Slashdot Mirror
PC Fan of the Future?
baptiste writes "While we marvel at the latest CPU release or new motherboard chipset, we still put the same old fans in the neon lit cases and then complain that it is too loud. Well, maybe someone has finally come up with the next generation PC fan. Y.S. Tech has announced a new fan which is driven at the blade tips by a magnetic motor in the housing. Without the motor in the middle they claim a 30% airflow improvement meaning, potenitally, you could get the same airflow of today's fans at a lower RPM meaning less noise. They also claim the fan tips result in the bulk of fan noise. In this design they are sort of enclosed, reducing noise further. There is also a PDF datasheet available."
Euck!
dominionrd.blogspot.com - Restaurants on
This is why dual-fan HSF setups primarily dominated, especially back when slot CPUs were still popular: you didn't have that static area of air. Sure, you had a hell of a lot more airflow from two fans, but one can argue that a lot of the kinetic energy is lost when air from the two fans collide.
Either way, this is a great improvement for CPU fans. Bravo, Y.S. Tech, it looks like you're taking the crown back from Delta (which is just more RPM, albeit much more noisy, for better performance).
So with my blinkenlights all taped up, and my fan silent.. I just need a way to find out if my systems are still running.
A big part of this for me is being able to turn off the MP3's every so often and have enough silence to think! I'd rather have a 500mhz that can do all the development I can throw at it, than a 747 powered fan sitting on top of a Gigahertz!
Seems that some of these companies are catching on that it might be possible to have the best of both worlds. My hope is that consumers will follow along enough to bring the cost of production low enough that even I can afford them. :)
The more you know, the less you understand.
It seems like every once in a while someone comes up with a latest-greatest new heatsink design. I've seen weird platinum peacock feathers and those wavy metal strips from a while back. They all look kind of goofy, and when really put to the test, don't do too much better. Short of pipes nd pumps, big hunks of copper attached to really fast traditional fans are still the best thing going, and I don't think that's for lack of effort at finding new things.
Because this is an improvement on the *fan* and not the whole heatsink, I give it a little more credence, but I won't be that interested until I actually see some Tom's numbers on it.
And I really won't be interested in it until the pricetag falls below $100 for a fan. For that money you could water-cool, or just soundproof your case.
In Capitalist America, bank robs you!
Who needs a fan when you can buy a new Imac from apple thats so quiet and flow-efficent ya dunt even need a stinking loud fan or a quiter one!! and u can run linux on these macs!
This postsoon to be modded down by humorless people......
The point is that airflow increases with rpm times the SQUARE of diameter, which means if you make the fan 2x as big, you can make it 4x slower. The original NeXT boxes used a big, slow-turning fan to keep noise down, and it was quite effective. PC's usually use 3 inch fans but with some case mods could probably be set up with 5 inch fans, which for the same airflow could quiet things down a lot.
Add to that a hard disk with a fluid bearing spindle motor (pdf) and you've got a rather civilized box on your desk. I'm using one of these drives now (Travelstar 30GN) and the difference between it and an old drive is wonderful. The quietness is like getting rid of a toothache.
Almost all Apples SILENT (Apple 2, Apple 3, Mac+, IIfx, iMac, Cube, iBook, Newton, etc.
That is almost the main engineering case design criteria and why so many fussy demanding people like artists, musicians, scientists (chemists, biologists) and even programmers continue to support apple products.
PeeCees are like load aircraft carriers or at least Vaccuum cleaners comapred to the majority of the most popular selling Apple Computers.
Did you know the Apple 2 had NO FAN at all?
Same with the Mac Plus... no FAN at all.
and most all the products since the IIfx have a variable speed fan that increases rotation only if truly needed... like the Wallstreet G3 laptops.
When Steve jobs created the NeXT workstation he designed every cable to be one long 10 foot single cable so that the machine (almost quiet) could be hidden insode a closet or put very far from your monitor! He hates noise of all kinds.
Hurray for quiet or semi-quiet hardware.
There may be good economic reasons to put the motor parts on the OD of the fan and that is good. But, all statements about the air flow and cooling capabilities are pure PR.
First, the velocity of the blades near the hub are too slow to put work into the air and therefore the air tends to leak backwards near the hub. This is why putting the motor in the hub area does not degrade fan performance.
Second, while the fastest parts of the fan (the blade tips) make most of the fan noise, changing their shape does the most to reduce the noise. The noise has nothing to do with the "motor parts" that reside in the blade tips in this design.
Third, the pressure generated by the fan is solely dependant on the fan design and has nothing to do with how the fan is powered.
Fourth, of course the torque is more effective at a larger radius, but this has nothing to do with efficiency.
Fifth, any increase in air flow has to do with the shape of the blades and the speed of the fan and can probably be improved a somewhat by blocking the hub a little.
Sixth, I do not see how the fan improves the efficiency of cooling anything. Increased air flow will cool anything better, according to how much horsepower do you want to put into your fan. And, it matters a whole lot where the parts to be cooled are in relation to the exit air stream, etc.etc.etc. Nothing but PR here.
Having torn a many pcâ(TM)s apart, to the risk of slicing my hands upon the un de burred sheet metal. I have noticed 1 common elements that contribute to fan failure.
Too much heat on the oil seal
Looking at this compared to a ordinary fan, it looks as though the bearings and oil seals are evenly dispersed over the surface area of the heat sink, where most common fans have the bearings and oil seals right in the center in the middle of rising heat. Iâ(TM)m not a thermodynamics expert but I can tell you from experience that I have been able to bring many a dead CPU fans back from the dead simply by peeling the sticker off in the center and dropping a dab of oil in there.
Anyways thatâ(TM)s my 2cents
Not quite. The caterpillar drive was a gigantic induction pump. Water moves in an electric field, similar to magnetism - generate a large enough field and you can get water moving at a decent pressure. Small induction pumps are fairly common in homebrew watercooling rigs on PCs.
I emailed the manufacturers regarding the free tests. Here's what they said:
;) I wonder why?
Thank you very much for your high interests in Y.S. TECH's revolutionary new product: T.M.D. FAN (Tip-Magnetic Driving Fan).
After the announcement of the T.M.D. FAN, we have been receiving uncountable inquiries everyday to review the T.M.D. FAN, to obtain the T.M.D. FAN samples and to attain developing schedule. To deal with all of your inquiries and be fair to everyone, here is what Y.S. TECH would like you to follow. We appreciate for your cooperation in advance!
1. Please visit Y.S. TECH web site at http://www.ystech.com.tw to obtain the detailed information (including technical issues).
2. We hereby enclose some images (.jpg at 72 dpi) that you are very welcome to apply them to your web site's product review and news announcement.
3. After your post or announcement of the T.M.D. FAN in your web site, please inform us the links. Then we will deliver physical T.M.D. FAN samples (possibly with heatsink) for your test and review purpose. The samples will be delivered to you in the middle of April.
4. After your test on the T.M.D. FAN, you will be much appreciated, if you post the test results and comments in your web site. It doesn't matter the results or the comments are positive or negative. The general public needs the truth.
Here is the rough schedule for the dimensional development of the T.M.D.
FAN:
Now: 70x70x15mm is now available. It is targeted for Pentium 4 CPU cooler.
April: 70x70x15mm T.M.D. FAN will be shipped out to variable locations over the world.
May to June: 60x60x25mm, 80x80x25mm T.M. FAN will be released to the market. These two dimensions are targeted for AMD CPU cooler and case cooling.
Again, thank you very much for your interests in T.M.D. FAN!
Should you have any questions or comments, please feel free to contact us. Y.S. TECH will reply to you as soon as possible.
Note the "uncountable enquiries..
I think their attitude about the reviews is very good. It's a shame more companies aren't like that.
--
Andy