Slashdot Mirror


The Two Towers DVD Release Dates

FortKnox writes "Mark these dates on your Calendar: 8/26/03 & 11/18/03. These are the (US) DVD release dates for The Two Towers. Like Fellowship, the first date is the release of the DVD, and the November date is the release of the special edition (with rumored extra 48 minutes of footage). Another one ring.net page has more details on the actual footage."

63 of 319 comments (clear)

  1. Comment removed by account_deleted · · Score: 2, Funny

    Comment removed based on user account deletion

  2. You know by Raul654 · · Score: 2, Flamebait

    It's one thing to have a lot of hype on slashdot about lord of the rings. It's another thing entirely to give it its own catagory. That's just sick.

    --


    To make laws that man cannot, and will not obey, serves to bring all law into contempt.
    --E.C. Stanton
    1. Re:You know by Ark42 · · Score: 2, Insightful

      So does The Matrix and Starwards... what I want to know is why Futurama doesn't have its own catagory :)

    2. Re:You know by Dirtside · · Score: 2, Funny
      It's one thing to have a lot of hype on slashdot about lord of the rings. It's another thing entirely to give it its own catagory. That's just sick.
      But how could they not? It is, after all, our precioussss.... yesss.... we loves it...

      *shakes head* Whoa, sorry, got carried away there a second.

      --
      "Destroy science and religion. Science would re-emerge exactly the same; but not religion." - Penn Jillette, paraphrased
    3. Re:You know by charon_on_acheron · · Score: 5, Funny

      They're still trying to find an icon of Bender's shiny metal ass.

    4. Re:You know by Rob+Simpson · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Ah, but the beauty of it having its own category is that you can exclude it using your Preferences/Homepage menu, instead of whining about LOTR topics. So, uh, why didn't you go do that?

    5. Re:You know by Pirogoeth · · Score: 2, Funny

      *shakes head* Whoa, sorry, got carried away there a second.

      No, that belongs under The Matrix category...

      --
      Happiness is like peeing yourself. Everybody can see it but only you can feel its warmth.
  3. Re:Forget that! by toddestan · · Score: 2, Interesting

    You mean you are going to buy the first edition when it comes out? I plan on renting that. I'll buy the special edition.

    I'm kind of tired of the re-release game they play with DVDs - though it is nice with Lord of the Rings that they tell you in advance that there is a special edition coming out. But I do expect after the third movie for a super-duper special edition box set we'll all have to have.

  4. Waiting for the complete set? by ic3p1ck · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I'm personally waiting for the complete box set. I hope it will include all the extended versions of the three movies with all the extras, i.e greater than the sum of these intermediate special edition releases.

  5. Comment removed by account_deleted · · Score: 3, Funny

    Comment removed based on user account deletion

  6. Save your money. by Asterax · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I really don't see much point in buying the LotR DVD's seperately. You just know that New Line will compile together all three movie's in one big massive package with an infinite amount of DVD extra's.

    1. Re:Save your money. by evilviper · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Well, some of us buy DVDs for the movie, and don't care very much about the rest. Deleted scenes are always good, but if you want interviews with air-headed actors, just watch the late shows.

      --
      Slashdot gets worse every day... Pipedot: News for nerds, without the corporate slant
    2. Re:Save your money. by coupland · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Your comment makes no sense. If a single compilation is what you want then you are guaranteed not to get it. The media industry has proven time and again that it makes no sense to release something their customers want when it's easier and more profitable to release many iterations of something you ALMOST want. Hopefully you'll buy them all and make them rich. Star Wars for example, will we ever see a digital DVD compilation? No. Not while you keep buying things piecemeal...

    3. Re:Save your money. by Xytras · · Score: 5, Funny

      Star Wars for example, will we ever see a digital DVD compilation? You think you'll see a Analog DVD Compilation?

  7. Likewise with FOTR extended DVD by PovRayMan · · Score: 3, Interesting

    I'm hoping I get a $10 coupon to the Return of the King movie.

    I'm a poor college student and I was so happy that I could spend $30 on a 4 Disc DVD, and get a FREE (afternoon shows here are $5.50) showing of the newest LOTR movie. It was very nice walking in to the theature after classes, handing them my coupon, and sneaking a bottle over to the water fountain because I was too broke to even afford a drink.

    Well I got my fingers crossed.

    1. Re:Likewise with FOTR extended DVD by buffy · · Score: 5, Insightful
      I'm a poor college student and I was so happy that I could spend $30 on a 4 Disc DVD, and get a FREE (afternoon shows here are $5.50) showing of the newest LOTR movie. It was very nice walking in to the theature after classes, handing them my coupon, and sneaking a bottle over to the water fountain because I was too broke to even afford a drink.

      Wait a sec. You were broke, but still had the $30 to spend on a 4 Disc DVD? That's sick.

      Broke is broke. Having $30 to by a movie that you have the luxury to have a DVD player to play in is NOT broke.

      So sayeth the fat white computer dude with a good job, and who worries about buying that new Wolverine XBox game 'cause he hears it kind of sucks. -buf

    2. Re:Likewise with FOTR extended DVD by cyrax777 · · Score: 2, Funny

      maybe he was broke after buying the dvd?

    3. Re:Likewise with FOTR extended DVD by PovRayMan · · Score: 4, Interesting

      I sacrificed many meals and ate leftovers from friends and neighbors to save up enough for the dvd. There was a strong sense of value for only $30. I got a movie, tons of extras, and a free pass to the theater.

      Plus the whole eating less made me kill off a couple pounds. I should try it again. the Lord of the Diet... Hmm...

    4. Re:Likewise with FOTR extended DVD by sowellfan · · Score: 5, Funny

      If you were really dedicated, you would've sold your plasma, too, and seen the movie twice or more ;)

      You could lose even more weight that way, too.

    5. Re:Likewise with FOTR extended DVD by KikassAssassin · · Score: 2, Funny

      Hey, even when you're broke, you've got to have priorities. :-)

    6. Re:Likewise with FOTR extended DVD by protein+folder · · Score: 2, Funny

      Yeah, after eating no food for a while, donating plasma and blood and shuffling into the theater ("Frodo movie good!" slapping down a twenty at the ticket window and walking away) he can have a completely immersive experience at the movies.

      "What's that Aragorn?! That man with a cell phone is an agent of Mor(rr)dor(rr)?"

      "Yes, most noble and brave hobbit, PovRayMan! Girt thyself with this knife of Westernesse! Wrest the One RingTone from he who hath obviously not watched the dancing Coke(TM) bottle commanding that all cell phones should be shut off!"

      Fortunately, in his weakened condition he should be easy to fend off, and the ushers can take him in the back room and feed him some Junior Mints. ("That will be $5.50, please!")

      --
      Your mind is squeezed by a blast of pain!
  8. Release date mix-up by dzym · · Score: 4, Informative
    The actual release date for the DVD with the theatrical version of the movie is august 26th, 8/26, not June 28th, 6/28.

    Hope that helps.

    1. Re:Release date mix-up by MrWa · · Score: 2, Funny
      The actual release date for the DVD with the theatrical version of the movie is august 26th, 8/26, not June 28th, 6/28.
      Hope that helps.

      Helps what? Rip out my heart, stomp on it, and pour salt all over it? The release quickly went from 2 months away to 4 in the time it took me to click "read more"!!

      Now I might as well wait for the Extended-Super-Delux edition...

  9. Comment removed by account_deleted · · Score: 5, Funny

    Comment removed based on user account deletion

  10. Re:Why? by dtfinch · · Score: 2, Insightful

    It's greed. They don't want you to just buy the special edition and be done with it. By delaying the special edition, they may be able to get you to buy the regular edition as well.

  11. Re:Sure go ahead by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

    Who cares about the MPAA and RIAA?

    This is LoTR!! I'll buy every DVD and soundtrack!

    Hell, I'll sleep with Jack Valenti and Hilary Rosen!

    Actually, ewww!

  12. Why yes... by GarfBond · · Score: 5, Informative
    If by 6/28/2003 you mean 8/26/2003 (bit of an odd typo...), then yes, that is the expected release date for TTT :)

    Here's the Official Site if you don't believe someone's scanner for this info.

  13. the onion by DanThe1Man · · Score: 5, Funny

    (with rumored extra 48 minutes of footage)

    That remindes me of an Onion side story title: "DVD contains two hours of previously unseen movie"

  14. Re:Why? by NeeNee3 · · Score: 3, Funny
    Exactly! They are counting on the kind of fans that love the movie so much they rush out to by the regular edition as soon as it hits the shelves because they can't wait. Then, they know these same fans are going to buy the special edition when it finally releases because of the all the extras.

    Heck, a lady I work with loves LOTR so much that she bought the special edition of Fellowship of the Ring TWICE! She lent the first copy to someone who was taking too long in returning it, and she didn't feel like waiting the extra day or whatever to get it back, so she went and bought it again. Movie companies love these kind of people!

  15. some news on the extended edition by TerraFrost · · Score: 4, Informative
    While we're talking about the Two Towers, the extended edition will have 43 extra minutes (compared to the 32 extra in FotR), and have more than 150 cgi scenes (compared to the 35 extra in FotR).

    Sources:
    http://www.theonering.net/perl/newsview/8/10503906 13
    http://www.aintitcool.com/display.cgi?id=14590

    1. Re:some news on the extended edition by cybermox · · Score: 3, Informative

      According to the official site, LordoftheRings.Net, the extended edition will have "35 minutes of new and extended scenes."

      Source:
      http://www.lordoftherings.net/index_400 _hv_presell .html (Click on the "Click Here" link to pop up the SE info.)

  16. Lucas by grungebox · · Score: 5, Funny

    I think George Lucas should watch the DVD extras so he can learn a thing or two about making good movies.

    1. Re:Lucas by BollocksToThis · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Umm, did anyone happen to watch the extras that came with the first DVD?

      I did, and what I saw amounted to one big fucking commercial.

      "Hi, I'm some chick who works for bla bla corp, oh look! Collector's editions of the original trilogy in book format! That's pretty interesting, why don't we show some shots of that while I keep talking? Did you know we sell these? Mmmm, these books sure do look nice... I wish I could be saying 'Only $69.95!' right about now... hey, let's have a shot of the director. He seems to be saying something. Oh, he's saying he wanted to be true to Tolkien's original trilogy! Well, let's fade him out and fade back in this shot of the trilogy that we happen to publish! The only thing missing from this 'making of' feature is an 800 number!"

      At least some of the extras on the Star Wars DVDs didn't appear to have anything to do with trying to sell me more crap.

      --
      This sig is part of your complete breakfast.
    2. Re:Lucas by daVinci1980 · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Why is it that when Lucas re-edits movies and adds scenes to them, we consider it evil, but when its LoTR its okay?

      And before you think I'm just whining, consider the amount of bandwidth spent discussing this specific evil.

      --
      I currently have no clever signature witicism to add here.
  17. Re:Sure go ahead by Loki_1929 · · Score: 4, Funny

    I'm sorry, could you repeat that? I was busy reading my Visa info over the phone to Jack Valenti to reserve the DVD and the special edition DVD set.

    --
    -- "Government is the great fiction through which everybody endeavors to live at the expense of everybody else."
  18. Re:Why? by fidget42 · · Score: 3, Informative

    The official reason is the extra production time it takes to edit the extended release. I'm not sure what an extra three months would really buy them, but that's the official line.

    --
    The dogcow says "Moof!"
  19. The smart move by WIAKywbfatw · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Amen to that. The smart move here is to wait until after all three movies have been out on DVD for about a year and then buy the "ultimate, super-duper, this-is-the-one-that-you-really-want" box set that contains all three extended additions and tons of extras.

    If you really need to see them on DVD before then either borrow a friend's copies or rent them out.

    Anything less will only lead to disappointment, in the next life if not this one.

    --

    "Accept that some days you are the pigeon, and some days you are the statue." - David Brent, Wernham Hogg
    1. Re:The smart move by KikassAssassin · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Actually, I'm planning on buying both versions of the DVD, because I'm sure none of my friends are going to let me keep borrowing their copy to let me watch it 30 times before the extended DVD comes out. Renting is out of the question, because the cost of renting a movie that many times would be rediculous.

      Sure, if you're only planning on watching it one or two times, renting might be a better plan, but I'm already having withdrawls since the movie left the theaters in my area a month or so ago.

    2. Re:The smart move by FroMan · · Score: 2, Funny

      There's a book you might want to read... I hear the graphics are pretty good and it follows the original storyline. :-P

      Seriously, I can see watching a movie a couple times, even buying a movie if its really good. But watching it 30 times in a 6 month period? No, there are some issues with that. You realize that it 5 times a month, which is more than once a week on average. You need some help.

      --
      Norris/Palin 2012
      Fact: We deserve leaders who can kick your ass and field dress your carcass.
  20. In other news by djupedal · · Score: 4, Funny

    Mark these dates on your Calendar: 4/28/03 & 8/11/03. These are the (China) DVD release dates for The Two Towers. Get in line now...(and wear that mask, dammit).

  21. Comment removed by account_deleted · · Score: 3, Informative

    Comment removed based on user account deletion

  22. Gonna start a piracy thread! by sludg-o · · Score: 3, Funny

    Another one ring.net page has more details on the actual footage.

    I bet KaZaA has more than just the details

  23. Herein lies the problem by Galvatron · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I KNEW this was going to happen. With so many people getting burned on special editions, people won't buy the original releases anymore. Now, the studios are practically obligated to make special editions, which further reinforces people's avoidance of the standard edition. I honestly think the DVD market is permanently fucked up by this, I can't see any way that the studios can reverse the assumption that all movies that were at least decent will have special editions, so there's no point in buying it when it's first released. I'm sure it was a tremendous moneymaker when they started, but now Hollywood's shortsighted greed has obligated them to waste money printing a non-special edition that no one wants, and filming special filler, just so that people will believe them when they release the real version.

    --
    "The question of whether a computer can think is no more interesting than that of whether a submarine can swim" -EWD
    1. Re:Herein lies the problem by MtViewGuy · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I think you have to understand why we're getting two different releases of each LoTR film on DVD.

      The first edition is the version we originally saw in the theaters, the version that is likely to be a big hit in the rental market (Blockbuster, Hollywood Video, etc.). The second edition is the long edition movie on two discs with added scenes, Dolby Digital and DTS soundtracks, multiple track commentaries and two-disc Supplementary material set intended for the serious videophile and serious movie fan. For historical reasons, I think it's actually better to have both editions available.

    2. Re:Herein lies the problem by beowulfcluster · · Score: 2, Insightful

      At least the LOTR people are upfront with it and tell everyone there will be a special one later. They did this with the first one as well, in case someone doesn't know. They were nice enough not to piss people off by first releasing the normal one and then announce the special one two months later when the fans had already bought the first one. I guess when you have a movie that'll make one "billion" dollars either way, you can afford to be nice (but it still isn't the norm in movieland so props to them for that).

    3. Re:Herein lies the problem by CrayzyJ · · Score: 2, Funny

      Some people *cough*me, have wives that attempted to do a good thing and buy the DVD when it first came out because they did not realize there was an extended edition.

      Therefore, some people *cough*me have both.

      In other news, FoTR standard edition for sale!

      --
      Holy s-, it's Jesus!
  24. Got a point here... by I-R-Baboon · · Score: 2, Funny

    For all the recent flames on the MPAA and all the other assorted horrors who is really willing to levy the boycott and make a statement that will be heard, and who is ready to just burn the pir8 as soon as it hits the file sharing methods not even known to the appointed greedy enemy? There is more drooling over this than at the mention of Leornard Nimoy's name at a Star Trek convention.

    And to boot a /. moderator mods this parent post DOWN because it rings a bit of truth and echoes hypocrisy in the ears of the modder. Somebody please mod the parent back up!!!

    *Burnin the midnight Karma for a good point*
    -1 Overrated
    -1 Flamebait
    -1 Troll
    -1 Not a sheep
    -1 Not brainwashed
    -1 Independant thinker
    +1 Smells good

    --
    -1 Overrated (Too many big words for me to comprehend)
  25. For Your Consideration by D+iz+a+n+k+Meister · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I was in the Philippines over the New Year and I came across a very nice Muslim women who sold me an awards screener for The Two Towers on DVD for $2 US. I have seen the movie in the theater(obviously) so I can attest to the screener's validity and quality. Basically a pretty dope find, and the whole movie is on exactly 1 DVD(huge plus IMHO).

    I also bought all 3 Indiana Jones movies and the first 3 Star Wars captured from Laser Disc on DVD. Total cost: $14 US. Arrrr Matey!!!

    --

    He painted a unicorn in outer space. I'm askin' ya, what's it breathin'?
  26. Re:Why? by Overly+Critical+Guy · · Score: 2, Informative

    They're still doing the effects shots and putting it together.

    Plus they're kind of busy with another movie due out in December at the moment. Slows them down.

    --
    "Sufferin' succotash."
  27. Mmmmmm Special Edition DVD's by OneArmedMan · · Score: 2, Funny

    Wantsssss... M. Mm. My Preciousssssss

  28. The Two Towers - Purist Edit by tangent3 · · Score: 5, Informative

    For those who are interested, there is a "Purist Edit" of The Two Towers floating around the Edonkey network. The quality isn't that great, being a rip of a rip squeezing 2 hours and 15 mins into 1 CD.

    The purpose of the edit is to make the movie follow more closely to the original books. It's amazing the work the editor has done by selectively removing scenes and rearranging them - without messing up the sound synchronisation. Now there are no longer any elves in Helm's Deep, Faramir is a good guy again, and the ents aren't idiots anymore.

    Here's the ed2k link:
    ed2k://|file|Lord_of_the_Rings-The_Two_Towe rs-The_ Purist_Edit.avi|729462784|ec0671172619e490d7b0ea6b 5278468c|/

    More information in the sharereactor forums.

    1. Re:The Two Towers - Purist Edit by rizzo · · Score: 2, Informative

      That must be some edit if he can also put Eomer in Helm's Deep the whole time (Eomer was never "banished") and have Erkenbrand come to the rescue at the end. And let us not forget the sweet, sweet Huorns. *drool*

      --

      "More organs means more human." - Zim

    2. Re:The Two Towers - Purist Edit by bigmouth_strikes · · Score: 2, Funny

      You, sir, are supporting terrorism!

      --
      Oh, I can't help quoting you because everything that you said rings true
  29. Actually by krelian · · Score: 2, Interesting
    I am realy looking forward to seeing what documentaries they are going to put on this DVD. The first movie had 2 disc's worth of doc's in it and they all were very intresting. The thing is that alot of them were based on general LotR stuff not specifically FoTR and i guess that they would not just repeat the same old doc's.

    I consider the first movie extended edition to be the best DVD release ever made, they really have high standards to repeat on future releases.

  30. Just like last time, I waited and bought neither by cardoso · · Score: 2, Interesting

    When something STARTS obsolete it really pisses me off. If the friggin edition is so special, release it, not a gap-filling money-harvesting disc that WILL be useless in a few months. I like money, I love it, but I know one can make much more money NOT calling people "stupid".

    After a few months, the hype was gone, and with it the desire of buying LOTR. Should they release the special edition at once OR later, but NOT releasing the idea of an special edition side-by-side the normal one, I'd be with it right on my desk...

    Just like Spiderman. Some marketing genious decided to save money, and DON'T make a two-sided DVD, with widescreen and TV formats. Released only the square one, here in Brazil. End of story? I passed the DVD and... KAZAA!!!!

    --

    []'s Carlos Cardoso - Becoming a brazilian ProBlogger, typo by typo
  31. Maybe the extra 48 minutes by jgerman · · Score: 3, Funny

    ... contains the scenes where Gimli kicks everyone's ass for making him comic relief.

    --
    I'm the big fish in the big pond bitch.
  32. LoTR is much-loved by the "techie" crowd by MtViewGuy · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Actually, I think LoTR is a very well-loved book among the regulars on Slashdot because they all admire Peter Jackson's audacity and vision to actually film three movies out of a book (a long-time favorite among Slashdot readers) that everyone else had said could not be turned into theatrical features.

    It also helps that Jackson created almost from scratch a visual-effects team that has done amazing CGI work that rivals anything done by the folks at Lucasfilm.

    It's the reasons I mentioned above that LoTR deserves its own category in Slashdot. =)

  33. Re:Sure go ahead by rizzo · · Score: 2, Funny

    Hell, I'll sleep with Jack Valenti and Hilary Rosen!

    Talk about pigs in a blanket!

    *rimshot*

    Thanks I'll be here all week. Try the veal.

    --

    "More organs means more human." - Zim

  34. Not deleted scenes by barnaclebarnes · · Score: 2, Informative

    Just a note that the extra footage in LOTR is not deleted scenes. They were never meant for the theater release but are made specifically for the DVD release. Peter Jackson has been very upfront about the fact that he thinks DVD's can add an extra dimension to the film and has incorporated this concept from the beginning. /b

    --
    [Please type your sig here.]
  35. Great value by Stickster · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I agree completely. But then, New Line has made a habit of releasing some of the best DVD's available. Cf. David Fincher's Se7en, which also featured four very informative commentary tracks by a number of cast and crew personnel. Admittedly it was not of the scope of LotR, but a fascinating movie nonetheless. That and Fox's special edition of Fincher's Fight Club were pretty much my favorite DVD's as far as fulfilling the promise of "film school in a box." However, New Line's edition of P.T. Anderson's Boogie Nights is another great one. Basically, no one has done DVD as consistently well as New Line -- with the possible exception of Criterion.

  36. Air Headed Actors? by tid242 · · Score: 4, Informative
    but if you want interviews with air-headed actors, just watch the late shows.

    Not all actors are airheads, i saw THIS interview on the Charlie Rose show (PBS) on December 3rd with Viggo wearing a shirt stating "No Blood For Oil"

    Charlie Rose: You're obviously making a political statement with your T-shirt.

    Viggo Mortensen: I wouldn't normally, but it's sort of a reaction to... I've heard a lot of people say to me and I've read in a lot of places about the first movie, and increasingly about the second one... I've seen where people try to relate it to current situation--specifically the United States and their role in the world right now. And I -- if you're going to compare them, then you should get it right--I don't like hearing... I mean I play the character who's defending Helms Deep and I don't think that The Two Towers or Tolkien's writing or Peter's work or our work has anything to do with the United States' foreign ventures at this time. And it upsets me to hear that in a way. And it upsets me even more that questioning what's going on right now, what the United States is doing, is considered treasonous really: "How dare you say that? How un-American of you." And really, this country is founded on the principle that if the government isn't serving the people you at least have the right to say, "Wait a minute. What's going on?" And there're no questions really being asked, at large, about what we're doing. Whereas in The Two Towers you have different races, nations, cultures coming together and examining their conscience and unifying against a very real and terrifying enemy. What the United States has been doing for the past year is bombing innocent civilians without having come anywhere close to catching Osama bin Laden or any presumed enemy, and, as a distraction, we're now--apparently it's a given--we're hell bent on increasing the bombing that's been going on for the past eleven years in Iraq. And I don't think that the civilians on the ground in those countries look at us in the way that maybe Europeans did at the end of World War II, waving flags in the streets, I think that they see the US government as Saruman.

    Elijah Wood: As a threat.

    VM: Yeah, as a threat. And they're terrified--and have been for a long time--and we are not the good guys, unfortunately, in this case, and ...

    CR: Even though right after 9/11 there was an extraordinary amount of public support for the United States to do something.

    VM: I'm supportive of the United States. I'm an American. And I have nothing against patriotism. But if one is going to compare then the comparison is quite the opposite of what is being made.

    CR: Let me just make sure of the comparison. Because I asked you about the T-shirt at the beginning and you said you made it yourself.

    VM: Yeah.

    CR: The idea... you object to the comparison of this film with respect to American involvement with Iraq or--

    VM: United States government

    CR: --with the Afghanistan war or the war against terrorism--in comparison with the film because of your opposition to American policy.

    VM: And the idea is--in that comparison--is that the United States is like the good guys in our movie against the bad guys in our movie and I think the opposite is true unfortunately.

    CR: We're the bad guys because we responded to--

    VM: You know, the people who are terrified at Helms Deep, who are outnumbered in this incredible violence and desire to control--to destroy--the people of Rohan and the rest of the free peoples of Middle-earth, and to control their wills, to control their infrastructure--or destroy it--that's what we're doing in these countries. That's really what we're doing unfortunately. I'm not saying to anyone, to you, or to you, or to you: "This is what you should believe." I'm just saying, why not ask the question: "Why are we doing this?"

    EW: Sure.

    VM: And I

    --

    With a few exceptions, secrecy is deeply incompatible with democracy and with science. --Carl Sagan

  37. Re:Why? by EvanED · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I can see 3 months helping a lot. They could probably get everything done in time for the first release date if they really tried, but remember that they are also working on Return of the King. Remember, no matter what, the bigger set would take significantly longer to prepare, so no matter what if they were released at the same time they would have been able to get eh 2-disc one out well before. So they figure why not? People who would only get the 2-disc set will be more inclined to get it rather than pirate it, while most people who would get the expanded one would probably wait anyway. And a few of them might buy or rent the 2-disc one in the meantime, which I suspect is probably more of a bonus than a motivation.

    I don't really buy the argument that it is a greed thing; maybe that is involved a little bit, but I don't think it's the major role. Remember, they announced (I think... if not, they will soon) that there is going to be a special edition, and I doubt that they will expect too many people to buy both. (Rent perhaps, but that's about where I think that theory ends.) Meanwhile, I see putting together a DVD like that to be a time-consuming venture.

    (And for any of you who think this is like what Lucas is doing, remember that Lucas released Episode I to VHS under the official line that NO DVDs were to be released until after Episode III, while just a couple months later reports surfaced that he was in fact working on an Episode I DVD, which was announced a couple months later. Had I (and many other fans) known a DVD was in the works, there's no way I owuld have bought the VHS. *That's* sleazy. There's no trace of sleaze in the Lord of the Rings.)

  38. Re:Sure go ahead by pig-of-war · · Score: 2, Funny

    Screw that. I would deliver the Ring of Power to the Dark Lord himself if he promised to give me a copy of the extended version a week before anyone else got it. (Sure, he would cover all the land in a second darkness, but just think how jealous all the other geeks on the block would be.)