Slashdot Mirror


Hacking the XBox

Kong99 writes "Here is a brief interesting read on hacking the XBox at USA Today. They claim an XBox-PC costs a total of $336."

31 of 339 comments (clear)

  1. $336 with a 120GB disk by drinkypoo · · Score: 5, Insightful
    Which is unnecessary and/or overkill for most applications. The 8GB disk will fulfill most users' needs because their media library can be stored on their PC (A more logical place for a large expensive disk than a cheapass little piece of consumer trash - I like my Xbox a lot but I don't think I necessarily trust it.)

    Make that more like $236, with no disk upgrade, which as I mentioned before is unnecessary. Actually, I think it will cost you a little MORE than that, though. It's $30 for a decent modchip, something that's updatable from a CD. You also have to pay shipping on cables to hook up USB, or you have to make cables out of Xbox extension cables and USB extension cables, which probably ain't much cheaper. Also, to get digital audio out of it you have to spend another $20. (That also gets you S-Video, though, it even comes with an S-Video cable to get you started... it's lousy but it works.)

    Then again, you can get an Xbox used for $130. So maybe it's actually not so expensive. Why buy an Xbox with a warranty if you're just going to void it anyway?

    --
    "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
    1. Re:$336 with a 120GB disk by SharpFang · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Why buy an Xbox with a warranty if you're just going to void it anyway? Maybe because if there IS warranty, you may be pretty sure the box is not broken? But in the other hand, you can buy an used Xbox with a warranty that's about-to-expire and get just enough time to test if you should make use of the warranty and take the xbox to service or void it safely...

      --
      45 5F E1 04 22 CA 29 C4 93 3F 95 05 2B 79 2A B2
  2. Re:or... by cscx · · Score: 5, Insightful

    The guy's got a point. Wait till Dell runs a sale and you can score a P-4 2.x GHz machine loaded, for about $450, sans monitor. That's just over $100 more than the X-Box, and look at the difference. Of course, that would make this whole 'Hacking the X-Box' appear to be a worthless waste of time...

    Wait a second...

  3. USA TODAY "research" by Alpha_Nerd · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Just because there's been 150,000 copies donloaded doesn't mean 150,000 XBoxen have been modded. I'm sure there's people who have downloaded it and not installed it(I do that to software often =/)and on the flip side I'm sure there's peopel who DL it and install on multiple. I'd take a guess and say the former is more common than the latter.


    And to the idiot that said XBox games look like Quake 2, well you're just that - an idiot. The XBox is the technically superior system. It also IMO has the best controler - too bad it's games suck =/

  4. Fair Use by InvaderXimian · · Score: 5, Insightful
    I believe all of these should fall into the "fair use" catagory. If Microsoft doesn't interfere with any of this alleged "illegal hacking" projects, they could sell those Xboxes like hot cakes. More people would buy them since they'll have more than one use. Since more people would buy an Xbox to say run Linux on them or what not, they could also use it to play games! That way games will be sold and Microsoft would make money of it since the publishers have to pay a royalts to MS.

    Also, whatever you do to the Xbox should be considered fair use. When you mess with the hardware, all that MS should be able to do is deny you warrany. Car manufacturers already do this. Think of the people that modify their cars and put in turbos and superchargers. If/when their engine craps out, the dealership or whatever doesn't have to cover anything since what you did to your car has voided your warrany.

    My point is MS has no right to take any legal action against any of these "illegal hacking" projects and should just leave them alone. Fair use is fair use.

  5. Re:or... by batkiwi · · Score: 5, Insightful

    About that cheap dell:

    -video out quality isn't as good (nvidia's video out sucks, ati's is good but not as good as xbox)
    -it's louder
    -it's bigger
    -it doesn't fit in with your other home entertainment stuff
    -no optical digital output
    -no rgb output
    -slower boot time

    If you want to spend 5-600$ or so for a loaded shuttle XPC (i got the nforce one) and another 100$ for a scan converter with component output, another 100$ for swank logitech wireless keyboard and optical mouse, then you'll have something worth comparing. This is almost exactly what I have, and it's nice. My only main complaint is the noise of the fan, but I have it hidden under my home entertainment system.

    But saying a cheap system will do the same is naive.

  6. Denying monopoly by TrekkieGod · · Score: 2, Insightful
    How would Microsoft deny having a monopoly if they went this route?

    By replacing the words "lock down" with "trusted computing"

    --

    Warning: Opinions known to be heavily biased.

  7. Because consoles are not about GFX or Online.... by Viewsonic · · Score: 3, Insightful

    It's about FUN GAMES. Period. Something which Nitnendo has been dominating Sony and Microsoft since the early 80s. Nothing has ever sold more than Mario and Zelda. You mention HALO, that's fine.. What else is there? Nothing... Thats why! You can give crap games all the online stuff in the world and they'll still be a crap game. In online gaming on the PC where people are used to playing againts thousands of users, 8-24 player deathmatch is simply lacking, they shouldn't even bother. Just my lame opinion, I know.. But yes, Microsoft is the runt of the three, they have no idea what they're doing, so they've gone the route of "hey, lets make this thing JUST like the computer I own already and see if anyone notices!" ..

  8. Re:Meanwhile, a LEGAL and FUNCTIONAL PC by Twister002 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    and you'll have a point once you are able to run Xbox games natively in Linux.

    Right now, the biggest complaint about Linux is "not enough games" (ok, maybe not the biggest, but one of the reasons that a lot of people are dual-booting). Once you can install Linux on your gaming console (PS2 or Xbox) you remove that reason for dual-booting. Now you've got a functioning Linux PC that you can reboot and use to play games with.

    What's the difference between that and dual-booting? Well for one thing you only have to maintain one OS installation instead of 2.

    --
    "For a successful technology, honesty must take precedence over public relations for nature cannot be fooled." -Feynman
  9. Re:You expect them to compete fairly? by GMontag · · Score: 2, Insightful

    As far as getting spanked for spiking or dumping, that is an international trade issue and is only brought up when the country getting the dumped goods complains/puts up trade barriers.

    I don't really know of anything in the US that prevents having a loss-leader ofr a product line (but there may be something out there).

    Even GM did it with their X-body(?) cars in the 80's. If you bought one "base" it cost you less than it cost them. As soon as you started adding options (including GMAC financing), they started running a profit.

  10. Re:Are MS by caluml · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I thought that - but then I thought: If they're already made, and are sitting on shelves, then they're losing more if they stay on the shelves.

  11. Re:What? by Cliffy03 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Maybe, they are thinking in "media" terms, but this is a hack (in the good sense). Now only if they know the difference.

    --
    In Soviet Russia, Nigel makes plans for you!
  12. Re:or... by aluminumtulips · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Hacking the XBox can hardly be called "a worthless waste of time." Anytime a person has enough curiousity and know-how to crack open the case of a computer/appliance/gadget; ESPECIALLY one manufactured by such a hated company as Microsoft; and tinker around with it to gain a better understanding of the device or to improve/change its function is NOT A WASTE OF TIME. We need more curious minded people if we are ever going to grow as a society. We need to understand the computers and devices that we depend on in the 21st century. Otherwise we be just as better off in the Dark Ages.

  13. you'd think... by dfj225 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    But it does highlight the complexity of Microsoft's struggles to make its products more secure. Because Xbox has so much capability...

    You'd think that MS would embrace this community and use thier advances as a selling point for the X-Box. Maybe they could make software of this type an official release. The whole idea of the media hub seems to be what most companies are moving towards today, so you would think that MS would want software of this type running on its system.

    --
    SIGFAULT
  14. The funny part.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful
    ..is that by buying an Xbox instead of a Mini-ITX PC, you're funding Microsoft. The "MS loses money on every Xbox sold" theory doesn't hold water due to the fact that 1) Thanks to the drop of PC part prices, Microsoft now turns a profit on every Xbox sold, and 2) even if they didn't profit on the hardware (which they, in fact, do), a purchased xbox loses them less money than an unpurchased one does.

    Microsoft thanks you, Linux community!

  15. dont understand.. by segfault_0 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    While it says it will attack hackers on a case-by-case basis, analysts say the company has so far tolerated the Xbox hacking as an unavoidable nuisance.

    Alright, im still having trouble with people selling others hardware products with the intentions of them using it for a specific purpose - and then suddenly its a punishable offense that they are going "attack". What business is it of theirs what I do with my XBox?

    If these machines come with these kinds of restrictions I think we're still getting ripped off at 180$ a box. Im on my way to buy an XBox to modify just for spite. :P

    --

    I was crazy back when being crazy really meant something. (Charles Manson)
  16. Re:Here's a wacked out idea... by demonbug · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Great idea. Lets waste our money so MS might lose some. Of course, considering they have $40 billion odd in cash lying around (at least, I think I remember hearing something like that), we're going to have to buy a hell of a lot of X-boxes. Lets see, something like 400,000,000 of them I think (assuming they lose $100 a console). Somehow I don't think that is going to work.

  17. Re:Meanwhile, a LEGAL and FUNCTIONAL PC by Tenebrious1 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    which runs the Linux OS can be had from wal-mart for >$100 less. I'm sorry, I don't see the appeal of this?

    Not that we haven't gone over this a thousand times on /., but:

    XBox- Great graphics to a TV (which most people already have). Great stereo output.

    WalMart PC- crappy video, crappy sound, cheap components all around. Still need to buy a monitor. Only available through mail order, that's at least $30 shipping (plus tax since Wal-Mart has a physical presence in your state). Doesn't fit in TV console, doesn't look good sitting on top of VCR. Doesn't play DVDs. Doesn't play xbox games. Doesn't play many games at all. Need to get IR mouse/kb or you can't use it from the couch.

    You're probably too young to remember this, but the reasons the Commodore 64 sold so well was it was much cheaper than other computers, but mostly because you could plug it right into the TV. The IBM PCjr selling for $1000 was too expensive for most people, but a C64 and tape drive could be had for $200 (or less!) and plugged right into the TV. That's what introduced millions of us to computers- the fact we didn't need to buy an expensive monitor. And the awesome COLOR graphics, sound, the the sheer number of games available, put the C64 into many homes. Oh, and most retailers were willing to sell the C64 at a loss to get customers in to buy the accessories and games.

    If MS were to market a "game" that consisted of Windows, Word and Excel, with a cheap xbox printer, I think it could create a HUGE market for the xbox, similar what happened with the C64.

    --
    -- If god wanted me to have a sig, he'd have given me a sense of humor.
  18. Oh. You mean like a Mac? by KalvinB · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Seriously. MS comming out with a proprietary PC has nothing to do with being a monopoly.

    Unless they prevent me from building my own systems and running whatever I want on them, there's not an issue.

    I wouldn't be shocked if MS came out with a WindowsPC. If they can put together a good PC at a good price, great for them.

    Ben

  19. I hacked my PS2 to run Linux (: by LoudMusic · · Score: 2, Insightful

    No wait, Sony did that for the community.

    If I had a good reason to hack an XBox I'd do it, but as it stands, it's best for playing video games. It would be fun to buy a bunch of XBoxes, mod them, and continue to screw Microsoft, though. Oh well.

    --
    No sig for you. YOU GET NO SIG!
  20. Re:or... by drinkypoo · · Score: 2, Insightful
    It would appear to be a worthless waste of time if you didn't want to also use it as an Xbox. Even so it isn't really, the portability makes it attractive, as you can treat it like just another home stereo item.

    Also, as I have pointed out elsewhere; If you're going to hack it you need to open it, which invalidates your warranty. You might as well get a used xbox for $130 or refurb for $150; I don't know if those prices have gone down since the Xbox dropped to $180. A used Xbox is at least $50 cheaper than a new one, and if you're not going to use the controller (perhaps even cutting up the cable in order to make your adapter to plug in a USB hub) then you won't care that it's not the newer Controller S, which can save you some money.

    So; You don't need a modchip if you rent that 007 game, you can get a used one; That's $70 off the listed price. You could get a cheaper hard disk, too, or just not bother to get one, and read everything across the network, that will save you $120, for $190 off the $336, which brings us to $146. I bet for $200 you could also get a (crappy but functional) wireless USB-connected keyboard/mouse in there if you found a deal, but let's call it $250 for a decent one. That's a pretty good price on a box like that, which incidentally is STILL an Xbox, which has some value of its own IMO.

    --
    "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
  21. Re:Oh. You mean like a Mac? by kuma · · Score: 2, Insightful

    take your head out of your ass, please.

    if i wanted to, i could easily load four different linux/bsd distro's on an off-the-shelf mac

    what the original post was talking about is:
    how do you use linux, mac os x or solaris on your desktop in a world where every email in your organization (including the ones about brownies in the kitchen) *requires* palladium to read?

    every hard-core tech could be forced to keep a windows computer on their desk (like me) even though their primary development platform is completely different

    and then be forced to justify using the optimal platform for their job because it's not *standard* (and challenges tech support's ciphincter grip on the enterprise desktop environment)

  22. Re:X-Box Troll Handbook by blincoln · · Score: 3, Insightful

    #8 - The only good games for the XBox are out for the other systems,

    No. Steel Battalion is reason enough to own an XBox, and it will never be released for anything else.

    --
    "...always new atoms but always doing the same dance, remembering what the dance was yesterday." -Richard Feynman
  23. Re:The Most Interesting Quote... by Babbster · · Score: 3, Insightful
    "Could" it happen? Sure. Is it going to happen? I don't know and neither does the person quoted. Every argument like this smacks to me of someone who simply wants to justify doing whatever s/he wants to do. It's like people arguing that they download MP3s because CDs are too expensive - if a CD is too expensive to purchase, how does that give you the right to steal it (yes, I use the word "steal" despite all the arguments about copyright being civil law and that copying supposedly isn't the same as stealing).

    That's not to say that I think people shouldn't be able to mod their Xboxen. As long as the person modding isn't pirating software then I myself don't see the big deal. But that quote from the article reads like the kind of paranoid spouting off that we read every day from posters on Slashdot...to those people, EVERYTHING is a "slippery slope."

    The truth is that I think Microsoft wants to "lock down" the Xbox hardware so that people can't play pirated games and not as some sort of diabolical plot that has something to do with Windows, Office and the Illuminati. I consider their stance on this matter reasonable (though maybe not defensible) considering that any money they make from the Xbox comes from software licensing.

  24. Surprising by bedouin · · Score: 3, Insightful

    . . . that /.'ers who are generally opposed to M$'s monopolistic business tactics rush to buy Xboxes. I know the usual arguments is "M$ loses money for each one sold," but it seems people are actually buying games for their systems too.

    I'm guessing you enjoy M$ dominating yet another industry?

  25. Not quite by LinuxGeek · · Score: 2, Insightful

    The XBOX is a DRM (digital rights management) PC type system, not a standard boot-any-x86-OS PC. Hacking on this hardware is nothing like hacking on standard x86 stuff.

    I think you meant to say that hacking the XBOX is a waste of your time. Also, the XBOX won't have a killer app. Apps are traditional applications and the XBOX runs games. As long as MS wants to sell these things cheaper than the cost of manufacture, people will want to buy it to potentially replace low end PCs, can't say I blame them.

    I bet MS appreciates your attempt to slow the hacking of the XBOX, however little it may help.

    --

    Kindness is the language which the deaf can hear and the blind can see. - Mark Twain
  26. Opportuinity by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    Im a business major so this is my train of thought: Why not give the people what they want, market the xbox as a cheap little computer entertainment center.

    MAking a few changes to the system cant be much of an effort if every joe smith out there is doing it in their living room. Maybe they could retool the unit or something...I dont really feel like reading up on the literature (if you can call it that) but maybe they could sell an Xbox makeover package (in addition to that stupid DVD remote that you have to pay 30$ for if you want to watch movies) that does the same things all those websites instruct you to do.

    Take a disadvantage and turn it in your favor.

  27. Re:Why teh X-Box sucks by Entropy_ah · · Score: 2, Insightful

    It single handedly proved FPSes can be great on a console.
    no, goldeneye 007 for the n64 proved that. ask any college student

    --
    my other penis is a vagina
  28. Re:XBox hackers are wasting everyone's time. by cscx · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I respect the "because it's there" mentality of getting Linux to run on anything

    Unfortunately I don't think the 'because it's there' thought process will get anyone very far. At some point someone needs to realize that their time is worth more than needlessly wasting it on disassembling something with no value to them in the future whatsoever. I could take my television apart because I can as well; however outside of "WHOO HOO I TOOK APART MY TV!!! I AM SO SMART!" there is no socially redeeming value whatsoever. Just think what ELSE you could be doning with your time.

    I think much of this X-Box shite has to do with the "sticking it to the man" beef that everyone around here seems to have with Microsoft. But seriously, they are not taking a cut anymore, I can pretty much assure you of that. Sure people could run Linux on their toaster if they really wanted to, but there is no socially redeeming value to doing that either.

  29. Tired of people that do not know arithmetic by jotaeleemeese · · Score: 2, Insightful

    If you don't buy anything related to the Xbos MS earns 0, nada, zilch, nil.

    If you buy only the Xbox they are recouping 140 or wahtever dollars. Do the maths wise one.

    Now, don't be stupid. This argument is the most idiotic one in the history of /.

    If you want to hurt MS don't buy their products. If you want to hurt them even more, don't use their products at all (i.e. don't buy second hand, don't pirate stuff you criminal, drop their stuff as fast as you can).

    I try to avoid people with shoddy legal and ethical records when making business. MS is no different on this respect.

    --
    IANAL but write like a drunk one.
  30. Re:Did ya get the memo? by cygnus · · Score: 2, Insightful
    Why would they want that? They make money from Live subscriptions and game sales. People who mod their XBox are unlikely to purchase either.
    people who buy xboxes for hacking are infinitely more likely to buy games (or xbox live) than someone who never bought an xbox at all.
    --
    Just raise the taxes on crack.