Slashdot Mirror


Microsoft, Facebook Declare European Kids Clueless About Coding, Too

theodp writes: Having declared U.S. kids clueless about coding, Facebook and Microsoft are now turning their attention to Europe's young 'uns. "As stewards of Europe's future generations," begins the Open Letter to the European Union Ministers for Education signed by Facebook and Microsoft, "you will be all too aware that as early as the age of 7, children reach a critical juncture, when they are learning the core life skills of reading, writing and basic maths. However, to flourish in tomorrow's digital economy and society, they should also be learning to code. And many, sadly, are not." Released at the launch of the European Coding Initiative — aka All You Need is Code! (video) — in conjunction with the EU's Code Week, the letter closes, "As experts in our field, we owe it to Europe's youth to help equip them with the skills they will need to succeed — regardless of where life takes them."

30 of 213 comments (clear)

  1. Apparently by Rinikusu · · Score: 4, Insightful

    The only competent coders in the world are the ones who will work for $8/hour.

    --
    If you were me, you'd be good lookin'. - six string samurai
    1. Re:Apparently by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Insightful

      This is an effort to saturate the market so that'll be the case. Nobody believes everyone needs to know how to code and there's no way any but the most tech savvy 7 year olds are even interested at all. If you stuck me in front of a computer to mimic code someone showed me at 7, I'd have thought "okay, great, when is recess?" No way I'd have been able to grasp a lot of the higher level thinking involved. Now it's a career and a passion, but that particular road didn't even start until I hit my early to mid teens. I even took programming in high-school and just absolutely hated it. Sitting in front of crappy macs writing boring basic was just not interesting at all and probably did more harm then good.

    2. Re:Apparently by Intrepid+imaginaut · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Yup, why not teach them plumbing, cost me a hundred bucks to have a tap fixed the last day. If everyone was a plumber I'm sure I could have gotten it done for ten.

      This is nothing less than for-profit corporations attempting to interfere with the education system for their own financial gain.

    3. Re:Apparently by Forgefather · · Score: 3, Insightful

      I'm sure that in the middle ages the same thinking was used to justify not teaching peasants how to read. The only book that they needed to read was the Bible and you had your priest that could handle that for you. It was only when reading became common that we learned how dumb it was to let other people read for us.

      Personally I believe that not everyone needs to know how to code, but they do need to be familiar with how code works, and how they interact with it. How many problems occur because people are just ignorant of what their devices are doing? Just look at the celebrity nude photo scandal. Do you think that if the majority of those people understood how their information was stored and what protections were used that they would have been so quick to create and store such photos? To say nothing of how laws surrounding software and computers are thoroughly borked due to judges and politicians having -2 clues between them on how a computer works and how their laws impact computer use.

      Once it became possible for books to be distributed on a large scale, and the written word became a ubiquitous way to transfer information it no longer became possible to live in a modern society without learning to read. The same will be true of computers and code. We try to abstract the difficult parts behind GUIs, but you can no more automate good software design than you can automate the creation of a novel. Understanding of software will be critical to having an advantage in the coming years.

      --
      "There are lies, there are damn lies, and there are statistics"
    4. Re:Apparently by Opportunist · · Score: 4, Insightful

      And just like you can't simply pump more people into med school to end up with more doctors, you cannot pump more people into computer schools to get more programmers. Programming isn't middle management, you can't simply take any simpleton and expect them to be able to learn how to do it.

      --
      We used to have a Bill of Rights. Now, with the rights gone, all we have left is the bill.
    5. Re:Apparently by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

      That is absolute fucking horse shit. The best coders I've ever worked with are American. The Indian coders I've met have create HORRIBLE code.

      And I've met and worked with/for/had working for me/had to debug/fix/maintain the code of a horrendous amount of both.

      It's politically correct to say Indians are the best coders.

      And it makes you feel good because they work for cheap.

      But it's horse shit and everyone knows it.

    6. Re:Apparently by 0xdeadbeef · · Score: 3, Interesting

      If you stuck me in front of a computer to mimic code someone showed me at 7, I'd have thought "okay, great, when is recess?"

      Wait, computer time wasn't recess?

      I actually think the ubiquity of computers is the reason CS graduation rates have declined since before the dot com bubble. For the millennials, the magic never wears off because computers were never magical to begin with. And kids don't program for fun as much these days because the distance between what they can write and what they see in AAA video games is astronomical.

      When I started programming I thought I was the shit when I made a 3d cube rotate on a TRS-80. Sure, it was simple, but it wasn't like I was used to seeing 3d computer graphics on a home computer. Graphics like that in The Last Starfighter blew my fucking mind.

  2. Is anyone buying this? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

    Translation: We need to flood the job market so we can hire cheaper workers. Is anyone actually buying this?

    1. Re:Is anyone buying this? by Lunix+Nutcase · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Yes. Politicians.

  3. Fucking liars by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Of course they are saying that. According to these huge multinationals, the only ones who are not clueless are always conveniently the ones from countries who will accept dirt cheap wages. Funny how that works out.

  4. early age influences by BringsApples · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Maybe we should explain how social structure works, and how human desires come into play when mixed with it - rather than teach them how to operate machines.

    ...oh yeah, the adults have to learn that first...

    --
    Politics; n. : A religion whereby man is god.
    1. Re:early age influences by BringsApples · · Score: 2
      heh, you must be an adult. Here:

      In the social sciences, social structure is the patterned social arrangements in society that are both emergent from and determinant of the actions of the individuals.

      Desire: a strong feeling of wanting to have something or wishing for something to happen.

      If you're unable to link those together, then hopefully you're not in any position to decide things for a large number of people. And if you do know how to link those things together, then you should (at least try to) be in a position to decide things for a large number of people. If a large number of people are able to link those things together, then we don't need so many people deciding things for a large number of people.

      --
      Politics; n. : A religion whereby man is god.
  5. Is the oposite true? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    As a former European kid, can I declare Microsoft clueless about coding too?

  6. They forgot by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    These 7 yr olds need to learn to EAT THEIR BROCCOLI!

    Oops, forgot... parents around the world have already been doing that forever.

  7. Consumer based economy. by krotscheck · · Score: 5, Insightful

    You can't exactly nurture a consumer based economy to support your profits, then complain that it's not producing enough builders.

    --
    This signature can save you $400 on your car insurance!
    1. Re:Consumer based economy. by Lunix+Nutcase · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Yeah, but paying your employees anything beyond poverty wages is SOCIALISM!!!!!

      Or, you know, it's simply smart business as Henry Ford found out. He made his money back and then some by paying his workers wages higher than he had any necessity to do.

  8. Total bullshit ... by CaptainDork · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Dear Europe and America ...

    From the Christian Alliance for World Dominance: Your young ones need to learn our stuff.

    From the Muslim Alliance for World Dominance: Your young ones need to learn our stuff.

    From the Fossil Fuel Alliance for World Dominance: Your young ones need to learn our stuff.

    From the Science Alliance for World Dominance: Your young ones need to learn our stuff.

    From the Welding Alliance for World Dominance: Your young ones need to learn our stuff. ...

    --
    It little behooves the best of us to comment on the rest of us.
  9. Fundamentals by clifwlkr · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Whatever happened to teaching the kids the fundamentals of math and logic, never mind reading comprehension? Guess what? All of that is far more important to learning to code than the actual code itself. I find it ironic to imply that the kids are lost if they don't start to learn actual code that young. When I started programming, computers weren't even really available to anyone. I had good knowledge of math and logic, and was able to figure it out on my own over 35 years ago, and keep up with 'all of the latest trends' and have quite a successful career.
    What I learned that help me do this, was how to learn. Start teaching that, and you will find they are prepared for whatever comes down the line in the future. Stop making automatons.....
    Jim

    1. Re:Fundamentals by tsa · · Score: 3, Informative

      Indeed! It was horrendously bad in the 1990s in the Netherlands. I have a friend who was graduating from 'teaching school' then. She sent me emails riddled with spelling errors and crooked sentences. Amazingly she got her degree no problem. Later, in the early 2000s the govenment finally found out that something had to be done and they settled for a mandatory writing and math test for everyone who wanted to teach 4 - 12 year olds. The majority of the people who took those tests failed miserably. Things have improved a lot since then. My friend also improved and I get messages from her with normal Dutch sentences and well-spelled words. She even teaches dyslectic kids how to read and write now.

      --

      -- Cheers!

    2. Re:Fundamentals by clifwlkr · · Score: 2

      Another funny story along that line. I bought my cabin from a former school principal and administrator. When I moved into it, I found a note on the sink reading: "Leek in Fawsett". I at first looked for a vegetable in there, but did not find one. It was deplorable to me that someone in the school system long enough to retire could not even spell these very common words correctly. Then I saw all of his 'fixes' around (split a pipe in two since it didn't fit easily, and tried hose clamping it), and felt very sad for the generation he mentored.....

    3. Re:Fundamentals by Lilith's+Heart-shape · · Score: 4, Insightful

      If people grew up literate, numerate, and capable of logic then our existing society would have no hope of survival. There'd be riots in the streets, and legions of politicians and corporate executives impaled on rebar as if Vlad Tepes had risen from Hell to claim revenge upon the world.

  10. It's so true by CQDX · · Score: 2

    My company has been trying to hire the 12 year old and younger set because they are cheap but out of all the ones we've interviewed they can't pass the technical phase of the interview process.

    Out of desperation we've been forced to hire CS and EE college grads that learned how to code as undergrads. They're ok. They typically know C, Java, Python, and such but we have still not found a candidate that has 2+ years experience writing device drivers in Scratch.

  11. No surprise. by bickerdyke · · Score: 2

    The same kind of protagonists are performing the same schtick in the US and in Europe.

    STEM is called MINT, skill gap is Fachkräftemangel, and H1B is called "blue card" (yes. someone mixed up work permit and permanent residency when looking for a catchy name)

    Arguments are the same, debate is the same.

    And it becomes slightly absurd when immigration officers at a US border somehow expect every other country but the US to be a 3rd world hole people would be happy to trade in for a McJob in the US of A. They can't even imagine that someone likes their job and their home country and actually WANTS to go home after their visit.

    --
    bickerdyke
  12. Re:Guys, do you any codes you can share? by ArcadeMan · · Score: 2

    Up, up, down, down, left, right, left, right, B, A.

  13. Re:Read: IT wages in Europe rising by Austerity+Empowers · · Score: 2

    Hey now, market forces only work for the rich. They're not supposed to work for their employees!

  14. Coding leads to a life of poverty by Pro923 · · Score: 2

    Look, I try to explain my though on this and everytime I do, my karma gets blasted. Please try to understand I'm not against anyone here or the principals that you stand for - I'm only stating my opinion. I don't teach my kids to code because I want them to focus on a field that has a future that could lead them to have a lucrative career, be successful, financially secure and someday marry a lovely wife and give me some great grandchildren. Coding is not that path. There are several factors that contribute. 1) We have people that come from other countries that bring with them a lower standard of living. Those people can be qualified for these types of jobs, and will bring the average salary down with them - simply because they'll accept less. 2) Our society is not impressed with those with brains. We are more geared toward giving money to the football team mentality, which basically entails - follow the team, take orders and don't think. These are the people that tend to become successful, as I have witnessed anyway. We also tend to make a joke of the bright. We make movies like "the intern" that shows smart people as not fun, not cool, and not someone you want to be. You want to be more like the idiots - Vaughn and Wilson. Smart people aren't respected, and as a result, society doesn't pay them. We'd rather pay the firefighters, our heroes. 3) Coders aren't the best business people. Although I understand the whole free software movement, and like aspects of it, it's bringing us all down as people who have a chance to be paid well (as I believe we should). My salary is not sufficient for joining the country club, or eating at the high end steak joints. My sales buddies have left me in the dust. When something is made to be free, for indirect reasons that I won't get into - it's quality goes down, and it's value goes down. Companies that make software have to come up with creative ways to even make money doing this anymore. I wish we'd take a cue from the artists and musicians, who constantly speak of the way that their product now being free has destroyed their industry, and led to nothing but crap being produced these days. So... For my kids? They're extremely bright - and could actually learn calculus and perhaps write brilliant code. But I'm going to steer them towards some public sector job - like spraying water on a fire - because that's how they'll become successful. They'll get the good healthcare benefits (that we pay for handsomely) that last for life, they'll work 3 days on and 4 days off, which will give them an opportunity to create some meathead company like landscaping or HVAC - then they won't have to pay taxes anymore either. It's just my opinion - but I really think we've shot ourselves in the foot.

  15. Re:Read: IT wages in Europe rising by Layzej · · Score: 4, Interesting
    I think the MIT Lifelong Kindergarten Group is doing more to address this issue than MS or FB: http://scratch.mit.edu/

    With Scratch, you can program your own interactive stories, games, and animations — and share your creations with others in the online community.

    Scratch helps young people learn to think creatively, reason systematically, and work collaboratively — essential skills for life in the 21st century.

    Scratch is a project of the Lifelong Kindergarten Group at the MIT Media Lab. It is provided free of charge.

    If you have kids, you should introduce them to scratch!

  16. Judging by salary and the "supply vs demand" logic by Opportunist · · Score: 2

    I dare say that we don't lack programmers. But considering the wages of C-Level execs, there must be an incredible shortage of them.

    In a nutshell, we need A DAMN LOT more C-Level managers. Push kids into MBA courses. A few decades of graduates might finally get that salary level back to something more in touch with their actual worth.

    Huh? What do you mean, that's not what you meant? Care to elaborate?

    --
    We used to have a Bill of Rights. Now, with the rights gone, all we have left is the bill.
  17. Kids also clueless about by Livius · · Score: 2

    structural engineering, gastrointestinal surgery, quantum mechanics, income tax law, synthesizing pharmaceuticals, etc...

    Some are calling the phenomenon "being kids".

    So much for reintroducing child labour.

  18. Re:Read: IT wages in Europe rising by LifesABeach · · Score: 2

    I'm certain places like India, and China have more "favorable" children?