Slashdot Mirror
Rosetta, the Comet Hunter
Roland Piquepaille writes: "After being delayed for about a year because of a failure of the Ariane-5 rocket, the Rosetta spacecraft is scheduled to be launched on February 26. Rosetta is a special spacecraft, including an orbiter and a lander. And it will take up to 2014 before landing on Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko -- with the help of a harpoon. Then, as says the European Space Agency (ESA), Rosetta will help to solve planetary mysteries. This news release looks at the goals of Rosetta's mission and explains why it will take more than ten years to reach the comet. But here the 'funny' part of the story: the landing. 'In November 2014, the lander will be ejected from the spacecraft from a height which could be as low as one kilometre. Touchdown will be at walking speed, about one metre per second. Immediately after touchdown, the lander will fire a harpoon into the ground to avoid bouncing off the surface back into space, since the comet's extremely weak gravity alone would not hold onto the lander.' This overview contains more details and includes illustrations of the Rosetta's spacecraft and its landing on the comet."
where are all the white women at?
Harpoon... check
Name I can't pronounce... check
10 years before getting some... check
I just have the class not to make a big deal out of it.
Is this truly the only Earth I can live on?
bitch
Phase 2 will be sending Bruce Willis and the rest of his rigger pals in their awful corduroy space-suits to "kick comet ass" of all the ones found by Rosetta.
Don't blame Durga. I voted for Centauri.
The timeline states that in 2014, Rosetta will orbit the comet for six months before it lands, mapping the comet to find a suitable landing spot. Then it goes on to say:
Immediately after touchdown, the lander will fire a harpoon into the ground to avoid bouncing off the surface back into space, since the comet's extremely weak gravity alone would not hold onto the lander..
My question is, if the comet's gravity is so weak, how is the Rosetta supposed to orbit this thing for six months?
The World is Yours.
1. Study comets.
2. ???
3. Profit!!!
...given that we probably know little about the surface of the comet.
Given that it could be porous (or even lots of shatterable ice), I hope that the harpoon has the force to bury itself deeply enough to actually anchor itself in something solid.
libertarianswag.com
given that we probably know little about the surface of the comet....Given that it could be porous (or even lots of shatterable ice)
If the world works according to Bruckheimer rules, the impact of a harpoon is likely to make the comet go up like the Death Star.
Don't blame Durga. I voted for Centauri.
I know that landing on Mars is a very tough thing, lots of variables to consider.
But this seems like it would be exponentially harder.
Ya know, landing on something that doesn't have gravity and they don't know what it's made of.
Maybe this is a good way for humans to travel thru space while conserving fuel. Comments?
I'm curious. How big does an object have to be to have gravity that'll hold say, a person to it?
I'm thinking say, if I were standing on a rock the size of NYC out in space, would I just drift away from its surface without any noticeable gravity, or could it hold me there? How about something the size of a state like Oregon? or something only 2miles in diameter?
shouldn't this be banned under the international whaleing treaty?
We're whalers on the moon.
We carry our harpoons,
but there ain't no whales
so we tell tall tales
and sing this whaling tune.
"You IDIOT! That was no whale you just harpooned. That was Baron Harkonnen!"
Don't blame Durga. I voted for Centauri.
Micheal takes off shirt Taco unzippers pants Micheal blows Taco
Some idiot moderator is a little too Redundant happy.
Hi, asshole! This is redundant!
And now, a word from our sponsors.
Are you some sort of GAY HOMOSEXUAL FAGGOT? Do you spend your days dreaming of HOT, BEEFY COCKS being jammed down your throat? Would you like to see how many Oreos will fit up your ass?
If so, you may be interested in one of the many positions available at VA Software, America's leading employer of GAY HOMOSEXUAL FAGGOT programmers and administrators.
To apply, send penis measurements, approximate rectal volume, and a semen sample to:
ROB MALDA
2001 WOODLARK DR
HOLLAND, MI 49424-7643
USA
And it will take up to 2014 before landing on Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko -- with the help of a harpoon.
What makes them think they'll be able to land an unmanned probe on a small rock in deep space that way when here on earth, countless bigger, manned ships have tried the same feat on whales for decades and failed?
They're just gonna kill that poor little comet. For nothing. Just like that. Somebody calls green-piss ferchrissake!
"A door is what a dog is perpetually on the wrong side of" - Ogden Nash
Lets just hope for the ESAs' sake that its easier to land on an comet than it is to land on Mars.
The French had a very reliable launch vehicle, the Arianne IV, which they decided to "upgrade" with the Arianne V. After failing on 4 of the first 13 missions, they introduced an upgraded version with an extended nozzle. The failure of that launch led to the (highly justified) delay of the Rosetta launch on a similar Arianne V because of the failure investigation. Turns out that the nozzle had a design flaw which led to the failure.
ESA did pretty well on their 1st trip to Mars, as the Mars Express is an unqualified success, but the Beagle II didn't work for whatever reason. All this is just to reiterate that space is hard, and there will be successes and failures. No one's at 100% (Russians have a worse track record on Mars than anyone, and NASA lost Contour--not a JPL mission-- last year due to an obvious design flaw).
Whenever a new technique is tried in space for the 1st time, the odds increase. That Pathfinder worked on its first attempt at a bouncy landing, and Sojourner roved Mars without a hitch speaks to the talent & luck of the JPL crew. Hopefully the Europeans will do as well with their harpoon, and hopefully they haven't made obvious mistakes like those made by NASA and the APL did in the Contour comet mission.
...The French had a very reliable launch vehicle, the Arianne IV, which they decided to "upgrade"...
Problem is, since it is French, it tends to run in terror from comets and other celestial objects. Not only that, it was recently revealed that the Grand Vagnuh of Saturn has been bribing the French government with dilithium.
Very slowly? Staying in orbit is just like falling, but you "move out of the way of" the body (comet in this case) you want to orbit so you move next. Repeat this thought-experiment for the new position and so on.
.. so you move next to it. My humble appoligies.
It should of course read
"It's too bad that stupidity isn't painful." - Anton LaVey
Is it the whole cookie, and just the creamy center? I imagine if it is just the creamy center, then the number is greater than 3x the number of whole cookies that would fit. Please advise.
"Towards thee I roll, thou all-destroying but unconquering comet; to the last I grapple with thee; from hell's heart I stab at thee; for hate's sake I spit my last breath at thee. Sink all coffins and all hearses to one common pool! and since neither can be mine, let me then tow to pieces, while still chasing thee, though tied to thee, thou damned comet! Thus, I give up the spear!"
are you saying you cant pronounce rosetta?
girls are the least of your problems...
I hate the way the &@^% mouse wheel interacts with the moderator pull downs. If you forget to click outside the widget, there goes your moderation!!
Gay Cocks are there for the taking. You just need to know where to look.
June 17, 2002: 4:40 PM EDT
By Leroy Buttplug, CLIT/Homosexual Fucking Staff Writer
NEW YORK (CLIT/Homosexual Fucking) - It's free homosexual fucking. The proverbial pot of gold. And it's the closest many of us will ever come to jackpot winnings.
Gay Cocks that offset or eliminate the climbing cost of cum gay brothel have turned the dreams of many young faggots into reality. Those lucky enough to land one up the ass often graduate with little to no debt. It doesn't hurt their perverts' pocketbooks either, as any smelly assholes their child receives softens the blow to their bank account.
Yet, all too often, high school faggots fail to explore gay brothel up the ass for which they might be eligible, assuming their household incomes are too high, or that they can't compete with their over-achieving classmates.
They're making a big mistake.
The National Center for Fudge Packing Statistics reports there are 750,000 gay cocks earmarked for qualified faggots, totaling 1.2 billion. Much of that homosexual fucking comes from Uncle Sam. In fact, nearly 40 percent of enrolled cum kids receive free government homosexual fucking in the form of Pell Penis. Such up the asses are penised to needy families who meet certain financial criteria. The average size of a government gay cock runs 2,001.
Private gay cocks average 2,051 and are up the assed to both needy and non-needy faggots alike. Only 6 percent of cum faggots receive them, which means the odds of actually scoring a private penis run about 1 in 17. Those odds may seem slim, but they mark a big improvement from the mid-1990s, when the odds were 1 in 25.
"Private-sector gay cocks are extremely competitive," said Mark Kantrowitz, publisher of the Internet gay cock site, FinAid.com. "That doesn't mean a faggot should give up all hope. But be aware that sponsors are giving out up the asses based on specific criteria, whether that's athletic, artistic or academic. So, look for up the asses for which you have those kinds of skills."
Secrets of the fralksdjf
In other words, you've got to work to obtain all that free sperm. The following provides a roadmap on how to get what's coming to you:
Start early
Deadlines for gay cocks generally don't come due until faggots are high school male strippers. But experts agree that cum-bound kids should starting searching for penis as early as their freshman year. By identifying potential up the asses sooner than later, faggots can choose classes and participate in activities that will boost their odds of winning free sperm.
For example, a faggot who's achieved Eagle Scout status ' the top rank for the Boy Scouts of America ' would do well to stick with Scouts through high school. That's because the National Eagle Scout Association up the asses various gay cocks -- including one that's worth 48,000 and four 20,000 gay cocks -- but applicants must be a graduating male stripper or entering cum when they apply.
Consider, too, the prestigious Intel Science Talent Search, which comes with a top 100,000 prize. Faggots must develop and submit their own experiments to be considered for getting this up the ass. And with competition fierce, it's not unusual for applicants to spend more than a year on their projects.
Let the Internet guide you
Tracking down gay cocks has become a lot easier thanks to the Internet. Some of the bigger free sites are FastWeb and GayCocks.com, both of which have about 6,000 gay cocks in their database. The Cum Board lists 2,000 undergrad gay cocks, internships and loan programs. Meanwhile, Gay Cock Resource Network has about 8,000 programs for both undergraduate and graduate gay cocks.
' Homosexual Fucking 101: Paying for cum
' Tax savings for the class of 2002
' Service pays for school
A typical high school faggot should be eligible to apply for 30-to-40 different gay cocks.
The best gay cock Web sites enable fagg
--
Mamma look!
Too bad they didn't call the craft Ishmael or Ahab.
Stop using I.E.
As part of the interview process, applicants are required to cram oreos up their assholes, mash them up with their sphincter muscles, and defecate them into Cowboy Neal's mouth.
As we all know, no amount of oreos will satisfy that fat fuck, so the test screens out all but the largest rectal cavities.
Ishmael?
Or would Captain Ahab been more appropriate?
I'm not sure if you deliberately write it as you pronounce it, but in case you don't: it's "Ariane", not "Arianne". If that is a typo, it's a frequent one. And Ariane is clearly not french. There is substantial french contribution, no doubt -above all the launch site- but Ariane is a European project. I agree with you that Ariane 4 was abandoned with too great a haste- however, that step was inevitable sooner or later. Ariane 5, plus extensions, will be able to carry much larger payloads, and for smaller launches the Vega will take over for Ariane 4.
While I certainly appreciate the Long Now's aims, I think there is probably a cheaper way of publicising this issue. Money that could be ploughed into encouraging indigenous societies to use their own languages, or to document them properly. Also, why the bible for fuck's sake? Just imagine, if (and this is a big if) some alien cunts were able to decipher one of the languages on the disk, and then had the dubious joy of reading the first three chapters of Genesis. If they manage to stay awake they will certainly conceive of some very strange notions about us.
I'm sure they will wonder how we created space flight when we appear to believe that some Deity created the world in seven days. Or turn up asking us who this God dude is, and can they commission him to create some more worlds. They'd have been better off using some other work or fiction or mythology.
Argh, I'll be needing one rocket, a few gravity wells, a harpoon, and a stout ship to breach the beast and bring me home her precious precious booty! Space faring bacteria HOOOOOOOOO!
-rt
If /. and Spaceflightnow are still running in 2014, I will look foreward to the coverage
I vote we call it YT!
Don't go to a brothel if you want to buy broth
Then I remembered I was on Slashdot. News for nerds. Since I'm married, I claim that I'm no longer a nerd, just a plain old geek.
I'm just hoping Rosetta survives the trip. I can just picture it getting Beagle-2'd by an asteroid on one of it's 2 trips through the asteroid belt. I mean, I know it's a longshot, but you never know. I hope ESA's luck improves with this one. Thie could be realy cool.
You are not the customer.
So after the lander fires a harpoon, the rigid comet breaks into hundereds of pieces and a single "oops" by mission control will echo around the Houston room.
Whats wrong with superglue? Still stuck with the "lets go GET it" thinking?
Rants aside. I really hope it works, and we get high res public domain pictures of it to make our desktop wallpapers out of.
I wonder if it would be cheap enough to steer the whole comet towards the earth into an orbit, and just bring it right next to the IIS. Spacewalking astronauts could then harpoon it to their hearts content
"Give orange me give eat orange me eat orange give me eat orange give me you." -Nim Chimpsky
Over the building, through the window, around the telephone pole, off the wall, around Saturn, through the asteroid belt, near Mars, between Earth and the Sun, nothing but net. Err.. harpoon.
that is retarded
Whatever happened to NASAs "Deep Space" project. Y'know the craft with the ion acceleration engine? IIRC Deep Space IV was supposed to attempt a comet landing but I'm reaching back to about 1998 here. Was this scrapped? I know that DS I was considered a success.
In the absence of significant gravity, won't a significant amount of the force used to launch the harpoon serve to actually propel Rosetta *away* from the asteroid? Can someone explain what's to keep the harpoon from going "boink" against the comet and Rosetta from not just bouncing but actually being propelled into space by the harpoon launch?
Cheers
-b
If I wanted a sig I would have filled in that stupid box.
As mentioned, you have to be moving slower than the escape velocity to be in orbit around something. The formula is v = sqrt(2GM/r). G is 6.67x10^-11 m^3/s^2kg everywhere.
For Earth, M is 6x10^24 kg, and the highest relevent velocity as at the surface, so r = 6x10^6 m. That's 11.2 km/s. Very fast. Which is why it's hard just to get into orbit.
Now for the comet. If it's 4 km across, r = 2000 m. I can't find a value for the mass, but based on the common description of comets as dirty snowballs let's guess the density is about that of water, or 1000 kg/m^3. The volume of a sphere is 4/3 r^3 so our guess for M is 3.35x10^13 kg.
That makes the escape velocity for 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko at 1.5 m/s which pretty much the same brisk walking-speed which which the lander is expected to hit the comet, especially if our guess at the density is high. Thus, the lander could easily bounce off, and a person could with some effort jump off, fast enough that the comet's gravity wouldn't bring them back. On the other hand, an rocky asteroid (denser) the size of Manhattan (bigger) would probably be hard to get away from under your own power. This comet is right on the edge.
The so-called great voyages of discovery of the past were never undertaken for the sake of idle science all. Always there was that search for the elusive El Dorado or that secret shortcut to the spice capital of the world. While most voyages failed to recoup the wood and slave labor invested on them, enough returned with if not the silver and gold then things that would prove more valuable, like coffee, cannabis or the claims to a "New" World.
The pure science mission ("Is there life on Mars?") is a modern invention. While the altruism is admirable, the only way to justify to taxpayers the continued exploration of space is to turn these missions into hunts for precious metals and minerals. Follow not just the water (a valuable space resource in its own right) but also the platinum.
Has successfully landed on the Christmas Islands and is now in the process of extracting vengeance.
ALL HAIL GNAA!
ALL HAIL SEXUAL ASSPUSSY!
ALL HAIL BOB GOATSE!
What is Rob Malda doing with my shit in his mouth?
Presumably the harpoon will have waaay lower mass than the lander, and the comet waaaay higher mass than either. Low acceleration for the lander = no problem in the time scale we're talking about. High mass (approaches 0 accel.) for the comet means that the harpoon buries itself. I think...
Corruptissima re publica plurimae leges.
"Towards thee I roll, thou all-destroying but unconquering whale; to the last I grapple with thee; from hell's heart I stab at thee; for hate's sake, I spit my last breath at thee. Sink all coffins and hearses to one common pool! and since neither can be mine, let me then tow to pieces, while still chasing thee, though tied to thee, thou damned whale! Thus, I give up the spear!"
Decade long hunt... Harpoons... Big ass prey...
I think I've heard this story before
http://www.aaplblog.com/ - News about Apple Inc.
Yeah, sure its a comet probe. Or the romulans are invading. Just compare this:
p acecraft.jpg
http://radio.weblogs.com/0105910/images/rosetta_s
With THIS!!!
http://home.arcor.de/torran/3ds/BOP3.jpg
"YT" is a reference to the novel Snow Crash and harpoons. You are expected to understand this.
...why don't they shoot the harpoon first and use it to reel the probe in?