Slashdot Mirror


Dell to Ship Linux Desktops in Europe

Anglophile writes "Looks like Dell has launched a new line of desktop computers. The Dell Optiplexes will be sold in Europe, come with the Linspire operating system and include a one year free membership to their download warehouse. "

26 of 207 comments (clear)

  1. great by fr0dicus · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Something wrong with the big distros?

    1. Re:great by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

      This is Dell we're talking about. The other distros didn't suck enough for them.

    2. Re:great by clester · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I agree... Although I prefer Debian, Something like Mandrake would be more suitable for the average joe. The tools that come right out of the box are great for anyone that wants to use linux. Not to mention a decent package manager...

      --

      -- Real programmers don't comment their code. It was hard to write, it should be hard to understand.
    3. Re:great by igrp · · Score: 4, Interesting
      I guess - and I am only assuming here - that a big distributor could get away with a lot more with a small distro.

      The big distributions aren't exactly operations run out of a garage any more. Redhat has some (serious) money. SuSe is backed by Novell. The Debian folks probably wouldn't exactly be too thrilled to budge to Debian's demands (well, let's say requirements) and customize a distro. They simply don't really need the money that bad. A lot of the other distros either have their own agenda or niche or simply are too specialized (e.g. Gentoo).

      Things are different if you're running a small distro though. There are bills to pay and contributions are always more than welcome. A company like Dell could therefore easily push some changes they deem necessary through. That way, they don't have to put their own people on it and, effectively, save a whole bunch of money.

    4. Re:great by manabadman · · Score: 5, Informative

      Linspire is Debian. Debian based distributions are even more similiar than rpm based ones. Once installed, you can hardly tell Debian distros apart. In fact many people call these Debian based distros alternative installers

    5. Re:great by Red+Alastor · · Score: 5, Informative

      I thought that maybe the bad comments on Lindows were made by Linux zealots. I read a good article on it on osnews that gave a discount number that made you able to download it for free for 2 days.

      I decided to try it... It is as bad as you heard.

      First, you log as root by default. No attempt to tell you that you should create users. You must know it, find it in the menus and compared to the rest of the distribution the dialog box that let you finally add users looks cryptic (from a total newbie point of view).

      Second and more important : this distribution is all about lock-in. They try to give you the impression that it is a different operating system than Windows and Linux. They rename everything to "make it easier for beginner". Other newbie-friendly distributions will write something as "Mozilla (Web Browser)" while Lindows will write "Web Browser". You can hardly switch for another application, you don't know what you are using to begin with.

      The commands are renamed.

      If you take a Knoppix CD and try to make a Lindows user use it, he will be confused.

      apt-get doesn't work if you don't pay. You don't just pay for their Click-N-Run gui, you must pay to use apt-get itself.

      And finally on a more philosophical point of view :

      They don't respect the GPL (they put a disclaimer that basically say : everything in there is copyrighted by us and us alone, don't steal !).

      They also don't mention like Mandrake and Fedora (don't know for SuSE) that what you are using is the result of a communauty effort).

      --
      Slashdot anagrams to "Sad Sloth"
  2. Less is more? by xOleanderx · · Score: 5, Interesting

    So are they gonna be $150 cheaper?

  3. it runs linspire, but by lanswitch · · Score: 5, Funny

    does it run linux?

  4. Linspire!?!!??? by Moby+Cock · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Why Linspire? Why not use a bigger, (dare I say it) better distro. SuSe 9.1 is Europe's biggest distro, why not that? Is there some anger between Novell and Dell?

  5. They used to... by mustangsal66 · · Score: 5, Interesting

    So Dell returns home to Linux...

    I bought several PC's from Dell in 2001 with RedHat preinstalled... They shipped with driver disks too...

    --
    Why worry? Each of us is wearing an unlicensed "nucular" accelerator on his back.
    Sig changed for readability by G.W.
  6. Download Warehouse? by AceJohnny · · Score: 5, Funny

    Download warehouse? is that like an apt-get repository? DAMMIT! It was so OBVIOUS! To get Linux on the market, it had to become paying, then add free offers!

    --
    Misleading titles? Inflammatory blurbs? Keep in mind that Slashdot is a tabloid.
    1. Re:Download Warehouse? by mustangsal66 · · Score: 5, Interesting

      Seriously,

      The only way to get my mother off windows was to get her onto (then Lindows). She didn't trust that 'free' stuff. She felt comfortable paying a few dollars for it, and the 'support' behind it.

      --
      Why worry? Each of us is wearing an unlicensed "nucular" accelerator on his back.
      Sig changed for readability by G.W.
  7. a bit misleading by theonlyholle · · Score: 5, Informative

    looks like this is a bit misleading - in fact, Dell is shipping them, but they are actually being sold by an Italian company called Questar. So while they are technically Dell machines and even shipped by Dell, this is not a big move by Dell onto the European linux market, it's a smaller company taking the initiative in partnership with Dell...

  8. Re:Finally we have someone like DELL doing it by NoData · · Score: 5, Informative

    Didn't Dell ALREADY have Linux offerings here in the U.S. a few years agon, but then got throttled by MS?

  9. Who gets the savings by MrMojado · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Do they still pay the microsoft tax? I would assume Dell passes the savings of not paying for an OS right into their pocket. Consumers will not see lower prices.

  10. Trickle-down economics by dankney · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Finally there's a version of the trickle-down theory that actually works.

    I'd bet that Dell made this decision because there are many large users (Munich decision, with many more considering) who will be switching over in the work-place.

    Many non-techie employees of those organizations will want to have the same environment at home as at work -- two OSs is simply too "confusing" for point-and-click types.

    And as more and more large institutions move to Linux whatever reason (there are many), I think we will see more and more pre-packaged systems available on a retail level.

    1. Re:Trickle-down economics by Synic · · Score: 4, Funny

      Which comedian was it that said, "visualize a billionaire pissing on your head"

  11. Re:No, try $25 cheaper. by jdhutchins · · Score: 4, Insightful

    "could basically shut down Dell by not selling to them"

    Microsoft COULD do that, but it'd be a blantant violation of their slap-on-the-wrist agreement with the DoJ. They probably couldn't get away with it, and would be forced to start selling to Dell again.

  12. Linspire = Lindows = Debian by Eloquence · · Score: 5, Informative
    From Wikipedia, licensed under the GNU FDL:

    Linspire, previously known as LindowsOS (also Lin---s, pronounced as Lindash), is a Linux distribution based on Debian. It targets the consumer user - its distributors market it more intensively than all other Unix-based or Unix-like distributions except Mac OS X. As Lindows, it was the first Linux distribution to replace Windows in home consumer desktop systems at a substantially lower price than Microsoft Windows.

    Michael Robertson, the founder and former CEO of MP3.com functions as the CEO of Lindows, Inc. It is still called "Lindows, Inc" even though the product is now Linspire.

    Microsoft Corporation sued Lindows, Inc for its use of the term "Windows", which Microsoft claimed constituted a trademark infringement. In February 2004, a judge rejected two of Microsoft's central claims. Though Microsoft lost the core of its case, and says it will appeal the decision, for uncertain reasons it also called the decision "a victory". (See Microsoft vs Lindows for more information.) Lindows was renamed Linspire to avoid further legal action by Microsoft. Michael Robertson called the legal action "Sextuple Jeopardy", which is like "Double Jeopardy" but sextupled.

    Lindows, Inc had the initial goal of developing a Linux-based operating system capable of running major Windows applications as well. It based its Windows compatibility on the development of WINE by the Linspire team. Lindows.com later abandoned its initial approach in favor of making Linux applications easy to download, install and use. They achieved this using an application called Click-N-Run, a program based on Debian's Advanced Packaging Tool, providing an easy-to-use interface and a slightly modified package system for an annual fee (apt-get costs no money, but has less user-friendliness). Click-N-Run has over 1,000 pieces of software for download.

    Lindows, Inc sponsors many open-source projects and events, including the Gaim instant messaging client, the KDE-Apps.org (http://www.kde-apps.org/) and KDE-Look.org (http://www.kde-look.org/) websites, and the Nvu project, which has started to develop an open-source WYSIWYG website editor (based on the Mozilla composer code) to rival FrontPage. In the past, Linspire.com has contributed over $500,000 to the WINE project.

    Editions

    Several varieties of Linspire, known as editions, target different markets. Three main editions exist: Standard, Developer and Laptop.

    • Standard - The standard edition offers the standard distributions, intended for most consumer desktops.
    • Developer - A version designed for developers, this version comes with many development tools such as text editors, compilers and libaries for developing software.
    • Laptop - A version of Linspire optimized for notebook computers, which have different hardware requirements from desktop computers.
    • LindowsLive! - Potential users can download a no-cost LiveCD version of Linspire in ISO image format from P2P networks.

    External links

  13. Re:No, try $25 cheaper. by Unnngh! · · Score: 4, Insightful
    They could do a lot of damage to Dell this way, but it wouldn't be smart for either party. How is average joe computer buyer going to respond when he sees that half the PCs at Bestbuy are running some thing called Linux, proudly embossed with the Dell name, when the salesman tells him it's just as good as Windows only cheaper? He'll probably buy the Dell Linux system.

    MS is dependent on its oem retailers probably more than the other way around.

  14. Re:Linspire? Isn't that...uh, stupid? by pyros · · Score: 4, Informative

    The distro wasn't banned, the courts just made the company change the name.

  15. Re:Finally we have someone like DELL doing it by pyros · · Score: 5, Informative

    That retaliation is part of why MS was convicted of abusing their monopoly. Microsoft is prohibited from retaliatory OEM licensing fees in the settlement now.

  16. Re:Finally we have someone like DELL doing it by pretzel_logic · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Dells work-around is to sell the machine without a OS installed. Dell has offered Linux solutions for about 5 years. Dell.com/Linux

    --

    pretzel_logic
  17. The real mainstream distros by Animats · · Score: 4, Interesting

    While on Slashdot we hear endlessly about Red Hat, Debian, etc., the volume manufacturers are going with Lindows, Linspire, Thiz, and in China, Red Flag. Maybe those should get more coverage. What do the installed base figures look like?

  18. Tinfoil helmet ON by cosmo7 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    2003: Dell asks MS for bigger discount. MS declines.
    2004: Dell starts selling PCs preloaded with Linspire.
    2005: MS quietly increases discount for Dell.
    2005: Dell quietly withdraws Linspire PCs, claims no market demand.

  19. Re:No, try $25 cheaper. by bechthros · · Score: 4, Insightful

    "Microsoft COULD do that, but it'd be a blantant violation of their slap-on-the-wrist agreement with the DoJ."

    And?...