Slashdot Mirror


A House For One Red Paperclip

Tim_F writes to mention the news that Kyle MacDonald (the guy trying to trade a red paperclip for a house) has succeeded in his quest. His recently traded a KISS Snowglobe in exchange for one afternoon with Alice Cooper. He in turn traded the snowglobe to an enthusiastic snowglobe collector, for a role in a movie. From the article: "Now, the town of Kipling, Sask., located about two hours east of Regina with a population of 1,100, has offered MacDonald a farmhouse in exchange for the role in the movie. MacDonald and his girlfriend will fly to the town next Wednesday. 'We are going to show them the house, give them the keys to the house and give them the key to the town and just have some fun,' said Pat Jackson, mayor of Kipling."

35 of 158 comments (clear)

  1. Red paperclip? by BeneathTheVeil · · Score: 3, Funny

    Wouldn't he have accomplished his goal quicker if he started with a red stapler? ...or would have have had to burn the house down when he finally got it?

    1. Re:Red paperclip? by skippy_twin · · Score: 5, Funny

      Actually, it should have been a green paperclip for the house.

      Save the red paperclip for a hotel!

      (Yes, I am missing a few Monopoly pieces. Why do you ask?)

  2. So what? by MarkByers · · Score: 5, Funny

    So what?

    He has a farmhouse in the town of Kipling, Sask.? So...? Why stop now? If he could trade that for two red paperclips, doubling his original investment, I'd be impressed.

    --
    I'll probably be modded down for this...
  3. quote from tfa by Ohreally_factor · · Score: 5, Funny
    "This is not the end. This may be the end of this segment of the story, but this story will go on. "


    It would be ironic if he died of a paper cut that could have been prevented by a paperclip.
    --
    It's not offtopic, dumbass. It's orthogonal.
  4. Kyle MacDonald! by RyanFenton · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Announcer: Kyle MacDonald - come on down! You've been selected to be the latest contestant on...

    Audience: Gimmicky Human Interest Story! [Wild Applause]

    Announcer: That's right! You've managed to amuse us with your heartwarming tale of despiration. You managed to stumble into a kindly corporate sponsor for your story of using ebay, and gotten that radio station to softball you into a whole lot of pain advertisement! And now, latching onto the story, everyone and their brother are selling the hype to eachother that a paper clip can buy a house!

    Audience: Paper clip! Paper clip! [Wild Applause]

    Announcer: It's a great day for you, and a wonderful day to sell shiney new hopes in pretty packaging! That's right folks - the system works - you too can become mega-rich if you're just clever enough to get a radio station to give you prizes!

    Audience: Rich! Rich! Rich! [Wild Applause]

    1. Re:Kyle MacDonald! by wbren · · Score: 4, Interesting

      I think you hit the nail on the head. This story belongs with the Million Dollar Home Page and other stupid ideas that people went along with because it was getting a lot of publicity. This story doesn't prove that bartering is still alive. It doesn't prove that you can start with nothing and end up with something. All it proves is that people are willing to jump on just about any bandwagon. I mean come on, some town no one has ever heard of just happens to give the guy a house for a small movie roll? Hooray for bartering.

      --
      -William Brendel
    2. Re:Kyle MacDonald! by dan.hunt · · Score: 2, Interesting
      I have heard of Kipling, Saskatachewan and a house is still a house. This one would come with a big bonus, a very large percentage of the 1100 people in that town, plus 100's of people who live on farms around that town would care about you. We are talking about the bring you supper and beer while your unpacking, care for you. Get up in the middle of the night to pull your car/truck/minivan out of a snowbank care for you.

      Granted no one would describe life as "fast-paced" and everyone would know details of your life. The joke about no one uses their signal lights because everyone knows where you are going is true. Short distance to Moose Mountain Provincial Park this is not bald prairie but a nice place to live. No I don't live near their. Dan Hunt St. Brieux SK

  5. Almost made it as far as him.... by gsfprez · · Score: 4, Funny

    you've heard all the stories about guys in the military during WWII trading whiskey for bullets or other such things, well, my buddy and i came upon a huge spool of single mode fiber optic cable - Like, dining room table sized. Anyhow, our plan was to trade up the spool of fiber to an F-15 that we could share since we were in the Air Force.

    we got as far as finding a guy that would take the spool from us after we used all the fiber... oh well.

    Best laid plans and all....

    --
    guns kill people like spoons make Rosie O'Donnell fat.
  6. Amazing. by NexFlamma · · Score: 5, Insightful

    This story, more than anything else I've seen, shows the amazing powers of the internet. Simply by connecting so many people in almost-real-time, stuff like this has become a possibility. Admittedly, I'm sure many of the trades only came about via the publicity and novelty of the idea, but before we had the world literally at our fingertips, such ideas wouldn't have been even remotely possible.

    I applaud this guy simply for trying something new and having it work out for him nicely.

    1. Re:Amazing. by AuMatar · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Most of them were. I see very few of the trades that weren't based on novelty or publicity. Paperclip for a pen- novelty. Pen for doorknob- novelty. THe stove and generator were legit, but the snowmobile was pure publicity. So was the trip to Yahk- although props for being so canny in setting it up. The truck was publicity. The recording contract was novelty. The years rent and the afternoon with Alice Cooper were legit (well, Alice probably liked the publicity but I could buy him doing it for an employee without it- it could happen). The snowglobe was legit but the movie role and house were pure publicity as well.

      Basicly he got lucky, got some publicity, and made a few good moves with that publicity to make it happen. Don't expect it to work for you.

      --
      I still have more fans than freaks. WTF is wrong with you people?
    2. Re:Amazing. by Illserve · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Not that the internet isn't useful, changed the world, etc, but this guy's gimmick is only indicative of the power of the internet to spread fads. It might work a second time for someone else, and possibly even a third time, but this kind of thing is basically a one-trick pony.

      It's the pet rock all over again.

      And that guy got more than a crummy farmhouse for his gimmick.

  7. Keep going... by cy_a253 · · Score: 3, Funny

    I think he should keep on trading up. I'm sure someone somewhere would be willing to trade this house for something better. There seems to be no limit now...

    News from the future:
    "This just in. We have learned today that Mr. Kyle MacDonald has just acquired the entirety of the United States of America."
    "I, for one, welcome our barter-trading overlord."

  8. Re:Slashdot story? by kripkenstein · · Score: 3, Funny

    Because it's an opportunity for people to write Funny +5 comments.

    Apparently, on Slashdot, that is reason enough...

  9. Hmm... by iamdrscience · · Score: 2, Funny

    Houses in Saskatchewan are only worth one paperclip? I'm going down to Office Depot to get a case of red paperclips and then I'm buying the whole province.

    1. Re:Hmm... by MrAnnoyanceToYou · · Score: 2, Funny

      Then you have to live there. I mean, that's just a waste of a case of paperclips.

  10. Re:Slashdot story? by Aranth+Brainfire · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Because it's quirky, and appeals to geek culture.

    Sorry for spamming up your Slashdot, I know all of these stories can be hard to follow all the time.

    --
    "Quoting yourself is stupid." -Me
  11. Damn Canadian Accents by Frogbert · · Score: 2, Funny

    I've watched both the videos on the site a number of times and I still have to say Canadian accents are impossible to understand. I can only barely pick out the names, the rest might as well be in french for all I could make of it.

  12. It's not the trade, it's the publicity by MrNougat · · Score: 3, Interesting

    So yeah, one might have been able to trade up a single red paperclip into a house without publicity, but it would have taken longer and been a much more impressive feat.

    Just to make sure everyone knows, this man's (still impressive) accomplishment was fueled not by being able to make smart trades, but by the publicity of the stunt. Clearly, the people trading with him were giving him items of far greater value than what he was providing. The balance of the transaction can be measured in publicity.

    --
    Web 2.0 == Giant Blogspam Circle Jerk
  13. Re:pure hype by jbarket · · Score: 4, Informative

    He traded the KISS Snowglobe for a role in a movie. He then traded the role in the movie for the farmhouse. Nowhere in the article, in his bio, or anywhere else you could have yanked it did it say he was a filmmaker.

    --

    -----
    jonathan barket
  14. Heh by retro128 · · Score: 2, Informative

    Considering you can get a 48 acre farm complete with structures and a home for $140,000 out there, I guess a ratty old farm house isn't too much to part with. Although, I doubt they will sign over the land underneath it, and will essentially let him live there rent free, at least until the novelty wears out.

    --
    -R
  15. Pet Choices by pipingguy · · Score: 5, Funny

    Saskatchewan is one of those places where you can watch your dog run away for a couple of weeks. This is not so with cats or hamsters (too disorganized and buffalo food respectively). Fish still refuse to live in the province.

    1. Re:Pet Choices by dexter+riley · · Score: 3, Funny

      Saskatchewan is one of those places where you can watch your dog run away for a couple of weeks.

      I've heard every joke, I've heard every word you said.
      You think there's not a lot going on...but look closer, baby, you're so wrong.
      And that's why you can stay so long...where there's not a lot going on.

  16. Re:Slashdot story? by NexFlamma · · Score: 2, Funny

    It clearly encapsulates how utterly powerful the internet as a medium for interaction on a world-wide scale has become over the last few decades. From such humble DARPA beginnings to an entity capable of brokering amazingly complicated details (hundreds of thousands of times a day, for that matter), the internet is THE technological advancement of our lifetime.

    How isn't that news for nerds / stuff that matters?

  17. Re:Am I... by pipingguy · · Score: 2, Informative

    I just Goog...uh, searched [Kyle MacDonald paper clip cbc] because I knew that CBC had covered this before. Google replied: "Did you mean: Kyle MacDonald paper clip abc".

    From 2005, CBC News, unformatted for your reading pleasure:

    Montreal man trading paper-clip for house Last Updated Thu, 08 Dec 2005 18:50:27 EST CBC News A Montreal man is grabbing international attention for his increasingly successful quest to barter a single red paper-clip for a house. Five months ago, Kyle MacDonald looked at a red paper-clip on his desk and decided to trade it on an internet website. He got a response almost immediately - from a pair of young women in Vancouver who offered to trade him a pen. "It was a fish-shaped pen. And I got it from a pair of vegans. So it was a great exchange. They didn't want anything to do with fish," he said. MacDonald, 25, then bartered the fish pen for a handmade doorknob from a potter in Seattle. "It was a ceramic doorknob that had been hand-shaped by, I believe the person I traded with, her son, and she had been trying to get rid of it for quite some time," said MacDonald. Annie Robbins, the Seattle potter who now owns the fish pen, says she loves the idea. "I think the whole concept really flips the idea of consumerism around. How we value things, and what things are really worth," she said. In Massachusetts, MacDonald traded the doorknob for a camp stove. He traded the stove to a U.S. marine sergeant in California for a 100-watt generator. In Queens, N.Y., he exchanged the generator for the "instant party kit" - an empty keg of beer and an illuminated Budweiser beer sign. On Thursday, MacDonald traded the keg and sign for a Bombardier snowmobile, courtesy of a Montreal radio host. "If I get up to larger items, I'm going to need a larger base of people to pick from. There is someone out there with a surplus house. I just have to find them," said MacDonald.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kyle_MacDonald

  18. Re:Red paperclip by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

    Oh, a "red" paperclip, is it?

    Do I detect a not-so-subtle anticapitalist polemic at work here??

  19. Off to prison... by Sqreater · · Score: 2, Funny

    [Two guys on the porch of a rickety farmhouse]

    Knock Knock Knock. "I don't think he's answering." KNOCK KNOCK KNOCK!

    Creak, crack, stomp stomp stomp, squeeeeeeeeek, "Oh, hello guys! What can I do for you?"

    Well, Old MacDonald, it's about your farm. We're from the Canadian Revenue Agency and we have a few questions to ask you regarding the taxes you did or did not pay on the transactions you made from paperclip to farm house. Would you please put these handcuffs on so we can converse in a calm environment?"

    --
    E Proelio Veritas.
  20. obvious question... by mennucc1 · · Score: 2, Funny

    nice house.... but did the paperclip run Linux?

  21. Kipling land value by mh101 · · Score: 4, Insightful
    To give you all an idea of how much land is worth... Current for sale in or around Kipling:


    And here's a complete map of Kipling.

    --
    Duct tape is like the Force. It has a light side, a dark side, and it holds the universe together.
    1. Re:Kipling land value by ckedge · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Very true. I'm originally from a town not far away. 10 years ago my grandparents died and we inherited their house. Built turn of the century with bricks (beautiful old thing), living room addition, beautiful huge yard with hedges and lawns (plural) and flower gardens (I mean 30 x 30 foot flower garden with paths and everything, another set of flower beds surrounding a path circling the house behind hedges), 2 sheds, 2 stories, 4 bedrooms, ancient beautiful hardwood floor dining room (not huge). Lot must have been 100 x 100 feet or larger. My Grandmother spent a huge amount of her time just gardening and keeping the yard up.

      It was on the market for 2 years. We were happy to finally unload it for $3000 CDN. Yes, I said $3000. And we were glad to get a buyer.

      Thing about small towns is their populations are decreasing, so there are a ton of houses of various ages and sizes that are selling for $2000-$15,000. In fact every single year the town siezes and demolishes a couple houses that were abandoned for 5-15 years (and were in bad shape for 10 years before that) and had taxes owing.

      I know retiring farmers who moved to town and bought an empty 100 foot lot (costs like $50) and build $200,000 houses (small town with plumbers and builders working for $20 CDN per hour or less - so these are nice f'ing houses), and these people buy the two old decrepid houses on either side of their lot for a few thou each and demolish them, just so they don't have to look at eyesores when they look out their windows. Seriously, brand new house, two empty lots on either side of them.**

      Fuck Toronto and it's $500,000 1200sq foot shitty looking two story duplexes (so you get a 2500 sq foot house that's been split in half internally by a wall, with your half spread over two stories - and you pay $500,000 CDN ($400,000 USD) for it.

      I'm retiring to Saskatchewan*, and I'll be doing it 15 years earlier than I otherwise would be able to afford.

      (*) or maybe some similar small town in Alberta or BC (if I can find something similar there, might not be, what with the mountains and oil and all).

      (**) Don't get the impression that it's a town full of decrepid houses. Most are well kept by owners. But here and there sprinkled throught town are ones for sale or held for rental (a lot of them empty, used to be a good idea). My hometown has had fully paved/curbed roads for nigh 20 years now, beautiful place. Not a single unpaved road in it.

  22. Re:Do you like Kipling? by pyrrhonist · · Score: 3, Funny

    I've never Kippled. What's it like?

    --
    Show me on the doll where his noodly appendage touched you.
  23. Now a Major Motion Picture! by jdbartlett · · Score: 3, Funny

    Kyle MacDonald: "One Red Paperclip" - NOW A MAJOR MOTION PICTURE!

    See! the hit comic action adventure drama, starring Will Smith as Kyle MacDonald, Uma Thurman as his long suffering girlfriend, and Lindsay Lohan as the paperclip.

    Hear! Will Smith's amusing remarks as he trades pieces of junk for larger, more profitable junk!

    Cry! when Will Smith unwittingly trades a van for a piece of paper, almos losing long-time girlfriend Uma Thurman.

    Laugh! when it turns out the piece of paper was a recording contract!

    Based on a true life story! (Some liberties taken; various items replaced by famous celebrities and the internet replaced by word-of-mouth of the quirky inhabitants of Will Smith's home town in Northern California).

    Sample the from riveting novelization:

    "CHAPTER 1. It started with this paperclip. Then he trades it in for a pen. Then, like, he trades it in again, but for a doorknob... Then he goes and trades it for a coleman stove. Then he trades the stove for James Woods. 'Hey, buddy.' Says James Woods, 'I'm James Woods.' 'Beleeve dat,' says Will Smith - his catchphrase for the film."

  24. List of trades by Diamon · · Score: 2, Informative

    Red Paperclip --> Fish Pen
    Fish Pen --> Doorknob
    Doorknob --> Coleman Stove
    Coleman Stove --> Generator
    Generator --> "Instant Party" (Beer Keg, Neon Sign, I.O.U. for Keg's worth of Beer)
    "Instant Party" --> Skidoo
    Skidoo --> Trip to Yahk
    Trip to Yahk --> Cube Van (Box Truck)
    Cube Van --> Recording Contract
    Recording Contract --> Year in Phoenix (Airfare to Phoenix and use of house rent free for one year)
    Year in Phoenix --> Afternoon with Alice Cooper
    Afternoon with Alice Cooper --> KISS Snowglobe
    KISS Snowglobe --> Movie Role
    Movie Role --> House

  25. Re:Do you like Kipling? by KnightStalker · · Score: 2, Funny

    Dammit! I've been out-obscured.

    --
    * And remember, it's spelled N-e-t-s-c-a-p-e, but it's pronounced "Mozilla."
  26. But how much did he spend? by Kuukai · · Score: 2, Insightful

    If this guy was flying from Montreal to Vancouver to Seattle and so forth, staying in hotels, paying for internet access, and eating food, for a whole year, how much money did he start out with?! I mean, is it not reasonable to assume that if he actually worked he could have easily bought a house on the Canadian countryside withing a year?

    --
    Sendou Wave Kick!!
  27. Re:Let the trading begin! by Flyboy+Connor · · Score: 2, Funny

    Hey, I have a Jenna Jameson doll which I intend to trade up to the real thing.