Slashdot Mirror


Scientists Clone Horse

The Night Watchman writes "Italian scientists have produced the world's first horse clone, according to Yahoo News. Racing is likely to become slightly more interesting in the coming years..."

79 comments

  1. Would you call it... by macdaddy357 · · Score: 1, Funny

    ... A clony pony?

    --
    How ya like dat?
    1. Re:Would you call it... by daeley · · Score: 4, Funny

      No, it's "My Little Clony"

      --
      I watched C-beams glitter in the dark near the Tannhauser gate.
    2. Re:Would you call it... by L.+VeGas · · Score: 1

      Spare mare?

    3. Re:Would you call it... by daeley · · Score: 1

      Spare mare?

      Fauxl

      --
      I watched C-beams glitter in the dark near the Tannhauser gate.
    4. Re:Would you call it... by GrimSean · · Score: 1
      Don't you know?

      A Horse is a Horse, of course, of course!

      --
      I don't need to be made to look evil. I can do that on my own. - Christopher Walken
  2. Racing likely to become more interesting? by James+A.+A.+Joyce · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I don't think that cloning will make much difference to current methods of selective breeding; after all, selective breeding works just fine as it is, and I don't think that horses can really be "improved" any further without some large anomalistic genetic change in a large proportion of the species.

    1. Re:Racing likely to become more interesting? by Dr.Dubious+DDQ · · Score: 1

      In addition to the strict breeding requirements, there's also the fact that race horses seem to have pretty much reached their "design limits", so to speak. WIthout some sort of fairly substantial change (which would render the horse no-longer-conformant to strict race-horse specifications that horse racing organizations use) to the horse's physiology, I doubt anyone could really get anything any better than what already exists...

      It does make me wonder, though - you couldn't race a cloned horse according to the existing rules, but could you 'naturally' produce a foal from cloned horses that WOULD be eligible to race?...

    2. Re:Racing likely to become more interesting? by Benm78 · · Score: 1
      Its logical to assume this is permitted:

      - The rule quoted above, doesnt seem to question the origin of the horses you breed, just their specifications - and HOW they must reproduce

      - Genetically, cloning a male animal and then using the clone to reproduce in a natural way, is identical to having the original reproduce in the same way

      If you were to clone a female animal, and reproduce using the clone, there would be a genetic difference. The offspring would then have:
      - one strand of DNA from its father
      - one strand of DNA from its mother, equal to the 'original'
      - mitochondrial DNA from its mother, different from the 'original' female

      Since metabolism (partially encoded in the mitochondria) is probably an important factor in racing horses, one could devise a way to create superior animals trough this route. This would require great analytical effort though.

    3. Re:Racing likely to become more interesting? by John+Hasler · · Score: 1

      > which would render the horse
      > no-longer-conformant to strict race-horse
      > specifications that horse racing organizations
      > use

      There are no such specifications.

      > It does make me wonder, though - you couldn't race
      > a cloned horse according to the existing rules,
      > but could you 'naturally' produce a foal from
      > cloned horses that WOULD be eligible to race?...

      No. The Jockey Club will only register the offspring of horses registered with them and they will not register a cloned horse.

      --
      Warning: this article may contain humor, sarcasm, parody, and perhaps even irony. Read at your own risk.
  3. SeaBiscuit 2 by Tumbleweed · · Score: 4, Funny

    ccBiscuit (carbon copy)

    Either that or a glitch in the Matrix...they've changed something...oh yeah, the new Apple license!

  4. Or less interesting... by nortcele · · Score: 5, Funny

    Gate1: Sea Biscuit Odds 1/1
    Gate2: Sea Biscuit Odds 1/1
    Gate3: Sea Biscuit Odds 1/1
    Gate4: Sea Biscuit Odds 1/1
    etc...

    1. Re:Or less interesting... by ArmorFiend · · Score: 1

      Um, coming from Kentucky, I have to say you picked the wrong horse:

      Gate1: Secratariat
      Gate2: Secratariat
      Gate3: Secratariat
      Gate4: Secratariat
      etc...

  5. Jeez... by IpsissimusMarr · · Score: 2, Funny

    Out of a total of 841 reconstructed embryos, only 22 developed to advanced embryos within about a week. Seventeen of those were introduced into nine mares, resulting in four pregnancies, but only one, Prometea, developed to full term.

    Jeez... if you really want that genetically enhanced captain of the football team genius scientist Richard Gere looking son you better start soon!

    --
    "Engineers do the work of man, Physicists do the work of God"
  6. The steed of choice for the by lightspawn · · Score: 4, Funny

    Clone Ranger.

  7. No, no, I've got it.. by L.+VeGas · · Score: 2, Funny

    They did it to make a...

    Battalion of Italian Stallions

    har har har *hiccup*

  8. a clone of a horse is a horse, of course,of course by Tumbleweed · · Score: 3, Funny

    And no one can talk to a clone of a horse of course
    That is, of course, unless the clone of the horse is a clone of the famous Mister Ed!

    "She's the clone!"
    "No, _she's_ the clone!"

  9. Current limitations of cloning by neglige · · Score: 1

    According to the New Scientist, cloned mammals suffer from some genetic defects. This would open new possibilites for betting: how many races can the horse run - or which clone dies in this race.

    I'm not sure if this is a good thing (TM)...

    --
    My cats ate my karma. They also wrote this comment.
    1. Re: Current limitations of cloning by pkhuong · · Score: 1

      Yup, you can't clone mammals all that well. Each cell's genetic code is imprinted (the DNA is chemically modified with -NH3+ molecules, iirc, so it can't be read) so that it's not the same as the original embryonic cells.

      The clone would be different from the original :D

      --
      Try Corewar @ www.koth.org - rec.games.corewar
  10. Horse Racing doesn't allow AI by dfinster · · Score: 3, Informative

    Thoroughbred's don't even allow artificial insemination (AI) much less embryo transplant, they are strictly live-cover only.

    In other breeds/diciplines it's fine. I'm not a breeding expert, but my wife and I own a stallion and we've shipped semen a few times to mare owners. A friend of ours runs a large operation this ships frozen and cooled equine semen. It's pretty interesting, actually. The technology is pretty advanced, and the recordkeeping / auditing requirements when dealing with million-dollar horses is staggering.

    1. Re:Horse Racing doesn't allow AI by RevAaron · · Score: 1

      The technology is pretty advanced, and the recordkeeping / auditing requirements when dealing with million-dollar horses is staggering.

      If you think that is staggering, you should check out the breeding records and projections of the Bene Gesserit. You could see a Muad'dib from a mile away!

      --

      Working toward a usable PDA environment in the spirit of Newton OS: Dynapad
    2. Re:Horse Racing doesn't allow AI by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Blowing the load is like extracting liquid gold!

    3. Re:Horse Racing doesn't allow AI by tommck · · Score: 1
      Horse Racing doesn't allow AI

      Good for them! It was a crappy movie anyway!

      --
      ---- It puts the lotion on its skin or else it gets the hose again. It does this whenever it's told.
    4. Re:Horse Racing doesn't allow AI by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I think I'm asking the question that we all want to know, did you or your wife jack off the horse?

    5. Re:Horse Racing doesn't allow AI by ckaminski · · Score: 1

      So does that make you a stallion fluffer?

      Reminds me of this conversation I started at a party once about bull-fluffers... what's even more amazing than the 12 people who participated, and the poor Domino's Pizza guy we scared the crap out of, is the fact we got 15 minutes of hang-time out of that gag...

      <shudder>

      Yah... that's a story I want to tell the grand-kids...

    6. Re:Horse Racing doesn't allow AI by dfinster · · Score: 1

      I'm sorry, I forgot I was posting this to Slashdot, I thought you guys could handle it.

      The answer to your question is that we pay a large animal vet to do the collection. Actually the mare owner pays, but that's not really important.

      I'm sure a google search would satisfy you perverts, but here's a direct link for your private pleasure.

  11. From the article by secolactico · · Score: 3, Informative

    "The most obvious use is to give a sterile animal or animals that die or can't breed because of some disease a chance to reproduce," Galli said.


    Thus doing away with that pesky natural selection. Not that that's a bad thing... ;-)

    --
    No sig
    1. Re:From the article by WoTG · · Score: 1

      This made me think about mules, which as we all should know, are infertile. Suppose you happened to get a super big strong and fast mule... I would probably think that cloning it would be a good idea. Then again, what do I know - do mules actually do anything that horses or donkeys can't?

    2. Re:From the article by secolactico · · Score: 1

      do mules actually do anything that horses or donkeys can't?

      I'm no zoologist, but I think they are sturdier than a donkey and more surefooted than a horse.

      --
      No sig
  12. Picture of the "mother" and clone here by danaedwards · · Score: 1
  13. Re:Now only if.. by I8TheWorm · · Score: 1

    Wow! Don't sugar coat it, tell us how you really feel...

    --
    Saying Android is a family of phones is akin to saying Linux is a family of PCs.
  14. Better? Doubtful by menscher · · Score: 1

    Breeding allows us to enhance the "good" genes while getting rid of the "bad" ones. Cloning doesn't allow for improvement. So until they start messing with genetic modifications (which will probably lead to a lot of screwed-up horses), I doubt clones are going to be winning many races.

  15. Yes, but.. by poity · · Score: 4, Funny

    have they isolated the genes that will make me hung like one?

    --
    your thin skin doesn't make me a troll
    1. Re:Yes, but.. by {8_8} · · Score: 1

      Yes, and there are a number of companies out there who want to sell you their penis-enlarging product. In fact, they keep sending me emails saying that my (nonexistent) relationship with my (nonexistent) wife and/or special person will be deepened and/or enriched if I use their product to enhance my (apparently so small it's nonexistent) penis.

  16. Re:Better? Doubtful by Raghead · · Score: 1

    But, it would be useful in the case of a gelding, for example, who turned out to be a good race horse after all. The genes are the same, so you could breed the clone.

  17. Washington Post version by $exyNerdie · · Score: 1
  18. If you wire the clones by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    you could make a Beowulf cluster of horses!

    1. Re:If you wire the clones by Tumbleweed · · Score: 1

      > a Beowulf cluster of horses!

      Wouldn't that just be a 'herd'?

      The only horse worth cloning, IMO, is the 1966 Ford Mustang Fastback. A black one.

    2. Re:If you wire the clones by G-funk · · Score: 1

      More importantly, do we have -

      A flock of birds
      A pod of whales
      A murder of crowes
      And a beowulf of computers?

      --
      Send lawyers, guns, and money!
  19. Re:Now only if.. by Reducer2001 · · Score: 1

    You seem to be ignoring the fact that France helped us out at point as well. It was called the Revolutionary War, without which we wouldn't even be here. Please don't be selective when quoting history.

    --
    When you get to hell -- tell 'em Itchy sent ya!
  20. Dolly and Arthritus by aplank · · Score: 1, Insightful

    I wonder how long this horse will live. Dolly didnt live very long because she had stunted telomeres and I am pretty sure that this horse's telomeres are stunted also.

  21. You all have no idea.... by wowbagger · · Score: 3, Funny

    You all have no idea how important this is!

    Don't you see - now, after we have beaten any given dead horse (e.g. Microsoft is evil, X is slow, ??AA sucks) into a slurry, we can salvage its DNA, clone it, raise the clone to maturity, kill it, and continue to beat it some more!

    This invention has singlehandedly saved the Internet!

    1. Re:You all have no idea.... by Strange+Ranger · · Score: 1

      So now we can ask...

      how many times will this story be cloned on Slashdot?

      --

      Operator, give me the number for 911!
  22. We can... by funwithBSD · · Score: 1

    but being a nerd, all you would do with it is piss on your shoes.

    --
    Never answer an anonymous letter. - Yogi Berra
    1. Re:We can... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      If I was hung like that I know what I'd do. Who needs a women if you can service yourself?

  23. a horse... by danratherfan · · Score: 1

    a horse is a horse of course of course
    and no one can talk to a horse of course
    That is of course, unless the horse
    is a clone of a horse with human genes spliced in

  24. Neigh! by NanoGator · · Score: 2, Funny

    Sadly, Wired magazine had a sharp drop in sales in the month of July when customers confused the cover featuring the cloned horse for Janet Reno.

    --
    "Derp de derp."
  25. Re:Now only if.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ..and they've not done shit for anyone (except themselves) since.

    Now whose being selective?

  26. Re:Better? Doubtful by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    I doubt these clones will ever run in a real race. I guess you didn't see this comment.

    --
    me

  27. Re:a clone of a horse is a horse, of course,of cou by devphil · · Score: 0, Redundant


    A horse is a horse, of course, of course.
    A Jedi horse, he uses the Force.
    His favorite code to use is Morse.
    He's the famous Mister Ed!

    From goats.com, one of the funniest comic strips on the web. (Hint: read the "kittens = poptarts" series from their archives.)

    --
    You cannot apply a technological solution to a sociological problem. (Edwards' Law)
  28. From a working horse owner's perspective by RobertB-DC · · Score: 4, Insightful
    I can't claim to have real "working" horses -- we're not on the King Ranch riding a hundred miles of fence on horseback. We've got a couple of horses (with more on the way) that we've selected for their smarts and endurance. They're Appaloosas, but the pretty patterns are strictly a nice feature, not a design requirement.

    So this statement really irritates me:
    [Texas A&M research veterinarian Katrin] Hinrichs is awaiting the birth of a cloned American quarter horse -- a copy of Hinrichs' 9-year-old daughter's show horse -- in mid-November. She believes cloning's most obvious use in the horse industry would be cloning such show horses.
    Unfortunately, this researcher is probably right on the money, literally. There is huge money in show horses, just like there is in purebred show dogs. The problem is how selective breeding -- in both cases -- has resulted in an animal that is useless for any real purpose.

    Appaloosas get bred for particular patterns of spots, Quarter Horses get bred for very specific ratios of body parts, Arabians are bred to hold themselves "just so"... you get the picture. Thoroughbreds, bred for speed, may be the only horses that are commercially bred for something that is even remotely "natural" to a horse's instincts -- and even they are broken down and "retired" at an age when a working horse is just getting started.

    What you see, way too often, is a horse that looks pretty, but is completely screwed up in the head. And that's with traditional breeding (and I'm including the straw o'semen in the "traditional" category). I can only imagine the neurotic, unpredictable horses that will come from cloning the "best" show horses. They'll be useless for any actual work, probably won't be able to reproduce without assistance (already a problem today), and will be a danger to their rider and anyone nearby.

    Give me a field-bred "grade" horse over a "show" horse any day. It's like our dogs -- we have two mixed-breed puppies (half Jack Russell) that are sharp as a tack. The big black dog that got dumped as a puppy is the loyal protector of the household. And the $700 Schnauzer is the stupidest creature on the face of God's green earth. Show dog? No thanks, I'll take the mutt in the corner.
    --
    Stressed? Me? Of course not. Stress is what a rubber band feels before it breaks, silly.
    1. Re:From a working horse owner's perspective by Zarquon · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Well, while that seems to be excluding many of the draft breeds, arguably they are being enhanced for function. Horses have 4 mainstream uses at the moment:
      1) Racing.
      2) Showing/Jumping/et al.
      3) Herding/farm work.
      4) Pleasure riding.

      I'm on the eastern seaboard, so I almost swapped #3 and #4.

      As for horses not right in the head, the worst ones I've encountered have _always_ been thoroughbreds off the track. Not that the others are all brilliant, but the thoroughbreds were almost exclusively ditzey.

      The one thing that don't mention about this process, is while it may conserve genetic material, there is also a lot of environmental impact in a horse's development. A clone of a horse will look the same, but probably won't behave or perform the same way.

      --
      "'Tis great confidence in a friend to tell him your faults, greater to tell him his." --Poor Richard's Almanac
    2. Re:From a working horse owner's perspective by Quill_28 · · Score: 1

      very common in dogs.

      For instance, Irish Setters are beautiful but the brains have been breed out of them.

      Golden Retrievers have big time hip problems.

      Cocker Spaniels have ear problems.

      The list goes on where beauty has overcome function.

      Whereas border collies are sharp as tacks because the are breed for working/brains. Not too many people care what they look like.

    3. Re:From a working horse owner's perspective by ckaminski · · Score: 1

      Except my parent's Irish Setter. With 3 legs and a penchant for scratching me whenever she sees me, I can't understand how she can balance on two legs... but she's got my parent's wrapped around her little paws. Whipped I say. That, and she's the first dog in the entire bunch, 4 purebreds and 3 mongrels, to detect strange people at 100 yards instantly.

      There is lots of variation in purebred dogs. The worst part is that many breeds, like my Gordon Setters, bring lots of genetic defects with them (hip dysplasia and the like).

      I find that the vast majority of a dog's personality comes from it's owner. An owner who brooks no shit and gives them appropriate space, you usually get smart dogs. Keep them inside all day, or don't give them any attention, or tie pretty bows in their hair, and you get a complete ditz (like my sisters spaniel). ugh. I'll take my four setters (2 gordons, irish and english) over your border collie any day. :-)

    4. Re:From a working horse owner's perspective by Lord_Dweomer · · Score: 1
      "What you see, way too often, is a horse that looks pretty, but is completely screwed up in the head."

      And how is this different from women?

      --
      Buy Steampunk Clothing Online!
    5. Re:From a working horse owner's perspective by srmalloy · · Score: 1
      What you see, way too often, is a horse that looks pretty, but is completely screwed up in the head. And that's with traditional breeding (and I'm including the straw o'semen in the "traditional" category). I can only imagine the neurotic, unpredictable horses that will come from cloning the "best" show horses. They'll be useless for any actual work, probably won't be able to reproduce without assistance (already a problem today), and will be a danger to their rider and anyone nearby.

      Some years ago, Scientific American had an article on the genetics of race horses. The thoroughbred racehorse has the best kept pedigree records of any form of livestock. The original founding stock was a mere 3 stallions and 40 mares; all racehorses alive today are descendants of those 43 horses, and every racehorse can have its pedigree traced back to the origin of the breed. Every racehorse is distantly or closely related to every other racehorse in the world. Racehorses must pass a "survival of the fittest" test, The Racecourse Test, and only the best horses are used for producing the next generation. If an expensive stallion proves to be a producer of poor stock, then he is banished from further breeding activity, despite his initial value; he is removed permanently from the breeding stock. Stallions of poor fertility are not persevered with, since they produce few offspring, and mare owners prefer to breed foals. Male thoroughbreds have a strong sex-drive and because of this, at least 90% of males are permanently excluded from procreating by castration. There are very few "genetic ailments" within the thoroughbred population, and weaklings are ruthlessly culled. One of the first use of cloning in racehorses is going to be its use to recover the genetic heritage of a gelding that proves to be a champion in its own right -- but only until that use demonstrates whether it's an effective way to recover the genetic line.
  29. Racing will not become more interesting? by TamMan2000 · · Score: 1
    Cloned horses wouldn't be allowed to race...

    D. To be eligible for registration, a foal must be the result of a stallion's Breeding with a broodmare (which is the physical mounting of a broodmare by a stallion with intromission of the penis and ejaculation of semen into the reproductive tract).


    Taken from this site.

    Also, NPR had a cool story a couple of months ago about the actual process that they go through when trying to breed thoroughbreds. All I can say is that I really felt sorry for the 'teaser stallions'...
    --
    "I'll have a Guinness, no wait, make that a Coors Light" -Grad student I work with, who shall remain anonymous...
  30. Re:Catherine the Great by FannyMinstrel · · Score: 1, Informative

    Why would she have loved this, when it's a LIE

  31. Re:Now only if.. by Reducer2001 · · Score: 1

    Here's something recent:

    http://www.iht.com/articles/96431.html

    Check it out.

    --
    When you get to hell -- tell 'em Itchy sent ya!
  32. Dolly COD & Telemere lengths by morcheeba · · Score: 1

    Nope, Dolly was put down when her viral infection got too bad. This type of infection is not unusual to find in sheep that live indoors, as Dolly did.

    True, dolly had short telomeres. But what's far more interesting is that cloned cattle don't have shortened telomeres ... I wonder how this horse's telomere will turn out.

  33. Why do we need this? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Isn't one Julia Roberts enough?

  34. Hybrid Vigour (or Mongrel Power) by quinkin · · Score: 1
    You rightly point out several of the fallacies in this current cloning debate.

    Unfortunately you also highlight why it will continue. Not so we can see Pharlap II race, not for laudable if debatable medical purposes, but so that rich fools with nothing better to waste their money on can attempt (and fail) to "recreate" their dear old Schmookie/Fido/Kujo...

    History does repeat, but not that literally. Hrm, an exact clone of my old pet that looks different, acts different and has a reduced life span...

    I'm a mongrel, all my pets are mongrels, and my wife and kids are all mongrels too. I'm a great believer in hybrid vigour and diversity - they are our greatest strengths - and in the long run, they are our best shot at survival.

    Let us not fall into this intellectual trap, and let sleeping dogs lie.

    Q.

    --
    Insert Signature Here
  35. Why? by Transcendent · · Score: 1

    The most obvious use is to give a sterile animal or animals that die or can't breed because of some disease a chance to reproduce


    And WHY do we want to do that? Are there morals that tell us to give every animal a chance to reproduce, or do we just like seeing weak and ill-prone beings reproduce and take a sh*t in the genetic pool?

    1. Re:Why? by schroddinger · · Score: 1

      hmm, not every circumstance in which an animal has acquired a disease may be due to natural causes, and many of the reasons that we now find animals becoming extinct has alot to do with humans exercising their right of "survival of the fittest." If it was true that when humans burn down a forest and any animals that don't survive have only been filtered out of the gene pool, then your argument would seem to make sense. But that's just not the case. This isn't us screwing up the gene pool, it's an attempt to fix it.

    2. Re:Why? by Transcendent · · Score: 1

      This isn't us screwing up the gene pool, it's an attempt to fix it

      By letting animals that naturally shouldn't have offspring... breed? Sounds like a good idea to me, since mother nature WANTED them to breed...

    3. Re:Why? by schroddinger · · Score: 1

      It's not about what mother nature wants or doesnt want. It's about preserving something that is about to be destroyed.

    4. Re:Why? by Transcendent · · Score: 1

      It's not about what mother nature wants or doesnt want. It's about preserving something that is about to be destroyed.

      Not everything is meant to be preserved... especially when it comes to horses. They have plenty, why bother with the sickley ones? There's no point in putting embryos in them.

  36. interesting? by misterpies · · Score: 1


    racing will likely become more interesting

    How will it be more interesting when all the horses are identical?

    --
    The author of this post asserts his moral rights.
  37. Give birth to your own clone by tsa · · Score: 1

    The mother horse gave birth to her own clone. That's somewhat like this plant I have that keeps making copies of itself. And even weirder: it's like giving birth to your own identical twin! Scary! I'm glad that I'm a man...

    --

    -- Cheers!

  38. MOD PARENT DOWN! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    That has to be the most disturbing picture I've ever seen on the Internet.

  39. Re:a clone of a horse is a horse, of course,of cou by ckaminski · · Score: 1

    Who was actually a zebra.

    http://www.snopes.com/lost/mistered.asp

  40. you'll see by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    An engineer, a mathematician, and a physicist went to the races one Saturday and laid their money down. Commiserating in the bar after the race, the engineer says, "I don't understand why I lost all my money. I measured all the horses and calculated their strength and mechanical advantage and figured out how fast they could run..."

    The physicist interrupted him: "...but you didn't take individual variations into account. I did a statistical analysis of their previous performances and bet on the horses with the highest probability of winning..."

    "...so if you're so hot why are you broke?" asked the engineer. But before the argument can grow, the mathematician takes out his pipe and they get a glimpse of his well-fattened wallet. Obviously here was a man who knows something about horses. They both demanded to know his secret.

    "Well," he says, between puffs on the pipe, "first I assumed all the horses were identical and spherical..."

  41. Clone SCO execs by ratfynk · · Score: 1

    Darryl and the whole works, if they have cloned a horse there is no reason why they cannot clone a certain part of the horse.

    --
    OH THE SHAME I fell off the wagon and use sigs again!