Slashdot Mirror


Slashback: Wireless, Gasoline, Prevarication

Slashback tonight with story updates on wireless networking on the highway, on the bounce, and among friends, as well as a more pessimistic report on Nigerian scammers, a good reason your car's mileage might not match the EPA's estimate, and a strange response from Macrovision about the copy protection it's employing in European-market CDs. Read on for the details.

It's not a feature, it's a bug. A representative from Macrovision writes "This statement is being issued to address some concerns that were recently aired on Slashdot with regards to the copy protection of some music CDs, the new Beastie Boys CD in Europe in particular.

Macrovision does NOT install any spyware, shareware, malware or any self-replicating code of any kind onto a user's PC.

When playing a (Macrovision CDS-200) copy-protected CD for the first time, playback software components may be installed, if needed. This software is used to enable the on-disc music player to load an on-screen user interface and to play back the audio. For further information, please contact: cds-info@macrovision.com."

Seems to me that a CD which that requires any software installed for it to be played by a standard CD drive is by definition at least "brokenware," or perhaps "meddleware." What if it's being used in a computer without an operating system supported by these "playback software components"?

Definitional evasion aside, so far CD "copy protection" is mostly about as effective as critics proclaim it to be: ptorrone writes "There has been a lot of talk about the copy protection on the new CD 'Contraband' from Velvet Revolver, but for us we didn't have any problems making MP3s for all our devices despite their efforts to stop us it seems. Here's our story..."

MSN Search pales next to Google, so far. An anonymous reader writes "Reported earlier today here on Slashdot, MSN is preparing a new search engine which is set to knock Google's socks off. However, early results show that not only is the new algorithm lacking enough smarts to knock Google as king, it doesn't even compete with the current MSN algorithm."

Open wide and say "ARRL!" dos4who writes "Well, the ARRL Field Day 2004 results are in, and posted on The The American Radio Relay League website. In the Single Operator High-Power class, congratulations to W5ZN for logging a score well over 600,000!

I had the opportunity to witness the Abbotsford, British Columbia club in action, and it was an awesome experience. Just the sight of all those massive antennae clustered on one field invoked visions of E.T. popping in for a visit."

And william_lorenz writes "Our own group from Ohio made contacts all over the United States and had a great time doing it, camping out in tents and running multiple battery-operated radios and make-shift antennas throughout the day and night. We even played with some Slow Scan TV! What are your stories?"

Seems unlikely it's the only country not to have done so ... bluethundr writes "On the flipside of a story from yesterday the Register reports today: 'Malam Nuhu Ribadu says Nigeria is the only country in the world that has failed to apply special laws or establish dedicated "front offices" to combat the crimes.'"

Are you pumping what you think you're pumping? couch_warrior writes "It was noted in a recent /. inquiry that EPA estimates of mileage vary from real-life experience. While there are several factors that can affect this, one major but often overlooked factor is that the amount of gasoline contained in a supposed 'gallon' varies by up to 10% due to gas pump fraud. Two illustrative stories show localized evidence of this scam, but few states regulate gas pumps effectively. The laws are on the books, but enforcement is typically lax. Cynics might speculate that this is because both the State and the Fed are getting a cut of the illegal proceeds. It is a way for them to increase the tax revenue on fuel, without taking the political hit for raising taxes. A challenge for /. readers -- go buy some gasoline in graduated containers, and check for yourself [avoid 1,5, and 10 gallon sizes; many states use these for testing purposes and the computers inside the pumps 'catch up' temporarily at these intervals]. Persons of conscience might feel motivated to flood their local state weights and measures bureau with complaints (if test results warranted :-)"

Never beam your secrets in a cornfield. bgumm writes "Hot on the heels of the Texas DOT's WiFi stories, here comes one from the corn state, Iowa. The Iowa DOT and an Iowan wireless network company, I-Spot Access, have partnered to offer WiFi at six highway rest stops across the state. USA Today picked up the story, as did the Des Moines Register..."

And for those in a state too backward to have rest-stop WiFi just yet, Porsupah writes "WirelessWeek is reporting that Ricochet has been sold on again; this time, to YDI Wireless. Bay Area readers may fondly remember the company as bringing flat-rate 28.8k wireless connectivity to all of the area several years ago for $30/mo, before expanding aggressively to cover several other major US metropolitan areas, financed by MCI, with a nominal 128kbps service at $75/mo. After bankruptcy, Aerie Networks bought some of the remnants, relaunched in San Diego and Denver, and then.. nothing. What next?"

42 of 259 comments (clear)

  1. That stuff about prevarication... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    It's all lies.

  2. Google article inaccuracy? by LaserLyte · · Score: 4, Informative

    From the FlexBeta article:
    Microsoft is working on a new search engine algorithm which is supposed to compete with Google, now that they have upped their hotmail storage in responce to Gmail's arrival.

    Correct me if I'm wrong, but Hotmail has upgraded neither their free accounts nor their paid accounts as of yet. I'm still stuck at 78%, and I have no more than a few MB of mail in my hotmail account.

    1. Re:Google article inaccuracy? by Neil+Blender · · Score: 5, Funny

      Correct me if I'm wrong, but Hotmail has upgraded neither their free accounts nor their paid accounts as of yet. I'm still stuck at 78%, and I have no more than a few MB of mail in my hotmail account.

      They're on it. Right after they finish that security thing they're working on.

    2. Re:Google article inaccuracy? by laiquendi · · Score: 5, Informative
      The storage increase has been announced, but not yet implemented.

      Supposed to be out any day now, but I don't anticipate seeing it until fall.

    3. Re:Google article inaccuracy? by irokitt · · Score: 4, Informative

      Indeed, my inbox is also still tiny.

      Just for kicks, I tried the MSN tech preview, and ran some terms that Microsoft would be expected to fudge (i.e. the infamous X11 term, Linux TCO, and others). From what I can tell, there isn't a bias, but I still doubt that MSN will ever knock Google off the hill, even if everything using Passport does end up there (i.e. Hotmail, and I suspect most of the hits MSN gets never lead to a search query).

      --
      If my answers frighten you, stop asking scary questions.
    4. Re:Google article inaccuracy? by Martin+Blank · · Score: 3, Informative

      Logging in through the interface for one of my accounts, I got the following in the sidebar:

      Coming soon!
      MSN Hotmail Upgrade

      Summer: Virus cleaning of incoming email
      Fall: 250MB of storage for your Inbox
      Fall: Send/receive up to 10MB of attachments
      Keep checking here to learn more!

      --
      You can never go home again... but I guess you can shop there.
  3. CD? by TommydCat · · Score: 5, Insightful

    If it's not redbook, it's not a CD!

    --
    This comment does not necessarily represent the views and opinions of the author.
  4. Alternatively... by Frankus · · Score: 5, Insightful

    ...always gas up in 10-gallon increments.

    1. Re:Alternatively... by Tsiangkun · · Score: 4, Interesting

      This has the makings of a great documentary.

      1) Test the accuracy of the gas pumps for one specific vendor. Inform vendor of results.
      --show retest done next day, next week, and the following month . . . assuming of course it's not an honest mistake that will be fixed.

      2) Get candid interviews with patrons of the station as they watch the video showing the bad measurments and the managments response when they are informed.

      3) Show scenes from the class action lawsuit filed on behalf of anyone who bought gas from specific vendor in the time frame the testing was performed.

      4) Hold flash mob at specific gas station to get incredible riot like footage to hype the film

      5) profit.

    2. Re:Alternatively... by Zapper · · Score: 3, Informative

      Maybe it's when that 10 gallon container is full...
      If your shoes are wet and smell like gasoline then you've probably got more than 10 gallons.

      --
      So much to do, so little bandwidth.
      --
      Try Mozilla
    3. Re:Alternatively... by Eric_Cartman_South_P · · Score: 3, Funny
      BRILLIANT! Seriously! I'm not being sarcastic... brilliant idea. I'm on the road a LOT being self employed, so I can pump 5 or 10 gal at a time, don't need to top it off 'cause I'm at stations a lot. Can't wait to get my extra 1-10% :)

  5. Spyware? Malware? Yes and yes. by NigritudeUltramarine · · Score: 5, Insightful
    Macrovision does NOT install any spyware, shareware, malware or any self-replicating code of any kind onto a user's PC. ... When playing a (Macrovision CDS-200) copy-protected CD for the first time, playback software components may be installed, if needed.
    If the software behaves differently when the CD is played for the first time then indeed it is altering the user's computer, to track how many times the CD has been played (zero, or more than zero for example). That's tracking the user's habits, thus spyware. And, by the fact that it is not made clear to the user that software is being installed on their PC, that's malware in my book.

    I haven't seen the software myself, nor yet found a detailed technical analysis, so I can only speculate beyond that point. But from the descriptions I've seen, I would not doubt that it continues running, even when the CD is not actually playing, using some amount of memory and some small number of CPU cycles. Can you imagine if every audio CD you own installed its own little software in this manner? Personally, I own around 300 CDs, which is not nearly as many as some of my friends. I surely wouldn't want 300 such applications intalled on my system!
  6. That Flexbeta article... by sploo22 · · Score: 5, Interesting

    ...is total and complete FUD. Come on... they searched for "Olympic gold metals." You can't judge the accuracy of the search engine by a query that only finds mistakes. And the number-one Google result for "fastest processor currently available" claimed it to be the Athlon 1.3GHz.

    Overall, the biggest problem with the new MSN search seems to be that it doesn't ignore words like "the" and "what" which shouldn't be in your search in the first place. I hate Microsoft and their anticompetitive tactics just as much as the next guy, but how is this article any better?

    --
    Karma: Segmentation fault (tried to dereference a null post)
    1. Re:That Flexbeta article... by FuzzyBad-Mofo · · Score: 3, Funny

      Leave it to MS to ignore case-sensitivity, until they find a place where it doesn't belong..

  7. A Microsoft Tactic? by artlu · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Does anyone think that microsoft may try to capitalize on people's fears of Google having complete access to email and the like? Seems like it might be a good option for them to attempt even though it would be pure hypocrisy.

    GroupShares Inc. - A Free and Interactive Stock Market Community

    --
    -------
    artlu.net
    1. Re:A Microsoft Tactic? by casuist99 · · Score: 5, Insightful

      It would be hypocritical, but they will probably try it anyway. "Trust the butterfly!"
      Seriously, though, as long as we are willing to allow "free" portals to have access to all of our personal information, how can we get upset when they have access to our personal information?
      MS can hold on to your CC# and passwords and automatically fill them in on sites that require it, if you use hotmail they have your email, and they're trying to improve their crappy search engine that few people use. Oh, and if you use MSN, they've got you that way too.
      Yahoo has shops and stores that I find somehow already know my credit card number (past purchase, no doubt), they have my email (one of my account anyway), and they offer searching, tv-listings, a calendar, etc.
      That's just a few examples of what MS and Yahoo! aleady have from millions of customers. The fact that Google (which has proven itself less scuzzy than its competition) is trying to expand is welcomed by myself and nearly all my friends.
      If you give all your info to a site, don't be surprised if they have all your info at a later date. Convenience and privacy are hard to simultaneously maintain with current services.

  8. Gas pump fraud by daveo0331 · · Score: 4, Funny

    A challenge for /. readers -- go buy some gasoline in graduated containers, and check for yourself [avoid 1,5, and 10 gallon sizes; many states use these for testing purposes and the computers inside the pumps 'catch up' temporarily at these intervals].

    All right, from now on, whenever I buy gas, I'll make sure to buy exactly 5.000 gallons :-)
    I don't want to get ripped off.

    --
    Remember the days when Republicans were the party of fiscal responsibility?
  9. Re:Fraud by Neil+Blender · · Score: 4, Funny

    seems to be the American way of doing buisness thesedays

    How old are you? One?

  10. ricochet by seringen · · Score: 3, Interesting

    When I moved back from switzerland where I had a dual ISDN line in 1994 to santa cruz, i got a ricochet modem. It was really wonderful, albeit very slow. I could go up into the hills between my house and UCSC and sit out on the field, something i can't do too efficiently nowadays. It was fun while it lasted!

  11. Not entirely true. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Assuming this is correct, of course. Also, according to this, copyright protected discs are only banned from using the CDDA logo.

    More accurately, "If it's not redbook, it's not CDDA!"

  12. I've always suspected gas stations... by abertoll · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I've ALWAYS wondered whether or not I'm getting a full gallon, or how accurate those pumps are at gas stations. It doesn't really make me feel good to realize my paranoia was right. I mean it's SO easy, and can be done in such a way that's very hard to detect. If I cut 1 ounce on every gallon of gas I pump who is to say I did it and it isn't just the pump which is a bit inaccurate? Not that it matters, but there ought to be a way that our CARS can tell how much gas has been put into them.

    --
    "he drew his sword Ringil that glittered like ice... and he wounded Morgoth with seven wounds..."
    1. Re:I've always suspected gas stations... by ChipMonk · · Score: 5, Insightful

      There's just one problem with that. A gallon is a measure of volume, which will vary by temperature. The weight of the gas you pump will stay the same, but it's more difficult to calibrate that kind of sensor on the gas tank. So, you have two options:

      Measure volume pumped, and hope your car is level, so that the irregular shape of your tank doesn't affect the sensors inside.

      Measure the weight, hope your sensors are correct, and avoid every pothole on the freeway so as not to wear out the sensors prematurely.

    2. Re:I've always suspected gas stations... by M.+Silver · · Score: 3, Informative

      A gallon is a measure of volume, which will vary by temperature.

      Mod parent up, because it does, and a lot more than you'd expect, too.

      I worked for a company that sold sensors to measure liquid levels, and we'd've sold a heck of a lot more if they'd been practical in gasoline storage tanks. (I'm not sure why we couldn't have just added temp sensors to compensate, other than in large tanks maybe the temp wasn't consistent even through the volume of the gasoline or something.)

      --

      Slashdot's token middle-aged housewife
    3. Re:I've always suspected gas stations... by Thagg · · Score: 3, Interesting

      I read the articles. The KCBS (2) article is interesting. They say that the state tolerates an error of 6 cubic inches in 5 gallons, and that the first pump he tested was off by 50% more than that. Wow! 50% more that legal! But how much is that?

      Well, 5 gallons is 1155 cubic inches, so 6 cubic inches is one-half of one percent. This pump that was off was off one-quarter percent more than that. 1/4% is 5 cents on a 20 dollar fillup.

      I wouldn't be at all surprised if gas stations try to hit that .5% low, but really that's pretty close to the mark. This is nothing compared to, say, the decrease in energy resulting from the mandated blending of ethanol with gasoline.

      In my experience, when the needle in my MR2 gets to E, it always takes within .1 gallon of 11.3 gallons, except for one time when it was considerably more -- and I called the state Weights and Measures people to report that station. The number is on a sticker on the gas pump, might as well attempt to make the system work. Anyway, since it always takes the same amount of gas, I have to think that most stations are either accurate or all cheating by the same amount.

      Thad Beier

      --
      I love Mondays. On a Monday, anything is possible.
  13. Truckstop WiFi by abiggerhammer · · Score: 5, Interesting
    Public WiFi at rest stops is neat and everything, but I've started noticing open WAPs at truckstops as well. For some chains, like Flying J, it appears to be a deliberate choice on the part of the company -- they all have 'flyingj' as their SSID. (Added bonus: at one where I refuelled in Michigan, I couldn't pull an IP under Windows, but it worked just fine under Linux.)

    I go to school in Iowa and my parents live in Texas, so I drive across both states pretty frequently. TxDOT doesn't spend a lot of money on rest stop maintenance, so there may be WiFi, but the bathrooms are nasty. (Iowa rest stops are very nicely outfitted, however, but that's not too surprising, since I-80 is one of the major freight corridors in the US.)

    --
    Dance like nobody's watching. Sing like you're in the shower. Fuck like you're being filmed.
  14. CD Protection Software? by jZnat · · Score: 4, Insightful

    That CD protection software doesn't sound like malware, but more like a step behind in programming by using proprietary software. Hopefully one day we can rid ourselves of proprietary things and get to using standards. I bet those CD decryptor programs are Windows-only also. Blargh...

    --
    'Yes, firefox is indeed greater than women. Can women block pops up for you? No. Can Firefox show you naked women? Yes.'
  15. Other Wi-Fi options for travellers by Einer2 · · Score: 5, Interesting

    For those who travel cheap, a lot of KOAs are also being wired as hot spots. Unfortunately, the access charges tend to be rather steep. I was told at the KOA in Cedar City, Utah that it'd be $3.95 for one hour of access. I get the impression that flat-rate packages are a much better deal, though.

    --
    Microsoft delenda est!
  16. EPA gas mileage differences by darin3200 · · Score: 5, Funny

    EPA estimates of mileage vary from real-life experience

    I've noticed this with my hummer. Its EPA highway mileage was 1.5 mpg but with a nice tail wind I can get it up to 1.7!

  17. erm by DHR · · Score: 5, Funny
    "Just the sight of all those massive antennae clustered on one field invoked visions of E.T. popping in for a visit"

    I think I'd be scared too if I saw a field full of gigantic insects

    ahem.

  18. Re:Spyware? Malware? Yes and yes. by NigritudeUltramarine · · Score: 3, Interesting
    Thus, it only tries to install stuff the first time (because thereafter it works) and it does this without actually running any wares to track usage.
    Yes, but consider that the mere existence of the application shows whether or not the album has been played on your PC. This is only a small step away from the RIAA subpoenaing your hard drive and proving that not only have you played the CD, but that you have no proof of having ever bought it, and thus are infringing a copyright. The slope gets slippery quickly. I'll agree that the software wasn't likely written with the intention of tracking your habits, but to say outright that it doesn't, or can't, is a lie.
  19. Correction to top story - XBox doesn't copy all CD by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Informative

    The Xbox doesn't recognise all CDs out there - had a Smashmouth single I tried to read on my brothers' xbox and it wouldn't recognise it at all...

    Just pointing this out as the link to the mp3's from Velvet Revolver story made it seem like the Xbox would work with every audio CD.

    (and note to the Grammar Nazis - yes, it should be "brothers'" not "brother's" - I have 2 brothers who share the console ;^)

  20. Re:Correction to top story - XBox doesn't copy all by ChipMonk · · Score: 3, Funny

    Well, at least you didn't say "Grammar Nazi's" or "Grammar Nazis'."

  21. That's me! by tji · · Score: 3, Informative

    The picture in the Des Moines register is me! ( http://dmregister.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/2 0040630/NEWS08/406300350/1001&lead=1

    I was driving out to visit family in Michigan, and stopped at that rest stop & noticed they had free wireless access.

    The funny thing is, it didn't work. I could connect to the access point, but I couldn't get beyond that (traceroutes, pings, and any other access stopped at the AP). The photographer called the the iDot people responsible for it, and the telco guys were heading over to fix it, but I didn't stick around.

    1. Re:That's me! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

      Sorry about that! I'm the ISpot guy who installed all of those rest areas. Qwest somehow managed to reassign one of the public payphones to our DSL line and they were still fixing it when you were there. It was back up about 10 minutes after you left. I let the reporter use my laptop to upload that picture to the newspaper because his didn't have wireless!

      -Tom

  22. or you could do this by xyote · · Score: 4, Insightful
    Just check the difference between how much gas they sell and how much they buy from their suppliers.

    I like the old fashioned way of doing it. Just watering down the gas. No gimicky reprogramming of gas pump electronics.

  23. Re:Fraud by minion · · Score: 3, Funny

    seems to be the American way of doing buisness thesedays

    How old are you? One?


    I just saw a History Channel show about the gold rush and copper rush in the 1800s. Seems that the smog and toxic fumes produced from smelting was passed off to the town's people as "good for the complexion" of young women.

    Yeah, what a load of crap.

    "Mommy, my eyes are watering and its hard to breathe!"

    "Quiet Johnny, its good for mommy's skin."

    --

    -- If we don't stand up for our rights, now, there will be no right to stand up for them later.
  24. Think before you test... by ezraekman · · Score: 4, Insightful
    A challenge for /. readers -- go buy some gasoline in graduated containers, and check for yourself [avoid 1,5, and 10 gallon sizes; many states use these for testing purposes and the computers inside the pumps 'catch up' temporarily at these intervals].

    You'd better know what you're doing, or you're wasting your time. According to the article:

    Some people take one of those red, five-gallon containers, fill it up with five gallons of gas and they think that's accurate,'' Pedersen said. "Those portable containers are not calibrated and different weather conditions can change the amount they hold. They are not an accurate measure of five gallons of gas

    I have a feeling that most "graduated containers" that people have are going to have the same issue. Then again, I imagine that the Slashdot community just might be made up of a slightly higher percentage of scientifically-minded individuals. ;-) So, perhaps a few of you might actually have a realistic chance at accuracy. Just bear in mind that the state is going to be using precisely-calibrated instruments, and know how to use them. You'd best do the same, or you'll just look like an idiot.

    1. Re:Think before you test... by grnbrg · · Score: 5, Insightful
      "Portable red plastic containers are inaccurate!"

      "Filling non-approved containers is illegal!"

      "The computers 'catch up' at 1, 5 and 10 gallons!"

      Well, DUH.

      • Buy a cheap 10 gallon red gas container.
      • Take it to your local filling station, and fill it with six or seven gallons of gas.
      • Note the amount the pump claims.
      • Take your mostly full container home, and measure out the gas in the container with an accurately calibrated container of your choice.

      Now if the pump claims 6.83 gallons, and you only measured 6.27 gallons, you can get excited.

      This isn't rocket science. It's stoichiometry.

      --
      grnbrg

  25. Gas Mileage by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

    This make sense to me. I have a bad habit of driving around until the red "get gas now" light comes on. I've noticed a difference of plus or minus a gallions in how many gallon I buy when I fill up. Funny thing the mom and pop gass station always takes the least. And Costco takes the most.

  26. defeating copy protection by nadaou · · Score: 3, Interesting
    Definitional evasion aside, so far CD "copy protection" is mostly about as effective as critics proclaim it to be: ptorrone writes "There has been a lot of talk about the copy protection on the new CD 'Contraband' from Velvet Revolver, but for us we didn't have any problems making MP3s for all our devices despite their efforts to stop us it seems. Here's our story..."


    It doesn't matter that it is a joke. What matters to the record companies is that you have to take pro-active measures to defeat it (holding down the shift button included). That is the trigger for the anti-circumvention clause in the DMCA, and that is what they will be able to go after you for. Defeating the anti-circumvention device is a crime they can send you to jail for, as they can't get you for a free-use copy for your car mp3 player, and non-free-use copyright infringement isn't exactly up there with murder in the eyes of most judges/juries or the law.

    I guess this means if you rip it with GRIP in Linux or with iTunes on the Mac, you're in the clear DMCA wise.....

    --
    ~.~
    I'm a peripheral visionary.
  27. Re:Gas Mileage - filling discrepancies by pwarf · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I've no affiliation with Costco, but how many gallons it takes to fill up until the auto-shutoff is triggered is not necessarily a good indication of whether you are being short-changed. There could easily be a gallon difference in shutoff levels between two gas stations. While filling a gas tank higher does add some risk of it expanding (see other comments about gas expanding up to two percent for a reasonable temperature range) and overflowing, most people drive enough soon after filling up to make the spill risk from thermal expansion a nonissue.

    However, mom and pop stores may have determined it was cheaper to give you more gas than it was to try and get the calibration closer and risk fines for dispensing too little. Sort of like bakers giving out 13 instead of a dozen to avoid serious penalties for shortchanging their customers.

    An interesting sidenote, this article has encouraged me to buy gas in the morning while it is cool instead of afternoons and has given me another reason (the dispensed fuel is typically hotter than that in the tanks at the gas station) to not visit a gas station right after it has received more fuel from a tanker truck (the primary reason not to fill up at a station that just received more fuel is that sediment in the tank is stirred up).

  28. Better idea - fill slowly by the_twisted_pair · · Score: 3, Interesting
    Seriously - I have a friend who works for UKAS (UK accreditation service, checks lab metrology etc) who suggested this.

    Pumps do drift in calibration, but they are calibrated to measure at max. output rate into free air, which allows for a certain amount of vapour, bubbling etc. Stick the nozzle in the tank, crack the valve open and fill as slowly as you can stand - the pump now under-reads the delivered quantity, because it is delivering against static pressure.

    Try it; I've regularly achieved 7-10% more for free on a whole tankful. That's a big deal here in the UK, at 80p+ /litre - about $5.20/US gallon - and no, I don't feel the least bit bad about cheating the Taxman in this way.

    Note that many pump are set to time-out after a few minutes to avoid the potential for being left running onto the forecourt.