Slashdot Mirror


Medicine for a Sick Linux Box

Squidgee writes "This is the site for "LIAP: Linux In A Pillbox". It is an interesting recovery distro made in the vein of pharmaceuticals; each floppy based 'minidistro' cures one specific Linux ailment. Or, as Luke Komasta (The creator of LIAP) puts it: "My Linux project contains "pills". Each of them is good for one disease, but it doesn't work good enough for another. When you know what you need a Linux for, you may choose a good pill. And of course, as you know, there is no drug which is good for treating all diseases." It's an extremely interesting approach to Linux recovery, and one that appears to be more effective than the other varieties of floppy/mini-cd based recovery systems. Worth downloading in case you ever need it!"

140 comments

  1. What Pill by AvitarX · · Score: 3, Funny

    What pill does it nead for a good slashdotting?

    --
    Wow, sent an e-mail as suggested when clicking on "use classic" banner, and got a fast response that addressed my msg
    1. Re:What Pill by mocktor · · Score: 2, Interesting

      iptables -A INPUT -p tcp -s ! 127.0.0.1 -j DROP

      or possibly

      echo "please upgrade my connection to an OC3 immediately and bill to uberadmin@slashdot.org" | mail -s "SOS!" admin@$isp

    2. Re:What Pill by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Prozac, for the poor sysadmin.

  2. Diagnostic disk? by Dr.+Spork · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Well, for those who don't have enough experience to correctly diagnose what ails their box, it seems logical to make a diagnosis diskette, one that doesn't fix anything, but might give them a clue which pill has the best chance of fixing their problem.

    1. Re:Diagnostic disk? by NorthDude · · Score: 1

      Yeah, I need to go see a doctor so he will give me a prescription.
      Then, i can buy the pills ;-)

      --


      I'd rather be sailing...
    2. Re:Diagnostic disk? by Psiren · · Score: 2

      Where the hell would you start? There could be a million and one things go wrong. I guess you could do something along the lines of the Microsoft troubleshooter. But whenever I've had need to use that, 90% of the time it ends up telling me it doesn't know how to fix the problem. Which is about as much use as tits on a bull :/

  3. blue pill ? by tiwason · · Score: 5, Funny

    And does the blue pill disk install windows ??

    1. Re:blue pill ? by discogravy · · Score: 2

      ...a bitter pill to swallow, indeed.

    2. Re:blue pill ? by JPriest · · Score: 1

      But, someone told me the blue pill fixes the Linux installation and backwards compatibility issues.

      --
      Saying Java is nice because it works on all OS's is like saying that anal sex is nice because it works on all genders.
    3. Re:blue pill ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Come on, nobody misses blue diskettes? Why the heck all turned black?

  4. A pill for . . by borg05 · · Score: 5, Funny

    What disk do you use if your floppy disk drivers break?

    1. Re:A pill for . . by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Drivers? These are boot disks.

    2. Re:A pill for . . by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What disk do you use if your floppy disk drivers break?

      You buy a new motherboard or floppy drive because one of them is fucking broke.

    3. Re:A pill for . . by prichardson · · Score: 1

      put 500 pills on a SINGLE cd and one pill on a floppy for when cd's stop working

      --
      Help I'm a rock.
    4. Re:A pill for . . by msim · · Score: 1

      To be honest, if your floppy drivers aren't working, then really it wouldnt be a issue, as logically its all on the boot floppy. and the borked drivers are on your hdd.

      Then again, if your floppy drive is borked, or the controller chip is, its a whole different enchalada.

      --

      Life is like a box of chocolates, you never know when your gonna get food poisoning.
    5. Re:A pill for . . by Ilgaz · · Score: 1

      Pay $10 and buy a new diskette driver? Thats the power of floppy :)

    6. Re:A pill for . . by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      > What disk do you use if your floppy disk drivers break?

      ZIP or compact disk :-)

  5. Pills? by Soko · · Score: 4, Funny

    Don't tell me. Lemme guess.

    The "Blue pill" returns your Linux machine back to normal function. The "Red pill" puts a trace on the kernel, and "shows you just how deep the rabbit hole goes...."

    Soko

    --
    "Depression is merely anger without enthusiasm." - Anonymous
    1. Re:Pills? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      what pill do i take to make you SHUT UP AND DIE tks

    2. Re:Pills? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0


      You do realize that this isn't even a remotely funny comment, don't you?

    3. Re:Pills? by Xaroth · · Score: 1

      You can take the red pill if you want, but ultimately you'll regret not having taken the blue pill.

      That's just the way it goes.

  6. Re:Steal Alanis Morrissette's Look! by ninjo · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    you moron ..... nothing better to say

  7. Hardly new by forged · · Score: 2
    Slackware has had a rescue root disk for as long as I can remember (somewhere ~1995 possibly). It provided most rescue tools that you needed on a single floppy.

    I still occasionnally download a boot+rescue root disk to repair a screwed-up system that fails to boot, even when said machine isn't running Slack.

    1. Re:Hardly new by bhsx · · Score: 3, Interesting

      It's a new approach at building those emergency boot disks, so that you get exactly what you need/want. I dont' care what you can fit on two floppies; there will be times when you don't have what you need. This tries to address that problem in a rather interesting(if not terribly intuitive) way.

      --
      put the what in the where?
    2. Re:Hardly new by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Slackware now has a resuce, or 'live' CD.

      Disc 2 of an official 4 disc set boots you in to a root filesystem on a ram disk.

      Infact, Slackware is about the closest you can get to raw *nix using a mainstream Linux distro. That is the reason I like Slackware - with most other distros, there is the distro's way of doing something, and the generic way. With Slackware, the Slackware way *IS* the generic way. Yeah, it might be difficult to learn, but if you learn Slackware, you'll pretty much know your way around any GNU/Linux machine, if not any *nix machine.

    3. Re:Hardly new by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      But dude, this is Linux.

      Where the developers strive to reinvent the wheel, hundereds of times over.

    4. Re:Hardly new by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yeah, it might be difficult to learn, but if you learn Slackware, you'll pretty much know your way around any GNU/Linux machine, if not any *nix machine.

      Of course, the problem with Slackware, and other UNIX versions in general is that they suck at package management. Oooh, new Apache exploit is out. I have to compile all this shit and hope it works. With Redhat or Debian I can just upgrade the package. Take Solaris for example. There's NO fix for the Apache exploit in an official patch I've found. The newest one you can get off of sunfreeware is 1.3.6 or 1.3.12 or something. Really ancient.

    5. Re:Hardly new by jasonditz · · Score: 1

      Yeah but this time they called it a pill!

    6. Re:Hardly new by KoolyM · · Score: 1

      Slackware 8.1 also comes with a rather complete distro on a cd-rom. If your mobo can boot off cd-rom, that's all you need.

      This "Linux Pill Box" thing primarily has novelty value, it's not really that useful. Even if your computer can't boot cd-roms, you'd still be better off with a floppy containing a minimal kernel, some flavor of fsck and a text editor. You can solve most immediate problems with that. Once you can boot your system again, you can take care of the rest.

    7. Re:Hardly new by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That is at least a 3

    8. Re:Hardly new by BabyDave · · Score: 1
      ... you'd still be better off with a floppy containing a minimal kernel, some flavor of fsck and a text editor. You can solve most immediate problems with that.
      ... assuming you know how to solve said problems. This is for less tech-savvy people. If you don't know what the exact problem is, but know "it's something to do with network card drivers", you just stick the appropriate floppy(-ies) and they (in theory) will sort out your system for you.

    9. Re:Hardly new by KoolyM · · Score: 1

      I'd say *especially* for non-tech-savvy people. How are they going to know which of these diskettes they're going to need?

      Not to mention that you'll need at least *some* knowledge to be able to fix Linux disasters.

    10. Re:Hardly new by kasperd · · Score: 1

      This is for less tech-savvy people.

      As long as they don't log in as root, they shouldn't be able to make any major damage in the first case. In that case the recovery procedure just has to do something like this:

      cd /home
      mv luser oldfiles
      cp -a /etc/skel luser
      chown luser:luser -R luser
      mv oldfiles luser

      --

      Do you care about the security of your wireless mouse?
    11. Re:Hardly new by Tony-A · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Where the developers strive to reinvent the wheel, hundereds of times over.
      Yeah, and you're thinking the first wheel was perfectly round and smooth?

  8. Naw.. by FreeLinux · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I'd rather have everything I need at once, rather than having to switch floppies and reboot for a different function.

    For me a bootable CD solution like Knoppix is a much better choice for a recovery disk.

    1. Re:Naw.. by bogie · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Yea I just downloaded it last week and I'm really impressed. Things you can do with it off the top of my head.

      Emergency disk repair via a nice gui!
      Network scanning via nmap and ethereal. How cool is it to be able to plug into a compromised network and scan it without worrying about your system.
      Ssh and vnc for admin without having to install it on your machine. This is great if you only have access to windows machine and don't want to have to download/install and software.
      Secure web surfing. Want to check your email or do something else online that won't leave cookies etc on the local machine?
      Great way to demo for people new to linux and let them learn linux without fear of them destroying their machine. This really would work great in a classroom setting and sure as hell beats having to reghost the machines every day.

      You get a usuable full featured linux system on any machine with a cdrom. It really is very usuable as a desktop on any half decent machine. The only time it felt slow was when launching Open Office. Every other app launched faster than I though it would.

      I know its not a new concept and others are available but its the best I've used so far,and should go in any admin's toolkit.

      --
      If you wanna get rich, you know that payback is a bitch
  9. Dear god by screwballicus · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I'd always thought, to a large extent, the frustration of dealing with Windows and Mac had been due to their perverse propensity for the use of abstract metaphors which complicate rather than explicate problems. That may be helpful for new users, but new users Linux users do not tend to be. Do Linux users want to be treated like babies all of a sudden? I know I certainly don't. And, somehow, I don't believe the linux community in general is going to be too impressed with useful utility encased in meaningless, obfuscating metaphors.

    1. Re:Dear god by N1KO · · Score: 1

      The stupid acronyms used to describe a useful utility aren't less obfuscating than the metaphors you speak of. Image manipulation program is easier to understand than photoshop... but gimp isn't.

    2. Re:Dear god by AvitarX · · Score: 1

      I would think that Photoshap actually conveys more meaning then Image Manipulation Program to the general public. But maybe I am just lame

      --
      Wow, sent an e-mail as suggested when clicking on "use classic" banner, and got a fast response that addressed my msg
    3. Re:Dear god by N1KO · · Score: 1

      Well, when i first heard of photoshop it sounded to me like a program used by the people who develop film, this was when all i knew about computers is you could play little games like outrun and megaman after typing wierd stuff in dos.

    4. Re:Dear god by AvitarX · · Score: 1

      and image manipulation program would have meant something to you back then?
      I think if you told the average person you have an image manipulation program on you computer they would go huh? But if you said I have a photoshop on my computer the would understand it at least had to do with photo images. I would call my IMP something like Photonator or something catchy like that. Or maybe photo slop, that would easily tell people it is a photoshop work alike.

      --
      Wow, sent an e-mail as suggested when clicking on "use classic" banner, and got a fast response that addressed my msg
  10. What about making it.... by ketamine-bp · · Score: 2, Interesting

    put all of them into a CD, which is bootable with isolinux and each remedy (that is the pills) is a root file system to mount - easier to use, faster, isn't it. i think that almost all recent years (5 years old computers) are ok with bootable CDs.

  11. Yeah But by jfonseca · · Score: 0, Redundant

    Did you need that stupid analogy for an otherwise good idea?

    --
    Broken Hearts are for Assholes. - Frank Zappa
  12. The windows version.... by Alien+Being · · Score: 3, Funny

    suppositories

  13. One pill makes you larger... by diwolf · · Score: 1

    I was a tad concerned about the lack of drug-interaction information. I mean, I'd be concerned that if I used the blue pill at the same time as I used the yellow pill, that I'd get some sort of green-pill effect. Likewise, if I used the blue and red, would I get a purple pill? :)

    1. Re:One pill makes you larger... by BJH · · Score: 1

      Just don't eat the brown acid.

  14. just wondering... by yanyan · · Score: 1

    what are some of the "Linux diseases" these disks cure? What if i have a broken floppy drive?

  15. Re:cheesecake truck by Mr+Thinly+Sliced · · Score: 0

    Man that is 'super-funny-post' - rumber one.

    lerry good.

  16. what we need now... by mad_cow · · Score: 3, Funny
    Is LOASC (Linux On A Street Corner). The first one's free... and so are all the ones after.


    Instead of lecithin, vitamin and insulin, we could have crack, lsd and heroin. You could even have a marijuana distro, which of course would be a gateway distro.

    1. Re:what we need now... by ketamine-bp · · Score: 0

      vitamin - `apt-get update; apt-get upgrade';
      helps your system functions properly.
      insulin - `sendmail -bp';
      try to keeps the glucose (mails) out of the blood (queue)
      crack, lsd, heroin - really unstable kernel patches (like the preempt patch a year ago) which makes your machine go as fast (and die as fast) as hell.

    2. Re:what we need now... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Chiiiillll Winston!

  17. Appropriate Packaging by pngwen · · Score: 1

    now, we just need 2 tone floppy disks that look like gel-caps to go with it

    --
    I am the penguin that codes in the night.
    1. Re:Appropriate Packaging by dattaway · · Score: 2

      I see real marketing potential: a boxed set of flourescent colored disks, labeled to look like prescription bottles. If a salesman at a floppy manfucaturing plant had a lunchtime to spare with the engineers, it could be possible to buy floppies with different colored sides on the front and back, just like a pill. I can see the possibilities with this and how easy it is to bring a package together. ..

    2. Re:Appropriate Packaging by Reece400 · · Score: 1

      Yah, 2 tone floppies!! that's a freaking ama;ing idea!!! i'd buy them, for now tho, i'm gonna try taking some of those translucent coloured floppios apart and supergluing them together with a different one,, so far it looks pretty promising, mwahaha, lol :), Reece,

  18. Not enought by Bastian · · Score: 2

    You can't fit everything you might need on one floppy, so it's hard to create a Swiss Army Rescue Disk.

    Of course, that's why God gave us zipdisks. . .

    1. Re:Not enought by whereiswaldo · · Score: 1

      If God gave us zipdisks, then the devil gave us the Click of Death. IOMega sucks.

  19. Would like comparison disk by Krellan · · Score: 4, Insightful

    More than a recovery disk/CD, of which several already exist, I would love a comparison disk. It would be for use after suspecting an attack.

    It would boot from floppy or CD, guaranteeing that it would be in control and not trusting the hard drive for anything at all.

    It would contain Tripwire-style keys for every system-installed file in the distribution. When booted, it would check each file against these keys, and output a list of files that do not match.

    So, if one has been rooted with a good rootkit that modifies the operating system to cloak hacked files, one could then boot this disk/CD and be sure of being completely in control with a known good operating system. All files on the hard disk would be able to be accessed honestly, for a true comparison!

    Does such a tool exist already?

    It would be fairly easy to add this to the Red Hat installer. In addition to having an option to install, it would have an option to compare an existing system. It would go through the standard installation steps (choosing partitions, etc.) but compare instead of copy. A byte-for-byte comparison could then be done, for true honesty. If any mismatches are found, it would complain loudly, and give you the option at the end of simply overwriting the changed files (under your control, of course, and on an individual basis).

    What do you think? Does such a tool already exist? I would love to use it if it does.

    1. Re:Would like comparison disk by ketamine-bp · · Score: 0

      actually, the RPMs (and similarly, DEBs) of the linux systems do have their file's md5 calculated. then do the following:
      1. cat all the original lines (e.g. /usr/bin/whatever 0faef6a7e8f67ef6a7ef6aef7f ...) of all installed packages together.
      2. md5 hash all the file available using a statically compiled md5sums (assume kernel is not binary-patched, and is armed with LIDS to prevent such), and cat them altogether into the previous file.
      3. use uniq to find out 'uniques'; strips out /etc and /var though. however, make sure that you actually reinstall the whole system (obviously) and not only the files if you actually got compromised.

      my 2 cents

    2. Re:Would like comparison disk by kanelephant · · Score: 1

      One difficulty is the user configuration files. If the attacker changes things like root's bashrc that may not be noticed by such tools as it is probably not deemed a system file. So what you say could help but still leaves large holes. The same is even more difficult to check if it is a user's bashrc as they may be modified moderately frequently (making them harder to check against a known good file).

    3. Re:Would like comparison disk by lpontiac · · Score: 5, Informative

      You can implement this yourself easily enough.

      Let's say you want to do it for all the files in /root, /bin, /usr/local/bin and /etc. The following will get you a list of md5sums:

      #!/bin/sh
      find -s /root /bin /etc /usr/local/bin | while read x ; do
      md5 $x
      done;

      Put the output of that into a file after a fresh install. Save it to disk. At any later point, do it again into another file. Use diff to find the differences.

      The wonderful thing about Unix is that you can do this sort of thing with the standard shell and 5 lines of script :P

    4. Re:Would like comparison disk by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

      Note: While this is a good idea, a kernel module can get around this technique (infiltrate the kernel, and any program on the system can do whatever you want- including md5sum).

      Be sure to boot from a known good floppy/cdrom rescue disk for full effectiveness.

    5. Re:Would like comparison disk by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      [...]

      The wonderful thing about Unix is that you can do this sort of thing with the standard shell and 5 lines of script :P

      Except, of course, that the code you posted does not
      work, and could be done in one line:

      find /root /bin /etc /usr/local/bin -type f | xargs md5sum

      AFAIK, there is no standard "-s" argument to
      find. Also the command, AFAIK, to compute an
      md5sum is md5sum.

    6. Re:Would like comparison disk by lpontiac · · Score: 2
      Except, of course, that the code you posted does not work

      Works fine for me on FreeBSD. YMMV.

      With xargs, you'll need it to run several instances of the md5 command to avoid having an arguments list that's too long. I'm not sure if this is standard behaviour. Of course, "find .. -exec md5 {}" should also work. Sorry, it was rather late :)

      You're right about the -s, that's BSD specific. I guess you could run the overall output through sort.

      "md5sum" is a GNU utility (found on most Linux systems), "md5" is the name of a utility written by Rivest (found on FreeBSD systems). Neither is standard.

    7. Re:Would like comparison disk by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      man tripwire

    8. Re:Would like comparison disk by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      > Does such a tool exist already?

      Well, you've already mentioned Tripwire, and it recommends keeping its file info DB on a separate media; what doesn't Tripwire do to fit your expressed needs?..

  20. One pill makes you larger... by i.r.id10t · · Score: 0

    And one pill makes you small. And the one your BOFH gives you won't do anything at all.... Go ask Luser...

    Actually, why bother with the floppy stuff if you have a CD that you can boot from? Even a business card CD could hold plenty for whatever kind of Linux tool you'd need for rescue work.

    --
    Don't blame me, I voted for Kodos
  21. I'm confused! by Hilleh · · Score: 0, Offtopic
    What pill to you use to get rid of an AC trying to single-handedly bring down /. by posting a poem?

    I know, I've got my own pill. It's called the "Stab them in the face with a knife...until THEY DIE!!!" pill.

    Some call it "alternative medicine."

  22. meaningless, obfuscating metaphors by Bastian · · Score: 2

    kernel, mount, daemon, zombie, thread, named pipe, kill (especially Kill : The Command), jiffies, etc, etc.

    1. Re:meaningless, obfuscating metaphors by timster · · Score: 1

      Those aren't really metaphors though, they're just jargon. Nobody expects you to understand what a "zombie process" is by thinking of it as a real zombie.

      --
      I have seen the future, and it is inconvenient.
    2. Re:meaningless, obfuscating metaphors by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Are you an idiot? Zombies conjour up an image of decaying processes stumbling about refusing to give up and die.

      Fool.

    3. Re:meaningless, obfuscating metaphors by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You must be joking. That's exactly why a "zombie process" is considered a zombie. You kill it, but it doesn't die.

    4. Re:meaningless, obfuscating metaphors by Alien+Being · · Score: 1

      Nobody expects you to understand what a "zombie process" is by thinking of it as a real zombie.

      Au contraire. A human zombie has no soul, no mind. All that remains for him is for the grim reaper to take his body. It's an excellent metaphore for what happens to a Unix process after it has exited, but before it's process slot gets deleted.

  23. Spelling by hobbicik · · Score: 1

    The guy's name is Komsta, not Komasta... Do we have a fix-my-spelling pill?

  24. link missing by jsse · · Score: 3, Informative

    The link to its ftp server seems to be missing...

    If you want some working linux distro in a floppy you may look at Tom's. It's my favourite, it helps me install Gentoo Linux on some boxes cannot boot from CDROM.

    Besides, you can find list of Linux floppy/CD distros here

  25. Mandrake by bigjocker · · Score: 2

    The install CD for Mandrake can boot using a "rescue" image, which mounts a full system. It's got all I need to get my system up and running again.

    I dont know who should ever need this thing, most distros already have a failsafe way of booting the machine (from cd, floppy or even hd).

    --
    Life isn't like a box of chocolates. It's more like a jar of jalapenos. What you do today, might burn your ass tomorrow.
  26. hmm... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I would not trust my system in the hands of his creations -- he sounds like a major druggie.

  27. Re:Steal Alanis Morrissette's Look! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    LOL I remember her! What was that song she sung? "I'm a bitch" ??

  28. "Full" system by fireboy1919 · · Score: 2

    Unless, of course, you need reiserfs. I'm not sure they've added ext3 support to that, either. No devfs, either, AFAIK. This might have changed since last time I checked.

    Of course, there aren't many systems that actually do include these things yet, so that could be the only reason.

    --
    Mod me down and I will become more powerful than you can possibly imagine!
  29. Re:Steal Alanis Morrissette's Look! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    No that was Meredith Brooks. Alanis sang "Isn't it ironic" and such.

  30. pills by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    viagra for linux?

  31. rm -R / by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The only command youll ever need.

  32. I doubt he has any downloads to solve this! by thelinuxking · · Score: 0

    I jammed caffiene pills in my linux box's floppy drive...

  33. This seems overly complicated by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I just have a boot disk, a root disk, and a CD with the contents of /bin, /usr/bin, /sbin, and /usr/sbin. That's enough to repair just about anything. It's also useful for rearranging hard drive partitions, since you don't have the hard drive mounted.

  34. Re:cheesecake truck by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    charles bukowski no?

    and the 20 second /. reply-post limit sucks greasy cocks - this was a legitimate reply thwarted a half dozen times because im too lazy to log in cocksuckers.

  35. Open Source - Osiris does most of it by capedgirardeau · · Score: 1
    Osiris

    From the Osiris website:

    Osiris is a file integrity verification system that can be used to monitor changes to a file system over time. Osiris consists of a pair of applications, osiris and scale. The first application, osiris, is used to collect specific data from the local filesystem and store that data into a database. The second application, scale, is then used to analyze, and/or compare the differences between two databases.

    This also keeps an administrator apprised of possible attacks and/or nasty little trojans. The purpose here is to isolate changes that indicate a break-in or a compromised system.

    --
    Wax on, wax off baby!
  36. Warning by schnitzi · · Score: 1

    Women who are pregnant, or think they may be pregnant, shouldn not touch LIAP.

    --



    I object to that article, and to the next reply.
    1. Re:Warning by EugeneK · · Score: 1

      Consult physician if dizziness occurs.

  37. In Windows land by Com2Kid · · Score: 1

    In Windows land we just reinstall the entire OS to fix pretty much everything.

    Amazingly enough with XP I have actually seen cases where less and less things work with each continuous fresh install of the OS though, heh.

    1. Re:In Windows land by Reece400 · · Score: 1

      i found it works about the same each time,, might be because i reformat & partiton each time,, or just because, it really can't get any worse, lol :). Maybe i should try a low-level format,,, Reece,

  38. American Medical Associate for Linux? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Hmmmph. Modern medicine has cured NOTHING!! And they subscribe to the pill for individual ailments. I think that if you take the holistic (or wholistic) approach to computing. Look at the environment which the system resides, and there you will find all the unhealthy problems.

  39. SuperRescue by meff · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Personally I prefer SuperRescue http://www.kernel.org/pub/dist/superrescue/ for system recovery, works remarkably well on a system with a CD-ROM. Give it a shot :)

  40. Re:Steal Alanis Morrissette's Look! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    Alanis sang "Isn't it ironic" and such.

    And the ironic thing is that none of the things she sings about in the song are ironic.

  41. tomsrtbt linux by rapidweather · · Score: 1

    I have a couple of those disks around, find them useful now and then...

  42. What pill finally gets Linux out of beta? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Will it ever be a complete product?

  43. I took the: by SHEENmaster · · Score: 1

    Red Pill

    Linux rules, and nothing will tear me away from it! The real world, and the crash world, simply SUCK. Trees can't be tied up searching for Pi. Windows would crash before finding it. Dos would give me several hundred "no command or filename" errors in the process.

    I took the Red Pill, and I am proud of it.

    --
    You can't judge a book by the way it wears its hair.
    1. Re:I took the: by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Would that be the RedHat Pill?

    2. Re:I took the: by The+Bungi · · Score: 2

      You really do need to get a life.

  44. they're metaphors by Bodrius · · Score: 3, Informative

    They are metaphors, they were meant as metaphors and they are still primarily used as metaphors.

    Jargon does not start as jargon, only after it's used has been established in their technical context are they considered the "jargon" or idioms of the field.

    Jargon terms have only three origins:
    - Metaphors: process, kill, zombie, kernel, pipe, thread, batch, stack, etc.
    - Codes and Acronyms: tcp, lisp, java, pc, minix, perl, etc.
    - Idiotic Puns: more, less, archie, most shell commands.

    Some, like GIMP, UNIX or GNU have mixed origins, but I'll let you decide which origins are present in the mix.

    Not only are most computer science terms based on metaphors, very few people expect you to understand them properly without the metaphors. That makes learning concepts more difficult, and makes knowledge incomplete and not-portable.

    --
    Freedom is the freedom to say 2+2=4, everything else follows...
    1. Re:they're metaphors by timster · · Score: 2

      That's not my point exactly, and it isn't what I said. In the case of a zombie process, it's certainly true that the name "zombie process" was established from metaphor ("hmm, we have a situation where a process won't die... we'll call that a zombie, makes sense") but what I'm saying is that it isn't intended to be understood as a metaphor. You have to assign a name to the condition - it's inconvienient to say "process that has terminated but whose parent hasn't read its result code yet" every single time - but the name "zombie process" isn't really an attempt to convey any kind of understanding of what it IS. All the name conveys is that the process is sort of dead but not really; it doesn't purport to suggest how it came about, or what you could do about it.

      A metaphor for a zombie process would be if you called it a "dead limb still hanging to a live tree" or something like that. It's certainly the case that the "process tree" is a metaphor, as the concept is usually taught and understood as a metaphor.

      The reason for my response was to express that there's a difference between concepts that are understood as metaphors and concepts that are only named as metaphors. If you attempt to understand a complex concept using a metaphor, your understanding is limited to the quality of the metaphor. But jargon, merely naming a concept after a convenient metaphor, is not the same thing. No Unix I've seen has a "shotgun" command to do away with zombie processes. Imagine if they did, though; that would result in sysadmins who said "zombie process? just click on the shotgun" and they wouldn't have any clue what was really going on. That's what the concern is.

      --
      I have seen the future, and it is inconvenient.
    2. Re:they're metaphors by Tony-A · · Score: 2

      The metaphor starts the conceptualization. The term becomes jargon after it has obtained a more precise meaning. I would guess that a zombie process is one that is dead, or should be dead, but for some reason has not made itself disappear. One reason for a zombie to stick around is that somebody should maybe do an autopsy.

    3. Re:they're metaphors by orkysoft · · Score: 1
      No Unix I've seen has a "shotgun" command to do away with zombie processes. Imagine if they did, though; that would result in sysadmins who said "zombie process? just click on the shotgun" and they wouldn't have any clue what was really going on. That's what the concern is.

      One word: sysadmin-doom :-P

      --

      I suffer from attention surplus disorder.
  45. tasty outside with rotten core by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The pill that will teach it not to suck

  46. What the F**K?? by fzammett · · Score: 0, Troll

    Linux recovery? What would I ever need that for? I thought Linux never experienced even the sightest hiccup, never crashed, never failed in any way shape or form, just runs until the end of time completely unattended and without any degradation in performance or stabiity EVER?

    Or did I misunderstand the FUD all these years?

    --
    If a pion (n-) collides with a proton in the woods & noone is there to hear it, does lamdba decay into the source pa
    1. Re:What the F**K?? by fzammett · · Score: 1

      Yeah, you would moderate me as a troll. God forbid anyone say anything bad about Linux. God forbid anyone point out hypocricy in the open-source community.

      --
      If a pion (n-) collides with a proton in the woods & noone is there to hear it, does lamdba decay into the source pa
    2. Re:What the F**K?? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What were you looking for? Ticker-tape parades? A "Holy SHIT, this guy is RIGHT...how incredibly bright of him to make the connection between the claims that linux is bulletproof and the obviously hypocritical existance of repair tools. Quick...give this unsung genius an honorary doctorate!"? God forbid somebody ever perpetrates an obvious troll and self-righteously protests it. What a child. Go play Counterstrike or something.

    3. Re:What the F**K?? by fzammett · · Score: 1

      Yes, I want my damned parade! NOW!!

      My very simple retort is this: had I been simply trolling I would have posted anonymously.

      Hey, didn't *YOU* post anonymously??

      (Now, if you want to say I have no life since I was obviously monitoring responses... well... I'm forced to admint I have no good response for that.)

      --
      If a pion (n-) collides with a proton in the woods & noone is there to hear it, does lamdba decay into the source pa
    4. Re:What the F**K?? by Tony-A · · Score: 2

      Linux recovery? What would I ever need that for?
      Well if my experience is anything to go by, broken Microsoft Windows systems
      Otherwise it's like you don't do away with the fire department just because you have flameproof shingles on the roof.

    5. Re:What the F**K?? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I agree with this fellow; the other replies by children themselves telling the bright guy to go "play counter-strike" and the sort are quite incorrect.

      You see, I'll be very honest when I make the harsh point that Slashdot has become a festering shithole. Moderation here is no longer realistic and just, but only to ensure that nothing negative is ever spoken about GNU/Linux, XFree86 and any other bloated garbage that happens to be liked by 600lb men who spend all day in IRC.

      I'm sorry to say, but please don't give fzammett hell for making good statements. His posts are nothing but informative and insightful.

  47. Doctor, it hurts when I do this! by Reziac · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Tell me if I'm imagining unlikely things, but for those of us for whom linux is still mostly a mystery, how about a diagnostic that checks to see what's wrong, then applies the right "pill(s)" ??

    --
    ~REZ~ #43301. Who'd fake being me anyway?
  48. Yeah...what the FUCK by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You mean to say that wasn't a troll? All the signals were there, and you're cute little "Oh, I'm an intelligent, insightful martyr" follow up just shows that you were, in fact, just looking for attention.

    1. Re:Yeah...what the FUCK by fzammett · · Score: 1

      You mean tp say you interpret "Yeah, you would moderate me as a troll. God forbid anyone say anything bad about Linux. God forbid anyone point out hypocricy in the open-source community" as meaning "Oh, I'm an intelligent, insightful martyr"?

      Dude, what are you smoking? Not everybody has a hidden agenda. Not everybody is trying to change the world. I said EXACTLY what I meant.

      But I digress. Arguing with anonymous posters is pretty silly, I do admit I look foolish for doing so.

      --
      If a pion (n-) collides with a proton in the woods & noone is there to hear it, does lamdba decay into the source pa
  49. A better name? by Alien+Being · · Score: 2, Insightful

    "The Linux Apothecary"

  50. so which pill do you take to... by glwtta · · Score: 2
    Each of them is good for one disease, but it doesn't work good enough for another.

    Which pill do you take if you want to learn to read good and do other things good too?

    --
    sic transit gloria mundi
  51. Let me guess... by messiertom · · Score: 1

    When you reinstall Windows on your dual-boot system and it destroys your partition table (not just the MBR mind you), the "morning after" pill comes in and wipes out the unwanted OS (Windows).

  52. Post the instructions... by Wolfrider · · Score: 1

    If you can get this to work, let us know about it. Even better, email the guy that runs the site and maybe he can make it available for download as well. :)
    .

    --
    .
    == WolfriderV6 == I'm willing to admit that *I just might* be wrong... Are you??
  53. List of Linux Ailment by Taco+Cowboy · · Score: 1



    Here's the beginning of Linux Ailment:

    #1. Where's the MS Windoze ?

    #2. Where's the BSOD ?

    And you can continue from here. :)

    --
    Muchas Gracias, Señor Edward Snowden !
  54. for the non-programmers by Bastian · · Score: 2

    A zombie process sticks around until either its parent dies without it being assigned a new parent or until its parent checks its exit status (the 'performing an autopsy' the previous poster mentioned).

    The metaphor extends a bit more, because you can't kill a zombie process the way you can kill normal processes - because you can't kill something that's already dead =)

  55. Re: Metaphors for New Users - Linux Dissent by BigBlockMopar · · Score: 2

    Do Linux users want to be treated like babies all of a sudden? I know I certainly don't. And, somehow, I don't believe the linux community in general is going to be too impressed with useful utility encased in meaningless, obfuscating metaphors.

    I will be.

    If Linux is ever going to replace Windows as a viable desktop operating system - which I think the majority of the Linux community rightly wants - then it's time to get your head out of the sand and look at the reality.

    I'm typing this on a Windows XP box at work. It's not by choice that I am using Windows, in fact, I have defenestrated my home computers despite several problems with Linux as a viable desktop operating system.

    This XP box is insipid, insulting, cartoonish, wasteful of CPU cycles and hardware resources. And, I think, Windows is almost at the point where any idiot can use it.

    If you've ever done a stint in tech support, you know how the operating system must pander to the idiot who doesn't realize that a case sensitive password must be entered with the Caps Lock in the same mode as it was when the password was created.

    Linux should not go this way by default, or else we will drive away both power users and developers.

    But there's plenty of room for distributions and tools which are designed to make Linux easy for the proles to handle.

    Don't knock them, applaud them. Unless you want to see all Internet protocols commoditized by The Borg.

    www.glowingplate.com/dissent

    --
    Fire and Meat. Yummy.
  56. Also available on Memory Stick media by GungaDan · · Score: 1

    for those who prefer suppositories.

    --
    Eloi are stupid, throw morlocks at them!
  57. BPOD ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Blue Pill Of Death?