More on NVIDIA's Involvement In X Box
ManWithNoName writes "In the Private Eye, there's an interesting look at NVIDIA's involvement (which was officially announced today) in the X-Box, with their APU and iGPU and how these technologies could have the potential to be used for other products other than Xbox. There's also a very satirical "General Industry Interview" (involving Sony, Sega, 3dfx, NVIDIA, ATI etc...)with everyone involved in the industry that either is inside the Xbox or has tried to get into it over the pasty year. On a more serious note, the authors talk about a conspiracy that Microsoft's Xbox will punch the PC industry in the nuts with the whole Delay to DX8 causing NVIDIA, 3dfx and ATI to delay the releases of their next generation 3D chips, which are dependant upon the unreleased API."
ATI and NVidia both know now that it's a race just as it is for AMD and Intel for chips. They would not delay their release of a chip just because DX8 wasn't out yet. After all, they could add extensions to OGL to fully use their hardware. Hell, when the GeForce came out, no game existed that could fully utilize its power, and few exist today. Just because directx 8 isn't out yet doesn't mean that they won't release the new chips. After all, it's the drivers that wouldn't be released, not the chips.
witty sig goes here
"If I'm not mistaken, all of the progress in Direct3d, from v1-v6 was to *catch* up to OpenGL.
Which means, as of D3d6, MS is starting to reach parity with OpenGL"
Well, if (according to you) they caught up to OpenGL around version 6, I guess they're PASSING OpenGL now, since D3D 7 has been out forever, and D3D 8 is on its way.
Then again, I think you just got your version numbers mixed up. I haven't done any D3D since version5, which was a complete mess. I did a little OpenGL too, and it was very simple and clean. I guess I'll have to try some D3d 8 programming soon, just to see how it will progress. Yeah, I'll be a game programmer someday, suuuuuuure I will....
OtakuBooty.com: Smart, funny, sexy nerds.
What ever happened to the new 3D API, called Farenheit, that was to be co-developed by MS and SGI? I remember it was announced not long after the GL vs. DX wars went into full swing, about 3 years ago. Where did that go?
Farenheit was basically dropped by both MS and SGI. SGI opted to concentrate more on the open-source, OpenGL on Linux, etc. There's a lot of debate on whether MS really ever intended to do stuff with Farenheit, or if it was a merely something they did to keep folks busy while they simultaneously marketed DX/D3D.
Does really matter, however. The end result is that Farenheit is effectively dead.
Don't tell me they're counting the blending multipliers.
--
It's a
-- Danny Vermin
I just went to an X-box presentation last Wednesday where that exact question was asked.
Their answer, in short, was that they are Microsoft. They make DirectX, therefore it makes since for them to push DirectX. The Dev guy also stated that if anyone wishes to make an OpenGL subsystem for the Xbox, they are welcome to, but it won't be supported by Microsoft.
One of their exact quotes was:
"Why put our eggs in 2 baskets that are half-assed, when we can put them all in one and it be kickass." This was from the Multimedia Head of the Xbox Dev Team.
Also, they stated that it will not BSOD.. they can't afford that. That quickly got questions like: "Then what color is it?". heh, quite funny.. you had to be there I guess.
But, overall, the presentation really didn't impress me... too much "This is what 10% of the theorectical power of the Xbox will be able to do" crap.
Well.. that's my bit for now.
Think how much more Blizzard would make if they re-released all their titles for Linux
Judging from past experiences, including Q3 for Linux, I think the answer is "not much." Linux may be growing 2000% a year or whatever, but it's a strange market. If you make one minor license screw up, you end up as a Slashdot headline and vigilantes bring down your site. Warning: This is how many developers see the culture surrounding Linux. Don't laugh it off.
Fair enough. But could you please follow the link in my original post? Sony isn't #2, Microsoft is. And that's not just computer related circles, it's overall brand recognition.
You got a better source than Interbrand for your claim? Post the link.
He won't follow the link. There is nothing that he can read that would change his preconceived notions. That is why he is a loser.
I will buy the Xbox the second it is released. I'm hearing the same from most of my friends. Even the lamers who think they're Bill Joy jr. because they run Linux.
-- You see, there would be these conclusions that you could jump to
xbox...no, i don't think so.
why on earth would anyone want to buy closed hardware? to use with closed software? just because the imac did well, doesn't mean this thing will take the industry by storm.
in fact, if it does well, it could have a devastating effect on microsoft. let's face it, there are numerous hardware companies that can probably bring a better, faster, cheaper product to market than MS, and have it be an open standard (they wouldn't have misguided loyalty to der fuhrer)
MS has had awful luck with previous ventures into hardware. the only two devices that ever sold were the mouse and keyboard, which, as i recall, were invented elesewhere and BBB (bought by bill).
i stopped buying MS software/products in about 1993, after they settled with stac, cuz i don't buy products from illegal, lying corporations. i did buy a natural keyboard, tho. i just don't understand why anyone would use a microsoft anything, given a choice.
about a year ago, i stopped buying computer hardware -- mostly because of bill (and friends) outrageous behavior in a court of law. i really have no interest in spending any money on PC hardware or software until MS is basically destroyed.
here's hoping the Xbox will be another nail in the coffin. fortunately, i have enough put aside from my unix career that i'll be able to just walk away from it all in a year or so, even if bill is able to bribe/lie/cheat his way through his legal problems again.
Treatment, not tyranny. End the drug war and free our American POWs.
See my user info for links.
Has anyone ever noticed that projects which were started to make great advances have never yielded the great advances they were supposed to deliver. (Like the Aswan dam, Reagan's "austerity" budget which racked up the largest deficit in US history, contact with sport safety equipment being the leading source of sport injuries, etc.)
I have a sneaky suspicion that the X-box that will eventually come out of the pipe won't be the be-all and end-all that is being touted and that the premises (I won't call them promises, they are more like soggy dreams,) are going to seem like the other stains in somebody's shorts when something finally pours out of the pipe.
Life is like a sewer. What you get out of it depends on what you put into it. This is the same bunch that took six years to kludge up an OS (NT) that's still worse that what a kid in Finland managed with no budget but with a lot of friends
MSBPodcast.com The opinions expressed here are my own. If you don't like 'em... Think up your own stuff.
They ARE making a network countroller and a sound chip for the X-Box. Their chip is supposed to be used as an ultra-high-end DSP to generate all the neato surround sound effects, as well be a "broadband" gateway, effectively turning the X-Box into a 'residential gateway' for everything hooked up to it.
check out this white boy trying to be controversial.
one eminem is enough.
-- You see, there would be these conclusions that you could jump to
On a more serious note, the authors talk about a conspiracy that Microsoft's Xbox will punch the PC industry in the nuts with the whole Delay to DX8 causing NVIDIA, 3dfx and ATI to delay the releases of their next generation 3D chips, which are dependant upon the unreleased API.
;-)
This would certainly not endear them to the DoJ, let alone lend credibility to their comical denial of monopolistic behavior. I keep expecting M$ to learn and shape up, but it's like there's pattern of behavior... Too bad Bill's not in California, we could possibly get him on the 3 strikes and cool him off in the pokey
Interesting side note (considering for a second the capacity at the XBox to do other than play games) The Register concerning the ditching of M$ ActiveTV by AT&T
It's all true! ±5%
A feeling of having made the same mistake before: Deja Foobar
Well, GL hasn't been sitting still, either. GL was released 1.0 on 1992. 1.1 in 1997, and 1.2 came out in 1999.
1.2 adds 3d texture mapping, multi-texturing, new pixel formats, specular lighting, level-of-detail etc.
V1.3 is under proposal, though I can't find anything concrete about it.
But this is why I asked; what is D3D doing that's surpassing OpenGL?
The nick is a joke! Really!
GPL Deconstructed
DirectX is winning lots of developers because MS actually implements new features and concepts ina standardized way in the API. All you get with GL is a bunch of vendor-supplied extensions. The paradigm for development hasn't changed at all for GL, whereas DX has moved along with the times.
That said, I think GL has a superior implementation. It's just a shame that GL is withering away in the face of new feature developments, losing to the MS machine.
What ever happened to the new 3D API, called Farenheit, that was to be co-developed by MS and SGI? I remember it was announced not long after the GL vs. DX wars went into full swing, about 3 years ago. Where did that go?
While the XBox may have superior performance over something like the Playstation2, think about what matters most in a game machine.... the games!
Microsoft's developers are all PC platform developers which means most of the games of the XBox are going to be nothing more than ports of PC Games (why wouldn't you just play them on the PC in the first place), whereas Sony has a huge developer base, experienced in developing CONSOLE titles. Sure, there's some overlap, some games play equally well on either console or PC, but some just flat out SUCK ported to console (Descent, Doom... need I say more?).
Just something to think about, the hardware alone cannot make the system. It takes software thats popular to drive a system to the top. Why do you think that the original playstation still has new titles coming out for it? It's certainly not the fastest/prettiest console out now... it's cause the system is popular, and it's popular cause it has a lot of games, and some extremely good ones.
It will be some time before the XBox gets enough really good titles behind it to do anything to the popularity of Sony's and Sega's systems.
> It's already here AND it's cross-platform.
Which is *exactly* why Microsoft won't use it. "Cross Platform" gives them nightmares. MS's mission is to lock consumers into *their* products, *their* systems, and *their* way of doing things. That way consumers are forced to keep buying MS, no matter what sh*t the company puts out.
Cross Platform means easy migration, which is wonderful for consumers, and horrible for Microsoft. If you could easily pick up shop and take your business elsewhere, MS would be forced to provide a decent product to win your business. Unfortunately, we don't live in that world. I keep hoping that consumers will wake up and realize that MS's actions are not in their best interest, but that's probably asking too much.
I can dream, can't I?
--Lenny
The GeForce is quality hardware, but I won't spend a dime for a black box lacking proper documentation. Intelectual property my ass, this is a $400 card we're talking about! Can you imagine Ford claiming they can't document the internals of your new car because of "Intelectual Property" issues? Would you buy that car? Would you have bought an S-100 Dazler shipped without documetation?
I'm a long time Linux user, and let me say: after going through the undocumented video card mess from Diamond years back, nVidia gains no "loving affection" from me. The last thing I need is to be forced into a video card upgrade because nVidia stopped updating drivers for MY old card and nVidia can't release their "Intelectual Property" (read: documentation) to their customers. Been there once before, NOT AGAIN!
I found this interesting article on the internet recently:
http://www.cs.berkeley.edu/~nweaver/x box.html
I'm wondering about those legacy PC bottlenecks on the xbox. It's on a x86 based processor going against a 100% 128-bit PS2 Emotion Engine that's got a main 300 mhz CPU and two vector coprocessors that blow Pentium III floating point ops out of the water.
For example, SquareSoft is trying to make their beat-em-up, The Bouncer, have Dolby Digital 5.1 support in gameplay. They used to think it was impossible, but it might not be so with the VU units. It seems MS just thought "Hey, we can beat 300 mhz easy!" without thinking about the hidden trump card in the PS2. Also, I noticed the 6.4 GB/sec memory bandwidth on the Xbox (shared, so it indludes video memory speed). And the PS2 has dedicated VRAM that flies at 48 GB/sec. So what do you guys think?
- Amon CMB
Men believe what they want. - Caesar
if NVidia started making network controllers and soundcards? Now that would rock! Considering that numerous Aureal employees are now working for NVidia, and Guillemot is a trusted partner, this could spell a new era for soundcards. Enough of this AC97, skimpily buffered, below 64 hardware channels crap; it's time for a MAN's soundcard!
"Ancillary does not mean you get to rule the world." --U.S. Circuit Judge Harry Edwards, speaking to the FCC's lawyer
Microsoft taking on Sony?? You got to be kidding. Sony is the second most widely known name in the world (behind Coke). I don't think they're going to roll over anytime soon. I wouldn't be suprised if the X-box was Microsoft's Network Computer. Sorry Larry, the time wasn't right for that either...
What directX conspiracy? Sony is the name for game consoles. Have they even heard of Nvidia or DirectX?
there are no stupid questions, but there are a lot of inquisitive idiots
Microsoft is clearly pouring a great deal of money into the XBox. A lot of it is, of course, going to nVidia. nVidia in turn, uses this big bag of free money to create a killer 3D accellerator (200 million triangles / second I believe?) for the XBox. Clearly it's unlikely that nVidia would not simultaneously (or a shorttime thereafter the XBox is released) present video card manufacturers with this technology. I also doubt that nVidia would do anything to limit this accellerator by making it DX8 specific. It'll support OpenGL too. (Why wouldn't they support OpenGL? After getting their act together with XF86 support, they're regained the loving affection of the Linux community.) So, after all that wordiness, my point is that we can actually thank Microsoft for helping to fund a truly great product on the part of nVidia. Thanks Bill!
Are you sure that'd take off? With the "software should be free" mentality with Linux, Blizzard would sell 100, maybe 200 copies at most. I sincerely doubt they would turn a profit.
So please clue me in on the advancing nature of Direct3d.
At least, I'm separating DirectX from Direct3d, because comparing the sound libraries of DirectX is meaningless.
If I'm not mistaken, all of the progress in Direct3d, from v1-v6 was to *catch* up to OpenGL.
Which means, as of D3d6, MS is starting to reach parity with OpenGL.
Which features are you talking about, in terms of GL, is M$ overtaking them? GL does rely on vendor extensions because it makes sense; each vendor will *want* to supply optimizations and features that they have, and when everyone else has those features, the GL board will increment the version number and include that feature into the set.
M$'s way is to implement in software mode, what isn't found in hardware, isn't it? That's not terribly useful, actually, if software can't keep up, and if software can keep up, then there is no need for there to be vendor implementations, right? So software supplied multi-pass texture is useless in this light.
So as far as I can tell, GL isn't behind and M$ isn't actually doing all that much.
The nick is a joke! Really!
GPL Deconstructed
Sorry to break up your rituous rant, but the parent was *sarcasm*. The P Naughton bit should have tipped you off.
But this is why I asked; what is D3D doing that's surpassing OpenGL?
As far as I can tell, nothing. All the 3D accelerated functions available on my NVIDIA card are exposed under the OpenGL 1.2 spec, GL_ext_ extensions or on NVIDIA specific extensions - GL_NV_. This is of course on Linux using the NVIDIA drivers and the NVIDIA GL/gl.h etc. headers converted to Linux. In many respects the functionality of the card is available faster on OpenGL than DirectX because the Vendor specific extensions do not have to go through the OpenGL ARB before being implemented, whereas vendors are dependent on DirectX being releases with their own extensions built in.
Cheers,
Toby Haynes
Anything I post is strictly my own thoughts and doesn't necessarily have anything to do with the opinions of IBM.
--Ty
I don't understand why you'd wait for the next version of DX--why not just use OpenGL? It's already here AND it's cross-platform.
--
Linux MAPI Server!
http://www.openone.com/software/MailOne/
Linux MAPI Server!
http://www.openone.com/software/MailOne/
(Exchange Migration HOWTO coming soon)
so far, I've only played one game on my brother's playstation. I've always been a computer gamer. Looking at the stats on this thing and knowing that NVidia is putting some pretty killer hardware in there, I might have to consider one of these when they are released. Is there a price guesstimate out there anywhere?
Also, are there any major game makers planning on developing for the X-Box? Maybe an X-Box only type game? Like Mario is only for Nintendo, something like that?
Come to think of it, I wonder if the X-Box will have a mascot? Maybe a cute little Borg!
I'm on a chair.
May I have your attention please,
...........
may I have your attention please,
will the real bruce perens please stand up,
I repeat will the real bruce perens please stand up
.....we're gonna have a problem here.........
Ya'll act like you never seen a slash poster before
mouse all on the floor
like mom and daddy just burst in the door
and started whoopin yer ass worse than before
they first had endorsed
buyin' ya a crappy computer (aaaaaah)
It's the return of the...
"awww..wait, no wait, you're kidding,
he didn't just say what I think he did,
did he?"
and Mr. Cray said...
nothing you idiots, Mr Cray's dead
he's locked in my bassment
microsoft women love Sig '11
chicka chicka chicka bruce perens,
"I'm sick of him, lookit him
walkin around, grabbin his GNU know what
flippin' to GNU know who"
"yeah, but he's so smart though"
yeah, I probably got a couple of screws up in my head loose
but no worse than what's goin on in your sister's webcam (eheheheh)
sometimes, I wanna get on ZD and just let loose
but cant, but it's cool for RMS to hump a dead GNU
My mouse is on your link, My mouse is on your link
and if you're lucky, I might just give it a little click
and that's the message that we deliver to little kids
and expect them not to know what a free software is
of course they're gonna know what Microsoft is
by the time they hit 4th grade
they got MS-NBC, dont they?
we ain't nothing but omnivores
well, some of us carnivores
who read other people's mail like crackwhores
but if we can read your e-mail like it's available
then there's no reason that a man can't forge spam from your account
but if you feel like I feel, I got the antedote
trolls wave your penis birds, sing the chorus and it goes........
I'm Bruce Perens, yes, I'm the real Perens
all you other Bruce Perens' are just imitating
so won't the real Bruce Perens please stand up,
please stand up, please stand up
cause I'm Bruce Perens, yes, I'm the real Perens
all you other Bruce Perens' are just imitating
so wont the real Bruce Perens please stand up,
please stand up, please stand up
Sig 11 don't got to cuss in his posts to get Karma
well I do, so fuck him and fuck you too
you think I give a damn about my Karma
half of you trolls can't even stomach me, let alone stand me
"but bruce, what if you win, wouldn't it be weird"
why? so you guys can just lie to get me here
so you can sit me here next to Natalie here
shit,Enoch Root's momma better switch me chairs
so I can sit next to trollmastah and Post First
and hear em argue over who modded it down first
little troll, flamed me back on IRC
"yeah, he's fast, but I think he types one-handed, hee hee"
I should download some audio on MP3
and show the world how you released it BSD (aaaaaah)
I'm sick of you little troll and l33t groups
all you do is annoy me
so I have been sent here to destroy you
and there's a million of us just like me
who post like me, who just don't give a fuck like me
who code like me, walk, talk and act like me
and just might be the next best thing, but not quite me......
I'm Bruce Perens, yes, I'm the real Perens
all you other Bruce Perens' are just imitating
so won't the real Bruce Perens please stand up,
please stand up, please stand up
cause I'm Bruce Perens, yes, I'm the real Perens
all you other Bruce Perens' are just imitating
so wont the real Bruce Perens please stand up,
please stand up, please stand up
I'm like a head trip to listen to
cause I'm only givin you things
you troll about with your friends inside you rabbit hole
the only difference is I got the balls to say it
in front of ya'll and I aint gotta be false or sugar coated at all
I just get on the web and spit it
and whether you like to admit it (riiip)
I just shit it better than 90% you trollers out can
then you wonder how can
kids eat up these posts like gospel verse
it's funny,cause at the rate I'm going when I'm thirty
I'll be the only person in the chat rooms flirting
cyberin with nurses when I'm jackin off to porno's
and I'm jerkin' but this whole bag of viagra isn't working
in every single person there's a bruce perens lurkin
he could be workin at Micron Inc., spittin on your SDRAM
or in the printer queue, flooding, writin I dont give a fuck
with his windows down and his system up
so will the real perens please stand up
and click 1 of those fingers till you drag up
and be proud to be outta your mind and outta control
and 1 more time, loud as you can, how does it go?
I'm Bruce Perens, yes, I'm the real Perens
all you other Bruce Perens' are just imitating
so wont the real Bruce Perens please stand up,
please stand up, please stand up
cause I'm Bruce Perens, yes, I'm the real Perens
all you other Bruce Perens' are just imitating
so wont the real Bruce Perens please stand up,
please stand up, please stand up
I'm Bruce Perens, yes, I'm the real Perens
all you other Bruce Perens' are just imitating
so wont the real Bruce Perens please stand up,
please stand up, please stand up
cause I'm Bruce Perens, yes, I'm the real Perens
all you other Bruce Perens' are just imitating
so wont the real Bruce Perens please stand up,
please stand up, please stand up
haha guess it's a bruce perens in all of us........
fuck it let's all stand up
Will the real Bruce Perens Please Stand Up
IMHO he says what his advisers want him to say, then he says what he wants to. Pity is, he doesn't realize how much this qualifies him to run for president. It's like the kiss of death.
It's all true! ±5%
A feeling of having made the same mistake before: Deja Foobar
First of all, not all games are made for the 13 year old hyperactive destructive kid (and I don't believe all of that media bullshit which tells us that violent games make kids violent; you can tell what is real by the age of 3..). There are actually games which are calm, and require some thought. I'm not saying it's gonna make you a genius or be harder than your Robust Digital Signal Processing class, but they aren't made to be for the twitchy-fingered young-uns.
Second, you might notice who plays the games: there are actually a lot of people in their 20s or 30s who play games, and they play all kinds of games. However, I must say that it is true that most young gamers do play twitchy games....
Oh. And there are Barbie games, as well as, gasp, a Barbie printer! It's sooooooo cute!
Ahem.
Just tryin' to defend us gamers some... Hyuk....
Fnord.
Quake 3 Arena!
Diablo 2
Counter Strike!!!
The Elder Scrolls: Morrowind!
My current GF loves these games as much as any guy I've met.. :)
So do a lot of women...
I think, if you look at the amount of time spent behind a keyboard by gender division, you'd find the amount of games purchasers/players are consistent with the PC home users figures.