Slashdot Mirror


City Of Houston To Offer Free Email To Residents

Don Symes writes: "The City of Houston is getting ready to roll out 'free' email and web-hosted word processing. First to libraries and fire stations(!?), poorer areas, then to those who can afford ISPs." It would be interesting to compare the cost of Internet Access Technologies' multi-million dollar contract with private ISP access, especially for the dozen other cities considering similar deals.

277 comments

  1. linux too.... by jeffy124 · · Score: 1

    [wishful_thinking] they're able to give each resident their own copy of Linux if they wanted to as well. [/wishful_thinking]

    --
    The One Rule Of Chess You'll Ever Need: Don't play someone who carries a kit in their bookbag.
    1. Re:linux too.... by SirNoir · · Score: 1


      Unfortunately they would also have to give each resident their own computer to run it on. I doubt very seriously if OS license cost is the blocking point for anyone that hasn't bought a computer.

    2. Re:linux too.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      At a few dozen cents per CD + postage + the salary of a gov't employee to do the burning and mailing, the total cost of something like that wouldn't be too much trouble for any municipality. Of course, handing out the requisite hardware would be costly.

    3. Re:linux too.... by pkimball · · Score: 1

      I think they have the right idea. First you allow the people who use the public access to knowledge to expand their horizons. You are rewarding the people who go out of their way to LEARN. When is the last time someone who could afford a broadband connection like most of us went to the public library. Maybe, often but I think most of us use the net or order books online. I enjoy my public library to keep up on current fiction but I rarely need to go there for information anymore. I think this is a good use of public money BUT, the best way to execute this program would be to use "free" or software that doesn't require a public license. This is why linux is so popular and why it could be the standard for browsers. We just need the great browsers to compete with IE.

    4. Re:linux too.... by iamblades · · Score: 1

      Well, not exactly, but a windows liscence is a large percentage (around 20%) of a low end system price. About 10% for an OEM copy actually... Which is still a sizeable chunk, and it is much cheaper to pay 2 dollars for a linux cd, which should be only a 20th or less of a windows OEM liscence...

      --
      Shit adds up at the bottom...
  2. typo alert by eudas · · Score: 0, Troll

    "The city of Hosuton" should be "The city of Houston".

    cheers,
    eudas

    --
    Blessed is he who expects the worst, for he shall not be disappointed.
    1. Re:typo alert by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      No, everyone knows it's "the planet Hooston."

  3. B.F.D. by FFFish · · Score: 2

    My local library has been offering free Internet access for a couple years now. Before that, you could get free access from a few government agencies.

    --

    --
    Don't like it? Respond with words, not karma.
    1. Re:B.F.D. by Jester998 · · Score: 1

      They're not offering free 'net access; they're providing free email and web-based word processing. email != Internet !!!

      To be able to use the service at home, users still need an account at an ISP. If they don't, then they need to use 'net access at a library or whatever.

      - Jester

    2. Re:B.F.D. by FFFish · · Score: 2

      Just noticed the bit about Word. Same thing as with the 'net access: there's been free access to it in my town for at least five years. All part of the "employment insurance" program: to get people into jobs, they gotta have access to the tools that'll get 'em hired.

      --

      --
      Don't like it? Respond with words, not karma.
    3. Re:B.F.D. by Glenn+R-P · · Score: 2, Informative

      The Enoch Pratt Free Library in Baltimore, MD, offered low-cost shell accounts ($36.00 per year) for several years (ca. 1996-98) until they were forced by some commercial ISP to stop the "unfair competition".

    4. Re:B.F.D. by GlassUser · · Score: 2, Informative

      You're even more right than you know, BFD. Public libraries already provide free access to free email. What they're actually doing is planning to provide word processor and spreadsheet access in addition.

  4. well by kraada · · Score: 1

    it's a start. next maybe we'll work on getting the poor food, shelter and jobs. i doubt it, but in the meantime, at least they can surf the web and pretend to be rich :)

    1. Re:well by Frymaster · · Score: 3, Insightful
      increasingly, email is an important vehicle for finding a job. if you can't afford the internet, maybe you need a job... if you haven't got a job, you can't afford the internet.

      now the firestation comes to the rescue.

    2. Re:well by agentZ · · Score: 2

      &lt alice-cooper &gt

      I can't get a job 'cause I have the 'Net,
      Can't get the Net 'cause I don't have a job,
      Don't you know where you are?
      Lost in America
      Lost in America
      Lost in America, lost!
      &lt /alice-cooper &gt

    3. Re:well by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Houston libraries already provide taxpayer financed free internet access.
      A huge duplication of effort which will eventually lead to dedicated city offices for email/internet access. Can you say 'community outreach'? How long will it be before the Terms of Service for the email will include 'users of Houston City email will from time to time receive offers, campaign materials, and charity solicitations. Users of Houston City Email approve receiving solicitations from ...."

      Bottom Line: Free political advertising for the mayor who is running for reelection.

      Here's another story on how government programs created to 'fix' some evil grow into multi-billion dollar industries.
      http://foxnews.com/story/0,2933,32555,00.html

    4. Re:well by Bobo+the+Space+Chimp · · Score: 1

      > it's a start. next maybe we'll work on getting
      > the poor food, shelter and jobs. i doubt it, but
      > in the meantime, at least they can surf the web
      > and pretend to be rich :)

      And much like government's involvement in helping "the poor" creates more, dependent poor, so to will government's involvement in e-Mail make it more expensive.

      Instead of working to provide low-cost e-Mail, the companies contracted to do this will keep whining about how much it costs, deliberately avoiding effeciencies to keep sucking on the government tit.

      Anyone wanna bet if a citizen of the Great People's City of Houston pays more via taxes for his "e-Mail" account than he does for his dialup?

      They're certainly paying more for it right now thru taxes than they pay for a Hotmail one, or any of hundreds of other free e-Mail services.

      --
      I am for the complete Trantorization of Earth.
  5. I live in Kansas City and... by crazyprogrammer · · Score: 1

    kansascity.com tried that last year and I don't think it took off too well. I don't know anybody who has a @kansascity.com address, and I've never recieved email from anyone with a @kansascity.com address(not even a SPAM message).


    --
    "the fax machine is nothing but a waffle iron with a phone attached to it." - Grandpa Simpson
    1. Re:I live in Kansas City and... by mr100percent · · Score: 1

      I don't think they're going to turn a profit or anything, it looks like a big money pit, maybe Kansas had financial troubles, ie. budget cuts.

    2. Re:I live in Kansas City and... by briareus · · Score: 1

      That's really great reasoning. X couldn't get Y to work, so no one should even bother . . .

  6. More Privacy violation by TrollMaster3000 · · Score: 0

    Just another way to violate privacy. More spam. More Spammers. More trouble.

    --


    I'm no punk bitch !!!
    1. Re:More Privacy violation by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's no more likely to cause a privacy problem than your average ISP.

      The rather poor proliferation of encrypted mail is a more critical factor.

  7. Web-Hosted Word Processing? by NitsujTPU · · Score: 1

    Why would anybody want to get on the net to word process, or am I merely misunderstanding this statement?

    1. Re:Web-Hosted Word Processing? by spudnic · · Score: 2

      Say you didn't have access to a computer at home, or consitant use of any single computer at all, it would start to make a little more sense.

      The whole idea, as I see it, is that you get their equivilent of a "web folder" where you can store all of your files. Working on your resume? A school project? Learning for learning's sake? You can go to any place that has an Internet connection and have access to your word processing application and files.

      No pesky disk problems or anything else to worry about. (with the possible exception of crackers, Government snooping/eavesdropping, project failure/lack of funding resulting in lost documents, etc.)

      --
      load "linux",8,1
    2. Re:Web-Hosted Word Processing? by mdw2 · · Score: 1

      You simply misread. What's been on the local news around here is that the city will offer free email for all residents, and that many public computers will word processing programs installed onto them (MS Word I would assume), and those computers would be the same computers you always see people browsing the web on from the library.

      --
      This sig intentionally left blank.
    3. Re:Web-Hosted Word Processing? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      MS Word Web folders

    4. Re:Web-Hosted Word Processing? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Uh, i think everyone in this thread misread (or didn't attempt to visit simdesk.com. To me simdesk looks like an office suite that is installed on the machine and is tied into simdesk's servers for storing information. That way you can goto any machine with simdesk installed, log in, and away you go.

  8. Great idea, but will it reach its potential? by CoachS · · Score: 1
    I'm always in favor of pushing technology to every individual who wants it, and so I like the idea of offering these kinds of services.

    I'm skeptical, though, that the people motivated and able to use it aren't already in possession of an e-mail address from somewhere. Does an illiterate who can't read or type really have much benefit from e-mail access? Isn't it possible that the Internet market is approaching saturation? Does anybody who wants to get online (especially in a major city) not already have at least a Hotmail or Yahoo! address through their local library, school, friends' house or Internet Cafe?

    Nonetheless, if it improves communication and helps people, especially those who can't afford a computer or Internet Access of their own, I'm all for it.

    Coach

    --
    Perhaps the world's greatest tragedy is that ignorance is not impotence.
    1. Re:Great idea, but will it reach its potential? by spudnic · · Score: 4, Insightful

      No, no, no, and finally, no. I've worked with a couple of freenet projects. We took donated old PC hardware, fixed it up and provided it free of charge (along with a free account with an ISP) to people who just couldn't afford to pay.

      Strange as it may seem to you, there are people who can't afford this who can read.

      Some are old folks who use the Internet as a companion when nobody else is around. Others are inner-city and/or very rural kids whose parents are so screwed up that they can barely afford to keep the electricity on, much less provide connectivity.

      The Internet to them can be a form of escape. Not only in the sense of a mental escape from their harsh reality, but in a physical escape from the poverty that surrounds them by utilizing the information that they then have access to via the 'net to make a better life for themselves.

      No, not everyone who can read has ready access to a computer and the Internet. Not even close.

      --
      load "linux",8,1
    2. Re:Great idea, but will it reach its potential? by CoachS · · Score: 1
      Well, if you say so. I'm certainly supportive of extending Internet services to anybody who wants them - they just seem awfully extended now.

      My grandparents have Internet access. I have friends in Los Angeles who can barely afford rent who manage to get e-mail. My uncle got WebTV, my friend "E" doesn't have a computer but checks his Yahoo! mail from a friend's house 2-3 times a week.

      Most of the public libraries I've been in lately have web terminals where one could access Hotmail or other web-based mail services for free.

      If there really are that many people who will use it then I'm all for helping them out. I'm just skeptical that the well is really that much deeper.

      -Coach-

      --
      Perhaps the world's greatest tragedy is that ignorance is not impotence.
    3. Re:Great idea, but will it reach its potential? by mr100percent · · Score: 1

      Perhaps it will be an ISP without all the strict TOS agreements, without all the strict restrictions.

  9. In reply to your .sig by jazmataz23 · · Score: 1
    gah, I was under the impression that /. was an erudite and thoughtful crowd before I followed your advice.
    I'm soooo disillusioned.

    jaz

    --
    Death to Argument by Slogan!! (This post twice-encrypted with ROT-13. Replies not using same will be ignored)
  10. How come they call it "Hewston"? by unitron · · Score: 3, Insightful
    Is Hosuton anywhere near Houston?

    Will the spammers be signing up all the poor people down there to do their dirty work for them? What kind of terms of service will the city impose and how bad does somebody have to screw up to lose their privileges, and how soon will the fight start over whether it's privilege or right?

    --

    I see even classic Slashdot is now pretty much unusable on dial up anymore.

    1. Re:How come they call it "Hewston"? by CoachS · · Score: 2, Interesting
      Will the spammers be signing up all the poor people down there to do their dirty work for them?

      An interesting question - hadn't occured to me. A new variation on the "Make money stuffing envelopes at home" scam could be the "Make money remailing spam" scam. Of course, this leads to the question of what proof of residency is going to be required to get an account? What stops spammers from just strolling in (or sending agents to do so) claiming to be "Carlos Moreno" ("Charlie Brown" for the Spanish-impaired) and asking for their free account.

      ...which they proceed to use to spam mercilessly until it's yanked (if it ever is) and they just stroll into a different library or fire station and claim to be "Dave Smith" and ask for their free account...

      What kind of terms of service will the city impose and how bad does somebody have to screw up to lose their privileges, and how soon will the fight start over whether it's privilege or right?

      Yet another important question. Can a spammer, who is a legitimate resident of Houston (or Hosuton) have their account revoked for ANY reason?

      I still like the idea of widening Internet access with programs like this, but these are troubling questions that don't appear to have any easy answers.

      -Coach-

      --
      Perhaps the world's greatest tragedy is that ignorance is not impotence.
    2. Re:How come they call it "Hewston"? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Can a spammer, who is a legitimate resident of Houston (or Hosuton) have their account revoked for ANY reason?

      Can a bad driver who is a legitimate resident of Texas have his driver's licensce revoked for ANY reason? Give me a break; these issues will take a couple of tiresome court cases to hash out, but it won't really be that difficult.

    3. Re:How come they call it "Hewston"? by CoachS · · Score: 1
      As a matter of fact it may well be that difficult. The Department of Motor Vehicles in %state% has an extensive and often court-tested set of guidelines for such things and even so there are regular disputes on the matter.

      The City of Houston may have to implement an equally extensive set of rules and regs, plus they don't have the same kind of enforcement infrastructure that the Motor Vehicles folks have.

      This also ties back into the question of proof of residency and identification -- what prevents somebody whose account is revoked from just getting a new account at a different fire station and/or under a different name? Then we get into issues of people with same or similar names, possible confusion, etc.

      It may well be a bumpy road.

      -Coach-

      --
      Perhaps the world's greatest tragedy is that ignorance is not impotence.
    4. Re:How come they call it "Hewston"? by Black+Parrot · · Score: 1

      > How come they call it "Hewston"?

      Etymologically, it's from "Hugh's Town". But I think Hugh's original Town was in England, and Houston, Tx, got the name indirectly.

      > Is Hosuton anywhere near Houston?

      Almost sounds like it could be a place in Japan. However, a quick googling turns up 608 hits on Hosuton, and all the ones I checked were for Hosuton, Tx.

      Maybe it's a little Texas Speed-Trap Town (tm), doing the geographic equivalent of cybersquatting?

      --
      Sheesh, evil *and* a jerk. -- Jade
    5. Re:How come they call it "Hewston"? by Bobo+the+Space+Chimp · · Score: 1

      > "Carlos Moreno" ("Charlie Brown" for the Spanish-impaired)

      Although I don't know what name, if any, Charlie Brown's name is translated to in Spanish, but wouldn't it better be translated as something like "Carlito Moreno"?

      As for terms of service, I can't wait until the city tries to stop spam mailings and gets slapped down by a court.

      --
      I am for the complete Trantorization of Earth.
  11. My favourite part... by wrinkledshirt · · Score: 4, Funny
    In the section on other acts of corporate philanthropy...

    * Microsoft. The software giant last year announced it will donate $100 million in cash and software over 5 years to the Boys & Girls Clubs of America to build 3,000 centers where kids can use PCs.

    Far be it for me to sound cynical, but I wonder how much of that $100 million "in cash and software" is software licenses?

    --

    --------
    Bleah! Heh heh heh... BLEAH BLEAH!!! Ha ha ha ha...

    1. Re:My favourite part... by xcomputer_man · · Score: 1

      4 points for that post, wrinkled shirt. 4 points!

    2. Re:My favourite part... by Reality+Master+101 · · Score: 2

      Do the math. 3,000 centers. Let's say 10 computers per center (high?). Let's say $100 per copy of Windows, plus $150 (?) for the home version of Office. That's only $7.5 million.

      Sorry to be the one to douse the "hardy har har" Microsoft bashing.

      But don't worry ... you can still be cynical by believing they are faceless automotons only doing it as a PR stunt, and they couldn't care less about the actual children.

      --
      Sometimes it's best to just let stupid people be stupid.
    3. Re:My favourite part... by Jebediah21 · · Score: 1

      Far be it for me to sound cynical, but I wonder how much of that $100 million "in cash and software" is software licenses?

      2 Computers - $2,000
      2 Windows liscenses - $300
      1 Lost windows liscence - $97,700

      --

      Everytime you look at porn a devil gets their horns.
    4. Re:My favourite part... by jhines · · Score: 1

      Don't forget the additional costs of complying with all those licenses, and the SPA audits.

      The time to install security patches over the years.

      Not to mention, by the time they implement 3,000 centers, it is all going to need upgrades.

    5. Re:My favourite part... by InigoMontoya(tm) · · Score: 1
      Far be it for me to sound cynical, but I wonder how much of that $100 million "in cash and software" is software licenses?


      2 Computers - $2,000

      2 Windows liscenses - $300

      1 Lost windows liscence - $97,700


      Watching another kid smash the keyboard because a Blue Screen of Death killed his Word document - priceless.


      There are some things money can't buy. For everything else, there's Microsoft.


      InigoMontoya(tm)

      --
      This signature is self-referential.
    6. Re:My favourite part... by ravic · · Score: 1
      Pathetic Linux automatons. Microsoft employees, Bill Gates and the corporation itself give away millions of dollars in cash, time, and (yes) software and all you can do is sound like the lame sheep you are.

      Cruel, cruel, Microsoft. You should be ashamed at all that you give away. You should be more like Sun, AOL, and Novell and keep it in the company so that MS bashers have even more to cry about.

      --
      Dont eat yellow snow
  12. Cool by sllort · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Cool! Maybe someday they'll catch up to the Cleveland Freenet, 8 years of free publicly accessible e-mail!

    This is a great step forward to catching up with Cleveland.

    1. Re:Cool by drsoran · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Yea, but the problem with Cleveland Freenet was that you needed a computer to access it. 99% of the time these days, anyone who has a computer should be able to afford at least dialup Internet access. If you can't afford $10/month for Internet access then you can't afford the electricity you're wasting with a computer either. Anyone who wants to be on the Internet is already on it. The rest are just cheapskates and technophobes. Do we WANT them on the Internet?

    2. Re:Cool by Boiling_point_ · · Score: 1
      Anyone who wants to be on the Internet is already on it. The rest are just cheapskates and technophobes. Do we WANT them on the Internet?
      By your thinking:

      people who can't afford a computer (with or without 'Net access) are wrong to put their kids' schooling or next meal ahead in the list of priorities, or

      people's distaste for currently available technology and/or those who find the standard of Internet content not useful or applicable to their lives shouldn't be encouraged to at least keep up, so that in five years' time when it does become essential, they're not an underclass?

      Step outside and see how 99% of the world lives, dude.

      --
      "If you create user accounts, by default, they will have an account type of Administrator with no password." KB Q293834
  13. Isn't that useless? by MSBob · · Score: 3, Interesting
    ''We expect to have (people) standing in line to use the Internet,'' says Denny Piper, the city's chief information officer.

    No wonder. If you're only giving them 1000 access points (PCs) for the whole of Houston then no wonder they'll have to queue for or even book their internet access. What good is a free email account when you dont have easy access to it?

    --
    Your pizza just the way you ought to have it.
    1. Re:Isn't that useless? by Imperator · · Score: 2

      Houston already has access in libraries and schools, though the computers in the schools are generally not open to the public and those in the libraries are often crowded. However, the public library system insists that the computers in their libraries are to be used for research purposes only, and the librarians will enforce this policy when there's a queue. This makes me wonder if they talked to the mayor's office about this plan, because according to the Houston Chronicle all they're doing is installing software in those same crowded public libraries.

      --

      Gates' Law: Every 18 months, the speed of software halves.
    2. Re:Isn't that useless? by Rimbo · · Score: 2

      I don't think that the majority of Houstonians are going to be using these access points. In general, I think that people who can afford their own computer and internet service will be using that, and not the public access point.

      It's like cell phones. If you've got one on you, and you've already paid for it, why bother using a public phone, even if the cost per call is cheaper?

  14. It wouldn't be Government unless.... by EABinGA · · Score: 4, Funny
    ''We expect to have (people) standing in line to use the Internet,'' says Denny Piper, the city's chief information officer.

    What would a true government programm be if it didn't involve standing in a line?

    1. Re:It wouldn't be Government unless.... by loconet · · Score: 1

      not only that, but what what do they expect to have? .. a couple of dogs, some elephants .. maybe some plants?

      --
      [alk]
    2. Re:It wouldn't be Government unless.... by sharkey · · Score: 1

      What would a true government programm be if it didn't involve standing in a line?

      They could be bent backwards over a porkbarrel while an emotionless IRS agent picks through their wallets.

      --

      --
      "Outlook not so good." That magic 8-ball knows everything! I'll ask about Exchange Server next.
  15. Is it really new? by Robert1 · · Score: 1

    My city has had internet access in their libraries for years. In fact they recently upgraded all the machines to p4 1.7 gigers. Each machine also has Office, so anyone can type documents or do spreadsheets.

    1. Re:Is it really new? by drsoran · · Score: 1

      Your city sounds like a macro virus breeding ground. :-) Do they have Outlook so you can check your mail?

    2. Re:Is it really new? by Afrosheen · · Score: 1

      Who needs a p4 1.7 ghz machine to access the internet and do a little surfing? Oh wait, they probably installed win2k, so in order to surf AND use office xp, you need at least 256mb of ram and a 1 ghz machine right?

    3. Re:Is it really new? by Robert1 · · Score: 1

      Actually yes, they do use win2k :)
      And indeed they also use Outlook, but the library system has a l33t group of computer geeks who work around the clock to keep them running and virus free.

  16. Why? by alen · · Score: 2, Interesting

    There is Hotmail, Yahoo and a ton of other free email services. Why spend tax payer money for another one? What is it going to offer that the other ones don't? You can have all the email accounts you can track, but you still need a computer to access them.

    1. Re:Why? by Nanookanano · · Score: 1

      If everybody has an email address, verified by the government, then the possibility of accurate, electronic voter representation becomes nearer to reality.

      Check your email, vote on a few issues, update your resume, log-off and go about your business.

      --
      "..don't you eat that yellow snow."
    2. Re:Why? by alen · · Score: 1

      Isn't it easier to just have computer centers and let them access private services? Hotmail or yahoo for email. Monster for job searches.

      As far as voting on the internet. When pigs fly, which with current tech isn't too far of.

    3. Re:Why? by Nanookanano · · Score: 1

      Centers located at welfare and unemployment offices. Not a bad idea.

      --
      "..don't you eat that yellow snow."
    4. Re:Why? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You've just given me a whole new goal in life. To make a flying pig. Then all those fuckers who have ever used the old, way overused saying... Time to cash in.

      Thank you.

  17. Firestations? by suwain_2 · · Score: 2, Insightful
    Yeah, my local news ran something on this.

    Apparently, police and fire stations will have public Internet access. Does anyone else find the concept of going to the fire station to send e-mail to be a bit bizarre? "Hi, sorry it's taken me so long to respond, but I haven't been able to get to the local fire station this week..."

    Also... Don't get me wrong, I have no reason to doubt the integrity of the police, but some people do. So... Wonder what they'll think about Internet censorship if you do your e-mail from a *police station*?

    And yet another thing - won't people be in the way? I don't quite see this taking off that well, but if it does, it could become a pain to get to these local places for "normal" reasons...

    --
    ________________________________________________
    suwain_2 :: quality slashdot p
    1. Re:Firestations? by catfood · · Score: 1

      Apparently, police and fire stations will have public Internet access. Does anyone else find the concept of going to the fire station to send e-mail to be a bit bizarre?


      Well, yes and no.


      In large cities, there's always a fire station within a mile or so. And it's less hassle to have people drop in there than in the police station or a school.


      It's no weirder than all those places that have voting at the fire station.

    2. Re:Firestations? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      To expand upon catfood's observation that fire stations are often closer I'll add that fire stations often have longer hours. My local library is lucky to have 4-6 hours a day, 4 days a week. My local fire station is 24/7. I expect I wouldn't be allowed to drop by at 3am to read email but it's got to be better than the library.

  18. More waste of taxpayer money by humblecoder · · Score: 2, Interesting
    Why is a government organization spending money to create a service that people can already get for free via the private sector? It seems like the only people that gain are the politicians (and maybe the advertisers since they have a another couple thousand email accounts that they can feel free to spam). They can pat themselves on the back for "narrowing the digital divide", when in fact they are doing no such thing.


    If they really want to make a different, why not provide vocational training for the disadvantaged so they can actually learn a skill to help them better themselves. Now, that would be money better spent.

    1. Re:More waste of taxpayer money by Rimbo · · Score: 2

      Where can I get a computer for free? Please, sign me up!

    2. Re:More waste of taxpayer money by spudnic · · Score: 2

      FreePC
      eMachines

      Doh! Nevermind.

      --
      load "linux",8,1
    3. Re:More waste of taxpayer money by garcia · · Score: 2

      it is big words spoken by big people that make it all seem sooo great.

      we have a poverty rate... we are spending money on free e-mail for the public... I don't see e-mail being a large priority over food/shelter.

      are they going to start putting e-mail stations in the shelters so that the "residents" there can have a place to send out their resumes for new jobs?

    4. Re:More waste of taxpayer money by Waffle+Iron · · Score: 2
      If they really want to make a different, why not provide vocational training for the disadvantaged so they can actually learn a skill to help them better themselves. Now, that would be money better spent.


      No, you're forgetting that this is Houston. Here, the first priority is trucks. The government has done a great job so far, because now every family here has at least one truck.


      Unfortunately, we now have a "maximum-GVW divide". It seems that many poor and minorities only have a short bed, a regular cab, or (shudder), a compact pickup. These people will never catch up with the affluent class who drive late model super-duty 4x6s with V10 engines.


      If they really, truly want to make a difference, they should provide a free crew-cab extended bed pickup to every family. Only then will we have social justice in Houston.

    5. Re:More waste of taxpayer money by Brian+Stretch · · Score: 2

      Where can I get a computer for free? Please, sign me up!

      It's called used hardware. Now that the new stuff is so cheap, it shouldn't be too much trouble to hunt down an old 486 or even a Pentium for next to nothing. Kinda like how the poor drive used cars instead of new ones. (Hell, I drive a used car, if only because I'd rather piss away my money on computer toys :-)) It also says something about America when people who are "poor" have cars, but I digress.

      Not that there isn't merit to having a few publically accessable Internet-connected PCs in libraries and such, it's just not that big a deal. If the politicians really wanted to help, they'd quit making it so damn difficult to build new (fiber optic) cable plants to compete against the existing antiquated communications infrastructure, assuming there's much to compete with in the first place. No more legal monopolies in exchange for taxes--er, "franchise fees", 'kay?

  19. Expect this trend to continue. by Apuleius · · Score: 2

    When Joe Sixpack starts to need email for
    things like job-hunting, things like this
    will be damned important.

  20. Not the government's job by kmweber · · Score: 1

    It was just a matter of time before someone said this anyway, so I will.

    Why should taxpayers be forced to pay for someone else's Internet access? It's bad enough we have public schools and public libraries. Also, why should the lazy and ignorant be the first to benefit from this?

    --
    "Other than that, Mrs. Lincoln, how was the play?"
    1. Re:Not the government's job by spudnic · · Score: 1

      What about the innocent kids of the lazy and ingorant?

      --
      load "linux",8,1
    2. Re:Not the government's job by kmweber · · Score: 1

      What about the innocent kids of the lazy and ingorant?

      Let's create a police state...it's for the children.

      --
      "Other than that, Mrs. Lincoln, how was the play?"
    3. Re:Not the government's job by briggsb · · Score: 1

      I think it's little jump from providing services to kids and people to a police state. I guess there aren't black helicopters in my world though.

  21. Forced Charity by Richthofen80 · · Score: 1, Flamebait
    What a waste of money.


    I bet every hard working taxpayer in that city will examine his paystub with pride, knowing his labor paid for internet access for others. Never mind if that citizen wanted the money to pay for others or not. No, we should never consider that. only consider the poor, internet-less.


    Someday, when people stop vomiting on the constitution of the United States, and the philosophy and principles it stood for, people will stop this nonsense. but for now, it's forced charity.

    --
    Reason, free market capitalism, and individualism
    1. Re:Forced Charity by Imperator · · Score: 2
      I bet every hard working taxpayer in that city will examine his paystub with pride, knowing his labor paid for internet access for others.
      Nope, Houston taxes sales, not income.
      --

      Gates' Law: Every 18 months, the speed of software halves.
    2. Re:Forced Charity by Faux_Pseudo · · Score: 2

      People like you are the reason most nations have a representative democracy. If people got to chose what their tax dollars where spent on then we would have no infrastructure* or defense**.
      But, since we do get a say in who we elect to make these decisions, if you are pissed that your money got spent on something that you don't like then you can vote them out.

      *The internet.
      ** The internet.

    3. Re:Forced Charity by Guppy06 · · Score: 2
      "I bet every hard working taxpayer in that city will examine his paystub with pride,"


      I don't believe Houston has an income tax. Or any other local government for that matter. I'm not sure any local government even has the right to tax income. Sales tax, yes. Property tax, yes, but not income tax.


      "and the philosophy and principles it stood for,"


      What, you think this is taxation without representation? You don't think there was a public quorum on this?


      "but for now, it's forced charity."


      ... and you have nobody else to blame but yourself and your neighbors.

    4. Re:Forced Charity by farmhick · · Score: 1

      "...when people stop vomiting on the constitution of the United States, and the philosophy and principles it stood for...."

      If this was being done by the Federal government, this argument would apply. But local and state governments can spend their tax revenue as they see fit. Just because you libertarians have a valid argument against the Feds funding education, Social Security, and Medicare, doesn't mean the states and cities can't do it on their own. Unless THEIR constitutions and charters say otherwise, they can do as they please.

      Also, if the Houston people don't like it, they can vote-in a different bunch next year that will repeal it, which is a lot easier than replacing the House of Reps, much less the US Senate. Or, failing that, those who really don't like it can always leave that city, move to Dallas or something, and still be in their same state, and same country. Can't do that when it's the Federal Government that your pissed at. You'd have to leave the country.

      And you wonder why so many people don't get it. Your viewpoint is the problem here. The US Constitution applies to the Federal Government, or is supposed to of course.

      --
      I have to stop wasting so much time reading Slashdot. It's interfering with my crystal meth addiction.
    5. Re:Forced Charity by catfood · · Score: 1

      I don't believe Houston has an income tax. Or any other local government for that matter. I'm not sure any local government even has the right to tax income. Sales tax, yes. Property tax, yes, but not income tax.


      Okay, don't believe it.


      But local income tax is very common in Ohio at least.

    6. Re:Forced Charity by Waffle+Iron · · Score: 2
      Never mind if that citizen wanted the money to pay for others or not.

      What part of "there's nothing certain in life except death and taxes" do you not understand? Deal with it or run for mayor.

  22. comparision.. by sjwt · · Score: 1

    Id guess they chose libraries and firestations,

    cause everywhere has one or the other? :)

    On a side note, a numbr of counciles out hear in

    .au have offerd free or cheep ($0.50 us an hour)

    access to the net for a few years, they also

    offer word prossesing, scaining and printing..

    basicly so those who cant offred computers can

    still use them, its a great idea..

    Though the email and web hosting, now thats

    something i havent herd of, but is it realy

    needed? In our libarys theres just info sheats

    up on Hotmail and a few free hosting sights..

    do they realy need to spend public money on

    some? mind you i havent used either hotmail

    or free hoasting for years.. so maybe they

    are worse then they used to be.

    --
    You have 5 Moderator Points!
    Which Helpless Linux zealot/MS basher do you want to mod down today?
    1. Re:comparision.. by Afrosheen · · Score: 1

      Do they teach english where you live? Maybe if you'd had internet access for free when you were growing up, the English language would've been more accessible.

    2. Re:comparision.. by sjwt · · Score: 1

      read my sig..
      .

      --
      You have 5 Moderator Points!
      Which Helpless Linux zealot/MS basher do you want to mod down today?
  23. So? by number+one+duck · · Score: 1

    Hate to be a cynic, but since when has *anyone* paid for email that didn't want to? Its been a free-via-ads industry since at least 1995... practically an ice age ago in internet time.

    1. Re:So? by duffbeer703 · · Score: 2

      How long will that continue?

      Hotmail will not be free for long and other mail providers are dropping like flies.

      Yahoo will not exist in 3 years.

      --
      Conformity is the jailer of freedom and enemy of growth. -JFK
  24. Quick, e-mail the firemen... by netsharc · · Score: 1

    the printer is on fire!

    --
    What time is it/will be over there? Check with my iPhone app!
  25. Digital divide by Faux_Pseudo · · Score: 4, Insightful
    We saw an opportunity in the information age . . . to bridge the digital divide

    Can some one tell how bad the digital divide was before the information age?

    Needless to say I am really happy that since the information age is here we can fix this problem.

    1. Re:Digital divide by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

      Can some one tell how bad the digital divide was before the information age?

      It was basically Boole and Turing on one side, and all the other slobs in the world one the other. Things have gotten better pretty steadily since then.

    2. Re:Digital divide by Jerf · · Score: 2
      Can some one tell how bad the digital divide was before the digital age?

      Only the poor were divided from their digits for stealing bread, or attempting to escape slavery. The rich were left with all digits intact. In the era of the computer, the digital divide strikes even harder: Without digits, it's much harder to type.



      Support stem cell research that might lead to cloning fingers and toes so we can finally close the digital divide, now that the electronic age is here!

    3. Re:Digital divide by skoda · · Score: 2

      Maybe it's just late, but that's one of the funniest two sentences I've read online, ever. Wish I had mod points right now. I'm tempted to use that for a .sig quote.

  26. This will not help the poorest. by Rimbo · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I noticed a small bit when RTFA:

    "People who verify their residence will get a SimDesk account number to access the software, including word processing, and e-mail."

    What precisely does "verify your residence" mean? My guess is that it means you will have to have a house, or an apartment, or some other solid place to live. People who are living out of a cardboard box need not apply. So although this is lowing the bar, certain people will still be denied access.

    Despite that, this is a dramatic step in the right direction. Although some say that only a thousand access points is too few, remember that the majority of Houstonians won't be using the public terminals -- they have their own connections -- and they probably don't even go into the neighborhoods where these will be installed.

    Anyhow, if people who can't afford the 'net are lined up to use these, that's a good sign to me. What I'd be most afraid of is that these people would simply have no interest in using them, either due to ignorance or because a particular library terminal is part of a gang's turf.

    1. Re:This will not help the poorest. by Imperator · · Score: 2
      What I'd be most afraid of is that these people would simply have no interest in using them, either due to ignorance or because a particular library terminal is part of a gang's turf.
      Disinterest due to ignorance is likely. However, I don't know about your part of the country, but here in Houston our problems with street gangs don't extend to use of computer terminals at public libraries.
      --

      Gates' Law: Every 18 months, the speed of software halves.
    2. Re:This will not help the poorest. by phalse+phace · · Score: 1
      Perhaps the "people who are living out of a cardboard box" can verify their address by using the police stations if they'll be using their computers to send e-mail.

      "Oh, I live at [insert address], cell number 3."

      I'm also wondering how annoyed these police officers and fire fighters will be with people walking into their stations just to use a computer. Seeing strangers walk in and out of the station throughout the day would sure annoy me.

    3. Re:This will not help the poorest. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      People living out of a cardboard box likely have things more important to worry about than free internet access.

    4. Re:This will not help the poorest. by farmhick · · Score: 1

      "What precisely does "verify your residence" mean? My guess is that it means you will have to have a house, or an apartment, or some other solid place to live. People who are living out of a cardboard box need not apply. So although this is lowing the bar, certain people will still be denied access. "

      Just like homeless people get their Social Security checks, welfare, etc., they can list a homeless shelter as their official residence, even if they only go their for soup at dinnertime.

      --
      I have to stop wasting so much time reading Slashdot. It's interfering with my crystal meth addiction.
    5. Re:This will not help the poorest. by crimoid · · Score: 1

      People who are living out of a cardboard box need not apply.

      People who are living out of a cardboard box probably have more important things to worry about than email. Nowadays we tend to think of the net as one of the most important things in life. But for the vast majority of the people on this planet the net is almost useless in their day-to-day lives.

    6. Re:This will not help the poorest. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Does the local Houston cable company wire up cardboard boxes? No! Why ever not?

    7. Re:This will not help the poorest. by Rimbo · · Score: 2

      People who are living out of a cardboard box probably have more important things to worry about than email.

      It's not just a question of emailing mom, dad, friends, that sort of thing. It's about economic opportunities--the one thing someone in a box on the street doesn't have. Access to the internet is a means to many ends; in the case of a homeless person, it could be the means to getting back on his or her feet once again.

    8. Re:This will not help the poorest. by darthpenguin · · Score: 1

      It's not just a question of emailing mom, dad, friends, that sort of thing. It's about economic opportunities--the one thing someone in a box on the street doesn't have. Access to the internet is a means to many ends; in the case of a homeless person, it could be the means to getting back on his or her feet once again.


      This reminded me of one time I was at the Central Library in downtown Houston. I was at one of the computer terminals, and four or five homeless people were using the terminals next to me. I recall seeing one person slowly typing into a search engine: "jobs". I don't think that would have actually gotten very far in finding him a job, but it indicates that the concept is viable, and if worked on could be very successful.

    9. Re:This will not help the poorest. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Honestly now, do you really expect homeless people on the whole to have anyone to e-mail in the first place. The majority of the reason they are homeless is that nobody is there to help them out except some homeless friends. There are the exceptions of people who are just temporarily homeless, but for the most part they are pretty unstable people with nobody (like caring family or friends) to help them.

    10. Re:This will not help the poorest. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Which reminds me, if you are gonna give homeless people anything, give them food, clothing, and if you can, a job and even a place to live.

    11. Re:This will not help the poorest. by JWhitlock · · Score: 2
      What precisely does "verify your residence" mean? My guess is that it means you will have to have a house, or an apartment, or some other solid place to live. People who are living out of a cardboard box need not apply. So although this is lowing the bar, certain people will still be denied access.

      ...

      Anyhow, if people who can't afford the 'net are lined up to use these, that's a good sign to me. What I'd be most afraid of is that these people would simply have no interest in using them, either due to ignorance or because a particular library terminal is part of a gang's turf.

      I was a bit shocked to read your post- obviously a humerous post, I thought, nicely done - but it got modded up as interesting, and people seemed to be taking it seriously...

      Why, when you think "free email accounts", do you immediately think of gang memebers and homeless people? Like others have said, homeless people probably have more to worry about than catching up on MAKE $$$ FAST FROM HOME!!! mesages, and gang members probably don't care for email. Don't get all your information about the "poor" from COPS and the 6 o'clock news...

      When I hear this, I think more of my aunt. She's got a good job, in a call-in service department, even has a manager's position, but isn't paid what she's worth. Unlike many of us, she has to make decisions like "Cable or Internet Access?". She can't use her work email for personal reasons, and was really enjoying the free email account Juno, but was annoyed at the limitations (couldn't follow any web links, for instance).

      There are probably lots of people like this, who have friends and family that have computers and email, but that they can't personally afford a computer and dial-up account, or have to decide amoung entertainment options, or even between necessities. What Houston is doing is making the first steps toward a universal system that these folks could use to check their email once a week or so, and learn the joys of the hoax email.

      It's also a step toward email addresses linked to a physical address - a marketer's dream. These kinds of services will probably be more profitable than the other "free" email services, and quickly you won't be able to get a free account without giving up an address.

      BTW - my aunt was able to upgrade from my hand-me-down computer to a shiny new Dell - her workplace sponsered reduced-cost computers through payroll deductions, along with Internet Access. This is a great move for companies - you get employee loyalty, give them a real benefit, and they train themselves to use computers on their own time. This isn't the first time I've seen a company's self-interest result in an employee getting a personal home computer - maybe companies aren't so evil...

    12. Re:This will not help the poorest. by crimoid · · Score: 1

      Granted. But simply having access to the net does not auto-magically get someone a job. Opportunity or not, there are issues that a homeless person must take care of before they even look for a job. Food, shelter, a bath. I'm being serious here. At the ISP that I used to work at we had a terminal in front for people to use. This one homeless guy started coming in and using it... with the hope of finding a job. After awhile he didn't show up anymore, then one day he shows up again, but this time he was all cleaned up. He said that he finally "broke down" and got a "real" job at the local lumber mill. He was still homeless, but he had camped near a park where he could shower and get clean water. He had saved enough to get new clothes and was working to save up enough for an apartment. He was there (at the ISP) to check the web for some sports scores or something (cause he didn't have TV, presumably). At any rate, my point is that when you are that down on your luck, it usually takes a lot more than email to get you on your feet. Sometimes you just need to break down and work your ass off.

  27. Houston to Give Itself Legal Headaches;Mediocre PR by lawyamike · · Score: 4, Insightful
    This is nothing more than a boondoggle, a misallocation of resources. Why don't they also give everyone a yourname.houston.tx.us web page, or any other service that is easily available gratis for everyone whom would take advantage of it.

    If the private sector is performing a service amicably -- e.g., providing free e-mail accounts to anyone with web access -- why would a locality waste even a tiny bit of resources to accomplish the same?

    The odd legal twist on this -- that reason that I am even posting on this thread -- is that the Houston e-mail account doubtlessly will be more constrained than AOL or its ilk in what it can and cannot do to subscribers.

    For example, let's say that some enterprising young tech at Houston's e-mail server decides to start reading e-mail at random, with the intention of invading privacy. That could satisfy the state action requirement necessary to make out a constitutional claim, with attorneys fees available for even a suit that garners only nominal damages.

    For a more dramatic example, let's say that the e-mail system is administered in a way that creates a disparate impact on racial minorities. Let's say that some nut commandeers a server and spams hatemail across the ether. The state could be liable where a private actor would not be. (The constitutional generally only prevents state action that impinges on a citizen's rights, not the same conduct undertaken by a private actor.)

    That's without even touching on the potential liability under Title VI and other federal statutes if the e-mail program employs federal funds.

    Why would any municipality want to do this?

  28. Poorer areas? by phalse+phace · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Just how will this change anything? There are already many free e-mail providers out there (e.g. Yahoo! Mail, Hotmail, email.com,... etc.). If they're so concerned about bridging "the digital divide by making computers accessible to every Houstonian," wouldn't it be a better idea to get computers into these poor homes first, so they'll have a way to access the Internet without having to go to libraries, fire stations, or police stations every time they want to check their mail or do anything else? Houston could even provide the poorer areas with free (or discounted) Internet access, or they could use one of the few, but remaining Free Internet providers.

    1. Re:Poorer areas? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      the poorer homes don't want that shit man. The niggers will just pawn the shit and by dope with the cash

  29. You have to see the good side of this by PRIME · · Score: 3, Interesting

    As a resident of Houston, it's actually a breath of fresh air to hear about forward thinking initiatives such as this. NO, this does not = free Internet access (as some readers have concluded) but this does give many of Houston's less fortunate (read poorer) citizens access to resources otherwise reserved for those who can afford a computer and regular Internet access. In my eyes, every step to elevate citizens beyond their financial boundaries, through the use of technology, is commendable.

    On another note, Houston is also experimenting with electronic voting tablets. They've already invested millions and have held a mock election. I hope this is the beginning of a trend. When I was in SF for training a few months back, I couldn't help but notice the "Peace Love and Linux" symbols on every other sidewalk corner downtown. The perception of a Linux loving community is pretty cool and very forward thinking.

    --
    PRIME - Indivisible by anything but ME!
    1. Re:You have to see the good side of this by yomegaman · · Score: 1

      I hate to break it to ya, but those sidewalk drawings were an IBM ad campaign. :-(

      --
      ...wearing a skin-tight topless leather jumpsuit, with cutaway buttocks and transparent crotch panel.
  30. Big brother issues... by Ryu2 · · Score: 2

    So, will they have the right to monitor your email, since it's a service provided by the government?

    --
    There's 10 types of people in this world, those who understand binary and those who don't.
    1. Re:Big brother issues... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      I agree. This allows a simple one node location to monitor everything passing through by any governmental agency that has the DMCA behind them. Is there a service agreement? Does it allow encryption?

      The libraries in Houston have had net access for years. I'm not sure what this is supposed to do other than corral people. Having grown up in Houston, I know the way the place works. Some sharp kid with family connections hustled the contract, will pocket the money, split, and the thing will be a million or more dollars in debt in about a year. I've seen this over and over in a bunch of diffent clothes for over 30 years.

  31. We've had this in St. Peters, Missouri for years.. by Mustang+Matt · · Score: 2

    I believe Westplex Information Network started in 1994 or 1995.
    www.win.org

    You get a free e-mail address and lynx dialup access for free and in addition you can pay $8/month for a PPP connection.

    It's more or less a good service. It does have short outages from time to time and during busy periods it gives you a two hour window to stay online and then you get booted and have to dial back in. This is by design.

    They're working on offering DSL.

    --
    The man who trades freedom for security does not deserve nor will he ever receive either. - Benjamin Franklin
  32. good - and I'll pay for it by jqh1 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Houston's had free internet access in libraries for as long as I can remember. So what's so good about offering email?
    The effort will (hopefully) involve an appropriately scaled public information campaign -- that's probably the only way to reach a good number of the city's residents who stand to benefit from email.
    It's easy to say that the effort would work just as well if the promoted hotmail or yahoo, etc., but would that be appropriate? What if hotmail goes under (or gets hacked!) - as a Houston taxpayer, I don't want city employees providing free tech support for those services.
    Now if the email is anything like the public works projects going on downtown, we're in big trouble (along the lines of 4,000 servers providing about 10 email accounts), but nevertheless, I think this is a good idea.Spam, we can just turn them on to Houston's spamgourmet :)

    --
    who's moderating the meta-moderators?
  33. Swell. How about state-funded backrubs, too. by brocktune · · Score: 1, Insightful
    What a stunningly transparent vote-buying scheme. Let me get this straight. They are not adding any new PCs - they are just giving free email and document storage.

    What the heck is wrong with Yahoo, Hotmail, etc etc ad nauseam? Secret answer: they don't generate votes for incumbents. PCs in fire stations? Good to know my house burned down because of the queue to get that government pr0n.

    I love the headline: "Houston citizens get free-email." No, it's not free. It will be paid for by your fellow citizens - most of whom work for a living.


    go ahead, mod me down - my dogma will chew the tires off your karma.

  34. Fire stations by agdv · · Score: 1
    First to libraries and fire stations(!?)


    Naah. No fire stations, they got confused. They mean fire hydrants, because nowadays everybody and their dog has e-mail.

  35. more wishful thinking by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    "FREE" No, it is NOT free. It is funded by blood money.

    Question to those who see this is good. If you are for this, then why must you be FORCED to fund it? If you believe it is necessary because 'the people' want it, then why must they be FORCED to fund this? Lazy stupid americans, you always talk about freedom and caring for others, but yet you hypocritically push your views on others, and only CARE if you are forced to. Lazy couch potatoes, why don't you get out and volunteer and contribute instead of lobbying/voting for scum that use violence to fund the 'issues' you claim to hold so dear?

  36. computer gangs by Cardhore · · Score: 1

    You'll have to watch out for the background image-tagged workstations. :)

    1. Re:computer gangs by yomegaman · · Score: 1

      And the IM programs will have to be extended to handle all the new emoticons associated with gang signals. That would be totally cool! Just what the Internet needs to enhance it's street cred.

      --
      ...wearing a skin-tight topless leather jumpsuit, with cutaway buttocks and transparent crotch panel.
  37. Potential email delivery of government documents by hillct · · Score: 2

    From the article, it doesn't sound like this is what they're considering, but a while back a federal program was being considered to assign each social security number would have an email address associated with it and government documents, such as ta forms, legal notices, etc. would be delivered via email. The idea was scrapped for technical, security, and privacy issues.

    The question is, does Houston expect to do something similar with their system or are their goals more limited.

    --CTH

    --

    --Got Lists? | Top 95 Star Wars Line
  38. I live in Houston. by Jin+Wicked · · Score: 1

    I saw the chaser for this on the evening news tonight, proclaiming "free internet access for all Houstonians." But then my dad changed channels to a Simpsons rerun, so I didn't watch the actual story.



    Certainly neat to see it on /. though...

    --
    My Webcomic: Asylum on 5th Street
  39. Urban Legend, but poignant... by srvivn21 · · Score: 3, Funny

    An unemployed man goes to apply for a job with Microsoft as a janitor. The manager there arranges for him to take an aptitude test -- (Floors, sweeping and cleaning).

    After the test, the manager says, "You will be employed at minimum wage, $5.15 an hour. Let me have your e-mail address, so that I can send you a form to complete and tell you where to report for work on your first day.

    Taken aback, the man protests that he has neither a computer nor an e-mail address. To this the MS manager replies, "Well, then, that means that you virtually don't exist and can therefore hardly expect to be employed.

    Stunned, the man leaves. Not knowing where to turn and having only $10 in his wallet, he decides to buy a 25 lb. flat of tomatoes at the supermarket.

    Within less than 2 hours, he sells all the tomatoes individually at 100% profit. Repeating the process several times more that day, he ends up with almost $100 before going to sleep that night. And thus it dawns on him that he could quite easily make a living selling tomatoes. Getting up early every day and going to bed late, he multiplies his profits quickly.

    After a short time he acquires a cart to transport several dozen boxes of tomatoes, only to have to trade it in again so that he can buy a pickup truck to support his expanding business. By the end of the second year, he is the owner of a fleet of pickup trucks and manages a staff of a hundred former unemployed people, all selling tomatoes.

    Planning for the future of his wife and children, he decides to buy some life insurance. Consulting with an insurance adviser, he picks an insurance plan to fit his new circumstances. At the end of the telephone conversation, the adviser asks him for his e-mail address to send the final documents electronically.

    When the man replies that he has no e-mail, the adviser is stunned, "What, you don't have e-mail? How on earth have you managed to amass such wealth without the Internet, e-mail and e-commerce? Just imagine where you would be now, if you had been connected to the internet from the very start!"

    After a moment of thought, the tomato millionaire replied, "Why, of course! I would be a floor cleaner at Microsoft!"

    Moral of this story:

    1. The Internet, e-mail and e-commerce do not need to rule your life.

    2. If you don't have e-mail, but work hard, you can still become a millionaire.

    3. Since you got this story via e-mail, you're probably closer to becoming a janitor than you are to becoming a millionaire.

    4. If you do have a computer and e-mail, you probably have already been taken to the cleaners by Microsoft.


    Not true in the details, but true enough in concept. Plus, it throws in a little MS bashing. Everyone loves that...
    1. Re:Urban Legend, but poignant... by yzf750 · · Score: 1

      Not true in the details, but true enough in concept. Plus, it throws in a little MS bashing. Everyone loves that...

      The city of Houston decides to do something for the people, and you use that as a means to bash Microsoft... Only on slashdot.....

    2. Re:Urban Legend, but poignant... by HongPong · · Score: 2

      Um, yeah, except that the manager would just call him at home, and, this being MS, they would probably give him an e-mail account accessable from a kiosk in the break room. What a bizarre way to manage maintenance... Not true in concept at all...

    3. Re:Urban Legend, but poignant... by Frymaster · · Score: 1
      yes, it is still possible to "get ahead" without having e-anything. however, the converse, that with e-everything you're doomed to life at minimum wage is just plain fallacious.


      pick up the want ads in your local paper and check through the trades and technical section (where you will ask yourself: "what the hell is a swamper? what are stwb's?") about 10% (in my paper at least) offer only email and fax as ways to apply. hm.


      hey, i crammed openbsd onto a quadra610!

    4. Re:Urban Legend, but poignant... by Apotsy · · Score: 1
      That's just a modernized version of a short story I read in high school English. I forgot was historical period it was set in, but it was about a man who couldn't read, so he lost his job and ended up doing something that made him rich. At the end of the story, someone asks a similar question, with a similar answer ("I'd still be doing ").

      Unfortunately, I can't remember the name of the story. Anyone?

    5. Re:Urban Legend, but poignant... by rtoads · · Score: 1
      I read the same story. It's "The Verger" by Somerset Maugham. The title is the name of the guy's position at the church. Same punchline, different era. It's about a guy who loses his job in a church because he can't read. So he opens a tobacco/convenience store and then several such stores and is a big success. Punchline at the end is:
      "And do you mean to say that you've built up this important business and amassed a fortune of thirty thousand pounds without being able to read or write? Good God, man, what would you be now if you had been able to?" "I can tell you that sir," said Mr. Foreman, a little smile on his still aristocratic features. "I'd be verger of St. Peter's, Neville Square."
      This urban legend is shameless swiped from this story.
    6. Re:Urban Legend, but poignant... by Apotsy · · Score: 1

      Ah yes, thank you. I wonder how/why things like this get turned in to urban legends? Perhaps someone modernized the story, but never intended for people to take it seriously (which of course, some did).

  40. And this is supposed to help, how? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    More specifically, how will this help the poor get the food and shelter they need to survive, to say nothing of assistance in getting vocational training and finding a real job?

    How will this help school kids who need to be learning critical thinking, basic logic (not the digital kind!), and social skills, not where to find the latest edition of 'Quake?'

    How will this help to keep the city's crime rate down, and pay for things like fire and paramedic services?

    I will grant that I don't live anywhere near Houston (thank God), but after reading Cliff Stoll's two excellent books ("Silicon Snake Oil" and "High-Tech Heretic"), I tend to seriously question the motivation and priorities of ANY community that wants to give its citizens "free" 'net access.

    Quite bluntly, it's just NOT as important as most politicians would like the masses to think. There are probably any number of better uses that the money required to do this could (and should!) be put to.

    I would be interested to see commentary from someone living in the affected area about this project. My open question for them: Do YOU think the project is worth the effort and funds?

    If not, where do you think said funds and effort should go?

    Keep the peace(es).

  41. Great Idea! by Nanookanano · · Score: 1

    We can call it "Minitel".

    --
    "..don't you eat that yellow snow."
  42. Well by Scoria · · Score: 2, Informative

    As a pseudo-resident, I'll say this:

    Lee Brown, the mayor of Houston, has his priorities all wrong. He neglects the city and builds the new stadiums (for the "Houston Texans" (I wonder what kind of genius came up with that name), and the Astros) with the name of the energy company, Reliant, tagged onto it. So now the Astrodome is part of "Reliant Park", which consists of the "Reliant Astrodome", "Reliant Astroarena", "Reliant Stadium (a new one)", etc. We're taxed for it.

    Also, Houston does nothing for free. If this ever becomes more than a plan, you can rest assured that it will be slow and pathetic. Or, better yet, they'll make you pay -- and it will still be slow and pathetic.

    This is what I see in Lee Brown and the management of Houston. They have much bigger fish to fry, imo. Try the roads or the school system, not something to inflate this city's already gigantic ego...

    I'll shut up.

    --
    Do you like German cars?
  43. Right direction anyway by Decimal+Dave · · Score: 1

    While I don't think free email provided by the state is really all that useful, I do like the direction thay're going. What people really need is free broadband. In my opinion, broadband is just as importand as other utilities such as electricity and running water. While the latter aren't exactly free, it would be nice if the govn't would do something about shoddy BB providors.

    --

    "Leave the strategizing to those of us with planet-sized brains." -Tycho
  44. Here's your free email account... by mystery_bowler · · Score: 1

    perhaps it can help you forget about the disparity in education, substandard housing, and, for that matter, legal representation. Oh, and when you're looking for jobs online, be sure to mention how you don't have any high-tech training because the poorly-funded school systems can't afford as much as a working 386.

    Yup, this'll fix that whole digital divide right up.

    --

    My sigs always suck.
  45. No kidding by CptnKirk · · Score: 1
    The City of Houston is getting ready to roll out 'free' email and web-hosted word processing.

    So you mean the residents who payed for this system can use it in their local library? No kidding.

    Being realistic though. The article didn't mention the cost of this new system. Many "free" ISP/E-mail providers are loosing a lot of money and have started charging users. This could lead to higher taxes. Not to mention the legal ramifications of this system. Is it legal to view pronografic E-mail attachments to your free government account at your library access point? What level of MS Office support is offered by this web interface? If there isn't any, what good is this product for resumes?

  46. This reminds me of Wisconsin... by Mzilikazi · · Score: 2, Interesting
    Wisconsin decided to provide free voice mail for the homeless...


    http://www.jsonline.com/news/metro/aug01/voice1108 1001a.asp>

    --
    Random Musings at Rum Smuggler
  47. refuge for TOSsed people by mr100percent · · Score: 1

    I think it's more of "Has your ISP cancelled you for TOS violations? Did you get cancelled for running napster and spamming? Well, use the free government ISP".

    Think they'll ban napster/gnutella from the network? Could the RIAA get your account cancelled easier?

    Nicely socialist, that's a good thing.

  48. Government to provide cheap messaging service by Microsift · · Score: 1

    For about a quarter the federal government will deliver a message from you to another individual. The message can contain pictures and/or text. Correct delivery is insured by using "ZIP" protocol(5 or 9 digit near GUID). For international messages, a slightly higher delivery cost will apply.

    --
    My other sig is extremely clever...
    1. Re:Government to provide cheap messaging service by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      About a quarter? Your cost estimate is off by about a dime.

    2. Re:Government to provide cheap messaging service by Microsift · · Score: 1

      I guess stupid little shitheads who post anonymously have never heard of a postcard!

      --
      My other sig is extremely clever...
  49. Carnivore by mr100percent · · Score: 2

    Has anyone thought of Carnivore, since it's technically a government ISP, though not a .gov domain?

    Yes, there will be people dumb enough to send a threatening letter to the president using that e-mail.

  50. Public access PCs in Library - old news by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    My local library also has been providing patrons with free access to a computer lab for over 3 years. They offer MS Office apps (Word, Excel, PowerPoint) plus web access. No personalized email is provided, but you can always use Yahoo or the other free webmail services. They've got about a dozen PC's in the lab and there's usually never much of a waiting line to get to use them. The only restrictive things are that children must be accompanied by a parent to use the PCs and they'll only let you use floppy disks that you purchase from the front desk, no outside floppies are allowed, since they're paranoid of viruses. The machines are kept up to date with weekly antivirus updates too.

  51. News at 11... by DuranDuran · · Score: 2, Funny

    "...and we leave you tonight with scenes from the City of Houston where residents today were up in arms because of a 'bug' in their email. City commissioners last year elected to use Hotmail as their free mail provider only to find some 'hackers' are able to read users' email. Well, Tony, looks like all their base certainly don't belong to them!"

    --
    "You can justify anything by putting it in quotes, adding a famous name and making it a sig" - Albert Einstein
  52. This is just more city corruption by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    First off i'd like to say that anyone in houston (or any other city for that matter) has had access to free internet almost as long as the internet has existed... juno/yahoo/hotmail/etc... and houston libraries have had computers connected to the internet for a couple of years now, which often remain unused.

    So how does this change anything? Well, someone will get rich no doubt and i'm sure it will cost taxpayers money, as everything else does, lets not forget the new baseball stadium, football stadium, the 12 mile/hr train between the old baseball stadium and new one, the upcoming new basketball stadium, city-owned convention center, the poor excuse for a bus system, etc...
    If they want to save money they can pay me $10,000,000 and i'll send out some mailings to all these people telling them they can register for free email at the places mentioned earlier and can access it at the libraries for free.

  53. dude by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Slashdot requires you to wait 20 seconds between hitting 'reply' and submitting a comment. It's been 4 seconds since you hit 'reply'! If you this error seems to be incorrect, please provide the following in your report to Source Forge: * Browser type * User ID/Nickname or AC * What steps caused this error * Whether or not you know your ISP to be using a proxy or some sort of service that gives you an IP that others are using simultaneously. * How many posts to this form you successfully submitted during the day * Please choose 'formkeys' for the category!

  54. SiMicrosoft vs. Houston by idonotexist · · Score: 2

    This free service (known as 'SimDesk') also allows for access to software? While the article did not specify exactly what type of software will be available, I certainly hope the City of Houston has researched the possible legal ramifications of offering access to Microsoft products to each Houston resident. And, I hope the City's legal staff reviewed its city's selection for the mark of this service.

    This gratis act may arguably result in one of the largest assessed licensing fees in history and a lawsuit by SimCompany.

    I'd like to see the face of the attorney for the software maker of SimCity, SimTower, the Sims, blah blah everything Sim when he/she sees this story.

    How much, exactly, does the city of Houston have in cash reserves?

    --
    "There ought to be limits to freedom"
    1. Re:SiMicrosoft vs. Houston by scrytch · · Score: 2

      I'd like to see the face of the attorney for the software maker of SimCity, SimTower, the Sims, blah blah everything Sim when he/she sees this story.

      That'd be Maxis. Don't fuck with them, all they have to do is hit the disaster button a few times and Hsouton is hsitory!

      --
      I've finally had it: until slashdot gets article moderation, I am not coming back.
  55. Houston Firestations???? by ohdafromboda · · Score: 1

    Yes, the very same firestations in which Mayor "Out of Town Lee Brown" can't come up with funding to provide four firemen per firetruck. Three has been deemed adequate, and look at all the money it saves.

    I suppose Houstonians can all feel better knowing that folks can get on the internet at the firestation, after their house has burned down.

  56. Doesn't minitel do a lot more? by Microsift · · Score: 1
    Americans don't realize what a technological backwater we live in. & years ago I went to europe, they had replaced most pay phones that took coins with pay phones that took smart cards, the French phone book was on minitel, as were train schedules. When we went out to eat, the waiter brought the Credit Card machine to our table! At this point in America, the internet was just taking off.


    Some of this sucked, you had to know where to go to get a phone card, and there were no phone books in the phone booths, so I had to use my barely passable French and get phone numbers from the operator. But for people who lived there, and had access to these technologies, I imagine they simplified matters.


    I guess this might be offtopic, but since we are talking about how the government can help people get access to technology, this seems sort of appropriate.

    --
    My other sig is extremely clever...
    1. Re:Doesn't minitel do a lot more? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's true Americans think they have all this high tech shit, but Europe and Asia are way ahead. The media tries to paint Europe to look like a bunch of little villages with cobblestone streets up in a mountain somewhere. Which maybe true for some places, but they also have kick ass tech that America ain't gonna see for a while. As long as American companies are getting rich and turning out good profits they have no reason to push out new tech. People in japan are way more tech savvy than your average american.

  57. related subject by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A381 62-2001Aug20.html

    Since we are on the topic of those who choose to divorce all aspects of logic and reason from their lives, here is a good one. Violent crime is on the rise in France, specifically involving guns. When questioned about how France with its draconian gun laws is having such a dramatic (and proportionately larger than US) amount of gun crimes a police spokesman talked about making more laws and "limiting circulation"

    That is about as intelligent as saying that by adding yet another "no peeing" sign and threatening people on the grass at a public pool but providing permits for liscensed 'pee-areas', that you will reduce the pee circulation within the pool at large. stupid morons. Stop empowering criminals. Stop neutering honest citizens of their right to be safe. Spend that money, time and rhetoric on education and reducing CRIME!

  58. lyric correction by Sexual+Asspussy · · Score: 0

    We ain't tryin' to be police
    You ain't the cops, this ain't anarchy


    correction:

    We ain't tryin' to be police
    When you ape the cops it ain't anarchy


    bet you didn't think i owned the 7".

    YHBT!

  59. Houston==Banana Republic by cryofan2 · · Score: 1

    HAHAHAHAHAHAA....
    Houston cannot even get the buses to run on any kind of schedule.

    This would be yet another joke...

    1. Re:Houston==Banana Republic by briareus · · Score: 1

      Never mind that Metro is a *county* agency. Not that I'm defending them or anything. It's taken them forever to realize that relying on buses isn't the solution for Houston.

  60. Re:Houston to Give Itself Legal Headaches;Mediocre by jedwards · · Score: 1

    No, let's not do anything that might have the slightest potential for problems. We can go back to living in caves where the worst that can happen is being ripped to bits by a tiger.

  61. Minimum wage laws by phutureboy · · Score: 2

    If they really want to make a different, why not provide vocational training for the disadvantaged so they can actually learn a skill to help them better themselves. Now, that would be money better spent.

    An even better way to make a difference would be to eliminate minimum wage laws, which serve as a barrier to employment for those with few marketable skills. Get people into the workforce and let them learn on the job, real world style.

    I remember when I worked at a bike shop many years ago, there was a guy from the homeless shelter up the street who would stop by several days a week asking for odd jobs. I think he made regular rounds of all the businesses downtown, and we were just one stop of many. Anyway, the bike shop owner would pay him to clean the parking lot every Saturday, and would often find other odd jobs for him to do. The guy was hard working, punctual and honest, but really didn't know how to do anything but pick up cans.

    My point is that people like this are on the verge of entering the workforce, but the value of their labor is less than minimum wage. There are many employers who would give them an entry-level position doing odd jobs like keeping the parking lot clean, but are not able to reconcile the payroll expense of a minimum wage position with the value of the person's labor.

    There are some who are upset by any suggestions to lower or elminate the minimum wage. I realize that most people have a gut reaction that 'people need a living wage'... but jobs simply do not materialize out of thin air. Higher minimum wages cause higher unemployment. Lower minimum wages result in lower unemployment. Ergo, it is more humane to eliminate minimum wage laws.

    1. Re:Minimum wage laws by iamblades · · Score: 2, Insightful

      All that is aside from the fact that minimum wage laws hamper free trade.

      If someone want (or needs) to work for less than minimum wage, then they should definately be able to.

      --
      Shit adds up at the bottom...
    2. Re:Minimum wage laws by FunkSoulBrother · · Score: 1

      Hmm.. sounds all fine and good for the guy who has few skills, except we live in a capitalist society where the rich would be quite happy to take more skilled workers and reduce their wage, knowing that they will have to take it, or lose their job. Thus a current minimum wage job drops below that, the worker has to suck up and take it, the rich get richer, etc.

    3. Re:Minimum wage laws by SurrealKnife · · Score: 1

      There is, however, an easy way to get around the minimum wage laws (at least in the UK): Pay for a single *job* (ie $10 to sweep the lot) rather than per hour, and call it 'subcontracting'.
      Then, it's up to the subcontractor to make sure his/her employees get NMW, which is in other words the old bloke who doesn't care. Hence, labour for less than NMW...

  62. Tech Support Hell by Alien54 · · Score: 2
    kansascity.com tried that last year and I don't think it took off too well. I don't know anybody who has a @kansascity.com address

    I'll pass on the obvious jokes.

    In this situation of free email, the obvious point is that the folks who will be getting the email are folks with less education. This would be true if you imagine that personal income is generally proportional to education.

    I can imagine the poor tech support flogs who have to help these folks out, Unless they make them go through a long and extended glass first. or have it at a city facility or a hall for a long time until the folks get certified that they are expert enough to have it set up at home.

    It appears that the computer market has reached saturation in the US with maybe 60% of US homes having a computer. The other 40% may not be able to afford one, or the learning curve is a bit too steep.

    I can see this. It can get really ugly.

    - - -
    Radio Free Nation
    is a general news site based on Slash Code
    "If You have a Story, We have a Soap Box"
    - - -

    --
    "It is a greater offense to steal men's labor, than their clothes"
  63. It's always nice to get a little recognition. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Although I'm not sure whether I like this news or not. Are we talking about Houston, Texas? I haven't heard anything about it. OH WAIT! never mind Dominique on KPRC just announced it so it must be official. I never underestimate the number of friends our Mayor has that need jobs.

  64. SimDesk? by Advisador · · Score: 1

    Has anyone had any experience with SimDesk or know anything about it?

    Despite their fancy moving menus and weird text animation in the status bar (isn't that a FrontPage thing?), the home page has no . I guess that's not a given when working in FP.

    I'd really like to see a web-based word processor (text areas don't count).

    1. Re:SimDesk? by Advisador · · Score: 1

      ok. i'm a newbie. i didn't realize it'd strip the TITLE tag out, but that's what i meant. no TITLE tag.

    2. Re:SimDesk? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Yahoo has a great writeup on two web based word processors that really rock:



      I think this will answer your questions, and of course, a TITLE BAR is not a problem, Gomer.

  65. Please mod parent:: +1, Informative by Rimbo · · Score: 1

    Because he answered my question. :D

  66. [OT] "Houston Texans" by hitchhacker · · Score: 1

    > "Houston Texans" (I wonder what kind of genius came up with that name)

    They set up a website where people could submit name suggestions. I think a committe selected a few and then had a vote.

    Why my suggestion of the "Houston Hooters" wasn't selected... who knows.

    metric

  67. thank goodness... by Arkive · · Score: 1

    First to libraries and fire stations. I sure am glad to know that all firemen will now be able to spam "first post!!...ph33r m3!@#" while my house is burning down.

    --


    Just my 1.4 cents (after taxes)
  68. Re:We've had this in St. Peters, Missouri for year by biggerboy · · Score: 1

    How big is St. Peters? Is it anywhere near the size of Houston?

  69. Gift Horse(mouth) by Nihilanth · · Score: 1

    Thinking back to my high school years...

    When a publicly funded institution or service provides you with "free" (forgetting about taxes for the moment) internet service (email in this case), you can expect it to be restricted and/or monitored. The government already does enough unlawful invasion of privacy, i certainly don't want them administering my email account.

    Hey, if this free email adress seriously hampered other businesses that sold this service (by giving it away free), would it be seen as anti-competative? It would be amusing to see the government's anti-monopoly rhetoric turned against them.

  70. No, not at all. by Mustang+Matt · · Score: 2

    Westplex actually serves all of St. Charles county which is maybe 200,000 people.

    No where near the size of Houston, but it's a relatively simple process. You start small and grow the service based on demand.

    It will probably suck for the first year or so as they get everything worked out.

    --
    The man who trades freedom for security does not deserve nor will he ever receive either. - Benjamin Franklin
  71. ESR, chester county set examples by defence+budget · · Score: 1

    Eric S. Raymond had helped design and maintain the free ISP for Chester County, called Chester County Interlink. Their mission is "to ensure that Chester County residents and organizations have easy and equitable electronic access to information while encouraging interaction among them as part of an electronic community". Perhaps Hosuton based hackers could help out in similar ways, lending expertise if not equipment?

  72. New York City has an income tax by Bob_Robertson · · Score: 1
    I guess that's the difference between political reality and political theory.


    Oh, and get it right: Governments have POWERS, individuals have rights.


    Bob-

    --
    The Ludwig von Mises Institute. The reasoning individuals economics
  73. Gee, free email. Everyone gets a Hotmail account by Bob_Robertson · · Score: 1
    Automatic account generation: Social Security Number @ houston.tx.us


    It's unique, convenient, and everyone has one, right?


    The idiocy is using force to do what has been done many times before in many different places by interested individuals.


    Re-inventing the wheel with someone elses money is an old tradition among bureaucrats, if they have the power to gather other peoples money in the first place.


    Bob-

    --
    The Ludwig von Mises Institute. The reasoning individuals economics
  74. Its still nice by Srin+Tuar · · Score: 1


    to be able to give away 5-15 million dollars worth of almost nothing to pad the tax write off.


    The shrink wrap and printed holograms get a real nice markup.


    Perhaps they should reveal exactly what the cash/imaginary ratio is. For all you know it could be 50/50. (Encarta, W2K server CAL's, MSN, you never know...)


    Honest question: If you were a charity organization, and were offered a large contribution from Microsoft (or any company) on the condition that you only use their software, would you accept it still?

    Is the cash worth the risk of vendor lock-in?

    Will the kids even gain as much from the monoculture environment?

    1. Re:Its still nice by Klaruz · · Score: 2

      I worked for a computer center in a small rural town when I was in high school. We were offered ms products for free if we used them exclusivly. There was no way, I (the only tech guy) wasn't going to have it. It meant ditching the macs, buying windows machines, ditching the novell server, buying nt 3.11 (this was a while ago), and so on. Forget that... We did manage to get office on both platforms for free though, through another grant.

  75. extended glass? by crucini · · Score: 2
    Unless they make them go through a long and extended glass first.

    I'm having a hard time picturing the process you describe. Should I imagine these newbies viewing a CRT through the bottom of a beer glass? Or using a display two miles away with a telescope (which is certainly an extended (spy)glass.)
    I can see this. It can get really ugly.

    I get it! A looking glass.
  76. Houston is named after Sam Houston by rhinoX · · Score: 1

    There was no Hugh's town. They renamed the city after Sam Houston because he did so much for Texas, and ended up settling in the area.

    Houston, for those who have never been there and like to just bash those of us in Texas, is one of the few great world-class cities this country has. It has awesome food, and good night life, and diversity that you would not believe. Houston is really pretty cool, if not far too large and congested.

    --
    The copper bosses killed you, Joe. 'I never died', said he.
    1. Re:Houston is named after Sam Houston by Bobo+the+Space+Chimp · · Score: 1

      > [Houston] has awesome food, and good night life, and
      > diversity that you would not believe. Houston is
      > really pretty cool, if not far too large and
      > congested.

      Yeah, but you have to become a drinking club member at every different damned bar and restaraunt you go to.

      Now if Hugh's Town (soon to be Sam's Club) gave away free beer instead of free e-Mail, now then I might move there, even if I had to register.

      --
      I am for the complete Trantorization of Earth.
    2. Re:Houston is named after Sam Houston by briareus · · Score: 1

      and humid

      and mosquito-infested

      But our rent is cheap!

    3. Re:Houston is named after Sam Houston by rhinoX · · Score: 1

      You do not have to be a member of anything to drink in Houston.

      --
      The copper bosses killed you, Joe. 'I never died', said he.
  77. Awsome by ioman1 · · Score: 1

    This is good news.

    Even greater new can be found at DT

  78. Re:Houston to Give Itself Legal Headaches;Mediocre by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    leopard

  79. The *real* story by crucini · · Score: 2
    ...which they proceed to use to spam mercilessly until it's yanked (if it ever is) and they just stroll into a different library or fire station and claim to be "Dave Smith" and ask for their free account...

    Ah, but these "fire stations" are actually an elaborate sting operation set up by disgrunted sysadmins. Those guys sitting around sharpening their axes to a razor edge are the same ones that got paged at 3:00 am when the mail server buckled beneath a torrent of spam. They've put out a lot of fires, but not the thermal kind.

    When "Dave Smith" asks for his free account, they take his thumbprint and the computer links him up with "Carlos Moreno" whose account was TOS'd last night. Yes, spammers are stupid.

    "OK, Dave, we just need you to lay your head on the desk for a minute. Yeah, right on that deep groove."
  80. fire station access... by DigitalGodBoy · · Score: 1

    I've heard of accounts being hosed, but this puts a whole new spin on it...

    (drum crash)

    --
    "liberty and justice for all those who can afford it"
  81. Oregon Offered Free PPP, But... by box2321 · · Score: 1

    The library system of Oregon, centered here in Portland, not only had the funds and equipment to offer free PPP service for the whole state but made the decision to offer free PPP service to the whole state. Several local ISPs teamed up and took the County to court, claiming (very rightly, I'd say) that such an offer would put them out of business. The Library system withdrew the offer, although it does still offer a lightning fast dial up (hint: once you are in their shell menu, select a Web address to go to, then telnet://your.favorite.address to open a shell session elsewhere). And all you tattle-tails can put it back in your pants, as the Library is very aware people use their dial up for this purpose and do not mind. Only jackasses would abuse the Library that feeds them. If you must do bad things electronically, do them to deserving parties. Here endeth the sermon.

  82. They don't get it by Steeltoe · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Donation is something remarkable. It's giving something to other people, no strings attached, no expectations of the outcome. It may make you feel good, but without conditions, it can be even better. You can donate in many ways: Material, money, working, educating and generally helping out or being friendly.

    What corporations like Microsoft do when they "donate" their own software to get tax-refunds and with conditions to ensure vendor lock-in, it can hardly be called donation at all. It's like a crack-dealer. The first dose is for free to get you hooked, then they start charging. Let me repeat: There's no way this is donation.

    It should not be tax-refundable. Unfortunately, common sense has dropped significantly in later times. Now rules and laws reign supreme, and people abuse whatever holes they can to reach their own ends. It's ironical that donation is on that list too.

    - Steeltoe

    1. Re:They don't get it by Winged+Cat · · Score: 2

      And I wouldn't put it past MS to make a special "ultra-enterprise for non-profits" edition that never actually seems to sell, possibly due to its being 1000 times market value of equivalent editions (except maybe the icons got changed a bit), but it makes a good tax writeoff.

  83. Re:Houston to Give Itself Legal Headaches;Mediocre by ralphbecket · · Score: 1

    Let's say that some nut commandeers a server and spams hatemail across the ether. The state could be liable where a private actor would not be.

    Perhaps the land of the free should take a look at its legal system?
  84. Belgium. by Gummbah · · Score: 1
    Here in Antwerp, Belgium we've had free email, free 10 meg web hosting and free limited Internet access for about 2 years now. Recently the service even offers full free Internet access. All you pay is telephone cost (still quite enough :)


    ad

  85. What's the proper role of government? by PHAEDRU5 · · Score: 1

    Basically, government is there to provide protection from taking by fraud or force. Nothing else. In return for that, we give government a monopoly over the use of force.

    Look where that's gotten us. Our monopolists on force now see think it's perfectly permissible to hold a gun to my head, take my money, and provide "free" internet access to eliminate the "digital divide".

    Well, just remember, as soon as government has *freely* given away service, it'll start to demand control over that service. And then what?

    Is the local government in Houston going to demand control over what you can browse on their "free" internet service? Will it want access to your email, to make sure you're not doing anything illegal? Think PRC, people.

    You know, I can't tell you how much a trip to the DMV resembles a trip to communist Russia. Line up for this, then line up for that, then line up for the other. And God forbid your paperwork's not in order.

    Think of that the next time the government offers you an ISP.

    --
    668: Neighbour of the Beast
  86. [OT] Re:Houston is named after Sam Houston by Black+Parrot · · Score: 1

    > There was no Hugh's town.

    As I said, the original Hugh's Town was in Merry Olde England.

    Houston [Tx] < [Sam] Houston < ... < Hugh's Town.

    --
    Sheesh, evil *and* a jerk. -- Jade
  87. MICROSOFT.NET Anyone? by chef_raekwon · · Score: 1

    doesnt this sound a bit like .net being tested out in Houston? Word Processing on the server side?? Am i way off base here, or does anyone else see the same thing?

    --
    We're like rats, in some experiment! -- George Costanza
  88. Space City Cyber-Scam by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    "To be honest, it sounds like a marketing ploy the city of Houston has gotten caught up in," said Ray Quay, an assistant planning director for the city of Phoenix who has extensively studied relations between the Internet and local governments.

    http://www.chron.com/cs/CDA/story.hts/front/101491 2

  89. you can do everything throw email by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You can retreive web pages, ftp files, etc.. all threw email. If they R too poor to afford an isp, then chances R they R too poor to afford a computer. The government should give everyone who has an old working computer 500$ to buy your old system to give to the poor, so we can use that money to buy new computers. I would uppgrade if somebody gave me 500$ for my k6233.

  90. Naturally by chainsaw1 · · Score: 1

    This way they can also maintain the lines of cars trying to get through downtown without losing a wheel or engine by falling in a pothole. So they get more than just one line and an excuse to keep the streets under repair.

    "We can't afford to speed up construction with the new city email project draining resources..."

    If you have driven through Houston downtown (or Med Center?), you know what i'm referring to...

    --
    - Sig
  91. This is probably more PR than substance by ArhcAngel · · Score: 1

    It is no secret that Houston REALLY wants the 2012 Olympic games. To that end former mayor Bob Lanier and current mayor Lee Brown have been "steering" the Houston community to improve it's image world wide. For the last 15 years or so Houstonians (myself included) have watched project after project initiated all the while scratching our heads as to what the city is thinking. The current lite rail project that spans from downtown to the "Medical centers" IMHO actually spans from Downtown to the newly rebranded Reliant Park which just happens to be next to the Medical center. This current announcement is probably just another project to get world wide publicity (Which, to be honest, Houston will need to get the Olympics). Houston has had free internet access in Libraries for years. The only thing new here is offering to give Houstonians a yournamehere@Houston.Texas.com email address. It's about city pride which is important to the Olympic oversight commitee. If people are proud to have and email address then they support their city and that looks good to the world community. This is my opinion and may not in any way reflect the views or opinions of CowBoyNeal or the staff of /.

    --
    "A person is smart. People are dumb, panicky dangerous animals and you know it." - K
  92. my my my by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    yet another randite who hates the poor

    what a surprise

  93. Until they find kiddie porn by gelfling · · Score: 2

    or there's a news story about how some molestor hooked up with a kid using his paid by Houston connection or crack dealers are running a free website - blah blah fucking blah. Then the sanctimonious pricks will be screaming to pull the plug faster than you can say "Whaaaaaat about the Chilllllldrennnnnn!!!!!!!!!"

  94. On a Commodore? by SpiceWare · · Score: 2
    load "linux",8,1

    I'm impressed :-)

  95. Streaming Bloatware=Boondoggle by aka-ed · · Score: 1
    Free email and storage provided by the guv'mnt is no problem for me, but why should a "multi-million-dollar contract" be needed to proviode such basis?

    *Look* at all the unnecessary foo-faw SimDesk provides. You really think the digitally deprived need a spreadsheet, a contact manager and remote printing capability?

    This looks more like taxpayer money applied to a dot-com bailout than anything of real use.

    --
    I survived the Dick Cheney Presidency 7 to 9 AM 7-21-07
  96. Re:Carnivore - dumb people.. by (H)elix1 · · Score: 2

    Or better, be shocked when they get a follow-up email from bush@whitehouse.com.

  97. "Free web-based word processing" -- l000kie here! by Bobo+the+Space+Chimp · · Score: 1

    Tucked away in a few words is the core of Microsoft's complete Internet reorganization six years ago.

    Web-based word processing.

    And it looks like they just might make it, having all but killed off Netscape.

    Whew! That was a close one! A defacto "thin client", "web-based pseudo-boot to virtual machine" almost made it in without everyone being dependent on Microsoft.

    Now you still have to buy Microsoft OS's, ha ha ha ha ha ha (singsong lilt) to get your IExplorer to get to all these great v0.001 web office-style apps that are going to just keep growing and growing and growing over the next decade.

    ha ha ha ha ha ha! Whew, I say again! Close one! As Will Smith might say, with spittle flecks flying, "Elvis has left the building!" Whew! Just made it!

    As Ripley might say, "Punch it Bishop!" Whew! Just made it!

    As Trinity might scream, "Neo! (the phone!)" Whew! Just made it!

    As Linda Hamilton might say, "You're terminated, fucker!" Whew! Just made it!

    As Arnie might say, "Now I know why you cry." Whew! Just made it!

    --
    I am for the complete Trantorization of Earth.
  98. "Free"? Sure... by radartroop · · Score: 1

    Noticed that the author placed apostrophes around "free", implying the inaccuracy of that word in this context. The Libertarian in me winces every time I see the word 'free' used in conjunction with the Government... As a memeber of the middle class I refexively reach for my wallet to see if it's still there.

    In many (most) cases, if the governemnt is involved (any form of government) not only is it not free, it costs one hell of a lot more than it otherwise might. Besides that, did I miss something? Is there a shortage of (truly) free web-based e-mail providers? Typical: government, driven by vote-seeking politicians, proposes a solution to an imaginary problem (in this case, a shortage of free e-mail providers), throws a lot of money at it, wasting it in the process, all for nothing.

    The most infuriating (and ingenious) element of this process: those that speak out against the program are bombarded with accustaions of insensitivity to the needs of the poor. It's perfect, in a perverse way: a ridiculous idea that has a built-in controversy eliminator or, at the least, minimizer.

  99. Re:Carnivore - dumb people.. by mr100percent · · Score: 1

    You intentionally meant .com, right?

  100. Re:Carnivore - dumb people.. by (H)elix1 · · Score: 1

    Thats the porn one, right? [100 pop up windows later] Yup, that is exactly what I meant...

  101. umm people by sgups · · Score: 1

    ummm people this was supposed to be a joke. u dont have to dissect it.

    --
    Democratic USA - Government of the corporations, by the Corporations, for the corporations.
  102. Spammers by rocca · · Score: 1

    Will the spammers be signing up all the poor people down there to do their dirty work for them?

    Yes, something similar has already happened around here (Ontario, Canada). We noticed about a million email relay attempts from a library proxy machine machine in a nearby city that started every day at 7am and ended every day at 4pm -- apparently a spammer had installed spamware on one or more of the machines there and each day as the machine was powered on it'd start it's spamming routine. A couple emails back and forth between the techs there got things straightened out pretty quick, but spammers are certainly aware of the opportunities...

  103. im in houston by topdogg · · Score: 0

    I say just offer free email, don't try to make us all use it. >:|

    --
    Got shack?
    ShackCentral Network
    Worlds best gaming network!!!
  104. email is a postal address for the homeless... by Technodummy · · Score: 2

    don't underestimate it's usefulness

    after you become homeless it's hard to break the cycle

    not having a contact point only increases the effect of homelessness, no one can offer you a job or a place to live if they cannot contact you

    I've spoken to some youth workers who help homeless kids with email addresses (they used free services like Hotmail) and they were surprised how much it helped, even things like keeping contact with each other and youth workers

    isolation is increased when communication is cut off, if you have no phone and no snail mail address, an email address may give you a little more stability...

    MAKE $$$ FAST FROM HOME!!! is hardly going to be important to them, as they don't have homes, but being able to email a resume... that's another story...

  105. job hunting by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    that depends on why they are homeless

    not all homeless people are unskilled

    the definition of a homeless person is being without a home

  106. Nice idea, but what really interests me ... by pasinpsycho · · Score: 1

    is the blurb in the story about the Boys and Girls Club's Internet access centers. I had a similar idea, but couldn't sell it to either the then-local newspaper or TV stations (I thought they'd like the chance to have a portal front page).

    This, it seems, is the real issue, the divide between those who own and use a computer and those who don't. Without a computer, this is no big deal since there are already services out there that don't require proof of residency (e.g. Hotmail). With computer access, people can e-mail, set up Web pages, etc.

    --
    The /. sig is too short for anything I'd want to say.
  107. or... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    education, communication and support