Slashdot Mirror


eMac Video Upgrade

Bri3D writes "I've got an eMac G4/700, with a GeForce2 220 32MB video card. The video card is great for everyday use, but woefully slow for gaming. I looked for a method to replace the video card, and found these pages about eMac disassembly, but no information on if the video is upgradeable or even seperate from the motherboard. Does anyone have information on replacing the video card on an eMac?"

81 comments

  1. obvious answer by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    did you look at the pictures of the disassembly? there is no way you're replacing it, it's almost surely integrated on the mainboard.

    if you didn't want such a slow video card then don't buy an emac, and if you want to game don't buy an apple computer period.

    1. Re:obvious answer by astrodawg · · Score: 5, Informative
      While Windows undeniably has more games, contrary to what many will try to tell you, the Mac has more than a few as well.

      http://www.apple.com/games/

    2. Re:obvious answer by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What you really meant to say was "if you didn't want such a slow video card then don't buy an emac, and if you want to play crappy games don't buy an apple computer period".

      One of the benefits of the Mac is the good software. Any 12 year old that codes will write for Windows and market his silly game or database template through the local Safeway, usually on a wire rack next to the National Enquirer, with all the other loser garbage (ooooh a bowling league template and only $5 and on a CD yet!!!). The games that do actually become popular make it to the Mac world and we don't have to search through all the muck to find the occasional gold nugget.

      I won't say that there hasn't been bad Mac software but it's much less common than in the Windows world.

    3. Re:obvious answer by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      two words

      half life

    4. Re:obvious answer by noewun · · Score: 4, Funny

      If you didn't spend so much of time your time playing video games, you'd have an entire life.

      --
      I am a believer of momentum and curves.
    5. Re:obvious answer by bedouin · · Score: 1

      I'm surprised more people haven't been talking about the recent Spy Hunter remake. I thought it would be a lame game at first, but it's actually pretty cool.

  2. Nope... by PrimeWaveZ · · Score: 5, Informative

    I'm looking right now, and short of a soldering iron and God's good graces, it is definitely a no go.

  3. Here it is by BoomerSooner · · Score: 4, Funny

    Upgrade

    Unfortunately this is the easiest path. BTW What games? I play NWN on my iBook 900 w/32MB FX card and it runs great, not to mention Quake III.

    1. Re:Here it is by Bizzarobot · · Score: 1

      "iBook 900 w/32MB FX card..."
      Huh? Where did you pick up an iBook with an FX card in it? Apple says: ATI Mobility Radeon 7500 with 32MB of DDR SDRAM

    2. Re:Here it is by BoomerSooner · · Score: 1

      FX == graphics

    3. Re:Here it is by bedouin · · Score: 1

      My Quicksilver came with a 32mb Radeon 7500. It's been fine for most games until Unreal Tournament 2003 came out. My Ti Geforce should be here some time next week . . .

    4. Re:Here it is by martingunnarsson · · Score: 2, Informative

      FX!=graphics GFX==graphics

      --
      Martin
  4. you're stuck by Bizzarobot · · Score: 5, Informative

    Apple Discussion Board says the only mac you can replace the video card on is a tower.

    1. Re:you're stuck by York+the+Mysterious · · Score: 1

      Or a cube

      --

      Tim Smith - Ramblings from Nerd Land
  5. Good news or the bad news? by Elwood+P+Dowd · · Score: 5, Funny

    Short answer: No

    Long answer: No

    In summary: No

    --

    There are no trails. There are no trees out here.
    1. Re:Good news or the bad news? by bsharitt · · Score: 3, Funny

      So I can't replace to videocard?

    2. Re:Good news or the bad news? by Alan+Partridge · · Score: 1

      it doesn't HAVE a videoCARD

      --
      That was classic intercourse!
  6. Pudge - Pull this? by LookSharp · · Score: 1, Flamebait

    I think the article was a PC troll trying to point out that all-in-one Macs of the past 5 years are not video-upgradable.

    1. Re:Pudge - Pull this? by dead_penguin · · Score: 3, Funny

      I think the article was a PC troll trying to point out that all-in-one Macs of the past 5 years are not video-upgradable.

      And he was consipiring with other trolls, setting them up to use the "There are no games for the Mac!" line.

      --

      It's only software!
    2. Re:Pudge - Pull this? by Wyatt+Earp · · Score: 2, Informative

      The first iMac could have a Voodoo 2 card put in the seriously unsupported expansion slot.

      The G3 All-In-One box (education and government only) which I have has 3 PCI slots and works great with a Radeon card for a second display.

    3. Re:Pudge - Pull this? by wilko11 · · Score: 1

      I run the website that was linked in the story, and I did receive an email with the same question around the same time as the story went up. I cannot confirm whether my correspondant and Bri3D are one and the same, but to me it looks genuine.

    4. Re:Pudge - Pull this? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Except for the Rev A and B iMacs which had that small PCI (mezzanine I believe it was called) Slot. Remember the Voodoo2 card you could get called the gamewizard... I think that's what it was called... but yeah other than that...

    5. Re:Pudge - Pull this? by Bri3D · · Score: 1

      We are indeed the same person.

    6. Re:Pudge - Pull this? by Bri3D · · Score: 1

      The first iMac's expansion was called the Mezzanine Port, and was not suppported by Apple in any way("For development use only," they claimed). The Voodoo card is not sold anymore, but Griffin still makes a device called the iPort that gives the iMac a serial port, etc. In this comment iMac means the first generation of the non flat-panel iMac. This version can be identified by the tray-loading CD-ROM drive and an IR port on the left speaker.

    7. Re:Pudge - Pull this? by baldass · · Score: 1

      I have a g3 allinone, the beige jobby. I used to run 2 monitors while I was borrowing a nice 128mb video card from school..and the built in monitor runs off another pci video card... so you can upgrade some allinone macs. just not imacs/emac... maybe try dreamware's firewire to agp converter. (i made that one up, it's not a real product)

  7. Specs by pagercam2 · · Score: 2, Informative

    Spec's don't list PCI or AGP slot so doesn't look like upgrading is an option. Have you tried changing settings??? Often there are some compatability controls that can make things better. The graphics processor is realatively recent so it should be decent but not great at games, often more memory is more of a issue try increasing ram, it makes everything faster and so even if it doesn't improve game play the machine will be more fun to use.

  8. it has a really cool by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    looking carborator

  9. macpearl developer? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    He has a little blog about being on the open source project(click on byline)......? hmmm. a little perplexing? Is this why open source seems so hobbyist?
    Chris, do you really contribute? No offense, but 'cummon.
    The E in eMac was for education because of the low pricetag/G4 w/altivec.
    The latest games will be wasted on anything less capable than the G5 from now on.
    Before everyone gets pissy note: latest......from now on. Who would have it any other way?

    oh yeah...
    http://www.pudge.net
    read his last blog on 6-4-03
    what can I say? What is X.

  10. Woefully slow? by MalleusEBHC · · Score: 4, Funny

    What games are you playing where your computer is "woefully slow"? I game regularly on my Cube (450 MHz G4 with a stock Rage 128 and 1 GB RAM), and I'm still able to play everything, save UT2k3 which is just a little too slow. Ghost Recon, Jedi Knight II, and Warcraft 3 run just fine on it. Admittedly, it is not a speed demon, but it gets the job done with low settings.

    If you bought an eMac you shouldn't have expected that it would be awesome for gaming or upgradeable. Try upping your RAM, as I noticed a nice speed burst when I brought my Cube up to 1 GB. Other than that, you are more likely to harm your eMac by opening it then you are likely to help it by soldering on a new video card (if that is even possible).

    1. Re:Woefully slow? by Bri3D · · Score: 2, Informative

      I play Warcraft III at 640x480x16 with all Video settings at low on my eMac, and it gets about 6fps while battling small Creeps with about 5 units without using spells. The eMac has 640MB of RAM. This speed is totally unaccetable to me(maybe you are fine with it). Maybe there is a compatability problem between WcIII and the GeForce 2 220?

    2. Re:Woefully slow? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I can't help but feel that people with eMacs (with more than the base ram) have something else causing performance problems with Warcraft III. I've played through the first two campaigns on 1024x768x16, and have never had performance problems - and i generally have lots of little units.

    3. Re:Woefully slow? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I have the original TiBook. It has an ATI Rage M3 wit 8 MB VRAM. It's not even a Rage 128. It's sure as hell not capable of QuartzExtreme. I play WarCraft at 800x600x16 and get significantly better performance (more than double the frame rate) than what you're saying you get. It's got to be something other than the video card. Perhaps your 512 MB DIMM is slightly out-of-spec, or maybe it has a 3-cycle latency instead of a 2-cycle latency. Or maybe something is actually wrong with you VRAM, in which case, I hope you've got AppleCare.

      And I know it's been said already, but your video card is actually an integrated part of the main logic board, and is not upgradable. And you won't be able to get a newer logic board from an Apple-authorized service center, because they only swap like for like on service parts, and they're the only people who can legally get service parts.

  11. try again by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    http://www.lowendmac.com/imac/upgrades.html

    g4 even...

  12. MOD PARENT DOWN by Bri3D · · Score: 2, Insightful

    The writer of this comment was not informed, as Slashdot does not pull stories. Additionaly, I do own an eMac G4 and am very happy with it besides its unacceptable Warcraft III performance. There are games for the mac(LOTS!). As a note, newer eMacs have a better graphics card (ATI Radeon 7500) anyway.

    1. Re:MOD PARENT DOWN by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      I own an eMac with GeForce gfx, and I get excellent performance with Warcraft III - did you actually add more System ram to your computer - most consumer macs come terribly under endowed with system ram

  13. oh yeah by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    http://www.mcetech.com/sdimacsl.html
    http://www.t echnowarehousellc.com/g4upforslloi.htm l
    http://www.powerlogix.com/products2/index.html

    Give them some time...

    1. Re:oh yeah by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I find the best mac upgrades are from:

      http://www.dell.com
      http://www.gateway.c om

  14. emac/imac not very good for gaming by Enrique1218 · · Score: 1

    If it is an old game like quake 3, your emac should be ok. My PowerBook does a decent job with ati rage 128. However, for anything recent , you will have to look to spend more than what the emac costs. For gaming, I decided against the mac and went with a Dell for $1500. Its ok but even this doesn't do the games I play justice not to mention it crashes alot. Forget about emac, save your pennies for a G5 or high end PC.

    --
    You don't have to be smart to use a Mac, you just have to be smart enough to buy one
  15. What I am thinking?!!! by Enrique1218 · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Just get an Xbox

    --
    You don't have to be smart to use a Mac, you just have to be smart enough to buy one
  16. The problem with eMacs by dereklam · · Score: 1
    You're discovering the main problem with eMacs:

    it's monolithic.

    Ba-dum *bum*

  17. Directions by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    Step 1) Unplug all peripherals
    Step 2) Replace eMac

    I have done this before, and it is a proven and time-tested method that works.

    1. Re:Directions by el+stevo · · Score: 2, Funny

      step 3) ????? step 4) profit! i couldn't resist.

      --
      i'm sorry, i'm just sleep deprived... but bitter. yes. very bitter.
  18. Replacement Impossible by JM+Apocalypse · · Score: 5, Informative

    You may be able to replace the video card, depending on which eMac generation you have. The eMac LAN that I manage is what I would call first-generation, because when Apple released the eMac, they first fulfilled all the orders to educational institutions. Not until this was complete did they start shipping to the public. There is only one problem with this: The first-generation eMacs actually had on-board video acceleration, which made it impossible to replace. This was something that was on the original iMac, until Apple realized that it caused display problems and such, and moved this off-board. Of course, they brought this back on the first-generation eMacs, (arg!). You may not have the option. The only way to find out is to actually open up the eMac and look.

    --

    - - - - - - -
    Orppf urp mf y.ppcxn. yflcbi otcnnov C am yflcbi yr n.apb Ekrpatv (Dvorak -> Qwerty)
    1. Re:Replacement Impossible by Anonymous+Freak · · Score: 2, Informative

      Actually, even the iMacs don't have replaceable video. The very first generation (233MHz) had an undocumented/unsupported 'mezzanine' slot that an enterprising company managed to use as an interface for a VooDoo card, but that was really a video add-on, not an upgrade. (Only an external monitor was accelerated, and only accelerated video appeared on the external monitor; so the OS was internal, games were external.)

      --
      Another non-functioning site was "uncertainty.microsoft.com."
      The purpose of that site was not known.
  19. MOD PARENT UP! by HaloZero · · Score: 1

    +1, Insightful

    This is more often than not overlooked, and needs to be said more often.

    --
    Informatus Technologicus
  20. MOD PARENT UP by TwitchCHNO · · Score: 1

    lol

    --
    ___________________________
    I'm not a geek, but I play one on TV.
  21. Gaming experience? by MaxQuordlepleen · · Score: 4, Interesting

    OK, I get that the "can I upgrade video" question is dead, but I thought I'd ask another somewhat related question.

    Just what is gaming like on either eMac (the GeForce 2 and Radeon versions) ? I have a CRT iMac (600 Mhz G3 with the ATI Rage Pro) and I wonder if the upgrade would be worthwhile.. On the iMac, you can play Ghost Recon, Quake 3, Myth 2, with reasonable frame rates but UT (the original) is brutal and UT2K3 is a slide show.

    Anybody want to share their eMac gaming experiences?

    1. Re:Gaming experience? by Shishio · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Unreal Tournament and UT2K3 are both heavily processor based. Turning off textures and world complexity do very little to increase frame rates on my machines. I would recommend getting the best processor model of eMac you can, or getting a used PowerMac. A GeForce 2 or Geforce 4MX are both fine for those games. I don't have much experience with the Radeon cards, but I imagine that ones with 32 or more MB of ram on them would be fine.

      --
      Twelve fingers or one, its how you play. ~Gattaca (Vincent)
    2. Re:Gaming experience? by gdarklighter · · Score: 1

      Running on an 800 MHz eMac with 512 megs of RAM and a GeForce 2, here are my thoughts on some of the higher end games currently available on the Mac...

      JKII: Runs fine at 1024 x 768 (although you may get some slowdown at that resolution when you are a) swarmed by enemies or b) playing on Yavin 4 where the rain effects REALLY slow things down)

      WC3: Nothing bad to say here. Runs perfectly smooth at high resolution without slowdown.

      UT2K3 (demo, don't have full version yet): It's pretty...serioiusly, looks beautiful with very little slowdown.

      NWN (demo again): Another great-looking game.

      All in all, I've been pretty satisfied with my eMac as a gaming machine. Well, except for the speakers. But that's what headphones are for, right?

    3. Re:Gaming experience? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Never ever ever ever ever buy an eMac. The Main Video assembly WILL go out on it, and fairly quickly. It'll start with the shrinking screen of death.... then you'll have to pay $450 to replace it if it's not under warranty.

  22. War III performance on eMac by ajc · · Score: 1

    I have an eMac 800 with 1GB RAM, and Warcraft III is only just OK single player... if you try to play against multiple human opponents it will lag badly during battle (just when you need to select your hero you can't!).

    I have seen the same effect with a Duron or Athlon systems (Duron 900, Athlon 1000/133), so I suspect it's just that the game needs more CPU power.

    When you say excellent performance, do you mean single player, or multi player? If multi player, how did you achieve this???

    1. Re:War III performance on eMac by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Wow, plays great on my Celeron 700. Are macs really that slow?

    2. Re:War III performance on eMac by ajc · · Score: 1

      Hmm... tasty looking hook!

  23. What about a tower? by kwerle · · Score: 1

    I just got an ATI 9800 Pro for a PC and thought I'd give it a shot on a G4 tower.

    No dice - machine refused to boot. What gives?

    1. Re:What about a tower? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You have to flash the card with the mac version of it's ROM.

      Googling will reveal procedures for doing this with earlier Radeons. I would assume the 9800 would respond to the same treatment with appropriate 9800 ROM updaters.

    2. Re:What about a tower? by pi42 · · Score: 1

      I believe that Macs need a different BIOS on the vid card in order to boot. So theoretically, it should be possible to just flash a PC card with the Mac BIOS and ta-da.

      Here's a quick link I found Googling for Mac BIOS flashing on the R8500 -- I guess the PCB is actually sometimes different on the Mac too.

      I was looking into this awhile ago, trying to sell my r8500 to a friend with a G4 Cube, but it seemed too risky.

  24. Architectures by Baloo+Ursidae · · Score: 1

    Just because they both have PCI doesn't mean that i386 and PPC are the same in every respect. This is obvious to anybody who has sat down and thought about this for a minute.

    --
    Help us build a better map!
    1. Re:Architectures by kwerle · · Score: 1

      Just because they both have PCI doesn't mean that i386 and PPC are the same in every respect. This is obvious to anybody who has sat down and thought about this for a minute.

      Yeah, I was crazy to think this ATI AGP vid card would work with a Mac - which often uses ATI AGP vid cards.

      What was I thinking!?!?

      Oh, and a nit: I don't think i386's ever shipped with PCI slots, did they?

    2. Re:Architectures by Baloo+Ursidae · · Score: 1
      Just because it comes from the same manufacturer does not mean it will work across architectures. It's kind of like expecting a IBM BladeCenter HS20 to work in a Mac because IBM makes the PowerPC processors. Totally different architectures, same manufacturer.

      Nit picked: i386 was the first architecture to support PCI.

      --
      Help us build a better map!
    3. Re:Architectures by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      your saying to me that back in the day you could get a 386sx/dx with pci slots, if i remember correctly pci slots were not introduced till the 586 generation (compatible with the i386 generation but obviously not the same) might have even been 486 but definately not a 386

    4. Re:Architectures by Yarn · · Score: 1

      I have a 486 with pci slots, bought it as the price dropped when the P5 60MHz was released

      --
      -Yarn - Rio Karma: Excellent
    5. Re:Architectures by b1t+r0t · · Score: 1
      Mac video cards have always required a ROM on board to describe the capabilities of the card. In addition, I think they also require a big-endian access mode in either the PCI interface or video chipset.

      You could probably use a Mac video card in a PC, but (apparently) not the other way around.

      --

      --
      "Open source is good." - Steve Jobs
      "Open source is evil." - Microsoft
    6. Re:Architectures by Omega996 · · Score: 1

      The difference in the ROM between Macintosh boards and PC boards is for Open Firmware enumeration. Without that, no operating system that relies on Open Firmware to provide the list of hardware will work. Linux can access a lot of hardware (once it's booted) that isn't normally useable in a Mac ( Promise RAID cards, 3com NICs, etc.), but it won't be available until linux has booted from hardware that Open Firmware supports.

    7. Re:Architectures by mobileskimo · · Score: 1

      Actually, I believe they were in i386. It wasn't very popular, however I think that's when they were introduced.

      --
      "Last one in is a rotten goblin!" - Kepp
  25. Well, it can be done, sorta by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

    The original eMac has an nVidia NV11 soldered on the motherboard. This is pin compatible with the nVidia NV17b. If you can get one of these chips and don't mind working with surface mount components you should be OK as far the hardware is concerned.

    One problem, the Apple ROM on the eMac contains the Open Firmware driver for the NV11 which definitely will not work with an NV17 - it wasn't in production when the eMac ROMs were first released. However, current Apple motherboard ROMs still support the eMac and also have support for the NV17.

    1. Re:Well, it can be done, sorta by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Actually it should work, All nVidia chips are reverse compatable with drivers. This has something to do with governement contracts. But it's nice, if you have an old box with a nVidia card in it, if the card dies, get the latest and it'll work, mind you the new one might not be able to do the newer functions with the old drivers ... but it will work.

      Wich brings up the point that the new chip might run at the old speed.

      -GReg

  26. You need 900 Mhz by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Go to Apple's gaming web site and there they have a low-end to high-end minimum suggestions for gaming. Their minimum hardware to run games, as Apple suggests, is 900 Mhz. These machines come with a better gfx card too. I am afraid you bought the lowest-end Mac, and you expect it to work on all levels...

  27. Dear Apple: by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Dear Apple:

    I bought an Apple computer because of its native support for teledildonics. I bought a USB FUFME and MacOS immediately recognized it and installed drivers instantly! As a gay Catholic priest who often can't be at the altar all the time, you can understand how the ability to have sex with children whilst on the airplane with my Powerbook and wireless internet service is a lifesaver.

    I just have a single question, will Apple be releasing a firewire version of the FUFME anytime soon?

    With much gayness,

    Father Michael "Arminass" Sims

  28. Dear Father Sims by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Dear Father Sims

    Thank you for your kind letter! Being a former Catholic priest myself, I know exactly what you are talking about! It has been our dream at Apple Computers ever since we began in the 80's to shape the homosexual experience with the ultimate computer.

    I can answer your letter by saying that YES we will indeed be making a firewire version of the FUFME. With the additional bandwidth offered by the firewire bus, we will be able to more accurately record and deliver more minute and subtle movements that the USB FUFME simply couldnt support due to lack of bandwidth. You will be able to recognize our firewire FUFME in stores by the fancy holographic logo of a cock entering an Apple.

    We are glad to help loyal customers such as yourself. If you ever have any more questions, feel free to drop a line (or connect to my teledildonic FUFME server on fufme://cockman.apple.com).

    Hugh G. Cockman
    President
    Homosexual Liaison Services
    Apple Computer, Inc.

  29. still pissed over 1024x768 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The only reason I bought an emac over the cheap fp imac so long ago was I thought I would be able to get up to
    1280 x 1024 pixels to display.

    Instead It flickers at anything above 1024x768.

    First and last new apple I will buy.

  30. KVM on eMac? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    What about hacking the connector from the video card to the CRT? Can a KVM switch be grafted into works?

    I'm thinking you'd mount two monitor plugs in the case, and then wire them to the KVM. Even slicker would be to install the KVM inside the emac case and mount a switch and a VGA port... but there isn't much room in there...

  31. Only if you can get the card by littleghoti · · Score: 1

    I own a cube and would love to upgrade the video. However, no-one sells officially sanctioned cards for the cube anymore. Sure, you can get a normal card and shoehorn it in, but this often involves moving the power PCB and taking a dremel to the chassis. Another problem is the heat build-up, as the cube is cooled passively. Still, it is a great quiet computer and fast enough for most things.

  32. correction by Anonymous+Freak · · Score: 1

    Apparently one company did make a Voodoo2 card that had a pass-through, so it did work on the internal monitor.

    --
    Another non-functioning site was "uncertainty.microsoft.com."
    The purpose of that site was not known.
    1. Re:correction by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yep. If you take the iMac appart, you'll see, iirc, that there's even a standard [Mac] video cable running to the "built-in" monitor.

  33. clone cows by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Gateway is no upgrade. They will be selling blenders and other appliances before you know it... sorta like those junk mail catalogs people put out, selling other companies crap with their name on it.
    As for Dell, well Michael Dell has done very well for himself, but what has he ever contributed? It's certainly not quality. Ever heard of W.C. Fields? Remember his best quote?

  34. Simple Rule by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    There is a simple rule of thumb for Power Macs: if it has a built in monitor, its built in video cannot be upgraded.