Slashdot Mirror


The Future of Telecom is in Wales

An anonymous reader wrote to mention a CNN Money story about the future of U.K. telecommunications. British Telecom is planning on rolling out an $18 Billion new system in 2010, and the first location to get the hook up is Cardiff, in Wales. From the article: "What's really cool about what will happen in Cardiff - and eventually the rest of the U.K. - is that BT is creating an open, standards-based platform for which anyone can develop new applications. In other words, the phone has the potential to become more like the Internet with its proliferation of cool new Web sites, tools and services."

125 comments

  1. Whales have telephones? by spun · · Score: 1, Funny

    They must use hands free headsets. Damn, I knew whales were smart, but this is amazing.

    --
    - None can love freedom heartily, but good men; the rest love not freedom, but license. -- John Milton
    1. Re:Whales have telephones? by mmarlett · · Score: 2, Funny

      No, no ... it's not the whales. It's the people they eat. It's very hard to get reception inside a whale, and therefore very difficult to get help when a whale eats you. In old days, they had to light a fire and hope that a passing ship could see the smoke -- now we'll be able to send pictures of the ribcage and everything. Come on, man, RTFA.

    2. Re:Whales have telephones? by tverbeek · · Score: 1

      Whales can communicate with probes in outer space, you id10t! Didn't you see ST4:TVH?

      --
      http://alternatives.rzero.com/
    3. Re:Whales have telephones? by LordSnooty · · Score: 1

      That truly is the worst pun ever. Not only is it hackneyed but it doesn't make literal sense. The future is in whales would mean phones will be made from whalebone, or whales will ferry your conversation over the seas.

    4. Re:Whales have telephones? by Jambon · · Score: 1

      this could make quite a splash.

    5. Re:Whales have telephones? by jimmydigital · · Score: 1

      Oh no! Not Little Wooden Boy!

      --
      Every normal man must be tempted, at times, to spit on his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin slitting throats. -HLM
    6. Re:Whales have telephones? by deathy_epl+ccs · · Score: 1

      OK, seriously dude... when you feel the need to nitpick bad puns (is there any other kind?), then it's time to up your dose. heheheheheheh.

    7. Re:Whales have telephones? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Nah, they use flipper phones.

    8. Re:Whales have telephones? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Please someone make sure that the sound is actually good? I cannot understand that in this day and age we are still hearing hissss, cracks and pops, and can barely recognize who is talking in a conference call. It should sound like that guy on the FM radio, not the one at the end of the tunnel.
      I want my phone to be a 100$ microphone with a sound output to my digital sound system, not a 15 cents 1/4" speaker!

  2. The IT Parallel by neonprimetime · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Asked to speculate on why other big phone companies have been reluctant to embrace open standards, Reynolds demurs, but suggests that openness makes BT's strategy less risky, not more. "You get more people's intellectual capital," he says.

    There is a parallel here to the IT world ... and I'll give you a hint: Microsoft would make a great big phone company.

    1. Re:The IT Parallel by WindBourne · · Score: 1

      I would not be surprised to see the set-up and laws are slanted towards MS.

      --
      I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
    2. Re:The IT Parallel by gstoddart · · Score: 1
      There is a parallel here to the IT world ... and I'll give you a hint: Microsoft would make a great big phone company.

      You're right. They would have produced some great-big phones alright. Gargantuan no less. It would still be a rotaty phone, it would take three people to dial it, and for no good reason, it would disconnet your calls at random. And, it wouldn't work with any non-Microsoft phones. You'd need to talk to your friends in an obscure dialect of Swahili, but soon, everyone would be speaking that no-longer-obscure dialect, and pretending they loved it. Every few years, you'd need to buy a new great-big phone at great expense, as your old phone wouldn't be able to dial new phone numbers any more.

      Who knows, they might have even become the "Acme Great-Big Phone Company" and corner the market on great-big phones.

      Or, did you mean a "great", "big phone company"?? =)

      [ To any non-native speakers of English, I apologize for the preceding. To any native speakers of English, I apologize even more. ;-]
      --
      Lost at C:>. Found at C.
    3. Re:The IT Parallel by Goodgerster · · Score: 0
      You're right. They would have produced some great-big phones alright. Gargantuan no less. It would still be a rotaty phone, it would take three people to dial it, and for no good reason, it would disconnet your calls at random. And, it wouldn't work with any non-Microsoft phones. You'd need to talk to your friends in an obscure dialect of Swahili, but soon, everyone would be speaking that no-longer-obscure dialect, and pretending they loved it. Every few years, you'd need to buy a new great-big phone at great expense, as your old phone wouldn't be able to dial new phone numbers any more.

      Actually, with the release of Microsoft PhoneXP, it only disconnects when both users are shouting; and it has touch-tone, but you need to undo a special catch to use it, and even then it's only sitting on the rotary dial. And it requires five people to dial it.

  3. on BT... by joe+155 · · Score: 4, Interesting

    ...My mum's husband works for BT as some kind of manager/organiser; he was telling me that they had been at a team meeting about a year ago where they were looking at replacing the current phone system with ultra high band VOIP. They were also taking about putting television content down the line as well... I don't know when they were thinking of trying to get this sytem out but it sounded interesting

    --
    *''I can't believe it's not a hyperlink.''
    1. Re:on BT... by thePig · · Score: 2

      I am not too sure.
      VOIP shouldnt have any say in this.
      VOIP is primarily bearer channel, while for providing services etc, the signalling channel is what is important.

      But it is true that signalling protocols are also changing for the better.
      Instead of the TDM based ISUP etc, the movement is towards SIP, which should help.

      Mind you, this is not a new thing. SIP was completely ready by 2000 itself. Only that it is now everybody is moving towards it.

      --
      rajmohan_h@yahoo.com
    2. Re:on BT... by techno-vampire · · Score: 1
      They were also taking about putting television content down the line as well...

      If so, they can set it up so it can be viewed on sets that haven't the ability to receive broadcasts. Won't that make the TV license people happy!

      --
      Good, inexpensive web hosting
    3. Re:on BT... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      ...My mum's husband works for BT as some kind of manager/organiser; he was telling me that they had been at a team meeting about a year ago where they were looking at replacing the current phone system with ultra high band VOIP. They were also taking about putting television content down the line as well... I don't know when they were thinking of trying to get this sytem out but it sounded interesting

      This project has been in the works for a while and it has hardware vendors salivating. A small piece of $18 billion is a lot of money. There are a lot of technical hurdles too. How do you track, manage, perform lawful intercept, ensure privacy, ensure Quality, and route enormous amounts of voice data encapsulated in VPNs and other tunnels? Most tools regard them as sort of a black box, and thus do nothing with it. This project by BT has spurred more than one new technology. Some of the security features they are rolling out are also cutting edge. Cool stuff.

    4. Re:on BT... by nickh01uk · · Score: 1

      I was surprised to learn that BT arent actually the number 1 provider of Internet Access to businesses in the UK, actually its Verizon through their UUNET/MCI/Worldcom acquisition last year. The info on exactly who owns what part of that market is here (registration required).
      N.

    5. Re:on BT... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Sounds like rubbish to me. VoIP doesn't even apply here. My take is they're talking about replacing SS7, which is showing its age.

    6. Re:on BT... by cb372 · · Score: 1

      Are you referring to the "21st Century Networks" project? I don't know that much about it either, but I have a friend who is working on it as a contractor for BT and he thinks the whole thing is a big waste of time. It seems to be some hugely over-ambitious project to replace the whole PSTN network with some kind of spooky half-circuit/half-packet switched network that's kinda like VoIP but not quite. Anyway, as I said before, I don't know much about it :)

    7. Re:on BT... by SteveAyre · · Score: 1

      I worked there too for a while (student placement).

      21CN is basically running fiberoptic cable to the green box at the end of your road, and you only use ADSL as far as that box. That'll let you get much faster speeds than ADSL does currently, and it won't matter how far you are from the exchange. In the longer term they may even run fiberoptic straight into your house.

      Once they've done that they'll move the entire phone network onto running over a network using the IP protocol (they've already done this for the core of the network). That's where the VOIP comes in - they'll move calls onto IP.

      It goes further than that though because they'll have much faster connections than now and be able to do things like HDTV streaming.

      Whether it's worth it is debatable. Phonewise, it won't really be different now, except for subtle differences like being able to use your computer as a phone (easily). The increase in speed will be nice on it's own, but should also lead to people coming up with new ways of using it which BT's hoping. The new connection's should also be more reliable and easier to debug when there is a problem. It'll take quite a while to upgrade though, and cost them a hell of a lot.

    8. Re:on BT... by camiel · · Score: 1

      The 21 Century Network sounds very VDSL to me. I don't see why the 21CN is very special. The telecom operators in Belgium and the Netherlands already provide television service over their ADSL2 networks. Belgacom, the Belgian operator, already has VDSL in service and KPN, the Dutch operator, will roll-out VDSL at the end of this year or next year.

    9. Re:on BT... by ofcourseyouare · · Score: 1

      They were also taking about putting television content down the line as well... I don't know when they were thinking of trying to get this sytem out but it sounded interesting
      BT's TV-down-a-wire project is called BT vision, info at http://www.btvision.bt.com/
      The clever thing about it is that is integrates video-on-demand coming down a wire with on-air content via Freeview ("Freeview" is the UK's name for digital terrestrial TV).
      Translation: if you want to watch a movie on demand, it comes down your ADSL line. But if you want to watch the FA cup live with 10 billion other Britons, it goes through the air, thus reducing the network congestion issues you get with webcasting. Both forms of content are controlled from the same integrated electronic programme guide. Or that's the plan anyway...

  4. Of course it is by Robotech_Master · · Score: 5, Funny

    The future of everything is in Cardiff, really. And so is the past. All bundled up in a police box with a flashing blue light on the top...

    --
    Editor Emeritus and Senior Writer, TeleRead.org
    1. Re:Of course it is by eheldreth · · Score: 1

      Funny, I thought he just stoped to reenergize.

      --
      The perversity of the Universe tends towards a maximum. - O'Toole's Corollary
    2. Re:Of course it is by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's the Blaidd Drwg Project, of course.

    3. Re:Of course it is by Psychotext · · Score: 1

      Damn lack of mod points!

      --
      People that believe in their opinions don't post AC.
    4. Re:Of course it is by jacksonj04 · · Score: 1

      It's also the home of BT's biggest datacentre (And one not-biggest BT datacentre).

      --
      How many people can read hex if only you and dead people can read hex?
    5. Re:Of course it is by Mercano · · Score: 2, Informative

      Well, they were refuling off the temporal rift left over from a previous (by ~9 episodes or ~125 years) visit.

      Back on our rather mundane version of Earth, the show is filmed in Cardif, as is Torchwood, the upcoming spinoff, which also takes place there.

      --
      #include <signature.h>
    6. Re:Of course it is by tweek · · Score: 1

      Is there any news of when Torchwood shows? I'm guessing they've already started filiming.

      --
      "Fighting the underpants gnomes since 1998!" "Bruce Schneier knows the state of schroedinger's cat"
    7. Re:Of course it is by eheldreth · · Score: 1

      Being a dumb USA'n I didn't realize where it was filmed. Good info.

      --
      The perversity of the Universe tends towards a maximum. - O'Toole's Corollary
  5. Other way ? by earthstar · · Score: 3, Interesting
    the phone has the potential to become more like the Internet

    Is it not the other way ?
    Infact ,

    (British Telecom) the incumbent phone company in the United Kingdom, is planning to shut off all of its legacy phone networks - a hodge podge of systems that includes the traditional "circuit switched" system that has served as the architecture for delivering phone calls for more than a century - by 2010
  6. Won't be open because of stupid laws by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

    This will not be an open system because of the stupid laws that have been passed in the UK. As soon as someone attempts to use the system for something innovative or query the system they will be charged with a computer crime.

  7. This is good? by tverbeek · · Score: 2, Insightful

    "the phone has the potential to become more like the Internet with its proliferation of cool new Web sites, tools and services."

    ...spam, phishing, viruses, DDOS, adverts....

    --
    http://alternatives.rzero.com/
    1. Re:This is good? by MrSquirrel · · Score: 1

      don't forget: "ring ring ring ring ring ring ring, banana phoooone, ring ring ring ring ring ring ring, banana phoooooone" ...except replace "banana" with "porn".

      --
      A computer once beat me at chess, but it was no match for me at kick boxing.
  8. Writing Applications in BT? by organgtool · · Score: 0, Redundant
    "BT is creating an open, standards-based platform for which anyone can develop new applications"

    Why go through all the hassle of developing applications in BitTorrent when you can just download them like a normal person?
    1. Re:Writing Applications in BT? by $RANDOMLUSER · · Score: 3, Funny

      Uh, that's British Telecom.

      --
      No folly is more costly than the folly of intolerant idealism. - Winston Churchill
    2. Re:Writing Applications in BT? by organgtool · · Score: 0

      Yes, Ted, that was the joke (Obligatory Family Guy reference)

    3. Re:Writing Applications in BT? by Mikelikus · · Score: 1

      I was actually tempted to mod the parent funny :)

      --
      -- Would it be acceptable to just put my name on my sig?
  9. What are they changing? by thePig · · Score: 1

    From the article

    Right now, for example, most of the mildly interesting stuff consumers can do with their phones - call waiting, caller ID, call forwarding - is programmed right into the big computers that route calls around the network. That makes it impossible for some some teenager tinkering at his computer to develop a new phone service.


    Not exactly.
    Heard about IN or CAMEL ??
    These were all designed as a way to take the power out from switches and provide a database which can be used by small switches.
    Using IN/CAMEL, it is very easy to provide/handle ANY service.

    And what I want to see is how they are going to provide Lawful Intercept using the new platform.

    --
    rajmohan_h@yahoo.com
    1. Re:What are they changing? by grasshoppa · · Score: 1

      And what I want to see is how they are going to provide Lawful Intercept using the new platform.

      If anything, an ip based system will make it easier..far far easier..to do wiretaps. it can all be done online and remotely as needed.

      Hell, the phone system where I work has this capability. I can call up, enter my password and listen in on any zap line. Easy to program too.

      --
      Mod me down with all of your hatred and your journey towards the dark side will be complete!
    2. Re:What are they changing? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Sure, there is a published interface of messages you can use for IN or CAMEL. But, the phone companies make it nearly impossible for anyone to actually connect to the network and run applications; something about it making them a dumb pipe and they don't trust developers from destroying their control network somehow. That's why we don't see applications now and why I doubt we'll see any applications result from this so-called openness in the future.

      I can publish my website and run a service on it right now. How many years and meetings and dollars do you think it takes to hook an app up to the paranoid, parochial phone company controlling access for would-be application providers?

  10. This is probably the last big battle by artakka · · Score: 1
    This is the last big battle to control the ones and zeros that enter your house.


    In the very near future there will be one pipe that pump all the bits into and out of your house, be it video, phone, audio, internet or just your house alarm.

    And I bet the conduit will not be a couple of copper wires. Telephone, you are so 19th century....

    1. Re:This is probably the last big battle by $RANDOMLUSER · · Score: 1

      The "last mile" is going to be twisted copper for a looooong time to come.

      --
      No folly is more costly than the folly of intolerant idealism. - Winston Churchill
    2. Re:This is probably the last big battle by hador_nyc · · Score: 1

      Verison, in parts of the New York area, is installing fiber for the last mile. While I agree that most places, particularly in rural areas will be fiber for a long time, the denser ones will likely get the fiber. It's the best way for the telcos to fight with Cable, so it seems logical that they'll pursue it.

      my two cents.... i admit i could be wrong...

      --
      - Mike
      Once you've lost your temper, you've lost the argument - Me
    3. Re:This is probably the last big battle by brez180 · · Score: 1

      Verizon already offers FIOS - one fiber optic link that gives you Internet, TV, and Phone service.

  11. Blimey... by Clazzy · · Score: 3, Funny

    I never expected sheep and mountains to be the future of telecom. Scientists nowadays, eh?

    --
    If we can hit that bull's-eye, the rest of the dominoes will fall like a house of cards... Checkmate.
    1. Re:Blimey... by CommunistHamster · · Score: 1

      Very odd to see Wales on Slashdot

    2. Re:Blimey... by dr_dank · · Score: 2, Funny

      leaps into the room in red garb

      NOBODY expects the sheep and mountains!

      --
      Where does the school board find them and why do they keep sending them to ME?
    3. Re:Blimey... by TheRaven64 · · Score: 1
      Over the last few years there has been a lot of funding poured into technology-related businesses in South Wales. The infrastructure is there - both cable and ADSL are available in and around the major habitations, and if you are in one of the Techniums then you may be able to connect to the South Wales Metropolitan Area Network (a 10Gbit backbone that goes along the south coast; I've got a couple of machines on 1GBit links connected to it).

      The Welsh Development Agency (which is now part of the Welsh Assembly Government's Department of Enterprise, Innovation and Networks) has been keen to fund tech-related start-ups, and there are a large number of small software and related companies sprouting up all over the place. This is helped by the very low cost of living in South Wales; you can pay people half what they would earn in London, and they still have more take-home pay. Persuading people to move there is made easier by the gorgeous scenery, and harder by the typically British weather (although it has been very hot the last few days).

      The Technium project, and a few similar enterprises, have been running for a few years, providing incubator units for small businesses. These allow start-ups to share facilities such as meeting rooms, and to talk to each other regularly and pass business to each other.

      A lot of companies Slashdot would be familiar with have employees in the area. If you use Linux, you've probably heard of Alan Cox; he works for Red Hat these days and still lives in Swansea. At least one of the Mono developers who works for Ximian/Novell also lives in the area. There is a relatively active Linux Users' Group, and the Swansea University Computer Society is also very active.

      Wales has a reputation for being all about the sheep (in more ways than one), but the Welsh Assembly has been trying hard over the last few years to reduce the country's economic dependency on farming and increase the tech sector to compensate.

      --
      I am TheRaven on Soylent News
    4. Re:Blimey... by DiscoDave_25 · · Score: 1

      You owe me one keyboard...

      Mines just been destroyed by the very effective coffee through nose delivery system.

  12. Oh no you don't BT! by drspliff · · Score: 2, Insightful

    There's a problem here, we already have an open standards based telephony standard, that allows custom application developers and users to customize their telephones.

    "This is no small thing. Right now, for example, most of the mildly interesting stuff consumers can do with their phones - call waiting, caller ID, call forwarding - is programmed right into the big computers that route calls around the network. That makes it virtually impossible for some entrepreneur in a garage or some teenager tinkering at his computer to develop a new phone service."

    While on the other hand, with SIP and IAX you can do whatever you want.. today! As we speak I have an Asterisk server with a Cepstral auto attendant connected to a PSTN gateway.. Voicemail. call forwarding, location tracking (e.g. at lunch it directs calls to my mobile/cell phone).

    Knowing BT's history with pricing and service quality I'd stay fairly clear from this. (For the record, BT's customer support and internet services are appallingly bad, and compared to existing SIP to PSTN or even Skype their international calling rates are very high).

    BT's problems are deeply routed in the way they do business with their infrastructure services, to mention a few: price fixing and their 'modular' internal structure... In short it means everybody offers ADSL at the same price, apart from them.. and their Billing, Broadband, Dialup and Telephone departments seem to rely in pidgeons or paper cups on strings to communicate with each other!

    Just my two pennies.

    1. Re:Oh no you don't BT! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hey genius, your two cents aren't worth shit--they're using SIP to build this. http://btsoftphone.com/

    2. Re:Oh no you don't BT! by gpuk · · Score: 3, Informative

      BT is a huge corporation. You need to make a distinction between their various retail arms and their network/infrastructure arm.

      BT retail is appaulingly bad and the criticisms you make are all valid.

      However, the network/infrastructure arm of BT is among the best in the world.

      Thanks to BT:
      1). The UK enjoys 99% ADSL coverage
      2). The UK has the deapest ADSL penetration in Europe (http://www.theregister.co.uk/2006/01/03/broadband _france_uk/)
      3). Thanks to the recent successfull rollout of MAX DSL you can now get up to 8MB down and 480KB up
      4). We have some of the most competative ADSL pricing in Europe
      5). There are a huge array of different ISPs and packages available on the market (http://www.adslguide.org.uk)
      6). They are no longer a monoply which is why you can get ADSL for GBP£10/mnth or you can get ADSL for GBP £70 month depending on what you want and who you want to provide it.
      7). We are approaching over 500,000 unbundled lines (LLU) which puts us second place in Europe for LLU

      The Cardiff initiative is nothing to do with BT Retail. It is BT's next generation infrastructure trial and from what I have read this new platform will ensure the underlying BT network remains one of the most advanced and reliable in the world, with all the benefits this will bring.

    3. Re:Oh no you don't BT! by tehcyder · · Score: 1

      BT certainly sounds like a great company to work for, they even give you time to post on slashdot.

      --
      To have a right to do a thing is not at all the same as to be right in doing it
    4. Re:Oh no you don't BT! by gpuk · · Score: 1

      *sigh* do I detect another BT hater?

      No, I don't work for them and yes I do work for a great company in a position that affords me 30 minutes on slashdot once or twice a week.

  13. Re:Whales by EL_mal0 · · Score: 1

    It is in whales. You may have heard about the bandwidth of pigeons a while back (http://science.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=04/03/ 31/2224227). Whales are even better. Not only do they have a vastly higher BPA (bytes per animal) than pigeons, but they can get your data to different continents!

    It's the wave of the future!

  14. Pot Noodles by Anne+Thwacks · · Score: 3, Funny

    At least it will create work for all those redundant pot noodle miners.

    --
    Sent from my ASR33 using ASCII
  15. Doubts by Sv-Manowar · · Score: 1

    Somehow I doubt it will create a rival to the internet, but to see the telecoms companies finally upgrading the basic abilities of the phone is good, they have been complacent in the past and they were risking the whole market share of the phone (after the proliferation of mobiles and services such as Skype). Hopefully they will keep up this creativity and be rewarded for it by the consumers.

    1. Re:Doubts by stunt_penguin · · Score: 1

      This isn't supposed to be a rival to the internet, but instead to make telephony and other data services (including TV) more like the internet. RTFA.

      --
      When the posters fear their moderators, there is tyranny; when the moderators fears the posters, there is liberty.
  16. Re:tags by venir · · Score: 1

    Sounds like someone needs a cookie.

  17. Notable people by Rob+T+Firefly · · Score: 2, Funny

    The measure is primarily backed by a Mr. Jonah and a Mr. Ahab, two men who claim lots of experience with Wales.

  18. They've been saying that for years by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Or was that the Isle of Mann?

  19. I imagine by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I seem to get a mental image of the Pony Express, with sheep..

  20. Nice PR, but let's see it happen... by raoul+Pop · · Score: 1
    It's one thing to tout the capabilities of a future system, and it's quite another to put it into practice and deliver the goods. I'm reading a book called "Making Change Stick", by Richard C. Reale, and wanted to quote a couple of sentence from it, which apply nicely to this:

    "The key question is, why does change so often fail to stick? On closer examination perhaps it's not that we regressed but rather that the change was more illusion than reality. We painted a few eggs gold in the expectation that the goose would be inspired, get the picture, and start laying golden ones. The elements necessary to accomplish and sustain the change were neither identified nor implemented."

    I say it applies to this because I haven't heard many good things about BT over the years. On the contrary, I've heard they're stodgy and set in their ways. I'm curious to see how they're going to pull off something this big, and I wonder if it's not a a lot of hot air. But there's something to be said about a hungry workforce from an ex-coal town. They're hungry to work and be productive, so let's see if they can change something at BT.
    --
    ComeAcross -- You never know what you'll find.
    1. Re:Nice PR, but let's see it happen... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's one thing to tout the capabilities of a future system, and it's quite another to put it into practice and deliver the goods.

      We've already shipped them cutting edge gear for this project. They definitely are building things.

      I say it applies to this because I haven't heard many good things about BT over the years. On the contrary, I've heard they're stodgy and set in their ways.

      Compared to most tier-1's I'd say they are probably more open to change, if anything. I can say with confidence they are the very first people to roll out some of the new technologies we've developed, eagerly signing up as alpha and beta customers. That puts them 6 months to 2 years ahead of the rest of the pack.

  21. Re:Slashdot: by rob1980 · · Score: 1

    Shut your goddamn mouth. All hail Commander Taco!

  22. Old News by KyrBe · · Score: 1

    Check out: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2005/02/22/bt_21cn_re ynolds/ and http://insight.zdnet.co.uk/communications/networks /0,39020427,39220184,00.htm

    And there's been plenty more discussion about this online and in the UK media. Probably been posted or commented on here too...

  23. My favorite telco "application" is... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Free power from the line. ;)

  24. It's all just data. Content should be king. by stunt_penguin · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I've been saying for a long time that the means by which data will go in and and out of our homes and businesses is going to just boil down to one means, and that'll either be a single copper or optical wire with a router at the end, or a dish that communucates with a mast a few miles away.
    Living in Ireland at the moment , I've got a telephone line (which i'm soon dropping), cable internet, and a satellite TV dish all sending and receiving data at various times. They're all branded under different names etc- NTL, Sky, Eirom etc, but they;re all just doing the same thing. All these people are doing is selling me different ways of getting information in and out of here, and they're charging me a combined total of about 100 a month to do it, too.

    The sooner someone can give me a line that will serve my internet, telephony and TV needs with one 50 a month connection the better.

    It seems we pay so much for our data connections, and very little for the content. That missing 50 that would no longer be leaving my pocket for the shareholders of various telecoms every month would do very nicely in the pockets of content providers, whose channels I would be able to subscribe to and whose programmes would be downloaded to my hard disk while I sleep. Maybe then they'll be more content to let me watch their content without watching the commercials.

    Anyway my bottom line is- simpler infrastructures means less money paying for various telecoms, and more money left over every month to pay for subscriptions and content.

    --
    When the posters fear their moderators, there is tyranny; when the moderators fears the posters, there is liberty.
    1. Re:It's all just data. Content should be king. by inKubus · · Score: 1

      What about redundancy, in light of: backhoe operators, lightning, government wiretapping, corporate mismanagement, black hats, "phishers" (I hate that term), etc. do you think it's a good idea to have all of your connectivity through one provider? All of your eggs in one basket. The only way I would have it that way is if there was strong regulation by a non-government independent body with power and accountability of the actual physical wire. Then the wire will be "sold" based on the available bandwidth, in certain chunks guaranteeing QOS of that amount.

      The problem is exactly like what happened in the 90's with ELECTRICITY. Enron "oversold" some lines, causing them to go down. All of a sudden there's a bidding war because all of the traffic still needs to travel somewhere but there's not bandwidth for all of it. In addition, the providers won't invest in new bandwidth because that will drop the overall "value" of a bandwidth "frame" or unit (unless demand is skyrocketing). The market forces basically guarantee that all lines will be filled almost to capacity.

      Therefore this regulating body must be totally neutral and totally about getting as much bandwidth to the people as possible, taxing the PROVIDERS who use the wires in order to make sure everyone has everything they need at the lowest possible cost.

      Members of the body would have to prove their nutrality ahead of time by showing:

      a. They are not immediately or indirectly related by blood to any employee of any of the providers (to a certain point, ie: 3 generations, by law across 3 degrees)
      b. They do not own stock in any of the companies
      c. a. and b. qualify also for any company that has, is or will contract(ed)(s) with the provider for any purpose
      d. Anyone who lies will have their right hand chopped off and will be publically humilliated in a stockade.

      The problem is the utility paradox, as I like to call it. It's a flaw in the capitalist system based on human desire. It would be pretty easy to open the utility business up to everyone, but you'll have a huge web of wires from 123818 different companies overhead. Company 1 only runs to house A on your block, etc. And gradually market forces whittle it down to the people who are making money, with Company 2 saying "well, we only got 10 people signed up in the city, it's not worth going in there). Which is where we're at now.

      The problem is that these companies are settled in and there is a huge war between the party line cable providers and the star topology telcos at the local (to the end) level. The cable companies are ahead because their loop/party line is way cheaper to implement within a city. BUT, as bandwidth requirements skyrocket, they are going to run out fast. The star topology telcos have a huge infrastructure in place but it's all outdated and they need to raise money to build a new network. Otherwise, they are going to lose out in the short term to the better positioned cable providers and eventually the cable providers will buy them up to shut them down.

      The trump card of the telcos is twofold:

      #1, they have a monopoly on long hauls. The industry consolidation has converged what used to be 12-15 long haul "tier one" providers into about 5 (V, E, M, A, U). Pretty much every long haul line in America and translantic is owned by a telco. I think Cox (a large privately held cable provider) is trying to put a network into place, but it's held together by leased lines from the telco, which would be affected by the new tariffs.

      #2, they have WIRELESS, which is going to be a big part of local access. Where I'm from, most people don't have a land telephone line; they use a cellular. Wireless still needs long hauls for long distance though...

      So, the telcos need to raise money to boost their failing high-profit local business. How to do that? Leverage their trump card with a government imposed corporate tariff that taxes their competition more than anyone else. And of course consumers are going to be affected because we will be paying a third time for any bandwidth we consume.

      --
      Cool! Amazing Toys.
  25. Really looking forward to by Linker3000 · · Score: 1

    Hi tech phones eh? Hmm..I can see it now: my home phone having an 8 megapixel camera so I can lift it up and take a picture of the postman as he drops off my mail, or maybe an artistic one of the shelf on the wall in the hallway.

    --
    AT&ROFLMAO
  26. Wales - a country where people live by epa · · Score: 2, Informative

    It is rare that I get annoyed to the point of being offended, but this thread has almost done it. For those (especially in North America) who lack education, Wales is a small western European country of about 3.5 million people. It is a semi-autonomous part of the United Kingdom. In the 1970s and 1980s, it suffered tremendously from loss of traditional industries, but that is the past. We have have a vibrant business environment that has encouraged centres for optical technology in St Asaph, software in Bangor and biotech in Swansea. Wales now has low unemployment, and has one of the largest manufacturing installations in Europe, in Airbus (Broughton, Flintshire). BT does not have much of an enthusiastic following in the UK. That is litotes! The Welsh Assembly Government has been central in even getting me ADSL, here in North Wales. Artificially confusing Wales with whales is really just racism. Just because we are a small country does not mean that we should be subject to snide quips. The comments I have read here are below the level I normally associate with slashdot. A

    --
    Time is life: speed saves it. LJK Setright
    1. Re:Wales - a country where people live by dugjohnson · · Score: 2, Funny

      It's not the lack of education, but the love of the pun that is offensive, but not particularly rare, unfortunately. A lot of us Americans know about Wales, and where it is, and la la la. Welsh Corgis, Welshmen taking a leek, Welsh's grape juice (Ok, sorry).
      Unbunch thy panties, we make fun of ourselves too.

      --
      My brain is overly lubricated
    2. Re:Wales - a country where people live by mmarlett · · Score: 1

      As the first person to reply to what was clearly a bad pun for the sake of fun, let me point out that it is not racism. Racism would be something like, "Welsh people have no sense of humor -- probably because they are so pale." But, since they picked up the torch with that delightful new Doctor Who series, they must have some sort of sense of humor (if not melanin). Artificially confusing "Wales" with "whales" is really, in fact, making fun of the English language. Homonyms are fun. And so are palindromes. ("The palindrome of 'Bolton' would be 'Notlob.' It don't work!") I think plenty of us here in North America (regardless of how much edumatatiom we lack) would probably think that just because we're a large continent (actually, rather medium) doesn't mean we should be the subject of snide quips, either. This, however, is perfectly on par with the level of comments normally associated with Slashdot (which, if I was educated properly, is capitalized). Now if you'll excuse me, I'm going to find my Stetson and my Smith and Wesson, step out into the hot Kansas sun, and rustle me up some cattle (left 'em right down there between the Boeing and Airbus factories).

    3. Re:Wales - a country where people live by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The Welsh also live down mines, sing about gold, and have a far too close communion with sheep to make me comfortable.

    4. Re:Wales - a country where people live by epa · · Score: 1

      So, would you be content with making the same puns/slanders/slights against black people in your county? Bet you wouldn't! You seem to be suggesting that we in Wales ought to be amused by your racist quips. Would you suggest the same to a black american when you made some quazi racist remark that effectively ignored their identity? A

      --
      Time is life: speed saves it. LJK Setright
    5. Re:Wales - a country where people live by spun · · Score: 1

      I'm sorry. Gosh you Brits are touchy. Haha, no, Not only do I know about Wales, I also know you get horribly offended being called British. Seriously, I'd love to visit someday, make a tour of England, Scotland, & Wales. I wasn't trying to put you down, really!

      --
      - None can love freedom heartily, but good men; the rest love not freedom, but license. -- John Milton
    6. Re:Wales - a country where people live by dugjohnson · · Score: 2, Insightful

      How is Whales vs. Wales racist?
      And as a Polish American I have heard and told my fair share of Polack jokes.
      Your response makes my point perfectly. Nobody said ANYTHING bad about the Welsh. Yet you are offended. Your panties are, indeed, in a bunch.

      --
      My brain is overly lubricated
    7. Re:Wales - a country where people live by epa · · Score: 1

      I do not think you do know, but here is not the place to discuss it. Nothing that an american could write or say would "put down" any European. I am a Scot who lives in Wales and is of French descent. Please do visit Europe and enjoy the huge diversity of lculture and language that the continent has to offer. Going back a few years, most citizens of the USA found Europeans to be most welcoming. However, Europe has had such a public battering from your current Bush that it is actually percolating down to personal feelings - and that is dreadful. Honestly, a few years ago, I would have had no bias against any US citizen. Now, and it shames me to say it, anything that anyone from the US says or writes is tainted with that president person who presumes to speek for the nation (and whose name I will not type). So, what I am saying is: sorry. I am uppity about those that trivialise Wales. OTOH, I am disposed to think that all Americans are ignorant, reactionary morons, just because Bush is. Oh, to those who like Bush; I am not saying sorry. (Maybe using a semicolon in the last sentence was a mistake. It might get them stuck. Oh no!) A

      --
      Time is life: speed saves it. LJK Setright
    8. Re:Wales - a country where people live by epa · · Score: 1

      What does the word "polack" mean? A

      --
      Time is life: speed saves it. LJK Setright
    9. Re:Wales - a country where people live by Dining+Philanderer · · Score: 1

      Confusing Whales and Wales, which is a stinky semi-autonomous country somewhere in Europe where no one brushes their teeth and everyone marries their sister, is insulting to our sea going friends. It is really just cetaceanism. Just because they live in the sea does not mean they should be subject to snide quips. The comments are below the level I normally browse Slashdot at. Nice sig though...

      --
      Are we perfect? No. But where I should move when I renounce my U.S. citizenship, North Korea, Libya, China, or Iran?
    10. Re:Wales - a country where people live by dugjohnson · · Score: 1

      Ah....a person of Polish descent, but a disparaging term. The comedian began a joke, then stopped...."I'm going to tell a Polack joke now, is there anyone in the audience who's Polish? I don't want to offend you." Pause. Silence. "OK, then, well this Polack walks into a bar."
      A man in the front row stands up and says, "Hey wait a minute, I'M Polish." badda-boom.

      An American entrepreneur took a box of Cheerios to Poland to sell them as donut seeds. chhhh!

      A guy in a bar leans over to the guy next to him and says, "Wanna hear a Polack joke?"
      The guy next to him replies, "Well, before you tell that joke, you should know something. I'm 6' tall, 200 lbs. and I'm Polish. The guy sitting next to me is 6'2" tall, weighs 225, and he's Polish. The fella next to him is 6'5" tall, weighs 250, and he's Polish. Now, you still wanna tell that joke?"
      The first guy says, "Nah, I don't want to have to explain it three times." Bam!

      Thank you, thank you very much, I'm going to be here at the Holiday Inn all week.

      --
      My brain is overly lubricated
    11. Re:Wales - a country where people live by spun · · Score: 1

      I lived in Crete for a year. I visited London for a month. I know more than most Americans do about Europe. I despise Bush. I fear for where my country is going and have tried my damndest to do something about it. I wasn't trivializing Wales. I made a bad pun, nothing to do with trivialising Wales, to be honest, I was trying to make fun of ignorant Americans who probably don't even have a clue that there is a place named Wales somewhere in the world. So please get off your high horse before I start making fun of your country's world renowned love of sheep, and how you all have tails. Oh wait, that's Cornishmen, sorry. ;)

      --
      - None can love freedom heartily, but good men; the rest love not freedom, but license. -- John Milton
    12. Re:Wales - a country where people live by grasshoppa · · Score: 1

      So, would you be content with making the same puns/slanders/slights against black people in your county?

      We can and do. I'm proud to say that for the most part, americans have gotten over our prejudices to the point where we can laugh at them.

      At least my generation does ( 30-35 ). I realize that I am a wetback/cracker mix, with all the jokes that entails.

      --
      Mod me down with all of your hatred and your journey towards the dark side will be complete!
    13. Re:Wales - a country where people live by epa · · Score: 1
      Totally confused! In the UK just now, there is the architypal "Polish Plumber".

      For years, the UK has been desparately short of skilled manual workers. Since Poland joined the European Union, Polish workers (amongst all from other accession states) can work in the UK. The "Polish Plumber"b is the plumber that (unlike the local person) you can get on the 'phone, who is keen to do the job, charges a good price, and is skilled.

      I really do not know why, but the term "Polish Plumber" has come to exemplify a hard-working, reliable, low-cost expert in domestic pluming installation. (I think it could be the alliteration).

      So, "polak" here is probably a like a term of surprised admiration. Polish plumbers are heroes!

      A

      --
      Time is life: speed saves it. LJK Setright
    14. Re:Wales - a country where people live by dugjohnson · · Score: 1

      And here someone from Wales is thought of as.....OK, you were right the first time, most Americans don't think of Wales at all...
      I'm looking forward to getting there someday. It's on my list of places that I want to visit. Now I just need to get it on my wife's list.

      --
      My brain is overly lubricated
    15. Re:Wales - a country where people live by AvitarX · · Score: 1

      You sound like the Kazakhstanis that think Borat is an attack on them, and not an attack of the ignorance of others.

      When I watch a bunch of Texans singing "throw the Jew done the well" I do not think Kazakhstanis hate Jews, I feel sad for my countrymen and at the same time arrogently supperior in a funny way, but nothing negative to Kazakhstan.

      If you could find a pun that attacked America I would be perfectly content (as long as it was punny)

      If I were you <a href="http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/wales/3715512.stm ">this</a> is what would offend me personaly.

      Maybe I am just thicker skinned though.

      --
      Wow, sent an e-mail as suggested when clicking on "use classic" banner, and got a fast response that addressed my msg
    16. Re:Wales - a country where people live by mynameismonkey · · Score: 1

      As a Welshman born and bred I'd like to (a) point out that one Welshman's knee-jerk jump to the front of the racist line is not indicative of all of us, most of us are actually quite thick-skinned, and (b) let you all know that "twpsyn" is Welsh for idiot, feel free to throw that around to any other Cymro whose inferiority complex can't let them hear the "Wales/whales" gag for the nine hundredth time.

      hwyl,

      mae'n enw ydy mwnci

      --
      -- Religion is not an exact science
    17. Re:Wales - a country where people live by NoMaster · · Score: 1
      Homonyms are fun. And so are palindromes. ("The palindrome of 'Bolton' would be 'Notlob.' It don't work!")
      No, but the palindrome of "strap-on" is "no-parts" ;-)

      --
      What part of "a well regulated militia" do you not understand?
    18. Re:Wales - a country where people live by Jaruzel · · Score: 1

      But this is the whole point. Even after all their protestations to the contrary, the US is far LESS integrated racially and culturally than the UK. The UK has had a mix of different cultures since the dawn of time, millenias before the discovery of the 'New World'. As such, when the european borders were opened up, and we started getting eastern european migrants arriving, to do all manner of blue collar work, we took in our stride, and in the most instance, absorbed them into the community.

      From a non-US point of view, the US is inherently racist. Yes it's got lots of cultures, but they are all ghettoised, blacks hang with blacks, latinos with latinos, and WASPs just sit in their big New-England houses sneering at everyone else.

      Just my 2p on this, but I bet I get modded down.

      -Jar.

      --
      Together, We Can Make Slashdot Better. I Do NOT Mod ACs. - Check Me Out
    19. Re:Wales - a country where people live by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      We met in a secluded field, the sun nearly kissing the evening horizon. The warm breeze was full of that earthy, musky scent that only those fortunate enough to live outside the urban rat race know, and a quiet whispering of leaves in the weeping willow overhead added the final touch to the most romantic scene. We lay there, both naked. I knew I had to have her, and have her now. Without a word being spoken, I moved to a position of dominance. I could feel instantly that this was what she was waiting for as she frantically thrust her pelvis at my approaching organ. I moved slowly at first, Inch by inch, until I was fully inside her.

      Then as the tension rose, we threw caution to the wind and abandoned ourselves to the moment. Although inexperienced, she approached every change of position with enthusiasm, moaning with despair every time I withdrew to prevent myself ending it all too soon. As the sexual tension heightened towards the inevitable mind blowing climax, it was all I could do to hold out any longer.

      Finally, the moment we had been building up to was upon us, and passed all too quickly. Breathlessly we rolled together in the now damp grass. As the last deep orange glow of the long setting sun melted into the darkness of approaching night, we lay there still entwined in an amorous embrace. I kissed her long and lovingly, and whispered reassuringly how good she had been. She tenderly and sensuously licked my inner ear then whispered, 'Baaa' and rejoined the flock.

      Extract From The Latest Mills and Boon Novel, only available in Wales.

    20. Re:Wales - a country where people live by thaig · · Score: 1

      I'm from Zimbabwe and of Irish descent and I know what it is to be put down and joked about - it's something that everyone tries to do to everyone and based on many things and not only nationality.

      It is much much harder to not ever put anyone else down than it is to complain when people do it to you. i.e. people always notice insults to themselves and ignore their own insults to others.

      If you can honestly get rid of your prejudgement of Americans then you have some right to ask for the same lack of prejudgement of Welsh people.

      Regards,

      Tim

      --
      This is all just my personal opinion.
    21. Re:Wales - a country where people live by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Wtf is this? a competition to see who designs the next holiday brochure?

    22. Re:Wales - a country where people live by clickclickdrone · · Score: 1

      And people wonder why the Welsh have a reputation for having no sense of humour. Next thing you know you'll be complaining about the Pot Noodle ads. Oh, hang on... Wales: The land that brought you Goldie Looking Chain, which is no bad thing.

      --
      I want a list of atrocities done in your name - Recoil
    23. Re:Wales - a country where people live by drsquare · · Score: 1
      For those (especially in North America) who lack education, Wales is a small western European country of about 3.5 million people.


      To be correct, Wales is a small western European principality of about 2.9 million people.

      It's a principality because it's controlled by the first-born son of the English monarch, and has been since the 13th century. To be technically correct, Wales is a province of England, rather than a country in itself. Sort of like Hawaii or Puerto Rico is to America.
  27. New applications for phones by groeswenphil · · Score: 1

    New applications for phones.....I could design a new application for a phone. I'd call it the somebody answers the phone facility. It works like this.......you phone a bank or a store or an IT support department and you press a magic button on the phone and somebody answers you. A real person that is...not a mindless message asking you to press a combination of buttons. Phil

  28. Nobody cares by DragonHawk · · Score: 1

    The thing is, this is in Cardiff. London doesn't care. The South Wales coast could fall into the sea and they wouldn't notice. ;-)

    --

    dragonhawk@iname.microsoft.com
    I do not like Microsoft. Remove them from my email address.
    1. Re:Nobody cares by Psychotext · · Score: 1

      They might have missed their FA Cup for the last few years...

      --
      People that believe in their opinions don't post AC.
  29. That's not a bad pun, THESE are bad puns... by spun · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    Q. What do you call a cow with two legs shorter than the other two?
    A. Lean Beef!

    Q. What do you call a cow with no legs?
    A. Ground Beef!

    Q. What do you call a cow that has just had an abortion?
    A. Decaffeinated!

    Q. What do you call a bull masturbating?
    A. Beef Straganoff!

    --
    - None can love freedom heartily, but good men; the rest love not freedom, but license. -- John Milton
  30. Re:Whales by josteos · · Score: 0, Troll

    POTS have a new theme song:

    "Bomb the Wales; Bomb The Wales
    Drop the Big One on their.... umm.. Tales?"

    --
    Save the Music; Save the World at http://www.TuneTriever.com (Our latest Android game)
  31. Oh great! by tweek · · Score: 2, Funny


    Wasn't Blaidd Drwg enough of a warning?

    What, are they going to call it "Raxacoricofallapatorian Telecom"?

    --
    "Fighting the underpants gnomes since 1998!" "Bruce Schneier knows the state of schroedinger's cat"
  32. This is different? by ccherlin · · Score: 1

    ...spam, phishing, viruses, DDOS, adverts....

    ...collect-call marketing, phone fraud, slamming, robot calls, junk fax....

  33. Re:Whales by Mercano · · Score: 1

    Of course it is? Why else would lunar whales be in such demand that they become extinct by the year 3000?

    We're whalers on the moon,
    We carry a harpoon.
    But there ain't no whales
    So we tell tall tales
    And sing our whaling tune.

    --
    #include <signature.h>
  34. An ex BT member of staff told me the other day... by VlartBlart · · Score: 0

    ...that British Rail (BR - as it was at the time) have a bigger telecoms network than BT (British Telecom). Something to do with train signals and cables down the side of every track. British Rail *does* have a telecoms license and thought about becoming an internet provider as they have *loads* of spare bandwidth (they're only controlling the signals and other low-bandwidth stuff)

    So - our train network has a better & bigger telecom network than our phone network - typically British! (Wouldn't surprise me that BT has more trains than BR ;))

  35. Ambiguous title by alerante · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    I was really confused by this article until I realized that we weren't talking about Jimbo.

  36. Ym Cymru by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Ym Cymru, ffôn arddel CHI!

    Who says you can't learn taf with an online dictionary? (Cue angry taffs with correct translation and barrage of abuse).

  37. Why? by scotbot · · Score: 1

    Jeezo. Why can't we just have a system that just makes phonecalls? Why does everything have to be applicable? I want to be able to phone someone or have them phone me. I don't want to suffer from someone else's idea of an application.

  38. Re:An ex BT member of staff told me the other day. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    What I'd say was more likely was that the Royal Mail owned more rolling stock than BR, and some other former monopoly delivers more letters, while being outperformed at their key task by BT.

    That straight 1:1 thing isn't convoluted enough for a British system - what were you thinking?

  39. No THIS is a bad pun... by richy+freeway · · Score: 1
    How do you get two whales in a mini?


    Down the M4.

    This'll probably only make sense to UK readers.

  40. NTL by Nurgled · · Score: 1

    You do realise that NTL can already provide you with Telephone, TV and Internet service all down one line, right? :)

    1. Re:NTL by clickclickdrone · · Score: 1

      Don't forget Telewest - they'll even give you the TV in HiDef along with content on demand.

      --
      I want a list of atrocities done in your name - Recoil
    2. Re:NTL by stunt_penguin · · Score: 1

      Yea but their TV service sucks the sweat off of a donkey's balls around here- they've got a shitty remote control and user interface, their programme guide only goes to midnight that night (even if it's 11.30 at night you can only see the next programme or two), their video quality on some minor stations is quite frankly shocking and they accidentally cut me off in the middle of a Grand Prix weekend when they went to disconnect someone else at the same box.

      The eircom line was something I got to get broadband on when NTL weren't doing digital services in our area. I've had so much trouble trying to get decent information services here it makes me cry....

      *runs off sobbing*

      --
      When the posters fear their moderators, there is tyranny; when the moderators fears the posters, there is liberty.
    3. Re:NTL by stunt_penguin · · Score: 1

      True, though they're not anywhere in Ireland AFAIK. That said, NTL and teh 'west are merging aren't they?

      *goes off to check facts*

      --
      When the posters fear their moderators, there is tyranny; when the moderators fears the posters, there is liberty.
    4. Re:NTL by Nurgled · · Score: 1

      I'm sure it'll happen eventually. Telewest has been going broke for a while now. So many of their franchise areas still don't have digital services because they can't afford to upgrade, and people leave them because they don't offer digital services, thus creating a vicious cycle of decline. A merger with NTL (or more likely, NTL just buying Telewest outright) seems very likely at this point.

      That said, I am operating on information from a couple of years back, since I used to live in one of the aforementioned franchise areas and have Telewest service. I now live in an NTL area, though, and I don't subscribe to any cable services.

  41. IP4 or IP6? by Viol8 · · Score: 1

    One would hope its IP6 but the article doesn't state this. Does anyone
    happen to know.

    Also will it be using the SCTP/IP protocol which was specifically
    designed for telecoms or something they've rolled themselves on top
    of IP?