Slashdot Mirror


Randall Davis: IBM Has No SCO Code

Mick Ohrberg writes "As reported by Groklaw, Randall Davis, renowned professor of Computer Science at MIT has after an extensive search found no evidence of SCO's claims that IBM has incorporated parts of the Unix System V code. Davis says "Accordingly, the IBM Code cannot be said, in my opinion, to be a modification or a derivative work based on the Unix System V Code." Surprised, anyone?"

32 of 405 comments (clear)

  1. Wait... by Dayze!Confused · · Score: 5, Funny

    you mean that SCO has been lying to us?

    --
    "All tyranny needs to gain a foothold is for people of good conscience to remain silent." [Thomas Jefferson]
    1. Re:Wait... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

      "We are still seeing copyright violations being committed and the damage is still occurring on a daily basis, yet the other side said, "What is the problem? Look, we took it out of the future versions."

      We showed over a million lines of code and where it has existed. [Linux creator] Linus Torvalds has told me that the Linux kernel has around 5 million lines of code. This derivative code accounts for 20 percent of the Linux code base."
      Q&A: SCO Group CEO Darl McBride By Michael Singer
      http://www.internetnews.com/ent-news/article.php/3 114341

      WTF! This guy can find a single line!! he must be blind! The CEO of SCO says that 1/5 of linux is a copy. Darl Mcbride would not lie!!!

      Remeber SCO owns c++ too!
      "And C++ programming languages, we own those" -Darl McBride
      Caldera CEO waves UnitedLinux banner By ZDNet Staff August 15, 2002 http://techupdate.zdnet.com/techupdate/stories/mai n/0,14179,2877578,00.html

  2. Figures... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

    Well, you thought that SCO's case had to be standing on SOMETHING, right? COlor me surprised! ;)

  3. In other news... by CrayzyJ · · Score: 4, Funny

    rocks are hard and water is wet.

    More at 11.

    --
    Holy s-, it's Jesus!
    1. Re:In other news... by escher · · Score: 4, Funny

      Counterexamples: magma, ice.

    2. Re:In other news... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

      okay, fine...

      rocks are wet and water is hard...

    3. Re:In other news... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

      Examples noted, please provide empirical evidence that magma doe indeed qualify as "wet" and that ice while qualifying as "hard" does not also qualify as "wet" even in that state.

      Also, magma and ice not being capable of existing in the same environmental conditions, may not meet the requirements of proper experimental research, therefore all experiments must be carried out at 0 degrees kelvin to avoid corruption of data, atmospheric pressure may be designated by the experimenter.

    4. Re:In other news... by escher · · Score: 3, Funny

      Crap. You win.

      *bows*

      Wait... I don't have to commit nerd ritual suicide now, do I?

      *prepares to FLEE*

  4. Really??!! by theparanoidcynic · · Score: 5, Funny

    I thought SCO was telling the truth the whole time. You mean to tell me that those bastardly socialist hackers have done nothing wrong? Impudence!

    --
    Only in a Slashdot fantasy can a Slackware install turn into several hours of sex . . . . .
    1. Re:Really??!! by theparanoidcynic · · Score: 3, Funny

      I think that would break me if it were true. It can't be true. I thought Redmond was a happy forest filled with drunken leprechauns and talking unicorns. I know it is . . . .

      * Runs off crying. *

      --
      Only in a Slashdot fantasy can a Slackware install turn into several hours of sex . . . . .
    2. Re:Really??!! by pixelpusher220 · · Score: 3, Funny

      Kind AND Honest? no

      Kind OF Honest? well you're getting closer ;-)


      --
      People in cars cause accidents....accidents in cars cause people :-D
  5. At $550 per hour... by Bull999999 · · Score: 5, Funny

    8. I have been retained by counsel for IBM in this lawsuit and am being compensated at a rate of $550 per hour.

    20. These comparisons required on the order of 10 hours of computation time on a dual 3 GHz Xeon processor system with 2 GB of RAM. This is a high-end workstation routinely and easily available off the shelf from commercial vendors such as Dell.


    At $550 per hour, I would've used something like a 386 processor with 8MB of RAM.

    --
    1f u c4n r34d th1s u r34lly n33d t0 g37 l41d
    1. Re:At $550 per hour... by Aardpig · · Score: 5, Funny

      At $550 per hour, I would've used something like a 386 processor with 8MB of RAM.

      Hell, I would have built a wetware turing machine using a dozen grad students armed with abacii. In treacle. With Natalie Portman implementing the I/O subsystem.

      --
      Tubal-Cain smokes the white owl.
    2. Re:At $550 per hour... by John+Harrison · · Score: 4, Funny

      At $550 an hour from IBM you think he would have at least had the decency to not plug Dell.

    3. Re:At $550 per hour... by Yewbert · · Score: 5, Funny
      Hell, I would have built a wetware turing machine using a dozen grad students armed with abacii. In treacle.

      Inevitably,...

      Imagine a Beowulf cluster of grad students armed with abacii,....

  6. What about all of these? by I_am_Rambi · · Score: 5, Funny

    What about these snippets? // /*
    */
    while(1)
    {
    }
    return(0);
    return(1);
    if (...)
    elseif (...)
    else

    And don't forget the white space! That is a clear copy!

    1. Re:What about all of these? by ClippyHater · · Score: 5, Funny

      elseif(...)

      Your compiler: We hates it, it burns us, precious, nasty syntax it is!

  7. It's a matrix... by GillBates0 · · Score: 4, Funny
    where there is no SCO code.

    SCO, don't try and claim that IBM has your code. That's impossible. Instead, realize the truth. There is no SCO code.

    --
    An Indian-American Hindu committed to non-violent thought/speech/action alarmed by the global explosion of radical Islam
  8. $550 an hour....and he reviewed 15 lines of code? by zerofoo · · Score: 4, Funny

    Where do I get a gig like that?

    He basically had some software look for similarities in the code, and then manually verified the hits.

    Wow....$550/hour to do that. I've got a CS degree - I'll volunteer to do it for half that!

    Oh yeah, he also explained the significance of return statements so that non-programmer types could understand.

    -ted

  9. Not So Fast Mr. Davis! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    That's ... that's ... that's because Randall Davis doesn't have the Secret SCO Decoder Ring (tm) (patent pending) (C 2004 SCO). The Decoder Ring ... it ... it detects our IP where no mere mortal could ever hope to find it!

    And now ... for a limited time only ... buy SCOSource licenses for 5 or more friends, and SCO will throw in a Secret SCO Decoder Ring (tm) (patent pending) (C 2004 SCO) at no additional charge!

    My name is Darl McBride, and I have authorized this message!

  10. busted! by 192939495969798999 · · Score: 5, Funny

    SCO: b-b-but, you're not supposed to use a COMPUTER SCIENTIST!
    IBM: byte us.

    --
    stuff |
  11. IBM has WMD, claims SCO. by ARRRLovin · · Score: 4, Funny

    SCO claims an attack from IBM, using these weapons, is imminent. SCO has 2 carrier battle groups in the area and 250,000 troops on call to go in and find the WMD, pending UN approval. More news to come.....

    --
    -Randy
  12. SCO hasn't played their trump card yet... by SpaceBadger · · Score: 3, Funny

    Your honour, when we apply the standard abstraction and filtration phases to any Unix System V file we can clearly see that the resulting 0 byte file is identical to every abstracted and filtered 0 byte file in the latest Linux kernel.

  13. Re:Finally... by glib909 · · Score: 5, Funny

    They're not quite dead yet.

    SCO: I don't want to go on the cart!

    Oh, don't be such a baby. You're not fooling anyone, you'll be stone dead in a moment.
    --
    Suudsu, that stuff is G-E-W-D.
  14. IBM had to do this... by dR.fuZZo · · Score: 4, Funny

    To strengthen their case, IBM needed to trot out an MIT professor to counteract all of those fictional MIT folks that found this infringement in the first place.

    --
    -- dR.fuZZo
  15. SCO has their 'expert' by Hamster+Of+Death · · Score: 3, Funny

    SCO has apparently already recruited their expert, apparently it's this guy. SCO Expert

  16. Darl sez... by phyruxus · · Score: 5, Funny
    Darl McBride was reached for comment and had the following comments to make:

    There are no American tanks in Baghdad!
    They are nowhere near Baghdad.
    Their forces committed suicide by the hundreds.... The battle is very fierce and God made us victorious. The fighting continues.

    Ooops, wrong script. (fumbles with papers)

    IBM is lying about the lack of stolen code.
    We need another delay to find stolen code.
    There can be no doubt that Linux contains stolen code.

    --
    "A witty saying proves nothing." ~Voltaire
    "d'Oh!" ~Homer
  17. In related news... by IronChefMorimoto · · Score: 3, Funny

    In related news, the same researcher has determined that the brown stripe in the BVD briefs of 77-year-old Frank Wilson of Alatoosa, Mississippi does not contain SCO bullshit.

    Wilson was subpoenaed on July 3, 2004 for apparently using SCO Unix bullshit in his underwear. SCO lawyers contended that, in addition to all of their other bullshit, this particular stripe of fecal matter in Wilson's BVDs was, in fact, similar the other bullshit that they have spread around since they began their legal actions.

    Wilson, a World War II veteran and resident at the Shady Acres Memory Care facility on the western edge of Alatoosa, was not immediately aware of what SCO was in the first place.

    "I thought it was the VA -- finally giving me my money for that piece of Kraut shrapnel I took in 1942! Fucking Krauts! Where's my applesauce? Is my wife around?"

    Officials at the memory care facility noted that Wilson is an Alzheimers patient who frequently forgets to wipe himself after using the bedpan, hence the source of the stripe in his underwear. They were aware of the legal action again Wilson by SCO, but rather than stir up his angina and blood pressure by witholding the mail that he watches being delivered every day, they let him open the SCO legal letter himself.

    "We're just glad he didn't keel over with a stroke," said Frank Johnson, the head nurse of the memory care facility. "He just ranted about the VA and pissed down his leg while asking for his son, who has been dead for 16 years after a car accident. It could've been a lot worse."

    The examination of the fecal stripe in the suspect pair of BVDs turned up concrete evidence that, in fact, the shit was Wilson's. In fact, it was not even bullshit and thus not legally open to subpoena by SCO on the grounds that it was more of SCO's bullshit. No countersuit has been filed, as Wilson's surviving family members have apparently never visited him at the facility and only wish to pay the bills for his care.

    IronChefMorimoto

  18. Re:His resume! by kzinti · · Score: 3, Funny

    "I have also been retained by the Department of Justice in its investigation of the INSLAW matter. In 1992 (and later in 1995) my task in that engagement was to investigate alleged copyright theft and subsequent cover-up by the Federal Bureau of Investigations, the National Security Agency, the Drug Enforcement Agency, the United States Customs Service, and the Defense Intelligence Agency."

    So Professor Davis can not only tell us that there is no SCO code in linux, but he should also be able to tell us how much crack the SCO weasels had to smoke before formulating their outrageous claims.

  19. SCO Stalling by helmespc · · Score: 3, Funny

    I think SCO is stalling so that they can rewrite their code to match the Linux code...

  20. Maybe SCO should get Dan Rathers help. by 1shooter · · Score: 4, Funny

    Dan and CBS is very good at finding documents even when they don't exist so they ought to be able to find code that was "stolen" from SCO.

    --
    6F 9E A9 1E 96 9F 74 27 ED B8 81 6D 0C 4E 1E 78
    My other Sig is a 229.
  21. SCO MATRIX by rock_climbing_guy · · Score: 4, Funny
    Do not try to find the code. That's impossible.

    Only try to realize the truth: There is no code.

    Then you will see it is not the code that is gone; it is only your head.

    --
    Wh47 d1d j00 541, 31337 15n't t3h r0xor5 ne m0r3???