Slashdot Mirror


eBay To Offer Health Insurance

Logic Bomb writes "EBay has announced it will be offering group health coverage for "full time eBay merchants". Anyone who grosses over $1000/month in sales -- at least a whopping 80,000 users in good standing -- will be eligible to buy into a typical "employee" health plan. This is a big first in the Internet world. Full details from the LA Times." And the LA Times, trying to cop a pose from the NY Times, reqs a login.

33 of 202 comments (clear)

  1. Hey by Sc00ter · · Score: 3, Interesting
    Somebody make this work for the LA Times :)

    1. Re:Hey by guttentag · · Score: 4, Informative
      And the LA Times, trying to cop a pose from the NY Times, reqs a login.
      Someone set up an easy-to-remember, stick-it-to-em login for NYTimes.com:
      Username: nopassword
      Password: nopassword
      So I took the liberty of setting up the same thing at LATimes.com. Feel free to use it, and set up the same username/password combo at other sites.
  2. Starting bid: $1.00 by Brento · · Score: 5, Funny

    The important questions:

    Will they allow you to give feedback to health providers in your area?

    Can you pay with PayPal?

    Will you be able to set up a doctor's appointment for organ removal and simultaneously list the spare kidney for sale?

    --
    What's your damage, Heather?
  3. what happens if? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    What happens if the reseve on your bid isn't met? Do you die?

  4. Who said the .boom was entirely over? by Vengie · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I think we're seeing the eventual effects of the web that were severely disturbed by the dot-boom(bomb) phenomenon. Ebay is unquestionably _the_ online auction website and its full time merchants generate a significant amount of revenue for ebay. This further increases the incentive for many of these "marginal" merchants to go full time -- they can drop the job that they may have "just for the benefits" and furthermore, it may make dealing with some of Ebay's idiosyncracies a bit more palateable. About time! Hopefully, ebay will set a nice precedent for the rest of the industry.

    --
    When in doubt, parenthesize. At the very least it will let some poor schmuck bounce on the % key in vi. (Larry Wall)
  5. eBay and health insurance coverage by mercynre · · Score: 4, Insightful

    as a small business trying to operate mainly on eBay (for credit card purposes), this is another step in proving how corporate they have become, and another step in eliminating the small sellers, which was the whole purpose of eBay to begin with, the access to COLLECTIBLES not mass-produced merchandise.

    1. Re:eBay and health insurance coverage by Andy+Dodd · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Sounds like all that needs to be done is some further subdivision of the Art and Collectible forums.

      I've had no problem selling stuff on eBay - If you list it right, it gets found in a search along with all the other stuff.

      I like the large businesses because there are some items I know I'm always going to be able to find cheap on eBay. (Cornelius kegs for homebrewing, a top for the convertible I'm planning on buying, cell phone faceplates, etc.)

      --
      retrorocket.o not found, launch anyway?
  6. Don't listen guys... by 3Suns · · Score: 4, Funny

    Don't be misled. Today is Chinese April Fools Day.

    --

    -3Suns

    ~~~~
    The Revolution will be Slashdotted
  7. Numbers talk.. by lionchild · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Health insurance has always been a huge game of numbers and betting on the odds. Betting on the odds that you are, or aren't going to get sick, are or aren't going to need major medical, are or aren't going to need an operation, etc. And in that big game, the more people you have on the plan, the more likely you're going to find alot of people who pay you for insurance, but don't need those things.

    An insurance company is out to make money, just like you and me, who get a job to make money (or sell things on eBay in this case.) So, if you offer them a large customer base, 80,000 people, then that's a big enough market you start to drop your prices signifigantely.

    This will be an interesting precident to set in the marketplace of health insurance. If it goes through and works, ..when will we get to have /. insurance? Any web-following then, with sufficient numbers, should be able to follow suit and get big discounts on a group plan. With enough people, you even get to have the nice and spiffy plans where you can pick the sort of benefits you want.

    Whose going to manage these benefits? Will eBay have a new department for assisting their people with benefit claims?

    Hmm...imagine if http://www.yahoo.com/ or http://www.msn.com/ were able to follow suit and offer health insurance. Anyone else think there's a web-organization that can claim more members?

    --
    Awk! Pieces of eight. Pieces of eight. Pieces of seven... ERROR: General Protection Fault. [Paroty Error.]
    1. Re:Numbers talk.. by Jonathan · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Whose going to manage these benefits? Will eBay have a new department for assisting their people with benefit claims?

      No -- like in any job in the US with a group health plan, you deal with the insurance company providing the coverage and not your employer.

    2. Re:Numbers talk.. by Zathrus · · Score: 5, Insightful

      So, if you offer them a large customer base, 80,000 people, then that's a big enough market you start to drop your prices signifigantely

      Yup. Admittedly, not all of the people eligible will opt for this insurance -- either they have their own insurance already and eBay's offering isn't better, or they apply and the insurer turns them down due to liability issues (this is why it's critical to always have health insurance in the US -- once you are uninsured for 6 months you can be declined for just about any reason... or you can be insured and "preexisting conditions" will simply be declined coverage).

      This will be an interesting precident to set in the marketplace of health insurance

      Yup... to call a seller an employee of eBay is something of a stretch, but apparantly they have found an insurer who is willing to try. Kudos. And they're willing to test some very murky legal waters here -- once you offer health insurance for these pseudo-employees, you may discover that the federal government is going to start expecting more from you -- even if it's just forms stating that these people are contractors and that you aren't responible for their FICA and Federal taxes. What about FMLA? What about disability? There's a lot more here than meets the eye in my opinion.

      Whose going to manage these benefits? Will eBay have a new department for assisting their people with benefit claims?

      In theory, HR does this. If eBay has any clue, however, they'll be using a 3rd party administration service to provide these benefits. They're the ones that actually handle the interface between employees and the health plan -- all your HR does is forward them whatever you hand HR. These are popular nowadays because they significantly reduce the paperwork that HR has to deal with.

      Anyone else think there's a web-organization that can claim more members?

      That's easy. AOL.

    3. Re:Numbers talk.. by acvh · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Actually, you don't have to be an employee to get group health insurance. There are many instances of "Association" based health plans: Blue Cross/Blue Shield do this often. It lets lawyers, accountants and other self-employeed professionals get group rates by being members of the Bar Association or something similar.

    4. Re:Numbers talk.. by PMuse · · Score: 5, Informative
      Health insurance has always been a huge game of numbers and betting on the odds. . . . So, if you offer them a large customer base, 80,000 people, then that's a big enough market you start to drop your prices signifigantely. . . .

      Whose going to manage these benefits? Will eBay have a new department for assisting their people with benefit claims?

      What an insurer needs in order to spread risk is a large pool of people selected for some criteria not related to their health/propensity to make claims. The healthy group members pay and don't claim, while the unhealthy members claim a lot more than they pay, and the system works. Traditionally, such groups have been {all employees of a given company}. EBay is a good candidate for a new type of group. What will not work is any internet community that is self-selecting on the basis of wanting health insurance. Such groups will contain too high a percentage of unhealthy people.

      EBay will be pretty limited as a precedent, I think. EBay's members have to really commit to EBay (be high volume sellers) to get covered. It's not as easy as saying, "I think I'll switch ISPs to Earthlink because I like the health plan."

      On another note, it's not trivial to offer health insurance to a national group. Most health insurers have regional networks of physicians and services. (This is partly because insurance is licensed on a state by state basis.) Some few have enough regional networks to be effectively national, but you can bet that people outside population centers are going to find they have somewhat limited choices when it comes to selecting physicians near them. EBay sellers have got to be just about the most geographically diverse insurance group ever attempted. Many, many employers have one or a few locations, e.g. a plant. EBay users don't have any locations/concentrations other than the fact that more of them will be found in cities because that's where the people are.

      Still and all, more power to 'em, I say.

      --
      "We reject as false the choice between our safety and our ideals." --The American President (20.1.2009)
    5. Re:Numbers talk.. by morgajel · · Score: 4, Funny

      I think I'll pass on the /. insurance.
      last thing I need next time I'm in a hospital is some troll adding "goatse" to the doctors "to do" list.

      ow.

      unless the slashdot insurance offered protection from robots. that's the kinda insurance you can live with!

      --
      Looking for Book Reviews? Check out Literary Escapism.
  8. No Reg Copy of Story by LISNews · · Score: 4, Informative

    Houston Chronicle has the story available with no register.

  9. New urban legends!!! by fritter · · Score: 5, Funny

    I wouldn't do this, my friend's sister's cousin tried getting a surgeon on eBay. He seemed nice and said he had great deals on triple bypass surgery because a "friend's" practice was going under and he wanted to use up the remaining surgical supplies as soon as possible. But the next thing she knew, she woke up in a bathtub of ice with two scars on her back and a note that said "Dial 911 Immediately"!!!!

  10. .com users equal to employees? by totallygeek · · Score: 3, Informative

    Could I just simply start calling the users of www.dmarien.com my employees?


    They could all be considered independent contractors if their purpose of being a user of your site is to generate funds for your company and they have signed an agreement as such. When we sign up for an eBay account, we make such an agreement.


    Let us look at Slashdot. For them to do the same they would need to demonstrate that the funds they make are a direct result of user activity. This is not so clear in their case because while the site wouldn't make any money with no users, it becomes questionable they can determine a scale for each user's contribution to their bottom line. If they had some pay for play, those items could qualify, but the numbers would need to be staggering. Don't forget that eBay is not paying this insurance, rather the qualified members would pay their own.

  11. Re: not but the tools are available by CMiYC · · Score: 5, Funny

    Will you be able to set up a doctor's appointment for organ removal and simultaneously list the spare kindey for sale?

    I find that prospect likely. Afterall, Ebay does provide you with the necessary (unused) tools.

  12. Yahoo/MSN - Not gonna happen. by Andy+Dodd · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I think you missed a key point - It's only sellers who gross over $1k/month that eBay is offering this too, not eBay's entire userbase.

    eBay takes a commission from every sale - So those sellers are far, far beyond even paying customers at many sites as far as the revenue they bring into the company.

    Meanwhile, Yahoo and MSN are free services, or if they charge, they don't charge nearly as much as the amounts of commissions eBay skims from the qualifying classes of sellers.

    --
    retrorocket.o not found, launch anyway?
  13. .Boom 2.0 by peterdaly · · Score: 4, Insightful

    This I feel is the start of the second Internet boom, just this one will be for real. All the companies with no hope of making a profit online are gone. The ones that are left either make money, or at least have a pile of cash they are sitting on.

    Buying your couch online is out...earth to owner, couches cost A LOT more to ship than books, and people want to sit in them first. Commerce on the web that makes sense is in. eBay is probably the first in the second stream of successful internet companies to start gaining attention.

    Can't wait to see more real profits from the internet...

    -Pete

  14. Once again the /. editing calls attention to itsel by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Insightful
    Good editing should not be visible; the story should come across as the focus of the article. After reading this exciting headline, I was disappointed to read:

    the LA Times, trying to cop a pose from the NY Times, reqs a login.

    I found myself asking these questions:
    1. Why do I need to be told a login is required? Won't I find that out soon enough?
    2. Why reference the NYTimes? Is there some campaign to have them remove their logins? I know it gets mentioned often enough on /.
    3. What's this "coping a pose" reference? A clever hip way to suggest one site copies from another?
    4. Is the LATimes copying from the NYTimes, or the other way around? Is this relevant? (That is, who is coping a pose from whom?)
    5. Is there some way that stories can just be edited for spelling, clarity and facts, and then LEFT ALONE
    6. I understand the editor has opinions (thought I'm not sure if the opinions concern NYTimes, LATimes, both, or just logins in general--odd, considering /. supports but does not require logins as well.) Could the editor perhaps clarify their opinions in an appropriate forum, like an editoral, and not a story? Or at the least be less crypting about what they mean?


    In the end, I'm left with the impression that this is just a young kid editing a web page who wants to use a clever turn of phrase he heard. It adds nothing to the story; it takes away much.
  15. Side effect: Now something else the IRS can use... by will_die · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Since I doubt that most of theses sellers declare thier full income from ebay, I wonder if the IRS will attempt to use this to get a listing of thoses people.

  16. Re:HMO's are cheap by truthsearch · · Score: 4, Informative

    Self-employed purchase of health insurance is very expensive. Maybe you live in the middle of nowhere and the rates are cheap, or maybe you're smoking some really good crack ;), but in the NYC metro area, if you're self-employed it costs a small fortune to buy health insurance from anyone. HMOs and others charge much higher fees to self-employed individuals than to corporations (per person). That's one reason why there's a larger federal tax break for money spent on health insurance when you're self-employed (there's an additional Schedule (E?) that you have to fill out if you don't work for someone else's corporation). So I'm sure the "bulk" insurance that E-Bay is selling is cheaper per person than buying it alone. E-Bay's insentive may partly be for the tax benefits.

  17. I'm just waiting by nochops · · Score: 4, Funny

    I'm just waiting for eBay to start offering sick days and paid vacation so I can quit my day job.

    --
    "A terrorist is someone who has a bomb but doesn't have an air force." -William Blum
  18. Re:What's their hidden agenda... by jlower · · Score: 3, Insightful

    The 'why' part is obvious (to me). The perception in the eBay community has been that the wholesalers are taking over and pushing the independent sellers out. eBay is attempting to stem a revolt and/or mass migration to another auction site.

    It may seem like 1K/month in sales is a lot but compared to the liquidators who sell there, it isn't. eBay needs those 80,000 Power Sellers to be able to keep selling too.

    My guess is that this arrangement won't cost eBay much, if any, money from their own pocket. I saw no mention that they are going to co-pay for the insurance. But, they've made it possible for the full-time eBay dealer to get decent group insurance. Not a bad incentive to stay with eBay.

  19. Insurance depends on feedback?!?! by jsimon12 · · Score: 3, Interesting

    So I have to keep my account in good standing? That means if some malichious little brat decides he doesn't like me and makes up all sorts of slander and negative feedback I can lose my eBay healt insurance? Or by good standing do they simply mean paying my auctions fees? Anyone have any input?

  20. NOT EMPLOYEES! by chill · · Score: 5, Informative

    To all those wondering how auction sellers qualify as employees -- a quick "find text" in the article doesn't turn up any form of the word "employ".

    This is simply a group policy, like those you can get thru the National Association of the Self-Employed, or dozens of other small-business and "group" organizations.

    All you need for group discounts is a large group -- they don't have to be co-workers. E-Bay isn't contributing to the funds.

    --
    Learning HOW to think is more important than learning WHAT to think.
  21. Re:Ebay is no longer worth it by nochops · · Score: 4, Insightful

    How do you suggest that they "bring back the old eBay service"?

    They started a medium that turned out to be wildly popular, and I'm sure that [insert company name here] noticed that a lot of people were turning to eBay to buy the same products. Who can blame them (the company) for auctioning directly on eBay also?

    What's eBay supposed to do? Only allow individuals? Hah! I'm sure they have no plans to kill half of their revenue stream anytime in the near future. I say bravo to eBay for proving that it is possible to be profitable on the Internet.

    --
    "A terrorist is someone who has a bomb but doesn't have an air force." -William Blum
  22. Re:Once again the /. editing calls attention to it by Mr.Ned · · Score: 3, Interesting

    > 1. Why do I need to be told a login is required? Won't I find that out soon enough?

    I would waste more time trying to load a slashdotted page than reading a sentence fragment and deciding that since I'm not going to register anyway I might as well just go to the comments and hope someone has whored the story.

    I'm of mixed opinion on the reference. On one hand, it's childish and, as you indicated, is trying to be "hip". On the other hand, I'd rather have bad personality than none at all. I view slashdot as a community, not a newsfeed. If I want a newsfeed, I can check out Newsforge or C|Net or CNN's Tech section and get it there. I come to Slashdot because of the (sometimes) insightful commentary coming from people who know more than I do about a subject, and the occasional amusement from some troll who has been modded up. Sense of aquaitance is important. I don't want hemos and cmdtaco and whoever aloof from Slashdot's user base (even though they sometimes seem to be from themselves) - the site looses a lot of its appeal because it becomes just another newsfeed I'll check a few times a day.

  23. Re:HMO's are cheap by M'Barr · · Score: 4, Informative

    FYI: for those in NYC & NY state, there is a program that offers very inexpensive access to the HMO's. I'm not a hundred percent sure of how much the government is picking up, but it's called Healthy NY.

    It is available for uninsured working individuals, sole proprietors, and small buisness owners. They each have their own rules. However, the prices are in the 180-220 /month, and covers most of the necessary things in medicine. It is offered by *all* HMO's that operate in New York State. Same coverage, different administation, and networks, yields the price difference.

  24. Re:HMO's are cheap by mesocyclone · · Score: 3, Insightful

    For those of us who are a bit older, the issue with insurance isn't so much the price as it is the availability.

    Insurance companies will deny coverage to individuals, or will deny coverage for preexisting conditions, for the flimsiest of reasons. Also, there is no federal law preventing them from cancelling your insurance, or raising the rates through the roof if you get sick.

    This same "medical underwriting" applies to small businesses and associations.

    In the US, if you don't have a job, you run a real chance of losing everything in order to pay for a medical event. You can always get the treatment - you just may end up broke to get it.

    All of the federal protections on health insurance is offered only to people covered by group insurance (companies, etc.) and not to individuals.

    Oh, BTW, the insurance companies don't do this just because they are evil predators. They know that if they offer insurance without conditions, too many people will wait until they get sick, or at least until they get old, before applying. This negates the "share the risk" aspect of insurance. OTOH Company insurance, which is virtually forced on all employees, produces a crop of young and healthy people to pay the expenses for us older folks.

    Some states have pools from which you can buy insurance regardless of your medical status. Unfortunately, these are almost impossible to get into, or are extremely expensive. And given the previous paragraph, you can see why this is not an ultimate solution.

    --

    The only good weather is bad weather.

  25. Re:HMO's are cheap by Fjord · · Score: 3, Insightful

    It sounds like there are group systems for the self employed, but I just wanted to note that personal medical coverage is very different than group coverage. If you are healthy, then it's an option, but if you have a preexisting condition within the last 10 years, you won't be covered on it for the next 10 years, whereas with group coverage it only looks 6 months into your medical history and after 1 year you get full coverage. There are other differences (the price for one. Personal is a lot more expensive), but this was a big one for my wife and I since she has breast and thyroid cancer.

    --
    -no broken link