Slashdot Mirror


Where Were You When PLATO Was Born?

PLATO, cradle of so many firsts, was born 50 years ago. Next week the Computer History Museum is hosting a two-day conference to celebrate the anniversary. Microsoft's Ray Ozzie, who worked on PLATO as an undergraduate, will be one of the keynote speakers. Co-producer Brian Dear has put together a list of today's technology notables and what they were doing in 1973, the year that social computing suddenly blossomed on PLATO.

162 comments

  1. WTF? I was in Sudan, but who cares? by EWAdams · · Score: 3, Informative

    PLATO rocked, but to be honest it didn't have anything to do with me.

    Think of a better headline.

    --
    I piss off bigots.
    1. Re:WTF? I was in Sudan, but who cares? by WrongSizeGlass · · Score: 1

      OK, PLATO was the most expensive and complicated teacher ever built by mankind. If PLATO was so smart, shouldn't it have put together this list of "who was where when" instead of some blog-monkey?

    2. Re:WTF? I was in Sudan, but who cares? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      no, it should have found the question to Life, the universe, and everything.

    3. Re:WTF? I was in Sudan, but who cares? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      > Think of a better headline.

      And think about a better story -- too much M$ over here lately... (for my taste).

    4. Re:WTF? I was in Sudan, but who cares? by davester666 · · Score: 1

      I was where I always am. Wandering around aimlessly on Earth.

      --
      Sleep your way to a whiter smile...date a dentist!
    5. Re:WTF? I was in Sudan, but who cares? by WrongSizeGlass · · Score: 1

      no, it should have found the question to Life, the universe, and everything.

      You're thinking of 'Deep Thought', who was a deep thinker much like PLATO's namesake.

      BTW, I think the answer was '42', but they never did say if it was base 10 or some another base ... and they never did figure out the question.

    6. Re:WTF? I was in Sudan, but who cares? by Gaian-Orlanthii · · Score: 0, Flamebait

      Amazing - because so was I! In fact, apart from trying to understand why these human-being-things (of which I was supposed to be one of) were actually the most stupid fuckers I had ever seen outside of the zoo, I was looking forward to my ninth birthday party.

    7. Re:WTF? I was in Sudan, but who cares? by Garble+Snarky · · Score: 1

      "What do you get if you multiply six by nine?"

    8. Re:WTF? I was in Sudan, but who cares? by lordharsha · · Score: 1

      "What do you get if you multiply six by nine?"

      54

      --
      I am, and that is sufficient.
    9. Re:WTF? I was in Sudan, but who cares? by YttriumOxide · · Score: 1

      "What do you get if you multiply six by nine?"

      54

      Not in base 13...

      --
      My book about LSD and Self-Discovery
      Also on facebook as: DroppingAcidDaleBewan
    10. Re:WTF? I was in Sudan, but who cares? by mcgrew · · Score: 1

      Me either, I was on an Air Force flightline in Dover, DE. The computer that mattered to me was a building full of bookshelves full of circuit boards hooked up to a C5-A simulator; I got to play with it when I hauled two big air conditioners to it in the snow.

      It's amazing how primitive the world was then -- a modern cell Phone is probably more powerful than that building full of circuitry was.

      But that was 40 years ago, not 50. I was only 11 years old in 1963. I'd bet most slashdotters weren't even born then.

  2. nowhere by meerling · · Score: 4, Informative

    Sorry, but Plato was born and died a few thousand years before I was.

    (Yeah, I know, wrong Plato, but with that headline, you knew someone was going to say it.)

    1. Re:nowhere by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Sorry, but Plato was born and died a few thousand years before I was.

      Wow I haven't even died yet, but I was born a few months before the PLATO of which they speak.

    2. Re:nowhere by magarity · · Score: 1

      but I was born a few months before the PLATO of which they speak
       
      Me too; did it scare you too when between the title and the summary it says 1973 was 50 years ago?

    3. Re:nowhere by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That's not true! As a kid, I remember seeing Mickey Mouse walking him all over, and he would always get into trouble...

    4. Re:nowhere by Gilmoure · · Score: 1

      Actually, that's who I thought the headline referred to. Didn't make much sense.

      --
      I drank what? -- Socrates
  3. So, What Is PLATO? by WrongSizeGlass · · Score: 3, Informative

    The links don't say what PLATO is, except "the greatest untold story in the history of computing". So, what the heck is it?

    1. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by hedwards · · Score: 2, Informative

      PLATO was the first ever computer based instruction course. Which I definitely wouldn't expect most people to know. The only reason why I know is that the community college my mother works at they use it.

    2. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by flydpnkrtn · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Dude make friends with Wikipedia and Google... you guys should hang out

    3. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by WrongSizeGlass · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Dude make friends with Wikipedia and Google... you guys should hang out

      I don't RTFA, so why on earth would I Wiki or Google it? Isn't that what the other slash-monkies are for? Eventually someone will post something informative or of value. ;-)

    4. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by Darkness404 · · Score: 1

      But Google will keep notes on everything you say and Wikipedia will correct you for using words that are "not notable"

      --
      Taxation is legalized theft, no more, no less.
    5. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by vanyel · · Score: 5, Insightful

      While you can find out what it is without too much trouble, that doesn't detract from the fact that the summary would be vastly improved if it had included that information in the first place.

    6. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by dwarfsoft · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I love Wikipedia and Google, but it is a Platonic love...

      --
      Cheers, Chris
    7. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by __aasqbs9791 · · Score: 4, Funny

      It wouldn't be the greatest untold story then, would it?

    8. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by Jeff+DeMaagd · · Score: 2, Informative

      The availability of Google and Wikipedia doesn't excuse clumsy article summaries. If most of your audience doesn't know what X device is, taking a sentence to explain it makes it a much better article summary. I would say it is pretty fundamental to good writing. I would grant that Slashdot editors don't know much about good writing, but that's not a good excuse.

      Maybe PLATO was very important, but despite having actually read about computer technology history in the past, I don't remember ever having heard of it. That, and based on other comments to this story, I'd say that PLATO must have been pretty obscure.

    9. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by Waffle+Iron · · Score: 3, Informative

      In a nutshell: It was a preview of most of the features of the Internet (analogs of web 2.0, email, usenet, etc), except it was done on dumb terminals hooked to a central mainframe. Many PLATO systems were hosted on school campuses and used mainly for computer-based education.

      They somehow managed to support hundreds of simultaneous interactive user sessions hosted on a single CPU with horsepower comparable to that of an 80286. The graphics-capable terminals used a cool 500x500 plasma display that took advantage of the fact that a grid of plasma dots can act as a memory array, so no frame buffer was required.

    10. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by hedronist · · Score: 5, Interesting

      PLATO was where I learned to program. Where I learned how to write a couple of lines of TUTOR (back before they even had an FM to R) and then hit Shift-EDIT. That sent me through the "compilor" (their word, not mine) and straight into execution. As soon as I liked/didn't like what I saw, I hit Shift-EDIT again and I was back in the editor exactly where I had been.

      This means that in 1973 I learned to work with an Edit-Compile-Execute-Edit cycle that was often measured in less than 10 seconds. It's a hell of a way to learn quickly.

      You use IM? I was using Talkomatic in 1973. You use forums? Try Notes (and I don't mean Lotus), again in 1973. MMO Games? Dogfight (1973) or even Nova (1974) (I was the coauthor with Al McNeil). Touch panel? Been there, got the T-shirt (and I still have this bee stuck to my finger (that's a deep, deep PLATO old-timer's joke.))

      Between PLATO in the early 70's, and Xerox in Palo Alto in the late 70's (where I was on the BravoX Project at ASD (think "Microsoft Word")), about 80%+ of the fundamental user interface and the foundations of networking (communications and social) were created. In some cases these functions not only haven't improved all that much, some of it is sliding back down hill.

      That doesn't mean you need to kiss our ass or anything, but some people around here really need to understand that the world did not start when they were born. It makes me cringe to even hear me say it, but sometimes the arrogance of the young—many of whom cannot be bothered to read even the history of their own industry—really wears thin.

    11. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by Trepidity · · Score: 2, Informative

      It was also one of the earliest persistent online communities (before the WELL, Usenet, and BBS eras).

    12. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by Mr.+Protocol · · Score: 1

      Hello, fatankles. Good to hear from you. :-)

      I think I'm the one who taught you TUTOR.

      Do you think Slashdot would improve if they hired The Red Sweater as an editor?

    13. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by flydpnkrtn · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Cool posts and good stories like this are why I still read Slashot... thanks for the interesting writeup man

    14. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by nathan.fulton · · Score: 1

      It's blackboard, but without patent trolling and general suckage.

    15. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      PLATO (Programmed Logic for Automated Teaching Operations) was the first (1960s) generalized computer assisted instruction system, and, by the early 1970s, there were 1,000 terminals worldwide.

      Touchscreens were incorporated into a computer-assisted learning terminal that came out in 1972 as part of the PLATO project.
      From here - http://www.notascoolasitseems.com/review/innovation-what-when-and-who#touch

    16. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by shutdown+-p+now · · Score: 0, Flamebait

      That doesn't mean you need to kiss our ass or anything, but some people around here really need to understand that the world did not start when they were born.

      We so understand, dude. The sheer horror of seeding a torrent over those mythical 300 baud channels... that, and Hitler. I sure am glad I wasn't born back then, it must have been hell to live in. ~

    17. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That sounds so cool.

      I'm a young man and even though I'm a little versed in old systems' history I wasn't aware of that one.

      Nice story, man!

    18. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by Ixitar · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I worked on the PLATO system at Control Data Corporation while interning in college. It was a pleasure working on it, but it was a system before its time. When the PC came out, the PLATO system could not adapt. Its screen resolution was 512x512 and the displays of the existing code could not adapt very well. They tried another approach using the CPM operating system as its base for a microcomputer based solution.

    19. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by rickb928 · · Score: 1

      notes is where Kapor got the idea for, um, Notes. Look it up.

      Not to mention a few multiplayer games, in virtually every genre, that would have been MMOs except for the problems of any lesson being massive. I saw 25 users in Avatar pretty regular, and once I think I saw 42, but that might have been my imagination. Gaming was bit on PLATO, especially in the UICU days. The times it reported to to be running 24.9 hours a day were fun times indeed.

      In 1973, I was learning digital logic, microprocessors, and microwave technology in the USAF. Some time around 1988 I got into Plato courtesy of the University of Maine. I also got kicked off, being just a little to far to the right for =events=. After more than a year hearing how I was Rush Linmbaugh's butt boy, I moved to southern Maine and *actually* heard him for the first time. Hmm. Yup, they were half-way correct - I was where Rush was. Not a good place to debate apartheid and the savings & loan scandals with a bunch of college professors and Marxist students. But it was fun while it lasted. Sorry for all the problems, mainei. They restored the group from backups, right?

      I still play avatar on Cyber1. Still good fun. Lots of stats, so come play Zavatar, the economy isn't ruined like the original, and the studs don't own everything yet.

      --
      deleting the extra space after periods so i can stay relevant, yeah.
    20. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by frank_adrian314159 · · Score: 1

      The Red Sweater lived on my dorm floor. He was a fucking legend. One day someone took his sweater. He curled up in a fetal position on his bed in the corner of his room until someone got it back. That would have been in 1975-76.

      PLATO (and TUTOR) rocked. I had the green, paper-covered TUTOR manual on my bookshelf up until about two years ago, when I threw out a bunch of stuff. Had the paper notes of Kuck's book on parallel computation, too. I actually drug around a couple of the boards from the G-20 they yanked out of the EE building, too, but that went before I left Illinois in 1981. People have no fucking clue...

      --
      That is all.
    21. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by Sulphur · · Score: 1

      A director of such a place got into trouble with Plato. He ordered a bunch of Plato terminals without realizing that a connection with CDC was needed to run them.

      The Plato terminal used a non standard line protocol with more bits than usual. Back in the mid 70's someone was thinking of bit banging the serial line to make S-100 Plato terminals.

      --

      _____ said _____ _____
      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Know_thyself

    22. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by MidnightBrewer · · Score: 2, Informative

      The post, and the links, fail to explain what PLATO is. If I have to go do research to figure out what exactly the subject matter is, then the article isn't ready to publish. Just to be a good sport, I'll actually post the pertinent Wikipedia link. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PLATO_(computer_system)

      Your welcome.

      --
      "Give a man fire, and he'll be warm for a day; set a man on fire, and he'll be warm for the rest of his life
    23. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by JasterBobaMereel · · Score: 1

      PLATO not well known outside the US and SA? ...another US centric story then

      Roll on the anniversary of the BBC Micro - the foundation of the UK computing community .... and the making or Acorn/ARM which is still used in a *couple* of devices ....

      --
      Puteulanus fenestra mortis
    24. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      I think you're being a tad harsh - /. is a site with a reasonably wide audience and not every technological field is of interest to every geek here (other than a general interest in all technologies), so it's not unreasonable to ask that a summary gives some indication of what the subject of it actually is. That way, if it's something our geek should know about, he can go read up on it, while if it's something of limited interest to our geek, he can decide whether it's worth his time and at the very least file that as useful information. You can't seriously expect everyone who arrives here to already know in advance about every single part of the entire history of the field they work in so they can make an instant judgement call on whether an article has value based on the inclusion of one acronym - surely if someone comes here and reads up on a bit of history they didn't already know about on the basis of a well-written summary that leads them into the article, then that's a good thing?

    25. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by darkonc · · Score: 1

      Also known in Canada. I worked at the University of Alberta in the late '70s and the '80s. They had a Plato system... I've got all sorts of interesting stories (( like reaching 15Mlillion Gs in Dog, having my account be the default destination for print jobs, etc...).

      --
      Sometimes boldness is in fashion. Sometimes only the brave will be bold.
    26. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That doesn't mean you need to kiss our ass or anything, but some people around here really need to understand that the world did not start when they were born.

      My world started when I was born. The rest of history was just preparation

    27. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by dpiven · · Score: 1

      That sent me through the "compilor" (their word, not mine)

      IIRC, their word for the TUTOR compilation process was "condensing". (Or, if you wrote code like mine, "condemning".)

      I heartily agree with your comments on the PLATO authoring environment -- for a line-oriented editor, the environment totally rocked for code development and testing... I wish Eclipse was that fast.

    28. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by theNAM666 · · Score: 1

      >not only haven't improved all that much, some of it is sliding back down hill.

      sLIDING? Slid, sunk...

    29. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by djdavetrouble · · Score: 1

      I was a tender aged elementary school kid interested in computers in the late 70's and early 80's.
      Before my dad bought a trash 80, I would go to Lawrence Hall of Science and rent time by the
      hour on Commodore PET's and such. One day this all changed when a row of CDC Plato Terminals showed up.

      These things were awesome, they were networked, there were social aspects, they had touch sensitive screens,
      and I was just a kid, I wasn't even getting into the higher functions. This was years before wizardry, and there were some great dungeon crawling games on the Plato network,
      One was called Mines of Moria, the other was called 0Krozair (I think many programs had a zero in the front
      for some CDC reason.) I was literally hooked on 0krozair, and even did my first cracking on there.
      I discovered some user was levelling up characters with the simple name of a string of x's. The password was always x.

      I would try to steal a character every Saturday Morning.

      --
      music lover since 1969
    30. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      > The sheer horror of seeding a torrent over those mythical 300 baud channels...

      Yeah i recall it was pretty horrible. It was difficult to find peers over a point to point communication. The server and the protocol, well, they were so unstable they didn't even friggin' exist! A royal PITA lemme tell you.

      sure, wooosh, i know i know

    31. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by DarwinSurvivor · · Score: 1

      Now if only that person would add a link to the important information somewhere's near the top of page. Maybe they could even write a quick "summary" for us really lazy people.

    32. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by keltickal · · Score: 1

      Actually, they were 512X512 displays. I was in the development group that produced them. The memory feature seemed fantastic at the time since computer memory was core but of course dynamic ram soon eliminated that advantage and the displays would also burn-in. It seems that burn-in still exists. :-(

    33. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by Buelldozer · · Score: 1

      Eventually yes, but until then you're into the whole million monkeys with a million typewriters thing. You could be waiting be a while for something informative or of value here on /. :)

    34. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I learned the Control Data peripheral processor assembly language in their training centre in Bristol. It was nothing more than a computerized learn by rote system, if you knew a bit more than the programmer who created the class you could work out what answer he (and it was almost always he) expected. But it was the origin of many technologies, computer aided learning, touch screen technology etc. Unfortunately the learn by rote system they created is still the way computer based learning still works.

      PeteH

    35. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by npsimons · · Score: 1

      That doesn't mean you need to kiss our ass or anything, but some people around here really need to understand that the world did not start when they were born. It makes me cringe to even hear me say it, but sometimes the arrogance of the young--many of whom cannot be bothered to read even the history of their own industry--really wears thin.

      All due respect, but you might need to take some of your own medicine. Ever hear of The Mother of All Demos? Sure, sure, it was "only" demoed in 1968, but it still gives PLATO a run for its money (including a mouse!), and my reading of the history doesn't make it clear which was first.

      It does sadden me that computer technology has (at best) appeared to stagnate in terms of features (don't even get me started on language features that are showing up in Java and Python that have been in LISP for decades). The funny thing is, some of the most radical advances (including both PLATO and The Mother of All Demos) seem to have been publicly funded. Of course, back then, open source was the dominant culture in terms of software. I think proprietary software (and this includes such "innovators" as Apple and Microsoft) has really held back the march of progress.

      You want to blame someone for ignorance of computing history? Blame Apple and Microsoft who are always claiming "we've done this *incredible* thing that no one else has ever done before!". At least people here at slashdot are inquisitive and *asking* what PLATO is.

    36. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Heh... The Red Sweater (we renamed him more polically correct: The Scarlet Perspirer) is Bruce Parello. I wonder what he's doing now. And the bees that come off on the finger are probably Paul Tenczar's flies -- fruit flies which were used for a genetic lab. I don't remember that -fly worked that way or that there were bees that did.

      But there was also a lesson whose name I forgot, maybe "karyo", by Darlene Chirolas Tenczar (Paul's wife) in which CHROMOSOMES, not flies, come off on your finger when you touch them and return to the screen when you touch it again.

      I directed the program that paid for and finished the development of -karyo (or whatever it was called) at U of I school of basic medical sciences at Urbana/Champaign (SBMS-UC). It was without a doubt, one of the most labor intensive and expensive programs on PLATO. More than 4000 person-hours of expert talent used to write it. For about an hour of instruction.

      I guess I'll have to get a slashdot signon and join this discussion if only to keep the "young-uns" straight.

      -G. Hody
      (hody/med)

    37. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by sd_of_css · · Score: 1

      Definitely. I started on PLATO in 1975 after taking the CS course on it when I was a CS grad student at Illinois. I was a columnist for the Red Sweater News Service - I wrote the Star Trek Preview column, which started describing which Trek the Urbana PBS station was running. I suspect this might have been the first online Star Trek column ever (but I never get invited to any conventions.) I got to keep my login because George Friedman, the CS prof who administered the CS department account, liked my column. Much of PLATO has been implemented - but not term pizza, alas.

    38. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by sd_of_css · · Score: 1

      You use IM? I was using Talkomatic in 1973. You use forums? Try Notes (and I don't mean Lotus), again in 1973. MMO Games? Dogfight (1973) or even Nova (1974) (I was the coauthor with Al McNeil). Touch panel? Been there, got the T-shirt (and I still have this bee stuck to my finger (that's a deep, deep PLATO old-timer's joke.))

      Remember when they implemented Quoting in Pad, and we had a massive thread of "I get a feeling of deja vu when using Pad" about 20 levels deep. Pad got broken when someone started a thread with "It was a dark and stormy night." It was discovered that while there was a limit of 128 poats (or was it 64?) no one bothered to check if several people were composing after max - 1 had been added. This was before they split Pad up into different topics as Notesfiles. I think I have a fanfold paper listing of some of an sf notes thread floating around somewhere.

    39. Re:So, What Is PLATO? by sd_of_css · · Score: 1

      Just found an article by the developer of Notes. It was 63 messages max.

  4. Um... by Codename+Dutchess · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Where were you when PLATO _WAS BORN_?

    Then I read that PLATO was born 50 years ago.

    Then I read that someone put together a list of what people were doing in 1973.

    So, I'm to understand that 2010 - 1973 = 50.

    1. Re:Um... by WrongSizeGlass · · Score: 1

      So, I'm to understand that 2010 - 1973 = 50.

      Back in the early days of computing they had a little trouble "carrying the one" when doing subtraction ... and it looks like the the other 12, two ;-)

    2. Re:Um... by FunPika · · Score: 3, Informative

      No it was born in 1960....its just that nobody gave a damn about it until it was 13. Such a lonely childhood....

      --
      After years of not using a signature, I am going to make one to say the following: Fuck Beta
    3. Re:Um... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      They were older than that, they got their start as a project with Control Data. They were originally used for flight simulator software for the military and ran off of an early mainframe. From there the company grew to support other training software and has very slowly evolved over time. The company really does go back that far, they were around before Microsoft, Apple or even Unix, they are that old.

    4. Re:Um... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      yeah seriously whats going on?

    5. Re:Um... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      while PLATO itself was created in 1960, what people are celebrating is the birth of the PLATO Notes, a precursor to LOTUS notes and one of the worlds first online message boards, which was created in 73

    6. Re:Um... by querent23 · · Score: 1

      mod +1

    7. Re:Um... by Alphathon · · Score: 1

      and it looks like the the other 12 too ;-)

      I fixed that for you. That was just the wrong time to use a number incorrectly ;).

    8. Re:Um... by zaft · · Score: 0

      If you actually bothered to read, you might realize that while PLATO was started in 1960, it didn't blossom as a community until 1973 when notesfiles began. Newbie.

    9. Re:Um... by WrongSizeGlass · · Score: 1

      Thanks. I'm horrible about editing during 'preview'. At least compilers warn me about the stupid mistakes I type.

    10. Re:Um... by dpreformer · · Score: 3, Informative

      PLATO was born in 1960. By 1973 it had grown to the point that it enabled social networking of sorts - online games as well as its ostensible purpose for computer aided instruction.

      I remember PLATO terminals in the university library when I was first using computers - they were big amber plasma screens that did pretty good graphics for the time. Beat punched cards and green bar paper as far as user interface hands down. It was a lot nicer than the dumb terminals that were starting to be available for coding.

    11. Re:Um... by Codename+Dutchess · · Score: 1

      Right, which would make you wonder why the article poster asked the question "Where were you when PLATO was born?". The error obviously isn't mine.

      Man, the trolls are plentiful here.

    12. Re:Um... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Join the club. I was also born in 1960, and in 1973 I was on vaca in the UK with my parents. I bought a lot of Corgi model cars and H.P. Lovecraft books, between being dragged around to every cathedral and historic monument by my Mom.

      1974 was the first year I started computing, when my stateside highschool let a select group of interested students learn how to program on the pdp-11/16 (normally used for holding everyone's academic records - n.c.). We had DEC terminals that chattered through reams of greenbar paper every day, but no video - everything was on paper. We weren't allowed to store anything on the hard disk (the size of a small clothes washer), so we had to send our code to a TTY machine that punched it out on paper tape which we then rolled up tightly and stored in plastic film containers (thumb-cans?).

      But first we had to learn how to boot the machine, by flipping through several combinations of toggle switches.. yeah, 0s and 1s, baby!

  5. Please explain... by RyanFenton · · Score: 4, Informative

    I know it's news for nerds... but I've never heard of this PLATO (other than the philosopher), and it would be nice to explain what it is in the summary or in an editor's sentence at the start.

    Ryan Fenton

    1. Re:Please explain... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Do you make a habit of posting simple questions in forums and waiting for a response? How's that working out for you?

      http://www.justfuckinggoogleit.com/

    2. Re:Please explain... by mozumder · · Score: 1

      No.

    3. Re:Please explain... by __aaclcg7560 · · Score: 2, Funny

      Got a problem with Socratic method of learning? Not like anyone is asking you to drink a cup of poison.

    4. Re:Please explain... by The_mad_linguist · · Score: 1

      Too soon!

  6. In an infinite void of nothingness.... by FunPika · · Score: 4, Insightful

    ...because I wasn't born yet.

    --
    After years of not using a signature, I am going to make one to say the following: Fuck Beta
    1. Re:In an infinite void of nothingness.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      must post as an A/C - please forgive.

      the timeline is close - but not quite close enough so I can honestly say "I was in the dream of my father, nestled in his boxer shorts until a few days later he met my mother."

  7. Back in 1973... by __aaclcg7560 · · Score: 0

    I was a four-year-old who had taken off the cover of the 26" TV console in the living room to poke around the glowing vacuum tubes. "Solid State" (TM) electronics was still a few years off. Surprisingly, I made it out of childhood without electrocuting myself too many times. Since then, I've been working my though every Fortune 500 company in Silicon Valley. Always arriving after some big name had left. Sad but true.

    1. Re:Back in 1973... by John+Hasler · · Score: 1

      > "Solid State" (TM) electronics was still a few years off [in 1973].

      Not true.

      --
      Warning: this article may contain humor, sarcasm, parody, and perhaps even irony. Read at your own risk.
    2. Re:Back in 1973... by mirix · · Score: 1

      Solid state was already in high gear by '73, although I suppose most people still had older tube or hybrid sets at the time.

      PS - You can only electrocute yourself once. I've been shocked a few too many times though, myself :)

      --
      Sent from my PDP-11
    3. Re:Back in 1973... by __aaclcg7560 · · Score: 1

      Yes and no. I used "electronics" when I meant "TVs". My family didn't get a solid state TV until 1977 and the vacuum tube TVs we had back then weren't retired until the 1990s.

    4. Re:Back in 1973... by mcgrew · · Score: 1

      We had transistor radios back in the 1950s ("Solid state" means "transistorized"). From wikipedia:

      Physicist Julius Edgar Lilienfeld filed the first patent for a transistor in Canada in 1925, describing a device similar to a Field Effect Transistor or "FET".[1] However, Lilienfeld did not publish any research articles about his devices,[citation needed] nor did his patent cite any examples of devices actually constructed. In 1934, German inventor Oskar Heil patented a similar device.[2]

      In 1947, John Bardeen and Walter Brattain at AT&T's Bell Labs in the United States observed that when electrical contacts were applied to a crystal of germanium, the output power was larger than the input. Solid State Physics Group leader William Shockley saw the potential in this, and over the next few months worked to greatly expand the knowledge of semiconductors, and thus could be described as the "father of the transistor". The term was coined by John R. Pierce.[3] According to physicist/historian Robert Arns, legal papers from the Bell Labs patent show that William Shockley and Gerald Pearson had built operational versions from Lilienfeld's patents, yet they never referenced this work in any of their later research papers or historical articles.[4]

      The first silicon transistor was produced by Texas Instruments in 1954.

      Note that your 1977 "solid state" TV was NOT 100% solid state -- it had a cathode ray tube (CRT). The rest of the circuitry may have been solid state, but the picture itself was not. And without the picture tube, it's just a transistor radio.

      The TV I watch now I bought in 2002, and it has a flat screen CRT. They still sell lots of CRT TVs.

    5. Re:Back in 1973... by __aaclcg7560 · · Score: 1

      "Solid State" (TM) always struck me as a marketing term back then. I also thought "solid" meant you couldn't take the cover off to mess around inside the TV. If you can't look inside the box, who knows what was going on inside. I didn't pick up on electronic theory until I got into college. By the mid-1990s, DIY electronic repair was on the way out and the local community colleges in Silicon Valley cut their electronic programs to nothing.

    6. Re:Back in 1973... by mcgrew · · Score: 1

      No, it was used as a marketing term but was actually an engineering term. Tubes have vacuum gaps between anode and cathode, while semiconductors have no mascroscopic gaps. That's where the term "solid state" came from.
      Oh, and "solid state" wasn't a trademark.

      And, you could still take the cover off of a solid state TV.

  8. I have the speech synthsizer on.... by AnonymousClown · · Score: 1

    What ....is.... this.....play....doh....you .... speak....of?

    --
    RIP America

    July 4, 1776 - September 11, 2001

  9. Exploration by Darkness404 · · Score: 1

    From what I've read about PLATO (I was born quite a bit after PLATO's heyday) it seemed to be in stark contrast with today's methods of teaching computers. It seemed like PLATO actually encouraged students to explore computers. Today though, teachers are too paranoid, thinking that the command prompt will "break" the computer and other stupidities.

    And we wonder why America experienced a tech boom in the 70s-90s and its drying up. Between the changes in education, legislation designed to make it be even harder to produce technology in the US along with R&D and government-funded monopolies, I don't think we're going to be number one in technology again.

    --
    Taxation is legalized theft, no more, no less.
    1. Re:Exploration by __aaclcg7560 · · Score: 1

      The tech boom of the 70s-90s came about after the IBM priesthood for the mainframes died out by smaller computers that require less maintenance. As for why there's no more tech boom now, there's no money in computers anymore. College graduates for the last ten years have been chancing after health care to make the big bucks.

    2. Re:Exploration by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      From what I've read about PLATO (I was born quite a bit after PLATO's heyday) it seemed to be in stark contrast with today's methods of teaching computers. It seemed like PLATO actually encouraged students to explore computers. Today though, teachers are too paranoid, thinking that the command prompt will "break" the computer and other stupidities.

      From my own experiences, it's not that the teachers are too paranoid and afraid the computer will 'break' from the command prompt, its that the teachers are either completely not qualified to teach a computer course or are given the Teachers Edition of the classes textbook which doesn't help much and are afraid of being shown up/embarrassed by the young kids/students. Happened to me in HS in the mid-90's, teacher told us that x was the correct answer (can't remember the question, was Algerbra 2 course) and I pointed out that it was wrong and told her why it was and what the right one was. A few students laughed since she was wrong and I was sent to the office for that since I accidentally embarrassed her. Its just dumb pride in stupid teachers.

    3. Re:Exploration by Waffle+Iron · · Score: 3, Interesting

      From what I've read about PLATO (I was born quite a bit after PLATO's heyday) it seemed to be in stark contrast with today's methods of teaching computers. It seemed like PLATO actually encouraged students to explore computers. Today though, teachers are too paranoid, thinking that the command prompt will "break" the computer and other stupidities.

      When I was a student back in the days of PLATO, I had a part time job as the human tutor in one of the PLATO terminal rooms. I don't remember it being focused at all on exploring computers. The system was all about the pre-canned apps. In fact, my memory is a little rusty, but I don't recall that they really had a command prompt at all, at least as far as end users were concerned. I think it was all a hierarchical full screen menu-driven system. (I assume that some CS majors were taught how to write software for PLATO, but that would be a small minority of the users.)

      One problem with the course that I worked with was that the software was a bit too linear and inflexible. For example, students weren't allowed to go on to the next problem until they correctly answered the current one, and the range of acceptable answers was usually very constrained. The software basically kept repeating: "Wrong. Try again.", and you were stuck at a dead end.

      Unfortunately, back in those days this was often the first exposure the users had to a computer system of any kind. They had never experienced anything as exacting and unforgiving as a computer, and it didn't help to heap that on top of the inherent stress of a "weed-out" engineering class. That's why they needed me to be in there as a backup; I think that some of the people would have eventually gone postal on the terminals if they didn't have access to someone who could see how and why they were stuck, and dole out helpful hints.

    4. Re:Exploration by Lil'wombat · · Score: 1

      You had "Wrong. Try Again". The luxury! In Physics 107 at UofI we got the most basic prompt "No"

      --

      Truth: If it's not one thing, it's another

    5. Re:Exploration by zaft · · Score: 1

      That's correct, the student users of PLATO never saw a command prompt. However, get an "author" signon was not that hard for computer geek types, especially at UIUC.

    6. Re:Exploration by Uzuri · · Score: 1

      I'm having this mental image of the machine then reaching out and hitting you with a rolled up newspaper.

      --
      I'm a she-slashdotter... but I make up for it by living with my folks.
    7. Re:Exploration by hody-med · · Score: 1

      The abrupt "no" response was a system default that programmers were expected to anticipate and correct. PLATO, in fact, had a very rich set of possible responses based on system variables set by the student reponse. But a lot of authors had no idea how the system worked or what its potential power was so it was the usual garbage in and garbage out just as so many computer-based teaching programs are today! Sadly. Properly programmed lessons would parse and process a student response, give appropriate correction and feedback, provide several levels of HELP, and the system used automatic spelling checks and markups. The problems came from inexperienced authors, not from the system software which was brilliantly conceived and amazingly well executed by highly talented people who made it happen with incredibly primitive hardware by today's standards. It was a lot like NASA's moonlanding computers. They did an amazing job for their minimal specifications.

  10. Old company by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

    I used to work for them many years back and it was the most archaic company I have ever worked for. Far older than Microsoft or Apple or most other traditional technology companies. Your talking about a company that was old enough to have one of the original licenses for commercial Unix from the early 70's (it was considered an asset of some value at the time even though they no longer produced it). They had technology in use at that time that was 15-20 years old at and still actively supported.

    I learned a lot by working with some pretty diverse environments - I distinctly recall having to solve a problem with token ring, 10base2, and a lightning strike all inside a federal maximum security prison. Did I mention the admins were convicted murderers?

    The company today is a shell of it's former self, and I think surprises many with it's continued survival. They had a lot of very good internal technology staff, but have long been plagued by management issues. I recall before Y2K the company was claiming their software did not have Y2K issues when it was nowhere near Y2K compliant. Management officially refused to acknowledge the issue and threatened to fire anyone that put anything in writing.

    I bribed a developer with a bottle of mountain dew to put a hard checksum into the installer code that would present a unique and undocumented error if someone tried rolling back the clock before installing the software. We got many calls about the mysterious installation error, with every institution that received it told to make sure their system date was correct. They survived Y2K without a single system going down, perhaps the first and last time a company was saved by a 20oz bottle of mountain dew.

    They could have been sued into oblivion by any number of institutions if all their data was wiped as they knew about the Y2K issues. This was data that was used to do things like justifying rank for the military, determine if prisoners got out of prison or if students graduated school. Since their public stance was they were Y2K compliant, and a code review would prove otherwise, it was a pretty big deal at the time. When your customers are people like the federal government and the Bill Gates foundation, they have more money for lawyers than you do.

    1. Re:Old company by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Ha ha, funny. Makes me feel old I guess when I hear people speak of Apple and Microsoft as "traditional" technology companies. IBM, HP, Unisys, those are traditional tech companies in my mind.

  11. And then they screwed him over... by denzacar · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    ...and took away his planet and gave it some dwarfs.

    Not to mention the humiliation of naming a cartoon dog after him.

    --
    Mit der Dummheit kämpfen Götter selbst vergebens
  12. what plato is.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Google Search Yields:
    The PLATO system was designed for Computer-Based Education. But for many people, PLATO's most enduring legacy is the online community spawned by its communication features.

    I work in a school that uses plato for an alternative education. Generally the degenerates end up there and "pass" their classes in a few weeks get a GED and go home. So basically it's a shared cop out for both the students and the district.

    1. Re:what plato is.. by Darth+Cider · · Score: 1

      The PLATO Notes application that allowed communication was written by David Woolley, who was 17 years old at the time.

    2. Re:what plato is.. by uglyduckling · · Score: 1

      It was a stroke of genius, but also an idea that was ripe for the picking. When I was at school in the early 90s, we had a lab full of networked BBC Micros, plus another 20 or so distributed through the school. We had never heard of the Internet, we knew nothing of ARPAnet or JANet (the UK Joint Academic Network which was connected to the Internet). I wasn't the most proficient hacker in the school, but I was the most 'social'. I wrote a program that would show a list of connected users and allow instant messaging between terminals, it just seemed like an obvious thing to send messages between remote computers. For some reason it never occurred to me that someone might want to leave a message for someone offline for them to collect later.

  13. Playing With My First Calculator by cmholm · · Score: 1

    While some folks were connected enough to play with PLATO, I was trying some then-new calculator "games", where the pseudo text answers to your arithmetic questions appeared when the display was turned upside down. My device also did square roots! To prove my semi-geek cred, I've still got it (a Kingspoint), functional in all its VFD glory.

    --
    Luke, help me take this mask off ... Just for once, let me butterfly kiss you with my own eyes.
  14. My parents weren't even conceived yet. by Vekseid · · Score: 1

    I wonder how many people we're going to make feel old with this one.

    1. Re:My parents weren't even conceived yet. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Nah just shows that you're very young!

  15. Notesfiles and graphical Star Trek by billstewart · · Score: 1

    PLATO terminals were graphical orange-plasma-screen things, with the best interactive multiplayer Star Trek game *ever* (well, at least for 70s versions of "ever"), and an application called "notesfiles" that was a lot like Usenet or BBSs later became. My university had a few PLATO terminals, and I never had an "author account", so my access was read-only, but it was cool stuff.

    --

    Bill Stewart
    New Fast-Compression-only CPR http://preview.tinyurl.com/dy575ks
    1. Re:Notesfiles and graphical Star Trek by PopeRatzo · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I've got a better one:

      Where were you when Half-Life came out, and which classes did you miss because of it?

      I distinctly recall having a big file of undergrad papers to grade and saying "Fuck it. Not when there's a rent in the fabric of space and time".

      --
      You are welcome on my lawn.
    2. Re:Notesfiles and graphical Star Trek by sd_of_css · · Score: 1

      Do you mean michelin/empire? Awesome multiplayer Star Trek based game, which I spent many nights on, and which chewed up an impressive percentage of CPU cycles at night. I saw it advertised in a UNIX trade rag in the early '80s.

  16. 50 years ago by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I was the slap that my grandfather gave my grandmother's ass...

  17. dana plato? by ifeelswine · · Score: 1

    i was swallowing pills when dana plato was born. waaa choo talkin bout?

  18. Just a twinkle in my daddy's nutsack by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Or a stain on the sheets, you pick :)

    1. Re:Just a twinkle in my daddy's nutsack by exley · · Score: 0

      So your mother fucked the sheets after your dad dropped his load prematurely on them?

  19. Fond memories of Physics exercises in Loomis Lab by lemonk · · Score: 1

    I have fond memories of taking Physics quizzes and exercises on the PLATO machines at Loomis Laboratory while an undergraduate engineering student at the University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign in the early 90s. The plasma monitors with their orange glow were cool for such "old" technology.

    --
    You are only popular on the Internet.
  20. PLAY-DOH & Moonwar by Nom+du+Keyboard · · Score: 1

    Our I.T. administrators at SDSU were soon calling the one demonstration terminal we had for a few weeks the PLAY-DOH system. Who could ever forget playing Moonwar on it. Great fun for its time.

    --
    "It's the height of ridiculousness to say for those 9 lines you get hundreds of millions."
  21. Made some bucks off PLATO conversions to micros by dougsha · · Score: 1

    In the early '80's I made good money from CDC for a few years by converting PLATO ed games to every micro under the sun - Atari 800, TRS-80, Apple II, C-64. My partner Mike Johnston and I bankrolled development of our game ChipWits with money we saved from those contracts. The games we ported were pretty dry - Decimal Darts and such.

    1. Re:Made some bucks off PLATO conversions to micros by Dunbal · · Score: 1

      How on earth did you ever manage to make money in an environment devoid of copy protection technology and with everyone copying floppy disks like mad?

      Never mind, it's a rhetorical question.

      --
      Seven puppies were harmed during the making of this post.
    2. Re:Made some bucks off PLATO conversions to micros by fusedlight · · Score: 1

      Yeh, I remember the money that was lost when CDC insisted that PLATO games be ported to EVERY platform. By the time my Yahtzee knockoff "HiFive" was ready the window of good money had passed. Oh well. Fun thing is that "0hifive" on the Cyber1 PLATO system passed 10,000 games a month or so ago.

  22. In regards to the question asked by jonfr · · Score: 1

    In regards to the question that is asked here the answer for simple for me.

    I was nowhere, as I did not yet exist and I where therefore not yet born.

  23. No Plato users here? by AstroWeenie · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Jeez, I can't believe I'm the first actual Plato user to post. I played lots of games on Plato in the middle of the night while I was writing my thesis in 1977-1978. It was amazing at the time -- an online system where you could play real-time networked games with people across the country built around a plasma bit-mapped "high resolution" display (probably 512x512 pixels). There was even a quasi-three-dimensional game called dnd where you explored dungeons with a party of other players. ("Quasi 3-D" because all it could do was draw the lines indicating the corners of walls, ceilings, floors.)

    Anyway, I think it was way ahead of its time. I don't know how successful it was as an educational system, but it ought to be legendary as a network gaming system.

    1. Re:No Plato users here? by dunng808 · · Score: 1

      Claim to Fame: Not much
      Name: Gary Dunn
      Age in 1973: 23
      Doing: Graduate school, University of Illinois, Master of Music in Composition

      I would walk past this big building every day and see kids working at computer terminals. They seemed strangely engaged, as if in a trance. At the same time my friend John Van der Slice was learning FORTRAN in order to use a music composition program. He used to carry around long boxes of punch cards. I thought computer programming was the nerdiest thing possible, as lame as playing the accordian. In 1984 I was working at the University of Hawaii, writing some audio analysis stuff in Basic on a Harris. In the same terminal room were some PLATO terminals, with erie orange screens. I recall watching someone play hangman against an opponent somewhere on the mainland. I was impressed.

      In 2000 I wrote to David R. Woolley in regards to my newly formed Open Slate Project. Here is his reply, being sent from one of my mail account to another:

            At 11:04 AM 9/19/00 -1000, you wrote:

          > I am designing an educational system to be propogated in the spirit of
          > the
          > open-source software community and would like to draw upon the lessons
          > learned
          > at Plato. I found a web page ( [dead link] h t t p://www.cbi.umn.edu/inv/cerlplat.htm
          > ) listing
          > articles related to Plato, but without pointers to the text of the
          > articles.
          > It's a start.

            Yes... I expect that little, if any, of that material is online. To
            read it you'd probably have to travel to where the stuff is physically
            archived (apparently both at the U of Minnesota and the U of Illinois).

          > I would like to ask more questions about Plato, if you are interested.

            Sure, I'd be glad to tell you what I can. If you just have a few
            questions, and they're fairly simple, I can answer by email. If there
            are a lot, I'd prefer to do it by phone. You can reach me at
            [he gave me his phone number but I regret I never called].

            David R. Woolley
            http://thinkofit.com/drwool/

      I find it incomprehensible that PLATO and everything like it has been so successfully kept out of schools.

      --

      Gary Dunn
      Open Slate Project

    2. Re:No Plato users here? by hody-med · · Score: 1

      Interestingly, PLATO was successful in narrow areas of work and in strange ways. The airlines adopted it for pilot training. I don't know whether those programs/lessons are still in use today. The military used it, especially the Navy. And there was a wonderful real time (and quite costly) emergency room simulator for training medical technicians. That was from Canada and I can't find the link at the moment. The elementary math lessons were amazing-- kids thought they were games but they taught serious arithmetic skills. There was a wonderful chemical titration lab simulation, great physics lessons by Bruce Sherwood, and many many other terrific pieces of "courseware" or "lessonware" as it was called at the time. Unfortunately, too many people used PLATO to develop bad courseware. Equally unfortunate, bad software and courseware is still all too common. Aside: ever encounter a long, seemingly endless and unstoppable flash animation before you can get to a site or web page? Well, unfortunately, that also got its start with PLATO. LOL.

  24. Mickey Mouse's dog ... by wylderide · · Score: 1

    ... Is 50?!?

    --
    This is the best restaurant I ever eat in
    1. Re:Mickey Mouse's dog ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Mickey Mouse's dog is plUto, not plAto

  25. Well now, let's see... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    A few handful of molecules decided to say hi to each other.
    Oh yeah, that was my mother, woops.
    Well... i guess the same thing still applies.

    Even that one is still too old for me.
    Damn all you old people in the future from this post!
    I'll shake my walking stick at you too!
    Ah, jokes about ill-health, a great game for all the family.

  26. WTF?! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Micro$$$oft? Aren't they Teh Evil????

    Total fucking fail.

  27. Where was I? by bytethese · · Score: 1

    Not even yet a tickle in my father's pants.

  28. Plato rocked! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I remember sneaking into the CCIS Microlab at Rutgers University in Piscataway at age 13. Apple-Trek on the old Apple IIs was OK fun, but the real run to be had was plaing Empire on the Plato systems!

  29. Denied! 403 on the where are they now link by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Getting 403 on one of your links>

    http://www.platohistory.org/blog/2010/05/where-were-they-in-1973.html

    Forbidden

    You don't have permission to access /blog/2010/05/where-were-they-in-1973.html on this server.
    Apache/1.3.41 Server at www.platohistory.org Port 80

  30. 3 years old. by Nick+Driver · · Score: 1

    I was a four-year-old who had taken off the cover of the 26" TV console in the living room to poke around the glowing vacuum tubes.

    I'm not very far behind you.

    In 1973, I was three years old, my dad was a TV repairman who owned his own TV repair business, and I took apart every gadget I could get a screwdriver to.

    However, If I tried to remove the back panel of the living room TV set, I would've got my ass busted in a big way. Twice. First by my mom, then secondly by my dad when he got home at the end of the day from running TV repair service calls.

    Yes, back then you could still get TV repair service at home.

  31. Re:Fond memories of Physics exercises in Loomis La by zaft · · Score: 1

    OMG I worked on the Physics 2 series in 1984-85ish... good times. I was at U of Arizona.

  32. user Id graph by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    to bad /.doesn't have afunction that makes a histogram of userId#s; can't be a lot of articles with 50 replies that include a 3 and a 4 digit user id

  33. Not that Plato by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This one. He was born 1950, or thereabouts.

  34. Re:Fond memories of Physics exercises in Loomis La by Ritchie70 · · Score: 1

    I was there 86 - 90 and remember both the old plasma screens and newer green-screen CRT displays. A lot of the plasma terminals didn't work very well so everyone preferred the CRT ones.

    I hated using PLATO for physics class because the software was so picky about the answer, giving an "incorrect" for things a human probably would have marked as correct.

    As I recall I actually used the PLATO terminals in the basement of the Foreign Language Building more than the ones at Loomis just because they were closer to where I was living.

    --
    The preferred solution is to not have a problem.
  35. I Flunked Out of College Because of Plato by WallyHartshorn · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I attended the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign in the early 1980s and I flunked out of college in part because of spending too much time playing games on PLATO, particularly a MMO dungeon game called Avatar. The way things worked, the "free" (i.e. not connected to coursework) account I had could only be used at night. As a result, I and similar Avatar addicts would gather in the basement computer lab on Friday night and play until around 5AM or so, when the system went offline for maintenance. At that point we would go to IHOP for breakfast, then return at 6AM to play another couple of hours, until our accounts were booted off at 8AM.

    Strangely enough, this was not conducive to good study habits! Luckily, after I flunked out, I managed to get accepted into another university which did NOT use PLATO! :-)

    You can install software that emulates a PLATO terminal, allowing you to connect to a PLATO host (Cyber1.org).

    Here's a video introduction to cyber1.org: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DgMG9NCWoaU
    And here's a video showing a battle in Empire (a Star Trek space battle game): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vMPC1eG5cko

    You'll need to view these videos large to really see what's happening.

    1. Re:I Flunked Out of College Because of Plato by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Sounds like my habits at U of I too except my game of choice was EMPIRE ...

      Had to have a professor grant you an "Author" account and agree to do some TUTOR programming to play EMPIRE everywhere on campus. Regular accounts didn't always allow it ...

    2. Re:I Flunked Out of College Because of Plato by mombass · · Score: 2, Informative

      I was at U of Illinois 69-74, and one of the things I DO remember was working with PLATO. It was all very "futuristic" to do a course on a COMPUTER!! Not terribly easy, but fun in a geeky way. Times being what they were, I don't remember the course.

    3. Re:I Flunked Out of College Because of Plato by mcgrew · · Score: 1

      No you didn't. You flunked out of college because you lacked maturity and self-control.

  36. Mod This -1, Pedantic by guyminuslife · · Score: 2, Informative

    Asking a question when you're looking for information is not the Socratic method. That's being a student, asking a teacher. The Socratic method involves the teacher asking the student a question in order to get the student to think about the problem.

    IMO, the AC, despite being rhetorical, is much closer to being Socratic than GGP.

    --
    I don't believe in time. It's a grand conspiracy designed to sell watches.
  37. In 30 seconds or less.... by ckolar · · Score: 1

    Fifty years ago next week
    Screens alit with amber glow
    Press the NEXT key to begin
    Name/group and shift-STOP make it go

    AUTHOR MODE choose an option
    Pad, avatar, wasted, or empire kills?
    But DATA leads to one concoction
    That's fun to play and builds your skills

    =BTYPING!

    1. Re:In 30 seconds or less.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      *grin*

  38. Where was I? by lordharsha · · Score: 1

    Dead.

    --
    I am, and that is sufficient.
  39. Re:Fond memories of Physics exercises in Loomis La by lemonk · · Score: 1

    Yea now that I think back I do recall the software being very exacting at times. I lived just down the street from Loomis but I do recall visiting the lab at FLB a few times.

    --
    You are only popular on the Internet.
  40. I actually used it in college. by NicknamesAreStupid · · Score: 1

    I really didn't understand it, but it was new and I could get to some documents. Never knew how to use any chat function, but I do remember that I used a terminal, a breath of fresh air after punching Hollerith cards. A friend wrote a program to draw images on it. Little did I know.

  41. I got to play with PLATO for an afternoon... by Gavin+Scott · · Score: 1

    As a kid. I don't remember exactly what the circumstances were, or how old I was (possibly middle school), but it was probably because the school thought I was smarter or stupider than the other students (it was often unclear which it was).

    The school district had like one PLATO terminal in the district office locked up in a small room as I recall. I had no idea what the system was about, or what it's scope was, and as I recall I spent the time looking at a few of the games available on the system (probably to the disappointment of the administrators). They didn't invite me back :)

    I wish I had known more about the system and what was possible, or maybe not, as that was more computing power (and network!) than I'd ever had access to before and probably would have been seduced beyond all hope of recovery.

    G.

  42. playing with it at that time by Scotch42 · · Score: 1

    We had a wonderfull time playing fligh simulator (remeber becoming so often a peperoni pizza) or dungeon of moria with PLATO when I was freshmen ;-)

  43. boobies by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    PLATO was born in 1960. By 1973 it had grown to the point that it

    had boobs.

    ftfy

  44. PLATO Was Alan Kay's Muse by theodp · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Brian Dear, on PLATO: One of the most interesting little-known aspects of Xerox PARC has to do with its relationship to PLATO. What people don't realize is that Kay attended a 1968 symposium sponsored by ARPA, at the Univ of Illinois. Among the presenters was Don Bitzer and company, and what did they present? A 1-inch-by 1-inch prototype of a gas plasma flat-panel display. This was a major "aha" moment for Kay, who told me it was his "big whammy" epiphany. It suddenly occurred to him that computers of the future were not going to have big, bulky CRT screens, but rather, flat-panel displays. It is directly because of his seeing the demo of the PLATO plasma prototype that he got the idea for the Dynabook.

  45. and I was... by AliasMarlowe · · Score: 1

    ...directly above the exact center of the Earth.

    --
    Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities. - Voltaire
  46. The backstory by Jim+Hall · · Score: 1

    For those interested: PLATO was actually created around 1960 as an electronic instruction platform. But it wasn't until around 1973 that things really started to take off for PLATO. That's because the system had developed features like talking to others across a distance via terminals, graphics displays, etc. that wouldn't hit mainstream for a few years.

    My Mom worked for CDC PLATO in the late '70s (or was it early '80s?) working in a group that provided English as a Second Language programs. I got my exposure to the PLATO system through her, but I didn't really care about the ESL stuff.

    It was an impressive system, especially considering its time, featuring touch screen, networking, etc.

  47. What is Plato? by 192939495969798999 · · Score: 1

    The PLATO system was created in 1960 at the University of Illinois. Initially it ran as a one-terminal system connected to the ILLIAC computer. By 1963, the system was running on a CDC 1604 with multiple simultaneous users. By 1972, the system had expanded to run a thousand simultaneous users on a CDC CYBER mainframe. Control Data Corporation began marketing PLATO commercially in 1976, resulting in PLATO system installations in dozens of cities around the world. Many of these systems were interconnected, enabling email and remote logins through the network. For nearly ten years, there were more users on PLATO than there were on ARPANET, the precursor to the Internet.

    http://www.platohistory.org/about/

    --
    stuff |
  48. Oooh, I know! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    In base ten, you get fifty-four.

  49. Plato on the TI-994/A by wandazulu · · Score: 1

    I used Plato as a cartridge on the TI-994/A...it was a math instruction course if I recall. I know the original Plato was an online system, and our TI-994/A was definitely *not* online, so it always confused me to hear about Plato as this enormous ecosystem, when all I thought of it was a boring program that kept me from playing "King Tut".

    The only thing I do definitely remember about the program was that it was white text on a blue background, and the copyright included the University of Illinois, which being from Chicago, gave me some sort of excitement that if I went there, *I* could write programs for the TI-994/A! Maybe even the Apple ][!

    Anyone else use this version?

  50. Aaah... The sense of humor... by denzacar · · Score: 1

    Can't put a price on that.
    And even if you could - you can't buy it.

    --
    Mit der Dummheit kämpfen Götter selbst vergebens
  51. D&D by mqhiller · · Score: 1

    I was in High school in 1983, learning BAL on an IBM 370. I first used PLATO at UIUC in 1977, playing interactive D&Dgame. BTW, how is 1973 50 years ago?

  52. PLATO at UIC by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I remember using PLATO in the mid 70s at UIC...played Airfight and Dungeon in the middle of the night when the system was faster. Also took the TUTOR programming course. Talkomatic was ahead of its time. Great system for the era.

  53. That was PLATO IV by Baldrson · · Score: 1

    PLATO I was born 50 years ago and PLATO IV was the first version that had anything resembling "social networking" (although PLATO III running on Cray's first computer -- Cyber 1604 -- did have real time multiuser games).

  54. Dynamic memory model algorithm by Baldrson · · Score: 1

    You obviously didn't work in the language lab.

    The drill and practice engine driving the vocabulary lessons of virtually all language courses was built around a model of short term vs long term memory where an erroneous answer would provide the negative feedback along with the correct answer and then almost immediately re-present the vocabulary term but a series of correct answers would shift that term further and further back in the queue so that the next time it appeared would help drive it into long term memory.

    It was quite effective and actually made something that could be somewhat tedious actually entertaining.

  55. PLATO on the iThings? by BrainBarker · · Score: 1

    In the mid eighties, I spent many hours in the lab at the University of Illinois, working through endless physics problems on PLATO. It was a great system. I'm jealous that I never had access to games on it. From what others have said, there was some serious fun to be had there.

    Remembering the interface, I can't help but think that a port/remake would be a perfect fit for Apple's iThings. Just the nostalgia aspect would probably force me to jailbreak my phone.

    --
    "Dance like it hurts. Love like you need money. Work when people are watching." - Dogbert.
  56. Where was I? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    1973? My parents hadn't even met at that point.

    Hmmm, I should probably get off of this lawn.

  57. Where's CmdrTaco? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    TFA (yes I lookaed at it) listed people like the founders of Digg and FourSquare and LinkedIn, but what about the founders of /.?

  58. ballz by DutchMasterKiller · · Score: 1

    I was still in liquid form dangling about...

  59. The Princess Bride Reference by Puppet+Master · · Score: 1
    Remember Aristotle, Plato, Socrates?

    Morons!

    --
    The day Microsoft creates a product that doesn't suck, it will be known as the Microsoft Vaccuum Cleaner!
  60. Plato was around my HS in 1968 by SimCash · · Score: 1
    Okay, I was introduced to Plato at Mayo HS in Rochester MN, where I was told it was a sort of dial-up to a UM system. No BBS or the like, just a simple programming environment. I wrote codes in a sort of basic-like language with line numbers and stuff, saved them on paper punch tapes. The terminal had cylindrical keys like an old teletype terminal (which it probably was), with only paper print out as the computer-to-human connection. This was the system where I wrote my first modeling program, an empirical solution to the diffraction pattern from a double slit experiment. Full disclosure, they told us a very high price per minute, so when I wrote my first infinite loop I panicked and just unplugged the system to force a reboot.

    A very funny episode of Big Bang actually showed how to use a loop counter to break the loop, something I had not yet figured out back in '68, and obviously I was way ahead of the programming support at the high school at the time, so even if I were hiding from the sysadmin, he/she certainly did not live locally. Sigh, time to get out the suspenders and start talking like the Unix guru in Dilbert. I feel old.