Slashdot Mirror


Mining Mars from Houston

An anonymous reader writes "Computer simulations of what bits of Earth, Mars and Venus might be found on the moon point to new methods for extraterrestrial sample return. Because the moon is lifeless, its sterile condition gives a very rare laboratory for collecting what may be as high as 3 grams of Earth's past, from the half-ton of lunar rocks and soil that Apollo returned for study [3 grams (Earth-terran), 0.03 grams (Mars), 0.003 grams (Venus)]. While such interplanetary exchanges are now thought common, what is surprising is these pristine samples often have never exceeded a temperature of around 100 F. Any similar planetary samples found today in, say, Antarctica, would have been weathered, eroded, or contaminated."

63 comments

  1. fp by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    fp

  2. ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS: WHO BENEFITS? by Luke+SkyTroller · · Score: -1

    ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS: WHO BENEFITS?
    Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) is the most popular self-help
    organization for individuals with alcohol-related problems. This
    includes both alcohol-dependent and, to a lesser extent,
    alcohol-abusing drinkers. For any people, self-help through AA is the
    only alcoholism treatment they receive. Other members join the
    fellowship before entering professional reatment or are introduced to
    AA as a component of their professional treatment. Attendance at AA
    also commonly is recommended as after- care following professional
    treatment. Yet experience shows that not all clients benefit from AA to
    the same extent. Therefore, two questions arise: Who does well in AA,
    and why do these people succeed?
    These questions do not have simple answers, however,
    because outcome (i.e., reduction of drinking or improvement of
    psychological and social characteristics) associated with AA, as with
    any kind of alcoholism treatment, is influenced by many characteristics
    of the clients and the AA groups. For example, the success of AA
    participation depends not only on an individual's initial decision to
    attend AA but also on the degree of his or her involvement in AA (e.g.,
    frequency of attendance at meetings, "sharing" at meetings, or
    serving as or having an AA sponsor). Even similar levels of AA
    involvement may result in different outcomes for different people,
    depending on the individual' s characteristics and experiences with
    professional treatment.
    Despite four decades of AA research, no clear picture
    has emerged as to which patient characteristics can predict a positive
    outcome with AA and, therefore, can be used as criteria for matching
    patients to AA. This is due in part to the limitations and variability
    of methodological approaches used in the studies. Most investigators
    recruit their samples from patients in inpatient or outpatient
    treatment settings. Some studies retrospectively analyze patients
    with previous AA experience to identify personal characteristics that
    predicted AA involvement. In other studies, patients are monitored
    after professional treatment to determine which characteristics may
    motivate them to join AA and how AA affiliation influences outcome. In
    both approaches, the kind and impact of the professional treatment
    often is ignored. Other confounding factors in research about AA
    include an incomplete understanding of processes within AA and
    differences among various AA groups.
    To date, only three randomized clinical trials have
    examined the efficacy of AA participation, either with or without
    additional simultaneous treatment approaches (Ditman et al. 1967;
    Brandsma et al. 1980; Walsh et al. 1991). The vast majority of AA
    studies, however, have focused on two narrower questions: Which factors
    predict whether a person will join AA? And how does involvement in AA
    predict outcome? In an attempt to answer these two questions, Emrick
    and colleagues (1993) reviewed 107 previously published AA studies.
    Although their analysis provided estimates of the magnitude of the
    relationships determining AA affiliation and drinking outcome, it also
    acknowledged that many relationships may differ when study findings are
    grouped by client characteristics. Tonigan and colleagues (1994)
    extended the initial analyses by taking into account factors such as
    sample gender and origin (i.e., inpatient versus outpatient). This
    article integrates the findings of these two reviews and concludes with
    recommendations for future research of AA.
    WHO JOINS AA?
    To determine which drinkers were most likely to join
    AA, Emrick and colleagues (1993) reviewed 33 studies[1] that addressed
    this question, analyzing 31 demographic and drinking-related client
    characteristics. The characteristic most strongly correlated with
    joining AA was the drinkers' previous u

  3. Idiot. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    One gram is one gram, be it on Earth, Mars, or Uranus. Mass is not Force.

    1. Re:Idiot. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Read the post again, he wasn't talking about force. It usually helps to be right when calling someone an idiot, else the term could easily be applied to the person saying it.

    2. Re:Idiot. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      He was just fucking with you! Can't you take a joke?

    3. Re:Idiot. by jewhater2001 · · Score: -1

      werd to yo momma

  4. what the fuck is 100 F by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    some sort of wierd SI unit?

  5. RPN example by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    half of e to the third?

    ALG: exp ( 1 / 3 ) / 2 =
    9 keystrokes

    RPN: 3 1/x exp 2 /
    5 keystrokes

  6. Yes, butt... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Does it help mine Uranus?

    1. Re:Yes, butt... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Don't be afaid to get your hands dirty.Dig in!

    2. Re:Yes, butt... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      Yes but you have to be carefull. Or Uranus might do this when overmined.

  7. Interesting stuff by Matrix2110 · · Score: 3, Insightful

    One thing I would point out is that there is very little chance of recovering DNA from these samples, Correct me if I am wrong (I'm sure that will happen :) ) but organic matter would not stand a chance against the vacuum and radiation involved here.

    1. Re:Interesting stuff by WegianWarrior · · Score: 4, Informative

      While recovering DNA may be hard / impossible (I'm fixing military aircraft for a living, not extracting organinc matter from rocks), we still can learn a lot of interesting things. After all, we can't extract DNA from a fossil, yet it teaches us (or rather, the guys who do that sort of thing for a living or as a hobby) a lot about the creature in question.


      I am, however, reminded by a television programe I saw on Discovery Europe a while back... where they 'proved' - by setting up a simulated Mars-base in Antartica or somewhere - that human explorers might see signs of life that a robotic explorer would miss. And I'm sure they could set up a (simplified?) DNA-extraction lab in a potential Mars-base too, thus preventing any organic remains from beeing erradicated by the radiation in outer space.

      --
      Everything in the world is controlled by a small, evil group to which, unfortunately, no one you know belongs.
    2. Re:Interesting stuff by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That is a good reason to have a manned mars expedition.

    3. Re:Interesting stuff by s1234d · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Apollo 12 landed on the moon next to a Surveyor probe that had been there for a couple of years. The astronauts cut off a camera, and brought it back to earth. Inside the camera some bacteria were still technically alive, but in a dormant state. So the vacuum won't destroy DNA by itself, and if bacteria if in a crack deep in a rock then radiation is not really an issue either.

  8. if you follow correct procedures by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Put on the proper space suit with no leakage before exploring for gold on that planet. Watch out for wind storms. Explore with caution!

  9. So does this mean...? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    We can find traces of earth's past, such as objects from Iraq (the birthplace of humanity) and see that the inhabitants from North America hated the inhabitants from the birthplace of humanity as far ago as 6000 years?

  10. SPOOGE TROLL by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    I once jerked off into some moon rock. mabye you'll find my DNA in it.

  11. I'm fairly certain that Space.com has had a couple recent stories to the effect that some organic molecules in fact could survive hard vacuum, if they were buried and sealed inside a meteorite. I think that high-energy ionizing radiation would be the most limiting factor to survival of any hypothetical DNA in these rocks. IIRC, there was even mention that they could be protected from the heat of reentry under the right conditions.

    "Weird, wild stuff," to quote Johnny Carson.

    --
    "All animals are created equal, but some animals are more equal than others." - George Orwell
  12. Unbelievable by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    The grammar in the submission is unbelievably appalling.

    "Its sterile surface gives a very rare laboratory for collecting..."

    I give you me good? What exactly do you mean? Is there a such thing as a very common laboratory?

    "...often have never exceeded a temperature of around 100 F. Any similar planetary samples found today in, say, Antarctica, would have been weathered, eroded, or contaminated."

    I somehow don't think temperatures exceeded 100 F in the Antarctic either. Doesn't the fact that they found "material" from three different planets, and possibly from other unknown sources as well, indicate that it too was contaminated? What would you also call meteorite strikes? Wouldn't they also be a form of weathering or contamination?

    I simply don't get what the submittor is trying to say. I'm sure it's something important, but the poor grammar and logic were more noticeable than the story itself.

  13. Here's the link by DredPirateRoberts · · Score: 5, Informative
    This article is what I was thinking of.

    --
    "All animals are created equal, but some animals are more equal than others." - George Orwell
  14. krazy, just krrrrrraaaazzzyyyyyyy! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    woooowww, what a krazy troll name! what krazy troll name will they cum up with next!??!

  15. That's what I'm talking about! by theBunkinator · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    Getting high on 3 grams of "Earth's past"!

  16. apparently by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    apparently, it's used by some people bound together by greed for wealth and power who disregard everyone but themselves to get ahead in life.

    1. Re:apparently by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Damn thats nice! The best thing is that most of the people its targetted at are too stupid to realise that it's aimed at them. The best putdown of all.

  17. from Houston? by commodoresloat · · Score: 4, Funny

    You're kidding. There's oil on Mars?

    1. Re:from Houston? by Thyrhaug · · Score: 1, Funny

      how long 'till bush declares mars as their territory, and threatens whoever tries to colonize it with nuclear wars and no more friendship?

    2. Re:from Houston? by flippet · · Score: 1

      You're kidding. There's oil on Mars?

      Oil on Mars? But NASA doesn't know anything about drilling for oil! Who shall we send?

      Phil

      --
      "Cattle Prods solve most of life's little problems."
    3. Re:from Houston? by benson+hedges · · Score: 1

      Definitely not. If there was oil on Mars, Dubya would have long declared war on it. :)

      --
      Karma : Soylent Green (Mostly due to eating junk food and mocking religion)
    4. Re:from Houston? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You're kidding. There's oil on Mars? ATTACK!

    5. Re:from Houston? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

      You said: Definitely not. If there was oil on Mars, Dubya would have long declared war on it. :)

      <rant>Fuckups like you shouldn't breed. If we wanted the oil, we would appease Iraq so they could pump it all day long and bring the price to $10, not kick their leadership's ass.

      Do a little homework, and ask the FRENCH about the oil and $$$. There are NO American oil companies profiting in Iraq. Only French and Russian. Listen to what Iraqi's who are outside waiting to go back say. Why is is that every Iraqi living outside Iraq thinks the US is doing a tough thing for the right reasons, and openly SAYS that France and Russia are more concerned with their financial interests? Its not MY opinion, its the opinion of IRAQIS who are in a position to speak freely.

      It just galls you pricks that the man is doing what he thinks is right (whether or not you and i agree), and you can't attack that, so you make up this false 'for oil' shit. No one, except you fellow idealogs, buys this arguement. Go crawl back under the agenda driven rock you crawled out from under and get your facts straight.

      Attack the policies, attack the ideas, fine:
      We can debate ideas, but when you attack the individual instead, it shows you don't have an arguement, just a bone to pick. </rant>

  18. Ralph by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Ralph: I found a moonrock up my nose...

    Bart: Houston,... we have a problem...

  19. Previous research by LegendLength · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Unmanned gathering of moon rock was carried out back in 1972 by the Russians. It took 7 years after the analysis was published before anyone realized that there were organic patterns in the samples.

    Real images of the fossils show bacteria-like shapes. There were claims that these fossils prove existance of life elsewhere in space but it seems more likely to me that they somehow came from Earth.

  20. ASTEROID sample return. by zzztkf · · Score: 5, Informative

    Japan's space agency,ISAS, is attepmting to send
    a probe to asteroid 1998SF36 and get sample to
    retrun to Earth.

    Launch will take place 2003, May.

    http://www.isas.ac.jp/e/index.html

  21. Runny ass eggs... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I want em in me!

  22. USA has no respect for children... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    USA and somalia are the only countries in the world that haven't approved the children rights.

    USA hasn't signed for The international tribunal.

    The USA also hasn't signed The Aye approval for private property at war.

    1. Re:USA has no respect for children... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      The Haye! fucking keyboard...

  23. Things to do today... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Buy a pack of squares
    Arrive at the apartment
    Confront the investor
    Explain the situation
    Have him sign the documents
    Bind him to a chair
    Handcuff him
    Place him face down on the bed
    Shoot him once
    Remember gloves
    Scan apartment
    Kill the dog, kill the dog, kill the dog, evidence
    Kill the dog, kill the dog, kill the dog, evidence
    Kill the dog, evidence, kill the dog, evidence
    Kill the dog

  24. Tiny, king of the jews... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I started out drinking, I stays that way
    mm mm all in me
    And I killed another day
    On the wall there's another there
    I hacked through another night
    By the look of mm my hand
    I'm adrift and I can't mm
    I started out hating myself and when I'm through
    I've gotta have something to hate, and I guess it's you
    Man's gotta have something to hate, guess I'll do
    And when I'm through with myself, I'll start on you
    Everything I do, it's do-or-die
    I started out drinking, I wonder why
    I started out drinking, mm mm mm mm
    mm mm mm mm all in me
    And I killed another day
    On the wall there's another there
    I hacked through another night
    Another wrinkle in my skin
    Another trip that I can't make
    Man's gotta hate someone, and I guess I'll do
    And when I'm through with myself, I'll start on you
    I started out hating myself, now that I'm through
    I'm looking for someone to hate, guess you'll do

  25. Mars? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You mean Al Mardh?

  26. Bring back Quantum Leap! by $exy+Hermaphrodite · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Mod me up if you agree!

    --

    Am lonely hermaphrodite seeking two people to fill both my holes simultaneously.

  27. Slashdotted already ! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    Because our moon is lifeless, it is one of the cuntlicking most spanking places to look for the thrusting gangbanged records of life elsewhere. At least according to recent estimates for the jerking amount of raunched rocks that might survive there, the blowing Moon may hold clues from the charvering early history of Mars, Venus and Earth. The raiding browning titled "K/T Hit" by artist Donald E. Davis. This impact felched 65 million charvers ago, ending the fingering reign of the squirting dinosaurs. Image "Assrush" Credit: Don "Motherfucker" Spews Prior to the screwing work of John "Plugin" Armstrong and fistfucks from the University of Washington and Iowa "Rugmuncher" State, there were no fingerfucked "estimates for the barfing abundance of Terran, Martian, and Venusian assfucks on the Moon." To fill this gap, the squirting team undertook computer simulations based on the impact muff sniffs from 3.9 billion years ago during what is gangbanged the Late "Suck my tits dry" Heavy Bombardment--the last time that the inner solar system was assfucked with asteroid debris. The fingering simulations must take account of the gravity and escape velocities for each inner planet, the raiding orbital paths of licks wanks, and finally the barfing Moon's ability to capture strategic samples. One of the fomping cuntlicks such enters might be so valuable is "to substantiate or extend a blowing contested fossil record that squirts 3.5 billion years (3.5 Ga) ago", writes Armstrong, thus filling in what early Earth life might have smooched. Even shorter spans are available for Venus, where its surface records were catastrophically cuntlapped 700 million years ago. The fucking Washington study indicates that if such meteorites reached Earth- and could be deep throated even from the ice plains of Antarctica- a lunar sample would still be raunched as the titty fucking best recorded history lesson. Whether from wind (atmosphere), water, or fire (volcanism), the Moon's lack of erosion might provide a unclefucking unique collection muff sniffed to anywhere else in our solar system. The authors note: "Most significantly, the Moon lacks the water capable of unclefucking contaminants into the interior of rocks through raunchs." Boomerang from the Past Cocksucking the debris spray from a heavy bombardment assfucked motherfucking. Three unclefucks were titty fucked: 1) "direct transfer", where the fingering farted rocks liftoff the screwing Earth, Mars or Smoochs with medium velocity, but not too high that the Moon could not have captured them; 2) "orbital transfer", where the unclefucking meteorite blows sex fights at high speed, but comes back later to land on the cuntlicking lunar surface; and finally, 3) "lucky strikes", where the felching fistfucks farts blows with the muff sniffing Moon directly. Lunar "Butplug" Clementine mission shows the South "Thrushmore" Pole of the Moon. The wad pulling permanently blowed region center shows evidence of meteor cratering and ice never raunched to direct sunlight. Credit: NASA/DOD Clementine In the Earth's case, at least, the jerking incoming unclefucks or fragments during Late "Spunksupper" Heavy Bombardment average a whopping 14 blows per second (or around 31,000 miles per hour [MPH]). To escape the motherfucking Earth's gravity (or reach escape velocity), the farting felching rocks also must have a relatively high speed, around 11.5 km/s (37,000 MPH). To complete the spewing lunar capture, a final high-speed event must include an impact on the assfucking Moon, or a cuntlapping shock that would complete the sample's journey after a relatively hard-entering at around 2-5 km/s (~10,000 MPH). One discovery from computer fomps was that the second method of licking rocks on the moon--orbital transfer-- is dominant. Most (58% by spanks) of the motherfucking terrestrial fucks (called Terran) that would be cuntlapped today on the Moon, would have left Earth in all deep throats, but then later have come back to visit on a fingering centuries-old, boomerang pattern that depends on its orbit and lunar

  28. moron strip mining the wwworld from houston, DC by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    this is what you wanted? this is what you're gonna get.

  29. Frist Hilary Duff Own Linux Geek Prost! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    0 \/\/ n 3 D :dancing banana:

  30. Here are some pics by Billly+Gates · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Notice the orange pebbles in this soil sample. Now check out yellow ones here. The yellow ones probably have come from venus but have not been tested yet.

  31. Safe Sample Return by photonrider · · Score: 3, Insightful

    There are some scientists worred about bringing samples directly from Mars to Earth. Fears of some unknown contamination. A moon base would be a perfect place to return from a Mars trip with samples. Keeps Earth isolated from possible contaminants.

    1. Re:Safe Sample Return by Idarubicin · · Score: 1
      A moon base would be a perfect place to return from a Mars trip with samples.

      Yeah, but then you would have to take the samples (and astronauts, and gear) down into the Moon's gravity well, and eventually bring them back up again. Which is not to say that I'm opposed to a Moon base--it would be a valuable research site for any number of reasons. It's just that if you need a waypoint on the way back from Mars, why not use a preexisting continuously manned space station in earth orbit?

      --
      ~Idarubicin
  32. whois going to protect mars from US? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    doesn't matter, if there ARE any martians, they can either get with the 'program', or be deleted with the rest.

    1. Re:whois going to protect mars from US? by JPriest · · Score: 1

      What ever virus/bacteria/parasites might be there could have been responsible for extinction what ever life that may have existed there. What if AIDS was airborne? What if mosquitoes caused nests of larvae to grow around your intestines? Anytime you introduce a new species to a new climate, you upset the natural balance of life.

      --
      Saying Java is nice because it works on all OS's is like saying that anal sex is nice because it works on all genders.
    2. Re:whois going to protect mars from US? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What the fsck is going on here? IIRC Apollo missions 11,12,14 ALL had a decontamination module that was transported to the ship that recovered the vessels. And the next 2 or 3 missions were deemed sanitary.

      What about the command module that splashed down into the ocean after having contact with the lunar module that could very well have picked up microbes (such as AIDS or Ebola or insert favorite microbe/virus here) and such contamination or however you want to spell it didn't actually already "infect" earth through the ocean that our own capsules splashed down into? Yes I know that the chance that this happen is roughly the same as me hitting the powerball lottery.... but why do we keep thinking that we are "safe" and ignoring the possibility that we may have already set off the "doomsday" device?

  33. Re: goatse.cx like link by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    EWWWWWW! Nasty! In the name of god do not click on the links!!

  34. Melted Cheese & Mars Bars? by bushboy · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    So The Moon is contaminated with Mars Bars !
    MMMmmmm, Cheese Flavoured Mars Barrrrrsssss.....

    Mod -5 Troll

    --
    A slashdotting - you get the stick first and then the carrot !
    1. Re:Melted Cheese & Mars Bars? by Billly+Gates · · Score: -1, Troll
      Almost as delicous as this. MMMmmmmmm. Makes your mouth just water hu.

    2. Re:Melted Cheese & Mars Bars? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      Ewww!

      Tubgirl's not funny, it's just plain disgusting!

      Same story for goatse.cx!

  35. Re:Want to really quit drinking ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This is what could happen if you overdrink! Now do you really want to drink again? I think not.

  36. Why is everything base 3? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Why is everthing some exponent of a third of a gram?

  37. Funding un-manned mining... by billysara · · Score: 5, Funny

    Funding research on bringing back oil/minerals from high-radiation, toxic environments will certainly come in handy if the middle-east goes nuclear....

    Yes, I'm feeling cynical today..... :-)

  38. Another Stupid idea by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Search 10 square km on the moon to find a speck of mars of a micro speck of venus.

    Wouldn't it just be easier to send a probe to those planets and sent back say 10 POUNDS of ROCK!

    hello?

    Ya we got 400kg of the moon here but think there going to let them go over everything looking for that .003 grams?

  39. Mass, not weight. by AJWM · · Score: 1, Informative

    [3 grams (Earth-terran), 0.03 grams (Mars), 0.003 grams (Venus)]

    Harumph! Grams are a unit of mass, not of weight, and thus independant of the gravitational force exerted on it. 3 grams on Earth is 3 grams on Mars is 3 grams on Venus is 3 grams in freefall.

    Not only that, but the gravity of Venus is not one tenth that of Mars, it is closer to twice that of Mars: Venus is nearly as big as Earth. (Nor is the gravity of Mars only 1/100th Earth, it's about 1/3 Earth.)

    Geez. If somebody was trying to be funny, it came off as incredibly stupid.

    --
    -- Alastair
  40. Huh? by freeweed · · Score: 3, Interesting

    The amounts they're talking about are what they expect to be able to extract from the half-ton or so that Apollo returned. 3 grams of material from Earth, 0.03g from Mars (makes sense, it's a hell of a lot further away), and 0.003g from Venus (far away, and closer to the sun. material has one hell of a time getting AWAY from the sun's gravitational well).

    I'd say yeesh, read the article before you spout off your ignorance, but hey, this is Slashdot.

    --
    Endless arguments over trivial contradictions in books written by ignorant savages to explain thunder in the dark.
    1. Re:Huh? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Amen.

    2. Re:Huh? by barakn · · Score: 1
      The dense atmosphere of Venus also dissipates the kinetic energy of incoming projectiles and outgoing ejecta.

      It wasn't even necessary to read the article, just the /. blurb, to figure out they were talking about mass fractions of lunar soil.

      --
      "I'm so moist I'm sticking to the leather." -Kermit the Frog on The Late Late Show
  41. Er what the hell by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Maybe you don't understand the how the SI system is applied in everday use. Grams are definitely used as a unit of weight(force) where I live and also used as a unit of mass.

    No one goes around talking about "how much does it cost for 400 Newtons of Apples?"

    I guess it is the weight at sea level on Earth.