Slashdot Mirror


D&D Is 30

mainframemouse writes "For those who have not seen the Beeb article, Dungeons and Dragons is 30 years old. After many years of role-playing is wonderful to see the mother of all RPG's given respect and mention in the national press. There's even a note about the false accusations of the 80's." And for the record - flanking & attacks of opportunity in 3/3.5 Edition still irritate me. Combine a familiar with Master Tactician and some rogue levels, and you're off to the races.

39 of 763 comments (clear)

  1. The flagship... by danielrm26 · · Score: 5, Funny

    Ah, D&D -- the flagship of geek hobbies. Many people do video games or comic books and want to include themselves in the group, but until you've re-written your character sheet 15 times, had discussions about what makes a good DM/GM, and carried around a fuzzy bag full of expensive dice, you aren't the real deal. :)

    --
    dmiessler.com -- grep understanding knowledge
    1. Re:The flagship... by SoTuA · · Score: 5, Funny
      My first d20 dice is almost a perfect sphere from wear! does that count?

      Ooops... failed my "Burning Karma" saving throw...

    2. Re:The flagship... by ScottGant · · Score: 5, Interesting

      I remember playing this for the first time back in 1980. We were playing "AD&D" by the way...hehe.

      The second edition rules were a cludge...everyone knew that...but that's why I loved them. I loved how they worked. When the d20 system came into being..I felt it just lost something. Hard to track down. The second edition rules with their patched together charts...the rules that contradicted other rules etc...that was just part of the fun.

      But the ultimate insult was when "Call of Cthulhu" when to a d20 system. Yes, you can still play with the old rules...which were better...than using the d20 system, but still. They should have just well enough alone. "Call of Cthulhu" was and still is my favorte PnP role playing game. Bar none.

      But the AD&D games me and my friends would play around 1989ish were some of the best times I've had with a group of goof-balls joking around, drinking huge amounts of caffine drinks and pizza and generally just having a good time.

      --

      "Music is everybody's possession. It's only publishers who think that people own it." - John Lennon.
    3. Re:The flagship... by Newander · · Score: 5, Funny

      The ever popular caltrop +1.

      --

      Jesus saves and takes half damage.

    4. Re:The flagship... by qengho · · Score: 5, Funny


      Unrounded D4s....One of my most painful memories is stepping on one of those buggers.

      I guess you missed your Dex throw against the Caltrop of Mighty Hopping.

    5. Re:The flagship... by haystor · · Score: 5, Funny

      Now you know the reason they were flattened on their corners. In the 70's, before consumer safety laws, they were razor sharp, needle points and tipped with poison.

      --
      t
  2. D&D is 30 and.... by ThePlague · · Score: 5, Funny

    It still hasn't kissed a girl!

  3. 3 Decades! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    And still proudly living in the parent's basement!

  4. Yep by EpsCylonB · · Score: 5, Funny

    And for the record - flanking & attacks of opportunity in 3/3.5 Edition still irritate me. Combine a familiar with Master Tactician and some rogue levels, and you're off to the races.

    Yep you are a nerd.

  5. I had a discussion... by dijjnn · · Score: 5, Funny

    The other day with a friend about which type of dice hurt the worst to step on. we decided that, while a d4 was bad (the worst if you step straight down hard), that a d8 was really the worst because it rolled with your foot.

    My girlfriend immediately said, "oh my god, i'm dating a nerd."

    Thank you D&D.

    --
    ~dijjnn
    1. Re:I had a discussion... by maxpublic · · Score: 5, Funny

      My girlfriend immediately said, "oh my god, i'm dating a nerd."

      I didn't know they made talking RealDolls.

      Max

      --
      My god carries a hammer. Your god died nailed to a tree. Any questions?
    2. Re:I had a discussion... by D-Cypell · · Score: 5, Funny

      Yeah, I have noticed this lots recently, its like guys read threads about how slashdot is full of sexually frustrated geeks and want to prove that they can play happily in both worlds (and make all the true 'significant-other-deficient' geeks jealous)...

      My and my girlfriend both hate posts like that..

  6. House rules? by Phs2501 · · Score: 5, Insightful
    And for the record - flanking & attacks of opportunity in 3/3.5 Edition still irritate me. Combine a familiar with Master Tactician and some rogue levels, and you're off to the races.

    If they irritate you, change the rules. One of the things a good GM needs to do is to keep the game from becoming too cheezy. If they players are abusing the rules, nerf them! The 3rd Edition Harm spell is a perfect example of something that desperately needs it.

    In my opinion, rules like flanking and attacks of opportunity add a whole lot more tactical depth to the combat without slowing it down much. It's certainly more fun than combat in old D&D.

    1. Re:House rules? by Dark+Lord+Seth · · Score: 5, Funny
      If they players are abusing the rules, nerf them!

      Not only is it fun to retaliate on abusive players, it's also fun to get back at players who use annoying, stupid and or nonsensical rules. Or, players who are generally idiots.

      Ingham: I summon a mindflayer and order it to use psionics against the enemy.
      DM: A red dragon eats you.

      Adellon: I cast "Hold Person" on Illandria and grope her breast!
      Illandria: HEY!
      DM: A red dragon rapes you.

      Illandria: What? My attack missed!?
      DM: Yes.
      Illandria: You just said that because I'm a girl!
      DM: A female red dragon kicks your ass.

      Suffice to say, dragon rock as plot elements.

  7. Don't you mean... by glpierce · · Score: 5, Funny

    ...Ex-girlfriend?

    --
    G
  8. Some classic Christian D&D FUD by gid13 · · Score: 5, Interesting

    http://www.chick.com/bc/2002/dnd.asp

    Quote from the link: "The goal of the game [D&D] would be to see who could obtain the most erotic pleasure"

    As my friend who sent me the link originally so accurately stated, "I don't know about you, but my D&D sessions were never like that."

    Btw... D&D is 30... But what about its other attributes? What's its alignment? Strength, dexterity, intelligence, etc? Okay I'm a nerd.

    1. Re:Some classic Christian D&D FUD by FortKnox · · Score: 5, Interesting

      I've seen theologists write PhD thesis' about how D&D is not sacreligious. Basically, it hits on the points that good is always better than evil, it can help satisfy evil needs by 'pretending' them, and if you can't tell the difference between reality and fantasy you have worse problems than playing D&D.

      --
      Good quote, too many chars. Seriously, the slashdot 120 char limit sucks!
    2. Re:Some classic Christian D&D FUD by SyntheticTruth · · Score: 5, Interesting

      I've DM'd since the early 80's, rarely ever been a player.

      I once played AD&D 2nd Ed. with group of gamers that included a catholic priest. That pretty much erased such irrational notions from my mother's head at the time. And, may I go on record as saying, he played the best damn drunkern dwarven cleric I have ever seen.

      Potential wise-cracks aside, he had great story-telling talent to go along with his role-playing. That group is the first to really show me what kind of good role-playing can happen when you have good, pro-story, non-powergaming, players.

      It's something that any computer RPG has yet to capture.

    3. Re:Some classic Christian D&D FUD by mojotooth · · Score: 5, Funny

      I've seen theologists write PhD thesis'

      Holy CRAP you need to get out more.

      --
      -- Mojo Tooth : exploring our world as only an idiot can.
  9. Military Potential of D&D by handy_vandal · · Score: 5, Funny

    It was even a cult at a Wisconsin naval base. "At one time every nuclear submarine had a D&D group," says Arneson.
    - from the article

    Nuclear submarines? D&D groups?

    My God ... do you think the Commander-in-Chief knows about this?

    -kgj

    --
    -kgj
    1. Re:Military Potential of D&D by The_Mystic_For_Real · · Score: 5, Funny
      Wisconsin naval base

      I can't imagine they had much else to do while at a naval base in Wisconsin.

      _____________
      It was just a joke, please don't hurt me.

      --

      _____

      Thank you.

  10. Takes me back a bit by Skyshadow · · Score: 5, Interesting
    I'd forgotten what a pain it was to play D&D in the 80's. You young'uns might not realize it, but for a while D&D was seriously considered as being directly linked to satanism by an awful lot of people. Those morons looked at an activity which was developing imagination, math skills and the ability to think on your feet and somehow twisted it into us getting ready to boil babies or something.

    I remember that "expose'" where they made D&D out to be some big satanic training session because (gasp!) there were demons and devils listed in the Field Folio. And then some shooter someplace had a DMG in his backpack or something like that...

    Parents just ate that shit up. I think a lot of them couldn't understand why we just weren't spending our time watching TV like normal kids. We basically had to operate under the radar or risk losing a several of our players to easily paniced parents.

    --
    Every year during my review, I just pray the words "slashdot.org" aren't mentioned.
  11. picking on D&D by zptdooda · · Score: 5, Interesting

    "The game was wrongly implicated in a missing persons case, a teen suicide and a number of murders. Some schools banned the game, and many parents refused to let their children play."

    It bugged me at the time that for the amount of people playing the game, the incidence of suicide seemed lower than in the rest of the general public, but the press never seemed to report that.

    --
    Esteem isn't a zero sum game
  12. Multiplayer Online by JSkills · · Score: 5, Interesting
    Having been a old school D&D player (4 hours after school almost every day in high school), I have always looked forward to the development of D&D PC games. The well thought out rules and balance in D&D kind of spoiled me as I would only play games that used the actual D&D rules (same races, classes, spell names, etc). Even Diablo (although fun at the time) was a stretch because it really didn't use the same conventions. And the multiplayer was all about hacks and player killing.

    Of course I ripped through all of the SSI games and the Baldur's Gate Series. Then came Neverwinter Nights. A beautiful game, but instead of controlling a party of people, it's just one character and a side-kick. This was a big mistake. However, the fact that one could assume the role of Dungeon Master made this game somewhat revolutionary.

    But after playing multiplayer online a bit, I must say, that although I have found some new places to explore (people have spent some time on putting together some very cool levels), it still seems to come down to everyone being 40th level and killing each other. Maybe I'm just not playing in the right places?

    Maybe I'm just missing the old days of getting together with pen paper and the dodecahedrons? I don't think so - who's got time for trying to orchestrate that?

    And yes, I've tried Everquest and just couldn't seem to get into the flow of it. I couldn't see what the "big deal" was ...

    1. Re:Multiplayer Online by drinkypoo · · Score: 5, Insightful
      If you want games centered on storytelling, then play games which eschew all possible rules. You don't need a detailed character sheet to have a good time.

      My best roleplaying sessions, bar none, have been while playing the Amber Diceless RPG. No dice, four stats, just a few powers to deal with, and a point system so every character (which is based on the same number of points) is more or less equal. Even the powers are balanced; In order to be attuned to the logrus (and it to you) you have to be a shape shifter. Hence the Logrus powers which are arguably more powerful than those of the Pattern are balanced by there being a prerequisite. (And people with the pattern can generally see right through shapeshifters if they're paying attention, so good roleplaying can be rewarded by a good GM.)

      Ultimately, the game comes down to the storyteller, GM, DM, or whatever they're named in your game of choice. It can only be as good as they are creative. The next thing is the players; are they serious about the game? I don't mean you can't make jokes, but the idea is to roleplay right?

      Put another way, the "secret" is to form a group which shares your goals. You sound like you want to roleplay - you need a group of roleplayers. Most computer gamers don't want to roleplay, they want to kill shit. When I play a pen and paper RPG, then the world is open, it can be anything. When I play a computer RPG, this is not true, so I resign myself to killing stuff.

      --
      "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
  13. Re:Ugh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    I wish I had your mother. Mine was "progressive" and just let me go ahead and play. Now my soul belongs to Mephistopheles and I can look forward to an eternity in boiling excrement.

  14. Re:Congrats! by Analogy+Man · · Score: 5, Funny

    Isn't yours the 4" one handed sword?...and haven't you been playing with it enough already?

    --
    When the people fear their government, there is tyranny; when the government fears the people, there is liberty.
  15. Re:Ask the girl out on a date! by grub · · Score: 5, Funny


    I'm sorry, the girl makes a saving throw against your 1st level charm spell

    My ex-wife fell for my 1st level charm spell but it turns out she was Chaotic-Evil and when we split up she took all my GP.

    --
    Trolling is a art,
  16. Karma Whore by handy_vandal · · Score: 5, Funny

    Another trait of geeks is obsessive hairsplitting. I mean my god, man.

    Who cares about the obsessive hairsplitting? The important thing is the successful karma whoring.

    -kgj

    --
    -kgj
  17. Re:Logic, Logic -- Who's Got the Logic? by Uncle+Gropey · · Score: 5, Funny

    Are you sure? The act of observing disturbs the observed. Until you have looked, you must consider D&D to be both 30 and not 30.

  18. A great movie for D&D players... by Abraxis · · Score: 5, Informative

    Pardon the slight off-topicness... but some friends of mine from college started their own production company, and made a movie called "The Gamers". It certainly ain't no hollywood production, but that's the charm of it. Do yourself a favor and grab the DVD and watch it with your gaming buddies to celebrate D&D's 30th... I promise it'll be a good time. I think they have a quicktime trailer and stuff here.

  19. support your local indie RPG author by sammy+baby · · Score: 5, Informative

    If you remember your times long past playing D&D fondly - heck, if you're still playing it - you really owe it to yourself to check out some independent roleplaying game producers. They're cheap, they're great, they're a break from THAC0 and saving throws and god only knows what else. A great place to start is with The Forge, which specializes in such games.

    And while you're their, a shout out please for Lumpley, an old friend of mine, and the author of kill puppies for satan: an unfunny roleplaying game. (I'd link directly to his site, but I doubt it could take the slashdotting. Still, I must advise folks to look him up. And send him money.)

  20. Re:Borrowed very, very heavily by Tackhead · · Score: 5, Funny
    > D&D takes a *lot* from Tolkien. This shouldn't be all that shocking -- Tolkien's stated goal with LOTR and middle earth was to create a sort of modern mythology, and he did so sucessfully.

    And sometimes, D&D gives back:

    ~wavylines~

    "A balrog!" Gandalf rasped. "I might have known!"

    Pippin hauled out his well-worn copy of the Monstrous Manual, while Merry peeked over his shoulder. "I don't see 'Balrog' listed in the index anywhere."

    "Of course not, foolish Took," the high-level mage chided him. "The copyright to the 'Balrog' name is owned by the Tolkien estate. Gygax had to call it 'Balor' or a 'Type VI demon' when he put the MM together."

    Merry quickly thumbed to the Demon section, only to recall that in 2nd Edition, "Demons" and "Devils" had been renamed Baatezu and Tanar'ri, although he never could remember which was which. He cursed the Fundamentalist Christian parents' groups who had threatened to boycott TSR for creating a "demonic" game, and which had forced that particularly stupid name-change upon them. Finally, though, he located "Balor" in the Tanar'ri section, grateful that they weren't among the discontinued demon listings like Orcus and Demogorgon.

    "They're only 13 hit dice," Merry dutifully reported, "But they can cast dispel magic every round at 20th level, so watch yourself, Gandalf!"

    "That also do 4d8 damage if they make a to-hit roll with their whip and drag you close to their bodies," Gimli noted. "I'm outta here!" He turned and ran at his full movement rate of 9 (12 if he wasn't wearing armor).

    "Leave him to me," the mage intoned. "They're worth 46,000 experience points apiece, and if I kill him by myself, I get *all* of those points!" He strode toward the Balr-- er, Balor, and blocked the 10-foot-wide corridor leading out of the room. "YOU SHALL NOT PASS!!!!"

    LOTR as written by others - as a D&D novel.

  21. Remember when D&D was BAD? by Jethro · · Score: 5, Funny

    Anyone remember when mainstream thought D&D was evil and was corrupting our young minds? Apparently anyone who played it couldn't tell the difference between Fantasy and Reality and ended up killing themselves.

    My father (by chance a paranoid hypocondriac) read or heard one such article. This is when I was 18, and not living with him, which of course made him even MORE worried. He tried to sit me down and discourage me from my Evil Ways, and said that he read an article where someone said that people who play D&D can't tell fantasy from reality.

    I told him that that's nonsense, and if I ever see the person who wrote that article I'd cast a fireball at them.

    So he tried to get me into counselling.

    Oh, did I mention my dad has NO sense of humour?

    --


    In the land of the blind, the one-eyed man is kinky.
  22. Your familiar has been slain! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

    And for the record - flanking & attacks of opportunity in 3/3.5 Edition still irritate me. Combine a familiar with Master Tactician and some rogue levels, and you're off to the races.

    First, I don't know what "Master Tactician" is; you are probably referring to "Expert Tactician" which allows you to make an additional attack whenever someone is denied their dex bonus to AC. Since a Rogue also adds sneak attack damage to any attack when the opponent is denied their dex bonus to their AC this is a good combination.

    However flanking does not deny the opponents dex bonus to their AC, so the familiar flanking example you used would not work to give you an extra sneak attack as you suggest. Additionally if your familiar is killed there are harsh penalties. You must make Fortitude save DC 15 or lose 200xp per master level (save for half). You also cannot get another familiar for a year unless you raise dead. Since you will be progressing as a Rogue and not a Wizard or a Sorcerer, your familiar will not increase along with you. By level 6 opponents will simply squash your familiar like a bug, costing you 6750gp each time for a scroll of raise dead.

    AC: Armor Class, how hard you are to hit in combat.
    Dex Bonus: Dexterity is a measure of how nimble a person is, the bonus from this score adds to your AC.
    XP: Experience Points, a measure used to determine the level of your character.
    DC: Difficulty Class, in order to succeed you must roll a twenty sided dice (d20) and add your relevant bonus and get a result equal or higher.
    GP: Gold Pieces.

  23. As a representative ... by burgburgburg · · Score: 5, Funny

    of Mephistopheles, I'd like to point out that the excrement is kept boiling due to Federal regulations. I'd also like to point out that the AC will not, in fact, be spending all eternity in the boiling excrement. Every 10 years, the vats of excrement are switched out. During the 15 minutes that this procedure involves, the AC (and all similar clients) will be kept in a pit of superheated beaver vomit. Again, this is the mandated Federal procedure.

  24. Top 35 Similarities between RPG'ing and pron by jcayer · · Score: 5, Funny

    1. The typical customer is male, unattractive, and socially handicapped
    2. Both are frequently enjoyed in dark basements
    3. The size of your collection is obscene
    4. It's not a good idea to talk about either on a first date
    5. Both revolve around fantasy and obtaining the unobtainable
    6. The artwork depicts images impossible in the real world
    7. When purchasing either in a store, you always ask for a bag
    8. It may be fun to make your own at home, but rarely turns out as good as the professionally produced stuff
    9. If you saw a woman buying either, you'd probably want to ask her out
    10. Extra excitement can be added with the use of props and / or costumes
    11. Low quality versions of both can be found for free on the Internet
    12. Countless Usenet groups are dedicated to both
    13. In either case, a gang of heavily-muscled men in leather with whips spells trouble
    14. Everyone uses a silly, made-up name
    15. It is not uncommon for participants to assume the opposite gender
    16. Both are frowned upon by the conservative right
    17. You usually take interest in both around age 13
    18. New purchases are usually looked at once, then put on the shelf
    19. The best and worst examples of each was produced in the '70s
    20. The German versions of each are the most bizarre
    21. Both are plagued with bad dialogue
    22. You usually spend a lot more time enjoying each alone than with a group of friends
    23. Everyone's called in to work sick at least once to stay home and enjoy one or the other
    24. Both make excellent bathroom reading
    25. There's always a big finish when you get to fire your gun
    26. Hollywood's attempts to mainstream both have been largely unsuccessful
    27. The hero's prized possession is his big, black gun
    28. Plots are often present only to serve the action scenes
    29. The story can be set anywhere from spaceships to dungeons
    30. While the person directing the action is usually blamed for a bad experience, it's usually the fault of poor writing
    31. Characters can have either high APPEARANCE or STAMINA, but rarely both
    32. You can tell the climax is imminent when the characters start screaming
    33. Candles and music enhance the mood
    34. You can meet your favorite B-list stars at the annual convention
    35. One word: Dwarves

  25. Check the source code, and roll for initiative! by dexter+riley · · Score: 5, Funny

    you can not get Array out of Bounds errors on pen and paper D&D

    You enter a 10 x 10 array. You see a Null Pointer Exception guarding an Object of type Chest. What do you do?

  26. What everyone else does by empaler · · Score: 5, Funny

    Whine that it's all MS's fault and reboot.