work, or only works sometimes. No a big deal of course, but simply useless. However, this seems to be a rather consistent problem with Dell monitors. The same thing keeps happening to many of the 24" models at work.
Overall, I'm happy I got the monitor at the time I did, however, my next will be an Eizo, price be dammed.
Why would this hinder piracy? This is just about pixel resolution, and file-size, no?
The back of a pen is sufficient to point at something. No need to smear grease all over my screen. I've tried to wash it away, but it doesn't get properly clean; not like a pristine out-of-the box look anyway.
Thank you, finally somebody how understands me! Finger-prints all over the screen is disgusting.
And if they really have to point at something, it's far better to use the back of a pen, or similar. That way my view is not obstructed by half an arm.
Good read; thanks. However, you seem to be more of a half-empty than half-full type?
Only looking at your last paragraph, I'd see gold, if I was running a small-town computer shop, or in my university years again. Charge people $100-200 to fix up their computer by installing a GNU/Linux distribution. Or, if that's not interesting, exchange their old hardware, and re-sell that to somebody else. Maybe supplement the business with some courses.
(Just don't patent the business plan though; stories of people doing exactly that have been frequent over the last couple of years).
shares virtually nothing with the common Linux environment encountered everywhere
Here's my usual plug; quote by Richard Stallman:
“Android is very different from the GNU/Linux operating system because it contains very little of GNU. Indeed, just about the only component in common between Android and GNU/Linux is Linux, the kernel. People who erroneously think “Linux” refers to the entire GNU/Linux combination get tied in knots by these facts, and make paradoxical statements such as “Android contains Linux, but it isn’t Linux”. If we avoid starting from the confusion, the situation is simple: Android contains Linux, but not GNU; thus, Android and GNU/Linux are mostly different.“
Linux has always been, and will always be just the kernel. Although the kernel is at the core of an operating system, it is not the complete OS. It sounds what you are looking for is the rest of the OS, typically the GNU tools. We can all save a lot of text and sweat by using the those three letters when discussing OS specific topics.
What you call it when talking to non-technical people does not matter that much. However, here on Slashdot everybody will understand "Android is not GNU/Linux".
I'm all with you, and keep seeing these things being used in places where there are much better tools for the job: Go to any tourist attraction these days, and you'll find people holding up their aluminium slabs to take pictures. Surely, if you can afford a trip around the world, you can also get a half-decent camera. Then there are the people who claim that writing e-mails, articles and even books is without effort on these things. The mind boggles.
As for niche use cases, I can think of a few: Once you get down to $50-100 range, they might make better picture frames than the dedicated devices for that purpose. For face-to-face survey-taking they work very well; think trade-show booth, or door-to-door questionnaires. An architect / building inspector recently mentioned that his tablet helped him is his job, so I'll have to take his word for it.
However, for John Doe, it's nothing but a fashion accessory at the moment. And as long as the iPad costs 5-10x times its competition, it will continue to be a show-off, just like bespoke suites, gold watches, and small-dick cars.
We need free and open source software now more than ever. The laws against installing any think you like on a tablet goes to show how backwards some people have this issue. We need free software to prove that there are a lot of alternative OSes out there, and that doing anything you like with the hardware you'd bought should be the law, as opposed to what is currently the case.
So, let's throw out the "pack of four", and build and use our own alternatives, whatever that might be. You bought the hardware; you own it.
Using the term GNU/Linux clarifies the topic, while stating "Android is Linux" makes it more confused. Just like a Boeing 777 is not a Rolls-Royce just because of its engines, so Android is not Linux. The kernel is of course a critical part of the OS, but it is not the only part.
You're absolutely right, a lot of this is due to the patent and copyright shenanigans of the major industry players. They commit fraud and treason against society in broad daylight. So if there was software "that is acceptable to the six major motion picture distributors", I would reject it on principle. Example: I have never, and will never, buy anything related to BluRay.
As for the tax software, I'm not quite sure what you get from the accounting firms. A list of loopholes? Just some slightly more friendly documentation than from the state? In the various countries that I have filled in taxes, the software I used was free of charge, and distributed by the national tax authority or city counsel. In one instance through a central web service where you would fill in and save the number online, and in another through cross-platform (Java) software, which also included a GNU/Linux installer. If I needed more help, I could certainly pay an accountant, however, even at a very moderate rate, I think I would incur a net loss.
Finally, for video games, I made an exception, and went for a console. That took a long time to reason about: Should I pay any of these companies at all, and if so, which one was the lesser of evil. In the end, I feel the choice between Microsoft and Sony was arbitrary. Neither company deserves a penny from me, and I would happily see both vanish. So maybe I made a mistake.
Well, what I wish for already exists, with millions of people benefiting and contributing to many thousand free and open source projects all over the world. If you were not aware of that, I'd suggest you download one of the common GNU/Linux distributions (it's for free), and give it a go. Try to apt-get, or similar, any application you'd like to use, and it will be installed within seconds, without any other action or transaction needed on your part. Even after nearly two decades, the efficiency and quality of the repositories blows me away every time. If I had to, I'd fight vigorously to protect that model, for others and for myself.
The Windows, OSX and Android ecosystems are infested with a culture of greed and egoism. Pay $10 for DVD-burning software, $15 for an archive program, $120 for anti-virus, $50 for an SSH client/server, $40 for a media player, and so on and so on.
If I can contribute to the community in some way, and get free and libre software in return, that seems like a much better deal for everybody. But by all means, if somebody wants to put energy into a distribution which mimics the money culture of Windows and OSX, all power to them. I'm just not interested.
With their apps and cloud space and Ajax.
Back when I was young, we called them applications, servers, and well, soap.
See also
> Lets just hope you can trust the ATM's that you use.
No, you cannot. I've lost count of how many times my cards have been skimmed and defrauded in various ways. Luckily, I have not taken any loss myself, but it is still a hassle to report, renew the cards, etc.
If you are really paranoid about these things, you'll have to use cash as you said, but go inside the bank to withdraw your money. On a regular basis, that's probably even more hassle, and also puts you at risk of being mugged.
As always, security is a trade-off and compromise between a whole set of different attack vectors vs. convenience and ease of use of the security measures. There is no way to make it perfect, and we will just have to continue updating the security systems and practises as new threads emerge. Also, the same solutions will not fit all; each will have to judge for himself what is the best combination of security vs. convenience.
And with that; the flip of a bit, a mere config setting somewhere deep in the Google hive, their relevance is gone.
Now, who's up for a new toy: The Porn Search Engine.