Slashdot Mirror
Nintendo Releases The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword
mayberry42 writes "Finally, the wait is over — for European fans, anyway. After months (well, over a year) of delays, the latest adventure of Link is finally out. Reviews for the game are consistently favorable. Famitsu magazine has given it a perfect score. IGN says it's 'the greatest Zelda game ever created,' and even the best game for the Wii. Of course, some of you may have already known this, given that it has already been hacked to run on an emulator (and yes, it looks even better in HD). I would love to hear the opinions of you Europeans who've played it. Is it as good as they say?"
(Skyward Sword doesn't come out in the U.S. until Sunday, and not until next week for Japan and Australia.) While still complimentary, Giant Bomb's review goes into a bit more depth on the game's shortcomings.
>I would love to hear the opinions of you Europeans who've played it. Is it as good as they say?
Nah. It is a silly game. Running around in a silly hat with a sword, packed with all sorts of unrealistic creatures and someone has apparently built all sorts of puzzles into the world. Who would do such a thing? Totally unrealistic and stupid. You'd probably want to give this one a miss.
It's nice to get the first last for once, but I have to say that I don't understand why developers still release their games at different dates in different regions. Especially with the internet, reviews are going to be coming out as soon as the game is out anyway, which if the game is bad will reduce sales in the regions where the game comes out later (not that this is a concern in this case).
This game has been circulating the net for well over a week now, and has been pirated like crazy. I personally don't care for the game so I wont bother to pirate it or buy it. But how the hell is this slashdot worthy news?
Time to put this one to rest.
A feeling of having made the same mistake before: Deja Foobar
It's a very good game, the best Zelda made. I would say between 9/10 and 10/10. The controls are very accurate and it feels amazing to control the sword in 1:1 movement with the Wiimote. This game shows the power of Motion Plus and It's too bad games of these caliber have not released before. Imagine a Star Wars game like this where you swing a light sabel...
I'm really interested in this game since it seems to be one of the first to use the motion plus support very effectively. Any comments on how it feels or plays in this regards would be good to hear. Everything I've looked at online seems to indicate a good quality title. Will be good to play the wii again.
Anonymous Coward because this WILL be modded down to hell, but I'm sorry, SOMEONE has to call Nintendo on this stupid motion control garbage. This is the worst damn idea for gaming ever conceived of and should have never left Nintendo's R&D all those years ago.
Even with the more "accurate" Motion Control Plus, it's still a glitchy, imprecise pile of garbage no gamer should have to put up with.
How does this game compare to Die by the Sword?
Skyward Sword doesn't come out in the U.S. until Sunday, and not until next week for Japan and Australia.)
What is this madness? Perhaps I started gaming in the 90s, but I always thought that games were released in the country they were made first, then either America or Japan (whichever one didn't make it), then Europe a month or three later (and then Australia gets a new game whenever there's a chilly breeze in hell). Has Nintendo moved their HQ and developers to Europe without me noticing?
I mod down anyone who says "I will be modded down for this", regardless of the rest of their comment
it would have to be REALLY good to beat Link to the Past. or even Ocarina of Time for that matter. I have my doubts. But will need to see this for myself
... yes. It IS as good as we say. Can't be bothered with emulators, it looks great on the Wii. Even better on my old CRT TV. :)
Compared to what? The 150th version of Halo? NHL 2011?
You bitch like hell about all that's wrong with Zelda but you don't give us your frame of reference. How can we reply properly to your obvious stupid trolling?
obviously you've never played zelda in your life, am I wrong ?
I wont even address what you said because you simply suck.
1/10 - Trying way too hard. Your grasp of the English language is fair but you're among men here. We've been trolled by the great flamers of internet history while you were still sucking your thumb.
A good troll draws it's reader in and strikes once he's let down his defenses, his attention attracted by a mildly controversial topic. You start out pounding hard and blow your load before we even noticed you were there.
I played the demo at Target today and to misquote Dr. Zira "It's just so damned ugly". I love cell shading, and the cartoony graphics ,and the great color scheme, but it is in my eyes a pixelated mess. I know the Wii can't due HD, but I really thought Nintendo could pull some magic out of a hat on this one and have it look good. I have a hard time looking at most Wii games except the Nintendo ones, both the Galaxy game and SSBB look great. Monster Hunter Tri even looks better than this. I'm really looking forward to playing this come Sunday, but I'm not sure how happy I'll be looking at it (52" 1080p LCD tv).
There, it took you 4 lines but you eventually figured I could not possibly be "trolling".
I didn't apply any "trolling techniques" (at which you seem to be such a master) for the simple reason I was only winking at the last few able-minded gamers out there, some of which might buy Zelda for their wife but surely not for their kids. They'll know what I mean.
I hadn't really thought about all that. The region code system still seems like a money grab though.
"The Legend of Zelda: The Rise of Tim Tebow"
Probably have to be an NFL fan to get it.
Vote monkeys into Congress. They are cheaper and more trustworthy.
It has nothing to do with "save the princess." Its about game play.
Table Tennis has NO plot at all and is just a ball bouncing a short distance! Yet somehow it is in the Olympics?
Golf involves different hills of the same grass that you play fetch with yourself in...
Football involves the same thing over and over...
Checkers has almost no purpose. yet people still play it.
Pinball has only 2 buttons and you just watch a rolling ball the whole time!
Video games are not a "sport" (neither is golf) but that does not mean they can't involve developing skills and have enough depth to entertain somebody who has developed the skills.
New movies largely suck; video game movies largely suck even when some of them now out perform Hollywood. Many people do not want an interactive movie that is drawn out for 10x the length of time; I know I do not.
Zelda is as far as I'm willing to stretch it; the puzzles are fun and the premises are simple. Batman is a good game but its a slow motion ok movie I just am not willing to put my time into finish. If I want to fight against depressing situations I'll break out a mindless shooter. Better yet, do something in the real world rather than appease your humanity by proxy... your subconscious does not know the difference which is why escapes work so well as a substitute.
I'll stop Zelda when they think we are too stupid to read, like most games.
Democracy Now! - uncensored, anti-establishment news
Amidst the obvious trolling, there is a point; Zelda has become very stale with beat dungeon, get item to get to next dungeon, repeat formula. I don't know if this one fixed that issue, but I haven't seen anything indicating it has.
Give it up. A new Zelda game will never recreate that experience of firing up The Legend of Zelda on your NES for the first time when you were 10 years-old.
http://fc09.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2011/320/3/0/if_you_like_zelda_2_by_dungeonboss-d4gdo3k.png
Operation Rainfall
In my pants.
I picked up a copy yesterday and started it last night. Verdict so far? It's ok - pretty good. Heading for a 7/10 or 8/10 kind of score.
It's difficult stepping back to Wii level graphics these days. I didn't notice the difference so much early in the console cycle, but Wii games really do look very grim indeed next to anything else around. The artwork goes some way to compensating - it's very good in places. That said, it doesn't have the really strong visual style we've seen from other games over the last few years; Ratchet & Clank, Gears of War, Dark Souls, Mirror's Edge etc have all carved out really distinctive art styles - and have done so on better hardware. Even on the Wii, Xenoblade Chronicles has had more visual impact. There's just a bit too much "generic fantasy" around Skyward Sword (which is a criticism that can be levelled at a lot of the recent Final Fantasy spin-offs from Square-Enix).
The controls are undoubtedly better than Twilight Princess. There are occasional issues with the motion sensing refusing to register an attack at all, but they're the exception rather than the norm now. That said, I know this is a point about the Wii in general, rather than this game in particular, but I remain unconvinced that motion controls really add as much immersion as they were supposed to. There's that same "lack of connection" feeling that has always undermined motion gaming, be it on the Wii, PS Move or Kinect.
To be honest, if Zelda has one really, overwhelmingly huge problem, it's called "Dark Souls". I know that stylistically, the games are worlds apart (Zelda being a bright, colourful fantasy, while Dark Souls shares its palette with the original Quake) - but they are very similar in gameplay style - the same mix of exploration, combat, back-tracking and problem solving. And in every respect, Dark Souls is infinitely superior; not just to Skyward Sword, but to pretty much everything else in the genre. It's a pity that the reviews focussed so much on the difficulty (insanely hard though it is), because there is a supremely awesome game in there as well - and one that took me 79 hours to beat. The game's melee combat sets the new standard for this genre, with a real and distinctive sense of weight and mass to every weapon. After that, a bit of Wii-mote waggling, even with the Plus enhancements, just feels a bit limp.
Sorry, the text above is more negative than intended. This is a fun game. It's not kept up with the competition, but if you haven't played the competition yet, that might not matter to you.
Actually what's really weird is that Japan is last. You know, Nintendo being Japanese and all.
Most games just get released for Japan & US first (i.e. NTSC countries), followed by Europe/Australia/NZ (PAL countries) shortly after. Which makes sense - they are two different versions of the game disc. This release schedule is odd though because it's releasing in some PAL territories first (Europe), then an NTSC (US), then another PAL and another NTSC (Australia, Japan)...
why such a feeling? even the second zelda didn't require you to go through the dungeons in order, but doing so would make life easier. I know, as a 6 year old, it was hard to do something else, but when I did it recently, it wasn't that hard to do it out of order....
which game would you buy for your kids? zelda was one of the original "great" games, next to final fantasy. and for kids, it's a great introduction to story telling games, which are becoming more and more rare now.
You didn't think Twilight Princess was better than Link to the Past?
Back in the Wii Menu 3.x days, Twilight Princess let you install the Homebrew Channel and start Snes9x GX to run the copy of A Link to the Past that you dumped with your Retrode adapter. (In 4.x, the go-to games are the Lego series and Super Smash Bros. Brawl if for some reason you can't use Bannerbomb 4.0, Bannerbomb 4.2, or LetterBomb 4.3.)
With a few bucks and a decent PC and you can play in HD.
So I have a PC and a Wii, and I've letterbombed it to install Homebrew Channel. What software would I need to run on the Wii to copy a game disc to a PC to run it in Dolphin?
The aesthetic feels a lot more nuanced and inspired, and overall looks a lot less generic. It's also an adventure game and not a tournament.
I fail to see how releasing it in Europe first is either A) Hippie or B) Liberal
It's a good game, but was over-hyped. A lot like most games in a series, I supposed. But, hey, my save file hasn't yet corrupted itself and there aren't weird glitches making people spin for no reason, so I'm happy. It's harder than previous Zelda games, which I am starting to appreciate, and I'm getting the hang of having to actually fight the monsters instead of just hitting a button over and over again. I agree, though, that it's not as pretty as I had hoped, and I say that compared to just other Wii games. It's more a stylistic thing than a pixels thing, for me. I preferred Wind Waker's visuals.