Slashdot Mirror
EU Passes Resolution Against ITU Asserting Control Over Internet
An anonymous reader writes "Today, the European Parliament passed a resolution that condemns the upcoming attempt from the International Telecommunications Union (ITU) to assert control over the Internet, and instructed its 27 Member States to act accordingly. This follows an attempt from the ITU to assert itself as the governing body and control the Internet. From the article: 'The resolution, which was passed with a large majority, included Members of European Parliament (MEPs) from all major party groups, and the Pirate Party’s Amelia Andersdotter had been playing a central role in its drafting, together with MEPs Marietje Schaake and Judith Sargentini from the Netherlands, Sabine Verheyen and Petra Kammerevert from Germany, Ivailo Kalfin from Bulgaria, and Catherine Trautmann from France.'"
Despite all the failing and shortcomings, mother Europe still delivers.
we had Andersdotters here in India. Young politicians here are 40+, most are 60+ who can't understand tech if their lives depended on it. hence the facebook-post-arrests seen recently.
I'm pretty sure that having the EU tell you "STFU and leave it to the yanks" is one of the harsher put-downs that a multinational treaty organization can suffer...
But as with all things of this nature, I can't help but wonder where the catch is - sensible sounding legislation always comes back to bite us doesn't it?
Please consider this account deleted, I just can't be bothered with the spam anymore.
The anti-innovation, anti-competition strategy of the telcos must be stopped. The only thing as dysfunctional was the old USSR planned-economy model.
Most ACs are not even worth the keystrokes to insult them. Be generically insulted by this and ignored otherwise.
Today, the European Parliament passed a resolution that condemns the upcoming attempt from the International Telecommunications Union (ITU) to assert control over the Internet, and instructed its 27 Member States to act accordingly
The EU Parliament can instruct whatever it likes but it has no power over the member states. It might as well instruct all other world governments to agree as well, instruct the ITU to change track and instruct the weather to improve.
The most an instruction from the EU parliament to nationals governments can achieve is to raise enough outrage from nationalists that they take the opposite stand. In practice though nobody's likely to do more than roll their eyes at them.
Seriously, between the shittiness that is our national government and the shittiness that is the European Commission (fairly well demonstrated by having put my countryman Barroso in "charge"), the European Parliament seems like the only sane institution around here.
Dilbert RSS feed
Despite the US still being conservative compared to the progessive world, it is definetly far more liberal than nations such as Saudi Arabia where everyone citizen has to belong to the state sanctioned religion and women barely get by with showing their faces in public. Sure the current situation isn't ideal, but the ITU's solution is far worse.
Time is what keeps everything from happening all at once.
regulation from America. It leaves the countries themselves to regulate it which is open and free. That's all they're saying
good thing. But we have to keep knocking these douches out as they keep coming back like one of those psychopathic children in a fight that doesn't know he's beaten..
"sensible sounding legislation always comes back to bite us doesn't it?"
it just appears that way. The same people that want som d-bag international telco to control everything will be the same people that abuse the shit out of the internet spreading terrorism so that people eventually ask for the international telco company to take over. Unless we start killing/exiling these muppets if/when they want to raise the stakes
When I saw the list of names, I was positively surprised about the high number of women protecting our civil freedoms.
Support Eachother, Copy Dutch Property!
I have a naive and maybe stoopid question : If ITU wants to grab the authority that IANA has now, how the hell are they going to enforce it ?
Root servers are not going to magically change overnight, and people in the US and Europe are certainly not going to switch to whatever the ITU decides, just because the ITU decides.
It would be nice for the ITU to remember that the Internet works because everybody agrees with it. If people start to disagree, it will only lead to a split in the internet, and I'm pretty sure the ITU fork will not be the winner, given the history of the slug.
To be frank, after having travelled with railways in many places. I must say that the Dutch railways are probably the best working ones on the entire continent (except for when it is snowing).
"Civis Europaeus sum!"
'a VVD whore who sells voters to big business everytime she gets the chance'
[citation needed]
Looks like someone didn't vote for one of the current government coalition parties and is now grumpy!
it was this whore
Starting with a stupid sexist accusation like that makes me and many other people ignore the rest of your comment. Perhaps you have a valid point about her behaviour in office, but if you're unable to make it without a completely unjustified sexual slur, then you don't deserve to be heard.
Grow the fuck up.
The Dutch railroads are among the best in the world, with huge double-decker passenger trains between major cities with the frequency that some large cities don't even get on their metro lines. The cost of a ticket on Dutch trains is significantly lower than on the French or UK trains, and they are easier to get (from the machines), without the need of a stupid reservation. Even if a train is delayed, this delay is mostly measured in mere minutes. Only real accidents or failures will result on longer delays. And snow. Snow f***s everything up, because the Dutch don't invest enough to avoid that. But this is a sensible choice, not a failure. It just happens that it snowed in the last 2 years.
I never understand why the Dutch complain so much about their train system. I guess this is just because they never take the trains abroad.
The VVD may be wrong on many things, but they haven't messed up the trains.
I've been to Netherland several times in the last two decades and lived there for some time and I do have to say that while the Dutch railways were the best and still do work well, the legendary punctuality of Dutch trains is just a fond memory now..
We need to put a stop to this nonsense.
The only TLDs we need are country codes. ICANN should have just given control of these to their respective countries and left their root server list uncluttered.
Country governments can use the .gov.* and .mil.* for themselves, give state/province name and abbreviations to their respective local entities, and lease anything else --for a hefty multi-million per year fee-- to commercial registrars (ie: Verisign). The registrars of major high-level-domains (HLDs) would presumably lease their names from several different countries' TLDs.
When it's time for Slashdot to pay the rent, it goes to directly to Verisign's dotORG department and register the "slashdot.org.us" domain. Since Verisign would likely own the org.?? domain for most, if not all, country TLDs they might offer a multi country discount (but really, this is Verisign we're talking about...)
So if Amazon wants to be their own TLD... they'd have to buy an island and declare state sovereignty. But if they'll settle for being their own HLD, they could go to one or more country TLD operators, pay their steep lease rates, and then do whatever they want with the *.amazon.?? name. The .us .eu .uk and .au operators probably wouldn't have any issue with it; but .br might reject their application.
There, problem solved.
You are right, the dutch railway system is one of the best in the world (if not the best). People here just feel that it would have been even better if we hadn't privatized it. Whether that's justified I don't know.
I like her about a million times better as Eurocommissioner than as a minister. She's seriously doing some really good stuff now, and is the only Eurocommissioner that I regularly hear something positive from.
Too bad they're in the process of completely fucking up the ticket system. I used to be a fan of public transportation, but they're making it impossible for me now.
America is keeping control over the Internet. We are never going to relinquish it. There is nothing anyone can do about it.
You are perfectly free to build your own Internet anytime you want.
As a taxpaying American, I would gladly give over the control of the internet, if the acquiring country(ies) would reimburse us for past monies spent, and assune what it costs annually. We currently owe $17 trillion to other nations, and many of those countries we give financial aid to. Then we can bitch about it's operating problems. Takers?
You haven't been to the Netherlands recently. NS should stand for "No Show"!
In my experience, while traveling between FR, DE, BE, LX, CH, AT and the NL, once a train (including a high speed train) crosses the Dutch border it's instantly delayed. Should I count the part where they are changing the trains to between NL and BE to "high-speed" trains, even if they are traveling at normal speed, is just an excuse for making the prices 3-4 times higher and with mandatory reservations (unless you buy the tickets from Belgium). Should I count the times that I've wasted on their platforms mostly in bad weather.
The Dutch are good at a lot of things. Punctuality hasn't been one of them in a long time, whether you're talking about KLM, KPN (especially Getronics), NS they have completely forgotten what punctual means. Furthermore, they have replaced their BS-free attitude to a disgusting "politically correct/tongue up your arse" attitude, where, in order not to loose your business they tell you what you want to hear instead of the ugly truth. Fortunately, the Germans and the French are still frank enough.
UNIX was not designed to stop you from doing stupid things, because that would also stop you from doing clever ones.