For someone who claims to be a master of English after spending many years in boring and repetitive schooling, who posts severely off-topic and anal-retentive replies to others over simple spelling mistakes, with no thought of the actual discussions at hand, I find myself shocked and horrified at this lapse.
Could it be? Is it possible that all this time you really were just a useless dumbfuck as many have suspected?
"When the law is immoral, it is the duty of any moral individual to ignore the law"... Funny this seems to be exactly how your president is justifying the illegal phone taps, and the many ways in which the Patriot Act breaks your constitution. Both of which have led to the harm of others.
Since you have not stepped up and stopped Bush personally, and also have not stepped up and eliminated your constitution, I declare you to be immoral.
So, as an immoral person, you have no business posting on what is and is not moral. Your postings must be assumed to be here with the intention of corrupting the truely moral.
No, what distinguishes us from the OTHER animals is our DNA. Whether or not the DNA of the other animals has led to sentience in them or not is irrelevant, and very subjective. How is it that you can reduce the importance of DNA down to mere appearances, ignoring that nothing but our DNA makes us human.
Take away sentience and you still have a human being. Remove your brain and you are still a human being albeit a dead one. You have in no way changed what distinguishes you from the other animals. Considering that a corpse is defined as a dead body, this choice of word is also inappropriate.
Although I have no problem with the killing of human fetuses where necessary, your justification of it using an arbitrary and subjective definition and questionable 'logic' is laughable at best. A fetus becomes an adult human being when the usual opportunities are not taken away from it.
A cow shall always be a cow. A cow fetus will never become a human or vice versa. It is supremely illogical to equate the value of a human fetus to that of a cow.
The anti-abortion crowd is not simply using emotional arguements. Does anyone really have to point out the religious bias in this group, and their inability to respect the freedom of religion of others? The 'looks' of a fetus is irrelevant.
Schiavo was absolutely human even in a vegetative state. There is no need to dehumanize her in order to justify giving her a dignified death. I would argue that it was her humanity itself that demanded that she be given the dignity she deserved, and be allowed to die peacefully, without the religious fanatics and media turning her into a freak show.
Even your imagined origins of morality are way off base. It is purely an extention to the genetic means of the perpetuation of the species. Killing animals instead of humans will generally be less harmful to your tribe and your species in general. Killing your neighbours when you are hungry will generally be quite harmful to your tribe and species. Take a look at these horribly primitive 'animals', the beasts that you would separate us from based on your arbitrary ideas of what sentience is. You will find that generally they are less likely to kill their own kind than we are.
So, you have now seen that despite your years of boring and repetitve schooling, your supposed mastery of the Queen's English, your imagined eloquence (obvious ignorance)... you really are a clueless dumbfuck. Your high and mighty attitudes over spelling and grammer have apparently failed to give you the ability to research and learn. I have no patience for the likes of you! hahaheheheh.
You have no patience... yet you take the time to post the most off-topic anal-retentive reply I think I've ever seen over a simple spelling mistake.
If you can't handle your poor choices in life that led to years of boring and repetitive schooling just to get your own shit thrown back in your face then open your self-righteous eyes... don't throw the shit in the first place!
Exactly what drugs are giving you the idea that I used the words "Nazi", "pedant" or "stick" in reference to you?... The first two words I did not use, and the last word was clearly "a redwood sized broomstick"... not "stick".
If you insist on arguing over my supposed writing problems, then...
"have some fucking self-respect, and use the correct words."
PC Gamer prides itself in writing reviews when a game comes out, not waiting for patches since when you buy the game, you're stuck with it for weeks if it is a lemon until a patch finally arrives, thus encouraging publishers to not release a game til its ready.
I'm not sure when the last time they actually followed the practice was, but i'm guessing it's been years.
Take CIV4 for example.
I did them a favour of informing them of how a significant percentage of gamers could not play the game because of brutal bugs that get worse as the game progresses. And I warned them that if they ignored it, they'd loose me as a reader as well as everyone else I could pass the word on to. They obviously didn't care.
For many, excitedly buying CIV4 when it came out meant nasty graphics problems ending in a crash to desktop or bluescreen. Playing with the large map settings made the game entirely unplayable beyond the early stages with turns that took exponentially longer until the crashes happen.
For at least 2 months gamers were subjected to this bullshit with almost no word out of 'gaming god' Sid Meier's Firaxis.
Then what do you know, a miracle happened. A patch was released and the game became playable, and was finally the game we expected.
I think it was the next damn day (gee what a coincidence) that I found the PC Gamer issue with a massive review suddenly now available which expounded on what an incredible game it is, gave it a very high mark in lines with the past CIV games... and spent only about 2 sentances describing that the game may have been released early in an 'unpolished' and 'slightly buggy' state !!!!
They mention that a few gamers had posted about problems in a forum. No mention was made about the wide spread crash to desktop problem. This game deserved a mark in the low 40's, not mid 90's.
It's total bullshit. hundreds complained on the CIV4 fansite forums. hundreds tried to find any link between their hardware and the crashes... which there was none, it was purely buggy programming. hundreds were very pissed off that they had trusted the great Sid Meier name and been screwed over simply so that CIV4 could launch before AOE3.
So I'm sticking to my word. I'm not buying PC Gamer anymore and several of my friends are doing the same. A couple of them are serious CIV fans and will not be giving their money to Firaxis over the way they've treated their fans.
Why?... Because he said nothing AGAINST those laws!
None of you seem to get it... encroaching on the freedom of ANY PERSON destroys freedom for ALL PEOPLE. This whole incident proves that freedom of speech is dead... in addition to the 3 or 4 other parts of the constitution that the Patriot Act breaks, and that your judges don't have the balls to deal with properly.
In Canada, when The Charter of Rights and Freedoms is infringed upon, when the constitution is broken by a law, the courts disalow the law... yes, there are exceptions, no, the system isn't perfect, but at least our system does something to protect people's rights.... You'll wish people had read my snide comments and done something about your Orwellian government when you 'accidently' are held without charge, with no contact to a lawyer or your family simply because you read a certain book or your name was similar to some one else's.
It's already happened to hundreds in New York when your government decided to crack down on the bike protest rallys. In several occurances there, people spent 3 days locked up without charge, not allowed even to tell their families where they were. The people had simply vanished.
If you really think that way about derogatory statements, tell your GOD DAMN FUCKWAD American diplomat to Canada to stop trying to interfere in Canada's election process!
Of course you probably are not aware of how Wilkins has been screaming for Our Prime Minister to layoff all the complaints about how YOUR country won't honour the trade agreements you freely chose to sign, that it may damage US/Canadian relations... AS IF YOUR OWING US 6 BILLION IN ILLEGAL LUMBER TARIFFS wasn't the real problem!
You don't want derogatory?... clean up your own house first.
Why is it relevant in any way that the student was taking a class?
Your constitution protects freedom of speech. It doesn't matter of Mao's book is from 1950's china or present day texas.
You dont require any special circumstance to be allowed to read any book you want, if you submit to such circumstances, than you've already thrown away what the founders of your country fought for.
If by chance your name had matched the name of someone on their secret lists, you would have been held without charge, unable to contact even your family, under the patriot act law.
But it didnt happen to you, so its all just fine and dandy. 'freedom' is preserved.
Library, bookstore, internet, that's not the issue, you've missed the point.
The material the guy wanted to read is also not the issue, it could have been any book that your government has deemed innapropriate for your poor sensitive brain to consider.
Why aren't you more concerned with the real issue?... the suppression of freedom of speech exhibited by this incident?... it ain't free if you can't get the message without government interference and tracking.
... then you must be unaware of how the patriot act allows your government to monitor all activity of people signing out books at libraries.
But that's the american way... be unaware, give away all your rights at the slightest startle,... then wonder why the special police aren't letting you, an innocent person even contact your family, let alone tell you why you've been arrested.
But that's just inside your borders. It's far worse if you include the atrocities your country commits outside your borders, pretending that you don't need to uphold your own values when its not US soil, and not US people, as if they are any less human than you.
Instead of enforcing constitutionally protected freedom of speech, its better for you to choose what people can read. Your constitution doesnt really matter.
yup, there's no chance that anyone could possibly read the book and not come away a devout communist. Yup, no one has ever read the writings of such figures purely to try and figure out how they think, with the understanding that it will lack a true representation of what happened to the people.
If you choose this repression, then you are simply walking down the same path that Mao himself followed.
So, only the USA can do anything at all useful, and if you didnt do it, you think you should take the credit for somehow inspiring us.
So the CANADIAN company that created the blackberry was somehow inspired by a stinky dipshit like you? sure. You can barely write a coherent sentance and you think our greatness is derived from you. You probably don't even know where Canada is!
Of course the USA has changed the world. The world now knows that regardless of any logic or any LACK of evidence you will freely run over whatever country you want just so your president can make his daddy proud.... Funny how its only non-americans who can see that as bad as Hussein was, he was actually keeping terrorists out of Iraq because they were a threat to his power. The terrorists arrived when YOU stirred the pot.
I'm really glad you mentioned WWII.
You have read the history books haven't you?... the non-american history books that don't leave out the FIRST TWO YEARS OF THE WAR BEFORE PEARL HARBOUR... when you were perfectly happy letting Hitler rampage across Europe. Now THAT's inspiring!
Have you any clue what rules you live under thanks to the PATRIOT ACT?
YOU DO NOT LIVE IN A FREE COUNTRY, not by a long shot!! The Patriot Act breaks 3 amendments to your constitution! YOUR beauracracy doesn't have the balls to declare the law unconstitutional. Why don't your judges do their job the way Canadian judges do? Those idiots HAVE taken away your rights, but you seem to think it hasn't happened.
Think your free? do a few minutes research on the HUNDREDS of ways your government has used the Patriot Act to spy on YOU, pretending its to fight terror.
Your government has given themselves the right to arrest you, hold you for an indefinate time with no charge, and refuse you any contact with any lawyer or even family. To your family, you simply vanish.
YOU stop being a fucking idiot and smell the coffee. YOUR COUNTRY IS the reason the world is so unstable and why oil costs so much. YOU ARE THE FUCKING PROBLEM.
Take your damn head out of your ass. It's your shit you smell, not roses.
It's a shame it takes a Canadian to enlighten you on the conditions you are living under and the harm your country is doing to the world.
... and you are still wrong. Basic Thermodynamics! Come on! If you knew anything at all about thermodynamics you never would have posted your message.
Perhaps the complete reading of my post would have enlightened you.
one square meter of the earth receives a certain amount of energy from the sun.
two square meters receives twice as much.
Stick with, it gets complicated here:
three square meters of the earth receives three times that of one square meter.
Your vortex system, and my solar system are working with the same amount of energy input into the system per square meter of affected ground.
Whether your system draws upon energy over 1km2 around the vortex or 1000km2, the same area covered with solar cells will collect that energy more efficiently and outperform the vortex.
You can not get all the energy that hits the ground around your vortex to enter your system. The further away, the less energy gets drawn in.
That same area affected by your system, covered with solar cells has no decrease in efficiency with distance from the center.
Your system spends huge amounts of the input energy to get the vortex moving and to keep it stable. Then your system throws away a huge amount of that kinetic energy in the wind that leaves the system... unless you're dumb enough to try to tell me that nearly all the energy is retrieved, leaving the output air barely moving... which of course would shut the system down, choking on the increased air pressure. Your system also has many moving mechanical parts, every one of which steals energy in the form of friction, and wear on parts.
The bigger your system is, the worse the power drain from friction will be, and the more energy will be lost in the wind leaving the system. Your dumbass vortex will in fact NOT scale up. It scales DOWN with size.
My system requires NO energy to maintain a stable state, it sits there with no inefficient moving parts, it does not require moving huge amounts of air in and out of any dumbass contraption, it has no friction, and endures extremely little wear and tear. While your system performs worse with size, my system maintains its performance. There is no competition here.
Do you have even two freaking brain cells to rub together? This is all so damn obvious.
"This month."
That is not a complete sentence.
For someone who claims to be a master of English after spending many years in boring and repetitive schooling, who posts severely off-topic and anal-retentive replies to others over simple spelling mistakes, with no thought of the actual discussions at hand, I find myself shocked and horrified at this lapse.
Could it be? Is it possible that all this time you really were just a useless dumbfuck as many have suspected?
"When the law is immoral, it is the duty of any moral individual to ignore the law" ... Funny this seems to be exactly how your president is justifying the illegal phone taps, and the many ways in which the Patriot Act breaks your constitution. Both of which have led to the harm of others.
Since you have not stepped up and stopped Bush personally, and also have not stepped up and eliminated your constitution, I declare you to be immoral.
So, as an immoral person, you have no business posting on what is and is not moral. Your postings must be assumed to be here with the intention of corrupting the truely moral.
All this imagined and twisted logic in your posts Caspian.
All this denial of emotions and beliefs as if it was not a part of our humanity.
I do hope you got the name of the priest you had to blow each week after sunday school.
No, what distinguishes us from the OTHER animals is our DNA. Whether or not the DNA of the other animals has led to sentience in them or not is irrelevant, and very subjective. How is it that you can reduce the importance of DNA down to mere appearances, ignoring that nothing but our DNA makes us human.
... you really are a clueless dumbfuck. Your high and mighty attitudes over spelling and grammer have apparently failed to give you the ability to research and learn. I have no patience for the likes of you! hahaheheheh.
Take away sentience and you still have a human being. Remove your brain and you are still a human being albeit a dead one. You have in no way changed what distinguishes you from the other animals. Considering that a corpse is defined as a dead body, this choice of word is also inappropriate.
Although I have no problem with the killing of human fetuses where necessary, your justification of it using an arbitrary and subjective definition and questionable 'logic' is laughable at best. A fetus becomes an adult human being when the usual opportunities are not taken away from it.
A cow shall always be a cow. A cow fetus will never become a human or vice versa. It is supremely illogical to equate the value of a human fetus to that of a cow.
The anti-abortion crowd is not simply using emotional arguements. Does anyone really have to point out the religious bias in this group, and their inability to respect the freedom of religion of others? The 'looks' of a fetus is irrelevant.
Schiavo was absolutely human even in a vegetative state. There is no need to dehumanize her in order to justify giving her a dignified death. I would argue that it was her humanity itself that demanded that she be given the dignity she deserved, and be allowed to die peacefully, without the religious fanatics and media turning her into a freak show.
Even your imagined origins of morality are way off base. It is purely an extention to the genetic means of the perpetuation of the species. Killing animals instead of humans will generally be less harmful to your tribe and your species in general. Killing your neighbours when you are hungry will generally be quite harmful to your tribe and species. Take a look at these horribly primitive 'animals', the beasts that you would separate us from based on your arbitrary ideas of what sentience is. You will find that generally they are less likely to kill their own kind than we are.
So, you have now seen that despite your years of boring and repetitve schooling, your supposed mastery of the Queen's English, your imagined eloquence (obvious ignorance)
pr0n?
What kind of English word is that? Does the true word, porn, scare you that much?
As do you apparently. Try: .... too litle OF A grasp on ....
And the hypocrite parade starts!
... yet you take the time to post the most off-topic anal-retentive reply I think I've ever seen over a simple spelling mistake.
... don't throw the shit in the first place!
... The first two words I did not use, and the last word was clearly "a redwood sized broomstick" ... not "stick".
...
You have no patience
If you can't handle your poor choices in life that led to years of boring and repetitive schooling just to get your own shit thrown back in your face then open your self-righteous eyes
Exactly what drugs are giving you the idea that I used the words "Nazi", "pedant" or "stick" in reference to you?
If you insist on arguing over my supposed writing problems, then
"have some fucking self-respect, and use the correct words."
Wow, all the spelling and grammatical errors in my post and you chose to pick up on lose / loose?
I may be sloppy, but it's obvious that you simply think you have some understanding of the Queen's English with little idea of the bigger picture.
That picture of course consisting of a redwood sized broomstick being lodged up your ass.
PC Gamer prides itself in writing reviews when a game comes out, not waiting for patches since when you buy the game, you're stuck with it for weeks if it is a lemon until a patch finally arrives, thus encouraging publishers to not release a game til its ready.
... and spent only about 2 sentances describing that the game may have been released early in an 'unpolished' and 'slightly buggy' state !!!!
... which there was none, it was purely buggy programming. hundreds were very pissed off that they had trusted the great Sid Meier name and been screwed over simply so that CIV4 could launch before AOE3.
I'm not sure when the last time they actually followed the practice was, but i'm guessing it's been years.
Take CIV4 for example.
I did them a favour of informing them of how a significant percentage of gamers could not play the game because of brutal bugs that get worse as the game progresses. And I warned them that if they ignored it, they'd loose me as a reader as well as everyone else I could pass the word on to. They obviously didn't care.
For many, excitedly buying CIV4 when it came out meant nasty graphics problems ending in a crash to desktop or bluescreen. Playing with the large map settings made the game entirely unplayable beyond the early stages with turns that took exponentially longer until the crashes happen.
For at least 2 months gamers were subjected to this bullshit with almost no word out of 'gaming god' Sid Meier's Firaxis.
Then what do you know, a miracle happened. A patch was released and the game became playable, and was finally the game we expected.
I think it was the next damn day (gee what a coincidence) that I found the PC Gamer issue with a massive review suddenly now available which expounded on what an incredible game it is, gave it a very high mark in lines with the past CIV games
They mention that a few gamers had posted about problems in a forum. No mention was made about the wide spread crash to desktop problem. This game deserved a mark in the low 40's, not mid 90's.
It's total bullshit. hundreds complained on the CIV4 fansite forums. hundreds tried to find any link between their hardware and the crashes
So I'm sticking to my word. I'm not buying PC Gamer anymore and several of my friends are doing the same. A couple of them are serious CIV fans and will not be giving their money to Firaxis over the way they've treated their fans.
wow.
takes a true DUMBFUCK to misunderstand and rate the above post as 'offtopic'.
Must have been an intelligent design believer.
A time warp has occured!
April fools day has fallen a miraculous 3 months early!
This is nothing more than a convoluted tax on the drivers.
The energy comes from the passing cars, the cars must burn a little more gas to overcome the resistance that the ramp uses to generate the energy.
Why not just tax the drivers instead of forcing them to burn even more polluting gas? The money could fund a cleaner way of generating the energy.
Such a dumbass waste.
Why? ... Because he said nothing AGAINST those laws!
... encroaching on the freedom of ANY PERSON destroys freedom for ALL PEOPLE. This whole incident proves that freedom of speech is dead ... in addition to the 3 or 4 other parts of the constitution that the Patriot Act breaks, and that your judges don't have the balls to deal with properly.
... yes, there are exceptions, no, the system isn't perfect, but at least our system does something to protect people's rights. ... You'll wish people had read my snide comments and done something about your Orwellian government when you 'accidently' are held without charge, with no contact to a lawyer or your family simply because you read a certain book or your name was similar to some one else's.
None of you seem to get it
In Canada, when The Charter of Rights and Freedoms is infringed upon, when the constitution is broken by a law, the courts disalow the law
It's already happened to hundreds in New York when your government decided to crack down on the bike protest rallys. In several occurances there, people spent 3 days locked up without charge, not allowed even to tell their families where they were. The people had simply vanished.
If you really think that way about derogatory statements, tell your GOD DAMN FUCKWAD American diplomat to Canada to stop trying to interfere in Canada's election process!
... AS IF YOUR OWING US 6 BILLION IN ILLEGAL LUMBER TARIFFS wasn't the real problem!
... clean up your own house first.
Of course you probably are not aware of how Wilkins has been screaming for Our Prime Minister to layoff all the complaints about how YOUR country won't honour the trade agreements you freely chose to sign, that it may damage US/Canadian relations
You don't want derogatory?
now THAT deserves the insightful mod.
I feel as if maybe, just maybe one pair of eyes has been opened. only 300million more to go.
Why is it relevant in any way that the student was taking a class?
Your constitution protects freedom of speech. It doesn't matter of Mao's book is from 1950's china or present day texas.
You dont require any special circumstance to be allowed to read any book you want, if you submit to such circumstances, than you've already thrown away what the founders of your country fought for.
... to their credit blah blah blah.
If by chance your name had matched the name of someone on their secret lists, you would have been held without charge, unable to contact even your family, under the patriot act law.
But it didnt happen to you, so its all just fine and dandy. 'freedom' is preserved.
Wow, you really are a prime example, you don't even see (or at least admit too) your own repression.
Your repression is the act of trying to substitute another book in the place of what a FREE person CHOSE to read.
He was not looking for a historical perspective, he wanted to read the actual propaganda for himself.
But yes, you are right books are not harmless, they are bad bad dangerous things because they make you think. I'll see you at sunday's book burning.
Library, bookstore, internet, that's not the issue, you've missed the point.
... the suppression of freedom of speech exhibited by this incident? ... it ain't free if you can't get the message without government interference and tracking.
The material the guy wanted to read is also not the issue, it could have been any book that your government has deemed innapropriate for your poor sensitive brain to consider.
Why aren't you more concerned with the real issue?
... then you must be unaware of how the patriot act allows your government to monitor all activity of people signing out books at libraries.
... be unaware, give away all your rights at the slightest startle, ... then wonder why the special police aren't letting you, an innocent person even contact your family, let alone tell you why you've been arrested.
But that's the american way
But that's just inside your borders. It's far worse if you include the atrocities your country commits outside your borders, pretending that you don't need to uphold your own values when its not US soil, and not US people, as if they are any less human than you.
It is true.
No where in the world do people give up their own constitutionally protected rights faster on the slightest scare than in the USA.
Who cares if the 'protection' you think you get out of it totally undermines the reason for your country's existance.
yes your absolutely right.
Instead of enforcing constitutionally protected freedom of speech, its better for you to choose what people can read. Your constitution doesnt really matter.
yup, there's no chance that anyone could possibly read the book and not come away a devout communist. Yup, no one has ever read the writings of such figures purely to try and figure out how they think, with the understanding that it will lack a true representation of what happened to the people.
If you choose this repression, then you are simply walking down the same path that Mao himself followed.
So, only the USA can do anything at all useful, and if you didnt do it, you think you should take the credit for somehow inspiring us.
... Funny how its only non-americans who can see that as bad as Hussein was, he was actually keeping terrorists out of Iraq because they were a threat to his power. The terrorists arrived when YOU stirred the pot.
... the non-american history books that don't leave out the FIRST TWO YEARS OF THE WAR BEFORE PEARL HARBOUR ... when you were perfectly happy letting Hitler rampage across Europe. Now THAT's inspiring!
So the CANADIAN company that created the blackberry was somehow inspired by a stinky dipshit like you? sure. You can barely write a coherent sentance and you think our greatness is derived from you. You probably don't even know where Canada is!
Of course the USA has changed the world. The world now knows that regardless of any logic or any LACK of evidence you will freely run over whatever country you want just so your president can make his daddy proud.
I'm really glad you mentioned WWII.
You have read the history books haven't you?
Have you any clue what rules you live under thanks to the PATRIOT ACT?
YOU DO NOT LIVE IN A FREE COUNTRY, not by a long shot!! The Patriot Act breaks 3 amendments to your constitution! YOUR beauracracy doesn't have the balls to declare the law unconstitutional. Why don't your judges do their job the way Canadian judges do? Those idiots HAVE taken away your rights, but you seem to think it hasn't happened.
Think your free? do a few minutes research on the HUNDREDS of ways your government has used the Patriot Act to spy on YOU, pretending its to fight terror.
Your government has given themselves the right to arrest you, hold you for an indefinate time with no charge, and refuse you any contact with any lawyer or even family. To your family, you simply vanish.
YOU stop being a fucking idiot and smell the coffee. YOUR COUNTRY IS the reason the world is so unstable and why oil costs so much. YOU ARE THE FUCKING PROBLEM.
Take your damn head out of your ass. It's your shit you smell, not roses.
It's a shame it takes a Canadian to enlighten you on the conditions you are living under and the harm your country is doing to the world.
American courts helping a Canadian company?
no way. Goodbye RIM, no matter how invalid NTP's patent scam is.
... and you are still wrong. Basic Thermodynamics! Come on! If you knew anything at all about thermodynamics you never would have posted your message.
... unless you're dumb enough to try to tell me that nearly all the energy is retrieved, leaving the output air barely moving ... which of course would shut the system down, choking on the increased air pressure. Your system also has many moving mechanical parts, every one of which steals energy in the form of friction, and wear on parts.
Perhaps the complete reading of my post would have enlightened you.
one square meter of the earth receives a certain amount of energy from the sun.
two square meters receives twice as much.
Stick with, it gets complicated here:
three square meters of the earth receives three times that of one square meter.
Your vortex system, and my solar system are working with the same amount of energy input into the system per square meter of affected ground.
Whether your system draws upon energy over 1km2 around the vortex or 1000km2, the same area covered with solar cells will collect that energy more efficiently and outperform the vortex.
You can not get all the energy that hits the ground around your vortex to enter your system. The further away, the less energy gets drawn in.
That same area affected by your system, covered with solar cells has no decrease in efficiency with distance from the center.
Your system spends huge amounts of the input energy to get the vortex moving and to keep it stable. Then your system throws away a huge amount of that kinetic energy in the wind that leaves the system
The bigger your system is, the worse the power drain from friction will be, and the more energy will be lost in the wind leaving the system. Your dumbass vortex will in fact NOT scale up. It scales DOWN with size.
My system requires NO energy to maintain a stable state, it sits there with no inefficient moving parts, it does not require moving huge amounts of air in and out of any dumbass contraption, it has no friction, and endures extremely little wear and tear. While your system performs worse with size, my system maintains its performance. There is no competition here.
Do you have even two freaking brain cells to rub together? This is all so damn obvious.