Slashdot Mirror


Tech Punditry In 2005

Wired has an article looking back at some of the most obvious, some of the most topical, and some of the least accurate predictions for 2005. From the article: "Wireless will continue to replace land line at a faster pace: Internet telephony pundit Jeff Pulver's prediction seems somewhat obvious, but nonetheless accurate. In 2005, personal calling on wireless phones in the United States exceeded that on residential land lines, even though 35 percent of the U.S. population doesn't have wireless, according to the Yankee Group."

7 of 49 comments (clear)

  1. The funniest part... by Starker_Kull · · Score: 4, Insightful

    ...is the link to Art Bell's predictions. The man never found a conspiracy theory/alien abduction/perpetual motion scheme he didn't like. But for laughs, here it is - it does illustrate the principle that if you guess wildly about enough crap, by sheer luck you'll get something right.

    http://myweb.tiscali.co.uk/aspie/trueorfalse/newye ar.html

  2. So? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Insightful

    Sorry but predictions seem rather pointless most the time. So many are made that of course most are wrong and of course some are right. Yet the correct predictionners are still treated as somewhat intelligent?!

  3. Here are my 20 predictions for 2006... by pieterh · · Score: 4, Insightful

    1. The EU Commission will make a new attempt to introduce software patents in Europe.

    2. They will lose, again.

    3. The top gadget of 2006 will be the portable video player, specifically aimed at TV downloads.

    4. Music sales will fall and the RIAA will blame piracy.

    5. Apple shares will rise by 100% over 2006.

    6. Neither Linux nor Apple will make much inroad into Microsoft's PC market in 2006. The public has learned to live with viruses and spyware.

    7. Apple will announce deals with several more broadcasters and become the premier online distributor of TV shows.

    8. Microsoft will not buy Google.

    9. Google will not buy Sun but at least one Industry Pundit will suggest this.

    10. The big Internet technology of 2006 will be Ajax applications.

    11. The big Internet business of 2006 will be spyw^h^h^h^h Personal Data Security and Collection services.

    12. Someone will say, "the Internet is a terrible system but it's better than all the alternatives".

    13. Oil will hit $75 per barrel and there will be minor riots in several countries.

    14. Most of the rioters will be returned unharmed from police custody.

    15. The War on Terror will continue, unabated.

    16. Security services and telcos will gang up on free wifi, which will become known as "the service of choice for pedophiles and terrorists".

    17. At least one EU country will attempt to ban unmonitored access to web-based email services, and be roundly ridiculed for the attempt.

    18. China's economy will grow to be number 3 in the world.

    19. The USD will continue to prosper, as people realise that it's a terrible currency, but better than all the rest.

    20. Many of these predictions will be proved wrong.

  4. Re:Wireless REPLACING land lines? by Saib0t · · Score: 4, Insightful
    I find the easiest way to transfer a few hundred gigs, wirelessly, to our other office, involves a Chevrolet.

    Yep, always remember this quote:

    "Never understimate the bandwidth of a station wagon full of tapes hurtling down the highway"
    Andrew Tannenbaum

    --

    One shall speak only if what one has to say is more beautiful than silence
  5. Doesn't surprise me by XxtraLarGe · · Score: 1, Insightful
    "In 2005, personal calling on wireless phones in the United States exceeded that on residential land lines, even though 35 percent of the U.S. population doesn't have wireless, according to the Yankee Group."

    It seems to me that a lot of people who own cell phones talk on them just to be seen talking on them. "Hey everybody, look at me! I have a cell phone. I'm important! The person on the phone is more important to talk to than the other people I'm with!" Obviously, it's not the case with everybody. My wife has a cell phone (I do not), and we typically only use it for minor emergencies. Has this been others' experience?

    --
    Taking guns away from the 99% gives the 1% 100% of the power.
  6. Re:Wireless REPLACING land lines? by BadassJesus · · Score: 3, Insightful
    I've "upgraded" my wireless home network to PERMANENT gigabit ethernet recently. So far so good.

    Main reasons for trashing wireless:

    1. bandwidth is limited (my top of the line Wireless-G router ASUS-G500) "top speed" is 2000kB/s and most often much much lower
    2. latency is not even close to the ethernet and with aggregation goes up
    3. annoying antennas at PCs (notebooks are ok)
    4. fear factor that I developed during use of this wireless network,
      outages and downtimes, router restarts, wireless card failures, instant vigil about the signal strength etc.
    5. signal fluctuations due to moving people, home antenna shifts and other unpredictable factors that limits the signal


    My notebooks are still on wireless, for the web it is just ok though.
  7. The Apocalypse by dangitman · · Score: 3, Insightful
    Predictive punditry is about the lowest form of tech journalism. It's also one of the most amusing. I wonder if these pundits realize that a significant portion of their audience only reads their columns to laugh at the author and deride the predictions?

    2005's list is a real low-light. The opening paragraph of the Wired article is like a kick to the groin. Dvorak was right! Neener neener neener. Nevermind that he got the timing wrong, and just about everything else he says never comes true. Is it really predicting when you just throw as many possibilities out there as possible, and ignore the 99% failure rate?

    For your New Year's schadenfreude entertainment, be sure to catch Robert Cringely twist and turn his predictions ikn an effort to make himself look insightful in hindsight. Last time he claimed a 70% accuracy rate, or some bullshit figure.

    http://www.pbs.org/cringely/

    His New Year column isn't out yet, just some ramble about advertising killing print media. But he's always at his most hilarious when trying to justify his predictions.

    --
    ... and then they built the supercollider.