Slashdot Mirror


Arab Mars Probe Planned For 2020

SpankiMonki sends word that the United Arab Emirates has announced plans to launch a Mars mission in July, 2020. They want to send a probe (named "al-Amal",or "Hope") that will orbit the Red Planet for several years. It will analyze the Martian atmosphere, observing clouds and dust storms to help scientists figure out how water gradually escaped from Mars over a long time scale. [A]fter being inserted into an elliptical 55-hour orbit in the first quarter of 2021, Hope will carry out its nominal two-year science mission at altitudes ranging between 22,000 to 44,000 kilometers. From there, the mission will investigate how the lower and upper levels of the Martian atmosphere are connected. One goal is to create the first global picture of how the Martian atmosphere changes throughout the day and between seasons.

110 of 190 comments (clear)

  1. This will be a historic mission. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    It will be the first time the Arabs have used science in 800 years.

    1. Re:This will be a historic mission. by cheesybagel · · Score: 5, Insightful

      They'll probably just pay someone else to do it for them with the oil money as usual.

    2. Re:This will be a historic mission. by William+Robinson · · Score: 1

      UAE, Malaysia are actually a different world than other places you might have perception about (like Afganistan, Iran, Saudi, Pakistan etc.) They are pretty much open and have far better developed infrastructure, wide open for technology and business.

    3. Re:This will be a historic mission. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

      Its being built in Colorado by CU

    4. Re:This will be a historic mission. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      All of the countries you mention have good things and bad things going for them. Just like you shouldn't take Slashdot comments about how the US has third world infrastructure too seriously... except when it kind of does. The Saudi's can be repressive, but they also have a very impressive research university. Iran has a crazy government, but who doesn't these days? The French will complain about the Americans being crazy, while their president has an approval rating down around 20%...! And the people and the food and the culture of Iran is amazing (good luck finding decent Iranian food in the US, though... went to a high end Persian food place in NYC once and it was run by Afghans or such... the servers didn't speak the language, and the food had the right names but the wrong taste).

    5. Re:This will be a historic mission. by Voice+of+satan · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Quite a lot of people will benefit form this "arab" mission i guess. Other sources mentioned a contract between Abou dhabi and France for the formation of experts in the CNES center of Toulouse.

      I think it is a good thing they invest their money and their pride in this kind of stuff. More global funding for science and also some arab kids will be able to identify with something they will be proud of and doesn't involve blowing up people or some retarded religion.

    6. Re:This will be a historic mission. by alvinrod · · Score: 1

      While in the long run it would be better for them to develop the capacity in their own country for these kinds of endeavors, this still does benefit humanity and the space industry as a whole and it's oil money far better spent than Saudi Arabia, which seems to dump a lot into financing extremism and human misery.

    7. Re:This will be a historic mission. by hey! · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Pop quiz: what is the top Arab engineering school? Alright too hard. Name *one* Arab research university.

      Now answer this question: does the fact that most people find these questions hard reflect on *Arab* ignorance, or their own?

      --
      Post may contain irony: discontinue use if experiencing mood swings, nausea or elevated blood pressure.
    8. Re:This will be a historic mission. by itzly · · Score: 3, Insightful

      I have no idea what the top German/Chinese/Russian/Israeli engineering schools are either, still there are many more Arabs driving German cars, than the other way around.

    9. Re: This will be a historic mission. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      Or work on fixing their broken economic and political systems that result,in huge percentages of young men with no economic future and only one avenue for them to take out there anger and frustration surrounding that. Islamic extremism. If they had to go to work to pay the bills and support a family most wouldn't have time for that crap. You show me an area where young males have no economic future and I'll show you an area where a lot of bad things happen.

    10. Re:This will be a historic mission. by itzly · · Score: 3, Funny

      And as a side benefit, they'll learn how to launch ICBMs at the same time.

    11. Re:This will be a historic mission. by ITRambo · · Score: 1

      Google (US News link) says its King Saud University. Other Arab schools rank #1 in specific fields of engineering. Seemingly trick questions like yours are easy to answer these days without any previous knowledge of the subject.

    12. Re:This will be a historic mission. by hey! · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Really? You've never heard of Beijing University? Or the University of Heidelberg? Does "Max Planck Institute", "Moscow State University", or "Tel-Aviv University" ring a bell? Well then why not "King Saud University" or "Cairo University"?

      As for the production of cars, that's not a measure of a country's intellectual attainment; it's a measure of a country's industrialization. Show me *any* region that has a resource extraction dominated economy that designs automobiles. I can name just *one* off the top of my head, and that's Iran.

      There's an automatic assumption people make that when others disagree with them it's because they're stupid or ignorant. You can see that in the recent debate over the Iranian nuclear deal. There's an implicit assumption that the Iranian government is a bunch of uneducated, provincial hicks. Now I think Ali Khamenei is a terrible person, but it's not because he's ignorant. He is, in fact, superbly educated by any reasonable standard. As are many leaders in the Iranian government and opposition. The Iranian foreign minster Dr. Zarif holds three advanced degrees from US universities.

      This kind of bigoted thinking is going to get us into trouble. Iran is not an Arab country, but it gets lumped in with Arab countries in American perception as an intellectually backward Muslim backwater. This is a dangerous attitude to take. Iran has substantial intellectual and technological resources to draw upon. Despite their names differing by only one letter, Iran is not Iraq. While Sadaam wasted his money on showy wonder-weapons like super-guns, the Iranians have built a fleet of advanced diesel subs that can operate in the shallow waters of the Persian Gulf. They have formidable industrial capability, including indigenous aerospace, automotive and electronic industries. While there is little doubt we would win in an invasion of Iran, it's far from clear it'd be the kind of cakewalk we had in the Iraq invasion.

      Americans need to write this down and paste it in their hats: just because someone doesn't think like you doesn't guarantee he's ignorant or stupid.

      --
      Post may contain irony: discontinue use if experiencing mood swings, nausea or elevated blood pressure.
    13. Re:This will be a historic mission. by fustakrakich · · Score: 1

      ...Saudi Arabia, which seems to dump a lot into financing extremism and human misery.

      Hey, at least they buy American

      --
      “He’s not deformed, he’s just drunk!”
    14. Re:This will be a historic mission. by hey! · · Score: 1

      Sure, but you've heard of King Saud University, right?

      --
      Post may contain irony: discontinue use if experiencing mood swings, nausea or elevated blood pressure.
    15. Re: This will be a historic mission. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      Don't forget the. Ansari xprize. Anousha ansari is iranian

    16. Re:This will be a historic mission. by itzly · · Score: 1

      Really? You've never heard of Beijing University? Or the University of Heidelberg? Does "Max Planck Institute", "Moscow State University", or "Tel-Aviv University" ring a bell?

      I've heard of those, but that's about it. I have no idea what they teach at those, and how good they are in relation to each other.

      As for the production of cars, that's not a measure of a country's intellectual attainment; it's a measure of a country's industrialization

      Which is a decent measure of the ability to build and launch rockets and space probes.

      The Iranian foreign minster Dr. Zarif holds three advanced degrees from US universities.

      How ironic.

      Iran is not an Arab country

      So why did you bring it up?

    17. Re:This will be a historic mission. by Voice+of+satan · · Score: 1

      While i think you are correct when your refute the stupid notion that Iranians would be primitive towelheads, i wouldn't call their industrial capabilities "formidable". Their only industrial achievement i can think of that had a strategical effect is making extra strong concrete that contributed to prevent aerial raids against their nuclear installations. This is no trivial material science feat indeed. That and retaining the know how to fly tomcats.

      But many of their industrial projects make no sense at all, even as industrial prototypes. Their two tailfin F5's, ekranoplanes or supercavitating torpedoes come to mind. That's just senseless waste of money.

      Besides, that very off topic. We are speaking of a UAE funded space mission here.

    18. Re:This will be a historic mission. by Feral+Nerd · · Score: 1

      It will be the first time the Arabs have used science in 800 years.

      Arabs and Moslems in general are in many ways a lot less hostile toward science than many Christians. The standard bearers of the most popular movement to ban the theory of evolution from schools are evangelical christians from the USA. You can point your finger at salafists and bandits like ISIS and the Taleban all day long but they are the exception not the rule. Iran for example is a pretty fundamentalist state that is opressive in many ways but Iranians are no anti-scientific luddites who make asses of them selves internationally by preaching inteigent design. Most Quaranic scholars have spent much more energy on trying to reconcile scripture with the theory of evolution rather than just trying to ban it by law.

    19. Re:This will be a historic mission. by benjfowler · · Score: 1

      The Americans aren't hanging homosexuals by the neck with nylon rope from cranes in public though. Nor are they doing judicial amputations and blindings.

    20. Re:This will be a historic mission. by benjfowler · · Score: 1

      That in itself is a sign of weakness and laziness.

      They only seem to do technical disciplines in great numbers (and aren't particularly good at it; the shops here in London are FULL of "Asians" with worthless IT degrees). They will not study the humanities or anything which challenges their strident, deeply held prejudices. Their inability to throw off their ignorance is what's holding them back. Ironically, worthless technical degrees from crap universities doesn't help with this. "Thinking" entails much more than paying others to build bridges or cut code.

    21. Re:This will be a historic mission. by ericloewe · · Score: 1

      You have a funny definition of "open".

    22. Re:This will be a historic mission. by chthon · · Score: 1

      If they want to use that capacity, they will also need to develop an industry to build and arm them.

    23. Re:This will be a historic mission. by hey! · · Score: 1

      Iran is not an Arab country

      So why did you bring it up?

      Because you brought up automobile design.

      --
      Post may contain irony: discontinue use if experiencing mood swings, nausea or elevated blood pressure.
    24. Re:This will be a historic mission. by hey! · · Score: 1

      I take your point, but I'm addressing the attitude that because Muslim countries are different from us that must mean they're incapable of doing impressive things. That's just wishful thinking.

      Of course "formidable" is a relative term. Iran's industrial capability isn't formidable compared to Germany, but it sure is compared to Iraq. Their automotive industry builds over a million cars a year.

      --
      Post may contain irony: discontinue use if experiencing mood swings, nausea or elevated blood pressure.
    25. Re:This will be a historic mission. by Teun · · Score: 1

      Iran is not an Arab country

      So why did you bring it up?

      I can see a reason, 'Arab' is generally equated with 'Muslim' and Iran is (how silly can it get) by law a Muslim country.

      To come back On Topic, this is going to be a Muslim Mars mission which makes me wonder how they plan to overcome the associated extra fuel use and thus extra weight,
      I mean, this thing needs to turn it's head to Mecca five times a day!

      --
      "The likes of Facebook and WhatsApp are free to those whose privacy is of zero value."
    26. Re:This will be a historic mission. by Type44Q · · Score: 1

      That reminds me of the one about how President Carter brought a pooper-scooper to the Strategic Arms Limitation Talks...

    27. Re:This will be a historic mission. by Applehu+Akbar · · Score: 1

      Let's all hope that by the time this flies that the Abbasid Caliphate is on the way to being revived.

    28. Re: This will be a historic mission. by Circlotron · · Score: 1

      " Show me *any* region that has a resource extraction dominated economy that designs automobiles. " ------- AUSTRALIA.

    29. Re:This will be a historic mission. by Whiteox · · Score: 1

      University of Teheran designed a Solar Challenger car a few years back. It didn't arrive in Australia in time for the race. There was a lot of disappointment by many here and overseas. The story we heard was that the car was loaded on a transport, but arrived at a non-Aust. destination then got sent back. Then the whole thing was hushed up and never spoken of again.
      About a week before the start of the race, I googled some of the team members and found a few entries in a German forum on solar development, asking for a source for specific parts. I even emailed the organizers of the Solar Challenge who were expecting the team and car to show up soon. Images and a short video from the Uni website were available at the time and it looked like a serious contender.
      The timing of the event sort of clashed with the political events at the time. There was a period where Iran was seen as having relative freedoms and its academic work was being recognized. Politically, they were at a turning point (or the western world saw it at that) and various commentaries and sanctions turned them away.
      As far as science was concerned, this was not a good development and due to this, the project got canned - or I think it did.
      http://www.ut.ac.ir/en/content...

      --
      Don't be apathetic. Procrastinate!
    30. Re: This will be a historic mission. by Whiteox · · Score: 1

      Not for long. Toyota, Ford and Holden (GM) are in the process of pulling out.

      --
      Don't be apathetic. Procrastinate!
    31. Re:This will be a historic mission. by jafiwam · · Score: 1

      They'll probably just pay someone else to do it for them with the oil money as usual.

      And what they buy will be an empty bomb casing full of pinball machine parts.

      Seriously though, I don't see the level of cooperation required for this project persisting long enough to pull it off. But, the best of luck to them for trying.

    32. Re:This will be a historic mission. by Rei · · Score: 1

      Seriously though, I don't see the level of cooperation required for this project persisting long enough to pull it off.

      Of course given history, there will be disruptions, but it'll work out in the end. They are easily startled - but they'll be back, and in greater numbers.

    33. Re:This will be a historic mission. by ZiggyM · · Score: 2

      Hopefully they wont pay this guy: "Saudi Cleric Reveals The Sun Rotates arround the Earth" http://www.huffingtonpost.co.u...

    34. Re:This will be a historic mission. by benjfowler · · Score: 1

      America gets the elite. Europe gets the rabble.

      Count yourselves lucky.

    35. Re:This will be a historic mission. by muecksteiner · · Score: 1

      KAUST might be world famous, but for what exactly? For the most money spent on what amounts to, given the resources available to them, at best mediocre science output?

      I can tell you that in my discipline (computer graphics), KAUST only has a reputation of an elephant graveyard for greedy elderly not-really-at-the-top-of-the-A-list academics who want to roll in some hard petrodollars before retirement. Science? Yeah, some is bound to happen if you lock up lots of people with long publication lists in a luxury ghetto in the desert. But a role model university? Hardly. More an elaborate joke of sorts.

      Locals are forbidden to attend, or to enter the campus. Undergrads (all foreigners, of course) have to be paid hefty salaries to even show up.

      Sound like Harvard? Sure does, right? Just vacuum up all that sand which tends to accumulate everywhere, and you will hardly be able to tell the difference...

    36. Re:This will be a historic mission. by hey! · · Score: 1

      My wife was at the Woods Hole Oceanographic when Bobby Ballard found the Titanic. You know what his colleagues there talked about? How he wore a baseball cap on TV to hide his bald spot.

      --
      Post may contain irony: discontinue use if experiencing mood swings, nausea or elevated blood pressure.
    37. Re:This will be a historic mission. by dave420 · · Score: 1

      You condemn "their" "strident, deeply held prejudices" by vomiting your own strident, deeply held prejudices? Get a fucking grip - you are just as ignorant as the stereotypes you are railing against. You should try thinking for yourself - it will help you stop sounding like a backwards xenophobic redneck or an "I'm not racist but..." EDL/UKIPper.

    38. Re:This will be a historic mission. by Teun · · Score: 1

      I'm not so sure I can follow you.
      What I meant is that I oppose the idea of writing anything more than the personal freedom of religion into law.
      Anywhere.

      --
      "The likes of Facebook and WhatsApp are free to those whose privacy is of zero value."
    39. Re:This will be a historic mission. by Teun · · Score: 1

      Sorry for the late reply but it can't be denied that the first prophet of Islam was an Arab and it became the next iteration of the existing Middle Eastern Abrahamic religions.
      I dare postulate that today's Islam is mainly different from it's predecessors due to great simplification and the inclusion of certain ancient beliefs from the Arabic peninsula.
      After all, the holy sites of Mecca had seen worship for much longer than Christianity existed.
      I see nothing wrong in my observation Islam is still heavily dominated by Arabic culture or do you feel that culture is somewhat inferior?

      To cut it short, I have nothing against Islam as the religion of the Koran (Gods word) but I have serious reservations with the almost automatic inclusion of the Hadith, Sira, Salaphistic and other local customs like female circumcision or the hiding of women from public life.

      --
      "The likes of Facebook and WhatsApp are free to those whose privacy is of zero value."
  2. Fitting Viewpoint by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Observing atmospheric phenomena and the dynamics of water is a very fitting viewpoint for the UAE. As various countries gain capability, the impact of cultural differences might get even stronger in the choices of viewpoints to research questions.

  3. Metorite cult by l0n3s0m3phr34k · · Score: 1

    returning to the stars. Quite poetic, for a country who worships the Alhajar Al-Aswad (The Black Stone). Saul, who became Paul, also was spooked into religion by a meteorite...Constantine's "vision" may well have also been burning, falling rocks. The UAE most likely has some pretty advanced tech for looking at water...launching a probe to Mars isn't the difficult part. That is getting the probe deployed and functioning properly once it's there lol.

    1. Re:Metorite cult by phayes · · Score: 3, Interesting

      It's not a rover, it's an orbiter. The only thing that need to be deployed are the three solar panels & that will be in Earth orbit - the spectrometers & an imager do not need to be deployed.

      My question is how they will be communicating with it. Does the UAE have the capability to do so alone or will they be relying on NASA's DSN?

      --
      Democracy is a sheep and two wolves deciding what to have for lunch. Freedom is a well armed sheep contesting the issue
    2. Re:Metorite cult by buddyglass · · Score: 1

      Saul, who became Paul, also was spooked into religion by a meteorite

      How do you figure?

    3. Re:Metorite cult by antiperimetaparalogo · · Score: 2

      Saul, who became Paul, also was spooked into religion by a meteorite

      How do you figure?

      He wrote something bad about Muslims so he had to write something bad about Christians also, because you know... it's Slashdot, so "all religions are the same"...

      Anyway, he probably is refering to Paul's (a.k.a. Saul) sudden blindness -for few days-, before he became a Christian, but the story is: while persecuting Christians, Jesus appeared to him making Paul blind, BUT also telling him "Saul, Saul, why you persecute me?"... and the great story continues, but if you are interested you should read it in the Acts of Apostloles and his own Epistles, both found in the New Testament - by the way, since New Testament is originally writen in Greek, i can ensure you that Paul was not "blinded by a meteorite", nor was Great Constantine (the other mentioned by the parent comment as "meteorite blinded") who thanks to a vision before a battle with the Cross and the Greek phrase "with this you win" ("En Touto Nika") became a Christian.

      DISCLAIMER: I am a Greek (Orthodox) Christian.

      --
      Antisthenes: "Wisdom begins by examining the words/names." - excuse my English, i am (slightly...) better with my Greek!
    4. Re:Metorite cult by buddyglass · · Score: 1

      I agree Saul/Paul wasn't "spooked into religion" by a meteorite. I just wanted to hear his reasons for thinking that's the case.

      Re: the road to Damascus, it's worth noting that Saul/Paul was already highly "religious" prior to that experience.

    5. Re:Metorite cult by antiperimetaparalogo · · Score: 1

      I agree Saul/Paul wasn't "spooked into religion" by a meteorite. I just wanted to hear his reasons for thinking that's the case.

      Maybe it was wrong from me to judge him by making such assumptions about him without realy knowing him (but changes are i am right, because... Slashdot!). I just wanted to inform you about the "non-Slashdot" version of the story... i understand now that you did not needed my help, since you already know it.

      Re: the road to Damascus, it's worth noting that Saul/Paul was already highly "religious" prior to that experience.

      Hmmm... i just searched this "road to Damascus" ("Protestantic") phrase that i didn't know (we Orthodox-Greeks use some other terms for this type of conversions) - it may worth repeating (even if i feel that it is NOT a "dogma" you follow) my criticism to the "all religions are the same" mantra of the "religious Atheists"... Saul was a Jew before become Paul the Christian, but Constantine was a Pagan before become Great Constantine the Christian... and a was a "religious Atheist" before become Christian!

      --
      Antisthenes: "Wisdom begins by examining the words/names." - excuse my English, i am (slightly...) better with my Greek!
    6. Re:Metorite cult by l0n3s0m3phr34k · · Score: 1

      Mostly because I read this page and a few others...and this satisfies Occam's Razor far more than a supernatural being.

    7. Re:Metorite cult by l0n3s0m3phr34k · · Score: 1

      It's not "bad" about Muslims, it's a fact. There is a big rock that they all make a pilgrimage to, in Mecca, named Alhajar Al-Aswad. It could also be a piece of shock glass from an impact. And your not quoting me about "blinding", I didn't type that. Not sure why you think I said anything about "blinded by a meteorite"...maybe you should read my comment again? Here is some info on Constantine and the possibility of a meteorite fueling his conversion, or at least his conversion of everyone else since he didn't actually convert until on his deathbed.

      It's not "bad" if they worship a space rock, it's somewhat common. It does seem a bit paradoxical for a religion that is so iconoclastic to hold a physical object in such veneration.

    8. Re:Metorite cult by l0n3s0m3phr34k · · Score: 1

      Constantine didn't fully convert until he was on his deathbed, he mostly did it for political reasons.

    9. Re:Metorite cult by buddyglass · · Score: 1

      Doesn't seem to explain the full biblical account. The voices he heard, for one, but also the claim that the "scales fell off his eyes" immediately after he was prayed for by Annanias. Of course you could argue those bits are fictional. The fact remains, though, that Saul was already "religious" prior to his experience on the road to Damascus.

    10. Re:Metorite cult by antiperimetaparalogo · · Score: 1

      Yes, what you write about Muslims is a fact. What i have problems with, is writing "bad" things about Christians...

      About Constantine: we know about this story from (Roman) Lactantius, a close advisor of Constantine, who wrote (as Constanine told him, and know about him writing it) that this vision of the Cross with the phrase "with this you win" (in Greek) was during Constantine's sleep (before the battle, and after he prayed to the "Sun God", since until then he was "Heliolatris") - also from (Greek) Eusebius of Caesarea (the first Church's historic) who was a bishop and know Constantine personaly: in his major work he wrote about Constanine's vision without mentioning if it was during his sleep or not (but based to the usual terminology we can assume it was during sleep) - in one work attributed to him, BUT IT IS *ALMOST* CERTAIN IT IS NOT ACTUALLY HIS, called "Life of Constantine", it is mentioned that this vision was while Constantine was awake. For us Greeks, Constantine the Great is very important for some non-religious reasons also: with Greek origins from both parents (his father -Constantius Chlorus- become Caesar), he is the one that as Caesar of the East Roman empire -i.e., the Greek in reality- founded Constantinople and what is known as Byzantine empire. His mother Helen is also an important person for us Greek Orthodox Christians. I just write all that to note that i may know few things - don't take it as an attack because "a 'barbarian' like you made fun of us great Greeks". About BBC: don't let me start... let just say that most Slashdoters will feel very comfortable there, plus any anti-Catholic/Orthodox will find so many (stupid) stories to make fun of us!

      --
      Antisthenes: "Wisdom begins by examining the words/names." - excuse my English, i am (slightly...) better with my Greek!
    11. Re:Metorite cult by antiperimetaparalogo · · Score: 1

      Constantine didn't fully convert until he was on his deathbed, he mostly did it for political reasons.

      That is true but in the way you put it may not be clear what were those political reasons: remember that even while he made Christianity legal, most people were non-Christians yet!

      --
      Antisthenes: "Wisdom begins by examining the words/names." - excuse my English, i am (slightly...) better with my Greek!
  4. Arab? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Insightful

    It's the UAE. The Emirates. Do you write about the "Caucasian Moon missions", or the Apollo program?

    1. Re:Arab? by Megol · · Score: 1

      True, and here I have no mod points :(

    2. Re:Arab? by itzly · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Do you write about the "Caucasian Moon missions"

      Maybe, if they were launched from the United Caucasian States of America.

    3. Re:Arab? by phayes · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Hypersensitive much?

      UAE: United Arab Emirates
      USA: United States of America

      Calling it an Arab mission when the word Arab is in the name of the country that is financing it is neither more nor less precise or racist than calling the Apollo the American moon program -- which is often is.

      Is the UAE the only Arabic country? No, but then neither are the citizens of the USA the only Americans.

      --
      Democracy is a sheep and two wolves deciding what to have for lunch. Freedom is a well armed sheep contesting the issue
    4. Re:Arab? by Hognoxious · · Score: 1

      There is a difference between nationality and race.

      Give it time, they're working on that.

      --
      Confucius say, "Find worm in apple - bad. Find half a worm - worse."
    5. Re:Arab? by GNious · · Score: 1

      don't worry, I have about 15 mod points currently

    6. Re:Arab? by NoKaOi · · Score: 2

      Hypersensitive much?

      UAE: United Arab Emirates
      USA: United States of America

      Except that the word "Arab" does not refer to the UAE. The proper term is "Emirati," the word "Arab" means something else. The point the OP was making is that many people in the US are ignorant and seem to lump everything "Arab" together as if there were only one "Arab" country (or that there is no difference between Arab countries), and I think your ignorance helped prove his point.

    7. Re:Arab? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      as if there were only one "Arab" country

      That's the one between the "Africa" country and the middle of nowhere, right?

    8. Re:Arab? by Beeftopia · · Score: 1

      No, but then neither are the citizens of the USA the only Americans.

      Actually, without a qualifier (i.e. "north", "south", "central"), citizens of the US are in fact the only "Americans". Since the name "America" is in the name of the country.

      The best demonstration of this would be on a hijacked plane. When the terrorists ask, "Who here is an American?", rest assured that no Central or South American is going to raise his hand.

      Saying USAians or US Americans makes you sound like Miss South Carolina.

    9. Re:Arab? by phayes · · Score: 1

      Really... So that middle word in UAE is some completely different word that is just spelled the same. Of course it's everybody else that is ignorant & you are here to teach everyone else that Arab doesn't mean Arab.

      As for your brilliant conclusion that I'm an ignorant American, eh bien non mais mes potes Moroccains, Tunisians et Algerians vont trouver cela hilarant.

      --
      Democracy is a sheep and two wolves deciding what to have for lunch. Freedom is a well armed sheep contesting the issue
    10. Re:Arab? by phayes · · Score: 1

      Spent any significant time outside The US? I've been taken to task by people from other countries in the Americas for the USA's use of American to mean only US citizens. Travel some more and you'll see my point. You'll also use fewer US specific references like Miss SC.

      --
      Democracy is a sheep and two wolves deciding what to have for lunch. Freedom is a well armed sheep contesting the issue
    11. Re:Arab? by MorePower · · Score: 1

      I've spent significant time in Europe and Asia and "America" is universally understood to mean USA and "American" to mean people from the USA, even by people who can barely croak out an English sentence. They might understand "USA", but "U.S." or "United States"? Forget it.

      The only people who take issue with that usage of "America/American" (aside from internet pendants) are Spanish speakers who rather arrogantly insist that the English word "American" needs to match up with the Spanish word "Americano".

      Personally, I say we adopt "Americano" into English as a word meaning "person from the Western Hemisphere" and end the debate.

    12. Re:Arab? by Why2K · · Score: 1

      Well, their own web site calls it the "First ever Arab mission to another planet"

      http://www.emiratesmarsmission...

    13. Re:Arab? by Hognoxious · · Score: 1

      Seconded. If we want to talk aboot^H about Canadians, Mexicans or Brazilians we have words for them.

      --
      Confucius say, "Find worm in apple - bad. Find half a worm - worse."
    14. Re:Arab? by phayes · · Score: 1

      Who is arrogant? The more numerous Spanish speakers in the rest of the Americas ? Or the USA for assuming that American refers uniquely to those in the US. Apparently you consider it pedantry to point out that that people holding your opinion are in the minority.

      --
      Democracy is a sheep and two wolves deciding what to have for lunch. Freedom is a well armed sheep contesting the issue
    15. Re:Arab? by dywolf · · Score: 1

      So by your definition that is no such thing as a European. Or Asian. and only one or two countries of Africans.

      --
      The guy who said the election was rigged won the presidency with the second-most votes.
    16. Re:Arab? by Beeftopia · · Score: 1

      Trying to induce ambiguity into American - where none actually exists (see the hijacked airplane example) - is obfuscation for no apparent benefit. Forcing Americans to use more syllables to describe themselves is increasing the number of syllables - lowering signal to noise - for no benefit.

      If an American wishes to describe himself based on continent, he would say he's a North American. A South American or Central American would do the same. Here's the USGS list of continents.

      If they wish to describe themselves by country, there are already clear methods to convey that.

      Lowering the signal to noise ratio of verbal communications won't help anyone it seems to me.

    17. Re:Arab? by phayes · · Score: 1

      You gotta just love people ignorant enough to think that knowledge of their culture means that they can generalise to other cultures. It's really comical.

      Here's an example: How many continents are there? Seven right? Same thing in Spanish, right? Uhhh no. Google "cuántos continentes hay en el mundo" & you'll discover that Spanish speaking cultures generally only count five with no antarctica & Americas being one.

      Your assumption that a Spanish speaking "Central" American or "South" American would distinguish himself from a "North" American is bunk. You, the English speaking person from the US would. They don't. Your idea that I am trying to introduce ambiguity into "American" is bunk. All along I've been saying that for most "Americans" there is no difference. I do not care that this may hurt your pride in being "the only real Americans".

      --
      Democracy is a sheep and two wolves deciding what to have for lunch. Freedom is a well armed sheep contesting the issue
  5. Contract it out. by kenai_alpenglow · · Score: 1

    They'll probably contract with one of the major US/European contractors & put their flag on the rocket. Though I don't see any problem with that--they have the money, might as well do something useful with it besides build up big piles of sand in the gulf.

    1. Re:Contract it out. by hey! · · Score: 1

      On what do you base this "probability"?

      --
      Post may contain irony: discontinue use if experiencing mood swings, nausea or elevated blood pressure.
    2. Re:Contract it out. by ericloewe · · Score: 1

      The fact that they have zero know-how, essentially.

      In fact, they have essentially zero know-how in all fields. They're comfortable living off oil and slavery-backed glamour.

    3. Re:Contract it out. by kenai_alpenglow · · Score: 1

      Let's just say "Past Observation"--Note that I'm not saying it's wrong. And in their position (small, wealthy country), I would think that would be the best leverage of their resources.

    4. Re:Contract it out. by hey! · · Score: 1

      And how do you know they have "zero know how"? Know how isn't a property of nations, it belongs to individuals who can be hired for a reasonable price.

      If you mean "zero indigenous know how" that's something we can't take for granted either. The UAE is small (9 million -- just a bit larger than Switzerland), but it is very rich and no doubt has its share of talented individuals. What's more if they reached out to other Arab countries (as well as hiring a few key non-Arab personnel -- like we had Germans in the 50s and 60s), I don't doubt they could put together a reasonably "Arab" space program, which I see as a positive development. Such a program wouldn't build every jot and tiddle of their hardware right down to the nuts and bolts, but then we don't do that either.

      Thought experiment. Suppose you're in charge of setting up a UAE and they give you a huge wad of cash to set up a space program. How would *you* go about doing it to maximize national scientific prestige?

      --
      Post may contain irony: discontinue use if experiencing mood swings, nausea or elevated blood pressure.
    5. Re:Contract it out. by kenai_alpenglow · · Score: 1

      I think you may have misunderstood my original comment...What I said is basically what you are saying. (My comment about the piles of sand was the (from what I heard) failed project of creating islands to sell to wealthy folks. At least a space program is something that would help other folks. I have nothing against the Emirates.)

    6. Re:Contract it out. by ericloewe · · Score: 1

      Fact: they have no preexisting projects.

      Therefore, any know-how they acquire has to either be developed or "purchased" (traded for, if you will)elsewhere.
      Since the timeframe excludes the first option, the second one is the obvious one.

  6. Progress by Livius · · Score: 4, Insightful

    You know, if an Arab state is moving from Mediaeval barbarism to Enlightenment, maybe it would be a good time to say something positive.

    1. Re:Progress by Areyoukiddingme · · Score: 1

      Where's the kaboom? There was supposed to be a Mars-shattering kaboom.

    2. Re:Progress by Tablizer · · Score: 1

      moving from Mediaeval barbarism to Enlightenment

      Which turned into the ugly Catholic/protestant wars that didn't settle until late 1600's. I suppose you gotta start somewhere.

    3. Re:Progress by abies · · Score: 1

      Aren't you confusing Enlightenment with Renaissance? Thirty Years War ended in 1648 and Enlightement is generally counted from 1650 onwards. One of the points of Enlightement was that it was getting away with ugly, supersition-based wars.

      As for GP, don't worry, Arab states are nowhere near that point.

    4. Re:Progress by gsslay · · Score: 1

      Yeah, because they execute people by stoning! Funny!

      Executions in 2014 in USA - 35
      Executions in 2014 in UAE - 1 (firing squad, murder conviction)

      Executions per 100 million in USA - 11.799
      Executions per 100 million in UAE - 4.266

    5. Re:Progress by Tablizer · · Score: 2

      I don't think it's about superstition, it's about accepting pluralism and other opinions. Both sides realized the hard way that the religious wars were dragging both sides down, and learned how to live together. Some of it was a form of "let God decide in the afterlife" rather than let humans do all the punishing here and now. The government's role then shifted to keeping the peace instead of enforcing religious rules and doctrine.

  7. Interesting. by jpellino · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Five years to get from no rockets to an interplanetary orbiting probe. The video they produced clearly shows the launch from somewhere near UAE, so they're not just going to hire an existing launch-proven company/state to give their satellite a ride. Ambitious. Highly collaborative with the existing science community. Aces. There's a woman as Co-I on the project - well done. They're not going to try and land, good idea. And the not-landing part will fill in some pretty significant gaps in mars atmospheric science. The only true unknowns are how many freshman US legislators will become outraged and demand a congressional hearing.

    --
    "Win treats sysadmins better than users. Mac treats users better than sysadmins. Linux treats everyone like sysadmins."
    1. Re:Interesting. by l0ungeb0y · · Score: 1

      The only true unknowns are how many freshman US legislators will become outraged and demand a congressional hearing.

      Hopefully enough to get these hearings to focus on something big like building a Long Term Space Habitat stationed at a lagrange point rather than sticking to what we know.

    2. Re:Interesting. by itzly · · Score: 1

      building a Long Term Space Habitat stationed at a lagrange point

      Or on earth, which is just as useful, but a lot cheaper.

  8. Go away by AndyKron · · Score: 1

    We already have our flag there, go away. Besides, the people in the UAE couldn't make a bottle rocket if their lives depended on it. Other people will have to build it for them.

  9. here they come by jbmartin6 · · Score: 1

    Here come the Fremen

    --
    This posting is provided 'AS IS' without warranty of any kind, implied or otherwise.
  10. Funny by itzly · · Score: 1

    If you click on the first "Mars" link in the article, it takes you to the Mars food company.

  11. Comment removed by account_deleted · · Score: 2

    Comment removed based on user account deletion

  12. Thought Slashdot was better than this by Headw1nd · · Score: 1, Insightful

    So another country wants to develop space capability, and this is what Slashdot has to say about it? A bunch of half-assed racist remarks? It's not just shameful, it's lame. Of all places, here we should be celebrating people choosing to take part in scientific progress, not getting involved in ethnic or regional pissing contests.

  13. Piffle by koan · · Score: 1

    Another "because we have the cash" vanity project.

    --
    "If any question why we died, Tell them because our fathers lied."
  14. Space agency created in 2014 by Voice+of+satan · · Score: 1

    The UAE space agency has been created in 2014 and has invested more than 5 billions of dollars in various space industries.

  15. Way to go, UAE! by hey! · · Score: 4, Informative

    Seriously. Good for you.

    It sounds like you've got really interesting research goals for this mission, and I wish you great success.

    --
    Post may contain irony: discontinue use if experiencing mood swings, nausea or elevated blood pressure.
  16. if, and only if, they succeed by vikingpower · · Score: 1

    ...that will be the first useful thing done by Arabs-as-a-collective ever since the end of the Middle Ages.

    --
    Religous speak to God. Insane are spoken to by God. When all shut up, one can finally hear Shostakovich in peace
  17. Re:Women by JaredOfEuropa · · Score: 1

    Women in the UAE are allowed to drive, and can dress (more or less) as they would at home. On the other hand, if you (as a woman) get raped, do not report it! Chances are that you'll be charged with "extramarital sex", a serious offence, and with some other charges piled on top like consumption of alcohol in a public area. The UAE is actually quite liberal compared to most other countries in the area, but they aren't quite there yet.

    --
    If construction was anything like programming, an incorrectly fitted lock would bring down the entire building...
  18. Re:Arab knowledge by Hognoxious · · Score: 1

    So what? That was then, it's not now, and they've done fuck all since.

    P.S. And they didn't invent Arabic numbers, before anyone starts.

    --
    Confucius say, "Find worm in apple - bad. Find half a worm - worse."
  19. MIssion Accomplished by tomhath · · Score: 2

    (NASA Chief Charlie) Bolden said President Barack Obama had charged him with three things upon becoming NASA administrator.

    "One, he wanted me to help re-inspire children to want to get into science and math; he wanted me to expand our international relationships; and third, and perhaps foremost, he wanted me to find a way to reach out to the Muslim world and engage much more with dominantly Muslim nations to help them feel good about their historic contribution to science, math and engineering," Bolden said.

    The Prez might get a Nobel Prize in Physics from this mission.

  20. does this mean by dwpbike · · Score: 1

    they are tired of us using all their oil?

  21. Re:Arab knowledge by PPH · · Score: 1

    It's pretty well accepted that Archimedes developed calculus and wrote about it. And then his manuscript was erased by Christians so the parchment could be used for a bible.

    History is full of Greek, Arab and other discoveries and sharing of discoveries between cultures interspersed with religious nut-jobs stepping in and messing things up, either intentionally or through ignorance.

    --
    Have gnu, will travel.
  22. Astronomy repeats itself by requerdanos · · Score: 1

    > "It will... help scientists figure out how water gradually escaped from Mars over a long time scale."

    Early astronomers assumed that the Sun, stars, and planets revolved around the Earth and devoted time and study to figuring out how, in what manner. They didn't succeed because the Earth isn't the center of the solar system.

    Now, some scientists are assuming that Mars had a bunch of water that gradually escaped over a long time scale, and they're proposing to devote time and study to figuring out "how."

    I've got an idea: Why not devote time and study to figure out "what" is going on, and not "how" assumptions can be bolstered? Just saying.

  23. "For scientific purposes." by Jack+Zombie · · Score: 1

    Science only? No military purposes?

    --
    "You should never doubt what nobody is sure about." -- Willy Wonka
  24. ICBMs were progress by foreverdisillusioned · · Score: 1

    I would like to share in this sort of optimism, but the simple fact is modern rocketry developed out of a desire for long range ballistic missiles and most of the other countries that have major space programs tend to be nuclear powers. I don't know offhand how difficult it would be for UAE to get their hands on enriched uranium, (or how difficult it would be for them to sell some large ballistic missiles to, say, Pakistan at some point down the road), but I would tentatively suggest that these details are worth keeping a close eye on as we applaud the official/stated goal of scientific exploration.

    1. Re:ICBMs were progress by foreverdisillusioned · · Score: 1

      I didn't say you were Arabs and I know you don't have ICBMs (yet.) However, the anti-Israel movement has already done very well appealing to other non-Arab Muslims (particularly the Persians) and unlike Iran it doesn't seem like Pakistan is becoming more liberal or less religiously obsessed anytime soon. The Taliban and other fundamentalist groups seem more focused on local rule, but that can change, particularly as the situation re: US foreign interference in your government (read: the billions of dollars in bribes we spend to try to keep less-insane--although just as corrupt--people in power) and/or the rivalry with India evolves over time.

  25. Habitat trumph science: Arab backyard Mars-like by viking80 · · Score: 1

    What arabs lack in sceitific strength, they have in life experience. Mars is a dry desert, and nobody knows dry desert better than arabs. NASA has to travel far, and no NASA engineer has any experience with climate similar to Mars.
    Arabs just need to exit their door, and it is like being on Mars. Huge advantage over both USA as well as Europe, Russia and China.

    What is the most complex item you can buy in your local store manufactures in an arab country?

    --
    don't cut it off www.mgmbill.org
  26. How? by dcw3 · · Score: 1

    Will it have one hump, or two?

    --
    Just another day in Paradise
  27. Now waiting for Qatar to announce a probe in 2019 by cornelius1729 · · Score: 1

    Not that there's any rivalry between them and UAE, of course.

    --
    1729 = 9^3 + 10^3 = 1^3 + 12^3
  28. Re:Let's call a spade a spade by dave420 · · Score: 1

    You say you are not conflating Arabs and Islam, but then go on and do just that. And throw in Pakistan too, for good measure. It isn't crypto-racism, it's mindless, ignorant, scared-shitless-by-the-big-scary-world xenophobia. It's not reasonable to think ICMBs have anything to do with this, unless you are a xenophobe, I guess.

  29. Re:Arab knowledge by PPH · · Score: 1

    but no one thinks that he developed anything that you would see in a modern calculus course.

    This is true. But then it was only a few weeks in my high school calculus class to get from infintesimals to full blown differentials and integrals. And this is what we credit to Leibniz in the 17th century. So yes, there's more to calculus than that. But from Leibniz to now took 400 years. Archimedes did sugest the idea of infintesimals. So it looks like that idea sat in the dustbin of learning for 2000 years before Leibniz picked it up again.

    --
    Have gnu, will travel.