Slashdot Mirror


User: BarryNorton

BarryNorton's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
925
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 925

  1. Re:The law did provide an opportunity for redress on John Seigenthaler Sr. Criticises Wikipedia · · Score: 1
    He has a personal attorney already. He's clearly upset.
    Hardly - he's the kind of person who both has one or two on staff, and who almost certainly counts more than one among his friends. Finding out what can be done costs nothing, starting the ball rolling costs money or calling in a favour, something he was clearly not into doing.

    Similarly writing an editorial might seem like a big step to some people, but he used to be (at least) on the USA Today board - he was just sounding off...

  2. Re:Standard wikipedia response on John Seigenthaler Sr. Criticises Wikipedia · · Score: 3, Interesting
    Actually when the case is libel, he doesn't have to merely put up with it or change it
    No, he doesn't have to change it directly, but as I understand it, he does personally and actively have to pursue a court order, usually in conjunction with an action for damages. Normally, correct me if I'm wrong, this would be a cease and desist order on distributors, I don't know how a judge would tackle something like Wikipedia where it could simply be changed back.

    In any case, no amount of indignant editorials or feet-stamping make anyone else responsible for changing the article.

  3. Re:Standard wikipedia response on John Seigenthaler Sr. Criticises Wikipedia · · Score: 1, Flamebait
    If you disagree with it, just edit it!
    To quote Homer, he's essentially saying, "can't someone else do it?"

    He doesn't understand why corrections are normally made "within minutes" - it's because in the majority of articles someone gives a shit!

    If he's the only person that cares then it's clearly up to him to put or right or to live with it...

  4. Re:Patenting pie menus? on Glide File Sharing Service Debuts · · Score: 1
    From what I can discern, the "bubble" is a pie menu [...] That sounds lame, on the verge to stupid.
    What? They've taken a long-standing problem and found a solution to it... Don't you ever find that there are just just many items you can fit on a traditional menu? And what's the point in buying a high-resolution monitor if the applications aren't going to use it up?

    Seriously, though, am I being stupid with this interface? I created 'containers' for photos and for music and cannot drag'n'drop into either... (In Firefox it does nothing, in IE - with drag'n'drop enabled - it opens the file locally)

  5. Re:Whoopie on Glide File Sharing Service Debuts · · Score: 1
    why on earth should I give [David Pogue] opinon any creedance when its ovbious he does not even know what an OS does
    Thank goodness someone said it because I thought I was going mad!

    If I'd read him say that in the NYT, I'd have dismissed it as a stupid comment... but someone here quoted him, and an 'editor' let him, leading me to spend an extra five minutes of my life trying to figure out exactly what this thing is.

    Seriously, what is the point writing summaries if it's less clear after you've read it what the story is...

  6. Re:What is it then, Barry? on Vast Subsurface Martian Ice Discovered · · Score: 1
    Until you increase the sample size and realise that the length of days changes on a daily basis.
    Still only a model until you get where you can observe it directly though, no?
  7. Re:What is it then, Barry? on Vast Subsurface Martian Ice Discovered · · Score: 1
    Both in conjunction would be ideal
    That's all I'm saying - since water is only a hypothesis, adding evidence is the right approach (though I take your point about wanting to match the areas scanned).
    I'm an engineer - I take the data I'm given and draw the most logical conclusion
    Sun crosses the sky and emerges on the other horizon half a day later... the most likely explanation is that it circles the Earth. (Being facetious, but you know what I mean...)
  8. Belly of the sea monster? on Intel Yonah Performance Preview · · Score: 2, Funny

    With a name like Yonah (aka Jonah), what are they saying about their motherboards?!

  9. Re:Signing in with Passport on Microsoft Testing Its Own 'Google Base' · · Score: 1
    It's an internal thing only atm
    Yeah, I got that - that's why I corrected myself (and derided eWeek for being so mis-leading) - I could have been clearer, though.
    not to mention the fact that like other's have pointed out - it's more like craigslist
    I think I may have been the first to do so actually...
  10. Re:Yup on Vast Subsurface Martian Ice Discovered · · Score: 2, Funny

    I can never finish a Mars bar without a glass of milk... I hope there's some of that up there!

  11. Re:Yup on Vast Subsurface Martian Ice Discovered · · Score: 1
    Sounds to me like they found the spectrometry signature of oxygen as well as hydrogen, in approximately a 1-to-2 ratio
    ROFL... and you ask me if I read the article?!?

    The BBC repeatedly fail to distinguish speculation from proof, but at least they stopped short of making things up!

  12. Re:What is it then, Barry? on Vast Subsurface Martian Ice Discovered · · Score: 2, Insightful
    You have a very black and white world view. Either Spectrometry or RADAR must be the only useful evidence. I must either accept the speculative conclusion or believe there's no water (and provide an alternate explanation).

    At risk of repeating myself - NASA's evidence was compelling, but their conclusion cannot be accepted as proven. ESA's evidence adds something because their RADAR-like approach says more about the depth of whatever is there. (And NASA want to conclude not just water, but a significant amount of it.)

    For what it's worth, I am personally reasonably convinced, but I'm also a scientist...

  13. Re:Yup on Vast Subsurface Martian Ice Discovered · · Score: 5, Informative

    NASA did not "find water" years ago... or ever! They found the gamma-ray spectrometry signature for hydrogen and proposed this was likely locked up in ice. Now a different means has been used to measure the subsurface (much more effectively in terms of depth, if less conclusively in terms of composition) and also found results not inconsistent with ice. We will probably not 'find ice' until someone goes there and drills. Until then, different means of measurement are a good idea (even though the media, and worse the bottom-feeding pseudo-journalism of sites like Slashdot, will misinterpret the conclusions that can be drawn).

  14. Not for the English climate? on Next Generation of MP3 Glasses · · Score: 1

    These might have been cool (well, the Oakleys) while cycling in Summer (don't worry - on the cycle network in Milton Keynes, not on the road), but when it's dark by 17h00 and pouring with rain, I think I'll stick with 'street style' headphones and a cheaper player hung inside my jacket!

  15. Re:I'm confused.. on First Face Transplant · · Score: 1

    So what I really needed on the night of the 31st October 1993 was a head transplant?

  16. Re:I'm confused.. on First Face Transplant · · Score: 4, Insightful
    No seriously, what exactly are the "ethical considerations" of a face transplant?

    And the "psychological impact" to the patient of looking different?

    It's about having, to some degree, someone else's face.

    This is also why they're at pains to point out that the recipient does not look exactly like their donor.

    Just as people look back and can't understand why people were uncomfortable with the idea of someone else's blood running around their veins, or someone else's heart beating in their chest, so people might get over this idea - you apparently have.

    Have some imagination, though, and see why people have (it's true, and well-documented, not just sensationalism) been creeped out by this idea for decades...

  17. Re:The why not the how on How to Write Comments · · Score: 1

    // 30-11-2005 16:08 GMT Fixes a type checking error when no value is returned
    if (Account.Tarrif == null)
                        return false;

  18. News? Matters? on How to Write Comments · · Score: 1

    // Redundant.comment while(story = slashdot.getStory()) { story.read(); eyes.roll(); }

  19. Re:This day shall live on in infamy. on The Yellow Machine in Review · · Score: 2, Funny

    What had mean you over? *grin*

  20. Re:This isn't third grade.... on Microsoft Testing Its Own 'Google Base' · · Score: 1
    So explain to me how that is not copying?
    I think he's saying that the grown-up world (not always well represented on /.) doesn't stick its hand up in the air and say:

    "Miss! Miss! He's cooooopyiiiiing! That's bad, isn't it, Miss?"

    We understand that imitation and derivation are part of any healthy industry. Patents protect truly novel innovations (or they're supposed to), but only for a limited period to protect investment in R&D, not because copying is bad and means you have to stand in the corner and face the wall!

  21. Re:Why oh why.. on Microsoft Testing Its Own 'Google Base' · · Score: 1
    Why Microsoft has to poke its nose to every business opportunity possible?
    Yeah, these technological bandwagon-jumpers - IBM, Microsoft, Google - are real failures... if only they were like your company, right?
  22. Re:Craigslist is topping out in growth rate on Microsoft Testing Its Own 'Google Base' · · Score: 1

    That graph shows two previous 'levelling offs' with the subsequent rate of change (and local maximum) being greater each time - what are we supposed to learn from that?

  23. Re:Signing in with Passport on Microsoft Testing Its Own 'Google Base' · · Score: 1

    ... wait, 'glimpses' are the one screen about needing to register with a @microsoft.com account?

    This (eWeek) article is really misleading!

  24. Signing in with Passport on Microsoft Testing Its Own 'Google Base' · · Score: 1

    Anyone else have trouble signing in with a Hotmail account-based Passport?

    (I know, I know, but I'm not about to use any other address...)

    If I try to sign in directly, it says I have to register (but only allows this from a @microsoft.com address), and if I register separately it disallows @hotmail.com (and @msn.com and @passport.com).

  25. Re:When is this going to end? on Microsoft Testing Its Own 'Google Base' · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Agreed, Google Base is like everything2, but aren't you taking it to much for granted that Fremont is a 'Google Base killer'?

      Despite eWeek's headline and speculation, what Microsoft have actually said - 'online marketplace', 'localised listings and maps' - doesn't really make it sound like everything2, but rather like a hopeful 'Craigslist killer' (with an eye on eBay)...