Slashdot Mirror


Synthesizer Pioneer Bob Moog Dies

Sigalarm writes "CNN is reporting that synthesizer pioneer and all-around vanguard of electronic music Bob Moog has passed away at age 71. Dr. Moog built his first electronic instrument -- the theremin -- at age 14 and made the MiniMoog, 'the first compact, easy-to-use synthesizer,' in 1964. He was the first to bring the electronic synthesizer within reach of most musicians, and his MiniMoog is still highly praised and often emulated, to this day."

41 of 258 comments (clear)

  1. Moog Archives by bigwavejas · · Score: 4, Informative

    Since Moogmusic is ./'d to hell, try Moonarchives

    --
    "Simplify, simplify, simplify!" Thoreau
    1. Re:Moog Archives by pjwhite · · Score: 3, Informative

      Many nice tributes to Bob can be found in the guestbook at CaringBridge. I was especially impressed to see a recent entry from Isao Tomita, a true pioneer from the early days of electronic music.

  2. Pronunciation by lawpoop · · Score: 5, Informative

    FYI, proper pronunciaction of Moog is 'Moag', like 'moat' with a 'g', and not like 'Moo'-g, like a cow would say it.

    --
    Computers are useless. They can only give you answers.
    -- Pablo Picasso
    1. Re:Pronunciation by juangonzo · · Score: 5, Informative

      That's how his name is pronounced. He has stated that his products can be pronounced either way but he likes the way that sounds like a cow better.

      --
      c# - Wait, it's not pronounced coctothorpe?
    2. Re:Pronunciation by lawpoop · · Score: 3, Funny
      Oh thank god. I prefer Moo-g, but the geek in me wants to be a know-it-all pedantic stickler for language. So now I know enough correct to get me uninvited to any future party!

      "Yes, the name is pronounced Moag, but Mr. Moag has said that his instruments can be pronounced either way..."

      --
      Computers are useless. They can only give you answers.
      -- Pablo Picasso
    3. Re:Pronunciation by corpsiclex · · Score: 3, Informative
      Uh, no..you got it backwards. Here is the correct quote:
      Vermont Review: First off: Does your name rhyme with "vogue" or is like a Cow's "moo" plus a "G" at the end?
      Dr. Robert Moog: It rhymes with vogue. That is the usual German pronunciation. My father's grandfather came from Marburg, Germany. I like the way that pronunciation sounds better than the way the cow's 'moo-g' sounds.
      sources: http://members.tripod.com/vermontreview/Interviews /moog.htm
      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bob_Moog
      --

      eBayDig 1s a typo saerch engien
  3. Haunted House by kevin_conaway · · Score: 5, Funny

    Where would haunted houses be without the theramin?

    And where would boardwalks be without haunted houses? Childhood as we know it would collapse.

    1. Re:Haunted House by Eggman27 · · Score: 5, Informative

      FYI, Bob didn't invent the theremin, but rather it was his work building and marketing them that led to his innovation of the modern synthesizer.

    2. Re:Haunted House by Fear+the+Clam · · Score: 3, Funny

      When it happens, I'll blame those meddling kids.

  4. RIP Bob by Bjimba · · Score: 5, Interesting

    As a tribute, I'm queueing up one of the first mainstream albums to use a Moog: The Beatles' "Abbey Road".

    So long, and thanks for all the samples!

    --
    --- question = 0xFF; // optimized Hamlet
  5. The server seems getting slower, so... by rd4tech · · Score: 4, Informative

    The following is link from his biography on the same website:

    The Man Behind the Machines

    What would the world of modern music be like without the inventions of Bob Moog? One answer would be: very boring. Bob Moog's namesake analog synthesizers have affected popular music in ways he might not have expected back in 1954 when he began building theremins with his father. But 50 years later, Bob's musical instruments have catapulted so many styles of music into the future, and his contributions to both players and technicians grow even more profound in retrospect.

    Where would R&B, rap and hip-hop be if groups like Parliament and Funkadelic hadn't used Moog keyboards? Where would rock and roll be if groups from Yes to the Beatles hadn't used Moog keyboards? Would jazz music have branched off into fusion without Herbie Hancock and Chick Corea using Moog keyboards? And would classical music have enjoyed such resurgence without Wendy Carlos and her modular Moog synthesizer? The questions are hypothetical, of course, because synthesizers have infiltrated every style of music, and so many companies have tried to recreate that analog sound. But above all the copycats and spin-offs, it always comes back to one name: Moog.

    After ten years of making theremins, providing unearthly sounds to science fiction movies and avante garde musicians, Bob Moog met experimental composer Herbert Deutsch, whose search for electronic sounds inspired Bob to create the first Moog Modular Synthesizer. Though Bob took on the project just for fun, when he premiered it at the Audio Engineering Society Convention in October of 1964 the response was immediate and Bob started taking orders on the spot. By the time he received a graduate degree (PhD in Engineering Physics, Cornell University) in the summer of 1965, the R. A. Moog Co. had delivered several modular synthesizer systems, mostly to academic and experimental composers. But it would be a few years later when public awareness of Moog synthesizers would leap ahead beneath the nimble fingers of Wendy Carlos.
    Carlos' renowned album "Switched-On Bach" was released on Columbia Records at the
    end of 1968, achieving immediate success. The album went on to sell over a million copies, creating a sharp demand for Moog modular synthesizers throughout 1969 and early 1970. Many "switched-on" records were produced during that period. By the end of 1970, the now incorporated R. A. Moog Inc. introduced the Minimoog®, a compact performance synthesizer based on the technology of Moog modular products, enabling keyboardists to take the Moog on the road. And that began a decade of music that would be forever altered by the Minimoog and its incomparable sounds.

    R. A. Moog Inc. officially changed its name to Moog Music Inc. in 1971 and became a division of the now defunct Norlin Music in 1973. Moog synthesizers were widely used by professional musicians and the "Sound of the Moog" became an integral part of our musical culture. The list of songs is far too long to print here, but from rock to R&B, from jazz to classical music, the Moog sounds were everywhere.

    At the end of 1977, Bob left Moog Music and in 1978 founded Big Briar for the purpose of developing and building electronic musical instruments with novel player interfaces. Actual Moog keyboards were made for the better part of the next decade by Norlin Music, but with the heart and soul of Moog gone, Moog keyboards ceased production by 1986. Though gone from his namesake company, Bob's interest in synthesizers and instruments could not be quelled. From 1978 to 1992, Bob operated Big Briar on a small scale and kept building custom instruments. He was also representing Synton, a Dutch manufacturer of modular equipment, and providing consultation services to other music technology manufacturers. In addition, Bob served as Kurzweil Music Systems' Vice President of New Product Research from 1984 through 1989, and taught music technology courses at the University of North Carolina at Asheville from 1989 to 1992.

  6. Tribute by saskboy · · Score: 3, Funny

    Someone should posted a MIDI version of Taps.

    --
    Saskboy's blog is good. 9 out of 10 dentists agree.
    1. Re:Tribute by dstone · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Someone should posted a MIDI version of Taps.

      That would make for an awful tribute, in my opinion. Moog pioneered and championed analog, imperfect, and continuously variable signals. MIDI is all about crisp, quantized, digital, perfectly sequencable and recordable signals.

      A better tribute, in my opinion, would be to play taps on some his own gear (or at least a Theremin or something) run through a class Moog ladder filter.

      That would get him self-oscillating, I'm sure.

    2. Re:Tribute by JazzHarper · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Moog's low-pass VCF circuit is a brilliant design.

      Matched, differential transistor pairs are stacked to form a ladder. The transistors aren't being used for gain, though. The control voltage varies the current through the stack which causes the conductance of the transistors to vary... a lot. The cutoff frequency can be swept through five orders of magnitude by the control voltage alone.

      I showed that circuit to quite a few EE profs before I found one who could give an adequate explanation of how it worked.

      Sheer genius.

    3. Re:Tribute by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

      Actually, MIDI is all about being a language of messages and control, not about actual sound signal itself.

      The entire control aspect of MIDI, the entire frequency range and "note" aspect of MIDI, all of MIDI's timing, and every other control or signal is quantized, perfect, reproducable, and digital.

      You can't -continuously- vary the tempo, the frequency of gate signals, the frequency of any oscillator, the resonance value of any filter, etc. Oh, sure, you can get 16 bits or more of resolution on these digital settings in MIDI and you can send those signals at some divisor of 31 kHz (or whatever MIDI's rate is), which is fairly fast and fairly smooth, but it's simply not analog or continuous control.

      If you've ever heard classic MIDI "zipper" noise when controlling a filter or oscillator, you'll agree. And when you don't hear such digital artifacts during MIDI control, it's simply because a smart engineer has kept those artifacts below a reasonable level of perception. I'm not saying MIDI control is worse or evil, but it's not what Robert Moog pioneered, nor was it what he was best at, nor what is what most people will remember him for.

      MIDI is actually what seperates the performance from the sound generation.

      MIDI is one way to do it. Analog sequencers and analog patches are another. Where MIDI requires a distinction be made between an audio signal and a control signal (MIDI addressing only the latter, and only digitally), analog does not. Signal is signal and there's nothing to stop you from (and everything to encourage you to try) taking an "audio" output and sending it to a "control" input or vice versa.

      Sweep one -10V to +10V oscillator (audio) with another -10V to +10V oscillator (control) and you'll be doing something that MIDI just can't do. When a jack says "output" on a patchable analog rig, you can treat it as control or audio. It's really quite elegant. And nasty.

  7. Documentary about Moog by Jason+Scott · · Score: 4, Informative

    A documentary about Robert Moog, called simply "Moog", came out last year, directed by Hans Fjellestad. A site about the movie is here:

    http://www.zu33.com/moog/

    While the movie doesn't work for everyone (it's a little arty and a little weird), it has a lot of interview footage with Bob Moog and his unique outlook on life. It's well worth getting and a very dreamy, very loving portrait of the man.

    How lucky we are that Fjellestad took this project on.

  8. Minimoog was released in 1970! by Trurl's+Machine · · Score: 4, Informative

    As far as I know, the original article is wrong. Moog synthesizer in 1960's were modular. They were indeed easier to use than the competition because at least they included normal musical keyboard (oddly enough, Bob Moog was one of the rare engineers who understood that musicians want to play their synths just like piano or Hammond organ). Minimoog was the compact one, but it wasn't released until around 1970.

  9. Bye bye Bob... by MsGeek · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I remember meeting Robert Moog at a music technology convention in 1981. He was still designing new instruments, but was in the paradoxical position of not being able to put his own name on them...thanks a lot CBS Music.

    He was able to get his trademarks back and his designs, and a new version of the Minimoog came out at the most recent NAMM convention in California in January. Here's a non-sponsored link to it.

    He was a geek's geek, and put the tech in techno. He will be missed.

    --
    Knowledge is power. Knowledge shared is power multiplied.
    1. Re:Bye bye Bob... by AnalogDiehard · · Score: 3, Informative
      I remember meeting Robert Moog at a music technology convention in 1981. He was still designing new instruments, but was in the paradoxical position of not being able to put his own name on them...thanks a lot CBS Music.

      CBS Music never owned the Moog trademark. In the 1970/80s it was owned by Norlin, who also owned Gibson guitars, Lowrey organs, Maestro FX pedals, Pearl Drums, among others.

      The Moog trademark lapsed by the mid 90s and was snatched up by Don Martin. After promises of reissued Moog products, accepting 50% deposits, and very little product delivered, Don was forced into bankruptcy and the assets were liquidated. Bob Moog stepped in to reacquire the trademarks to his name and the instruments, and operated as Moog Music since 2002.

      Bob's 21st century Minimoog, the Voyager, is an outstanding product. I have one of the early Voyagers and it is a high quality product, as is the other Moog products they currently make.

      We lost a great man this weekend.

      --
      Eternity: will that be smoking, or non-smoking? I Corinthians 6:9-10
  10. A sad day in music history by Adrilla · · Score: 5, Funny

    As a friend said "...that guy was a legend.

    Robots, Computers and Satan would have nothing to dance to if it weren't for him."

    --

    "Plans are for fools! Oglethorpe, the plutonian (Aqua Teen Hunger Force)
    1. Re:A sad day in music history by Hatta · · Score: 4, Informative

      What's really sad is how persecuted those who enjoy electronic music are. Just last weekend a rave in Utah was broken up by the national guard. Hundreds of peaceful dancers threatened with guns, and dozens beaten and arrested. This was a fully licensed event, and the police simply ripped up the permits and waved their guns. Here is a video of the raid, and some first hand accounts.

      The government is waging war on its own citizens under the guise of the war on drugs, now blatantly violating the constition. It's clear that if you are not a good christian who drinks beer and watches football, you're a second class citizen. I'm just glad nobody died.

      --
      Give me Classic Slashdot or give me death!
    2. Re:A sad day in music history by Hatta · · Score: 3, Informative

      I'm not saying illegal things didn't happen there. But illegal things happen at every concert and club in the world. Electronic music fans are particularly singled out.

      Now as for the permits, they were destroyed by the police. If you don't believe it, we'll find out when it all goes to court. The police just didn't care that this event was as legal as an Allman Brothers concert. The linked article is extremely poorly researched, and deliberately biased towards the government.

      Anyway, if you've ever been to a rave you'd know that there's almost never any trouble. Ravers are peaceful friendly people. Most all raves are well planned with security and medical. The only "problems" that happen are people consuming drugs of their own volition. Illegal yes, but does that justify waving assault rifles in their faces?

      Besides, if you care so much about law and order, you should be concerned that this raid happened in a lawful manner. It wasn't.

      --
      Give me Classic Slashdot or give me death!
    3. Re:A sad day in music history by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative
      Now as for the permits, they were destroyed by the police.

      That doesn't really do justice to it:

      The police were rounding up the staff of the party and the main promoter went up to them with the permit for the show and said "here, I have the permit." The police then said, "no you don't" and ripped the permit out of his hand. Then, they put an assault rifle to his forehead and said "get the fuck out of here right now."

      Source: From the account of one of the headline DJs

      Other choice quotes:

      Next thing I know, A can of fucking TEAR GAS is launched into the crowd. People are running and screaming at this point.

      One of the promoters friends (a very small female) was attacked by one of the police dogs. As she struggled to get away from it, the police tackled her. 3 grown men proceeded to KICK HER IN THE STOMACH.

      Oh another interesting fact.. the police did not have a warrant.

      Spread the word.
  11. Listening Suggestion by Ann+Elk · · Score: 5, Informative

    Switched on Bach by Wendy Carlos, especially the last track (Initial Experiments). You can hear Wendy working with a prototype Moog pressure-sensitive keyboard, trying various settings and arrangements. Wendy's narration provides great background to the experiments. As a geek, it is (by far) my favorite track on the CD.

    RIP, Bob.

    1. Re:Listening Suggestion by Telecommando · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Actually Wendy was going by the name Walter Carlos back then, at least that's how she's listed on my copy of the album, which is worn and scratchy from repeated playing. It's a groundbreaking piece of work, somewhat mindblowing at the time. Must dig it out again and find a turntable.

      --
      Beta sux! Join the Slashcott! http://hardware.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=4760465&cid=46173047
  12. Bury him in a 19" wide, rackmountable casket... by dstone · · Score: 4, Funny

    powered by +/-12V DC, with lots of silver toggle switches, red LEDs, black plastic knobs, and a big patch panel of jacks for audio and Control Voltage in/out.

    Oscillate wildly, Robert Moog.

    See also: Robert Moog Wikipedia page.

  13. Cyberpunk Fuction by Jerk+City+Troll · · Score: 4, Funny

    "Whose synthesizer is this?"

    "It's a sampler, baby."

    "Whose sampler is this?"

    "Bob's."

    "Who's Bob?"

    "Bob's dead, baby. Bob's dead..."

    1. Re:Cyberpunk Fuction by Tackhead · · Score: 3, Funny
      > "Whose synthesizer is this?"
      > "It's a sampler, baby."
      > "Whose sampler is this?"
      > "Bob's."
      > "Who's Bob?"
      > "Bob's dead, baby. Bob's dead..."

      ...riffing on Cyberpunk Fiction , a parody of the Pulp Fiction soundtrack. (I'm going from memory here, it's been a while since I've heard it... but it's also probably a fitting tribute, since without Bob, none of the following suggenres would have existed...)

      "Y'know what they call industrial music over there? Electro Body Music!"
      "Electro Body Music? What do they call techno?"
      "Well, techno's techno. Except in Paris they call it 'le techno'."
      "What do they call house?"
      "I don't know, I don't listen to that shit. But you know what put on drums in Holland?"
      "What?"
      "Flange."
      "Goddamn!"
      "They fuckin' bury 'em in it..."

      The first track of the album album also features a bit of dialog that, by itself, is worth the price of the entire album:

      "All right, everybody, be COOL! I'm your new SYSTEMS ADMINISTRATOR!"
      "Any of you fucking Ewoks move and I'll terminate every last motherfucking job on the mainframe!"

  14. Better Guide by Rufus88 · · Score: 5, Funny

    Or, for the /. crowd:

    It's pronounced "moag", as in, "Worf, son of".

  15. FreshAir interview by kondrag · · Score: 5, Informative

    Terry Gross interviewed Robert Moog back in 2000. The interview is available online here:

    http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?story Id=1113447

  16. Sigh.... by aliensporebomb · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I think what we think of as "modern music" would not sound the same without it.

    Keith Emersons' heart stopping sounds at
    the close of the single "Lucky Man" was
    probably my first exposure to synthesizer
    music. I later heard Switched on Bach as
    well as many of the electronic german bands
    who specialized in synthesis.

    Some synthesizer-predominant artists
    such as Tangerine Dream, Synergy,
    Kraftwerk, Michael Hoenig, Klaus Schulze,
    Ash Ra Tempel, Vangelis, Wendy Carlos,
    and SFF among many, many others simply
    wouldn't sound the same OR actually
    sound at all without them.

    I think of an interview with the canadian
    band Saga who at one time owned "one of
    everything" that Moog made and was offered
    an endorsement deal from Moog and they said
    "why bother? We already own everything you
    make!" That's a ringing endorsement.

    And the secret to the Moog sound was the filters
    in those instruments. Every synthesizer made
    had their own unique sound. But everyone tried
    to copy the Moog filter sound and didn't quite
    succeed.

    I bet they will still be buying Minimoogs' in
    100 years - something about that design and
    sound with tweakable knobs urges playing.

    Small wonder that in the 80s when synth
    makers went to touch panels or increment and
    decrement buttons players liked them less
    even though the sounds were unique because
    the interface made you play a certain way.
    The sound was more alive when you could
    manipulate the sound with knobs while
    playing.

    Notable makers who used the "knobs as sound
    shaping devices" were Wolfgang Palm of the
    venerable PPG (and later Waldorf) as well as
    Roland who resurrected the "plethora of knobs"
    idea with their JD800. Knobs work and Mr.
    Moog must have just understood this. Some
    others did too.

    But the Moog sound was instantly identifiable.
    And it is still used today. And very likely
    100 years from now. That Minimoog voyager
    with blue LEDs is an object of lust for more
    than just a few.

    Bon Voyage, Robert:
    Let's hope he'll rest in peace or spend eternity
    driving God insane with giant filter sweeps on
    the biggest modular in the universe.

  17. I have an excerpt from his funeral... by Quaoar · · Score: 4, Funny

    beeep boop booooooop beeep boop booooooooop beeep boop booooop, beeep boop boooooop, beeep boop booooop...

    --
    I'll form my OWN solar system! With blackjack! And hookers!
  18. Re: Bob Moog by $RANDOMLUSER · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I'm going to have to listen to my Walter Carlos version of "Switched on Bach" - on vinyl.

    --
    No folly is more costly than the folly of intolerant idealism. - Winston Churchill
  19. Re:Wikipedia Article by Bender_ · · Score: 3, Funny

    Google search for Robert Moog

  20. Re: Bob Moog by burne · · Score: 3, Informative

    If you have it somewhere: I Feel Love by Donna Summer. Baseline is Giorgio Moroder and the classic MS-10/SQ-10 pair. Must have been the first introduction to a sequencer for most people. Little did they know.. He will be missed.

  21. Re:Fuck you Moog by Rosco+P.+Coltrane · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Well, the AC got modded as troll, probably because of his wording. But I'll rephrase his point of view and present the opposite as well:

    Pro-electronic music: synthesizer and samplers are instruments, just like a harpsichord or a bassoon. Instruments are just tools that channel the creativity of composers and performers. Therefore you still have to be a good composer or performer to make good music with electronics.

    Against electronic music: synthesizer and samplers sounds very good with little to no effort or talent. Therefore, a whole generation of people without talent, or the ability or patience to learn to play an instrument through years or practice, started to spew out what they think is music, but really isn't much more than a cold, soulless collection of sounds at best.

    My opinion is: yes, both.

    --
    "A door is what a dog is perpetually on the wrong side of" - Ogden Nash
  22. Switched On -- Honorably... by Kazoo+the+Clown · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Bob Moog proved that the term "honorable businessman" is not an oxymoron, at least not in his case.

    Bob had the occasion to visit Raymond Scott in his studio, and see one of Scott's secret inventions-- the sequencer. Scott unfortunately, was very protective of his ideas-- so much so that he undoubtedly took many of them to his grave. Scott didn't want his secret invention to get out-- though apparently needed some confirmation from someone qualified to appreciate it, else why would Bob be seeing it in the first place?

    Consequently, the Moog Synthesizers did not have sequencers until the competition came up with them and started beating Moog up in the marketplace, so finally Scott let Bob off the hook and allowed Bob to manufacture sequencers for his synthesizers. Bob probably could have just stolen the idea, though in fact it's likely he would have arrived at it independently, but because Bob was honorable, he didn't use the sequencer concept without Scott's OK.

    Just one of a wide variety of great stories. They don't make them like that anymore...

    I got to meet Bob briefly in L.A. at the unveiling of the Fairlight CMI in the 1970s (or was it early '80s, I forget)-- he was involved in some of the PR of the instrument. It was a small group, and Bob gave a nice talk on music technologies. Great guy...

    The Moog VCF is still being emulated (along with most of his other components) in digital "virtual analog" synthesizers today. I had a chance to pick up a classic Moog modular setup in the '70s for about $500. I still kick myself for passing it up. (big darn thing though, I had an Arp 2600 at the time (still have) and preferred the convenience of it, but while the 2600 has increased in value, not nearly as much as an original Moog modular-- plus the coolness factor now of a big 1/4" jack patched synth would now be pretty hard to beat)...

  23. Re:Fuck you Moog by CRCulver · · Score: 3, Interesting

    The basis of electronica is the Darmstadt electronic compositions of the 1950s, when Karlheinz Stockhausen and György Ligeti were active, some years before Moog became known to the public.

  24. Re:First song by Sonicboom · · Score: 3, Informative

    actually - the first Rock single to use a Moog synth (as an instrument - not as a noise machine) was The Monkees' "Star Collector".

    --
    [Connection closed by foreign host]
  25. Re:He Milked the Mini-Moog Then Fell Behind by DSP_Geek · · Score: 3, Informative

    Polymoog wasn't his. David Luce designed that one.

    I read a David Luce paper in Journal Of The Audio engineering Society. Nice measurements of musical instrument spectra, completely faulty mechanism for describing how they changed with amplitude.

    Here's a link to a good history of Moog Music, including how Luce was chosen to run the outfit after Moog left.
    http://www.synthmuseum.com/moog/

  26. A great man, leaving behind a wide wake by Cliff+Stoll · · Score: 5, Interesting

    From 1968 to 1973, I worked with Robert Moog.

    I was just an undergraduate, assigned to maintain the synthesizer at the University/Buffalo; Bob would often visit and show me nifty wrinkles and hacks for the system. It was a time when your fingers were likely found on a sliderule, an oscilloscope probe, or the cork of a soldering iron.

    For his large synthesizers, Moog's circuit cards were etched and soldered by hand, and fitted into a wood frame work, with a spiffy black anodized front panel. The potentiometers were a constant headache: even milspec pots developed noise after a month of hard use by musicians.

    Bob standardized on one volt per octave for his voltage controlled oscillators; my job was keeping these working ... along with Bode ring oscillators, third-octave vocoders, two flat-plate echo chambers, and a handful of multitrack Ampex tape decks.

    A visit from Bob Moog might mean experimenting with nonlinear mixers, measuring how an audio expander could minimize apparent noise, or the Fourier transforms of trumpets and coronets. With patch cords hanging around his neck, Bob helped rewire my homebrew Theramin to minimize drift, using a 2N107 germanium transistor as a thermal sensor.

    Thirty five years later, I've been an astronomer, computer jock, writer, lecturer, and Klein Bottle mogul. But I'll never forget Bob Moog ... a creative engineer, artistically aware, supportive of everyone from egocentric musician to a hopeful but uncertain technician.

    - Cliff Stoll 2005/8/22