Slashdot Mirror


Nigerian Scammers Claim Another Victim

A Florida newspaper ran a story yesterday about a local retiree who fell hard for a 419 scam. The story goes into depth on the methods used to play on the target's beliefs and gain his confidence - in this case, the target (who lost $320,000) is still having a hard time accepting that they were thieves. Truly remarkable.

33 of 600 comments (clear)

  1. Simply Insane by OS24Ever · · Score: 5, Insightful

    This is just simply greed run amuck. Not by the scammer - but by the idiot who fell for it.

    I can't feel sorry for this guy in the slightest. This guy was a whole lot of stupid. Just insane to fall for something like that and need to spend $320K to get it.

    There is a certain personaility type that has to fall for this no matter where it was from. It's not the internet that has caused this, it's just helped people find more idiots to suck in.

    --

    As a rock-in-roll Physicist once said, No matter where you go, there you are.

    1. Re:Simply Insane by OS24Ever · · Score: 5, Insightful

      I read the article start to finish prior to posting my comment. The guy is so stubborn and stupid to think that the government of the country is keeping him from his millions, not his friends.

      He's an idiot, plain and simple. When given documentation showing it's a scam he won't admit it, and won't even file an official complaint. He's a moron.

      He lost everything, yep. He's now a burden on society as a whole completely because he will loose his home, bankrupt off his debt and now the banking & mortgage industries will take the hit for it causing interest rates, and credit ratings to be just that much tighter for us non-greedy types to get a loan and/or credit card.

      The banking industry let him get *21* credit cards and cash advance all of them and no one blinked. They started blinking when they didn't get their payments though. That could be the only thing that might need to be fixed, the ability for a person to get *that* many credit cards in such a short time, and for no one to notice.

      --

      As a rock-in-roll Physicist once said, No matter where you go, there you are.

    2. Re:Simply Insane by Apreche · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I don't feel bad either. I in fact almost despise this man. Because of his ineptitude there are now drug trafficers in Nigeria who have some positive revenue. Why? Because this dumbass american is a fucking idiot. I feel bad for people who are screwed and it isn't their fault. Like a small child who gets kidnapped from the playground. Or someone who trips and falls into a fire. But if you are this dumb, your life deserves to be ruined. Darwinism at its finest I say.

      --
      The GeekNights podcast is going strong. Listen!
    3. Re:Simply Insane by Anonymous+Cow+herd · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Empathy? If you took all your money and flushed it down the toilet, do you deserve empathy? If you decide it'd be a neat idea to deliberately drive a 6" spike through your shin bone, do you think you're going to get a lot of sympathy?

      Don't get me wrong, I'm all for empathy... if unexpected medical bills had cleaned out his nest egg, or he'd lost it in some Enron-type pension plan raiding, I'd be Mister Empathy himself.

      But the long and short of the story is that he got greedy, he didn't listen to advice from good sources. Jesus Christ, he handed over $300,000 to these guys without even doing any due dilligence. And now he's in denial. This guy deserves everything he got, end of story.

      --
      Ita erat quando hic adveni.
    4. Re:Simply Insane by jandrese · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I think the "arbitrary level of worthiness" is "didn't inflict it on themselves". We feel bad for people when bad stuff happens to them, we don't feel nearly as bad when they do it to themselves, especially if it is for some unbelievably stupid reason.

      --

      I read the internet for the articles.
    5. Re:Simply Insane by starling · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Because of his ineptitude there are now drug trafficers in Nigeria who have some positive revenue.

      What, you think drug trafficking runs at a loss? The evil drug runners need to use scams like this because they sell of drugs at below cost? Yeah, right. That's progaganda, pure and simple - and you fell for it.

    6. Re:Simply Insane by RichardX · · Score: 4, Insightful

      It's incredibly easy to denounce this guy as an obvious idiot - indeed, his stupidity seems absolutely breathtaking, and therefore he deserves all the flak he gets....

      Or maybe not.
      It's always so easy to denounce things from the other side, for example, lack certain beliefs that some other people hold (I'm staying nonspecific here so's not to get into an argument about religion, or whatever).. to me, it seems absolutely staggering that anyone could possibly believe some of the things I don't - but it's never that simple.

      This guy is not of the internet generation - he's older. In my experience to many older people the internet is some "magical computery thing" that can do anything. I know people of that kind of age who are every bit as shrewd, bright, and worldly-wise as their years should suggest, but you tell them you can download money from the internet, and they'll believe you.

      Secondly, his wife is partially disabled. That's likely to put financial strain on him and his household. Strain = stress, and stress generates emotional rather than rational thinking.

      Thirdly, it's often difficult for people to admit they've been taken for a ride - even very smart people. Put yourself in this situation:

      You've been offered a bargain.. it all looks legit, and it's something you really don't want to pass up.. A really nice PC/Mac for $100, mebbe.
      So, you send off your $100, and after a while you're informed that due to some oversight, the cost is actually going to be $105.

      At this point, you grumble.. but what do you do? Risk throwing in the extra $5 for the machine you really, really want, and prove to yourself that you aren't stupid... or prove that you ARE a complete idiot for falling for it in the first place by trying to get your money back?

      It's a pretty devious trap. A lot of people would rather spend a little more to get a "good" result.. and will repeat ad infinitum. A little more.. just a little more.. one more bit.. etc. It's an age old con trick, but it's survived this long with good reason.

      Anyways, this has turned into something of a long winded rant.. by basic point is - don't be too quick to judge.

      --
      Curiosity was framed. Ignorance killed the cat.
  2. Golden rule by msgmonkey · · Score: 5, Insightful

    If it sounds to good to be true it most probably is. period.

    I dont know who came up with that line but it holds true time and again.

  3. Ouch.. by MattC413 · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I can see why he won't admit to having been scammed, and keeps denying that those people were scammers.

    At that age and point in my life, if I were to admit that I were completely scammed out of everything I had worked for my entire life because of a scam that has been around for decades, it would probably make me a broken man.

    How long can someone that age live with a broken heart?

  4. Re:It's not a scam by Leroy_Brown242 · · Score: 5, Insightful

    It's right up there with the lottery.

  5. Before you start feeling pity for him... by phorm · · Score: 4, Insightful

    We have to look at the signs. First, we have the obvious there is no free lunch and if it looks too good to be true, it probably is

    Next, we find this line:
    He ignored police warnings that the deal was bogus and instead blames his losses on corrupt foreign governments
    OK, so even the police told him that this would go bad, he continued to dump his money. So now we have "too good to be true" coupled with warnings from the law that he was going to get fleeced

    The actual premise of the transaction doesn't even sound legal. A banker needs to move money that isn't his by using an offshore account?

    The account had been dormant for years -- ever since the businessman and his family died in a plane crash, the e-mail read. The "banker" needed help moving the money. Otherwise, the government would confiscate it.

    That's where Sessions fit in.


    And finally the trump:

    Still, Sessions was so mesmerized by the well-spoken West Africans that to this day he does not think he was scammed. "I consider them my friends," he says. "They're not criminals."

    If this guy had more money and they asked for it, he would give it up. It goes beyond stupid and trusting to the point of insanity. Yes, he's old, but when you've been warned by police and god knows how many others, lost all the cash you have,and face losing your house then you should know you've been robbed.

    This guy has more in common with a gambling addict than a victim. He's still not giving up. I really wouldn't be surprised if he would have given to TV preachers or others who might have fleeced him had the nigerian scammers not caught him first.

  6. Re:It's not a scam by MoonBuggy · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I completely agree. While the scammers should not have tried it to start with, anyone stupid enough to be taken in by something so well documented after being warned by the police deserves to loose anything they put in. Why does nobody ever point out this side of the story? It's always like the victim was an innocent bystander, not a greedy moron.

  7. Denial's a wonderful thing isn't it. by antis0c · · Score: 4, Insightful

    My take is on this is more than likely he knows he was scammed. He would rather believe a lie he knows is a lie than accept the fact he was swindled for all he's worth.

    It's easier to blame "corrupt foriegn governments" than it is to blame yourself for being taken in by it. I think the poor guy is just too embarrassed to admit he was swindled.

    But did anyone else get the impression off this article like they were really poking fun of him instead of covering a real piece of news. Kinda like, "Look at this stupid old guy, haha"

    You know what else is a little odd:

    Jim Stratton can be reached at jstratton@orlandosentinel.com or 407-420-5379.

    That just screams, "please send donations." Makes you stop and think, who's scamming who..

    --

    ..There's a-dooin's a-transpirin'
  8. Sounds like Scientology.. by jcr · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Get the victim hooked, keep bleeding money out of him until he's ruined, and all along he'll insist that he's not being robbed.

    Sad. Very sad.

    -jcr

    --
    The only title of honor that a tyrant can grant is "Enemy of the State."
  9. if only by Camel+Pilot · · Score: 5, Insightful

    "I think the Lord uses people to do his work," Sessions said. "With that money, we'd be comfortable, and we could do some good things."

    This statement is another way to pc package the concept of greed. If only God would let me win the loto I promise I will use it to do the Lords work - after of course making myself "comfortable".

  10. Alive and Well by aufecht · · Score: 5, Insightful

    This is exactly why SPAM is thriving and so widespread. Someone, somewhere will fall for anything, no matter how propostrous. A million may complain about SPAM, but it only takes one to buy into the scam. I mean, this one he should have seen a mile away and yet he lost a ton of money. Sad.

  11. I'd laugh, but... by mblase · · Score: 4, Insightful

    ...I lived through the dot-com stock bubble.

    You don't have to be old and retired to be seduced by people promising you 500% returns on $50,000 investments. Twenty-somethings will fall for it if you use enough marketspeak.

  12. Feel sorry for him by Quixote · · Score: 4, Insightful
    It is quite easy, for us (20|30)-year olds to pass judgement on this man. But consider this:
    • He is 73
    • He and his partially disabled wife needed the money
    • He comes from a simpler time, a different era
    Please don't be harsh on him.

    What if, 50 years from now, there's a scam going around , today, you won't in your wildest imagination consider possible? Would you fall for it? It is possible some of you would.

    Please don't deride this old man, but feel sorry for him. He's ruined, with a disabled wife to take care of.

    If anything, us young folks also have to share some of the blame in not spreading the message clearly that such things are scams.

    1. Re:Feel sorry for him by OS24Ever · · Score: 4, Insightful
      Couple problems with this
      1. This scam has been around almost as long as he has, The oldest reference I could find is a reuters article in '91.
      2. The internet had nothing to do with it, this used to be delivered via fax, and good old US Mail
      3. He was greedy, and used god as a reference to fulfill his greedy needs. Just as bad as spending your life savings to win the lottery


      I don't buy it. hell the police TOLD him while he was being scammed it was a lie and he disagreed with them.
      --

      As a rock-in-roll Physicist once said, No matter where you go, there you are.

    2. Re:Feel sorry for him by nathanh · · Score: 4, Insightful
      It is quite easy, for us (20|30)-year olds to pass judgement on this man. But consider this:

      Look, you've pushed a particular button of mine with this one.

      * He is 73

      Ok.

      * He and his partially disabled wife needed the money

      Ok.

      * He comes from a simpler time, a different era

      No, I strongly disagree with this. There seems to be this all-pervasive myth that you go back 70 years and everything was rosy. People left their doors unlocked. Everybody tipped their hats to ladies in the street. Con-artists didn't exist and policemen had nothing better to do than provide consolation to young toddlers who had temporarily lost their mothers while shopping.

      It's a nonsense. Go back 70 years and there are drugs, crime and corruption on an incredible scale. The mafia rules several cities. Drive-by shootings are basically invented. Policemen are murdered in their homes. Con-artists swindle the entire population out of their money leading to a rather well known market crash; makes Enron look like a child's tantrum. Hollywood movie stars are involved in drug scandal after drug scandal. You have street gangs, street crime, etc.

      You need to lose this rosy-coloured vision of your history. Simpler time? Don't be stupid.

  13. Re:It's not a scam by Dan+Crash · · Score: 5, Insightful

    "The guy deserved to get scammed! Stupid people should suffer."

    Ah, the spirit of Christmas on Slashdot.

    --
    He who refuses to do arithmetic is doomed to talk nonsense.
  14. Scam who? by AnotherBlackHat · · Score: 4, Insightful

    He borrowed hundreds of thousands of dollars, gave it to some one in a foreign country, and now he may go bankrupt.

    Why do I feel like the real idiots in this story were the people willing to lend him the money?

    -- this is not a .sig

  15. Re:It's not a scam by Khomar · · Score: 5, Insightful

    We should be careful when we attack people like this. Did he make a huge mistake? Yes. Was the mistake a result of caving into greed? Yes. However, millions of Americans are currently putting themselves into similar situations by getting deeper and deeper into debt by taking loans to buy luxury items: a new yacht, a larger house, a fancy new car, etc. The evils of debt and the mounting interest costs is well documented, but it happens time and time again.

    While you may not have fallen victim to this particular scheme, are you certain that you have not fallen victim to the "must-have" commercialization scheme so prevalent (and legal) today? Yes, this was a very stupid mistake, but we are all just as capable of making equally stupid mistakes (an investment in the next Enron perhaps).

    Do not be so quick to judge and save a little room for compassion. If nothing else, think of his wife who has lost so much and may have had little to say in the decision. Consider the difficulties that they will both face in their marriage as they approach their final years in poverty. This is a heartbreaking story. Do not become so cynical that we lose sight of this.

    --

    I believe in de-evolution. God made the world perfect, man fell, and its been going downhill ever since!

  16. Re:It's not a scam by Fnkmaster · · Score: 4, Insightful
    In general, I agree with you, but you have to consider that many of the people who get taken are eldery retirees. In many cases, these people's mental faculties aren't what they were when they were younger. The elderly are unfortunately often the target of overt scams because of this very fact, and because they often have retirement nest eggs.

    There really needs to be stronger international enforcement on these scams. These scammers deserve to be taken out with extreme prejudice.

  17. And Worse Yet by blunte · · Score: 4, Insightful

    It said most of the 320k was new debt. There's no chance he can pay that debt back, as he can't even afford to pay current living expenses.

    That means he'll default on loans and credit card debt, which means creditors will have yet another reason to fleece good customers to make up for the bad ones.

    --
    .sigs are for post^Hers.
    1. Re:And Worse Yet by batura · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Uh, it is the creditors responsibility to only grant credit to those that can afford it. The fact that they gave a guy the ability to borrow 320,000 without the chance to repay it is what makes me think about who the true dumbass is in this story: the bank. The guy will file for bankruptcy next week, and they'll (the banks) will be the ones paying for thier greed.

  18. Bull by Hoi+Polloi · · Score: 4, Insightful

    "He is 73"

    So he had 73 years of life experience for him to know better.

    "He and his partially disabled wife needed the money"

    He had no problem burying his wife and himself in debt and putting everything they had in hock for the sake of a scheme that would have made Ralph Kramden (The Honeymooners) blush.

    "He comes from a simpler time, a different era"

    Bah, I hate that "Golden Age" bullshit. Life wasn't simpler and people act exactly the same as they always have. Some people are liars and cheats, some are greedy fools; time hasn't changed this. People even had fewer people watching out for them (bank insurance, auto insurance, consumer fraud protection, etc) than they do today.

    He grew up with Stalin, McCarthy, Hitler, the Depression, countless scams and scandals, and on and on. He wasn't from some innocent time.

    --
    It is by the juice of the coffee bean that thoughts acquire speed, the teeth acquire stains. The stains become a warning
  19. Why is this a scam, and televangelism not? by ColonelPanic · · Score: 4, Insightful

    If this guy had given all his money to a church, it wouldn't be in the news.

    --
    "Skill shows through where genius wears thin." -Wittgenstein || Religion: uniting aviation and architecture.
  20. Re:It's not a scam by stonecypher · · Score: 4, Insightful

    The lottery is occasionally in your favor

    Statistics are funny. Even if it's in your favor, you're still not going to land the sum, so it's still not worth it - unless you're willing to risk a huge amount of money.

    As the old saying goes - a variation on what this was started by - the lottery is a tax on those which are bad at math.

    I see the 419 scam as a form of social darwinism.

    --
    StoneCypher is Full of BS
  21. Re:It's not a scam by stonecypher · · Score: 5, Insightful

    However, millions of Americans are currently putting themselves into similar situations by getting deeper and deeper into debt by taking loans to buy luxury items: a new yacht, a larger house, a fancy new car, etc. The evils of debt and the mounting interest costs is well documented, but it happens time and time again.

    We're not laughing at this dumbass for getting into debt. We're laughing at him for spending three times his monetary worth on something that police had already told him was fake.

    While you may not have fallen victim to this particular scheme, are you certain that you have not fallen victim to the "must-have" commercialization scheme so prevalent (and legal) today?

    Not to the tune of a third of a million dollars, not once the police had told me not to, and certainly not to sixteen credit cards, two sold cars and a doubly mortgaged house.

    I do feel a bit dumb about my $50 electric razor. That's maybe a different caliber of dumb.

    but we are all just as capable of making equally stupid mistakes (an investment in the next Enron perhaps).

    Did the police tell you not to invest in Enron? Did you hear about Enron via email? Did you invest triple the amount of money you actually had, risking corporate funds loaned to you, on Enron?

    If nothing else, think of his wife who has lost so much and may have had little to say in the decision.

    I'm not laughing at her. I feel awful for her.

    This is a heartbreaking story. Do not become so cynical that we lose sight of this.

    Heartbreaking, yes. Uproariously funny, yes. I wouldn't think it was funny if he hadn't been specifically told by the fucking authorities.

    --
    StoneCypher is Full of BS
  22. The root of the problem... by X86Daddy · · Score: 4, Insightful

    is that people aren't encouraged to use critical thinking skills. As children, asking why too many times or spotting inconsistencies in explainations is often frowned upon. As adults, questioning your employer is an example of not "being a team player," while questioning your government is "unpatriotic." At any time, questioning an organized religion is usually branded "heretical."

    Trust is a good thing. Common sense is good too, but not encouraged as much. Just imagine a world where everyone had plenty of the latter.

  23. And not all debt is bad by Sycraft-fu · · Score: 4, Insightful

    A house is an asset. All things being equal, it will appreciate over time, and unlike an apartment, your money isn't just being dumped into someone else's pocket.

    I'm currently in more debt than I've ever been. I have $100,000 outstanding on a house I got. Before this, I'd never been in debt more than $1000. However, that doesn't mean I'm hurting in a bad way, on the contrary, my mortgage payments are LESS than my rent was, I have one more roomate so I'm paying even less, and now only 5% of what I pay goes to someone else, instead of all of it when I lived in an apartment.

    1. Re:And not all debt is bad by Frisky070802 · · Score: 4, Insightful
      I'm currently in more debt than I've ever been. I have $100,000 outstanding on a house I got....

      Assuming your house is worth more than you owe on it, I don't know that this is truly "debt" in the same sense as someone who owes credit card issuers. A debt that is secured by an asset is a completely different animal.

      So right, not all "debt" is bad. But neither would I call you in debt over a mortgage. Our friendly scam victim is not only in debt, he's in the doghouse and all that brown stuff that lies around outside that doghouse.

      --
      Mencken had it right. So glad that's old news.