Slashdot Mirror


CWRU Opens Largest Wi-Fi Net

server1 writes "In what could be the largest public wireless service in the world, Case Western Reserve University is opening more than 1,230 Cisco Aironet 1200 Series wireless access points on September 1, providing free Internet access to faculty, students, staff and visitors to the Case campus and University Circle." Good news for Clevelanders looking for some free wireless internet access.

33 of 135 comments (clear)

  1. Yay, Northeast Ohio! by Corvaith · · Score: 4, Informative

    University of Akron's also got very good wireless coverage, and they push laptops rather heavily. It was so terribly convenient. I'm not going there anymore, alas... I miss it. The speed was really blazing, and nothing compares to the ability to actually be online looking up information related to your lectures while they're happening... can make for a much greater understanding of the material.

    Alas, my current school has some kind of fledgling deal going on, but so far I haven't even been able to get it to work, and they aren't very good about providing information on it. :(

    1. Re:Yay, Northeast Ohio! by asdfghjklqwertyuiop · · Score: 3, Interesting


      University of Akron's also got very good wireless coverage, and they push laptops rather heavily. It was so terribly convenient. I'm not going there anymore, alas... I miss it. The speed was really blazing, and nothing compares to the ability to actually be online looking up information related to your lectures while they're happening... can make for a much greater understanding of the material.

      Alas, my current school has some kind of fledgling deal going on, but so far I haven't even been able to get it to work, and they aren't very good about providing information on it. :(


      Just a little heads up to anyone who might be thinking of going there, living in the dorms and doing anything but web browsing on your computer:

      I just graduated from there this month. I agree, the wireless is good. Unfortunately however, they also put that campus-wide firewall in place that would make Hitler seem liberal. I'm in the computer science club there. I hear plenty of complaints from students who are trying to use the campus network for useful things (ie, services) but can't. Even some video games aren't playable.

      Certainly don't try making any special requests to the IT department. To them, the students are like a disease. I lived in the dorms my first three semesters there, before the network nazis put up the campus wide firewall. I very humbly requested a reverse DNS entry pointing to a hostname in a domain I owned. I got a very bitchy response back about how anything in 130.101/16 "represents" uakron.edu and it was incorrect to have PTRs going to any other domains. I then requested any DNS entry at all (because at the time they had no DNS entries for any dorm net addresses). After about a week they put one in place.

      Also, our student senate representative found out that they log all network traffic at border and store it for some time. If the RIAA or federal government ever comes a knockin', your ass and every bit of information they have on you will be in the sling faster than you can blink. You may have heard stores about universities refusing to turn student information over to the RIAA on request. Well, this is no such university, trust me.

      And then they had the nerve to apply this "technology fee" to our tuition, after making the network LESS usable than before.

    2. Re:Yay, Northeast Ohio! by Corvaith · · Score: 2, Interesting

      There *is* access, allegedly, in some places. I get a connection in the student center, tried using it once, it comes up--in the web browser--with some kind of login screen, and then claims that my login is valid but that I'm not allowed to login without a 'secure' connection.

      I wasn't even aware that there were that many places to plugin to the network, though. I haven't been bothering... hard enough finding places with outlets to recharge in the middle of the day.

    3. Re:Yay, Northeast Ohio! by The+Briguy · · Score: 2, Informative

      I am a student at Case, and these wireless points are all "secured" - that is, you have to have a wireless card with an approved MAC address in order to use any of these APs, so the original poster was incorrect - this will have absolutely no effect on the greater Cleveland area.... no free internet.

    4. Re:Yay, Northeast Ohio! by The+Briguy · · Score: 2, Informative

      BTW, I know if you RTFA, it says the access is for visitors too, but thats just PR bullshit. You have to have thier VPN client installed and have your MAC address registered with access services.

  2. why so many? by Comsn · · Score: 2, Insightful

    why would you need 1000 ap's? arent these things good for at least 100 meters? just how big is CWRU?

    1. Re:why so many? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

      The goal is to make most of the Cleveland area to have free WI-FI available. The Playhouse Square are also just went wireless for free (www.cleveland-freenet.com)

    2. Re:why so many? by Douglas+Simmons · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I'd say maybe they're using a superfluous amount because "1000 access points" has a nicer zing to it than "we have 462 aps" does, which may have been the actual number needed if it were based on how much area was needed to cover. Keep in mind, a lot of this is to impress people to attract attention, money and applicants to a school. Touting that number is more buzz-worthy than saying We cover X square feet. You hear that, and you think, "Hot-damn, that's a lot of access points! They must really care about network accessability when I'm on the go." Marketing.

    3. Re:why so many? by scseth · · Score: 2, Informative


      The campus at Akron has over 1000 access points for full coverage in and outside of buildinds. I know of other universities around the US (Tulane, UofTenesee) that also easily have that many as well. As you start doing the site planning the numbers of APs can easily start to add up. The 1000 number for Case does not seem unrealistic to me.

  3. And in other news... by Blrfl · · Score: 3, Funny

    ...Cleveland becomes the world's spam capital.

  4. Free WiFi access will predominate by Alan_Peery · · Score: 3, Insightful

    This is the way I expect WiFi access to evolve. Fee paying (particularly at more than $1/day) WiFi hotspots will only survive in spots with limited access and one landlord like airports.

    1. Re:Free WiFi access will predominate by gmenhorn · · Score: 2, Informative

      There is a small article in the latest Wired (Sept 2003, pg. 34) that states exactly this. "The way to cash in on wireless: give it away".

      --
      George

  5. So? by pirodude · · Score: 4, Informative

    I don't really see how this is news. Purdue has a good 1600 access points on campus and have total coverage in all the buildings and are working on open space coverage now. Any student/staff member can use it free. Here's our coverage map: http://www.itap.purdue.edu/airlink/WirelessCurrent 3.pdf

    1. Re:So? by BlueTooth · · Score: 4, Informative

      I think the point is that you don't have to be student / faculty to use this. Hence "largest public".

      --
      SPAM
  6. Just remember guys... by morgajel · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Don't abuse it. if you want to go kazaa-ing, go somewhere else. remember- when people are nice, and you abuse their trust, they tend not to be nice anymore.

    Try to keep it to a dull roar, or use something encrypted at least. If you make it blatently obvious that you're doing any sort of mp3 swaping, the BSA and RIAA will rain the holy shitstorm of litigation on the school.
    make sure if you use it, you write a letter of praise or something to the dean or head of IT praising their decision to make it open to the public.

    --
    Looking for Book Reviews? Check out Literary Escapism.
  7. New Ian Hunter song verse by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    All the little nerds with the crimson Pringles cans
    Singing Cleveland WAPS Cleveland WAPS
    Living in Sin with a bogus MAC
    Singing Cleveland WAPS Cleveland WAPS

  8. "could be"??? by Douglas+Simmons · · Score: 4, Informative

    Last time I've checked, Drexel University in Philadelphia held this wireless title, not to mention the fastest Internet link of any university. When an announcement touts a school like this with "could be" instead of "is" makes me suspicious that they worded it in a way that could either allow what they're claiming to be false, or they didn't bother to fact check to confirm its validity.

    Anyone know more about where Drexel weighs in? Kind of a silly pissing contest, but having the Best or Fastest (blank) for a school is good marketing.

  9. All a 31337 h4x0r needs these days are: by Krapangor · · Score: 3, Funny
    1. a laptop with Linux/FreeBSD
    2. a WiFi card with reconfigurable ID
    3. assorted 31337 h4x0ring programs
    4. a ticket to Cleveland
    Risk: 0%
    Profit: 100%
    --
    Owner of a Mensa membership card.
  10. Re:Do NOT go there... by bob670 · · Score: 2, Informative

    While I do live in Cleveland, and on a whole don't care for the city much at all, University Circle and the CWRU area are great, home to some great museums and probably one of the most culturally diverse areas in the metro area. Your sad attempt at subtle racism just sucks. Get back to the lilly-white suburbs where you belong.

  11. Administration nightmare by Psiren · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I run a College network, and the thought of any Tom, Dick or Harry being able to wander in and use my network for pretty much anything would be enough to give me nightmares for a month. Can you imagine the potential security issues there, or virus outbreaks? Cold shower time...

    While I see wireless as a potentially flexible system, it is a security and management nightmare. We've banned our students from using their own wireless routers for just this reason.

    1. Re:Administration nightmare by slamb · · Score: 2, Informative
      I run a College network, and the thought of any Tom, Dick or Harry being able to wander in and use my network for pretty much anything would be enough to give me nightmares for a month. Can you imagine the potential security issues there, or virus outbreaks? Cold shower time...

      But they can already, most likely. Where are your Ethernet ports? If someone just plugs a laptop into one, what will happen? (On most networks, the DHCP server will issue the laptop an address and the "intruder" can go about his/her business merrily. To actually prevent random people from using the network, you'd have to actually authenticate the people whenever they use it, probably with a VPN. Remember, MAC addresses can be spoofed easily.) How is this different with a wireless network, aside from not needing to find an Ethernet port?

      To really achieve security, you need a segmented network with firewalls between that don't trust anyone more than necessary for them to do their work. And if you're worried about traffic being captured, encryption. (Either a VPN or application-level encryption like SSH and SSL.) I don't really understand how wired or wireless changes that.

    2. Re:Administration nightmare by Mr-Fish · · Score: 2, Informative

      This year was the first year we've had two vlans in our residence halls - one for the residential network & one for wireless access points in the residence halls. Unfortuneatly, XP has made it really easy for students to bridge the two networks together and wreak havoc for us. Tracking down the bridging machines is a nightmare.

      We're currently 3com core (cb9k) to edge (3300s & 4400s), but doing a fork lift Cisco core replacement this winter. Hopefully life will get better when we replace the core, but this has been the roughest semester start we've seen yet.

      Unfortuneatly I'm primarily the Linux guy & not the network guy... I don't know of an easy way to track these monkeys with our current equipment. Any brilliant ideas?

    3. Re:Administration nightmare by LurkerXXX · · Score: 2, Informative

      At CWRU you have to register your MAC address for your wired network cards in order to get a IP address on the regular LAN. Otherwise you get an IP in a different range with limited access. With wireless, you are on a separate network and must VPN in to the regular campus network LAN.

  12. While this sounds all awesome 'n stuff... by philStyle · · Score: 4, Insightful

    At least as of now, when they say 'faculty, students, staff, and visitors to the campus', they really mean it. Presently, if you want to actually USE the wireless, you have got to VPN into the system. Until then, your computer will just recognize that there IS an access point, but you sure can't surf the net unless you've got an account with CWRU.
    So maybe this isn't all that it's cracked up to be. Until i hear that anyone with a laptop can actually use the access points without going and talking to the school for access, i'm a little skeptical. It's still sweet tho, 'specially if you live on campus.

  13. Gloat, gloat! by sidecut · · Score: 2, Informative
    How cool is that?! I live two miles from that campus, my alma mater.

    I often work from home on my company-provided laptop. It's been my dream to work from a Starbucks or, in the case of Case, the locally-owned, thirty-year-old Arabica coffee shop. Hell, there's even a bar on Case campus I could probably work from!

    NOTE: This is not at all an informative post. I'm just gloating. >:-)

  14. Would never happen at Ohio State by Cerlyn · · Score: 4, Informative

    It is interesting to see CWRU do this, as Ohio State likely would never dare try this. At Ohio State, all systems connected to the network must authenticate their users. If a system is unable to do so, the network switches typically force users onto a logon server in order to verify whom they are.

    This is a result of OSU's network policy (PDF file - see item #13). There are a few exceptions, but for the most part this is true.

    OSU's wireless 802.11 service requires users to login, and pay for some sort of dialup plan. Even the $1.95/month one counts.

  15. Re:Paint the town red! by sidecut · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Nope -- just University Circle. It's less than ten square miles. Still -- mighty impressive, especially if they get places that are technically off-campus like bars and coffee shops. Hell, even some off-campus housing might be in range! The old "hippy street" there might be wi-fi accessible. Ironic, sitting outside on your balcony in your bare feet drinking herbal tea and writing an anti-capitalist screed, all the while hooked up via free wi-fi.

  16. Drexel's network is not public by Cerlyn · · Score: 2, Informative

    The implication here is that CWRU's network is publically accessible. At last check, Drexel's network was *not* publically accessible (MAC locked, IIRC).

    Of course, things may have changed and I could be wrong...

  17. The spam from cwru hath begun.. by grub · · Score: 2, Funny

    This just arrived:
    From: "Bennett Sims" <b_sims_ux@po.cwru.edu>
    X-Mailer: Pegasus Mail for Win32 (v3.12a)
    Subject: Check it out!
    Eerie coincidence? I think not! :)
    --
    Trolling is a art,
  18. I *STILL* have not forgiven CWRU... by Mhrmnhrm · · Score: 2, Interesting

    ... for taking down the Cleveland FreeNet (CFN). The grand-daddy of all freenets, it was taken down something like 2 years ago this month, ostensibly because they couldn't continue to maintain the dialup banks, or some such rubbish. The CWRU cash fund is supposedly something in the billions (though this may just be heresay), and I can't imagine that CFN really sucked that many resources out. SO... while this is all fine and dandy for the CWRU students/faculty tromping around the museums, the rest of us Clevelanders remain in the lurch with no real community site anymore.

    --
    I suspect that one of these choices is incorrect. Correct.
    1. Re:I *STILL* have not forgiven CWRU... by sinnergy · · Score: 2, Interesting

      While I feel your pain, CFN did have some serious issues, the biggest of which was the fact that the codebase was insecure, the least of which was the fact that staffing issues within ITS prevented it from being properly maintained.

      Besides, and I think you could agree, in the end it really became a pretty seedy place with more and more 1337 kiddies joining in that really had no business being there. A great influx of people that really didn't care about the "community" trashed many of the SIGs and caused the IRC server to revert into a wasteland (albeit a wasteland I miss dearly, hence the reason for starting up my own IRC server at Case (the address isn't that hard to find and is well populated by Case people, alumni and other interested parties)). The MUC, it's successor, was no better.

      So while I do yearn for the "good old days" so often, after actually meeting and becoming friends with some of the people that ran it, I understand a lot of the reasons why it simply had to go. It was a bitter pill to swallow and I understand now that the issue wasn't a black or white one... it was very gray indeed.

  19. CWRU=Cleveland Freenet back in the 90's... by SirDaShadow · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Does anyone remember back in the day when they used to give away free accounts? They weren't shell accounts, but you could do email, news and IRC. This was back in 1990, and basically that's how I got my feet wet on the internet. Good ol' times I reckon...

  20. OK Everyone. Here's how it's really going to work by sinnergy · · Score: 4, Informative

    I am not intimiately involved with the project, as I work in the EECS department at Case and not ITS. However, I do know a lot of people that *do* work within ITS and keep myself informed enough to know that most of what's being spouted here is inaccurate at the least and FUD at worst.

    In any case (no pun intended), here's what's going down.

    Case currently has deployed 600 at last count (a few months ago) Cisco WAPs with 802.11b. By the end of the project, almost 1200 WAPs will be deployed campus wide. When Cisco starts shipping the 802.11g radios for the Aironets, all of the radios in all of the APs are going to get upgraded to g.

    OK. That's done.

    Next, currently it is REQUIRED that anyone wanting to use the WAPs must authenticate to a Cisco VPN server and gain access to campus network services as if they were physically on the network. HOWEVER, starting September 1st, ANYONE will be able to use another SSID on any WAP to gain access to the network AS IF they were outside of the CWRU firewall. ANYONE. Script kiddies, goofballs, terrorists... your mother... anyone. Also with that, though, are some SERIOUS controls and, I would assume, monitoring of the traffic. The first big control is bandwidth throttling. No, you wouldn't be able to park (if you could find parking at least) outside of a building and snarf down kazaa bullshit (besides, Kazaa is mostly throttled for everyone anyway. P2P is such a waste of resources, but I digress). So don't think you're going to be able to pull down at 4 to 5 Mbps on the "guest" network. What you WILL be able to do is check mail, browse the web and do activity and most "normal" people would be able to do. If you want to do high bandwidth wireless applications, you'd have to use the VPN.

    So, while this is authoritative I believe I can speak with some certainty that what I have said above is correct and true.

    Also, I want to state that my words here are not necessarily the official views of my employer, Case Western Reserve University and are my own based upon publically published information.