Slashdot Mirror


Google Toolbar for Firefox Released

fizz writes "Google has released their toolbar, available in 10 languages for the Firefox browser, and available for 3 operating systems (Windows, Mac and Linux). You can download it from the Google Toolbar homepage, and you can read the Google Blog for more information." Reported on recently here on Slashdot.

45 of 277 comments (clear)

  1. That's great and all by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    But I think I speak for everyone on Slashdot when I ask when is Microsoft going to release the MSN Toolbar for Firefox?

    1. Re:That's great and all by Pantero+Blanco · · Score: 3, Funny

      Right after they get Microsoft Office and Outlook running on FreeBSD.

    2. Re:That's great and all by Rei · · Score: 3, Funny

      A million monkeys. A million keyboards. MSN Toolbar. Let it get in YOUR way!

      --
      "99 dead duelists of Dios on the wall. 99 dead duelists of Dios! Take one's ring, pass it around..."
    3. Re:That's great and all by cant_get_a_good_nick · · Score: 5, Funny

      A long time ago, in a Galaxy far far away, I actually had Word 6.0 running on Solaris 2.6/SPARC, under WABI, which provided a Windows 3.1 environment. It worked slowly, but other than that, pretty well. In fact, I got a macro virus, Concept1. Was weird for the guy running Solaris to be able to identify to the company (all 8 of us) that we had a Word macro virus. They started to scrub the fileservers and eventually traced it back to a Word doc from a vendor.

      Who says microsoft doesn't do cross platform, I got a cross platform virus people, years before java.

    4. Re:That's great and all by Jeremiah+Cornelius · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Gee. I want ALL my software vendors to inject spyware into my browser as a component!

      --
      "Flyin' in just a sweet place,
      Never been known to fail..."
    5. Re:That's great and all by dicepackage · · Score: 2, Funny

      I am still waiting for Microsoft to release a version of Internet Explorer for Linux.

    6. Re:That's great and all by Mozk · · Score: 2, Funny

      Why would you want to use an inferior product that's full of holes? There are many better alternatives.

      --
      No existe.
  2. Technically, it's not a dupe.... by TrentL · · Score: 5, Informative

    Since the article earlier today said they were "about to" release the toolbar.

    1. Re:Technically, it's not a dupe.... by MightyMartian · · Score: 4, Funny

      And, tomorrow we'll have "Google Firefox Toolbar released yesterday!". Then, the day after, "Two Days Since Firefox Google Toolbar Released". Then, in a weeks time "Major Security Issues with Google Toolbar for Firefox." Then a couple of days later "Security Issues Fixed In New Release of Google Toolbar for Firefox." Then a month from now "New Book About Using Google Toolbar For Firefox, ISDN#82389234"

      --
      The world's burning. Moped Jesus spotted on I50. Details at 11.
    2. Re:Technically, it's not a dupe.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

      I have a new theory about dupes.

      Slashdot is starting to suck so bad that the userbase is not longer submitting worthy stories (as witnessed by the crappy articles that have been posted lately). But the problem is even worse than first suspected. The submission rate is so low, that they must create filler inbetween the crap stories. This filler usually consists of dupes of the almost good to fairly good stories.

    3. Re:Technically, it's not a dupe.... by NanoGator · · Score: 3, Funny

      "How can it be your ISDN line number? It's eight digits."

      Checksum, duh.

      --
      "Derp de derp."
  3. Re:Poor, poor Zonk by ryanov · · Score: 2, Informative

    This is actually NOT a dupe. It was due to be released, and now has been. Is that why the sympathy?

  4. Its cool by ResQuad · · Score: 4, Informative

    The only problem I have with it is the doube google search box.

    1. Re:Its cool by richardablitt · · Score: 5, Informative

      You can always right click on one of the toolbars, go to customise (or customize), and drag off the other google box. It is kind of unnecessary, since firefox already has the search box and pop-up blocking installed, which were the two main features it added to IE. (I know there's more, but those were the main ones for me).

    2. Re:Its cool by kv9 · · Score: 2

      The only problem I have with it is the doube google search box.

      get rid of it and do it the smart way.

      note to knee-jerkers: before you jump allover yourselves, no it does not defeat the purpose, because the google toolbar isnt just for searching, it has a lot of other goodness too.

    3. Re:Its cool by owenb · · Score: 3, Funny

      Yes, know yore reply is guaranteed to bee prefect

  5. It works on Linux!! by utopicillusion · · Score: 4, Interesting

    It works on Linux, even on PPC ones. Finally, google released a product for Linux users.

    Does this mean that Google is going to migrate some more of their products from Google Labs http://labs.google.com/ on linux now?

    1. Re:It works on Linux!! by IntergalacticWalrus · · Score: 4, Informative

      Firefox extensions are written in their internal script (XUL), so unless someone does some stupid unportable shit (backslashes!!) they will run on any platform.

    2. Re:It works on Linux!! by n0-0p · · Score: 3, Informative

      That's not quite true; XUL is just the user interface markup. Mozilla (FF, TB, SM, etc.) extensions can be written in JavaScript or C/C++. The Thunderbird Enigmail extension, for example, contains numerous binary components and requires a seperate install per OS.

  6. Foogle-Gox and the future: by Nomihn0 · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Will this tool bar replace the default Firefox Google homepage? Sponsorship is what it's all about, after all, no? Do you really think that Firefox developers will tolerate such redundancy? My bet is on the discontinuation of the homepage paired with a default Google Toolbar installation.

    1. Re:Foogle-Gox and the future: by enosys · · Score: 2, Interesting

      If we were talking about a non-free browser, the company making the browser could probably earn some money by including another company's toolbar. They could probably even earn money by setting a default home page. Is the Mozilla Foundation making money by making a Google page the default home page?

  7. Other toolbars? by Jaymaedae · · Score: 4, Interesting


    Does anyone have suggestions for other toolbars that are useful that work in Firefox? I am sure auto-complete is just scratching the surface. ( That's really all I use the google toolbar for anyway...in IE)

  8. Google /.'ed by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

    Whats this toolbar.google.com is /.'ed? How ironic!

  9. Other (Google) Firefox Extensions by The+boojum · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Actually, I find the "other Firefox extensions" link almost more interesting. The Google Suggest extension looks pretty darn slick.

  10. "Toolbars" make me uncomfortable... by GillBates0 · · Score: 4, Insightful
    /tinfoil hat on Maybe it's just due to the abundance of spyware that disguises themselves as browser toolbars (I cringe everytime I see a MySearch toolbar running on an acquaintances IE), but it's more due to the fact that integrating my open-source browser with a proprietary piece of software is apt to open up all kinds of privacy issues like making me more vulnerable to a single entity (in this case Google) tracking all my online activity, searches, form information, etc.

    I know Google tracks and logs every search query by IP address, but it's these persistent session pieces like the GMail cookies, "Personalized results" etc, that I find scarier. And what's more, a large number of people tend to use their full names as Email IDs (moreso for an attractive email service like GMail, which can be used as a formal email account for most purposes), which gives Google a way to directly map People Names to Google Searches.

    /tinfoil hat off

    --
    An Indian-American Hindu committed to non-violent thought/speech/action alarmed by the global explosion of radical Islam
    1. Re:"Toolbars" make me uncomfortable... by Mad+Merlin · · Score: 3, Interesting
      I know Google tracks and logs every search query by IP address...

      Not quite, Google sets a cookie on your computer that uniquely tracks you regardless of what IP you're browsing from. Not only that, but that cookie will probably outlast your hardware. The expiry on my Google cookie as reported by Konqueror, expires: 30/11/37 07:00 pm. You might want to invest in another layer of tinfoil there...

    2. Re:"Toolbars" make me uncomfortable... by plumby · · Score: 2, Funny

      What's your credit card number?

  11. Not enough features.. by mislam · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I do not see enough features in the toolbar to let it occupy 25% (ok maybe less) of my browsers tool space.

    1. Re:Not enough features.. by SavvyPlayer · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Nice to see this in Firefox, but I must confess some disappointment with the latest release. There is plenty of room to the right of the menu bar for all of the Google Toolbar features, however Google chose instead to gobble up a 4th row of buttons along the top of the window. Google chose the shortest path from point A (IE toolbar) to point B (straight port), not taking the time to properly implement Firefox's UI guidelines: its buttons are neither dockable or aware of the "show icons, text or icons + text" user preference.

      This isn't rocket science. When hiring offshore IT talent, does Google translate its requirements via http://www.google.com/language_tools?hl=en ?

  12. might as well by buddha42 · · Score: 5, Funny

    Google should just CNAME pr.google.com to slashdot.org

  13. any way to move it? by supersuckers · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I have it installed in my firefox in gentoo... is there any way to move the darn thing? It takes up a lot of real estate, I'd like to get rid of most of the buttons and move it to where the google search that comes with firefox used to reside.

  14. Too late... by wviperw · · Score: 5, Interesting

    When I was first thinking about converting to Firefox I remember that Google's toolbar was the "killer app" that initially kept me from switching over. Then I realized that I could do pretty much everything I could do using Google's IE-only toolbar using Firefox extensions and its built-in capabilities.

    For example, for instant Google searches, Firefox allows you to create Keyword Searches in which you can just type in, in my case, "g <search query>" in the URL bar. Or for Wikipedia it is "w <search query>". For word highlighting you can just use Firefox's search functionality. And finally, for AutoFill you can use the AutoFill extension (which ends up being better than Google's anyway IMO).

    So basically, Firefox has rendered the Google toolbar pretty useless to me.

    --
    Nothing disturbs me more than blind loyalism towards some unrealistic and over-idealistic notion of one's nationality.
    1. Re:Too late... by wviperw · · Score: 5, Informative

      Sure! It is really quite easy. Go to www.google.com and right click on the textbox where you would normally enter your search. Click on "Add a Keyword for this Search..." and then just set whatever keyword you would like in the Keyword textbox. So for Google I just entered "g". You can do the same thing with any search box, so I've got it setup to work with Google (g), Google Local (gl), Google Image (gi, Wikipedia (w), Download.com (dl), Dictionary.com (d), Rottentomatoes.com (rt), IMDB (imdb), and WHOIS (whois).

      --
      Nothing disturbs me more than blind loyalism towards some unrealistic and over-idealistic notion of one's nationality.
  15. All Fluff. by smug_lisp_weenie · · Score: 2, Informative

    The only thing this toolbar does that Firefox doesn't already is give pagerank- But there's a great site that'll let you do all this anyway. Otherwise, I recommend looking at open source Firefox extensions and YubNub.com (which integrates beautifully into firefox) for your enhancement needs!

  16. What's the benefit? by lhbtubajon · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Why would I install this toolbar when I have instant search access to google built in to Firefox already?

    Obviously the google toolbar offers a few bells and whistles, but I'll never use them. I just want to search.

    So, the Google toolbar for IE makes sense, this one not so much.

    Am I missing something?

    Are those bells and whistles something worth sacrificing half an inch of screen real estate?

    1. Re:What's the benefit? by Martin+Blank · · Score: 4, Informative

      The pop-ups got through because people figured out a way around them.

      That said, IIRC, Google has not included pop-up blocking in the Firefox version, because Firefox already has pop-up blocking.

      --
      You can never go home again... but I guess you can shop there.
  17. Gee, google, that's swell by RLiegh · · Score: 2, Interesting

    But I can use the Yahoo Toolbar on any platform that firefox runs on (any *BSD, solaris, etc). Because they had the smarts to write it in XUL (?) or what ever the native mozilla toolkit/extention language is.

    1. Re:Gee, google, that's swell by wviperw · · Score: 2, Informative

      According to the link to the Google Blog in the summary, they *did* use XUL to create this.

      --
      Nothing disturbs me more than blind loyalism towards some unrealistic and over-idealistic notion of one's nationality.
  18. Far from as useful as on IE by Jugalator · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Google Search -- integrated
    AutoLink -- US use only; most stuff don't work outside US, and even then a limited usefulness
    WordTranslator -- limited use; only useful if you must understand e.g. a french site, and even if you do, there are non-toolbar extensions for this
    Pop-up blocker -- integrated
    AutoFill -- as far as I can see, Firefox' form saving system works well enough here
    SpellCheck -- useful!
    PageRank -- why should I have a use for it? diagnosing rank issues with my own sites? seems like highly limited use
    Highlight search terms -- integrated
    Word find -- integrated

    An entirely new toolbar for this? Hmm... I can get the spell checking elsewhere without one, and besides that, it seems a bit much.

    --
    Beware: In C++, your friends can see your privates!
  19. Re:Slashdot promotes spyware by dameron · · Score: 4, Funny

    ...the page you are viewing will be sent to Google if you click on the "Cached Snapshot", "Backward Links" or "Similar Pages" features.

    Wow, imagine that, google needing to know which page you're viewing so it can 1) show you a cache of that page, 2) show links to the current page, or 3) show pages related to the one you're viewing.

    How on earth could they do this without knowing what page you're viewing?

  20. Word macro viruses and alternate OSs.... by commodoresloat · · Score: 3, Interesting
    I used a Mac at the time and had numerous instances of identifying viruses in Word macros sent to me by windows users. The Mac version of Word didn't play macros automatically and warned that there was a suspicious one, and Disinfectant 3.7 could identify them. The reactions I would get from windows users is first a smug "Hah! You told me macs didn't have any virus problems" ... then after explaining that my Mac at best was functioning as a kind of typhoid mary for viruses that didn't have any impact on the system I'd hear, "oh, so it's nothing to worry about then"... a bit of convincing to get them to fire up an antivirus program that scans Word files for such macros and then "Holy shit! this thing is all over my system!" How little things change sometimes.... Of course I pulled that Disinfectant version number out of my ass but for some reason I suspect it is accurate.

    [by the way the Mac of the time, while far more secure than the windows of the time, certainly had its share of problems. The autostart worm was a particularly nasty one that I was lucky enough never to get bit by. ]

  21. Guess I'll just have to bite the bullet ... by jc42 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    ... and finally learn how to uninstall these damned things.

    I made the mistake of deciding to give it a try on my Mac Powerbook (10.3.9). Bad mistake. This was typed to the Camino browser, because now my FF is all but unusable.

    To use an example that /. users can appreciate, I fired up a FF window that has two tabs, with the expected slashdot.org and slashdot.org/users.pl in them. I then opened a third tab with the Google Toolbar discussion, and waited for its busy wheel to stop spinning ... and waited ... and waited ... until finally, after several minutes the spinning froze. Another minute, and it hadn't moved. I hit the little stop-sign icon, and after a while, FF sorta came back.

    So I tried opening a new FF window, using CMD-N as usual. Nothing. I tried it a few more times. Nada. No errors, no windows. I guessed that CMD-N was dead.

    So I started playing with a few other things in the /. window. CMD-click did open a couple more tabs, all of which hung in the "frozen busy" state. I tried a few ways of getting menus; none worked. Clicking on a tab would bring it to the front, but click-hold never produced a menu. Neither did click-hold inside a tab.

    WTF?

    Then, after maybe 10 minutes, a set of blank windows suddenly appeared. So CMD-N isn't dead; it just takes 10 minutes. Now, I'd gotten used to FF taking 30 seconds on OSX, unlike my (slower ;-) linux box where it takes between 2 and 3 seconds. But 10 minutes is way past what I'd call marginally usable.

    Then, a few minutes later I saw a whole lot of menus flashing above the FF window where I was viewing /., meaning that the menus aren't dead, either. They're just so slow as to be unusable.

    So it looks like I'll have to hunt down this Toolbar and excise it. Too bad I didn't get a chance to try it. Well, actually, I did. I typed in a search string and hit Return - and the window became a zombie. And my cpu was pegged at 100%, with Activity Monitor saying that Firefox was hung. I got my cpu back by hitting the little 'x' "close" icon for the window, and after a minute or so it went away, and cpu usage dropped.

    I wonder where I can find the docs on removing the little monster? I'd sure like my firefox back.

    --
    Those who do study history are doomed to stand helplessly by while everyone else repeats it.
  22. Re:Slashdot promotes spyware by evilmrhenry · · Score: 3, Funny

    Wow, imagine that, google needing to know which page you're viewing so it can 1) show you a cache of that page, 2) show links to the current page, or 3) show pages related to the one you're viewing.

    How on earth could they do this without knowing what page you're viewing?


    By sending you the information for every page on the Internet, then allowing you to pick the page you want client-side, of course.

    (Note: may not be practical.)

  23. Superb dictionary! by sankyuu · · Score: 2, Informative

    Now is my first time to use Google toolbar (or any other browser toolbar add-on), and I find the dictionary superb!

    I'm running Japanese firefox and it translates any English word that I hover my mouse on into Japanese. And Firefox doesn't seem slowed down one bit! The "magic" of AJAX, I suppose...

    Now to see if it translates other languages into Japanese... ^_^

  24. Lovely first impression on OS X 10.4.1 by sjmacko29 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Firefox now crashes immediately on startup. Nice feature... back to Safari. Seriously, I think I will be uninstalling Firefox, and doing a reinstall. As soon as Firefox becomes visible, I get the "Thank you for installin Google Toolbar", and then the mozilla talkback pops up... Time to go back to watching the hurricane's progress in Safari. Steve on the Gulf Coast