Slashdot Mirror
eBay Starts Open-Source Community
Matt wrote to mention a MacWorld story discussing a new initiative by auction site eBay to open source parts of its search functionality, in order to expand their coder resources. From the article: " The software will be available under a new program called Community Codebase, which was announced at the eBay Developers Conference in San Jose, California, on Tuesday. The Community Codebase is free for all members of eBay's Developers Program and PayPal Developer Network. (Pay Pal is owned by eBay.) It allows individual developers and companies to access source code for various eBay and PayPal tools and applications. An example is a Java application that allows TiVo users to search and bid on items via their digital video recorder boxes. Other examples include a Firefox toolbar, various Pay Pal toolkits and an application used to extract information from Pay Pal's database and putting it into Microsoft Corp.'s Excel spreadsheet software."
What does eBay expect to give back to the OSS-Community?
I think they will only take and give nothing back!
Talk about stupid... eBay already sucks, so they want to share it.
What exactly is the definition of 'open source'. Could you open code to a specific community and still call it open source?
eBay to open source parts of its search functionality, in order to expand their coder resources.
Isn't this the same eBay that was suing people who were making auction search sites that linked to eBay items?
You say things that offend me and I can deal with it. Can you?
Currently eBay charges as little as a hundred dollars but up to $50,000 dollars before you can run your code against the production database. I think the open source move is a good one however some of us developers with limited resources won't be jumping on until it is "free as in beer".
EBay is a respected player in the business world. They are seen as an ecommerce model that works. When a "real" company with "real" profits suddenly starts looking to the Open Source community, it validates the Open Source model to investors, capitalists, etc...
The significance of this move is beyond EBay.
One ring to bind them - should probably have more fiber and less rings in their diet.
Microsoft Corp.'s Excel spreadsheet software
I read that as "Microsoft Corp.'s Excellent spreadsheet software". I thought the world was going to end or something.
Send email from the afterlife! Write your e-will at Dead Man's Switch.
While I applaud the small amount of legitimacy this may add to the open source community, it appears this may be just a way to make money off the open source community rather than truly help it. Open source is free and always will be (unless you count the s**tload of work that goes into it). On the other hand, this could also be used to help open source people make some money back for their invaluable efforts. The cynic in me thinks it's the former though, not the ladder. Only time will tell.
This seems to be a trend now. After Google (and I think Yahoo and Amazon), MSN will be now under pressure to go somehow the open source road. They will probably vehemently protest, try resist, twist things their own way and explain how open source is bad, but they can't go against the tide and ultimately one day or another they will follow.
It allows individual developers and companies to access source code for various eBay and PayPal tools and applications.
Or, phrasing it another way, it allows Ebaypal to take advantage of work done for them for free by someone else.
"A door is what a dog is perpetually on the wrong side of" - Ogden Nash
The term open source is not a trademark, and you can legally use it any way you want.
Whenever I do a search on Ebay, I always find ridiculous auctions. Just do a search for a Powermac G5 and you'll see what I mean. There are inevitably those auctions with buy it now of $29 where they claim you'll get a system for free. Of course, I look past those but it would be nice if someone could write a moderation tool that would allow you to filter your results. Perhaps with ebay opening up their systems a bit, a crafty developer could go in and make changes such as this, which would markedly improve the ebay experience.
Finance tutorials and more! Understandfinance
Hmm I see this trend more and more within the open source comunity, A company "Opens its Source" to the world, but it only opens small pecies of what it does, and/or puts it under restrictive licences that essentially say you have no ownership of any modified code ergo the orginating company owns copyright to all versions of the code that are made.
So what exactly IS the incentive to work on it, if all you are doing is ensuring that the company gets a better product, and that you have no legal right to implement the code without permission?
From time to time I purchase stuff online, but I have never used eBay. I wanted to register several times at eBay, but their conditions - we can do whatever we want to do with your data (read the license agreement very carefully) - were each time enough to convince me to simply contact the webshops directly. Anyway, for some reason I have troubles reading "eBay" and "open source" in one line. It just does not feel good.
Weird. The E-Bay source code appeared on TPB yesterday. Coincidence?
Caesar si viveret, ad remum dareris.
If they opensourced their auction code it might be something, but to open source just the search part o f it seems like it would barely benefit the developer and most certainly benefit ebay. Nothing wrong with that I guess, but I don't think the value is their for the developer.
Ebay certainly doesn't make it intuitive to report suspicious/fraudulent auctions. I did a recent search for Canon 1ds Mark 1 cameras and I found one listed for about 2k under it's normal price. In looking at the seller's other items, I discovered about 60 high priced tech items ranging from miniDV camcorders to plasma monitors, all listed in lots of three and ending at the same time.
Checking the seller's previous ebay activity, it contained only small purchases of seeds and gardening supplies and then lay dormant for a year until suddenly about 60 high priced items showed up.
That took about 3 minutes of work to check out, but I had to spend another 20 minutes trying to figure out how to report a fraudulent auction to ebay.
I think they really just don't want to be bothered with policing their own site and responding to complaints, and that's pretty unfortunate as their service is amazingly efficient and well-liked in nearly every other respect.
:::: the insomniac's digest
TFA didn't mention anything about which license they're going to use for the code. I hope we don't find another "OSI approved" license coming out of this.
If so, developers will soon have to become lawyers simply to distinguish which license is appropriate before adding anything.
IANAT, but i'm sorry, i am so sick of major corporation taking advantage of the "open source" hype simply for the benefit of their business.
/me steps off box of detergent
it helps them in two ways right off the bat:
1. it's a marketing gimic, because the news gets spread (as here) and
2. it garners them a better image immediately, because regardless of whether a single line of code gets written, they look good for being so magnanimous.
and if it DOES get written, then you can add #3 to that list: free code for ___, inc.
free software should be a *given* -- not some special marketing campaign.
for sure. yeah
Sure they just decided to do it. Not at all prompted by a rival online payment system to their subsiduary company which doesn't have the best reputation.
Example quote:
"Analysts on Monday said the biggest and most immediate risk to PayPal from a Google payment system would be a cap on growth in PayPal's off-eBay business, prompting a 2 percent drop in eBay shares."
Hmmm, let's compare a vague promise to open 'parts' of search functionality (only to registered eBay and PayPal developers) to Google's Summer of Code shall we? Let's face it, eBay still don't look like they "get it" and I doubt this attempt to get free labour will gather much momentum.
Phillip.
Property for sale in Nice, France
development of user enhancements. Onerous fees, Obfuscated interface, and threats.
It's no longer in my interest to develop around ebay. There are too many ther interesting things going on now. IMO, ebay management has missed the boat.
CAUTION! Read any licensing carefully to make sure you don't share or assume liability for ebay problems by virtue of your interface.
The Community Codebase is free for all members of eBay's Developers Program and PayPal Developer Network
If you have to be a member of some "developer program" or "developer network", then the code isn't open source. The term "Community Codebase" also suggests that it isn't open source, but that it is a program like Microsoft's "Shared Source" or Sun's "Community Source". Let's hope that eBay didn't mislabel a non-open source license as open source.
Even if the eBay code turns out to be truly open source, it is still closely tied to eBay's service. On balance, it's still better if such code is open sourced, but the decision for eBay to open source a bit of client code is a completely different business decision than, say, IBM or Intel open sourcing a compiler.
Companies like Sun, Microsoft, and (possibly) eBay seem to be trying hard to redefine the term open source for their own marketing purposes. Don't let them get away with it. A company that misapplies the term open source is being deceptive and should be condemned strongly.
(I suppose it isn't surprising that someone like McVoy would go along with this sort of thing; he has, after all, been trying to take advantage of the open source community as well.)
It gets a little old to see all these companies jumping on the latest trendy bandwagon. Google got a lot of well-deserved, positive press for its very innovative SoC idea. And Google has been reaping the rewards of encouraging its employees to devote time to their own pet projects, many of which are open sourced, and some of which turn out to be brand new kickass google features. To me, this is Open Source Corporate Advocacy done right.
Plenty of other companies are trying to jump on the Open Source bandwagon as a way to get cheap/free labor for coding projects. I can't say that this is EBay's intention, but it sure doesn't smell like an innovative idea to me. Just another PR flack's brainstorm.
Ideally, an opensource initiative would support OpenOffice or export OASIS-format data.....
I have been a user for about 10 years. This ends Feb 2014. The site's been ruined. I'm off. Dice, FU
There's nothing wrong with them opening their APIs and code to developers, in fact it may prove very useful. Still, it shouldn't be mistaken for a great act of charity on their part.
I think they'd be unwilling to allow users to post comments on their largely unmoderated site for fear of libel lawsuits
I have been a user for about 10 years. This ends Feb 2014. The site's been ruined. I'm off. Dice, FU
Of course this is probably just another way of "yet another company" to exploit the programming community for their gain. They'll suddenly slam it closed once they get what they want.
Oh well.
Yet more examples of companies trying to abuse the Open Source community, thinking that we're all just milling around in groups waiting for things to do and projects to contribute to.
Sure, we'll get right on that... writing your code for you, for free, while you profit and make a business model out of it. Absolutely! Where do I sign up?
Palm is trying it, Sun is trying it, Linksys tried it, and thousands of other companies tried it. When are companies going to learn that we don't just write code in our spare time because we're bored.
We write code because it is either improves technology, or it is fun, interesting, or scratches an particular itch we have, or because we're getting paid to write it.
If you want us to help you improve your business model, or write your code for you... PAY US. You know, like you would any other developer who writes code for you. What particular itch does the eBay search engine scratch for us? Why should we help? How does this improve OUR community? How can WE use this technology?
The real reason is because they think the Open Source community is just a free consortium to "cherry pick" whomever they want to write their code for them. They can't afford to hire anyone, so they turn to us. Nice.
So here's the obligatory HOWTO: HOWTO Pay for Free Software.
Seriously, I strongly recommend that every company read it and understand how our community works.
"EBay is a respected player in the business world."
That's true, if you completely reverse the statement. EBay and, if I may say so, their satanic 'child' PayPal are a few of the worst companies I've ever had the displeasure of doing business with.
Starting with the illegitamate charge backs (PayPal) I've mentioned on Slashdot on my most recent post, poor customer service (PayPal & Ebay) in the form of not responding to emails, a nice little trick of charging for auctions that were canceled (eBay), cancelling an auction the day before for selling game box of World of Warcraft (eBay) and more. I really would hate to be someone who does a lot of business with them.
If eBay really has opened up some code and it is Open enough that you have the freedom, as you should, to take it and use it as you want then I look forward to competing products that will result. I'd guess that anyone could do customer service better then eBay and if they want to give out the source to tools that can help their competitors (and others) why not :).
That depends on the open source license. If they distribute the software under the GPL or LGPL, they may implicitly be licensing all necessary patents along with the software. That's another reason why the GPL and LGPL are good for you.
But I see some around here are still spreading that lie.
5 44316/
And it doesn't help when Russ Nelson claims to have the "moral authority" on what is Open Source
http://slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=138002&cid=11
That is a very interesting, because the _main_ eBay search guy, Louis Monier (also the guy behind AltaVista technology), just announced he is leaving eBay and going to Google:
http://battellemedia.com/archives/001653.php
Simpy
IIRC, in order to access the "production" eBay servers with your third-party app, even through their published API's, you have to pay eBay hundreds of dollars to have someone "certify" your application. Anyone know if this policy is changing?
Can your IM do this?
Back a year ago or so, I tried without success to create a desktop app that could run Ebay searches. However, it was a very expensive thing to do and I was doing it free as an academic project, so I had to go the route of HTML parsing and all that jazz.
This is definitely a step in the right direction...
This sig donated to Pater. Long live
Strange this announcement should come after Google finally confirms the construction of their Wallet System. With all the hype built up around that project over the past few days, and the negative outlash towards Ebay during that time, its interesting they now announce their 'open source' release to the community.
"A war over religion is like fighting over who has the best imaginary friend."
...just what the hell is going on with this?
Finally someone from PayPal is speaking up:
http://paypaldoesntsuck.blogspot.com/
Seriously, learn the facts. You ARE FDIC insured with PayPal.
It is, however, FDIC "pass-through" insured.
(i.e. the bank that actually holds the funds is FDIC insured, so if paypal folds, your money is still held in a FDIC insured account and would be eligible to be covered by FDIC insurance.
I patented screwing your mom. But it got revoked for "prior art."
Maybe I can stop buying GUIDs with this new movement.
Coderz 4 Life
http://developer.ebay.com/
Would that be the same broken eBay Search that inexplicably alters the search string in some cases, that can't find items clearly up for auction, and that fails to find items clearly up for sale by a seller but that can't list them when pulling up all the auctions for the same seller's ID?
Offering to open up that stuff strikes me like Saddam offering to open-source his blueprint for better government.
Look at the bright side: there's always seppuku.