Slashdot Mirror


Mining Asteroids@Home

An anonymous reader writes "Like the lively discussion on mediation strategies for exterminating asteroids, a six-person expert panel is debating today whether humans exist because of big collisions or in spite of them. Interestingly Mexico's oil (and most of the rest of the world's resources) seem to have arisen from later mining of these byproducts: the luck of geography or the price at the pump for dead dinosaurs."

27 of 110 comments (clear)

  1. Has been cancelled by QEDog · · Score: 4, Funny

    The discussion has been cancelled after a meteor crashed into the 6 panelists hotel...

    --
    "There is no teacher but the enemy."-Mazer Rackham
  2. Lets not rock the boat by EMiniShark · · Score: 5, Funny

    Regardless of whether we exist because of asteroid collisions, I'd rather not give space the chance to reinvent the planet again :)

  3. At home ? They'll sue you know.. by MosesJones · · Score: 4, Funny


    I can just see the adverts now

    "Did you read an article that encouraged you to mine asteroids in your own home? Did you drag an asteroid out of orbit, or drive to a place in order to catch one, did this vapourise you, your loved ones and most of the state ? Here a Sue, Grabbit and Runne Associates we specialise in extra orbital and terrestrial accidents. Last year we helped Bob who strapped himself to 10,000 fireworks to get into space, Bob sadly died but were helped his widow sue Nasa for 100,000,000 dollars. Phone us now and we'll help you get over your stupidity"

    (quick voice over)
    "ActualAmountMayNotBeAsAdvertisedHereLevelO fClaimI sNotIndicativeOfAwardChargesApplyAndWeOnlyAcceptSt upidPeopleWhoDon'tReadInvoices"

    Your just building yourself a litigation hell Slashdot.

    --
    An Eye for an Eye will make the whole world blind - Gandhi
  4. Big collisions exist because of humans by leonbrooks · · Score: 4, Funny

    Stands to reason - we destroy practically everything else, it must be the Universe's way of protecting itself against us.

    --
    Got time? Spend some of it coding or testing
  5. Great Impact Debate I: Benefits of Hard Bodies by mikeophile · · Score: 4, Funny

    For a minute, I thought this would be pr0n.

  6. Humans Would Never Have Survived Without Asteroids by Doctor+Sbaitso · · Score: 5, Funny

    Asteroids, without a doubt, helped our species survive. What else would have filled the immense void in the arcade hall in the years between Pong and Pac-Man?

    --

    ---
    Hello, Slashdot user. My name is Dr. Sbaitso. I am here to help you.
  7. Regardless... by AndroidCat · · Score: 4, Funny

    Regardless if asteroid impacts helped or hindered life on Earth (no so good for the dinosaurs, good for our proto-mice ancestors) I don't think that an asteroid impact would be a good thing today, thank you. Any future life forms that would be helped by an impact can kiss my grits.

    --
    One line blog. I hear that they're called Twitters now.
  8. Billions of factors... by $$$$$exyGal · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Humans exist, today, because of billions and billions of tiny factors, and probably about a dozen large factors. If you took any of them away, you wouldn't be alive today.

    As a matter of fact, if you won't back in time 1 billion years and swished your hands around, and then came back, nothing would be the same. You guys know the Simpson's episode ;-)

    And from the article: We should bear in mind that 99.9% of all species that ever dwelled on Earth were wiped out, most likely, as a result of large impacts.

    If those species wouldn't have died, we also wouldn't be here today.

    --naked

    --
    Very popular slashdot journal for adul
    1. Re:Billions of factors... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Interesting
      If you'd finished reading the article, most of them disagree with the fact that spieces died out "most likely, as a result of large impacts."
      First of all, in contradiction to Benny Peiser's remarks, Peter Ward has presented data showing that while it is true that the majority of species that have ever existed are now extinct, only a minority of those, a few percent in fact, were victims of mass extinctions. Instead, most extinct species have come to an end at some random time between mass extinctions.
    2. Re:Billions of factors... by blair1q · · Score: 4, Informative

      Maybe.

      Chaos theory doesn't say that every change will result in a vastly different outcome.

      It just says that some changes can result in vastly different outcomes.

      What it rarely points out is that most change results in only a minor difference. But then, it wants to be ***Chaos***Theory*** and not just the instability section of the chapter on metastable systems.

    3. Re:Billions of factors... by Pharmboy · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Humans exist, today, because of billions and billions of tiny factors, and probably about a dozen large factors. If you took any of them away, you wouldn't be alive today.

      Im a big believer of the concept that "the reason it looks this way is because if it was any other way, we wouldnt be here to look at it." as well.

      It seems a slight waste of time to debate if they made a difference or not, when there are so many other questions that are more relevent, such as 'are we alone?'.

      Oh yea, and I had to fight REALLY REALLY hard to not comment on "billions and billions" Carl Sagan style comment. :-) God I miss him.

      --
      Tequila: It's not just for breakfast anymore!
    4. Re:Billions of factors... by Turbyne · · Score: 2, Funny
      I have a friend from Boston that helped me on a Lorenz Equations assignment. Towards the end of the assignment, there was a question asking what we had learned from the lorenz equation. He wrote the following:
      The Lorenz Equations show that a small change at the beginning _CAN_ drastically alter the ending, just like the title of the assignment. Basically Lorenz showed that weather is random. What I don't understand, however, is why it took a tenured mathematician at a prestigious university to figure this out when all that is needed is a New Englander!
      The professor, a native Masshole, gave him full credit on the problem.
      --
      ~A'Ëq'i4d)^'$ÊSÈòB
  9. Role in planetary forming by nairnr · · Score: 4, Interesting

    A few interesting points from this article. One is that a number of impacts helped in creating some of the earths key resources. As evidenced by Canada's nickel deposits around the Sudbury impact crater, and Mexico's oil deposits around the Chicxlub impact.

    In addition, the major impacts may not have contributed that much to mass extinctions. While there may have been a momentary spike in extinctions, the vast majority of extinctions were not related to a major event.

    It is difficult for us to fully understand the effect of asteroid and comet impact on the earth, as we are so dynamic that much evidence gets lost..

    1. Re:Role in planetary forming by Mr+Foot · · Score: 2, Informative

      There are other events that might cause a mass extinction. A gamma ray burster within our galaxy could cause quite a problem. Or a nearby star goin supernova. Now there would probably be some evidence of these things happening... does anyone know anything about this?

  10. Bruce Rules by sbillard · · Score: 3, Funny

    strategies for exterminating asteroids

    Just send up Bruce Willis, Steve Bushemi, and, Ben Afleck. Billy-Bob will coordinate the whole she-bang from the ground.
    Good luck and God speed gentlemen

    1. Re:Bruce Rules by Niadh · · Score: 3, Funny
      Just send up Bruce Willis, Steve Bushemi, and, Ben Afleck. Billy-Bob will coordinate the whole she-bang from the ground.
      Good luck and God speed gentlemen


      I'll vote for launching Bruce Willis, Steve Bushemi, and, Ben Afleck into space anyways.
  11. And I thought it was a new client... by nairnr · · Score: 2, Funny

    I was all excited, I was going to work on a new project Seti@home, meet Asteroid@home...

  12. Not dead bodies, dead world. by Angelwrath · · Score: 3, Informative

    It would have been the remnants of the entire world, representing far more mass than dinosaurs, that would have turned into the "fossil fuels", and not merely dinosaurs. Come to think of it, the vegitation alone would dwarf the collective mass of the dinosaurs, not to mention insects, which can breed and grow on high geometric curves.

  13. Bah! by Rayonic · · Score: 4, Funny

    I've been mining asteroids at home for the past twenty years! How is this "News for Nerds, Stuff that Matters"?

    Wait... hemmaroids are the ones in space, right?

  14. Bush Administration by sterno · · Score: 4, Funny

    At the conference, the Bush Administration is expected to seek support for a pre-emptive strike against the Universe. Administration sources were quoted as saying, "The Universe has a long history of unpredictable agression and deterrance of its threats is simply not an option." Donald Rumsfeld went on to state that the US military strategy would bring about a swift and clean victory over the Universe.

    --
    This sig has been temporarily disconnected or is no longer in service
  15. Make Material Fast! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny
    Take five minutes to read this and it WILL change your life!

    All you have to do is send an asteroid to the planet at the top of the list. Then remove that planet from the list, move the rest up one space and add your planet to the bottom of the list. Pass this list around by radio transmissions to other solar systems. Eventually your planet will reach the top of the list, and you'll have more asteroids than you know what to do with!

    This really works. It is NOT a SCAM!

  16. Praise to the dinosaurs. by kkkalen · · Score: 4, Funny

    Since some of us figure we owe our petroleum resources to dead dinosaurs, it stands to reason that the next form of life on this one-day-to-be-post-apocolyptic planet will filling their gas tanks with dead humans.

    --
    If you don't believe me, ask that guy over there.
    1. Re:Praise to the dinosaurs. by blair1q · · Score: 2, Interesting

      1. There weren't enough dinosaurs. Oil is dead pine trees.

      2. Mummies were once so plentiful in Egypt (as recently as the '50s) that people were burning them for heat.

  17. Whether humans exist because of collisions by willpost · · Score: 3, Funny

    Most Definitely.. Collisions of men and women produce people all the time.

  18. 'Fossil fuels' are not! by Cognitive+Dissident · · Score: 3, Insightful

    There is a growing realization that the source of petroleum is not 'dead dinosaurs' or even dead plants and/or bacteria as had been believed for so long. It seems that what we consider 'organic' chemistry (in chemistry btw, 'organic' just means carbon containing compounds)) might be quite common in the natural world even without what we would recognize as life to create it. Some Google searches on terms like 'non-organic', 'inorganic' and 'petroleum' will turn up lots of articles about the new theories. This one, for example. Or This one in a respected journal of geology. It's looking more and more like the term 'fossil fuels' is a misnomer. That's not to say that the supply isn't limited, however...

  19. Why not just outlaw Asteroids by EvilTwinSkippy · · Score: 3, Insightful
    I seem to recall that prior to WWI a panel conviened to discuss the problems of warfare. The concluded that we should outlaw warfare entirely.

    I don't understand this obsession with panels. We really need action. We need someone to invent the mass driver in their back yard. Think of flight.

    Before the Wright Brothers, flight (when attempted) was perilous and uncontrolled. You could control your Yaw motion well enough, you place a rudder on the tail of the aircraft like the rudder on a boat. Pitch was easy, you take a rudder, turn in sideways, and you can control up and down movement. The tricky part was Roll. The Wright brothers developed a technique called "Wing Warping", where they altered the geometry of the wing to control roll motion.

    Think of radio. Deforest clodged together a bunch of parts and created the precursor to the modern Diode. He never really understood how it worked, but the invention (and the name escapes me) is the one missing piece that allows radio transmissions.

    The nautical clock, a stepping stone that allowed ships to calculate their longitudinal position, was invented be a sole crazed inventor.

    Einstein did not have a panel to work out relativity. Hell how many theorums do Newton, Fermat, Fourier, Laplace, and Liebnitz have to their names. And don't forget loonies like Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle.

    Face it, geeks rule. They always have. All of human history was more or less worked out by one crackpot at a time. We need crackpots working on this problem.

    --
    "Learning is not compulsory... neither is survival."
    --Dr.W.Edwards Deming
  20. The A.T.A.R.I. Asteriod Extermination System by ShinmaWa · · Score: 4, Funny

    Many years ago -- I exterminated thousands of asteroids at home using the Asteroid Targetting And Removal Instrument 2600.

    --
    The /. Effect: Thousands of users simultaneously accessing a site to not read its content.