Slashdot Mirror


PSP Emulation Madness

An anonymous reader writes "The PSP is now the ultimate in handheld emulation consoles, already it boasts Full Speed Gameboy Colour Emulation and improving Snes & Master System but added today it also has NeoGeo CD and Sega Genesis emulators added to the impressive list of homebrew releases."

36 of 328 comments (clear)

  1. This is SWEET... by ALeavitt · · Score: 5, Informative

    ... but so far it only works on the Japanese 1.00 firmware. So far there's no support for the US versions (1.5 and 1.51) so for most of us, it's nothing to get too excited about... yet. I don't know about you, but I don't want to flash my PSP's firmware... but I'm getting so impatient. Just imagine... a 1GB card of all of your favorite games for all of those classic systems, portable, on that gorgeous screen. I hope they hurry up and figure out how to run homebrew apps on the latest firmware.

    --
    This sig has been stolen. Return it to its original user for a reward.
    1. Re:This is SWEET... by sjf · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Clearly Sony doesn't want people to do this. That seems to be the point of the later firmware releases: to block unencrypted binaries. But, I don't see what is illegal or worthy of suit in running homebrew software on the PSP. Unless, of course, that homebrew is compiled (and probably distributed) with libraries that are copyright Sony. As far as I know, that is not the case.

      But, Goddamnit, I can't wait until we can run these emulators on the North American PSPs...oh the anticipation...

    2. Re:This is SWEET... by DeVryGuy23 · · Score: 4, Insightful

      There is no reason for Sony to get upset about this. People are simply making their system more marketable. It isnt economically feasible to pirate games using Memory Stick DUO(you might be able to get 1 game on a 1 gig stick, which is freakin expensive), it'd be cheaper to buy the UMDs. As long as the mods dont interfere with the PSPs ability to play retail games, then why would they take legal action?

    3. Re:This is SWEET... by drunkennewfiemidget · · Score: 2

      I absolutely agree. To this point, I have had no interest in the PSP. I've seen it as nothing more than an overpriced handheld.

      If I were able to play all my favourite old SNES, NES, GBC, GBA, TGFX16, or any other old system's games via a memory stick, I'd buy it in a second.

    4. Re:This is SWEET... by DeVryGuy23 · · Score: 2, Insightful

      They will definitly have no profit coming from games if you dont get the hardware into people's hands. The point is, if a great game comes out that appeals to someone, then no matter how many games they have emulated they will be able to buy it because they have a system. I dont think anyone would buy a machine meerly for emulation at a price of $250. It's more like an incentive, "Hey you get all those cool PSP games, PLUS you can play all your old NES, SNES, Game Boy, SEGA, etc." Playing Chrono Trigger on the go would be awesome.

    5. Re:This is SWEET... by aliquis · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I don't think they block unencrypted binaries to kill the homebrew games & apps scene, I rather think they do it to stop piracy.

    6. Re:This is SWEET... by apoc06 · · Score: 2, Informative

      i agree. sony is one of the few companies out there that has embraced the homebrew scene of the mod community. they did release a the linux version of the playstation: netyaroze or something like that. the problem that pops up whether or not leaving the psp as an open platform will result in piracy like you said. there are already isos of various psp releases. sony released psp games in the closed UMD format so that only sony [not the developers] will be able to press the discs. that eliminates the scare of people being able to burn / distribute illegal copies.

      the real question now is whether sony wishes to make it legal for users to copy legal games onto memory stick duo [MSD]. from a users standpoint, it would be a great way to prolong battery and laser lens life; since it doesnt have to constantly read from the disc.

      the threat comes from the fact that users have picked up speed quickly on how to program from the device. its only a matter of time before someone writes something that will enable the psp to load an iso from MSD. a constant updating of the firmware will just keep the pirates and homebrew developers busy.

      as with most encryption and DRM its only a matter of time before someone finds a way to circumvent it.

      when will someone find a way to keep things free enough that you are able to mod thing in your own way, but locked enough that sony wont have to worry about lost revenue from piracy?

  2. All these are for the 1.0 firmware only by CerebusUS · · Score: 2, Insightful

    No one's cracked the 1.50 or the 1.51 firmware yet, so US PSP owners are still SOL.

    1. Re:All these are for the 1.0 firmware only by cosinezero · · Score: 2, Insightful

      You're assuming the plan is to hack the encryption... likely the plan is to work around it. The japanese versions simply don't check for a digital signature; once the firmware or hardware is hacked to ignore the signature, it's game on.

  3. PIM Suite? by macemoneta · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Has anyone ported a PIM (Personal Information Management) suite and user interface (like Opie) to it yet (or are there any projects in progress)? That would make the PSP attractive as a PDA as well.

    --

    Can You Say Linux? I Knew That You Could.

    1. Re:PIM Suite? by bazio · · Score: 4, Informative

      Don't know if the software has been ported or not, but the PSP wouldn't really be a very attractive PDA option, since it has no touch screen.

      --
      Set the bar high, then bring a tall ladder.
    2. Re:PIM Suite? by macemoneta · · Score: 2, Insightful
      And the point of a PDA incapable of data entry is...?

      It keeps your schedule, documents, contact list, and to-do items with you in a portable manner. I rarely do data entry on the PDA itself. Other than checking off items or acknowledging reminders - which don't require a touch screen or keyboard - the bulk of the data entry occurs on my desktop/laptop. Some small amount of data entry could be performed with an on-screen keyboard and the two directional/select pads on the PSP. Heck, if you can put your name in the high-scores list on an arcade machine without a keyboard or touch screen, this shouldn't be a problem. Certainly more than enough to record a name and number, or schedule an appointment, for example.

      --

      Can You Say Linux? I Knew That You Could.

  4. Whats wrong... by timtwobuck · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Next step, GBA games.

    That would seal the deal for me, and probably many others.

    I think that it isn't outside of reason, its touted that the GBA is just as powerful as the SNES, so the hardware requirements apparently are close to being met....

  5. Hopefully Homebrew Will Run Soon.. by Mean_Nishka · · Score: 5, Interesting
    I will add my voice to the choir on homebrew software.. I bought a PSP at launch and haven't picked it up in weeks.. There's simply no decent software out for this thing, with very little on the horizon.

    Sony would be wise to open the machine up - it'll drive hardware sales certainly more than UMD movies will. Existing homebrew apps like PSPVideo 9 are probably driving more sales than software :).

    1. Re:Hopefully Homebrew Will Run Soon.. by LWATCDR · · Score: 2, Interesting

      What would make more sense for Sony would be to get sega to make a commercial version of the emulator for the PSP. The question then would be... How many people would pay for the games.

      --
      See my blog http://ilovecookes.blogspot.com/ for light hearted technical information.
    2. Re:Hopefully Homebrew Will Run Soon.. by maniac/dev/null · · Score: 2, Informative

      Currently, you can run unsigned code on any DS (reguardless of region or firmware version) with a small piece of hardware that inserts into the DS card slot and a GBA flash cart. You can even run the DS Downloadable demos (like they had at the kiosks at E3) with only a combatible wifi card for your PC. If you want a homebrew-able machine, buy a DS.

      I haven't played many of my commercial DS games in a while, but I play homebrew or E3 demos almost every day still.

      PS: I really hope they release an English version of Trauma Center. Or maybe I'll just learn Japanese...

    3. Re:Hopefully Homebrew Will Run Soon.. by poot_rootbeer · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Sony would be wise to open the machine up - it'll drive hardware sales certainly more than UMD movies will.

      If the PSP is anything like the PSX, PS2, and presumably PS3, Sony doesn't WANT to drive hardware sales -- unless sales of game and movie media are driven at least equally as hard. The hardware is the razor, they make their money from selling blades.

      Let's keep the attractiveness of emulation on PSP in perspective, too; out beyond Slashdot, very few people actually have enough interest in homebrew projects. More people buy PSP's thinking "hey, I can watch Spider-Man on the airplane" than "hey, I bet if someone manages to hack the firmware this thing would make a sweet Gameboy emulator"...

  6. Just say MAME... by bbzzdd · · Score: 2, Interesting

    ...and I am sold. I'd love to lay in bed playing the Capcom classics on the PSP. I can do it now on the PC and modded Xbox, but the portable angle would be killer.

  7. Re:Living under the law by CastrTroy · · Score: 2, Interesting

    That's why I don't really get why platforms like Palm don't catch on more. With anybody being able to create and load programs on them, its suprising they don't get more attention. I think they could just as easily create all these emulators for Palm, and not have to worry about being sued. I realize that PSP has a better interface, but couldn't they make something like a keyboard attachment that has a game pad and 4 or 5 buttons?

    --

    Anthropic principle: We see the universe the way it is because if it were different we would not be here to see it.
  8. Re:Living under the law by MoonBuggy · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Y'know there's nothing wrong with media-shifting games that you own. I've seen plenty of collections of old games lying around people's houses, if they own the game but want to play it on the train it's just a little more practical to use a ROM dump on a PSP than bring along a console, TV and bag of cartridges.

    On the other side of the coin, if I wanted to play Sonic 3 on my PSP (since it's one of my favourite games) I'd be quite happy to pay a few £ on eBay for an original cartridge so I'm then completely legit in downloading a ROM of that cartridge and running it under emulation.

  9. Re:The advance of Technology. by JaF893 · · Score: 2, Informative

    I assume you mean Moore's law. If you do then you are barking up the wrong tree:

    "Moore's law is the empirical observation that at our rate of technological development, the complexity of an integrated circuit, with respect to minimum component cost will double in about 24 months." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moore's_law

  10. Re:What we realy want to know is... by falcon5768 · · Score: 5, Informative
    Nintendo dropped the ball??? Last I looked except for 2 weeks the DS has outsold the PSP every week since release, not to mention Nintendo has more games comming out for the DS than Sony has for the PSP.

    Nintendo hardly dropped the ball on the DS.

    --

    "Slashdot, where telling the truth is overrated but lying is insightful."

  11. Re:Portable vs Console by Serapth · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Yes, but the Pocket PC video chipsets are pure arse compared. I have a HP3950 iPaq ( 400 mhz arm 64 ram ), and it cant run MAME or any other emulators worth a damn. I also have a PSP, and from what ive seen sofar, it will easily be capable of running most older emu's ( SNes, gameboy, earlier mame, etc... ). You really cant compare the two devices, they have different purposes. When it comes to graphics and sound, the PSP blows the PPC out of the water.

    But thats not the worst part. The controls for a Pocket PC are absolutely horrid for gaming! First off, the placement sucks... and secondly most units cant support multiple button presses concurrently.

    In summary, when it comes to gaming you just cant compare the two devices. The PSP way out performs the PPC, but it damn well better, seeing as it was designed for gaming. That said, it rather sucks at reading Excel spreadsheets :)

  12. Things they left out. by Rirath.com · · Score: 4, Informative

    They left out NES, TG16 / PC Engine, and the fact that so far, it's only 1.0. They also didn't mention that there's an up and coming emulator called PSPE that can run PSP some homebrew on your PC. No, it can't run PSP games... but it's interesting for devs and just playing around in general, and rather nice to have this early on.

    As much as I support PSP homebrew and emulation, it's premature to say it's "the ultimate in handheld emulation consoles". Many of these emus work at good speed, and many have sound, but it's still very early in the game. This is just ASKING for flames from the DS and GBA fans, not to mention the POCKET PC which can play everything from the Atari, NES, SNES, TG16, Amiga, C64, and etc including SONY PLAYSTATION.

    As for when us 1.5 folks will see homebrew... "soon", if you believe the rumors Several teams are hard at work on it, and the team Dynarox recently announced "In a really near future, a loader will be released to make games work via the memory card.", so far, no reason has been given to disbelieve them. This loader will probably be in the form of a bios replacement.

    And to answer all the silly questions that are bound to pop up: No, you can't do anything right now. No, you can't downgrade your firmware by any currently known methods. And yes, odds are that "backups" and "emulation" will go hand and hand when this is finally cracked. -- No, this did not kill the Dreamcast, and No, it won't kill the PSP either. -- Proof: It's easy as heck to convert video from your DVDs to MP4 and store on a memory card, but UMD Videos are already a commerical success.

  13. British Games by mr_gerbik · · Score: 3, Funny

    "already it boasts Full Speed Gameboy Colour Emulation"

    But it only plays British games because the US releases are not in colour.

  14. Re:Living under the law by Rayonic · · Score: 2, Informative

    "They" do release emulators for the Palm and PocketPC platforms. Example: http://paqpark.nuclearfallout.net/projects/pockets nes.php

  15. Re:What we realy want to know is... by xombo · · Score: 2, Informative

    Either I live in a topsy turvey town or most market research is wrong.
    PSP has outsold DS by a LONG-SHOT at my store since it came out.
    XBoX has outsold PS2 by a LONG-SHOT at my store since we opened.
    There are whole days where not a single game from the GameCube section leaves the floor.
    There are whole weeks where not a single person touches the DS section.
    But I must tell you, we get TONS of people shopping the PSP section.
    It got so bad that we simply took our DS marketing off the wall and put it in a small display rack like how we display the GBA games. It's nothing impressive. The PSP takes up about as much store space as our GameCube section now.

  16. Re:What we realy want to know is... by falcon5768 · · Score: 2, Funny
    try a real industry site.

    http://www.theregister.co.uk/2005/04/28/ds_psp_sal es/

    The DS has sold twice as many as the PSP has even shipped.

    --

    "Slashdot, where telling the truth is overrated but lying is insightful."

  17. Re:Living under the law by __aamkky7574 · · Score: 2, Insightful
    The problem with playing games on handhelds (I have experience of Palm and iPAQs) is that they simply aren't designed for it. Nothing is more frustating than trying to play a game with sticky keys. Also, the iPAQ couldn't register two seperate key presses at the same time (say, up-left and fire). I tried a few games, everything from NetHack to more recent proprietary games, and gave up.

    P.

    http://oceanclub.blogspot.com/

  18. Zaurus by dangerz · · Score: 2, Insightful

    My Zaurus has been emulating other game devices for a couple years now. Declaring the PSP the *ultimate* emulation machine is a little far fetched.

    --
    The greatest experience we can have is the mysterious.
    - Albert Einstein
  19. Yeah great, but.. by Keichann · · Score: 2, Informative

    A warning for anyone thinking of grabbing homebrew without reading up on it.

    Unfortunately the flash ROM on the PSP is completely writable by anything running on the machine. The 1.50 and 1.51 updates fix this, but in doing so locking out homebrew software. For anyone that can't see the connection - malicious writes to flash = a shiny PSP paperweight.

    http://forums.ps2dev.org/viewtopic.php?t=1962 [ps2dev.org]

    So, if you're going to run homebrew on your PSP, beware the possible consequences. Mine just arrived yesterday, I wish they'd release these things sooner in the EU! Alas, it's 1.50 :(

  20. Erm, no by Mwongozi · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Anyone who thinks the PSP is "the ultimate in handheld emulation consoles" clearly hasn't heard of the GP32.

  21. You forgot the ZX! by Spacejock · · Score: 3, Funny

    Never mind emulating all those trashy modern toys, I want to know when I can run Sinclair Spectrum games on it!

  22. Re:Ain't it funny... by bynary · · Score: 2, Insightful

    When did it become wrong to pay for things? If there is something that I really enjoyed from previous generations, I will pay for it. This whole "everything digital has to be free" movement is sickening. It's this idea of entitlement. Nintendo's not just going to release old games for the hell of it. Suck it up and pay for good software.

    --
    http://www.bynarystudio.com
  23. Re:What we realy want to know is... by delicious · · Score: 2, Funny

    (admit it, with few exceptions every single PS2 game is really just one of about 10 games, but with different graphics and sounds).

    and story, and controls, and gameplay...

  24. Re:Truly awesome by Aero+Leviathan · · Score: 2, Interesting

    This is the kind of thing I wish Sony would hear. They actually stand to profit from giving us what we want and opening up 1.5 to homebrew, via sales of memory cards and probably more systems, yet they don't!

    Tycho of Penny Arcade had a little rant the other day that I thought was quite succinct. Here's an excerpt:

    How would I distinguish the PSP from full platforms? Let me count the ways:

    * Full platforms can play any audio type, or allow applications to do so. . . .

    * Full platforms can play any type of video, or allow applications to do so, and these videos should be able to use the entire resolution of the screen. . . .

    * Executable code

    I'm willing to bend on this one if you give me the other two. But letting people expand the functionality and value of your hardware isn't some imaginary thing. People write whole browsers and operating systems and every other Goddamn contraption, just because it's there. They'll make your product the kind of phenomenon you couldn't pay someone to create.

    --
    ~ Aero