Slashdot Mirror


Slashdot Asks: How Do You Navigate Your Smartphone?

There are many different ways to navigate a smartphone. Some devices employ capacitive touch navigation buttons in favor of on-screen navigation buttons for the back, home and overview commands. Others, such as the recently released Moto Z2 Force and Moto Z2 Play, feature a mini trackpad under the display that lets users navigate their device through a series of swipes (on-screen navigation buttons are used by default, but the option to use the "one button nav" mini trackpad can be enabled in the settings). The upcoming iPhone 8, for example, may feature a software bar in lieu of a physical/virtual home button, introducing new gesture controls for returning to the home screen and switching between apps.

How do you navigate your smartphone? Given the many different options available on the market, do you think there is one method of navigation that trumps the others, or is it a classic case of "different strokes for different folks?"

66 comments

  1. Windows Phone 8: Live tiles by DogDude · · Score: 1

    I use the live tiles set up on the home page of my Windows Phone. Super simple.

    --
    I don't respond to AC's.
    1. Re:Windows Phone 8: Live tiles by unixisc · · Score: 1

      Or you could swipe right & see the entire list of apps there

  2. What smartphone? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    I navigate with maps.

    1. Re:What smartphone? by hughbar · · Score: 1

      You forgot the obligatory 'you insensitive clod'. But seriously, I don't have a smartphone and live quite happily without 'apps' they are insecure, data-thieving, usually badly-written, unnecessary and break the 'universalist' philosophy of the web. As usual, when I comment on this, here's a list of possible permissions:

      ACCESS_LOCATION_EXTRA_COMMANDS ACCESS_NETWORK_STATE ACCESS_NOTIFICATION_POLICY ACCESS_WIFI_STATE BLUETOOTH BLUETOOTH_ADMIN BROADCAST_STICKY CHANGE_NETWORK_STATE CHANGE_WIFI_MULTICAST_STATE CHANGE_WIFI_STATE DISABLE_KEYGUARD EXPAND_STATUS_BAR GET_PACKAGE_SIZE INSTALL_SHORTCUT INTERNET KILL_BACKGROUND_PROCESSES MODIFY_AUDIO_SETTINGS NFC READ_SYNC_SETTINGS READ_SYNC_STATS RECEIVE_BOOT_COMPLETED REORDER_TASKS REQUEST_IGNORE_BATTERY_OPTIMIZATIONS REQUEST_INSTALL_PACKAGES SET_ALARM SET_TIME_ZONE SET_WALLPAPER SET_WALLPAPER_HINTS TRANSMIT_IR UNINSTALL_SHORTCUT USE_FINGERPRINT VIBRATE WAKE_LOCK WRITE_SYNC_SETTINGS

      and 'Dangerous' permissions :
      READ_CALENDAR WRITE_CALENDAR CAMERA READ_CONTACTS WRITE_CONTACTS GET_ACCOUNTS ACCESS_FINE_LOCATION ACCESS_COARSE_LOCATION RECORD_AUDIO READ_PHONE_STATE CALL_PHONE READ_CALL_LOG WRITE_CALL_LOG ADD_VOICEMAIL USE_SIP PROCESS_OUTGOING_CALLS BODY_SENSORS SEND_SMS RECEIVE_SMS READ_SMS RECEIVE_WAP_PUSH RECEIVE_MMS READ_EXTERNAL_STORAGE WRITE_EXTERNAL_STORAGE
      Of course, all apps programmers are really careful with all these.

      --
      On y va, qui mal y pense!
    2. Re:What smartphone? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That's neat. I own a laptop so I don't need one.

    3. Re:What smartphone? by K.+S.+Kyosuke · · Score: 1

      Sounds like a Catch-22 situation if you stop needing a laptop upon acquiring it.

      --
      Ezekiel 23:20
  3. Navigate by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    with a Nutscrape Navigator

  4. The BEST way. by damnbunni · · Score: 1

    I use the keyboard, damnit.

  5. A Keyboard? Pfftt. Luxury by rsilvergun · · Score: 3, Funny

    I use punch cards the way God and Nature intended.

    --
    Hi! I make Firefox Plug-ins. Check 'em out @ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/youtube-mp3-podcaster/
    1. Re: A Keyboard? Pfftt. Luxury by aliquis · · Score: 1

      I just wiggle my magical probing stick until I find the right one.

    2. Re:A Keyboard? Pfftt. Luxury by K.+S.+Kyosuke · · Score: 1

      I use punch cards the way God and Nature intended.

      You mean as fashionable bookmarks?

      --
      Ezekiel 23:20
  6. How do you navigate your smartphone? by turkeydance · · Score: 1

    put it in my pocket and look out the window of my car.

    1. Re:How do you navigate your smartphone? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Keeping eye for law enforcement during a phone navigation session is indeed advisable.

    2. Re:How do you navigate your smartphone? by Mr+D+from+63 · · Score: 4, Funny

      WTF? How do you navigate your smartphone? That's your fucking question? Texas is flooding, the earth is going to shit, and your biggest question is how to use a freaking product that my grandma can use (in her grave)? I navigate the damn thing with the freakin GUI provided and don't really GARA if someone else is swiping while I'm typing, or wiping.

      Let's ponder the truly hard questions in life;
      How do you turn off your lights at night?
      How do you deal with seeds in seedless watermelons?
      How do you decide how long to heat food in your microwave?

    3. Re:How do you navigate your smartphone? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Thinly veiled attempt by some diapershit at getting some free "market research".

      I'm sure plenty of commenters will happily write multi-page screeds.

    4. Re:How do you navigate your smartphone? by thegarbz · · Score: 2

      How do you turn off your lights at night?

      With great difficulty. You see the electrician who wired this apartment has two sets of two double pole switches at opposite sides of the living room. The idea was that each set could independently control the two lights in the living room, but the problem is the lights in the living room are wired up in parallel. This leads to 16 possible combinations of switches of which only 4 are capable of turning off the lights in the living room in addition to the problem that I am unable to control both lights independently.

      Texas is on the other side of the world and my little piece of the earth is doing just fine. But what really grinds my gears, ... the 1 in 4 chance that I fail to turn off the lights at night.

  7. Easy... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    On my Android phone I swipe left to ignore a call or swipe right to answer one. The rest of the crud isn't used except for family texts.

    1. Re:Easy... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why don't you just buy a dumbphone then? It doesn't sound like you use any of the smartphone functionality and a basic phone would be cheap and get three times the battery life of the Android.

    2. Re:Easy... by Fly+Swatter · · Score: 1

      I wanted to replace my motorola flip phone with another flip, but the choices were junk and more junk. Finally just gave up and bought a cheap windows phone. Yea it's obsolete already but still better made than every current flip phone.

      Also I am glad I didn't choose an android phone. My android tablet doesn't like to take my taps, i get the animation when I press but then it just ignores my finger half the time like nothing happened. Do I have a fat thumb? maybe. If my phone acted like that it would have gone back. A phone needs to be reliable, my experience with android doesn't give me that feeling.

    3. Re:Easy... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hey Grandpa, there are some kids back home on your lawn that need chasing. Fire up up the Duesenberg and get back there.

    4. Re: Easy... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      If your mama fucked a slim thumbed man, this conversation wouldn't be taking place.

      I blame her.

  8. Finger by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I finger it.

  9. I talk to it by El+Cubano · · Score: 1
  10. I organize it & use search by ThomK · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I was in repair shop once (because my iPhone's phone jack wouldn't take the stereo mini cable I was trying to stick into it anymore. I thought something was bent inside the hole, turned out it was just jammed with pocket lint.) and the clerk did something I now do every day.

    She took my phone, and instead of hunting for the settings icon, she swiped down, hit the letters "se" and the settings icon presented itself! She f*cking searched for it! I do that with spotlight on my mac all the time, I don't know why it didn't occur to me to do that on my iPhone, but I sure do now.

    So to answer the question:
    1. I try to delete apps aggressively, that helps.
    2. I put the most used stuff on the first page, leaving empty space if that's required.
    3. I group games together and tuck them away.
    4. I search for stuff I use once in a while.

    Its an ongoing process. The problem is there's a long tail graph of usage of apps. My iMessage, phone and Skype apps get used a ton, my sense app and a few games get used once a day, settings etc, once a week and a hand full once a month. The remainder probably need to be deleted.

    The iOS app/interface manager isn't that great. Sure I have full control, but damn, help me out a bit. Doesn't the windows phone sort apps by usage? That would be amazingly helpful. So would a notification of what apps should probably be deleted.

    I don't want that much fine grained control & it's stressful to see all that crap on your phone.

    --

    TK

    1. Re: I organize it & use search by Dixie_Flatline · · Score: 3, Informative

      iOS 11 will automatically delete old apps that havenâ(TM)t been used in a long time if you ask it to. Itâ(TM)ll keep the data around, and you can just restore it from the App Store if you want it again

    2. Re:I organize it & use search by rwa2 · · Score: 1

      Yeah, I'm something of a minimalist. Here's my homescreen on Android 7:
      https://i.imgur.com/xswIxHi.pn...

      Just a big ol' analog clock and my most commonly accessed apps from the ground up.
      I prefer groups to screens, as much as I like the background scrolling animation. But even then there are just two groups for "Google" and "Nav" apps.
      There's just one more screen for widgets: the Google New/Weather ticker, the calendar, and a gTasks Todo list. That's pretty much it.

      Previously I had additional groups for:
      * Utils: calculators, periodic tables, and other stuff
      * Media: youtube, VLC, and other "gallery" type stuff
      * Net: SSH, VNC, SMB clients, etc.

      But now I just look up the rest of that stuff up in the alphabetical list or via search. It does get a little bit annoying when the app icons are too similar in appearance, but \_()_/

    3. Re: I organize it & use search by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I canÃ(TM)t &amp donÃ(TM)t want to believe your keyboard doesnÃ(TM)t send out the correct code for "'" (') = Ã(TM).

  11. I don't have one by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    You insensitive clod!

    1. Re: I don't have one by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Me neither!

      Sent from my iPhone.

  12. Moto G5 Plus here by willoughby · · Score: 1

    It's not really a trackpad but instead a fingerprint reader which also recognizes just two rudimentary gestures - touch for home button, touch & hold for fingerprint reader, swipe left to go back and swipe right for recent apps. But, still, I like that in normal use I don't need to wear out a physical button. Something else will break, anyway, I suppose.

    1. Re:Moto G5 Plus here by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I also have a G5 plus, and I purposely chose not to enable that feature. I prefer just using the fingerprint button to turn on/off the screen since the back, home, and app list touchscreen buttons are directly above the fingerprint reader.

      p.s. I really wish the phone gave you all 10 fingerprints instead of just 5. I also wish there was a way to remove the google search bar. I've disabled it by disabling the Google app, but it's impossible to remove the bar from the UI unless you root your phone or replace the launcher app with someone else's spyware.

  13. Volume Up/Down by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    On Android the cursor control is so terrible I have to use Vol Up/Down remapped to cursor left/right in order to fix certain corrections. Sometimes autocorrect works and sometimes it pretends it doesn't even exist anymore. Sometimes the red underlines provide a drop down list and sometimes they don't. Android has like 4 types of autocorrect enabled at any given moment which makes textboxes slow down to a crawl and then they don't even kick in when you need them.

    How does text entry work so well on iOS and fail in so many ways on Android? I defected from iOS long ago but text entry is fondly remembered by comparison.

  14. Ass swipes.... by __aaclcg7560 · · Score: 1

    I was doing a PC refresh project that required getting underneath desks to set up the cable for the file transfer between old and new PCs. I had a touch screen smartphone that was getting wonky. Every time I put the smartphone in my back pocket and got underneath the desk, an ass swipe would call my boss. He would hear nothing but me grunting or farting from the hard work. That would happen four or five times a night. I had to leave the smartphone on my cart to prevent the ass swiping from happening.

    1. Re:Ass swipes.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      He would hear nothing but me grunting or farting from the hard work

      Only Slashdot's resident tub-of-lard "bicyclist linebacker with hundreds of pounds of solid muscle on his frame" would consider "bending over to stretch a cable from one computer to another under a desk" to be "hard work."

      For a guy who bikes everywhere and does 35 pound seated cable rows, I'd expect that you'd only have problems with rolling an office chair out of the way. THAT's pretty hard work.

    2. Re:Ass swipes.... by __aaclcg7560 · · Score: 1

      Only Slashdot's resident tub-of-lard "bicyclist linebacker with hundreds of pounds of solid muscle on his frame" would consider "bending over to stretch a cable from one computer to another under a desk" to be "hard work."

      The old Dell workstations weighed 40 pounds. The newer models weigh less than.

    3. Re:Ass swipes.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "The newer models weigh less than."

      Wow, what a bold stylistic writer you are, askance than.

    4. Re:Ass swipes.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The old Dell workstations weighed 40 pounds. The newer models weigh less than.

      Wow, if you think sliding 40 pounds a distance of 3 feet across a floor is hard work, how much agony are you in shifting your 360 pound bulk around all day long?

      Seriously - there is NOTHING in IT that remotely resembles hard physical labor.

    5. Re:Ass swipes.... by __aaclcg7560 · · Score: 1

      Seriously - there is NOTHING in IT that remotely resembles hard physical labor.

      How about unboxing 750 PCs and 1,500 monitors, disposing the packing material, deploying the new systems, and recycling the old systems?

      Moving 1,000+ new PCs and 2,000+ monitors, and all the old PCs and monitors, on carts for two city blocks in each direction?

      Or building out a data center with rows and rows of racks to fill out with equipment?

      Or having to move an empty server rack on wheels by yourself because you're a big guy (aka Mr. Muscles) and six skinny guys move the other one?

      Or did you think that the IT fairy just pulls all infrastructure technology out of her ass?

    6. Re:Ass swipes.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Oh, that explains your weight loss!

    7. Re:Ass swipes.... by __aaclcg7560 · · Score: 1

      Oh, that explains your weight loss!

      That explains why I have the most stupidest trolls following me on Slashdot.

    8. Re:Ass swipes.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      We're not the ones claiming we need four pairs of new pants for a ten pound weight loss, then gain weight on a "low carb diet", sugarpuff!

      We're also not the ones who somehow have the BMR of a 140 pound woman yet are a middle-aged blimp!

      So what's your next fantasy, IT Walter Mitty??

    9. Re:Ass swipes.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      " the most stupidest trolls"

      Wow! The most bestest English askance than.

    10. Re:Ass swipes.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      How about unboxing 750 PCs and 1,500 monitors, disposing the packing material, deploying the new systems, and recycling the old systems?

      Sorry, "opening boxes and throwing shit away" is hard physical labor? Were you holding 750 pcs up in the air simultaneously, while doing all this?

      Moving 1,000+ new PCs and 2,000+ monitors, and all the old PCs and monitors, on carts for two city blocks in each direction?

      Putting a bunch of light electronics on wheeled carts, and walking a couple hundred meters while pushing those wheeled carts? Really? Do you count "operating my lark mobility scooter" as hard physical labor too? You are literally describing "walking back and forth a few hundred meters at a time" as hard physical labor?

      Or building out a data center with rows and rows of racks to fill out with equipment?

      Literally the only "physical labor" part of that is racking the servers themselves - yes, lifting a 30-40 pound server a few feet in the air, and mounting it on rails requires a little bit of physical exertion. The rest is simple, natural, light movement.

      Or having to move an empty server rack on wheels by yourself because you're a big guy (aka Mr. Muscles) and six skinny guys move the other one?

      Pushing a 275 pound rack ON WHEELS over a flat, level surface is now hard physical labor? The other six guys didn't want to help you because you're an insufferable twat, not because they *had* to all move the other one.

      Or did you think that the IT fairy just pulls all infrastructure technology out of her ass?

      Bro, I've built out data centers. The latest datacenter we expanded into had somewhere north of 2800 servers that we racked and cabled in about a week, including moving the racks into place in our cage. I would consider NONE of that "hard physical labor" - I broke a sweat a few times, but I've worked harder playing a round of fucking golf. Get the fuck out with your "hard physical labor" claims. Levering your significant bulk up out of bed in the morning probably counts as "hard physical labor" to you.

    11. Re:Ass swipes.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      you sound bitter, sweet tits

    12. Re:Ass swipes.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      creimer, put some zing into your stupid comebacks. Right now I have six week old celery that's spicier than you.

  15. Loran-C by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Until they started turning it off.

  16. Physical Buttons by ShakaUVM · · Score: 1

    I've had bad experience with touchscreens. Right now, I have a software back button on the corner of my touchscreen and it just won't recognize any touches. Sometimes I can tap at it for five or ten seconds to get it to register, but most of the time is is just.... dead.

    However, my phone has a single hardware button, and that allows the phone to still be usable.

    This is the second phone this has happened on, so I think physical buttons are now a requirement for me.

    1. Re:Physical Buttons by skids · · Score: 1

      Yeah I am forced to get a new work phone more often than I want and have had to grit my teeth lately and go with the soft buttons due to other features. Really would prefer the haptics of a button with a contact behind it so I can feel it click and then know whether the phone is just being slow or it ignored my touches.

      As to TFA, I disable the lockscreen pin or whatever other trash and have it only wake up during a side-button press, to keep it from turning on the screen in my pocket, then I combine the camera and gallery icons into a single icon to prevent accidentally opening the camera. Then I tell it I'm working without a google account and never enter any persistant creds for anything, basically using it as a phone, camera and a read-mostly web browser. Use a real PC for email because if you don't at least SMS it is not urgent enough for my immediate attention. Kill and deinstall everything app I can get away with without rooting it. Hit up fdroid for a notepad app and file explorer both of which should come standard, install connectbot for the rare emergency and otherwise try to forget it is there. Oh yeah, and curse at how the camera app UI gets worse and worse every time I get a new one.

      My personal phone is still a flip, grandfathered into a $200/year pre-payed plan. Will be keeping that until it dies... it's almost a decade old and still runs many days on a single charge on the original battery.

  17. By yelling at it! by Mr.CRC · · Score: 4, Informative

    I navigate my Moto E go-phone mostly by yelling and screaming at it, threatening to toss it, and uttering lengthy expletives about the programmers who created its perplexing and idiotic UI.

    It took me a few weeks to figure out how to answer the damn thing. It's still unreliable, as hitting *anything* by accident instead of performing the correct touch gesture makes it leave the answering context. I had to look up the manual (yeah the freakin' *manual*) to learn how to answer my phone! You would think they could have printed a little "swipe that-a-way to answer phone -->" on the screen to give new operators a clue. But no... If you fail to answer it with the right gesture, then it provides a menu of options including everything EXCEPT "Answer the fucking phone." There is some way to get back to having a chance to answer it, but I forget what it is. Then of course it always turns on the camera as the side button activates it.

    It is a hideous thing!

    If I didn't have Linux for my PCs, I would be extremely unhappy with the computing world, because everything else is borderline unusable by comparison.

    I would rather just have a simple phone. Maybe with an .mp3 player feature. Of course, such a thing no longer exists :-(

  18. No by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I don't navigate my phone. My phone is not a ship.

    Then again, if you insist on metaphors, YOUR PHONE IS NAVIGATING YOU!!!

  19. How I navigate my phone. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Sometimes, I throw it against the wall when it freezes up, other times I fumble with it and drop it on the floor. Otherwise, I rub the glass surface with my fingers, like everyone else I know, hoping it doesn't freeze up. Anyway, were you expecting that I use a hammer and chisel?

  20. With my thumb by fox171171 · · Score: 1

    And sometimes a finger.

  21. Using the assistant by RhettLivingston · · Score: 1

    Even if I touch "home", it's just to hold it and bring the assistant up without saying "OK Google". I then say "open xxxxxx" where xxxxxx is any app on my phone and it does it - even if it is nowhere to be found as it often is on my spouse's phone (who hates icons covering the background).

    With the assistant, I do a lot now without even looking at my phone.

    More complicated things like sending messages have become "text xxxx to yyyy" followed by answering "yes" when it verifies whether I'd like to send it - or "take me to xxxx". And with driving directions, I've found I can use common names almost all of the time now - addresses are rarely necessary.

  22. With the trackpad, real keyboard and "toolbelt" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I'm keeping this blackberry classic until it explodes, then I'll get a flip phone.
    I do have an android nexus they gave me for work, it sucks balls.

  23. Siri by tsa · · Score: 3, Funny

    I use Siri for all my phone navigation. You learn a lot about the world that way, because most of the times she doesn't understand me.

    --

    -- Cheers!

  24. As little as possible. by CptLoRes · · Score: 1

    I am MUCH more efficient on a real computer.

  25. Regular touchscreen, swipe by Qbertino · · Score: 1

    I use the touchscreen, but I also use swipe. Way easier and faster than typing (most of the time) but can suck if I mix English with German in one textarea.

    --
    We suffer more in our imagination than in reality. - Seneca
  26. I nominate this as the worst question ever on Slas by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    In 10+ years I have been lurking around these parts of the internet I struggle to remember a more absurd question. What's next? What finger do you use when turning on your computer? Do you use the same when turning it off? I use the middle by the way. Same finger the senior editor that approved this question should be shown.

  27. Richard by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I poke my cock at it because my fingers are too fat.

  28. What other options are there? by XB-70 · · Score: 1

    I use a Blackberry Thumb Operated Trackwheel on my 7290, you insensitive clod!!

    --
    *** Don't be dull.***
  29. I don't. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I don't because I made the conscious decision to never get one because they are life-consuming wastes of money and time.
    If people want me, they can e-mail me or FUCK off.
    Life is good.

    I do have a Tablet, though. I use a stylus like any sensible person. Touch-screen is the 2nd most inferior interaction right behind motion-based gestures. The only useful component of touch-screens is gestures for doing stuff like zooms, rotations, pans, etc. Basic interaction is atrocious. Typing with thumbs? Hell out of here with that noise. No amount of magical keyboards make that enjoyable.

  30. Soft buttons? Never by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I need to be sure that the basic functions are always accessible, so the next time an app pukes up a fullscreen ad I can just break out of it and delete the app. Of course app developers don't like that. They like soft buttons that they can disable.

  31. MG5 by jf_moreira · · Score: 1

    Have a Moto G5, I navigate using the finger sensor. One quick touch, main screen. Swipe to the right, shows background running tasks, swipe to the left closes or return to the prior screen. That's all, folks!