Slashdot Mirror


Wanna Buy a Reusable Rocket for 19k USD?

Anonymous Coward writes with story from the Mainchi Daily News: "'Earlier this month, Hokkaido University started putting its Camui rockets on the open market. Camui rockets are true rockets, being 1.6 meters long, flying at 300 meters per second and parachuting slowly to the ground after reaching heights of up to 1 kilometer.' The Camui use a mixture of fixed fuel acrylic and liquid oxygen."

47 of 153 comments (clear)

  1. Be sure to read the fine print: by Black+Parrot · · Score: 5, Funny

    "Not recommended for use near airports or presidential motorcades."

    --
    Sheesh, evil *and* a jerk. -- Jade
    1. Re:Be sure to read the fine print: by polecat_redux · · Score: 4, Funny

      Buying one of those rockets these days is a sure-fire way to get a puppet regime installed in your living room.

    2. Re:Be sure to read the fine print: by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

      Buying one of those rockets these days is a sure-fire way to get a puppet regime installed in your living room.

      So is marriage.

    3. Re:Be sure to read the fine print: by Skye16 · · Score: 2, Interesting

      This may not even be legal in the United States - at least for long.

      I mean, come on, if they're going to ban model rockets like Estes (and their engines), how long until they do the same with these?

    4. Re:Be sure to read the fine print: by eam · · Score: 2, Interesting

      They're going to ban Estes rockets?

    5. Re:Be sure to read the fine print: by Skye16 · · Score: 4, Interesting

      I guess not the rockets themselves, just the engines.

      1
      2

      And I'm sure Google has even more info on it. I haven't seen anything new on it, so I have no idea what has happened since then. I haven't seen any new complaints, but I also haven't seen anything to indicate people being happy it didn't pass, so...

  2. WMD? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    This seems much more of a WMD than the Iraqi aluminum tubes. When does the bombing start?

    1. Re:WMD? by Guppy06 · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Why? Japan is the largest aircraft carrier in the US Navy!

  3. Bonfire night by peterprior · · Score: 3, Funny

    Well, bonfire night in the UK is less than a month away. I wonder what the shipping time is on these. :)

  4. Camui rockets suck by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    I don't want to start a holy war here, but what is the deal with you Camui rocket fanatics? I've been sitting here at my freelance gig in front of a Camui rocket (a 300m/s w/1km altitude max) for about 20 minutes now while it attempts to copy a 17 Meg file from one folder on the hard drive to another folder. 20 minutes. At home, on my Titan IV running 150m/s, which by all standards should be a lot slower than this Camui, the same operation would take about 2 minutes. If that.

    In addition, during this file transfer, the guidance system will not work. And everything else has ground to a halt. Even GPS is straining to keep up as I type this.

    I won't bore you with the laundry list of other problems that I've encountered while working on various Camuis, but suffice it to say there have been many, not the least of which is I've never seen a Camui that has run faster than its Boeing counterpart, despite the Camui's faster propellant architecture. My hobby kit model rocket with helicopter nose cose runs faster than this 300m/s rocket at times. From a productivity standpoint, I don't get how people can claim that the Camui is a superior machine.

    Camui addicts, flame me if you'd like, but I'd rather hear some intelligent reasons why anyone would choose to use a Camui over other faster, cheaper, more stable systems.

    1. Re:Camui rockets suck by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

      Never underestimate the bandwidth-distance of a Camui rocket filled with DAT-72 tapes...

      Might be a possible candiate for a new "space speed record" for data.

    2. Re:Camui rockets suck by KrunZ · · Score: 2, Funny

      If they like auto trolls complaints, why not expect a little more. E.g. from Scott Pakins Complaint generator:

      http://www.pakin.org/complaint?firstname=Camui&p gr aphs=10&gender=c

      "The purpose of this letter is to outline a plan to rise to the challenge of thwarting Camui's money-grubbing, vile plans. Let's review the errors in Camui's statements in order. First, Camui's use of acrimonious scrubs is unquestionably pathetic. I do not find warnings that are stingy, sexist, and impolitic to be "funny". Maybe I lack a sense of humor, but maybe in order to solve the big problems with Camui, we must first understand these problems, and to understand them, we must replace today's chaos and lack of vision with order and a supreme sense of purpose.

      Camui will probably never understand why it scares me so much. And it does scare me: Its double standards are scary, its snow jobs are scary, and most of all, it has never gotten ahead because of its hard work or innovative ideas. Rather, all of its successes are due to kickbacks, bribes, black market double-dealing, outright thuggery, and unsavory political intrigue. Camui's wheelings and dealings leave me with several unanswered questions: Will peeling back the onion of its treacherous philippics cause it to shed tears or will it merely enhance its desire to manipulate everything and everybody? And when it looks in the mirror in the morning, does Camui see more than the same, dissolute face that all randy, flagitious worrywarts share? These are difficult questions to answer, because Camui hides behind the carefully managed prevarication that neurotic, brassbound geeks are easily housebroken. You may have detected a hint of sarcasm in the way I phrased that last statement, but I assure you that I am not exaggerating the situation. If Camui can't be reasoned out of its prejudices, it must be laughed out of them. If Camui can't be argued out of its selfishness, it must be shamed out of it.

      I may be beating a dead horse here, but I do want to point out that I find that some of Camui's choices of words in its pranks would not have been mine. For example, I would have substituted "ugly" for "hexosemonophosphoric" and "piteous" for "anthropomorphotheist." If there is one thing I have learned, it is this: At no time in the past did mean-spirited warmongers shamble through the streets of cities, demanding rights they imagine some supernatural power has bestowed upon them. Camui's smears are based on a denial of reality, on the substitution of a deliberately falsified picture of the world in place of reality. And this dishonesty, this refusal to admit the truth, will have some very serious consequences for all of us some day.

      What that means, simply put, is that I have traveled the length and breadth of this country and talked with the best people. I can therefore assure you that I have a dream that my children will be able to live in a world filled with open spaces and beautiful wilderness -- not in a dark, wishy-washy world run by surly cozeners. If my memory serves me correctly, Camui's cronies believe that anyone who resists Camui deserves to be crushed. It should not be surprising that they believe this, however. As we all know, minds that have been so maimed that they believe that we ought to worship bloodthirsty fast-buck artists as folk heroes can believe anything, especially if it's false. There is a problem here. A very large, frowzy, coldhearted ..."

  5. regulations by rguiu · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Can anybody buy his/her own rocket and launch it from the backyard?

    With so much airtraffic is not a danger?

    Can be this technology used for making weapons? I remember the article of someone building cruise missiles: http://slashdot.org/articles/03/12/09/205252.shtml ?tid=137

    Seems very nice, but I would not like a plane shot down because a rich kid was playing with one of this toys.

    1. Re:regulations by DrXym · · Score: 2, Interesting
      I was landing at San Jose airport once and there were fireworks were exploding all around the plane. I have no idea why, and I doubt a tiny cracker would harm a jet, but it didn't seem like a good thing to me.

      Still, if I were a terrorist I wouldn't be looking to buy some proper rocket system. Over the counter fireworks seem like a great way to dump anthrax spores over a wide area. Do it at an event like bonfire night, July 4, New Years Eve etc. and you'd probably have a nice crowd of people standing underneath to infect too.

    2. Re:regulations by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

      Concerned your plane might be shot down by a rich kid's rocket?

      Sir, the affordable Camui range is aimed at the masses so your plane is much more likely to be brought down by missiles fired by kids from lower income families.

      I trust this allays your fears.

      Camui Marketing Director

    3. Re:regulations by DrXym · · Score: 2, Informative

      Firework rockets usually consist of gunpowder propellant (to get them into the air), an explosive charge (i.e. more gunpowder tightly wrapped) and pellets containing various metallic compounds for the colourful 'starburst'. If you removed the pellets and packed it with your pathogen of choice it would have the desired effect. I imagine some thick cardboard would insulate the contents sufficiently for most of it to survive.

    4. Re:regulations by jguthrie · · Score: 2, Informative
      Can anybody buy a rocket and launch it from his backyard? Well, it depends on where you live. If you live in the United States, then the answer is a qualified "yes". It's "qualified" because you're not supposed to launch any rockets near airports.

      The air traffic is not really an issue, even near a airports. It's hard to hit an airplane with a rocket. That's why military missles are guided and typically use some sort of proximity fuse and explosive warhead. Those guidance systems and warheads with proximity fuses are not generally available to the general public.

      Anyway, the regulations recognize three different categories of rockets. If you have a rocket that masses no more than 453 grams and has no more than 113g of grams of propellant, with no more than 62.5 grams in any given engine, then you have what is known as a "model rocket" and you can launch from anywhere that isn't near an airport it without telling anybody you're going to do it.

      If you have a rocket that masses no more than 1500 grams and has no more than 125 grams of propellant, with no more than 62.5 grams of propellant in each engine, and a total impulse of no more than 160 NS and an average thrust of no more than 80 Newtons, then you have what's known as a "large model rocket", and you need to notify the FAA before you launch it.

      If you have a rocket that masses more than 1500 grams, or has more than 125 grams of propellant or has more than 62.5 grams of propellant in any one engine, has a total impulse of more than 160 NS or an average impulse of more than 80 Newtons, then you have a "high power rocket" which requires that you get the FAA's permission to launch it.

      There are two organizations supporting model and amateur rocketry in the USA. The National Association of Rocketry and the Tripoli Rocketry Association. Those web sites have links to local chapters all over the country.

      Whether or not you can legally buy the propellant (premanufactured "single use" engines are recognized by everyone as legal to buy, sell, and use) is a matter of opinion, and there are lawsuits pending on that subject right now. If you have an interest in these matters, please donate the NAR legal fund or the TRA legal fund.

      The guys I know who do high-power (I'm starting to do LMR's now) made a great deal of fun of these Camui rockets because the high-power guys build rockets that go a great deal higher for a lot less money. A $300 investment can get you a completely reusable rocket that goes up a couple of kilometers as well as the propellant for one flight.

    5. Re:regulations by The_REAL_DZA · · Score: 3, Interesting

      "Can this technology used for making weapons?"

      For some strange reason, there's something | There
      called a "lameness filter" that repeatedly | are
      rejected all attempts to post this message | lots
      the way I wanted it to appear and saying I | of
      had too few characters per line and that I | technologies
      needed to reduce the count of "junk" chars | that
      per line in my post. Perhaps it's just me, | can
      but I think that making me do something so | be
      TOTALLY HOKEY as THIS, JUST so the post'll | used
      appear the way I intended for it to appear | to
      somehow seems MUCH more hokey, in the long | make
      run... But maybe I'm just being too ornery | weapons...

      You just have to learn to think like this guy
      and turn yourself into a human one of these.

      --


      This space intentionally left (almost) blank.
    6. Re:regulations by solodex2151 · · Score: 2, Informative

      All of the existing regulations in place for High Power Rocketry would apply to these rockets. You need a cleared FAA wavier in order to fly anything above 2500 feet. These are not hard to obtain, and 95% of the population in the US is within 3-4 hours of a high power capable launch site. On the other hand, rockets are NOT capable of shooting down planes. Some government agencies tried proving this before, but were unsuccessful and looked like idiots doing it. Also, the rockets are not impressive at all. You can construct a much larger rocket out of composites with a homebuilt hybrid engine using HTTB and LOx as fuel compenents for under 500 dollars.

  6. Wanna Buy a Reusable Rocket for 19k USD? by Prophetic_Truth · · Score: 5, Funny

    No, Not really.

    --
    time is a perception of a being's consciousness
    time is your 6th sense, the wierd ones are 7+
  7. why is this here? by poptones · · Score: 5, Interesting

    a km? I made a solid fuel estes when I was in Jr. High that would go to 3000ft (more or less a km) and it required none of that other crap. It was about a meter tall, had three stages, and used three solid fuel engines that, all combined, cost about ten bucks.

    Why is this a story? Someone deisgned and constructed an overpriced, hard to use, liquid fuel rocket that can be outperformed by a twenty year old Estes and is offering copies of it for sale, but no one has been stupid enough to buy one yet. This is news?

    1. Re:why is this here? by Spy+Handler · · Score: 5, Informative

      Agreed.... this thing runs on LIQUID OXYGEN for chrissakes, it should be going 60,000 feet or more. Some of the high-powered homemade rockets those guys shoot in the Nevada desert easily go 60,000 feet or more, and cost way less than 10 grand. Maybe the original article misprinted the altitude, maybe it was 10km rather than 1km.

    2. Re:why is this here? by really? · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I think that's the case; you can see towards the bottom of the article they talk of "60Km" ... from one to 60 would be quite a bit of a jump.

      --

      "Consistency is contrary to nature, contrary to life. The only completely consistent people are the dead." A. Huxley
    3. Re:why is this here? by ceeam · · Score: 3, Funny

      The problem w/ 60km is that you can be sure you won't be the first one to pick it from the landing site.

    4. Re:why is this here? by craXORjack · · Score: 2, Funny
      a km?

      Yes, but Japanese are short so 1 km probably seems much more impressive to them.

      --
      Liberals call everyone Nazis yet they are the closest thing to it.
  8. Re:Second Amendment by rguiu · · Score: 3, Interesting

    can a libian/sirian/north korean citizen protect his own backyard from US airliners too? How far can travel this "second amendment"?

  9. To summarize by ceeam · · Score: 4, Funny

    19k big firework that you need some liquid oxygen to launch. Hm... Sounds like a bargain, what's the catch?

  10. +2 informative? by RMH101 · · Score: 2, Funny

    can we turn this into a "which is the better platform: crack or crystal meth" thread?

  11. On road costs by hfis · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Whilst 19k sounds like an "ok" (hah) price, imagine the 'on road' costs of running this thing. That fuel isn't cheap, no matter where you are..

  12. Re:Second Amendment by Stone+Rhino · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Countries have sovereignty over their airspace, just as they do over their seas. They're free to withdraw overflight privileges and shoot down any plane that tries to enter, but to do so is likely to cause a diplomatic incident.

    --


    Remember, there were no nuclear weapons before women were allowed to vote.
  13. IN OTHER NEWS: by nilbog · · Score: 5, Funny

    The Bush administration has found evidence of a massive WMD missile facility in your backyard.

    --
    or else!
    1. Re:IN OTHER NEWS: by nathanh · · Score: 3, Insightful
      The Bush administration has found evidence of a massive WMD missile facility in your backyard.

      That's OK. You have no oil in your backyard so you're perfectly safe, just like North Korea.

  14. One most important question! by ceeam · · Score: 4, Funny

    Is there a section for a cat or do you strap it externally? Do they provide a tiny helmet?

  15. Wanna build a reuseable rocket for 20 bucks USD? by mikeophile · · Score: 3, Interesting
  16. pictures ... by weighn · · Score: 5, Informative

    there's some pics here. and a cnn story here.

    --
    Mongrel News all the news that fits and froths
  17. Ainu by kahei · · Score: 3, Informative


    The real significance of this project is that it's probably about the last time anyone names anything in Ainu, the old language of Japan... ...although SNK fans will recall that Nakoruru's moves are named in Ainu, and her 'Kamui Mutsube' is Ainu for 'God Blade'. The real Ainu pronunciation would be more like 'Mutpe' though. Okay, I'm rambling.

    --
    Whence? Hence. Whither? Thither.
  18. It will go absolutely perfectly... by vudufixit · · Score: 3, Funny

    With the surplus decommissioned missile silo I picked up for a pittance. Next step: declaring my fully armed and operational missile silo sovereign territory. Surviving relatives of Randy Weaver, Ted Kaczinsky and David Koresh are welcome to stay with me.

  19. Within Three Seconds? by Rie+Beam · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I Googled for "Camui rockets", to see if the whole "1 km" deal was true. From what I read, this article was taken from an AP article, which originally read:

    "The Camui-50P rocket was developed by a team from Hokkaido University and can fly as high as one kilometer (0.6 mile) within three seconds after take off"

    Dunno if that means "that's as high as it gets" or "that's how high it can get within that short amount of time"; for $19,000, though, let's hope it's the second one.
    1. Re:Within Three Seconds? by Natchswing · · Score: 3, Informative
      Let's see. One kilometer in one second. This would require an average velocity of flight of, oh... 1 km/s. If we had linear acceleration (rough estimate) and we started from zero (sounds like a safe assumption) then we'll have 2 km/s by the time we hit 1km altitude.

      If the fuel is cut there:

      vf^2=vo^2-2*a*s or 1000^2/(2*9.8)=50km

      That sounds a bit better. Loki Darts could do that.

  20. reaching heights of up to 1 kilometer.. by D4MO · · Score: 4, Funny

    ..at 300 meters per second. A little over 3 seconds worth of blast. Hey, lasts longer than me, honey.

    --

    Rocket science is easy. Neurosurgery, now *that's* difficult.
  21. What makes this a "True Rocket?" by DevilsEngine · · Score: 5, Informative

    I have hybrid engine models (acrylic / NO2) that are larger and go higher. Heck, I had refillable solid engine models that were considerably more powerful -- though with new regulations, getting the refills has become too much of a hassle. I don't see anything to this that wasn't available in dozens, if not hundreds, of High Power Rocketry models available ten years ago. Standing next to me at the moment (in two pieces, because it's too tall to be assembled indoors) is a 11' tall model on 5.5" tubing (at base, step down to 4" at top). Hybrid engine in the "L" range. It's made half a dozen flights on hybrid power, and a couple before that with solids. Easily clears a mile. Next to it is a LOC Magnum, a standard kit available for nearly a decade, with what has to be a good twenty flights to better than a kilometer on a "J" class hybrid. What makes these any less "true rockets?"

  22. Wanna buy a re-usable rocket for 19k by El+Batemano · · Score: 2, Informative

    No and ill tell you why, Hobby stores sell a reusable rocket with a paracute and using solid based cheap fuels that can reach a thousad meters for twenty quid. Although the one i bought turn itself into a missile shortly after take off. Skimming the heads of passers by and embedding itself into a tree. So im sure the one for 19k is a bit safer!!

  23. Re:Ah, that's tame. by pklong · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Nukes don't kill people, people do.

    --

    Philip

    Signatures are broken

  24. Playboy magazine? by tod_miller · · Score: 2, Funny

    Star-struck space lovers can now buy their own bona fide rockets, thanks to a Hokkaido University aiming for the stars, according to Weekly Playboy (10/26).

    ?? So I am not the only one who reads the articles?

    Lets think seriously:

    1: When does linux get installed
    2: What kind of imaging can we expect
    3: Some more money than sense geek gonna hack us up a nice GPS tracking and imaging softwqare with gyro compass and GIS based ground sensing auto navigation?

    Neat.

    --
    #hostfile 0.0.0.0 primidi.com 0.0.0.0 www.primidi.com 0.0.0.0 radio.weblogs.com
  25. Real Rockets! by Natchswing · · Score: 4, Interesting
    > Camui rockets are true rockets (...) reaching heights of up to 1 kilometer.

    One kilometer?? DEBI was a real rocket. [pictures] About 30 feet long, two stage solid fuel. With 40 G's acceleration it reached mach 10 in a little under 30 seconds (below 40km altitude) and sailed to a apogee of about 800km. Since the rocket had a ballistic trajectory we needed clearance through the pentagon to circumvent the anti-ballistic missle treaty.

    Even little baby Loki Dart's will reach 50km on a good day.

  26. Re:Second Amendment by foobsr · · Score: 2, Interesting

    One of those U2s was also shot above the SU a little earlier.

    CC.

    --
    TaijiQuan (Huang, 5 loosenings)
  27. Talk about overpriced by pilot-programmer · · Score: 2, Informative

    I am level 2 certified through the National Association of Rocketry and Tripoli Rocketry Association. I have rockets, built from kits purchased for under $200 and propelled by solid fuel motors for around $200 or hybrid motors for about $100 that can carry a 0.5 pound payload far higher than one kilometer. Anybody on this list who is willing to take a few evenings to build a rocket kit, spend the money to join NAR or TRA, and join the nearest high power rocketry club will be able to launch a small TV transmitter with telemetry over one km and save $18,000 over the Japanese liquid rocket. And if you are really into liquid fuels, you can even find amateurs working with those.