Slashdot Mirror


David Tennant Cast as New Doctor Who

Stephen Williams writes "Doctor Who fan site Output Gallifrey is reporting that David Tennant has been cast as the tenth incarnation of the Time Lord. Tennant, who has recently appeared in BBC dramas Blackpool and Casanova, has been linked with the role of the Doctor since the announcement of Christopher Eccleston's departure."

200 comments

  1. Depressing by Average_Joe_Sixpack · · Score: 5, Funny

    I am now older than the guy playing Dr Who :-(

    1. Re:Depressing by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      Good point. One of the most sickening things about television these days is that with anything related to action/adventure, they seem insist on casting young actors, probably in hopes of creating a significant female following. "Casanova"? Give me a break! FormerSomething tells me this fellow will last as long as Eccleston did. Naturally, Doctor Who fans should be obsessed with the well-groomed careers of these actors. The better Doctors tended to be a little older, and so the show focused on plots and character than on mindless action and "adult drama in outer space". Computer-generated special effects? Wunnerful, but like these young things with great teeth and great hair, they get old pretty quick.

    2. Re:Depressing by j.bellone · · Score: 1

      What about Doogie Houser M.D.?

      --
      I'm f#$king magic!
    3. Re:Depressing by eclectro · · Score: 2, Funny

      I am now older than the guy playing Dr Who :-

      Agreed. He should have regenerated into Angelina Jolie and then I would not be so depressed about it by myself.

      --
      Take the cheese to sickbay, the doctor should see it as soon as possible - B'Elanna Torres, "Learning Curve"
    4. Re:Depressing by Skuld-Chan · · Score: 2, Informative

      Peter Davidson was 31 when he took on the role of Dr. Who #5 in 1981.

    5. Re:Depressing by DJTodd242 · · Score: 2, Informative

      I'll take your geek card now please. His name is Peter Davison!

    6. Re:Depressing by ignorant_newbie · · Score: 1

      and the worst doctor yet was he. not that he's a bad actor, it was just a bad casting choice. but then... I doubt that anyone would have been popular as the 5th dr :)

    7. Re:Depressing by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Quite correct. And many anoraks^Wfans (including myself) think that his era was marred precisely because of his age (some good stories, just that Davison didn't have the gravitas to pull them off).

      Still, Tennant is a fine actor and I'm not *too* worried.

    8. Re:Depressing by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      I'm glad you made a link to IMDB, otherwise I wouldn't have had any idea who you were talking about!

    9. Re:Depressing by WolfWithoutAClause · · Score: 3, Funny

      Still, it could be worse, you could be older than Dr. Who the character. :-)

      --

      -WolfWithoutAClause

      "Gravity is only a theory, not a fact!"
    10. Re:Depressing by unitron · · Score: 1

      Maybe you've stumbled onto a way around the re-incarnation limit problem. He gets to come back, but as a female. With the right actress and decent scripts it might just actually work.

      --

      I see even classic Slashdot is now pretty much unusable on dial up anymore.

    11. Re:Depressing by RyatNrrd · · Score: 1

      Yeah. Doctor Who should be a part that British Actors can only get when they're too old to be James Bond.

    12. Re:Depressing by michaeldot · · Score: 1

      I think Peter Davison was a more appealing Doctor than both Colin Baker and Sylvester McCoy. He was like a younger Patrick Troughton for me.

      What spoilt virtually all of the Peter Davison era for me was the companions, especially Tegan. There was just so much tension in the TARDIS.

      The best companions have been curious and playful, willing to experience all the wonder of a wide universe. I particularly liked those who were the Doctor's equal, especially Romana #2.

    13. Re:Depressing by belroth · · Score: 1
      Still, it could be worse, you could be older than Dr. Who the character. :-)
      I am.
      Your point is?

      I think Tennant has the potential to be a good doctor - I wasn't sure until I saw him in Casanova. Now I'm looking forward to seeing his realisation of the role, even if I wanted Richard E. Grant myself - at least he's older than I am! (And he'd be great in the part too).
      I hope they stop doing such short story lines - most of the better Who stories were 4-6 parters. Oh and my pet gripe is the credits - Ecclestone should be credited as The Doctor and not Doctor Who, sad geek that I still am.

      --
      I hereby inform you that I have NOT been required to provide any decryption keys.
    14. Re:Depressing by CaptainAvatar · · Score: 1
      I am.

      No, you're not!

      --
      The real Captain Avatar is a fictional character, so I suppose he doesn't mind if I impersonate him.
  2. Salary details by LiquidCoooled · · Score: 3, Funny

    In one of the papers, they are saying he landed a £500,000 salary deal.

    If he was the real doctor, he could setup a bank account with bit of money in, and come back in a couple of million years to collect his interest.

    --
    liqbase :: faster than paper
    1. Re:Salary details by MartinB · · Score: 1

      No no no - all he'd have to do is deposit one penny in a savings account in his own era, and when he arrives at the End of Time the operation of compound interest means that the fabulous cost of his meal has been paid for. This, many claim, is not merely impossible but clearly insane. Oh, sorry... I got a little confused there. All this reviving and updating Sci Fi from my youth is getting to me.

      --

      The only thing you can accurately describe as "Scotch" is a sticky tape made by 3M. And it's

    2. Re:Salary details by feronti · · Score: 1

      Except, in most cases, bank interest is close to or below the rate of inflation, so by keeping it in the bank, he'd actually wind up losing it all.

    3. Re:Salary details by 2sheds · · Score: 1

      That's not merely impossible but clearly insane. Anyone for breakfast?

      --

      Absit Invidia
    4. Re:Salary details by Elshar · · Score: 1

      Not to mention most banks also have clauses saying that if you don't check on your account within x amount of months, they can close it out. So you'd have to keep warping ahead in time in x-1 month intervals or so to keep the account open.

    5. Re:Salary details by AussieVamp2 · · Score: 1

      especially given recent Doctor Who at the End of hte Universe episode ";)

  3. great by Turn-X+Alphonse · · Score: 0, Troll

    Wonderful.. we go from a nutter with big ears to a guy best known for acting as a womaniser.. what snext? The cross dressing doctor?

    --
    I like muppets.
    1. Re:great by Hogwash+McFly · · Score: 3, Insightful

      A female doctor?

      --
      Mother, do you think they'll like this sig?
    2. Re:great by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That would be if Eddie Izzard got the role.

    3. Re:great by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Actually, in a Comic Relief (charity thing in the UK) episode of Doctor Who, they had it finish with The Doctor being killed and morphing (I forget what it's called) into a female Doctor!

    4. Re:great by LiquidCoooled · · Score: 1

      Actually, there was one guy lined up to be the doctor (Eddie Izzard) who is best known for his cross dressing comic routines.

      But on topic, the doctor has already done the crossdressing thing:

      As far as we can tell, The Highlanders is the first example of the Doctor cross-dressing, as he disguises himself as a washer woman. He was a cleaning lady in The Green Death some years later.
      from here

      --
      liqbase :: faster than paper
    5. Re:great by M1FCJ · · Score: 1

      I wouldn't mind that. Woman scientists and engineers appeal to me. It's better than a stupid bimbo. You can have sex and have meaningful discussion. You can't say this for the majority of Doctor's companions.

    6. Re:great by Dogtanian · · Score: 3, Insightful

      what snext? The cross dressing doctor?

      Tim Curry, dressed as he was in the Rocky Horror Picture Show (and I'd already posted that idea in response to a previous story).

      Actually, he'd probably be a bit old for that now.

      In all seriousness, I don't think Eddie Izzard would've been a good choice; too much baggage (not just handbaggage, arf), and I reckon he'd be playing "Eddie Izzard" all the time.

      I thought Christopher Ecclestone was a good choice, because he *wasn't* an obvious choice. The obvious choice, to go with a 'famous', 'eccentric', 'British', blah blah Doctor, really struck me as a bad idea, based on people with half-baked recollections of Tom Baker and Jon Pertwee trying to come up with ideas. I've nothing against Richard E Grant, but he was too much along that line (yeah, I know he did an online story or something). Apparently they also asked Hugh Grant (no relation AFAIK) to do it at one stage, but he turned it down. THANK GOD! Hugh-'king-Grant, fer chrissakes!

      I don't want well-known, and I don't want formulaicly eccentric. I want someone who can bring something new to the role without losing sight of who The Doctor is.

      Ecclestone seemed to be that guy, and then he buggered off. Damn.

      --
      "Slashdot - News and Chat Sites Deviant". (Click "homepage" link above for details).
    7. Re:great by Stween · · Score: 1

      Izzard never, ever wanted to take on the role, and I believe was never approached about it either. I think the tabloids made it up, and everybody thought "Actually, yeah, he would make a good doctor". Tom Baker even went as far as saying that Izzard had actually landed the role for the 9th Doctor, which clearly was not the case.

    8. Re:great by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      I wouldn't mind that. Woman scientists and engineers appeal to me. It's better than a stupid bimbo. You can have sex and have meaningful discussion. You can't say this for the majority of Doctor's companions.

      Or, better yet, we have a male Doctor and we have a good TV show without that estrogen crap.

    9. Re:great by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I can't say that I'm a hardcore fan of the Doctor Who series (I only vaguely remember watching reruns of the series that came on here when I was younger, I'm 22 years old currently), but what I do remember enjoying about it is the diversity that the various people playing the Doctor bring to the role, while still maintaining his (its?) basic character. I don't see any problem with bringing in people who have played roles that are detached from what they're normally typecast as, because it gives an interesting opportunity to see what they're really capable of -- and surprisingly, you have to be capable of quite a great deal to play a character like the Doctor!

    10. Re: great by gidds · · Score: 2, Interesting
      Not an impossibility IMO. But it would take a special sort of actress. (Or must we be politically correct and say 'female actor' now?)

      I think that the crucial characteristic of the doctor is authority. He can be serious, funny, dour, cheerful, young, old, fat, thin, whatever, but you need the feeling that he knows what's going on, that he can put things right. But for that he needs authority, leadership, strength of character, intensity.

      I think in general it'd be harder for a woman to pull that off, but I'm sure there are some actresses who could. (Probably a slightly older one; authority tends to go with age in women just as in men.) Helen Mirren, for example, springs to mind as someone who might be good. Even someone like Jennifer Saunders might be interesting in the role.

      Mind you, my first choice would have to be Alan Rickman...

      --

      Ceterum censeo subscriptionem esse delendam.

    11. Re:great by JaF893 · · Score: 1

      So what? He was good in Cassanova and I'm sure he'll make a good Doctor Who. I can't think of any Doctors who were especially famous before being timelords!

    12. Re:great by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Transexual Dr. Who followed by multisexual Dr. Who, followed by the upscale Dr. Whom, as for a woman doctor, that would be Dr. Womb

    13. Re:great by starwed · · Score: 1

      In the couple of movies I've seen Eddie Izzard in (Shadow of the Vampire and Mystery Men), it didn't seem like he was just using his stand-up persona. And I saw an interview with him where he mentioned he prefers acting to standup.

    14. Re:great by BasilBrush · · Score: 1

      Before my time, but Jon Pertwee was well known for "The Navy Lark". And (not before my time) Peter Davidson was famous for playing Tristran Farnon in "All Creatures Great and Small" - which was one of the biggest TV hits of it's day. But yes, most of the Doctors have been surprise unknowns.

    15. Re:great by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Transexual Dr. Who followed by multisexual Dr. Who, followed by the upscale Dr. Whom, as for a woman doctor, that would be Dr. Womb

      Followed by the slutty Doctor Whore.

    16. Re:great by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      No, that would be Dr. Whomevercomesalong

    17. Re:great by meringuoid · · Score: 1
      Tim Curry, dressed as he was in the Rocky Horror Picture Show (and I'd already posted that idea in response to a previous story). Actually, he'd probably be a bit old for that now.

      Drop the transvestism, but keep the camp eccentricity, and Tim Curry would make a terrific Doctor. The Doctor needn't be a young man; the first three were all older gentlemen, and Tom Baker wasn't exactly young.

      --
      Real Daleks don't climb stairs - they level the building.
    18. Re:great by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Wonderful.. we go from a nutter with big ears to a guy best known for acting as a womaniser.

      So fucking what? Give me a break, you close-minded twat. I'd watch anything as long as it's good. What's wrong with doing something different?

      Oh yeah, and learn to spell.

    19. Re:great by Walt+Dismal · · Score: 3, Funny

      If the Doctor has two hearts, how many extras might he have as a woman? The concept alternatively scares me and excites me. And he might find new uses for the sonic screwdriver.

    20. Re:great by Kaorimoch · · Score: 1

      There was a female doctor, in the episode "The Curse of the Fatal Death". Joanna Lumley. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0212887/

    21. Re:great by michaeldot · · Score: 1
      There was a female doctor, in the episode "The Curse of the Fatal Death". Joanna Lumley. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0212887/

      That's not canon of course (Comic Relief charity special), but it was very very funny.

      "Oh look, the sonic screwdriver has another setting..."

    22. Re:great by zakezuke · · Score: 1

      A female doctor?

      I'll be branded a true geek for this one.

      There are female timelords, in fact the Doctor worked with one, or rather two of the same one, named Romana during the Tom Baker era for the Keys of time series. After the Keys of Time story arc ended {Destiny of the Daleks - 9/1/79}, Romana decides to regenerate, and tries on a number of bodies before she decides on the image of someone they met in the prior episode.

      This may explain why we met so few female timelords, as they are only given 12 regenerations all that time trying on different bodies would lead to a lower life expectancy. But if a male timelord could regenerate into a female one, well this would explain why their population hasn't died out.

      --
      There is no sanctuary. There is no sanctuary. SHUT UP! There is no shut up. There is no shut up.
    23. Re:great by belroth · · Score: 1
      Before my time, but Jon Pertwee was well known for "The Navy Lark". And (not before my time) Peter Davidson was famous for playing Tristran Farnon in "All Creatures Great and Small" - which was one of the biggest TV hits of it's day. But yes, most of the Doctors have been surprise unknowns.
      Pertwee was a radio star in the late thirties too and very well known when he took the part (my favourite). If you ever get the chance read Moon Boots and Dinner Suits, it's a good read, I especially liked his Naval career (he was the inspiration for The Navy Lark - he went on parade as an ordinary Rating wearing a monocle, funny story. Not so funny was him being taken off the Hood a few days before she was sunk to go to Officer training. Mind you he ended up in Intelligence and went round with an id card with a photo of Hitler(or a close facsimile). Thoroughly recommened but very hard to get a copy.

      Hartnell had a long career before playing the Doctor, lots of Stage and Film work and a TV hit with The Army Game. Similar Story with Troughton.

      The point is most of the previous doctors had distinguished careers before taking on the Doctor. The fact that most of them are best remembered for their years in the tardis is more to do with the cult status of Dr Who than their careers.

      --
      I hereby inform you that I have NOT been required to provide any decryption keys.
    24. Re: great by mink · · Score: 1

      For a female Doctor I think Patricia Routledge could do a good job. Mix a little of Hyacinth Bucket and Hetty Winthrop and you have a Doctor that would at least be entertainting. My next pick would be Zoë Wanamaker, While she has already made an appearance in this new Dr. Who series as the last human being, I think she has the acting chops to be a Doctor.

      On an offtopic idea I think Patricia Routledge could do well as one of the witches (most likely Nanny Ogg) if there were to be any Discworld Films made.

      --
      Well I've wrestled with reality for thirty five years doctor, and I'm happy to say I finally won out over it.
    25. Re:great by mink · · Score: 1

      We allready saw Hugh Grant as Doctor in the Comic Relief Special.

      --
      Well I've wrestled with reality for thirty five years doctor, and I'm happy to say I finally won out over it.
    26. Re:great by Dogtanian · · Score: 1

      I didn't see that, and if it's even half as "funny" as the rest of Comic Relief, I don't think I'll bother.

      On the other hand, it can't be worse than "Dimensions in Time". Eeurgh, that was *foul*.

      --
      "Slashdot - News and Chat Sites Deviant". (Click "homepage" link above for details).
    27. Re:great by mink · · Score: 1

      Well, he was the Doctor for about 30 seconds(I'll explain later).
      "The Curse of Fatal Death" is about as good as a "real" episode of Dr. Who from the 70's (except shorter).
      I think every fan should see it and have a chance to laugh at some of the silly old Dr. Who cliches.
      It's got Daleks, The Master, three hundred miles of sewers, and more regenerations then you can shake a Dalek Manipulator at.

      If you happen to see the current release of it the DVD or tape will also contain a behind the scenes showing how Dalek costumes really work and a good fast/cheap way to build a convincing T.A.R.D.I.S.
      It explains how they got the dozen or so top actors to take part in the project and how it was written by people who actually liked Dr. Who and cared about what they were producing.

      IT also contains three other other parody bits that I am not familier with. One poking fun at the Colin Baker "Trial of a Timelord" and Dr. Who continuity. The other one is having a go at cancelation, cybermen and Thatcher. From what I can tell they were put on to make the running time longer and show you examples of BAD Dr. Who parody.

      --
      Well I've wrestled with reality for thirty five years doctor, and I'm happy to say I finally won out over it.
    28. Re: great by schon · · Score: 1

      my first choice would have to be Alan Rickman

      Wow, and all this time I thought Alan Rickman was a man!

  4. New NEW Dr Who by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I think I won't like him as much as the last - I don't think Dr Who will suit the new one.

  5. Classically trained. by MisanthropicProgram · · Score: 3, Insightful
    From imbd: Graduated from the Royal Scottish Academy of Music and Drama.

    I always wondered if people like this get bored playing TV characters. Then again, over the span of a series, I guess you can develop a character and his emotions.
    Or, he just wants to buy a house in the Caribbean.

    1. Re:Classically trained. by EpsCylonB · · Score: 2, Informative

      If like me you don't get BBC3, thanks to google image search you can see what he looks like here.

      And here he is with a pretty lady.

    2. Re:Classically trained. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      SlashdOt EdiTor in sTrangE CapitalisAtion shockEr.

    3. Re:Classically trained. by hey! · · Score: 1

      But it can make a difference. How do you you draw on your personal experiences to method act a character like Dr. Who? Or Richard III, for that matter? It may be that for the kind of archetypal roles that appear in science fiction, a classically trained actor is best.

      Recently I rented the original Star Wars movies for my kids, and the thing that struck me is how shaky and unsure most of the acting was. The exceptions were old pros Alec Guinness and Peter Cushing, who were completely sure of themselves and what they had to do with their roles.

      --
      Post may contain irony: discontinue use if experiencing mood swings, nausea or elevated blood pressure.
    4. Re:Classically trained. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Casanova has been on BBC One for the past two week. (Monday 9pm)

    5. Re:Classically trained. by belroth · · Score: 1

      As opposed to playing the same character saying the same lines every night in the theatre you mean?

      --
      I hereby inform you that I have NOT been required to provide any decryption keys.
  6. BBC by BarryNorton · · Score: 3, Informative

    Oh well, if a fan site say it they're the authority... never mind checking the BBC!

    1. Re:BBC by Stephen+Williams · · Score: 1

      The BBC announcement hadn't yet made it to their web site when I submitted the story last night.

      -Stephen

    2. Re:BBC by fishbot · · Score: 2, Funny

      I love this bit:

      "Actor David Tennant has been named the new Doctor Who after a meteoric rise in television and theatre."

      Meteoric? I wasn't aware of many meteorites rising. Let's just hope he doesn't wipe out any species, eh?

    3. Re:BBC by BarryNorton · · Score: 1

      True, the story had only been up on the BBC News site since early this morning (in UK, i.e. eight hours before this was posted), but the news had been already been long released officially; it was in The Guardian this morning...

  7. Typecast?!??!?!? by codesurfer · · Score: 1

    Eccleston, whose first appearance as the ninth Doctor attracted 10 million viewers, said he feared being typecast.

    Can one really be typecast as the sole surviving Time Lord? Did he think his next gig would be in a sitcom of a similar premise? :)

    1. Re:Typecast?!??!?!? by BarryNorton · · Score: 4, Informative
      Eccleston [...] said he feared being typecast.
      The BBC already had to back down over that 'quote' - they'd agreed not to make his departure public, then made something up when asked!

      (I know, I submitted a well-referenced story on this to Slashdot only to have it rejected and see one without the references posted days later!)

    2. Re:Typecast?!??!?!? by codesurfer · · Score: 1

      My apologies...I'd not seen the retraction.

    3. Re:Typecast?!??!?!? by notAyank · · Score: 1

      Every time I see Tom Baker on that Scottish show or hear his voice I think Dr Who. For a guy who hasn't been Dr Who in 30 years, I think he's typecast.

    4. Re:Typecast?!??!?!? by StormKrow · · Score: 1

      He's not the sole surviving timelord, The Doctor is just the one you see the most of. There are several others spread through out the universe. (I almost said galaxy, too much damn starwars..)

      --
      Who cares about the ozone layer?...thanks to CFC's I can write my name......IN CHEESE!!!
    5. Re:Typecast?!??!?!? by Bazzalisk · · Score: 1

      As of the second episode of the new series we've been told that he's the sole surviving one. I would be utterly shocked if no other timelord turns out to have survived - but at the moment he seems to think he's the only one still around.

      --
      James P. Barrett
    6. Re:Typecast?!??!?!? by StormKrow · · Score: 1

      ahh, I haven't seen that one yet. i've seen 3 and 4, but not 2.

      However, bearing that in mind, past episodes take place in the future, and Gallifrey was mentioned then, so if the council of timelords exists in the future and these episodes are taking place in the present, we have to assume that other timelords exist because they exist in the future. (aren't the mechanics of time and space wonderful?)

      --
      Who cares about the ozone layer?...thanks to CFC's I can write my name......IN CHEESE!!!
    7. Re:Typecast?!??!?!? by mink · · Score: 1

      Yah, you know The Master has to be kicking around somewhere, but I suspect he may have settled down to a palace on some distant planet to enjoy the evenings and some nice wine (rather then get screwed by everyone and everything). Probably calls himself Harem Stet, Seth Tamer or Mat Hester.

      --
      Well I've wrestled with reality for thirty five years doctor, and I'm happy to say I finally won out over it.
  8. A ploy? by johansalk · · Score: 1

    Sometimes i wonder if the tabloid drama generated by changing actors makes for more publicity than the quality of the show itself.

  9. The best Dr. Who by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

    Of all the modern incarnations of the Doctor, the best actor in the role was Paul McGann. He looked the part and is a very good actor.

    Now we get somebody who just doesn't fit the role. Kind of like what happened to the Batman movies. Most of the actors sucked at being Batman.

    1. Re:The best Dr. Who by loki1978 · · Score: 1

      I beg to differ I totally vote for Sylvester McCoy And ACE of course

      --
      According to prophecy
    2. Re:The best Dr. Who by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I always thought there was something about Nyssa & Tegan...nevermind.

      Come to think of it, Romana II was cute.

    3. Re:The best Dr. Who by BasilBrush · · Score: 1

      Are you in your late 20s by any chance?

    4. Re:The best Dr. Who by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Are you in your late 20s by any chance?

      I'm in my late 20s and I consider Peter Davison to be "my" Doctor (I even remember Tom Baker when I was really young)...

      I've said this before, but... it has to be remembered that there *will* be people out there for who Sylvester McCoy will always be "their" Doctor, the *only* one that they remember from the first time round- simply because they're too young to remember the previous ones.

      These people will now be past university age.

    5. Re:The best Dr. Who by loki1978 · · Score: 1

      yes, i actually am in my late twenties, but i have tapes with episodes of every doctor, so i surely had a chance to compare

      --
      According to prophecy
    6. Re:The best Dr. Who by BasilBrush · · Score: 1

      Oh sure, I wasn't saying you hadn't seen the other Doctors. But everyone seems to like the Doctor from their childhood best. I'm 40 and all the people my age seem to have Tom Baker as their favourite doctor.

    7. Re:The best Dr. Who by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Agreed. 37 years old here. For me, The Doctor is the guy with the floppy hat, scarf, and the bag of jellybabies. All the others are just his understudies.

  10. McGann's Doctor-by-committee was *wrong* idea by Dogtanian · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Of all the modern incarnations of the Doctor, the best actor in the role was Paul McGann. He looked the part and is a very good actor. Now we get somebody who just doesn't fit the role.

    Paul McGann was passable, but was really just a slightly bland generic amalgalm of previous Doctors (read the second half of this post) and someone's idea of what the Doctor "should" be like.

    IMHO, to be successful and avoid comparisons with previous Doctors, an actor *has* to bring something new. The Batman comparison is flawed, because Batman was meant to be the same character in each, whereas each Doctor has a distinctly different personality- or at least they should.

    --
    "Slashdot - News and Chat Sites Deviant". (Click "homepage" link above for details).
    1. Re:McGann's Doctor-by-committee was *wrong* idea by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The Batman comparison wasn't "flawed" when read the way it was intended. Just as the actors who played Batman DIDN'T FIT THE ROLE, this new actor playing the Doctor DOESN'T FIT THE ROLE. Got it now?

      Yes, because of the type of part being played, an actor has to bring something new to the part. New doesn't necessarily fit. A couple of the Doctors in the original series didn't fit, either.

      Paul McGann was perfect for the part, for that ONE movie. Nobody said he should play the Doctor from now on.

  11. Derren Brown by t_allardyce · · Score: 3, Interesting

    He'd make a good time lord.

    I've watched the first 3 episodes and i had only seen a couple of Dr Who's before that, but the old ones seemed more entertaining, tonights show will make or break it for me, I wonder if the ratings will still be high?

    --
    This comment does not represent the views or opinions of the user.
    1. Re:Derren Brown by The+Dark+P · · Score: 2, Funny

      I want a Red BMX

    2. Re:Derren Brown by MartinG · · Score: 1

      No, he just tricked you into thinking he would make a good timelord.

      --
      -- MartinG To mail me: echo kewyjlcxyzvjfxbqwh | tr bcefhjklqvwxyz .@adgimnoprstu
    3. Re:Derren Brown by Badfysh · · Score: 1

      Just the other day I was thinking he would be good as "The Master".

      --

      I was conned by an old man in a cloak. It turns out those *were* the droids I was looking for.

    4. Re:Derren Brown by Roberto+Salieri · · Score: 1

      I remember watching RISE when Derren Brown was on and Sue Perkins [the only woman named after a type of cigarette] wondering why all magicians and illusionists always have to dress and look like The Master...

    5. Re:Derren Brown by Denyer · · Score: 1
      He'd make a good time lord.

      Dunno... if he played it in the way he comes across on stage, he wouldn't make a very sympathetic figure. All my opinion of course, but there's a hard edge there that would jar with other portrayals of the Doctor.

      As someone else suggested, he might make a fine incarnation of the Master.

      --
      Ph-nglui mglw'nafh Gates M'dna wgah'nagl fhtagn.
    6. Re:Derren Brown by Catbeller · · Score: 1

      Hasn't anyone noticed that he's played the Time Lord before in a 2003 BBC web-only Dr. Who special, The Scream of the Shalka? IMDB calls him the ninth doctor! He'd be returning to the role, if that video is canonical.

      Some must have this file. Please seed that torrent up!

    7. Re:Derren Brown by Cerv · · Score: 2, Informative

      If you actually read that Imdb page you linked to, Richard E Grant was the Doctor, Tennant played the Caretaker.

      --
      sig
    8. Re:Derren Brown by Catbeller · · Score: 1

      Darn. I did read the page, but I just woke up. Little mistake, sorry.

    9. Re:Derren Brown by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You can find Scream of the Shalka at the BBC's Doctor Who site. However, The Scream of the Shalka is generally considered apocryphal because it has been repeatedly stated that the true Ninth Doctor is the Eccleston Doctor.

    10. Re:Derren Brown by tehshen · · Score: 1

      Imagine the spaceship pig from tonight's episode riding a red BMX. It would be soooo cute!

      --
      Guy asked me for a quarter for a cup of coffee. So I bit him.
    11. Re:Derren Brown by mink · · Score: 1

      I think part of the Charm of a villian like The Master was he was among other things so narcisistic that he kept the same general look about him rather then embrace the chance to change and be different(to an extent even grant the advantage of suprise).
      Most likely it was just luck that Anthony Ainley happened to look a bit like Roger Delgado who sadly died in an auto accident.

      --
      Well I've wrestled with reality for thirty five years doctor, and I'm happy to say I finally won out over it.
  12. what he looks like: by jago25_98 · · Score: 1

    At least he looks a bit more interesting than the current one:

    http://iloveharrypotter3.weblogger.com.br/img/we bl ogger82.jpg

    1. Re:what he looks like: by 0kComputer · · Score: 1
      --
      Top 10 Reasons To Procrastinate
      10.
  13. Woah Doctor Who AND Barty Crouch? by fussili · · Score: 1

    This guy's already got 2 roles he'll be remembered for. http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0855039/ Being in a Harry Potter film AND the Doctor must make you some kind of geek über actor. Only Patrick 'Picard and Xavier' Stewart and Sir Ian 'Gandalf and Magneto' McKellen can compete.

    1. Re:Woah Doctor Who AND Barty Crouch? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Well, Barty Crouch JUNIOR. Not quite as big in plot terms as his dad.

    2. Re:Woah Doctor Who AND Barty Crouch? by WIAKywbfatw · · Score: 1

      You forgot Christopher Lee (countless horror films, Star Wars prequels, Lord Of The Rings trilogy.

      --

      "Accept that some days you are the pigeon, and some days you are the statue." - David Brent, Wernham Hogg
    3. Re:Woah Doctor Who AND Barty Crouch? by jd142 · · Score: 1

      Um, don't forget all those Hammer horror films where he played Dracula.

    4. Re:Woah Doctor Who AND Barty Crouch? by WIAKywbfatw · · Score: 1

      Um, I didn't. Those would be the "countless horror films" that I mentioned before the more recent and more eye-candy-filled films.

      --

      "Accept that some days you are the pigeon, and some days you are the statue." - David Brent, Wernham Hogg
    5. Re:Woah Doctor Who AND Barty Crouch? by unitron · · Score: 1
      Does the James Bond flick "Man With The Golden Gun" count as one of the "countless horror films"?

      Come to think of it, how about Timothy Dalton as the next Doctor?

      --

      I see even classic Slashdot is now pretty much unusable on dial up anymore.

    6. Re:Woah Doctor Who AND Barty Crouch? by AussieVamp2 · · Score: 1

      Actually, make Timothy Dalton the Master!

  14. Thank goodness! by tyroneking · · Score: 1

    At last a good choice! Tennant is the just the sort of 'light' actor that can be driven by the role and not look like a big fish in a little pond (as Eccleston did).
    Nonetheless, I would have preferred Chris Evans (talented-yet-flawed DJ/TV presenter/Billy-ex) because he has obvious character; or Eddie Izzard (surreal comedian) who could have written his own lines and used his own clothes ;) and made the show something really special (and funny too!) but in an interview on fanboy Johnathan Ross's show recently Eddie was very reluctant when pressed about the role. Evans is effectively banned from the BBC I guess, and would have taken the show in a far more alcoholic/Chelsean kind of direction until the day he decided to have every other millenium off...

    1. Re:Thank goodness! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Nonetheless, I would have preferred Chris Evans (talented-yet-flawed DJ/TV presenter/Billy-ex) because he has obvious character

      Dude, you do *not* make suggestions like that if you want to live.

      The guy has character all right.... complete f*****g egotistical w*nker. Sad thing is that he did display some significant talent before his ego took over and everyone realised what a p***k he was. That happened between "Don't Forget Your Toothbrush" and "TFI Friday".

      If you ever want to convince me that the 90s sucked, just mention "TFI Friday". I HATED that bloody show.

    2. Re:Thank goodness! by 16K+Ram+Pack · · Score: 1
      Evans isn't an actor, and I think that Izzard is really too well known. You have to be careful of how much "baggage" people bring.

      Although him saying "Le Singe et Dans le TARDIS" would be cool.

    3. Re:Thank goodness! by tyroneking · · Score: 1

      Evans was my attempt at a little humour ;) Of course he would have been c**p, but to give him his due, he was responsible for some memorable moments on TV & radio, including the "classic" homage to Captain Scarlet / penguins in Toothbrush show and the whole 'I love Billy Piper' episode.

  15. Being a Dr Who veteran... by Skiron · · Score: 2, Informative

    ... and seen them all on TV from 1963ish onwards from behind the sofa, I don't care as LONG AS SWEET LITTLE BILLIE PIPER stays.

    She is real cute, and the best Dr Who assistant ever.

    From keeping a young boy 'shit scared behind the sofa' to keeping an older man watching, Whoo Whoooooo Whooo Whoooo (hum that last part) cares. Keep Billie!

    1. Re:Being a Dr Who veteran... by Loren_Burlingame · · Score: 2, Informative

      you are crazy, Romanadvoratrelundar (Mary Tamm) was the best assistant ever.

    2. Re:Being a Dr Who veteran... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    3. Re:Being a Dr Who veteran... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You've been watching since 1963 and have a thing for Billie Piper?

      I'd say that makes you a dirty old man.

    4. Re:Being a Dr Who veteran... by Neop2Lemus · · Score: 1

      Alright, Billie is a better actress than Nicola Byrant [who is appauling] but I still prefer Nicola or Jacqueline Hill [the fashion model]!

      --
      Needle Nardle Noo
    5. Re:Being a Dr Who veteran... by rjw57 · · Score: 2, Informative

      The Llana Ward version was better

      --
      Rich
    6. Re:Being a Dr Who veteran... by FortranDragon · · Score: 2, Informative

      Is that a regeneration of Lalla Ward? ;-)

      --
      "All the darkness in the world can not quench the light of one small candle."
    7. Re:Being a Dr Who veteran... by Chillum · · Score: 1

      Wtf?!? The width of her mouth when she smiles is waaay more frightening than the aliens!

    8. Re:Being a Dr Who veteran... by Loren_Burlingame · · Score: 1

      no, Mary Tamm is the original, though short lived. She was in the key to time plot arch (one season worth of episodes) starting with The Ribos Operation (my personal favorite episode ever) and ending with The Armageddon Factor.

  16. Relevant Links by RassilonOmega · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    Official BBC Announcement: http://www.bbc.co.uk/doctorwho/series.shtml Official Doctor Who Homepage: http://www.bbc.co.uk/doctorwho/ Official Questional Legality Distribution Site: http://www.btefnet.net/index.php?show=129 [Posting Disclaimer] I claim no responsibilty for anything I do, especially posting links in SlashDot. If anyone asks, a computer virus did it. It was them "bad hacker" persons. I am not guilty. Additionally, I do not recommend any illegal activity, particularly if I think I will get caught.

  17. Star of a not-very-well-known gem by joppabukowski · · Score: 4, Interesting
    This one seemed to totally slip by the mainstream. It's called L.A. Without a Map (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0119565/).

    It's a strange little film about a Scottish undertaker/wannabe screenwriter (Tennant) who falls in love with an American tourist and travels to L.A. to find her.

    Vinessa Shaw, Julie Delpy, Vincent Gallo are all excellent, and there are a few very funny cameos by Johhny Depp. He appears in most of the film as his own poster for Dead Man, who Tennant talks to for inspiration (difficult to explain, something like this:- http://www.posterplanet.net/images/deadmangun.jpg)

    Tennant is, in my opinion a good actor and while I'm not a huge fan of Doctor Who, I'm glad for his success. Maybe it will make this film easier to find?

  18. I can only say... by jotaeleemeese · · Score: 3, Informative

    ... she is chavtastic...

    --
    IANAL but write like a drunk one.
    1. Re:I can only say... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Perhaps I don't get it because I'm American, but why do the brits all seem to hate Billie Piper?

    2. Re:I can only say... by meringuoid · · Score: 1
      Well... she was originally famous, or rather, notorious, as a really awful plastic pop star.

      That didn't last; she proceeded to marry Chris Evans, an annoying radio DJ once enormously popular as a TV presenter but by that stage in deep decline - oh, and far older than her, so much so that it was really a bit creepy. They were a popular couple in the sort of paper that likes celebrity news. Of course it didn't last.

      However, from what I've seen of her acting she hasn't been too bad...

      --
      Real Daleks don't climb stairs - they level the building.
    3. Re:I can only say... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      Because we want to!

    4. Re:I can only say... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      At least they didn't spawn any brats together. Unless the fantasy involves the fiery death of the children in question as a lead-in, I just can't fantasize about women who already have children with other men (even "men" like Chris Evans), but I can still fancy Billie now that she's lost the ginger whinger. (Wanna know why there are so many single mums who can't get dates? Because unlike in most animal's societies, human males aren't generally permitted to kill the rival male's cubs after taking a new mate)

  19. he looks like a weed by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0


    he doesn't look like an all knowing all powerful time lord thats for sure, lets hope no baddies jump out at him and say "boo"

  20. If you think that's bad by PIPBoy3000 · · Score: 2, Funny

    Just think about how much older you are than all the doctor's female assistants. You could almost put a "Barely Legal Teens!" caption to most of them.

  21. Stick Around! by stellabambino · · Score: 3, Informative

    Hopefully, we'll get more than one season with Tennant's Doctor, since we're now on number ten - leaving us with what, three more before he's out of Regenerations? IF the actor's keep leaving, we'll be done with Doctor Who by 2010.

    1. Re:Stick Around! by tuffy · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I'm hoping the same if only for the sake of some consistency. But once they've exceeded the established limit of regenerations, you can be sure they'll find a way to bypass it for the sake of bringing new leads into the role. The whole concept was invented to serve the show not vice versa.

      --

      Ita erat quando hic adveni.

    2. Re:Stick Around! by stellabambino · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Oh no doubt they'll be some epic adventure adding twelve more to his Karmatic-Ticket

    3. Re:Stick Around! by NanoGator · · Score: 1

      " leaving us with what, three more before he's out of Regenerations?"

      Actually, there was a mention in an episode years ago about being able to renew regenerations in a Time Lord. I don't remember the specifics, sorry. (I do wonder, tho, how come the Doc was able to live to 900 years in his first incarnation?)

      Now that the Time Lords are gone, I'm curious how that'll play out. Hehe.

      --
      "Derp de derp."
    4. Re:Stick Around! by pjh3000 · · Score: 1

      The Master tried this in "The Deadly Assassin". He just needed to be exposed to the "Eye Of Harmony" (basically a self contained black hole) to get 12 more regenerations.

      According the 1996 TV movie, the Doctor Now possesses the EoH (in his TARDIS), so he could reset his regeneration whenever he wants. It would be against the Laws of Galifrey to do this, but since they are all gone now, the Doctor can do whatever he wants.

      And let us not forget that we still don't know how The Doctor managed to survive when his entire race was wiped out in the Time Wars. Perhaps he's not a normal Time Lord. I've always suspected he was Rassilon...

    5. Re:Stick Around! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      He's a renegade Xeelee trying to help Terra, and he's bent his entire history into a closed timelike curve. Er wait, wrong universe.

    6. Re:Stick Around! by belroth · · Score: 1
      Now that the Time Lords are gone, I'm curious how that'll play out
      That ticked me off and was totally unnecessary. If you don't want to use the backstory then don't. There's no need to trash it for future storylines - unless they're going to bring Gallifray back of course. It's also a bit anachronistic - when are the Time Lords dead - in 50 billion ad? Go back in time to when they're still around.
      Trek screwed around with crap time travel stories for years, let's have the Doc meddle some more.
      --
      I hereby inform you that I have NOT been required to provide any decryption keys.
    7. Re:Stick Around! by tuffy · · Score: 1
      That ticked me off and was totally unnecessary.

      We don't know if it was totally unnecessary yet, though. It's obvious they're building to something and now it's a matter of finding out what. I'm interested in finding out who the culprit is: Sontarans? 60s-style time travelling Daleks? Something new?

      --

      Ita erat quando hic adveni.

    8. Re:Stick Around! by Bazzalisk · · Score: 1

      when are the Time Lords dead - in 50 billion ad? Go back in time to when they're still around. Clearly something must have happened to wipe them out before they even became timelords. If I recall correctly several people have told me that this happend in one of the novels about the eighth doctor, in which the doctor himself has to prevent Gallifrey from ever having existed in order to prevent the destruction of vast numbers of inteligent species. Which is of course how he survived - because he was the one that changed it.

      --
      James P. Barrett
    9. Re:Stick Around! by Urchlay · · Score: 1
      I do wonder, tho, how come the Doc was able to live to 900 years in his first incarnation?

      I have a theory about that...

      Any Time Lord can live hundreds of years in the same body, provided they don't get seriously injured. They age at maybe 1/10 the rate of humans... so after 700-800 years, they start to look and feel old. The first Doctor (Hartnell) acted like a crusty old man... We don't know how old the Doc was when he `borrowed' the TARDIS, but he was old enough for Susan to think of him as her grandfather (or maybe he really was. I never thought so). Probably he led a very sheltered life on Gallifrey until he was 700 or so.

      My theory is that the Doctor was afraid to regenerate. Maybe it's a common thing among `young' Time Lords: regeneration is a bit like death. After you regenerate, you're not the same `you' as you were before. There's continuity of memory, and the core personality survives, but drastically altered. The first Doctor put off regeneration until he `died' of natural causes (old age plus maybe a heart attack or a stroke brought on by the combination of fighting off the Cyberman plus exposure to arctic conditions?), at which point it kicked in as an involuntary survival mechanism.

      Of course, the exception that proves the rule would be The Master: he's the same in all his incarnations (except the TV movie, where he acts like a cheap street hood... but he was using the brain and body of a human...)

      Can you tell I've put way too much thought into this?

    10. Re:Stick Around! by Urchlay · · Score: 1
      Clearly something must have happened to wipe them out before they even became timelords.

      In that case, how could the tree lady's PDA know what race he was, and why would she know anything about the time war and what happened to the Time Lords?

      (Did anybody else find it appropriate that the tree peoples' tech spoke to them in bird-language? I thought it was a nice touch...)

    11. Re:Stick Around! by AussieVamp2 · · Score: 1

      she looked it up on her portable media player/xenobiology database!

    12. Re:Stick Around! by meringuoid · · Score: 1
      Er wait, wrong universe.

      Since when was this a problem for Xeelee?

      --
      Real Daleks don't climb stairs - they level the building.
    13. Re:Stick Around! by mink · · Score: 1

      I believe The Master while not worried about regenerating (unless he is near his limit) is so narcissistic that he keeps the same look. Even in this time line I suspect he is around somewhere using a bad pseudonym and hiding out till he can score some more regenerations somehow.

      --
      Well I've wrestled with reality for thirty five years doctor, and I'm happy to say I finally won out over it.
  22. Casanova star to play new Doctor Who by JohnCC · · Score: 5, Funny

    Dr. Who: Lets go to my tardis, Rose.
    Dalek: Fornicate!! Fornicate!!

    1. Re:Casanova star to play new Doctor Who by pommiekiwifruit · · Score: 1

      If we're going for Russell Davies' ex-actors, can we get Charlie Hunnan (Nathan from Queer as Folk) to be a companion? Hubba hubba!

  23. When will it air in the States? by selectspec · · Score: 1

    BBC is holding out for cash before distribution in the US. I'll reserve judgement on this new series until I see it.

    --

    Someone you trust is one of us.

  24. When asked for comment... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

    ...David Tennant said, "I quit."

  25. But what does he sound like? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    This is the first doctor where I have to struggle a couple of times too understand what he's saying.

    What does he slip into at times, Cockney?

  26. Doctor who, now? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I just got^H^H^H buttfucked by^H^H a nigro

  27. Can we stop w/the Dr. Who posts? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    How many nerds really care about this topic? It's so early 80s and obscure. Might as well support 'Space 1999' posts. . .

    1. Re:Can we stop w/the Dr. Who posts? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I can't believe you came in here just to say that, you fucking knob.

    2. Re:Can we stop w/the Dr. Who posts? by RyatNrrd · · Score: 1

      How many? Well, 130 replies and counting isn't too bad for a slashdot story about a TV show that they can't get in the States. Except by torrent, of course...

    3. Re:Can we stop w/the Dr. Who posts? by AussieVamp2 · · Score: 1

      lots and what's Space 1999? :)

  28. Dr Hugh by BabyDave · · Score: 5, Funny

    Apparently they also asked Hugh Grant (no relation AFAIK) to do it at one stage, but he turned it down. THANK GOD! Hugh-'king-Grant, fer chrissakes!

    Dalek: YOU WILL BE EXTERMINATED!
    Dr: Well, I, um, gosh, I mean, that is to say, I ... um, well, er, this is all very, er, ... gosh [and so on].

    1. Re:Dr Hugh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Just more proof that Hugh Grant is actually Kif Kroaker.

  29. The last doctor? by nurb432 · · Score: 1

    What about the 10 regeneration limitation?

    I know, I know, its TV, they will think of something.

    --
    ---- Booth was a patriot ----
    1. Re:The last doctor? by davandhol · · Score: 2, Funny

      It's a 12 regeneration limit, not 10.

    2. Re:The last doctor? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      After the 12th, he could take over someone's body, ala the Master, and then a new "doctor" could start over all again.

    3. Re:The last doctor? by Skuld-Chan · · Score: 1

      Just so you know - the doctor can regenerate 12 times.

      (I can't believe I even said that)

      Besides - the world won't end if they extend it - there are plenty of plot holes in Dr. Who already.

    4. Re:The last doctor? by mrshowtime · · Score: 1

      What's worse is that the stupid producer of Dr. Who thought it would be so cool to blow up the Doctor's homeworld of Gallifrey in episode 2 of the new season, so the doctor has no real way getting more regenerations. They should just say that there were complications with the doctor's ninth regeneration and have Tennant and Ecclastion share the title of the ninth doctor.

      --
      "Jeremy, you need to get to an internet cafe and cut and paste some appropriate sentiments about me from the world wide
    5. Re:The last doctor? by NanoGator · · Score: 1

      "What about the 10 regeneration limitation?"

      Is consistency really so important that it could mean killing the show?

      --
      "Derp de derp."
    6. Re:The last doctor? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Uhh, that sounds like an attempt at having a plot arc that keeps you interested long term. I'm sure it will be dealt with.

    7. Re:The last doctor? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      But that's stupid. The Doctor is a TIME LORD. Gallifrey can be un-blown-up as easily as the dolphins pulled another earth copy out of the plural zone earth resided in in hitch-hiker's guide to the galaxy. Of course, (SPOLER) the blood-minded Vogons blew up all the Earths in a cascade along the probability axis eventually, but (a) Fenchurch was unaccounted for having disappeared earlier on as she was passing through another plural zone, and her existence would have kept at least one of the finitely probable earths around, just as the Vogons need Dent and co. to return to earth to stop their existence keeping finitely probable earths around and (b) there was this infinite improbability drive thing too - I doubt the Vogons could prevent earth(s) reappearing out of the quantum chaos summoned by the drive at some random point in spacetime.

    8. Re:The last doctor? by 16K+Ram+Pack · · Score: 1

      Mary Tamm wakes up goes into the bathroom and sees Tom Baker taking a shower and realises that all the doctors after him were all just a dream?

  30. Only Weirdos Watch this Show by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I hope you weirdo/virgins realize that the only people that watch this show are the anime fans that play dungeons and dragons and magic the gathering. everyone thinks you're weird guys.

  31. Why always the obsession with youth? by floorten · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Maybe Tennant will be a good Doctor - he's certainly got to be better than Eccleston, who I find frankly dire - but I really don't understand this obsession TV has with youth.

    Why does the Doctor have to keep getting younger and younger? To me he should be an eccentric older man, with enough years to give gravitas to some of the absurd lines he'll surely have to say!

    We're told that it is so "youth" can relate to him - but that's surely nonsense. As a kid I grew up with Tom Baker, and didn't relate to him any less because he was is his forties. Bah!

    1. Re:Why always the obsession with youth? by NanoGator · · Score: 1

      "Why does the Doctor have to keep getting younger and younger? To me he should be an eccentric older man, with enough years to give gravitas to some of the absurd lines he'll surely have to say!"

      We've got like 25 years of that. Frankly, I like Eccleston because his eccentricity is a little weird to watch coming from somebody who is fairly young and, for once, dresses sensibly.

      Truth be told, I don't think there's any requirement that the Doctor be 'old', just carrying the experience of traveeling around the universe on his shoulders.

      "We're told that it is so "youth" can relate to him - but that's surely nonsense. As a kid I grew up with Tom Baker, and didn't relate to him any less because he was is his forties."

      Well, your data pool of one is certainly very convincing, however... come on! Surely you can see the benefit of adding a little more energy to the show? It's certainly gotten a little faster paced in its latest incarnation. Can you imagine William Hartnell trying to keep up? Ick.

      --
      "Derp de derp."
    2. Re:Why always the obsession with youth? by floorten · · Score: 1

      I think the pacing has a lot to do with the short episodes, myself. And I'm not opposed to action per se, only if it's at the expense of plot and character development, which in the first couple of episodes certainly was the case. Should also make the obligatory point that Pertwee had lots of "action" scenes and he was an old codger too!

      Anyway, I enjoyed today's episode a lot more. Eccleston is getting gradually less irritating, or maybe I'm just getting used to him ;-)

    3. Re:Why always the obsession with youth? by Urchlay · · Score: 1
      Why does the Doctor have to keep getting younger and younger?

      Because he's Merlin?

      (Just recently saw that episode, it's called Battlefield).

    4. Re:Why always the obsession with youth? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Perhaps the phrase 'it is so "youth" can relate to him' is code for 'making it sexy'? Nothing wrong with being sexy ofcourse. But it seems that to qualify as entertainment these days, a tv show has to be something that pubescents can masturbate to. Think about it - nothing else has a chance of competing with computer games, the internet, DVDs, et al.

  32. One word by JustOK · · Score: 2, Funny

    Pierce Brosnan

    --
    rewriting history since 2109
    1. Re:One word by wibald · · Score: 1

      three words: Anthony Stewart Head

    2. Re:One word by michaeldot · · Score: 2, Funny

      George Lazenby

    3. Re:One word by TummyX · · Score: 1

      three words:

      Piecrse Brosnan isn't one word.

    4. Re:One word by AussieVamp2 · · Score: 1

      you trying to get Head into the Xavier/McKellen club then? :)

    5. Re:One word by mink · · Score: 1

      Five Sir!

      --
      Well I've wrestled with reality for thirty five years doctor, and I'm happy to say I finally won out over it.
  33. damn...was hoping for by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    a keifer sutherland reese witherspoon combo...
    at least it beats the hell out of tom arnold with barbara streisand!

  34. Re: regenerations used up by creedon · · Score: 2, Informative

    I think the Doctor has already exceeded his original number of regenerations.

    See http://www.bbc.co.uk/cult/doctorwho/episodeguide/b rainmorbius/ . In the Time Lord Mind Game the Doctor and Morbius battle and Morbius asks the Doctor how long he has lived. We see the faces of the incarnations of the Doctor we know and then other faces we don't know, totaling 12. This implies that Tom Baker's Doctor is the 12th regeneration.

    Then see http://www.bbc.co.uk/cult/doctorwho/episodeguide/l ogopolis/. I think the Watcher reset the clock on the Doctor's regenerations. Either from the point when the Doctor left Gallifrey or to one.

  35. I know what you mean! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Between that and the neighborhood kids who refuse to get off my lawn, I am going to have to get a new house coat that I can wear outside to chase them off.

  36. That's a flat out lie! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

    I have never once played Magic the Gathering

  37. Outpost Gallifrey by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Umm, shouldn't that read Outpost Gallifrey? 'Tis my favorite Who site...

  38. David's had a part on Dr. Who before by RobertKozak · · Score: 2, Interesting


    David Tennant already had part on the Dr. Who mini series "Doctor Who: Scream of the Shalka" as the Caretaker.

    --
    Bet this .sig looks familiar.
  39. Another one by Z0n3Gh05t · · Score: 1

    Now that they have found a new DR. Who does this mean that the series will continue onwards and upwards. God I hope so

  40. Just for reference: by Rob+T+Firefly · · Score: 4, Informative

    David Tennant turns 34 on Monday. When they each began playing the Doctor: Chris Eccleston was 40, Paul McGann was 37, Sylvester McCoy was 44, Colin Baker was 41, Peter Davison was 30, Tom Baker was 40, Jon Pertwee was 51, Patrick Troughton was 46, and William Hartnell was 55.

    1. Re:Just for reference: by Dogtanian · · Score: 1

      This is what shocked me about Hartnell when I found out; he wasn't that old at all. I'd have placed him at least ten years older than he was.

      --
      "Slashdot - News and Chat Sites Deviant". (Click "homepage" link above for details).
  41. Eddy Izzard!!! by Theovon · · Score: 1

    All I can say is that I was delighted when I'd heard that Eddy Izzard was being considered for the role. Of course, that may have been untrue, but it would have been brilliant!

  42. Eight words by RyatNrrd · · Score: 1

    Bill Nighy!
    Bill Nighy!
    Bill Nighy!
    Bloody hell!

  43. Leila by dangitman · · Score: 1
    You can have sex and have meaningful discussion. You can't say this for the majority of Doctor's companions.

    Yeah, but come on. We got a savage chick in torn clothing who liked to go around stabbing people for fun. What more does one need in life?

    --
    ... and then they built the supercollider.
    1. Re:Leila by M1FCJ · · Score: 1

      well I always preferred the 3rd Doctor's one and only scientist companion but she got instructed to scream, like the rest of the companions pretty quickly. OTOH, I can't remember her name but I remember the savage chick's body. :)

  44. No ... by SpooForBrains · · Score: 1

    ... it would have been shite, and I speak as a very-long-standing Eddie fan. For my evidence, I offer up every single film role he has taken on, all, unanimously, crap. The man can't act. He's a hysterically funny standup but he. can't. act. Oh, forgive me, he was excellent in Lenny (the stage-play based on the life of Lenny Bruce) which I saw, and in which he played a ... stand-up comedian.

    --
    "The dew has clearly fallen with a particularly sickening thud this morning"
  45. how many more lives by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I started watching dr who with Tom Baker. Is the doctor not getting close to the end his ability to reincarnate? If so, I wonder how they will get around this fact.

  46. Billie Piper: was "Definitely *Not* Legal" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Just think about how much older you are than all the doctor's female assistants. You could almost put a "Barely Legal Teens!" caption to most of them.

    What's ironic is that Billie Piper first rose to fame as a pop star at age 15 with the song "Because We Want To" (which could have been a minor classic if they'd done it with more attitude and less anodyne production).

    She wasn't even in the "barely legal" category; anyway, there was a predictable rash of "now she's legal" comments from various (male) sources when she hit 16 (the age of consent in the UK).

    And I'll bet Chris Evans was amongst them... ugh.

  47. Eccleston is the same age as Tom Baker was by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Maybe Tennant will be a good Doctor - he's certainly got to be better than Eccleston, who I find frankly dire - but I really don't understand this obsession TV has with youth [..] We're told that it is so "youth" can relate to him - but that's surely nonsense. As a kid I grew up with Tom Baker, and didn't relate to him any less because he was is his forties.

    If you compare their ages when they first appeared onscreen, Eccleston is actually a couple of months older than Tom Baker was when he started.

    Assuming the new series took longer to film than the old one, I'd say it all comes out in the wash...

  48. Wow. by beforewisdom · · Score: 1

    Wow. The Doctors are changing almost as fast as the post Breshnev Soviet leaders did.

  49. Good choice! by 16K+Ram+Pack · · Score: 1
    The guy's a good actor, and based on what I've seen of him in other things, he has really good range and can do slightly offbeat roles.

    He also has almost no baggage in terms of expectation.

  50. Riddl em this, Doctor by kgp · · Score: 1
    As the riddle goes:
    Sal and his son Sammy were driving down the road. A car ran into them and killed Sal. Sammy was rushed to the ER for an emergency surgery. The surgeon came in and said, "I can't help him, he is my son, Sammy."

    How could this happen?

    The answer is the surgeon is .... Sal's mother. Yes, women can be doctors too.

    It would finally be time in 2005 to make the Doctor Who a woman and the companion a male. I mean this is the 21st century and there seems to be nothing in the setup that requires the Doctor to be a male.
  51. Bizzare by glrotate · · Score: 1

    Did we ever get a good explanation of why Eccleston didn't want to do more than one season as Who?

    1. Re:Bizzare by mink · · Score: 1

      He was only signed for one season. This way they introduce the final "power" of The Doctor, Regeneration.
      Read up the BBC apology about the whole mess they made of it.

      --
      Well I've wrestled with reality for thirty five years doctor, and I'm happy to say I finally won out over it.
  52. Re:Bizzare at least by Darth23 · · Score: 1
    I've been spending weeks trying to get used to the ew Doctor, ever since I downloaded the first episode off the new.

    My guess is that we'll be 3 or 4 Doctor's behind by the time I can finally legitimately see the show in the U.S.

    --

    -------- In Soviet Russia, "Soviet Russia" sigs hate Slashdot.

  53. Good good by colinramsay · · Score: 1

    I don't really like Ecclestone's Dr. Who, but having see David Tennant in Cassanova, I think he'll be excellent. He is very bright and witty but his training shows through, and I think that he will bring some gravitas to the role.

  54. Re: regenerations used up by Bazzalisk · · Score: 1

    I believe that official line is that the ones we see in that episode (there are three of them actualy, making Baker the seventh doctor, and Tennant the last) are actualy Moerbius' previous regenerations. (yes obviously the writers of that episode intended them to be the Doctor, but as Retcon goes it's not bad)

    --
    James P. Barrett
  55. Too late for Ade Edmonson then by slashnik · · Score: 1

    Ade would have been perfect as the new Doctor, (-DM's and forehead studs) never mind maybe next time