Slashdot Mirror


George Lucas to Receive Lifetime Achievement Award

KefabiMe writes "George Lucas is receiving the AFI Lifetime Achievement award. I will make no other comment."

47 of 277 comments (clear)

  1. Lucas Also Plans by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    To receive the Lifetime Achievement Award Special Edition in 2005, and the Super Extended Lifetime Achievement Award Special Edition Platinum in 2014.

    1. Re:Lucas Also Plans by feidaykin · · Score: 5, Funny
      Yeah, in a recent interview, Lucas said:

      "I was only about 40% happy with the original award. There were things we just couldn't do when I first got it. The new award, I am 95% happy with. The fans of the awards may take some issue with it, but the award is for me, not them."

      Spoiling the joke by explaining it here: The 40% figure is what Lucas said about how happy he was with the original Star Wars when it was finished in 1977. He then went on to say he was 95% happy with Episode I. Which proves that the less happy he is with a film, the more happy everyone else is... ;)

      --

      "To confine our attention to terrestrial matters would be to limit the human spirit." -Stephen Hawking

    2. Re:Lucas Also Plans by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

      in an irritating form of CGI ;)

    3. Re:Lucas Also Plans by OverflowingBitBucket · · Score: 4, Funny

      I notice Harrison Ford won it in 2000. So Han (sorry Ford) won it first.

      Give it a few years, and they'll release a special edition of the award, where Lucas wins first.

  2. Remastered trilogy by Nova1313 · · Score: 3, Funny

    I didn't know trashing the trilogy was an achievement... go figure... fp?

    --
    There exists some positive integer N that you are the Nth person to read this signature.
  3. Hmmmm... by koh · · Score: 4, Funny

    I was unaware that giving birth to Jar-Jar Binks was considered as a "life achievement"...

    Then again, everything depends on what you mean by "achievement".

    --
    Karma cannot be described by words alone.
    1. Re:Hmmmm... by meringuoid · · Score: 5, Funny

      It's an immense achievement. Jar-Jar was so bad that it made the Ewoks look like fucking Shaft.

      --
      Real Daleks don't climb stairs - they level the building.
    2. Re:Hmmmm... by Tackhead · · Score: 3, Funny
      > > "Jar-Jar was so bad that it made the Ewoks look like fucking Shaft"
      >
      >I hope you're happy. I'll never be able to watch Shaft again without imagining an Ewok playing the role :).

      Who's the furry private dick
      That's a sex machine to all the chicks?
      WICKET!
      Yub dammmn nub!

      Coatee cha tu goo (Shaft!)
      coatee cha tu doo (Shaft!)
      coatee cha tu too (Shaft!)
      Allay loo ta nuv!

  4. woohoo by Turn-X+Alphonse · · Score: 4, Funny

    All we need, now he'll think he's good and remaster Indian jones... and Indie wont shoot first.

    --
    I like muppets.
    1. Re:woohoo by ibentmywookie · · Score: 5, Funny

      Indian Jones? What are they outsourcing fucking movie actors now?

      --
      -- The doctor said I wouldn't get so many nose bleeds if I just kept my finger out of there!
  5. Its not over! by bigwayne · · Score: 5, Funny

    I can't wait until 20 years down the road, when he releases the DVD of the AFI program, replacing a 60 year old Lucas with a virile 20 year old version of himself. There will be space battles, too.

    --
    400 Person LAN for Charity: Zion LAN 2005
  6. I thought by jstrain · · Score: 3, Insightful

    that that award was for someone who continues to innovate and pursue new things, not someone who does something great and spends the next 20 years tinkering with minute details of said work.

  7. Lifetime Achievement Award by slimyrubber · · Score: 4, Funny

    For remastering dvd to show a puppet, now with more wrinkles!?

    --
    [ I can not bring myself to believe that if knowledge presents danger, the solution is ignorance ] -- Isaac Asimov
  8. This one's got a bad motivator! by bbzzdd · · Score: 3, Funny

    <Wilhelm-Scream>AHHHHHHHHH! AHHHHHHHH!</Wilhelm-Scream>

  9. Re:I will. by Penguinoflight · · Score: 5, Insightful

    That's just the sad thing of this award. If the film industry had realized the long ranging impact of the 3 originals, they probably would have handed Lucas the award in the 80s. By now recieving an award doesn't make any sense because of low quality prequals, etc... but how can you know something is a classic in less than 10 years?

    --
    "And we have seen and do testify that the Father sent the Son to be the Savior of the World"
    1 John 4:14
  10. and maybe next year... by YodaToo · · Score: 4, Funny
    William Shatner will get a life time achivement award for "acting."

    Although I will say they have finally found a good character for his over-acting on Boston Legal.

  11. Lifetime Achievement Award Requirements by modifried · · Score: 5, Informative
    "The Life Achievement Award honors an individual whose career in motion pictures or television has greatly contributed to the enrichment of American culture.

    The criteria stated that "the recipient should be one whose talent has in a fundamental way advanced the film art; whose accomplishment has been acknowledged by scholars, critics, professional peers and the general public; and whose work has stood the test of time." In 1993, AFI trustees extended the criteria to encompass individuals with active careers and work of significance yet to be accomplished. "

    (From http://www.afi.com/tvevents/laa/laasite/)

  12. Lucas was a visionary by Goodl · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Despite the debacles that are the 'new' trilogy, no fan could watch the extras DVD that came with Star Wars and deny that it brought a lump to the throat to see how the film that defined space adventure for a generation was literally dragged kicking and screaming to the screen, all despite incredible odds, horrendous bad luck and dumbass studio execs through the sheer force of will and unshakable self belief that the story he was telling had to be told. Much as I really dont like how he conducts himself these days, no-one could say the man hasn't earned his place in history and in the hearts and minds of thirtysomethings globally. I can't hear the opening bars of the John Williams theme without getting chills down my spine and I'm sure I'm not the only one.

    --
    I've got some photographs, I'd like to show them to you. Though you don't know the girls You'll recognise the view..
    1. Re:Lucas was a visionary by Jugalator · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Good god, do you really have some sort of emotional bond with the original trilogy to such an extent that it affects you physically just being reminded of it? That's not insightful, that's sad.

      This "emotional bond" you speak of is common among people who like a movie, or any art form for that sake, a lot. I feel sad for you if you've never found a good enough movie to experience it. I can listen to great pieces of music and it gives me chills, and I can watch movies that brings me to tears. A whole lot of us can. I hope you can feel some kind of emotions when watching movies, since it's great things to experience. :-)

      I can't imagine how boring going to the cinemas would be if you couldn't create an emotional bond to some of the characters, for example by humor, anger, love, sadness, or something else.

      Star Wars was a good bunch of movies. But they certainly aren't anyhing to spend more than a few seconds reminiscing about.

      What can I say... That's just your opinion, and if you have a hard time accepting others, feeling the need to look down on others, you're just narrow-minded.

      --
      Beware: In C++, your friends can see your privates!
  13. The man deserves it by Dancin_Santa · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Having the dumb luck to stumble into the greatest movie franchise in history, Lucas has taken that little bit of luck and transformed it into his vision of a complete alternate universe. Had he been any other short-sighted director (Spielberg, I'm looking right at you and your last half of A.I.) the Star Wars trilogy would have simply ended with the dance of the Ewoks. However, Lucas was able to transform that complete story into a more complete story by going back and fixing and editing and putting in scenes that were originally not his vision in the first place. I hate to use the word visionary, but Lucas truly has a vision.

    The problem is that most people cannot understand the mind of a visionary and it isn't until long after they fade into irrelevance that they truly become appreciated. So too it is with Lucas, I believe. Many people are so worried about their childhood memories that they cry wolf every time Lucas decides to change a scene. Nevermind the fact that the whole Star Wars universe makes more sense when the updated (Director's Cut, if you will) scenes are added to the films.

    Lucas truly does deserve this award not only for what rich memories he brought to us when we were still kids, but also for the memories he gives kids of the future. When we look back in 20 years and reminisce about the Star Wars Nonology we will finally see why Greedo had to shoot first and why Jar Jar was crucial to the story of Anakin Skywalker.

    1. Re:The man deserves it by Dunkelzahn · · Score: 4, Interesting

      I think Revenge of the Sith is going to change alot of people's views of the Prequels and the Original Trilogy, in a good way. Judging from various leaks, spoilers, and Hyperspace tidbits, I think Revenge of the Sith will be the best of the prequels, and will be more than worthwhile.

      As for Jar-Jar - we're supposed to hate him. He's the dumb bitch who hands the Republic over to Palpatine on a silver platter, so...

      --
      .
    2. Re:The man deserves it by op51n · · Score: 5, Insightful

      When we look back in 20 years and reminisce about the Star Wars Nonology we will finally see why Greedo had to shoot first and why Jar Jar was crucial to the story of Anakin Skywalker.

      I totally disagree. I have tried not to care about the changes he continues to make, as I have copies of the original release that will keep me happy, but I just can't fathom his decisions. Well... No, that's not quite true.

      I took a look at the comparison of the three releases, and the apparently dodgy censorship (the red flashes in the prison scene) and Greedo's shooting first, only appear to be ways of making the film more kid friendly. As of course Jar Jar and the awful slapstick he added in the Mos Eisley approach and other inserts also go to show.
      I just can't understand why he is doing this. It removes about thirteen layers from Han's character, making him fairly uninteresting for a start.

      It's not that I'm worried about my childhood memories. Like I say, I have the originals, my memories are intact. The problem is, now anyone who hasn't seen the originals will see the new DVD release, and it's not the same movie. I can fully appreciate a director's wish to go back and fix special effects, and even insert some new scenes to expand the scale - like with Mos Eisley. But I'd do it seriously. Adding laughs into those bits is lame and wrong pacewise.

      Basically, he's taken his movies, and turned them into a cleaner, more child-friendly franchise. I almost wouldn't be surprised if he does release the unaltered remastered editions to get the rest of the available cash, but that depends on if he's willing to allow such violence to be seen! I've lost pretty much all my respect for the guy, aside from, as someone mentioned, what he did for sound and effects in the industry.

    3. Re:The man deserves it by WaterBreath · · Score: 3, Insightful

      I've got to wholeheartedly agree with the general sense of this article, that Lucas does deserve this award. I think people are overlooking some things when they consider this.

      First of all, Lucas has made more than 5 movies. Second, Lucas has made more than 5 blockbuster movies. (He had to be doing something right.) Third, not only has he made blockbuster movies, but he's made meaningful movies, such as American Grafitti and THX-1138.

      Regarding people's newfound hate of Lucas for his remastering/editing of the Star Wars Trilogy... I'll admit that I'm young enough that I saw the first three movies on VHS when I was very young. When the remastered versions came out I didn't remember the originals very well. It was like seeing them for the first time. And from that viewpoint I can tell you that the remakes are still good movies. I also think the prequels are good. As good as the originals. The problem is that the overall quality of movies in general has improved so much. There are many movies that flop today, but would have been blockbusters in the 1970s. The prequels are just not as far above the average today as the originals were when they came out.

      Lucas essentially created the film epic. It may have been tried before, but Lucas was the first to do it successfully in both the eyes of his peers and the eyes of the public. And I'll go so far as to say that he has had no rival. The Matrix started out great, but most of the people that went to the third one did it only out of half-hearted hope and a desire for some sort of closure. The LOTR trilogy is awesome, but it's an adaptation, not an original work like Star Wars. (And don't talk about theft of concepts, because Tolkein was just as "bad", stealing from all sorts of mythologies.)

      Lucas deserves this award, if solely for what he did with the original Star Wars movies. Even if you can't get over his recent changes, that doesn't changes how he affected the movie industry.

  14. Re:I will. by mankey+wanker · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Hey, I practically hate most of the guy's movies - but let's not forget what Lucas has done for special effects, cinema sound, etc. Somehow he was also partly responsible for the film "Mishima" which I think is quite brilliant. "American Graffiti" wasn't bad either.

    But anyway, the next time the special effects appear to be seemless and the sound quality vibrates your theater seat - remember Lucas for caring about that stuff. He's certainly moved some things along which is more than most people do.

  15. past winners by Pompatus · · Score: 5, Informative

    According to MSN Encarta (hey, it was the first one I found on a google search) these are the past winners of the AFI Lifetime achievement award.

    1973 John Ford
    1974 James Cagney
    1975 Orson Welles
    1976 William Wyler
    1977 Bette Davis
    1978 Henry Fonda
    1979 Alfred Hitchcock
    1980 James Stewart
    1981 Fred Astaire
    1982 Frank Capra
    1983 John Huston
    1984 Lillian Gish
    1985 Gene Kelly
    1986 Billy Wilder
    1987 Barbara Stanwyck
    1988 Jack Lemmon
    1989 Gregory Peck
    1990 Sir David Lean
    1991 Kirk Douglas
    1992 Sidney Poitier
    1993 Elizabeth Taylor
    1994 Jack Nicholson
    1995 Steven Spielberg
    1996 Clint Eastwood
    1997 Martin Scorsese
    1998 Robert Wise
    1999 Dustin Hoffman
    2000 Harrison Ford
    2001 Barbra Streisand
    2002 Tom Hanks
    2003 Robert De Niro
    2004 Meryl Streep

    There are some pretty serious names on that list. My point is, why now? The nostalgia for the first trilogy of films is good and all, but really, they were only 3 movies.

    --

    ----
    Squirrel ... It's not just for breakfast anymore
    1. Re:past winners by TheKidWho · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Stanley Kubrick should be on that list

    2. Re:past winners by fallen1 · · Score: 5, Funny
      2000 Harrison Ford

      YES! At least Han _won_ first and Lucas can't change it. ;-)

      --

      Dream as if you'll live forever.
      Live as if you'll die tomorrow.
      ~Anonymous~

  16. Well deserved by AndrewStephens · · Score: 5, Informative

    Much as we all enjoy reading about how Lucus raped your childhood, his movies are probably only a small part of why he is getting this award. The man is directly responsible for much of the technology behind modern film making - nonlinear editing, sound post-production and reproduction, digital effects, virtual sets, virtual extras, and now he is a leading force in digital film. Not to mention the great strides he made in marketing and licensing :)
    All these techniques were developed for his projects, and there is not a film made today that does not use them in some way.
    He is certainly more deserving than 2001's winner - Barbra Streisand!

    --
    sheep.horse - does not contain information on sheep or horses.
  17. Good by Riktov · · Score: 3, Funny

    Now he can quit.

    1. Re:Good by Ingolfke · · Score: 5, Funny

      Wrong, now he has confirmation he needs to pursue episodes VII, VIII, and IX. No, as a lifetime achievement award winner, no one will question his decision to rework the triology so that Han Solo's name is actually Beau, and in episode VII we learn that Beau and Luke are cousins, and Han's long lost father returns, Uncle Jessie. The empire is defeated, but pockets of control remain throughout the galaxy, especially on the planet of Hazzard. Here Beau and Luke, the newly named Dukes of Hazzard, are sent to eliminate the remaining emperial forces. Lando, will of course have taken the Millenium Falcon, but that's ok because Beau will reveal that he has been working on a supped up ship, named after one of the great hearo's of the rebel resistance, the General Lee. Finally the Star Wars vision, the Lucas vision, can be realized.

      Oh... and I've heard in episode VIII Beau and Luke will run into a group of wrongly accused ex-rebel fighters, named Murdoch, Hannibal, Face, and B.A. Barachus. I pity the fool who misses this movie!

      And finally, we might see N-Sync do a cameo in the movie (that would be awesome d00d).

  18. Re:It's a tremendous achievement by koh · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Okay, okay, so why isn't it called the "shitload of money achievement" ? Would be more to the point, don't you think ? :)

    --
    Karma cannot be described by words alone.
  19. Yeah, Lucas is a hack... by Perdition · · Score: 3, Insightful

    but what have YOU done?

    --
    Windows XP SP2 told me to install third-party software that prevents viruses and protects stability... I chose Ubuntu
    1. Re:Yeah, Lucas is a hack... by Tackhead · · Score: 3, Funny
      > but what have YOU done?

      Throughout my entire life, I was able not to create Jar Jar Binks.

  20. It's all about special effects... by pedantic+bore · · Score: 4, Informative
    If you RTFA, you'll see that what is being recognized is primarily Lucas's pioneering work in special effects: ILM, Pixar, Lucas Sound, etc. The man might not know how to direct his way out of a paper bag, and his ear for dialog went deaf about twenty years ago, but he has created some wonderful tools for other directors/writers to use. He deserves something for that.

    --
    Am I part of the core demographic for Swedish Fish?
  21. Hmm... by kjones692 · · Score: 3, Funny

    I sense a disturbance in the force... as if millions of voices cried out in terror, and then were suddenly silenced.

    --

    Love the Third Amendment?
  22. Re:I will. by arose · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I take good movies in black and white with mono sound over bad movies with excelent visual and sound effects.

    --
    Analogies don't equal equalities, they are merely somewhat analogous.
  23. American Graffiti by httpamphibio.us · · Score: 4, Informative

    I'm constantly surprised that George Lucas was lucid and creative enough to create American Graffiti... it's a film that has not only withstood the test of time, quite an achievement for what could have easily been just a nostalgia piece, but has the perfect balance of comedy and drama, and manages to develop many different storylines (most multi-threaded films tend to skimp on any sort of real character and story development and the crossover between storylines is often very poor).

    --
    sig.
  24. Maybe "lifetime" is the wrong word... by Daniel+Ellard · · Score: 3, Insightful
    I liked THX1138 a lot. American Graffiti was great. Star Wars 4-6: when they came out, people were amazed. The Indiana Jones still looks good (well, except for maybe the last one).

    That's quite a successful run. Maybe not a "lifetime" of achievement, but a bunch of great and/or insanely popular movies in a short period of time.

    It's unfortunate that the recent stuff sucks, but he's still got a pretty amazing record.

    --
    Disclaimer: I work for a company, but I don't speak for them.
  25. Who needs a hug? by Lisandro · · Score: 4, Funny

    "George Lucas is receiving the AFI Lifetime Achievement award. I will make no other comment."

    Oh, c'mon, don't like that. You'll get yours too, eventually!

  26. Re:Wait a sec... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

    Mesah won no award!?!? Yousah kidding! Jar Jar given award by Naboo Princess! Kiss on cheek! Jar Jar no need lifetime achievement award. Mesah still archieve only half lifetime greatness. Yousah gonna see lotsa more of Jar Jar nows!

  27. Short sighted posters by damieng · · Score: 4, Insightful

    As always a story brings out the most short sighted posters, upset over the treatment of Star Wars.

    Lets not forget that the award is not for Star Wars but for his achievements to the industry.

    Lucas helped found ILM which helped get special effects to the what they are today. Skywalker Sound has contributed to hundreds of films. THX certification got cinemas, film and DVD production quality up.

    And personally, I loved Howard the Duck...

    --
    [)amien
  28. He's done more for the business of movies by hargettp · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Yet perhaps not so much for the art of movies. Alas, because I enjoyed the original trilogy so much in my childhood.

    He created one of the greatest (and first, I believe) movie merchandizing businesses in history. I would question whether there would be so many "Power Ranger Toys" or "Barney" tie-ins if the Star Wars franchise hadn't done been so successful.

    He has continually expanded the frontier of digital effects in film-making, and although in recent years his studio's work has been eclipsed by other films (e.g., The Matrix, Shrek, Toy Story, Finding Nemo, Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow, etc.), I do believe that nevertheless he deserves credit for the push towards effective uses of digital imagery in cinema.

    He has enhanced the audio experience in most large cinemas in operation today (at least in the US). I can't say how many times I've seen "THX-1138" digital surround sound by Dolby--that sound system was developed in conjunction with Lucas' team.

    He was first to expand the idea of film sequels (and series) in modern cinema. Would we have had Die Hard, Die Harder were it not for Lucas? Would we have The Matrix, The Matrix Reloaded, The Matrix Revolutions were it not for Lucas? What about Star Trek the Movie I-IV? Back to the Future I-II? If the original trilogy had not been so popular with audiences, would subsequent sequels & series concepts have been developed other major film studios?

    There may be other such achievements as well, but with the above I think there is a strong case that Lucas reshaped how the business of movies does it's business.

    1. Re:He's done more for the business of movies by rdean400 · · Score: 5, Insightful

      although in recent years his studio's work has been eclipsed by other films (e.g., The Matrix, Shrek, Toy Story, Finding Nemo, Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow).

      I would dispute that.

      Pixar really plays to different market segments than Lucas's films, so they haven't really eclipsed Lucas's work. (And to be fair, Pixar itself started out as a division of Lucasfilm, Ltd. It was purchased by Steve Jobs for $10mil in 1986 and rechristened "Pixar".). No Pixar = no Toy Story, and no Toy Story means we probably wouldn't have seen a good wholly computer animated picture yet.

      ILM was the special effects studio for Sky Captain and the World fo Tomorrow, so Lucas's company was part of that one.

      That leaves the Matrix. Although bullet time generated more buzz than massively digitally created armies of Phantom Menace, it's about equivalent on the revolutionary scale. Matrix got perceived as better by having a more well-executed story.

      The fact is engraved into Pixar's HQ: "No amount of technology can turn a bad story into a good one" (Although TPM and AOTC were good stories, poorly told).

  29. We'll Ignore... by a_peckover · · Score: 5, Insightful

    ...the parts where he revolutionised film making (THX, Skywalker Sound, ILM, non-linear editing) and where he became the most successful independent film-maker of all time.

  30. I absolutely agree. by MtViewGuy · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I mean think about it:

    1. Industrial Light and Magic essentially pioneered the modern age of cinematic special effects. They took "traditional" special effects to new levels of excellence and helped pioneer CGI effects for movies.

    2. Pixar pioneered much of what computer animation can do, and under subsequent leadership of Steve Jobs the company has produced several blockbuster hit movies.

    3. Lucas Sound helped develop the THX certification for high quality movie presentation in the theaters, and it has extended that certification to DVD mastering, too. A THX-certified DVD tends to have high-quality picture and sound on average.

  31. Although ... by Vinnie_333 · · Score: 3, Funny

    ...some of the events in his life will be altered so they more closely match the life George originally intended.

    --

    "We shall party like the Greeks of old! You know the ones I mean." - HedonismBot
  32. Re:I will. by NanoGator · · Score: 3, Insightful

    "I take good movies in black and white with mono sound over bad movies with excelent visual and sound effects."

    George gave moviemakers better tools. He can't make other moviemakers make better movies.

    --
    "Derp de derp."