Slashdot Mirror


On Gay Characters In Videogames

Thanks to Armchair Arcade for its feature discussing the portrayal of gay characters in videogames past and present. The article starts by pointing out: "In Troika Games' computer role playing game The Temple of Elemental Evil (2003)... the player is asked to rescue, and given the option to marry, an openly gay character", and ends by arguing: "Gay avatars are an inevitable development in the evolution of the videogame that will take place with or without this article. If we already see such possibilities opening up in even mainstream titles like The Temple of Elemental Evil, I doubt it will be long before even the idea of a fantasy role-playing game featuring only one white male avatar will seem a strange, misguided aspect of our distant past."

34 of 272 comments (clear)

  1. Let's not forget... by metamatic · · Score: 4, Funny

    ...the fabulous portrayal of gay people in Grand Theft Auto.

    --
    GCHQ Quantum Insert installed. If only our tongues were made of glass, how much more careful we would be when we speak
  2. Trans... by elasticwings · · Score: 4, Funny

    I for one believe there should be more crossdressing in video games. I still remember I think it was Space Quest 3 where you cross-dressed in the mall.

  3. Same-Sex marriage allowed in The Sims 2 by TheRedHorse · · Score: 4, Interesting

    The issue of gays in videogames will get a lot more mainstream soon, one example is that the website for "The Sims 2" says that members of the same gender will be able to marry each other.

    http://thesims2.ea.com/about_faq.php

    1. Re:Same-Sex marriage allowed in The Sims 2 by Squozen · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Same-sex relationships existed in the first Sims game, though I can't recall what the situation was regarding marriage. You could certainly fall in love and share a bed with members of either sex, the engine didn't care.

  4. 700 hours of gameplay by AlternateSyndicate · · Score: 5, Funny
    In Troika Games' computer role playing game The Temple of Elemental Evil (2003)... the player is asked to rescue, and given the option to marry, an openly gay character.

    Do they have to wander around the United States until they find a city offering marriage licenses? That sounds like a pretty extensive side-quest.

  5. FPS more tolerant than the nation? by Tiamat · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Given the option to marry?

    I never thought I'd see the day that first person shooters would be more tolerant of social differences the the general U.S. population.

    1. Re:FPS more tolerant than the nation? by Original+AIDS+Monkey · · Score: 4, Funny

      What are you talking about? My neighborhood still does not tolerate head shots even though I've been trying to convince law enforcement that it's been standard in FPS games for years!

      --


      =======
      P.S. Bite! You've been bitten by the Original AIDS Monkey! You have AIDS now!
    2. Re:FPS more tolerant than the nation? by sfjoe · · Score: 4, Funny



      Will there be a constitutional amendment to ban gay videogames?

      Won't somebody please think of the children?

      --
      It's simple: I demand prosecution for torture.
    3. Re:FPS more tolerant than the nation? by moronga · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I never thought I'd see the day that first person shooters would be more tolerant of social differences the the general U.S. population.

      I don't know if you were making a joke here, but I'm not sure why you'd be surprised by this. Videogames are created and played by (generally) younger people, who are going to be more progressively minded than the general population.

      Also, videogames are often the place where people get to do things they'd normally wouldn't do in real life.

      And the game in question is an RPG, not an FPS. :)

  6. Birdo in SMB2 by HomerJ · · Score: 4, Funny

    Let's not forget the original gay character....from Nintendo no less...Birdo in Super Mario Bros 2. Yes, that pink thing that shot eggs and wore a bow...was a dude.

    1. Re:Birdo in SMB2 by NonSequor · · Score: 4, Funny

      I remember the book saying that he wore a bow because he wanted to be a woman. I think he's been retconned into a she now though. I can't believe I actually used the word retcon. I feel so dirty.

      --
      My only political goal is to see to it that no political party achieves its goals.
  7. Gamers are Awful by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Gamers are some of the most homophobic people out there. Using "gay" to mean "stupid" or "cheap" is clear homophobia, I don't care what kind of way people try to construe it.

    "That's so GAY!" is heard almost every round of Counterstrike. "God, why does that fag have to keep cheating?" If you're a real gamer, you know what I'm talking about.

    The worst part is that most of them think it's okay, because either a) They don't *really* mean Gay people, it's just a word, or b) they think gay people deserve it.

    Its really a problem that needs to go away. It makes online gaming less fun, and it makes otherwise intelligent people act like assholes.

    1. Re:Gamers are Awful by Imperator · · Score: 3, Insightful

      I know people who do this in real life, and they're not all homophobic. They just don't think about it. I'm pretty sure that if there were a gay person in the room, they wouldn't do it, because then they'd suddenly realize that it's insulting. But when among straight males, they figure "no one's going to get offended". I'm not trying to apologize for them, and if I were gay I'd be pretty pissed about it, but don't assume they're all homophobic.

      That said, some of the people who talk like that undoubtedly are homophobic.

      --

      Gates' Law: Every 18 months, the speed of software halves.
    2. Re:Gamers are Awful by Tiamat · · Score: 4, Insightful
      These words have a negative meaning because, and only because of their connection to gay people, and that makes them homophobic.

      For all those people who believe that words like "nigger" and "fag" aren't related to their original meaning, I invite you to come to my neighborhood and start calling my neighbors "niggers". I wager you won't walk out intact.

    3. Re:Gamers are Awful by Pluvius · · Score: 4, Informative

      These words have a negative meaning because, and only because of their connection to gay people

      Do you realize that "faggot" used to refer to a bundle of sticks, or that "gay" used to be a synonym of "happy"?

      Language changes all the time. Just because something became an insult because of homophobia doesn't mean that it will always be an insult because of homophobia. Even now, a significant number of people use the word as an insult just because it's accepted as an insult; sexual orientation doesn't enter into it. After all, how does it make sense to call, for instance, Star Wars Galaxies gay in the homophobic sense when SWG doesn't even have a sexuality?

      For all those people who believe that words like "nigger" and "fag" aren't related to their original meaning, I invite you to come to my neighborhood and start calling my neighbors "niggers". I wager you won't walk out intact.

      Because, as we all know, emotion not only overrides logic, it disproves it.

      Rob

    4. Re:Gamers are Awful by Rallion · · Score: 5, Interesting

      I'll go one step further -- I know gay people who do it. It really is just common slang now. Gay means either homosexual or stupid. It can mean both, but doesn't always.

      That said, I do try not to use it that way myself, but I'm exposed to it constantly, and ever so rarely it slips out.

    5. Re:Gamers are Awful by nekoes · · Score: 3, Informative

      I'm going to have to agree on this one, that is:

      Do you realize that "faggot" used to refer to a bundle of sticks, or that "gay" used to be a synonym of "happy"?

      Language changes all the time. Just because something became an insult because of homophobia doesn't mean that it will always be an insult because of homophobia. Even now, a significant number of people use the word as an insult just because it's accepted as an insult; sexual orientation doesn't enter into it. After all, how does it make sense to call, for instance, Star Wars Galaxies gay in the homophobic sense when SWG doesn't even have a sexuality?


      Now I do know a lot of "gay" and "bi" people who would actually be offended if they were around people who used gay as a pejoritive, then again I know twice as many "gay" people who no longer feels that gay really means what it used to. It no longer holds offensive meaning for them. Which makes sense, technically gay doesn't even have any sort of connection to what we'd now call Homosexuals, besides the meaning it shares with happy, which I'd be more offended by. Of course these are the same friends that I game with occasionally, and I'd have to say that may have something to do with it.

      Sure these words may have become pejoratives because of their connection to gay people, but they're now losing that connection it seems. Same deal with nigger, sure you still have the rednecks who use it offensively, and the black people who consequently get mad. But that's to be expected. I've heard black people call eachother nigger, white people call eachother nigger, white people call black people nigger, and asians that say it and everyone laughs. Racism, at least in my area, is becoming quite the joke.

      --
      Hey, it's my OPINION that dogs have eight legs and make a sound like a car horn every time they take a piss.
    6. Re:Gamers are Awful by Jamie+Lokier · · Score: 3, Insightful

      I know people who do this in real life, and they're not all homophobic.

      I agree. These days in the places I travel, "gay" has a much more fun, cheery flair to it, even when used to diss something, than I recall from school (13 years ago, Wales). Back then, people said "gay" as an insult and they meant as in queer, as in homosexual etc. All homosexual-related terms were universally used as insults. Bisexual was strangely a word nobody used for anything, and transgender was unheard of.

      I'm pretty sure that if there were a gay person in the room, they wouldn't do it, because then they'd suddenly realize that it's insulting. But when among straight males, they figure "no one's going to get offended".

      That's just the trouble. They do it when they don't realise 5% of the room (or whatever it is) are, in fact, gay or bisexual, because most non-straights are very quiet about it, because it isn't universally accepted as ok, so they end up insulting people unintentionally.

      Imagine the guy at work whose parents have disowned him for being gay, who feels that life is harder than it should be because those who should care for him reject him, that it's better not to tell people at work, that he thanks god each day that the suicidal thoughts he had as a teenager didn't win, and he hasn't said anything to the folks in the room. Do those unintentional insults create a welcoming environment? Does it create an environment where he's likely to talk about it? Would those people even say the things they do, if they thought for a moment about how much they don't know about the people around, or even think they do know, because the people play along uncomfortably?

      If people used "that's so female" to diss products and people regularly, would that be ok? Ignore the feminist backlash -- would it be ok in terms of its effect on how people treat one another away from the spaces where they say that? I don't think so.

      Homosexuality is still far from general acceptance, yet it is good, because it does no harm and makes people happy. Homophobia still exists, and causes very much harm. That's why we still have to make a special effort to accept homosexuality, and reject homophobia, with our words, actions, and laws.

      -- Jamie
  8. Where's the trolls by Profane+MuthaFucka · · Score: 5, Funny

    For once, the GNAA would be slightly on-topic, and they are nowhere to be found. Trolls are so damn unreliable.

    --
    Fascism trolls keeping me up every night. When I starts a preachin', he HITS ME WITH HIS REICH!
  9. Players are already transgender... by the_skywise · · Score: 3, Funny

    How many guys play the female characters in DOA?

  10. Staring at Crystal Ball(s) by illuminata · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Well, we're bound to see some more gays in video games under the political climate. It really wouldn't surprise me to see quite a few titles.

    Why? Instant publicity. Your game will get mentioned in the press if you give it a decent enough initial push. Gay influence has already saturated movies, television, and music. It hasn't really been a big issue in video games (this slight mention doesn't really make it a big issue). But, if you show that it's out there, you can get the mainstream press debating like mad. Imagine Bill O'Reilly and Rosie O'Donnell debating in a knife fight.

    Those debates equal massive amounts of money, and gays will buy the game just to show support over the issue. A larger company might end up boycotted by some, but that would probably blow over.

    Eventually, this whole thing will die down. But, if a game company were to play their cards right, it could equal massive amounts of money.

    --


    Until Slashdot fixes the funny modifier, use insightful or interesting. The poster knows your intentions.
  11. Neverwinter Nights by TheDarkRogue · · Score: 5, Funny

    It always pissed me off that my female avatar couldn't get any lesbian lovin at that whorehouse/tavern in act 1. I had her strip her armor and all, but neither of the women would go for her, told her to go talk to the guy. And the Token was non-refundable too if I remember correctly. So I just killed everyone in the building (except for that fat bitch, she wouldn't die, vital part of the story or some shit), but it wasn't as filling.

    --
    (Score:0, Interesting)
    1. Re:Neverwinter Nights by ScarletEmerald · · Score: 3, Insightful

      This works in Fallout (or was it Fallout 2). Girls could sleep with the girls, guys with the guys... I think you could even have same sex marriages.

  12. The Longest Journey by AvantLegion · · Score: 4, Interesting
    The Longest Journey, a wonderful point-and-click adventure from a few years ago, featured a main character who rents her room from a lesbian couple. The game treated this like a natural thing, not something to be pointed out and grandstanded (in fact, it took a couple references before I got suspicious, and a couple more before I fully caught on).

  13. Eagle by LGagnon · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Eagle from Capcom vs SNK 2 (who was a character in the original Street Fighter) came out of the closet in that game as an openly gay character. Many of his winning quotes in the Japanese version of the game show this. The American version, however, had the quotes changed to not show his sexuality.

  14. geeze... by manual_overide · · Score: 3, Interesting

    the idea of a fantasy role-playing game featuring only one white male avatar will seem a strange, misguided aspect of our distant past.

    Right. Because heterosexual white males are, in fact, nothing more than a myth. And anyone saying otherwise is a homophobe or a terrorist. Puh-leeze.

    One white male avatar will seem strange and misguided??! Oh, of course. White males aren't really people. They are just dragons waiting to eat all the REAL, CLAIRVOIANT PEOPLE. After all, "white" is a real race. Just like ALL "black" people are african-americans. I guess I'm German-American, or European-American.... No? Not born in Europe or even in Germany you say? But the "black" baby born in Cleveland is somehow African-American?? Why not Kenyan-American, or even Egyptian-American?

    This story irritates me to no end. "Nickelodeon says it's cool to be gay!!" "MTV says all the white men are out to get me!" Why is this story big news?? Personally, I don't care what happens in your bedroom, and lets keep it that way, thank you very much. Also, what's so wrong about white males? I happen to be one, and don't think that I am contributing to the ruination of society by simply existing.

    I know for a fact that I can't be "The Man". I can barely wake up before 11:00 AM, much less keep entire races of peoples from attaining financial independance. It's not me!!! (or most of us, for that matter)

    Blah... I'm drunk and ranting... but you get my point. If you don't get it... I don't care. I'm gonna be sleeping until it's time for work.

    --
    If bad puns were like deli meat, this would be the wurst
  15. Re:Too early to tell by 0x0d0a · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Considering gamers still use the words 'fag', 'gay' and 'homo' in order to insult each other online, it'll be a while until homosexual characters are implemented more into games.

    Yes, they should be using "lame" or "retard" or "bastard".

  16. Guilty Gear XX - Bridget by Lemmy+Caution · · Score: 4, Funny

    The best traumatizing-to-fragile-heterosexual-identities videogame characters was GGXX's Bridget - a gender-confused boy who fights with a yo-yo and was raised as, dresses as and acts like a girl. A pretty hot girl. as cel-shaded Japanese fighters go.

    Bridget probably sent more than one fanboy to therapy.

  17. Morrowind by Hythlodaeus · · Score: 4, Interesting

    To me the best gay character in a game is great, because it was completely unintentional. The character is Crassius Curio in the game Morrowind. He was intended to be a very lecherous, but straight character. However, there was a bug that caused him to give the dialogue for female players regardless of the character's actual gender. The result: he comes across as absolutely, flamingly gay.

    --
    For great justice.
  18. Well, if you're going to play language police... by Dr.+Bent · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Gamers are some of the most homophobic people out there. Using "gay" to mean "stupid" or "cheap" is clear homophobia

    Ignorance, maybe. Insensitivity, sure. But homophobia? Most people who use that word use it without thinking about it's meaning in relation to the current context. But if they were homophobic, they would be thinking about it's meaning, and purposely using it with the intention of intimidating gay people.

    By branding ignorant or insensitive behavior as homophobic, you're guilty of making the same generalizations that truly homophobic make.

  19. Why focus on a facet, not the whole? by wowbagger · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Why is it that people insist upon focusing upon a single facet of their being rather than the entirety?

    In the specific case of homosexuality, too many people focus upon the fact that they are gay to the exclusion of all else. Should the person be famous and be on a talkshow, that's the whole of their discussion - their homosexuality.

    Now, consider somebody like Elton John. Queer as a three dollar bill, and has made no bones about it for years. Yet, that is only a small part of the man - yes, if he is on a talk show and the subject comes up he may discuss (briefly) his S.O., but then he moves on. He treats his relationship like any polite person should - it is his private life, and he trys to keep it such. I don't want to hear about Elton's bedroom, but then again, I really don't want to hear about Ahnold's bedroom, either.

    Which brings me to the subject of "Gay characters in (games|movies|TV)" - in most such cases that is ALL the character is - gay. No other character development, just "Look at Fred. He's gay."

    How about having a character who is, among other things, gay? Buffy the Vampire Slayer did pretty well with Willow - the fact she was gay was only a small facet of her character.

    So why must the fact that some character in this video game is gay be the main facet of the game, or the character? Why not just have the fact come out (pun intended) during the normal course of the game, and make it just another part of the character?

  20. Re:If I had the mod points.... by theghost · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Not giving a rat's ass is easy when you are not among the oppressed.

    People who don't use computers for anything more than Word and AOL generally don't give a rat's ass about the DMCA, RIAA, MPAA, and SCO, but that doesn't make them right.

    --
    The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing.
  21. Re:ok..so.. by theghost · · Score: 3, Insightful

    so, since we will have gay characters in-game, can I have a sexy donkey in my game?

    Way to throw that red herring in there. Consensual relationships between consenting adults of the same species are in a very different category than bestiality. If you can't see that then you are blind.

    why is homosexuality being 'rammed' down everyones throat over the past few years?

    Why did those uppity black people ram their race down everyone's throats in the 60's?

    Why are some members of our secular (separation of church and state?) society being denied their rights based on moral definitions that are purely religious?

    --
    The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing.
  22. Re:Well then. by theghost · · Score: 3, Insightful

    What about insect?
    That is the next step.
    Two consenting adults of the same specifies.


    Insects can't consent - they're not a sentient species. I don't even know what "specifies" they are.

    If you meant incest, then that's different. The argument you're trying to make is a logical bait-and-switch. We're not arguing that issue, but if it does come up as a significant issue, we can deal with it on its own. I haven't seen any incest-rights marches lately, so i'm not inclined to think of this as a pressing concern.

    Black people wanted equal treatment to the whites in the 60's.
    Homosexuals have equal treatment already. They can already marry some one of the opposite sex. What they want is SPECIAL TREATMENT.


    Not precisely. You can look at it as an increase in rights for everyone (straight people can marry other same-sex straight people too) or you can look at it more realistically, as if your head were not encased in your rectum. Straights have the right to have their romantic relationships sanctioned by law, same-sex couples don't. There are thousands of rights associated with marriage - property rights, inheritance, guardianship, adoption - that are currently denied to same-sex couples. That's unequal treatment.

    Comparing the homosexual quest for marriage to civilrights is horrible in logic and in sensitivy.

    Maybe when the butt fucking fags get out and start getting bit by police dogs, killed with buckshot, hit by water cannons, and arrested then you can compare the two. Until then stfu.


    Bullshit. Look up the arguments that were used to defend anti-miscegenation laws. They are the same ones that are used against gay marriage.

    And as to violence, maybe you never heard about a little phenomenon called gay-bashing? Not so different from lynching. Police have been raiding gay clubs, beating up, locking up, and generally persecuting homosexuals for years. I think that qualifies as "until then." Until you get past your uninformed bigotry, stfu.

    --
    The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing.