Slashdot Mirror


User: Mostly+a+lurker

Mostly+a+lurker's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
1,071
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 1,071

  1. Large charities on Philanthropy For Hackers · · Score: 4, Insightful

    In general, I think the point about large charities being mostly about sustaining themselves is correct. However, they have connections that can often make them the only (albeit imperfect) organizations that can mobilize relief after major disasters. Further, some specific large charities provide unique services that smaller organizations, however well run, cannot replicate. An example is the Red Cross and their monitoring of prisoners of war. I also greatly respect one or two large charities. Médecins Sans Frontières (Doctors Without Borders) does tremendous work, such as fighting the ebola outbreak for months before the WHO did anything effective.. Generalizations can have limited validity, but must not be taken too far

  2. Unsuccessful experiments still have value on Controversial Trial of Genetically Modified Wheat Ends In Disappointment · · Score: 3, Insightful

    It is easy to explain why an experiment failed after the event, but that does not mean the result was obvious. This is a case in point. Had the experiment succeeded, cheaper, safer food with reduced environmental impact would have been possible. Sadly, it failed. Now, we need to look at other approaches.

  3. Re:Static on IT Pros Blast Google Over Android's Refusal To Play Nice With IPv6 · · Score: 1

    With a mobile device (which most Android devices are) that are continually switching between networks, static IP addresses are not ideal. The "static" IP address (for most protocols) needs to be routable. This means the address must change when switching networks. Support for DHCPv6 is arguably the easiest way to do this. Having routers need to recognize when random addresses are generated inside their networks and correctly route them without security concerns is not ideal.

  4. Data collection for other purposes? on Dallas Police Falsely Credit TrapWire System For Arrests · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Apart from the obvious stench of corrupt commercial dealings, we should not forget that data collection by law enforcement has not always been for crime fighting purposes. Recall, for instance, J Edgar Hoover's uses for such data.

  5. Re: I'm afraid! Please send hugs! on Patriot Act Spy Powers To Expire As Rand Paul Blocks USA Freedom Act Vote · · Score: 2

    My post was intended as flippant, but I do know the full story.

    The woman was treated normally by the United flight attendant. Rude service by United is the norm, and excusing it by claims that it is necessary for security par for the course. However, the argument that a young woman armed with a cola could be dangerous was pretty ridiculous. The better airlines provide, not only cans of soda, but even small bottles of wine. I am unaware that these have ever been used for terrorist purposes.

    She was upset, posted about it on her Facebook page, and responded to media enquiries when the story went viral. Was there any Islamophobia? I think at least one of the passengers telling her to "shut the f--k up" was probably motivated by an antipathy to Islam. I certainly would not speak that way to any young woman.

    You are quite right that the story has been blown out of proportion. That said, many people exhibit a quite irrational fear and hatred of Islam. The vast majority of Muslims are normal folk whose dress code may or may not be old fashioned.

  6. Re:I'm afraid! Please send hugs! on Patriot Act Spy Powers To Expire As Rand Paul Blocks USA Freedom Act Vote · · Score: 2

    You are right to be concerned. Only Saturday, a young female student on a United flight tried to lay her hands on a can of cola. The flight attendant had been alerted to the danger (no doubt as a result of the Patriot Act provisions) and prevented the woman arming herself, storming the cockpit and flying the plane into the rebuilt World Trade Center. Who will monitor the intentions of these desperate terrorists if the Patriot Act provisions lapse?

    Seriously, the administration would prefer the provisions are renewed as it reduces the number of acts they carry out illegally. In reality, however, they will continue doing what they like, as they have been for decades. No prosecution for their illegal actions is possible, because the evidence of wrongdoing is classified for security reasons.

  7. Couple of observations on Black Hole Plays Pool With Plasma · · Score: 1

    In any decent analogy, the black hole ought to be a pocket if playing pool. Perhaps, they should have compared the behavior to one of those billiard games played on tables with no pockets.

    My other comment is that BH is a really slow player. I am not particularly speedy myself, but playing since 1992 and not yet finished a single frame ... jeesh!

  8. Windows for Workgroups on 25 Years Today - Windows 3.0 · · Score: 1

    I had limited exposure to Windows 3.0 (and 3.1). From a support angle, it was mostly a matter of it worked or it didn't (give or take memory limits). Windows for Workgroups (3.1 and 3.11) on the other hand holds many memories for me, almost all horrendous. To this day, I still do not understand why it would sometimes work Monday and Thursday, but simply refuse to network Tuesday and Wednesday. The hours I spent trying to make that garbage work ...

  9. Re:Why not just... on Ask Slashdot: Best Way To Solve a Unique Networking Issue? · · Score: 1

    Correctly spoken, TCP and UDP are two completely separate transport layers available within the Internet protocol suite. When people talk about TCP/IP, they should be talking about using the TCP transport layer and IP (v4 and/or v6) internet layer. This does not include UDP. Of course, as with most complex technology, the wrong terminology is often used. I am sure you can find references where the "Internet protocol suite" is called "TCP/IP" and all the distinctions between different layers and protocols confusingly blurred. That does not make such terminology technically correct, and it certainly does not promote correct understanding. Wikipedia actually has a superb and very readable description of the Internet protocol suite and all the different components that are currently part of it.

  10. Probably small static battery powered devices on Ask Slashdot: After We're Gone, the Last Electrical Device Still Working? · · Score: 1

    I doubt the ones that immediately occur to me will be the winners. However, there are smoke detectors guaranteed to work for over a decade, and there is a pacemaker with a minimum lifespan of 14 years. Some digital watches are also 10+ years. Tadiran batteries are supposedly good for 40 years in some applications (remote monitoring devices?)

  11. Re:Sororities on Sorority Files Lawsuit After Sacred Secrets Posted On Penny Arcade Forums · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Why do sororities even exist?

    The tribal instinct remains strong. Human beings tend to feel more secure when they can form themselves into groups with whom they identify and that exclude those with whom they do not identify. The "secret rituals" are one of the key ways of reinforcing this feeling of being in a cohesive tribe, protected against intrusion from outside.

    Some fairly modern tribes, such as country clubs and gentlemen's clubs, are now legally constrained in their ability to exclude members they feel uncomfortable with. Criminal tribes, like the mafia and yakuza are typically particularly careful about the members they recruit, and have many rituals designed to inspire loyalty and the feeling of exclusivity.

    Regardless of type, the instinct we have to form ourselves into tribes remains, long after it outlasted its useful protective purpose in primitive societies.

  12. Plausible versus implausible threats on VA Tech Student Arrested For Posting Perceived Threat Via Yik Yak · · Score: 1

    The article's assumption that the key difference between a Dec 7 and Apr 28 threat is passage of time is simply wrong. Another Virginia Tech shooting is plausible. A single mentally disturbed individual is quite capable of carrying it out. It is rather unlikely that any anonymous poster has a bunch of aircraft carriers handy to launch a new attack on Pearl Harbor.

  13. Re:"Drama of mental illness" on Child Psychotherapist: Easy and Constant Access To the Internet Is Harming Kids · · Score: 3, Informative

    the rate of youth suicides haven't [sic] gone up

    I cannot find a reliable recent source on this. However, older data suggests that the suicide rates for older people has been going down, but there is an uptick in rates for younger people. For instance, see Suicide rates by age from American Foundation for Suicide Prevention (based on CDC figures)

  14. Re:incredulity != evidence on Greenpeace Co-Founder Declares Himself a Climate Change Skeptic · · Score: 1

    ... anthropogenic global warming is not a grave threat to the planet and that climate change is being used as a scare tactic ...

    Sure, in overall terms, global warming is not a grave threat to the planet. It is probably only slightly more dangerous than a catastrophic meteor impact. Apart from some coastal areas, the fundamental shape of the continents will remain pretty much in place. If you do not care that most current animal species (including our own) will not be part of the picture, there is really nothing to worry about.

  15. Faster rate of scientific progress on Scientific Study Finds There Are Too Many Scientific Studies · · Score: 1

    As progress in most scientific fields occurs at an ever faster rate, it is logical that previous research is more quickly supplanted by more relevant recent papers. Are we supposed to be surprised by this phenomenon?

  16. Re:Budget Cuts on Argonne National Laboratory Shuts Down Online Ask a Scientist Program · · Score: 1

    Using the WayBackMacine to archive the site is risky. Recognize that one line added to the robots.txt at any point in the future can render all the content inaccessible (at least) and possibly cause it to be deleted.

    I am quite surprised IBM, Microsoft, Google or one of the other big organizations has not picked this up.

  17. Re:Budget Cuts on Argonne National Laboratory Shuts Down Online Ask a Scientist Program · · Score: 1

    Using the WayBackMachine for this is risky. All it takes is one line added to the robots.txt at any point in the future, and archive.org will make the content inaccessible (at least), possibly delete it.

  18. Not mouses or mice on Ask Slashdot: Where Can You Get a Good 3-Button Mouse Today? · · Score: 1

    According to the authority Mr Jinks, the correct plural is "meeces"

  19. A pessimistic view on AI Experts Sign Open Letter Pledging To Protect Mankind From Machines · · Score: 5, Insightful

    AI is going to be used by those in power (mainly government, security agencies and military) to extend their power further.Unfortunately, humans are genetically programmed to select leaders who aggressively seek to expand the influence of their own group and of themselves. This was an important survival instinct for ancient tribes. It now contains the seeds of our total destruction, and the scientists will be powerless to prevent it.

  20. Why migrate? on UK Government Department Still Runs VME Operating System Installed In 1974 · · Score: 1

    I assume these applications are not running on the original hardware. They should still be working fine on current Fujitsu mainframes. There may be a valid reason to rewrite part or all of the applications because additional functionality is needed but, too often, money is wasted replacing systems (especially mainframe systems) that still meet most of the enterprise's needs, Often, "more flexible reporting" is used as an excuse for hugely expensive rewrites, when a periodic data extract into a separate data warehouse can meet the need much better, much more cheaply, and without disruption to existing production systems.

  21. Rolaids? on The Search For Starivores, Intelligent Life That Could Eat the Sun · · Score: 1

    Some people find Mexican food hard to tolerate. This thing would need some *really* powerful indigestion medicine after that meal.

  22. Re:Presumption of innocence on Indiana Court Rules Melted Down Hard Drive Not Destruction of Evidence · · Score: 1

    In a US civil ,action there is no bias towards either side. The case is decided on a preponderance of the evidence. I am sympathetic towards file sharers. I believe they provide a valuable service that is usually legal. That said, I do not think the defendant in this case should just be allowed to get rid of potential evidence without court permission, regardless of whether he thinks it will be useful. My sense is that either the judge did not understand the technology, or he thought the infraction was limited and should not saddle the defendant with a huge default judgment. [I hope that this does not eventually get overturned on appeal.]

  23. She is an advisor on US CTO Tries To Wean the White House Off Floppy Disks · · Score: 2

    The impact she can have depends on the attitude of the President and those around him.

  24. Re:So what exactly is it blocking? on Gmail Reportedly Has Been Blocked In China · · Score: 1

    Wouldn't it be easier to filter outbound packets destined for Gmail's SMTP servers and prevent Chinese email users from sending email to Gmail users? (This is an honest question.)

    I think you mean Google's MX servers (the remote end when sending email through SMTP). If so, in a word, "yes", much easier, assuming users are using SMTP servers based in China. Indeed, you could simply prevent the connections from ever taking place, simulating authentication errors.

  25. Re:So what exactly is it blocking? on Gmail Reportedly Has Been Blocked In China · · Score: 1

    Since SMTP allows forwarding by other servers this would require deep packet inspection.

    If you mean the SMTP protocol supports chained delivery routes, then I do not think this is true (at least not used in practice). However, business customers of Gmail (at least) can request that a different SMTP server than Google's be used for outgoing mail, and (of course) anyone using an external mail client can send using any SMTP server they like.