Slashdot Mirror


MacBooks to Feature iPhone's Multi-Touch?

Gadgets Lover writes "According to CrunchGear's 'trusted source' that the upcoming MacBooks which are expected to be released around October will support the iPhone's multi-touch technology built into their touchpads. The feature will be built into the touchpads, allowing you to navigate through your notebook's files, applications, etc. the same way you can on the iPhone. (Yes, I know you can already scroll with them, that's nothing new. I'm talking about all the other finger gestures that can be done on the iPhone's screen) On June 20th, CrunchGear reported, "The upcoming MacBooks will be about half the thickness of current models (which would be quite the feat) and they'll be made from new plastics/materials"."

48 of 276 comments (clear)

  1. Yeah, and... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    The next MacBooks will also be powered by sunshine, float in mid-air, and cure cancer! Thank you Steve Jobs!

    1. Re:Yeah, and... by Sponge+Bath · · Score: 3, Funny

      ...powered by sunshine, float in mid-air, and cure cancer!

      Floating in mid-air would certainly look cool, so this should be a hit with the Mac crowd.

    2. Re:Yeah, and... by wcb4 · · Score: 3, Funny

      As long as they only float and do not move. Flying was featured prominently in Windows XP ads, and is patented by Microsoft. While Apple can not offer this, I hear that Novel might be implementing it for Suse 11

      --
      I reject your reality ... and substitute my own.
    3. Re:Yeah, and... by sokoban · · Score: 5, Funny

      I've got a finger gesture for you Mac fan bois. Ctrl-Alt-Delete?
      --
      09 F9 11 02 9D 74 E3 5B D8 41 56 C5 63 56 88 C0 is the magic number.
    4. Re:Yeah, and... by bakura121 · · Score: 2, Funny

      Now that I know it's powered by sunshine, I'll take three!

  2. Not just the touchpad by Chairboy · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Prediction: Within a year, all Apple products with displays will have multi-touch. Laptops, external monitors, iPods, the whole shebang. Sure, most people won't use it all in the beginning. The UIs we have today aren't set up for it, neither are our office spaces. But Apple will bet the farm and just make is a Standard Feature on the bet that while the demand doesn't exist NOW, it'll appear out of whole cloth once it's so ubiquitous.

    They did it w/ USB. They did it with mice.

    "Blah blah greasy fingerprints on monitors" Yeah, anyone with half a brain can think of 10 reasons why this is dumb. But it's the crazy guy in the back of the auditorium who's going to figure out how to get rich off of it, and in doing so will make the standard transition from 'crazy wacked out goofball' to 'eccentric visionary'.

    1. Re:Not just the touchpad by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting

      They said trackpads, which would be a pretty good compromise actually. Wouldn't have to move your hands far from the keyboard.

      Would make more sense if the Finder CoverFlow feature allowed touching and dragging the images rather than requiring a scrollbar (the way it is in iTunes now). It could be a usability improvement to allow that sort of scrolling in other documents, like webpages.

      If this is coming, then the changes are in Leopard now. Maybe some WWDC attendees know the answer.

      I just looked at the new Finder movie at Apple, and it's got a lot of tiny buttons everywhere for manipulating the view. I'd have to file this rumor in the doubtful category.

    2. Re:Not just the touchpad by skoaldipper · · Score: 2

      Sit at your desk. Now, the whole time you're normally at your computer, keep your hand suspended in the air touching the screen.
      Who says it needs to be limited by this design only? Remember Tron and Ed Dillinger's desk panel? You could easily have the screen at eye level and controls and wrist level. Whatever the case...

      The main benefit of such technology is portability. Also, the next phase of Apple's technology (I hope) would be voice recognition. If we can offload graphics to a dedicated GPU, why not voice to a VPU? Hell, with quad cores and gigahertz, even my poor little 8830 blackberry can recognize last names that would twist your tongue into a pretzel when pronouncing it. And it apparently has no problems decrypting my Texan drawl either.

      As I see it on all future computing devices, the mouse and keyboard should be relegated to the same status as the game port. With Apples' touch technology, you could even redesign the keyboard for external devices. For example, if you've ever used Never Lost on rental vehicles, once you type in a letter, the next set of letters decreases, et cetera, until you have that word. Some words obviously require fewer setup letters. But, you could minimize that effort even further. Say, just have 10 keypad spots for the finger. The left pinky is for articles - a, the, an, etc. The next finger over is for conjunctions - and, or, but, because, etc. And so on. The right few fingers for numerals, etc. After little training, I bet I could spell out words faster than I do now with a qwerty. The alphabet is finite for any language. Also, how many of us actually use a thesaurus in daily communication - the most often used words make that alphabet even more finite.

      Either way, I hope Apple continues this trend, and extends it.
      --
      I hope, when they die, cartoon characters have to answer for their sins.
    3. Re:Not just the touchpad by StarfishOne · · Score: 4, Funny

      "Hammer, problem, nail, etc."


      STOP! Hammer time!


      You can't touch this :P

  3. One step towards... by tehmorph · · Score: 5, Interesting

    ... the Mactablet? I need a decent tablet, and Apple seems to be lining itself up for the ideal position to release one in. Decent touchpads, thin computers... logical, no?

    --
    Could not open .sig for reading- sanity error
  4. Every time ... by WrongSizeGlass · · Score: 5, Funny

    ... I multi-touch a MacBook in a Apple Store I get dirty looks from the employees.

  5. My Thoughts by MBCook · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I have the last revision of the MacBook Pros that just came out. It's a great little laptop. It wouldn't surprise me too much if they did have multi-touch trackpads in the new Macs. It wouldn't surprise me if it was in mine and could be added with a software update. After all, they've supposed detecting when there are two fingers for a while, how much harder can it be to detect the stretching and squeezing motions? Apple has silently updated things before. For example, the cameras in the latest MacBook Pros are 1.3MP instead of 0.3MP. It's not exposed in software, but it's there.

    The 1/2 the thickness thing? Never. Don't get me wrong, I'd LOVE to see that. That would be amazing. But I just don't think it's really possible with the MacBooks. Now if you got rid of the hard drive and optical driver, you'd have a better shot... but I'd still peg this as very unlikely.

    --
    Comment forecast: Bits of genius surrounded by a sea of mediocrity.
  6. British humour by niceone · · Score: 5, Funny

    I for one look forward to giving two fingers to the new MacBooks!

  7. Re:Stop it. Stop it. Just stop it. by WrongSizeGlass · · Score: 4, Funny

    Enough. Just let it go. Please. For your own good. I'll trade you some karma if you just let it go. I already have enough Karma, but I'd trade you for an iPhone. Oh, wait, that kind of defeats the purpose. [Emily Litella] Never mind. [/Emily Litella]
  8. Or maybe just a Leopard feature. by supabeast! · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Given that the current touchpads already have limited capabilities to sense the placement of multiple fingertips, Apple could probably implement some of the technology in Leopard and only release it in the final build. It would certainly be a great way to get a lot of free press.

  9. It will take forcing her to use one. by Spazntwich · · Score: 2, Interesting

    She just plain doesn't want to switch, and there's no rational basis for her decision. As you've pointed out, at this point in time she is looking more for convenient rationalizations for not switching, "leaning curve" being one of the great excuses.

    This is a common thing among people. They'd rather cling to outmoded ideas or irrational opinions to which they're already married because switching would be admitting they're "wrong," a terrifying prospect in modern day society, as the smallest admission of imperfection is blood in the water for the egotistical social sharks that populate our wars.

    Basically, don't hold out much hope for her ever switching, as now that ego is involved she's incredibly unlikely to make any concessions.

    1. Re:It will take forcing her to use one. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Spazntwitch hit the nail on the head. I find it amusing when people mention that they'll "have to learn" how to do something all over again. When I hear this argument, the first thing that goes off in my mind is "If you've actually learned how to do something, then you should have no problem adapting to slightly different scenarios. If, however, you go through a series of steps to accomplish something that you don't understand, you haven't learned anything - you've memorized a series of steps."

  10. What about the heat? by JimDaGeek · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I have a late 2006 Macbook with the Core Due (should have waited for the Core 2, oh well) and a Core 2 Duo iMac. Love them both. The Macbook has a scroll feature I just can't live without. Use one finger on the mouse pad and it moves the cursor as normal. Use TWO fingers and you can scroll any windows content vertically/horizontally. Every time I have to use a regular old laptop, I really miss this nice feature. These new features should be pretty nice additions to the Macbook

    With that said, they only thing that bugs me about the Macbook I have is how hot the bottom gets. I had to buy a laptop pad which is a pain to have to remember to bring with me. In constrast, my Core 2 iMac is always cool and very silent. Are the newer models of Macbooks cooler so you can comfortably keep them on your lap?

    --
    General, you are listening to a machine! Do the world a favor and don't act like one.
    1. Re:What about the heat? by escay · · Score: 2, Interesting

      better still - will the new macbooks have the Santa Rosa platform that is known to consume less power and generate less heat? and will the screens be LED like the Pros? multitouch is cool and all but is a very minor upgrade, as has always been the case with MacBooks. some love for Cinderella too, please!

      OT, is it just me or am I seeing more Apple stuff being leaked out pre-release? whatever happened to the ultra-secret keep-it-under--wraps-until-very-last-minute Apple obsession?

    2. Re:What about the heat? by MsGeek · · Score: 4, Informative

      If you have the first version of the MacBook, you can't really do much other than software hacks and keeping your MacBook on a cooler pad to keep it cool. The Core 2 Duo was a major improvement heat-wise...it actually *is* a laptop rather than a lap cooker.

      The MacBook Pro also has LED backlighting rather than fluorescent backlighting. This is very significant in that the backlight becomes pretty much immortal...it will last as long as the computer does. With fluorescents, eventually you have to replace the fluorescent tube, which is a pain. I'm sure that eventually the MacBook will get it, but not just yet.

      --
      Knowledge is power. Knowledge shared is power multiplied.
  11. Re:But will it be made out of ubobtainium? by PenguSven · · Score: 2, Funny

    so the hotter they get, the more power they generate. and the more power they generate, the longer they run. and the hotter they get, the more power they generate... but what determines when a section will automatically be jettisoned? if the LCD gets a crack in it, will it instantly be disconnected, so the rest isn't compromised?

    --
    What is...?
  12. I think this is just a software change! by MoxFulder · · Score: 4, Interesting

    The Synaptics touchpads used on practically all notebook computers already support multi-touch features. These just have to be appropriately configured with software.

    For example, using the Xorg drivers and GTK configuration applet gsynaptics, you can set up a touchpad to do different actions based on double-tapping, triple-tapping, scrolling via linear and circular dragging, etc.

    So if Apple figures out how to make an intuitive user interface out of touchpad motions, that's pretty cool, and other operating systems should be able to adopt similar features quickly!

    1. Re:I think this is just a software change! by OECD · · Score: 2, Interesting
      So if Apple figures out how to make an intuitive user interface out of touchpad motions, that's pretty cool, and other operating systems should be able to adopt similar features quickly!

      As the article mentioned, they already do support scrolling with a two-fingered gesture. I can see the pinch gesture that the iPhone uses for zoom being pretty useful as well. I'm less certain about the 'flicking' gesture for scrolling in the iPhone, although I haven't tried it myself.

      --
      One man's -1 Flamebait is another man's +5 Funny.
    2. Re:I think this is just a software change! by Space+cowboy · · Score: 5, Informative
      Unless I'm being dense, none of the things you mention require multi-touch. They're just single-touch gesture detection routines. Looking at the author's website reveals that the only multi-touch support is two-finger or three-finger taps, and that this is not supported on all models.

      It's not clear from his site which models *do* implement true multi-touch, or even whether what he has done requires it. It could be a timing-related kludge if all it supports is taps and not drags. (ie: if I get 2 or 3 clicks within 5 ms, I'll assume the user did those simultaneously and send event X not event Y)

      The multi-touch touchpads on a Macbook(Pro) can scroll any window that has the mouse within its borders by:
      • pressing one finger onto the touchpad
      • *simultaneously* dragging a second finger up and down.
      That's multi-touch. And there's no reason why window-resizing or other manipulation couldn't be done...

      Simon.
      --
      Physicists get Hadrons!
    3. Re:I think this is just a software change! by John+Whitley · · Score: 4, Informative

      other operating systems should be able to adopt similar features quickly! Doubtful. This is more than a case of "just software"; it's a sophisticated collaboration of hardware plus software. Apple bought a company called Fingerworks, founded by Wayne Westerman and his Ph.D. advisor based on his doctoral research[1]. They sold mouse-pad sized touchpad devices with gesture recognition as well as zero-force keyboards with integrated mousing/gesturing. These multi-touch devices effectively do low-resolution EMF imaging of the hand near the surface. No "mis-touches", the keyboard didn't generate false hits from "resting" on the surface, etc.

      Fingerworks vanished off the face of the internet a couple of years back. Apple quietly bought the company, its patents, and and the key researchers and engineers. Since then, they've been puting the Apple shine on their technology since then. Much to the likely delight of the "Fingerfans" the iPhone is the first product to ship with this technology since Fingerworks' was bought.

      It *might* be possible to hack something together with a synaptics pad, but the hardware itself is likely deficient to do full-on multitouch. See section 1.3 of Westerman's thesis, linked below, esp. the pre-Fingerworks prototype hardware "producing a 50 frames per second (fps) stream of proximity images." I note that the Fingerworks devices connected via USB, but had on-device processing and firmware notably richer than what's in a simple touchpad. That alone may spell death to attempts at pure host-side multitouch with a "dumb" touchpad.

      [1] PDF: Hand Tracking, Finger Identification, and Chordic Manipulation on a Multi-Touch Surface.
    4. Re:I think this is just a software change! by DTemp · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Think there's a possibility my new MacBook will be able to gain these features with a software/firmware update? This doesn't seem like a hardware limitation to me, especially since it can already detect multiple touches for scrolling.

    5. Re:I think this is just a software change! by chappel · · Score: 2, Informative

      I've still got a FingerWorks keyboard in my Powerbook Ti - it was a drop-in replacement, and it rocks. I really love the fact you don't have to move your fingers off the keyboard to move the mouse (and that they offered a native Dvorak layout). I'd spend the night on Apple's front doorstep to be first in line to get a new Powerbook with an integrated Dvorak Fingerworks keyboard - but I'm not holding my breath. If they build it into the display, though - you still have to take your hands off the keyboard. Multi Touch does make playing games a challenge - where a 'normal' keyboard will detect two key presses independently (arrow up/arrow right moves diagonally), the FingerWorks sees one 'multitouch', so you have to define distinct functions for every required combination - although a seperate controller is the obvious solution for that.

  13. According to the town hall notes by antifoidulus · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Apple had a "Town hall" meeting with all employees on Thursday to kick off this iPhone thing. Finally, we got at least some confirmation that Apple is doing stuff with the macs again as Steve said, "The first leg is the Mac business, which Steve addressed by saying that they have the "best Macs" in the new product pipeline ever right now, and that the stuff coming out in the next year is "off the charts."

    So if this is true(hard to believe the half size thing, but..) we should be seeing them soon I would wager. Though I doubt the macbooks would get a feature that their pro bretheren do not have first...

  14. ease of service, anyone? by SuperBanana · · Score: 3, Interesting

    gestures that can be done on the iPhone's screen) On June 20th, CrunchGear reported, "The upcoming MacBooks will be about half the thickness of current models (which would be quite the feat) and they'll be made from new plastics/materials"."

    Hopefully they'll be more serviceable, too. Personal best for disassembling a G4 iBook to get to the hard drive? 45 minutes, and that was after doing it three times. The screw count is staggering; one heat shield had TWELVE screws. Most of the screws lack threadlocker (or it isn't strong enough) and the screws are so loose they are almost ready to fall out after 3 years of daily use.

    With IBM/Lenovo and Dell laptops (and probably many others), the drive can be accessed with one or two screws and they slide out of the chassis, even on their smallest+thinnest models. Why can't Apple do the same, especially given how Apple continues to supply mostly Toshiba drives, which have the highest failure rates of laptop drives? Even setting aside drive-manufacturer failure rates, drives are the most failure-prone components in any computer (well, save video cables and screen hinges, again in Powerbooks and iBooks.) I've never seen an Airport card or memory fail, yet they're the easiest to get to on almost any Apple laptop.

    1. Re:ease of service, anyone? by RJabelman · · Score: 2, Informative

      Why can't Apple do the same

      They did. To replace the HD in a MacBook, you take out the battery, remove a panel and the HD slides out. I wish they'd done that on the Pro too...

    2. Re:ease of service, anyone? by wolrahnaes · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Have you worked on a Macbook yet? The hard drive and RAM are trivial to get to. Pop the battery, unscrew one panel (three screws), and either flip a lever or pull on a strap.

      --
      I used to get high on life, but I developed a tolerance. Now I need something stronger.
    3. Re:ease of service, anyone? by maztuhblastah · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Have you used the new MacBooks? The hard drive and RAM can both be swapped in a total of 5 minutes. Remove the battery, undo two screws, and you have the HD. Pull out the lever, and you have the RAM. That's it.

    4. Re:ease of service, anyone? by Lars+T. · · Score: 2, Insightful

      With IBM/Lenovo and Dell laptops (and probably many others), the drive can be accessed with one or two screws and they slide out of the chassis, even on their smallest+thinnest models.

      This is particularly useful when "recycling" a laptop that's being replaced. I get a new laptop every 2-3 years to get the latest features and performance stuff, and when I do, I pull the HDD out of the old laptop and set it aside, as a "just in case" if I discover some important data that I forgot.

      Using Dell laptops at our company, this is a VERY painless process - it takes seconds to pull the old HDD, stick in the new one, and start loading Windows. Why wouldn't Apple do this? Because Macs had target disk mode for ages?
      --

      Lars T.

      To the guy who modded me down from perfect to terrible Karma - Apple haters still suck

  15. CPU to monitor? by johkir · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I wonder if Apple will move the CPU and associated bridge to the top half of the laptop, so heat vents up and out the top, a la the iMac. That might drop the size by dropping a relatively big fan wheel, but I don't think there can be much more of a drop in thickness while still including an optical drive and all the necessary ports to the outside world.

    --
    These are some of the things molecules do...... given 4 billion years -Carl Sagan
    1. Re:CPU to monitor? by iamdrscience · · Score: 2, Informative

      Not likely, that would almost certainly make the macbooks thicker as well as waste a lot of space them. Motherboards in laptops can't get a whole lot thinner than they currently so you're going to be adding on maybe a little less than a centimeter of thickness to the lid and moving the motherboard to the lid isn't going to make the base any thinner, because it still needs to fit the hard drive and optical drive. Plus, setting it up like that would basically leave a bunch of open space in the top and bottom parts of the laptop.

      I suppose they could move the hard drive and optical drive up to the lid with the motherboard and leave only the keyboard/touchpad on the bottom half, but that would make it awfully top-heavy, almost assuring that it would flip over when you used it.

      So no, I really can't imagine that they would ever do that.

  16. Re:Still a touchpad by yabos · · Score: 2, Insightful

    You're the only one I've ever heard of that actually likes those things. If you don't press them hard enough the mouse pointer hardly moves. If you press it too hard it goes flying around the screen. They're a nightmare to use.

  17. Touch screens, poor ergonomics by TibbonZero · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Someone mentioned that people's desks aren't set up right at the moment, and they are right. 95% of situations with current computers aren't set up in a way that a touchscreen would be ergonomically sound. Reaching out in front of you, reaching across you, etc... I think that making the trackpad to be more useful is probably for the best, but screen would be only for occasional use i think.

    --
    Tibbon
    tibbon.com
  18. text entry needs work by peter303 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I loved what multi-touch does for iPhone multi-media management. But the most difficult thing on the iPhone is typing text. This is less of an issue when the display reaches six inches or so.

    1. Re:text entry needs work by The+One+and+Only · · Score: 2, Informative

      Keep at it. Most typing mistakes, if you ignore them and move on, are automatically corrected, so if you just type out whatever word you wanted iPhone does a decent job of guessing.

      --
      In Repressive Burma, it's not just your connection that dies. slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=314547&cid=20819199
  19. Re:okay.... by MsGeek · · Score: 2, Informative

    The Mac version of the BSoD is the Transparent Multilingual Screen of Doom. Another word for it might be familiar to Linux/*BSD/Solaris/xNIX users: Kernel Panic.

    I have only had ONE on any Mac running Mac OS X. That was because I had the buggy version of the WiFi driver (fixed now) and I hit a WiFi access point that was malfunctioning.

    --
    Knowledge is power. Knowledge shared is power multiplied.
  20. Multi-touch was hard to get right. by rolfwind · · Score: 5, Informative

    Several years back, Apple bought up a company that made multitouch keyboards and pads and employed the two professors who made it. It's not just software, the hardware is fundamentally different than single touch.

    http://www.fingerworks.com/

    Look under news:
    http://fingerfans.dreamhosters.com/forum/viewtopic .php?t=678

  21. Re:Agree about the thickness by dal20402 · · Score: 3, Interesting

    The 17" could get 2.5mm thinner. They could use the 9.5mm optical drive from the 15" models. Since the 17" has enough room for the optical drive to fit completely under the right palm rest, it doesn't have to fit under the keyboard like it does on the 15".

    But the 17" is already too flexible... to make a 21mm thick 17" model work you'd almost have to have new case materials.

    I think you're right, though, that the big gains will come from flat solid state HDs. I don't know how they'll deal with the optical drive issue in the models (all but the rumored MBP subnotebook) that need an optical drive.

    In any case, it's time for new MBP form factors. The Al enclosure has to be one of the all-time best notebook designs -- it's still more functional and useful than most others -- but, for crying out loud, the 17" version was introduced in early 2003, and hasn't appreciably changed since!

  22. what about linux? by radarsat1 · · Score: 3, Interesting

    In response to this story, I had a look at the synaptics driver in Linux.
    According to my dmesg output, the touchpad on my HP does indeed have the flag set for "SYN_CAP_MULTIFINGER", which I assume means it can report the positions of multiple touches.

    Running "synclient -m 10" however reports a constant "0000000" under the "multi" field.

    Anyone know how to properly access the multitouch data provided by the Linux synaptics driver?

  23. Re:Stop it. Stop it. Just stop it. by Goaway · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Slashdot is not for technology enthusiasts. It's for people who dream of the days when computers were the size of closets, and who want a phone that "just makes calls".

  24. Re:greasy screen by Goaway · · Score: 2, Funny

    What about shares in companies that make materials to teach reading comprehension? Sell, right?

  25. Multi-touch Mac Mini by Snart+Barfunz · · Score: 4, Interesting

    How about a Mac Mini revision where it's whole top side is a multi-touch tablet? That would be very cool. Ergonomically, it would have to be no more than 1.5cm thick so there'd be no room for an optical drive, hard disk, CPU, etc - yet another opportunity for Apple to display their typical elegant minimalism!

    --
    --- Yx3 = Delilah ---
  26. Bad logic by PhoenixOne · · Score: 2, Insightful

    So, because some people can't use a technology, nobody should be able to?

    Lots of people can't eat corn, maybe we should ban everything with corn in it too? And nuts. With the war, how many people are missing an arm? Best not make cars with stick-shifts...

    I'm not saying ignore people with disabilities (many of my friends have serious disabilities), but you can't make the world one-size fits all. And, as much as blind people might not enjoy the new iPhone, deaf people may enjoy being able to send email, pictures, and videos from a pocket-sized device.

    --
    Spell cheek you've failed me four the last thyme!
  27. Re:Did what? by fangorious · · Score: 2, Informative

    USB was going nowhere until the iMac came out with only a USB connection for mouse/keyboard/floppy. I don't even remember any x86 motherboards where the USB wasn't just some random jumpers and an optional cable that had the regular connectors on an expanstion slot cover (so you had to give-up a PCI/AGP/ISA expansion slot to use the 'on-board' USB. Apple made USB and the mouse prominent technologies for consumer personal computers, and now they appear to be trying to repeat that for multi-touch, which was invented by other people, just like USB and mice.