Slashdot Mirror


Make Your Own Cluster Balloon

Mr. Christmas Lights writes "'Have you ever dreamed of being carried into the sky by a giant bouquet of colorful toy balloons?' John Ninomiya does exactly that using 50-150 four-seven foot diameter balloons filled with helium ... and sealed with tape (duct?) and cable ties. Folks may recall the lawn chair man who floated up to 16,000 feet, but John takes this to a whole new level and his site has some wild pictures ... and includes the comment 'Kids, don't try this at home!'"

58 of 243 comments (clear)

  1. The inevitable question... by Chairboy · · Score: 3, Funny

    If you were a sixth century Scandinavian warrior out to kill a Grendel, and providence provided you with one of these clusters, what would you call it?

    1. Re:The inevitable question... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

      Pretty fucking useless. Grendel lived underground

    2. Re:The inevitable question... by dogen · · Score: 2, Funny

      Himmel-belysning kjempemessig ballen. Lighter than air giant gonoidal units.

    3. Re:The inevitable question... by anagama · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Yeah, but then there would be no need to arrive by ship. In any event, John Gardner's book "Grendel", which tells the story from Grendel's perspective, is my favorite book of all time. Beowulf is a prick and deserves a cluster f .... ahem.

      --
      What changed under Obama? Nothing Good
  2. Mary Poppin's by Kevin+Mitnick · · Score: 5, Funny

    Call me when we have an umbrella that lets you fly through the clouds

  3. The lawnchair guy by tuxlove · · Score: 2, Funny

    He eventually committed suicide, though it's unclear if it had anything to do with the amount of ridicule he received as a result of the lawnchair incident. All he needed to do was to make it look like he flew away on purpose, and nobody would be any wiser. Kind of like the guy in this article. :)

    1. Re:The lawnchair guy by Quikah · · Score: 2, Informative

      Uh, a hellfire is an anti-tank air to ground missile. Not that useful for downing a floating lawnchair. Stinger missiles (shoulder launched ground to air) might work though.

      --
      Q.
  4. More information... by WalterGR · · Score: 5, Informative

    The lawn-chair man sounded like a hoax to me, but snopes.com (which we all know is the final word in urban legends) claims it's true!

    My favorite part:

    As Larry and his lawnchair drifted into the approach path to Long Beach Municipal Airport, perplexed pilots from two passing Delta and TWA airliners alerted air traffic controllers about what appeared to be an unprotected man floating through the sky in a chair.

    1. Re:More information... by mercuryresearch · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Assuming he's licensed (which this guy -- but not lawn chair guy -- is).

      The basic rule for right of way for aircraft is the the lesser manuverable craft has the right of way.

      So it goes like baloons, airships, airplanes, helicopters.

      Also, the "lawn chair guy" is dead, of suicide.

      It's definitely NOT an urban legend, I remember when he first did it -- made national news. The story still routinely pops up in pilot magazines.

      And to echo the cluster ballooning guy's advice: don't try this at home without training. I'm a licensed airplane pilot, and have crewed on hot air balloons a few times in New Mexico during their annual ballooning orgy. IMHO piloting balloons takes more skill as they're so much less manuverable you need to be considerably better at planning. Figuring out you don't have that skill while airborne is a bad thing.

      Heighting the terror factor is that when you're screwed you usually know about it well before the actual you're-screwed event takes place, and get to experience it in slow motion.

    2. Re:More information... by Geoffreyerffoeg · · Score: 4, Informative

      Yes. FAR 91.113, "Right-of-way rules: Except water operations," subsection (d)(1): "(1) A balloon has the right-of-way over any other category of aircraft." Generally, the craft that is hardest to maneuver has the right-of-way.

  5. Re:four-seven by marco0009 · · Score: 2, Informative

    *cough* Quote from the article: "The balloons range in size from four to seven feet; depending on the mix of sizes, anywhere from 50 to 150 balloons may be needed."

    --
    Physics makes the world go 'round.
  6. From the pictures... by kai5263499 · · Score: 4, Funny

    that looks like a prime position for a serious wedgie...

    --
    -Wes
  7. Yay! by Anubis333 · · Score: 4, Funny

    Sounds like we will have some new Darwin Award entries this year!

  8. For a movie inspired by the Lawnchair Man by lou2ser · · Score: 2, Informative

    Check out Danny Deckchair. Its relativly new, and recieved decent reviews.

    http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0337960/

  9. Mythbusters on helium balloons... by outofservice · · Score: 3, Informative
    The Mythbusters (Discovery Channel) did a segment on what it takes to get liftoff from helium balloons.

    From http://dsc.discovery.com/fansites/mythbusters/epis ode/episode_06.html:

    So, this guy named Larry Walters attached something like 45 weather balloons to this lawn chair. One of the tethers broke on the unemployed truck driver's little invention, shooting him straight up into the air. Apparently he sailed to 16,000 feet, where he was spotted by airline pilots, eventually closing LAX airport. He was finally rescued by a helicopter after he floated out to sea. Is this popular Internet legend full of hot air? Will Jamie and Adam close LAX?


    They tried doing this, and let's just say it took a LOT of balloons to get a young girl even neutrally buoyant.
    1. Re:Mythbusters on helium balloons... by Eric(b0mb)Dennis · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Well, it's not a 'popular internet legend' it just became one.

      It happened in the eighties, somewhere around 97 it started to go around the internet with numerous facts changed, including ""A helicopter after he floated out to sea"

      He actually got tangled in powerlines.

      Don't these 'mythbusters' do their freaking homework? god

      --
      Excuse me, I don't mean to impose, but I am the ocean
    2. Re:Mythbusters on helium balloons... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

      They tried doing this, and let's just say it took a LOT of balloons to get a young girl even neutrally buoyant.

      You're thinking of the one where the Mythbuster assistants filled regular helium party balloons to lift a child up. That was of a myth of a child being lifted up by a carnival balloon seller handing the child his whole lot, which did take several thousand to lift her.

      The one they did with weather balloons, which are MUCH larger, took substantially less to lift Jamie. 55 to be exact.

    3. Re:Mythbusters on helium balloons... by 1337+Twinkie · · Score: 3, Informative

      Indeed, it took them 3000+ baloons to levitate the little girl. Those ballons, hoever were of the average carnival variety. Also, at the time, they were testing the myth that a small child could be carried away by a large bouquet of carnival balloons, a la Mr. Bean.

      The Mysthbusters did a separate segment on "Lawnchair Lary" using large weather ballons. They also tested whether or not a pellet gun could be used to burst ballons to reduce altitude (as reported in the story). I know that they got the lawnchair off the ground (with adult pilot), but I don't remember the outcome of the pellet gun test.

    4. Re:Mythbusters on helium balloons... by Guru2Newbie · · Score: 2, Funny
      They tried doing this, and let's just say it took a LOT of balloons to get a young girl even neutrally buoyant.

      But Pamela Sue Anderson and Anna Nicole Smith only needed four between them for a heckuva lot more buoyancy! (and if I was between them, I sure wouldn't be neutrally buoyant).

  10. Re:What a waste... by Nine+Tenths+of+The+W · · Score: 5, Funny

    Yes. The Pentagon has to plan for all eventualities, including invasion by an army of angry clowns

    --
    Slashdot: News for Nerds, Stuff that matters only to them
  11. so far as oversized helium balloons go.. by way2trivial · · Score: 2, Interesting
    I wondered in my life- more than once, if you only wanted to SLOW DOWN someone jumping off a building, say due to a flaming jet being inbetween you and the ground floor.

    how much helium/how large of a tank/baloon to produce enough lift and wind resistance to lower you to the ground with, at best, a broken leg... something between a hot air baloon and a $2.00 mylar in size, and only created to drop you at survivable impact speeds....

    --
    every day http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Random
    1. Re:so far as oversized helium balloons go.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

      A man sized slingshot might just send you on a collision course with another building.

      Sounds like something from the Simpsons...

      Homer: Oh no! The building's on fire! No problemo, I'll just sit on this slingshot and fire away to safety...

      [Shot of Homer flying off and through the window of a building with the sign "World's Tallest Bed-Of-Nails Factory"... Sounds of Homer bouncing around...]

      Homer: Ow! Ow! Ow! Oooww!

  12. Re:four-seven by ryanmfw · · Score: 2, Insightful
    Yes, I have no clue why I posted that. I believe I am going insane. ;)

    Cheers, Ryan

    --
    Hurricane Ivan: A 17th century prison collapsed. All of the inmates escaped.
  13. Re:What a waste... by bm17 · · Score: 2, Informative

    Yes. Most of the world's helium comes from a bubble in an oil well in Texas. Once it is released it drifts off into space.

  14. Hmmm... by Rorschach1 · · Score: 5, Funny

    Let's see, in my bedroom and garage, I've got on hand:

    * Paraglider harness
    * Reserve parachute
    * Helium
    * Balloons
    * Duct tape
    * Oxygen cylinders and masks
    * Warm clothes
    * Flight helmet
    * GPS
    * Handheld radio
    * BB gun

    And here I was wondering what to do with my weekend.

    1. Re:Hmmm... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

      Excellent! I, too, have an open weekend. Perhaps we could meet up? In my garage and bedroom I have:

      * A large first-aid kit.

    2. Re:Hmmm... by Cable_Monkey · · Score: 2, Funny

      What part of the world are you from? If you are from the southern U.S., let me know when you are going to attempt this. I shall sit in my front yard with popcorn. ;-)

    3. Re:Hmmm... by Epistax · · Score: 2, Funny

      And now you know! Give out a bunch of helium-filled balloons to little kids in the big city. Get atop the highest building in the area. You'll need to use ogygen tanks for air up there and the warm clothes will come in handy. Now shoot the little kids' ballons from the top of the building. Use the radio to tell when the police are coming. Wear a flight helmet so the police can't identify you. Once they are almost on you, jump off the building utilizing a hybrid paraglider/parachute device (duct tape required). Try to drift into a heavily wooded area. Finally, use the GPS device to find your way home.

  15. Can not go too high by asadodetira · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I remember in a fluid dynamic course we did some balloon calculations, and one conclusion was that baloons are unstable, as they go up, the pressure decreases, so the gas keeps expanding until it bursts. I guess this might be different with a real materials, I don't recall how you model the elastic membrane stuff.

    1. Re:Can not go too high by Hans+Lehmann · · Score: 2, Informative

      I think your calculations were wrong. I remember the original event, it was all over the TV news. Also, sounding baloons are launched routinely. They rise until their expansion causes their weight to equal that of the air that they displace. They then tend to hover at that altitude until the helium leaks out.

      --
      09 F9 11 02 9D 74 E3 5B D8 41 56 C5 63 56 88 C0
    2. Re:Can not go too high by windows · · Score: 3, Informative

      They're only flying as high as about 20,000 feet at the most. The pressure up there is about 500 mb. Sea level pressure is approximately 1000 mb. Consider an experiment at the surface where we inflate a balloon in a 1000 mb environment. We then keep the same temperature, but drop the pressure to 500 mb. That means for the balloon to maintain equal pressure with its surroundings, it must double in volume. That means, since volume is a three dimensional quantity that the diameter must increase by the cube root of 2. The diameter is only 1.26 times what it was before. Even at 125 mb, the balloon would only be twice its previous size.

      The 300 mb level in the atmosphere is around 32,000 feet. That's higher than the peak of Mt. Everest. Unless you brought oxygen tanks along, you would almost certainly be unconscious at that pressure. And yet in our surface experiement, at 300 mb, the balloon would only have a diameter of 1.49 times its diameter at 1000 mb.

      And if your balloon is still intact at 300 mb and you're still conscious, you'd have more to worry about than your balloon bursting. You're likely to encounter some pretty strong winds at that altitude which might make steering a bit of a challenge.

      But unless you fill your balloon almost completely full at the surface, you'd likely be unconscious before you'd see your balloon burst.

  16. Oh My... by dallask · · Score: 2, Funny

    This is going to get at least ONE slashdotter killed....

    Great photos though.

    --
    The Code Ninja is swift with his tool, precise in his delivery, and deadly accurate in his execution.
  17. Re:In Korea... by iiioxx · · Score: 3, Funny

    I can't imagine what i would do if suddenly i was 16,000 feet high in a freaking LAWN CHAIR

    Yell "I'm a birdie!" and shit on passing cars?

    Just a thought...

  18. Comment removed by account_deleted · · Score: 4, Funny

    Comment removed based on user account deletion

  19. Re:four-seven by jfengel · · Score: 2, Interesting

    You end up with 100 non-holes in negative space. It must be spectacular to look at.

  20. Helium by zoeith · · Score: 2, Funny

    There is only so much Helium around... a very valuable resource. Please use hydrogen instead if you decide to try this at home.

    --
    Zoeith
    1. Re:Helium by Big+Bob+the+Finder · · Score: 2, Informative
      Helium is produced as a function of radioactive decay in the lab (or, in larger quantities, in nuclear reactors). The quantities are not commercially viable.

      Commercial quantities of helium come out of the ground in Texas. People think the Strategic Helium Reserve was such a big joke. Except for the fact that without helium, we can't make computer chips, can't do inert gas welding, can't do a lot of science and (most important) can't make squeaky voices at kid's parties. So, the government has decided it's in the best interests of all to privatize the collection, storage, and the distribution network for what is a non-renewable, economically critical element.

      Even Wired magazine has mentioned the potential helium shortage. We'll run out eventually. The American Chemical Society puts it at around 2015. That's not good. The spring of 2002, there was enough of a shortage that the distributors of air products had to clamp down on helium- there was rationing for a few months. And the government's concept is to *privatize* it. Wonderful.

  21. Re:What a waste... by cheese_wallet · · Score: 4, Informative

    "There is only so much left in the strategic reserves."

    There is enough helium in the US reserves to supply the states for 100 years, or the world for 10. I don't think this guy made a dent.

    http://www.agiweb.org/gap/legis104/heliumup.html

  22. Safety by OverlordQ · · Score: 2, Informative

    From the Site:
    Latex balloon clusters have been flown as high as 20,000 feet; however, for a recreational flight, a maximum altitude of 3,000 - 5,000 feet is more common.

    From a BASE Jump site:
    The safety margin in a normal free fall exercise is 800 metres (~2600 feet), the minimum height at which a jumper may deploy the chute safely

    So basically if something farks up, your really farked.

    --
    Your hair look like poop, Bob! - Wanker.
    1. Re:Safety by CvD · · Score: 2, Informative

      Minimum exit height for skydiving is around 2500 feet, but this is not recommended. We regularly jump from 3500 feet. No problem there, you just don't get much freefall time (couple seconds). I'm not sure how fast a paragliding reserve opens, but with regular chutes you need at most a couple hundred feet to open a parachute if you're doing a 'hop & pop' where you open your chute right after leaving the plane. This would the case as well, where the pilot of the cluster would find himself descending too fast, and decides to bail out... he would basically be cutting away from a low downward velocity (not freefall speeds - 120 MPH) and immediately opening his reserve, so he would only need a couple hundred feet.

      And I don't know which base jump site you got your information from, but BASE jumpers usually jump from objects which are less than 2600 feet high. Probably the lowest object ever jumped was the Jesus statue in Rio de Janero.

      The only problem I see with his setup is the extra balloons tied to his hands and feet... The harnas will not cut those away when you are in trouble, and they could severely tangle with your reserve parachute, which is not a good thing...

    2. Re:Safety by nikolas · · Score: 2, Insightful

      While normal parachutes are built to open comfortably (so skydivers dont have an acheing back after every jump), reserves are made to open rather _quickly_. A reserve can be deployed below 500m and still slow you down in time before you reach the ground.

      The CYPRES emergency opening device for example deploys at an altitude of 750ft (230m). The reserve chute still has enough time to open at that altitude.

      Skydivers have a problem that we would not have with our balloon cluster: they deploy at terminal velocity (around 180 km/h, maybe a little more), so at 500m they would only have something like 2.5 seconds left to react. With a cluster of balloons, ideally your initial vertical speed will be a lot lower.

    3. Re:Safety by pcraven · · Score: 2, Informative

      I'm a balloon pilot, and get questions like this a lot. Balloons don't fail at altitude. If you have a problem, it is because you hit power lines, a tower, etc. 99% of problems with balloons occur within 100 feet of the ground.

      Also, maximum descent for a hot air balloon is the same as a military parachute. So using a parachute would be kind of pointless.

      I only know of one cases of balloons failing at altitude. It was a mid-air collision between balloons. Even then, the pilot survived. A streamering balloon slowed him down just enough.

      Actually, balloons are pretty safe. They can take a lot more damage than any other aircraft I know of and still get you down to the ground ok.

  23. Re:What a waste... by bm17 · · Score: 3, Informative

    Yes, it floats off into space. Where did you think it went? It's lighter than molecular O2 and N2. If you don't believe me, check the wikkipedia or google for "strategic helium reserve". I weld with the stuff and I breath the stuff when I dive shipwrecks with a closed-circuit rebreather. I have a vested interest in knowing.

  24. Re:What a waste... by bm17 · · Score: 3, Funny

    It's not funny. When I was seven my parents were killed by an angry clown.

  25. Warballooning? by kinema · · Score: 2, Funny

    We've seen wardriving, warflying, warboating I think the obvious next step is warballooning.

  26. Re:What a waste... by bm17 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    No, there is enough in the reserve to supply the US government to 100 years, the entire US for ~15 years, or the world for about 10 years. The world helium supply is limited and non-renewable. Just like oil. However, when oil runs out we can use solar and alcohol and biodiesel. There is no substitute for helium.

    I didn't mean to come off as the Grinch. People like this guy are hardly putting a dent in the supply compared to those damn blimps that leak huge amounts of crude helium (Ne/He) into the atmosphere. I also hate those toy ballons they give to kids. It's another waste of helium and the balloons wind up in all sorts of environmentally unfriendly places.

    But I think I have to make an exception for these cluster balloon guys. I think the increase in human spirit and morale far outweighs the reletively small amount of helium used. I'd love to do it myself.

  27. Try this AT HOME! by InfiniteWisdom · · Score: 2, Funny

    Kids, don't try this at home
    On the contrary, if you want to try this, do it at home... that way you won't find yourself floating at 16,000 feet unless you have an exceptionally weak roof.

  28. The concept is right, but some of your math is not by expro · · Score: 2, Informative

    A one meter/three foot balloon has 27 times the lift of a 33 cm/one foot balloon, etc.

  29. Official "Lawn Chair Pilot" site by mcrbids · · Score: 4, Informative

    Go here to get the full skinny on the REAL lawn chair pilot, complete with streaming audio, pictures, maps, the works.

    It was on Art Bell a few years ago....

    --
    I have no problem with your religion until you decide it's reason to deprive others of the truth.
  30. Re:What a waste... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative
    Since you seem incapable of looking it up yourself, I did it for you:

    Abundance

    Helium is the second most abundant element in the known universe after hydrogen and constitutes nearly a quarter of the mass of the universe. It is concentrated in the stars, where it is formed from hydrogen by the nuclear fusion of the proton-proton chain reaction and CNO cycle. According to the Big Bang model of the early development of the universe, the vast majority of helium was formed in the first three minutes after the Big Bang.

    However, the concentration of helium in the Earth's atmosphere is only 1 part in 200,000, largely because most helium in the Earth's atmosphere escapes into space due to its inertness and low mass. All considerable helium on Earth is a result of radioactive decay. The decay product is found in minerals of uranium and thorium, including cleveites, pitchblende, carnotite, monazite and beryl. There are also small amounts in mineral springs, volcanic gas and meteoric iron. The greatest concentrations on the planet are in natural gas, from which most commercial helium is derived. The principal source in the world is the natural gas wells of the American states of Texas, Oklahoma, and Kansas.
  31. Re:What a waste... by mrhartwig · · Score: 2, Informative

    From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helium:
    "...the concentration of helium in the Earth's atmosphere is only 1 part in 200,000, largely because most helium in the Earth's atmosphere escapes into space due to its inertness and low mass."

  32. Re:What a waste... by Artifakt · · Score: 2, Funny

    You missed a great chance to use the "You Insensitive Clod" header there.

    --
    Who is John Cabal?
  33. Can't Take It With You? Maybe You Can! by Tackhead · · Score: 2, Funny
    > This is going to get at least ONE slashdotter killed....
    >
    >Great photos though.

    What, the photos on the site, or the photos and video our soon-to-be-deceased Slashdotter will be streaming back to his webserver as he falls screaming to his death, practically guaranteeing a simultaneous appearance on both Slashdot and Fark.

    Hmm, a late-model ruggedized laptop equipped with wireless and a dozen pringles cans to guarantee that at least one Starbucks is at range after the crash... it'll survive the impact, but nothing will survive a Slashfarking. You can take it with you!

    (I mean, think of the Afterlife. Oh, sure, you might go to the place where Tux gives everyone an iPod and a rack or two from ACSI Ultraviolet, but what if you wind up in the Other Place, with that chubby guy condemned to jump around and yell "Developers" for all eternity? Wouldn't you want to have at least one of your own servers with you?)

  34. Re:What a waste... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative
    Tell that to an analytical chemist who has his gas chromatograph explode because he has to run hydrogen instead of helium as the carrier gas. Sure, you get better resolution with hydrogen, but helium is safer. Add on to that the fact that in Europe, chemists collect and recycle their helium, one starts to appreciate the value only when there was a shortage. Ask any analytical chemist how their helium was rationed two summers ago- they'll remember it.

    Helium has utility in places where you'd never think about- heliarc welding, or any inert gas welding (TIG, MIG, etc.), for example. Welding aluminum isn't the same without it. Liquid fuel rocketry uses it to drive the fuel. It has innumerable cryogenic applications that are irreproducible with any other element. You can't grow silicon or germanium crystals without it, so kiss your computer chips and cell phones goodbye without it. The tests used to throw sizable chunks of foam into a Shuttle wing to simulate what happened to Columbia were done with a light gas gun- which uses helium to create a shock wave of sufficient velocity.

    Everyone thinks it's a big joke, a "strategic helium reserve." Truth be known, were it not for the eccentric and vast natural gas fields of west Texas that have very high concentrations of helium, we'd be up shit's creek without a pooper scooper on this one. Fact is, we can lord over other countries that require helium for their own purposes.

    Supplies are finite, and we're pissing it away on toy balloons. What a waste. Let 'em use hydrogen instead. Maybe they can do a Hindenburg. How's that for substituting for helium?

  35. Re:Well by anagama · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I dount you are in the minority with this fantasy. I clearly remember youthful days spending hours upon hours sitting on the back porch looking up at the sky and dreaming about floating off over the fields. This was around first grade, so that would be roughly 1975. I think the trigger was seeing an ad for giant baloons in a comic book. The flying/floating fantasy has been with me in one form or another since then. I have nothing but respect for this guy.

    --
    What changed under Obama? Nothing Good
  36. Re:What a waste... by bm17 · · Score: 2, Funny

    Hey, I'm new here, you insensitive clod.

  37. Re:Let's run some numbers! by Council · · Score: 2, Informative

    wrong. a) if you want velocities that slow, for most of your flight you're gonna be going even slower than your landing so ignore drag for now. You need to figure out the size of the balloon to provide a force resisting gravity for your dude. Helium will give a lift of something like 1.13 kg/m^3 around sea level at stp (iirc, my little bro asked me when he was building a balloon). So do some math, what radius gives you (1.13)(4/3)pi*r^3=100? Something around 2.5 I guess. If your radius is much bigger than 2.5 meters you'll float away. Now, if you get down to say 1.3 meters, where (again just by estimating) you'd have like half the bouyancy force, you're still talking about high impact speeds. You need to get pretty close to neutral weight if you wanna not hit hard. 1m/s is pretty slow, you can handle an impact of maybe 7m/s without broken bones too much, that's the highest I've fallen from. But 12m/s is the point where the fall is more likely fatal than not, a height of about 7m.

    Anyway to summarize, you need to get down to a speed where drag force is negligable so ignore that. You need a balloon radius that gets your effective weight pretty close to 0, then go a little smaller but not too much. You get an upper limit on size by solving (1.13)(4/3)pi*r^3=mass, and the balloon size will be between 2 and 3 meters.

    --
    xkcd.com - a webcomic of mathematics, love, and language.