Slashdot Mirror


When Gaming Trains You For Work

ac514 writes "Parents should review their education before punishing their children. BBC wrote 'Video game skills and a good poker face online are becoming essential job qualifications in the financial markets, with recruitment drives assessing potential star traders in online gaming exams'. I knew some day these extra hours would pay off."

35 of 105 comments (clear)

  1. Hey... by krymsin01 · · Score: 5, Funny

    It worked for the Last Starfighter.

    --
    stuff
    1. Re:Hey... by TAGmclaren · · Score: 5, Interesting
      seriously though, there have been benefits identified for kids playing games:

      Report 1; warninig pdf

      Schwartz (1988). He set out to compare customary teacher-based tutoring of reading and comprehension with practice on a set of computer games derived from analysis of the reading process. 24 primary school children were selected, who were of average intelligence and who were 18 months or more behind their peers in reading comprehension. The children were split into two groups and assigned to teacher-based tutoring or to a computer game training group where they received practice on four computer games. Training in both conditions focused on word decoding and phonics. The study found that almost all students improved their reading comprehension test scores after training, although the poorest readers made significantly greater gains in the computer game condition than in the teacher training condition

      study 2 - warning pdf:

      "Marble Madness" and effects on spatial skills: A study of 61 children, ages 10 to 11, compared the effects of two computer games on the development of spatial skills--the cluster of skills required for children to visualize and manipulate objects or images in their minds.1 Practice on Marble Madness was found to reliably improve the children's spatial performance, while practice on Conjecture, a computerized word game similar to the TV show Wheel of Fortune, did not. The children playing Marble Madness used a joystick to guide a marble along a three-dimensional grid, trying to keep the marble on the path and prevent it from falling off or being attacked by intruders. After playing the game, children were found to have improved their ability to anticipate targets and visualize spatial paths. ?"Concentration" and effects on iconic skill: A cross-cultural study carried out in Rome and Los Angeles examined the effects of playing a computer game on the development of iconic skills--the skills that enable people to read images such as pictures and diagrams.2Researchers found that after playing the game Concentration on a computer, undergraduate students offered more diagrams in their analysis of an animated simulation of electronic circuits, whereas those who played the game on a board offered more verbal descriptions. ?"Robot Battle," "Robotron," and effects on visual attention skills: A study compared the effects of computer game expertise on college students' visual attention skills, the skills required to keeping track of several different things at the same time--not unlike a pilot keeping track of a row of several engine dials simultaneously.3 Researchers measured participants' response time to two events at two locations on a computer screen, where one target icon appeared more often than another. Predictably, participants who were expert players of Robot Battle (scoring above 200,000) had faster response times than participants who were novice players (scoring below 20,000). But after five hours of playing the game Robotron, all participants responded significantly faster to the target at the low probability position on the screen, demonstrating a causal relationship between playing a computer game and improving strategies for keeping track of events at multiple locations.

      So there's more than just getting a job - there's actually advancing mental development.

      --
      Iran has endorsed
    2. Re:Hey... by ScrewMaster · · Score: 2, Funny

      On the other hand ... he was the last Starfighter.

      --
      The higher the technology, the sharper that two-edged sword.
  2. Poker by Qacker · · Score: 2, Funny

    Its easy as hell to keep a poker face online. Why do you need to train for that?

    --
    Learn lisp today!
    1. Re:Poker by luvirini · · Score: 5, Insightful

      The online pokerface they are talking about is the skill to act cool and not let your emotions run away in your actions. In a way is is actually harder when you do not "see" the other players.

  3. Poker Face? by SharpFang · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Excuse me! Online games isolate you! You can cry, kick and cheer, then reply to the email in ballanced, calm words. But if they call and ask you for a face to face meeting, where's your computer-trained poker face?

    --
    45 5F E1 04 22 CA 29 C4 93 3F 95 05 2B 79 2A B2
    1. Re:Poker Face? by BenjyD · · Score: 2, Insightful

      AFAICS, online gaming trains most people to be complete f***tards. In BF1942 it's enough to make me give up - every server seems full of Tkers, plane-campers, cheats, sniper-tards, non-team-players, base-rapers and stats-whores.
      When you see someone with a 42:1 kill:death put three tank rounds in a row into a panzer *he can't even see* because there's a wall in the way at long range in one game, and then next server have your team of 9 snipers + me overwhelmed by tanks, you start to get a annoyed.

  4. Hmm by n54 · · Score: 4, Funny

    Any job openings for first post? ;)

    But seriously, most finance traders are utter sleazeballs and assholes so the internet and multiplayer games should be good training for them.

    Maybe lawyers too? :)

    --
    this comment is provided "as is" and without any express or implied legibility or congruity [...]
    1. Re:Hmm by mikewas · · Score: 2, Funny
      Lawyers? No!

      A few years ago, where I used to work, I noticed a secretary using the copy machine on our floor. She was from legal & their machine was broken. She was making copies of a 4 inch stack of email printouts.

      Her job was to print all of the emails her boss got, stamp them with a date, then make copies. One copy got filed, the other read by her lawyer boss. She'd then respond to emails per her boss's scribbles, file the annottated hardcopies, print the responses, time stamp & file them.

      I wonder how this guy would handle gaming online?

      --

      "Glory is fleeting, but obscurity is forever." --Napoleon Bonaparte
    2. Re:Hmm by n54 · · Score: 2, Informative

      lol funny story but I know why they did some of it:
      0. I'm sure they did backups of their data, making the "ultimate" offline copies for the archive is adding another level of redundancy to the backup.
      1. dragging your laptop from archive to archive (not the zip kind but the fireproofed steel ones) finding references from a mail can be cumbersome, even a tablet pc loses out to a sheet of paper (or many). Maybe some of those archives are digitized but for really important cases they would still want to find true carbon copies.
      2. same goes for inclusion into court papers, sumbission as evidence, contracts etc., being able to offer a paper printed at receival, stamped by a second person, in addition to an electronic copy carries more weight than just an electronic copy.

      Even with excellent electronic timestamps and digital signatures, paper (done right) will rule the legal world. The two formats aren't mutually exclusive.

      As for games as a learning experience they should get ample training in tediousness by harvesting everything in some of those micromanagement resource-based strategy games like Warcraft2 :)

      --
      this comment is provided "as is" and without any express or implied legibility or congruity [...]
  5. Gaming at work, gaming at home by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    I know I play Solitaire at both places

  6. I'm still wondering... by 88NoSoup4U88 · · Score: 5, Funny
    I'm still wondering why I didn't get through that last job interview though...

    .

    ... it might have been that I yelled 'OMFG, YO FREAKIN' CH34T0R!!!!!oneelevenone!" at the end of it...

  7. Game programming (hobby) got me a job by theluckyleper · · Score: 4, Informative

    I don't know if playing games has helped me much, but I know for sure that my game development hobby got me at least one job.

    I went into the interview with a CD-ROM of all of my past programming work, including a few of my partially completed game projects. When they asked me, "What qualifies you to be our programming guru?" I showed them my games, and they asked me when I could start! I think they understood that game programming is inherently quite complex, and that if I could make spaceships swarm and attack in real-time, I could probably handle the optimization of their relatively simple business applications. And they were right!

    Anyway, that's my story :)

    --
    Visit the Game Programming Wiki!
  8. There are actually many places where games helpful by luvirini · · Score: 4, Interesting
    The fact is, the way our world is getting more and more computerised and at the same time getting shorter and shorter in attention span and quicker and quicker in requiring responses, the skills of quick analysis of things and then acting on them is getting important in many things.

    The traders are just a tip of the iceberg, with the advent of the generation of people who expect instant response to things, the skills of analysing data and leaping to right conclusion most of the time is going to be a major requirement in all fields that deal with humans.

  9. Based on the Traders I know... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    The gold standard in training should involve proficiency in both GTA3 and Leisure Suit Larry.

  10. Whatever happened to our "Future of Pure Leisure"? by Cryofan · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Remember the visions of the future we had decades ago? We saw the future as a place of nothing but leisure for humans, while our machines did the work for us. We would spend our time playing games, instead.

    But it looks more like a Slave Plantation Future, one where even our leisure time has to be dedicated to preparation for work. Gee, I wonder what happened?

    --
    eat shiat and bark at the moon
  11. Whoa.... by FusionDragon2099 · · Score: 3, Funny

    With the experience Simcity's given me over 10 years, I should be a shoe-in for a real mayoring job! Where do I start?

  12. Work? Try "life." by MsWillow · · Score: 5, Interesting

    While growing up, my mom used to tell me that I'd never learn any useful skills by playing video games. Now that I have multiple sclerosis, and cannot work, some of those skills are essential in my daily life.

    What use is being proficient with a joystick? Well, when your main means of locomotion is a power wheelchair, being able to manoever sure helps. Being able to judge speed/distance relationships helps, too - both skills fine-tuned in video game parlours.

    Life sometimes throws us a curveball, and there's no way to really predict exactly what skillset might be useful at every point in time. Video games are just another skill. Arguably more common than, say, brain surgery, but then, just how many brain surgeons does the world need?

    --

    Lemon curry?
  13. Cool! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

    Just added my ladder rankings to my resume.

  14. Oh yeah, ought to work.... by Dark+Lord+Seth · · Score: 3, Funny
    Co-worker: Hey Seth, the other development team managed to convince someone into giving them full access to some of our resources...
    Seth: Damn! Interceptors up front! FORM UP! Have assault frigates attack the flanks, keep a missile destroyer near the heavy cruisers in case bombers fly by! Protect the mothership! FOR HIGAARA!
    Co-worker: Once I find the idiot who hired you I'm going to strangle him...
    Seth: Shut up or I'll TK you.

    Somehow I doubt that will work...

  15. They're not the only ones by HangingChad · · Score: 4, Informative

    The military has used gaming to identify potential recruits for some high value jobs and Google is famous for using puzzles and games to indentify individuals they might want to hire.

    --
    That's our life, the big wheel of shit. - The Fat Man, Blue Tango Salvage
  16. How many scandals does it take? by danharan · · Score: 2, Insightful
    It's one thing to hire people that have great hand-to-eye coordination from hours of Gameboy play, but it's quite another to seek out good liars:
    "After all, in many workplace situations the ability to get away with white lies, to save face or be diplomatic, or to smooth over or disguise mistakes and errors, is a big advantage."
    Hire enough compulsive liars, and the people that are promoted will be the slickest players of the bunch. How long does it take those people to rise to the top? 10, 15 years? You can bet we'll have another wave of Enrons just about then.
    --
    Information: "I want to be anthropomorphized"
  17. Worked for me by Timesprout · · Score: 5, Funny

    The company where I now work were downsizing and I was hired because of my propensity to TK in team games.

    --
    Do not try to read the dupe, thats impossible. Instead, only try to realize the truth
    What truth?
    There is no dupe
  18. Do traders need a poker face? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting

    My vision of these guys is that they spend their entire days sitting in front of a terminal trading strictly on the numbers.

    That being said, most business people need advanced interpersonal skills. That can also be improved with the right kind of computer games. When I taught high school (back when a 386 was a worthy computer), I ran the 'hackers' club. Our computers were networked within the lab and there were a few games that could be multiplayer. The rugged individualists eventually learned that the other guys who cooperated always beat them. They didn't become skilled negotiators but they did learn that they need the help of other people to succeed. I thought that was a worthwhile improvement.

  19. Not listed - Essential Job Qualifications.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Financial Market Job Qualifications...

    1. Being able to parrot in-house analysts information, using words like "paradigm" and "fundamentals" while keeping a straight face and hoping noone asks for definitions

    2. Being able to locate a topless or gogo bar within ten miles of any client's office or home when making a housecall

    3. Being able to polish off an eight-ball without taking off your $150 YSL tie

    4. Being able to "max blast kudos to everyone"

    5. Believing that Gordon Gecko was the hero of Wall Street

    6. Unlike a used car salesman, who will sell his grandmother a lemon, you must be able to sell your grandmother a car that doesn't even exist, and manage to rip her off again when she comes back to complain.

    7. Being able to profit on both turning your client's $10,000 into $100,000 and when you turn $100,000 into $10,000

    8. And finally: Having a GED as your highest level of education, and still call yourself a professional with a title of "Executive Vice President" - as if you are a Wharton MBA.

    No seriously, stock brokers are the lowest form of life in the galaxy. While there are a small handful of exceptions (Certified Financial Planners who are also training Economists or accoutants), most don't give two shits about their clients, their coworkers, their boss or their current firm. They fly around more than IT people and stealing their firm's intellectual property is both tolerated and expected (firms have routine court cases against each other for the practice of using stock brokers as mediums to move high value clients around the block).

    If you can read the newspaper, use online stock analysis tools and place your own orders, you are much better off doing it yourself. Brokers don't have any specific understanding of any market or industry, they don't do their own valuations or formulas and they rely on the same advice that is mostly publicly available for free - and if you have an account with E*Trade or others, you can get the same quality tools that stockbrokers have for free. All they care about is writing tickets, and they don't care if you make or lose money, either way, they get paid.

  20. Can't stay in the game by Japong · · Score: 3, Interesting

    On the subject of online poker, TillerMan, once a top-ranked Warcraft 3 player, stopped playing Warcraft as a "pro" gamer and became a poker player instead, where he apparently now makes several times what he used to as a "cyber athlete".

    Apparently gaming can teach you the skills you need for a very small portion of jobs, but there's little chance of it keeping you employed.

  21. Online real-time RFQ responses by mikewas · · Score: 3, Funny
    One of our customers setup an online site for vendors to bid on supplying them with telecommunications equipment. Vendors' equipment had previously been qualified froom a technical standpoint.

    You could change options like price, delivery & support. The app had algorithms that scored your bid against the rest. The points for technical capabilty were determined from previous trials & fixed.

    It was scheduled for 2 hours, with half hour extensions if there was a change by one of the top 3 in the last 5 minutes. The business would be split by the top 2 bidders -- we were trying for the #2 spot to maximize our revenue.

    At the end (after half a day of this game!) we were surprised to find we were in the #1 spot. The company that we had expected to come out on top, that had been for most of 12 hours, didn't get any business. We found out later that the guy at the keyboard had had a heart attack and they dropped to #4.

    --

    "Glory is fleeting, but obscurity is forever." --Napoleon Bonaparte
  22. Re:Whatever happened to our "Future of Pure Leisur by ScrewMaster · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Uh ... Free Trade? Global Economy?

    "In the Year 2525, if Man is still alive, arms and legs have nothin' to do ... some machine be doin' it for you, oh woe."

    Boy, they sure got that one wrong.

    --
    The higher the technology, the sharper that two-edged sword.
  23. I know slashot helped by teamhasnoi · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Arguing on Slashdot has certainly helped me deal with the developmently challenged people that email me saying, "I can't get my email to work".

  24. Re:Work? Try "life."-Backwards. by ScrewMaster · · Score: 2, Informative

    Helps in job interviews so you can read the interviewer's notes while he's writing them.

    --
    The higher the technology, the sharper that two-edged sword.
  25. Yeah, you just have to remember not to... by mikefe · · Score: 2, Funny

    Yell out...

    No bitch!

    --
    There: Something at a specific location.
    Their: Owned by someone.
    Please make sure your english compiles.
  26. Hone your surgical skills by WomensHealth · · Score: 2, Interesting
    Here's a studypublished this year which confirms an association between video gaming prowess and laparoscopic surgical skills.

    When laparoscopy was first developed, the surgeon would peer directly through a rigid fiberoptic laparoscope to visualize structures within the body, both for diagnostic and therapeutic purposes. Nowadays, we just stick a video camera over the eye-hole on the laparoscope, and watch the pictures in real time on an attached monitor. The hardest part about learning laparoscopy is training your brain and hand so that regardless of the orientation, you can move the instruments in your hand such that they travel onscreen in the direction you intend. It's like using a mouse in three dimensions, but with the additional difficulty that moving the mouse "up" in physical space won't necessarily translate into one's instrument moving "up" on the monitor (and within the patient's abdomen). Once you get the hang of it, it's second nature, and you don't even think about the disconnect between what your hands are doing, and what the instrument is doing onscreen.

    Even before this study was released, I realized that perhaps by playing more video games I could become a better laparoscopist, with the video game controller forcing my mind to overcome the disconnect between my hand movements and the movements of instruments on the monitor. Alas, I've never been into video games. I sold my copy of Halo because I could never get past the first level. Now my Xbox just chugs happily along as a media receiver.

  27. bad use of words by nodwick · · Score: 4, Informative
    Its easy as hell to keep a poker face online. Why do you need to train for that?
    I thought the same thing when I first read the summary. It seems like a poor choice of words, since obviously you don't have to worry about giving away information through your facial tics or whatever online.

    The points they were probably trying to make come up later in the article:

    "It's the discipline of not getting too emotional about your transactions, and also the mathematical ability to keep track of numbers, as in card counting," said Ms McDonnell.

    "It helps to determine if people are bluffing, trying to make the market move one way or another," she said.

    "Poker-playing managers will be used to asking, 'did I play that right?'"

    Those three skills are probably the most important ones that would cross over. The last point is particularly often overlooked, since in poker (much like in the stock market) making the "right decision" doesn't always mean you win every time, because of the influence of random chance. Your opponent can play horribly and catch the one card left in the deck that gives him the win, but his strategy was still a losing one even though he "won" this particular time. Hence, unlike people without this background, poker players are already trained not to be results-oriented, but to be strategy-oriented (focusing on "given the information I had, did I make the right decision") instead.
  28. leisure time = leisure time by mr_angry · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I can't believe how many people are willing to sacrifice their every day life for more money/prestige/profit???

    I mean, when i'm not at work, I DON'T WORK. While some people are so lame at work that they should get extra training, some others are doing everything they can after regular work hours to train more and be more competitive.

    I officially declare that what i do in my spare time is for my own enjoyment (less the dish cleaning but enjoyment isn't easy when your kitchen is home to 132 rare insect species...)

    I just think that we are heading straight into the burn-out generation. I work hard every weekday, many people do. But i think the whole category of people obsessed by performance and money is going to be burning out sooner or later. They can have twice the money i got, the peace i have at home is priceless. I don't have a luxury appartment and can't afford a luxury car but having the possibility to spend time with friends is priceless. People can keep their cash and pseudo standing in business suits. I'm sticking with friends.

    This said, i think video games are one great way to have fun! I play on my gba SP everyday after work when i do the 40 minute bus ride to home. Oh and i want a Nintendo DS. Playing Animal Crossing anywhere is bound to be one of the leetest thing ever :)

    --
    100% of statistics are wrong.
  29. Just a marketing ploy to attract day traders by Swanktastic · · Score: 2, Informative

    First off, these 'employees' are really day traders who are paying a commission to get access to the firm's software and hardware connections into the Chicago Mercantile Exchange. They're not real employees in any sense of the word. The more "employees" this Geneva Trading attracts to its company, the more money it makes.

    What better marketing angle to exploit than 'people who are good at video games can make tons as traders?' You get a bunch of suckers in there who are told they're great and they blow through their cash. The only beneficiary is Geneva Trading. These kids aren't investment bankers or anything even close.