Slashdot Mirror


Sega Genesis Collection for PSP and PS2

An anonymous reader writes "Sega has announced what may be the coolest retro collection yet in a compilation of 30 Sega Genesis games for the PSP and PS2. 1up has a great breakdown of the games in the collection, which features everything from the Phantasy Star games to the Golden Axe games, to the Shinobis, to the Vectormans. Pretty cool stuff." From the article: "Sega's doing its part to give these games context with numerous unlockable interviews with the original developers and a museum with trivia on the disc. According to Sega, the games will be reproduced with 'the utmost accuracy to the originals as possible' by developer Backbone Entertainment. And as a special cool bonus, the PSP version will allow -- for the first time ever -- wireless multiplayer for several of the games. "

73 comments

  1. This is cool and all.. by rsilvergun · · Score: 3, Insightful

    now for God's sake, release ports of Radient Silvergun and Panzer Dragoon Saga so I don't have to blow $400+ dollars on ebay to play them.

    --
    Hi! I make Firefox Plug-ins. Check 'em out @ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/youtube-mp3-podcaster/
    1. Re:This is cool and all.. by joe_bruin · · Score: 4, Funny

      The PSP doesn't Blast Processing (tm), so I don't see how any of these games are going to work.

    2. Re:This is cool and all.. by despisethesun · · Score: 1

      That joke would have been funnier if he were talking about Genesis games. "Blast Processing" was never an advertised "feature" of the Sega Saturn.

      --
      This poo is cold.
    3. Re:This is cool and all.. by David+Nabbit · · Score: 1

      I acquired PD Saga for about $100 on ebay. Then again, that was five or six years ago, so it could be more rare now.

      --
      "Her idea of wit is nothing more than an incisive observation humorously phrased and delivered with impeccable timing."
    4. Re:This is cool and all.. by joe_bruin · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Actually, it would have been funnier if I had proofread it and found that it's missing the word "have" (or "do") in between "doesn't" and "Blast". That's what happens when you do copy-and-paste editing. In my post I wasn't referring to the games the parent was talking about, I was simply riding his early, well-moderated comment to tack my joke on. If fact, I was not even aware those were Saturn games, since I've yet to meet someone who admits to having owned one of those machines.

    5. Re:This is cool and all.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      if you can find the right model of saturn you can just install a modchip and play them burned. cost me about $80 total after shipping.

    6. Re:This is cool and all.. by twistedsymphony · · Score: 1

      Last time I checked $100 would get you just the first disc with no box or manual... and badly scratched at that. You'd be lucky if you could even find a complete PD Saga game in good shape, nevermind the price you'd have to pay to make it yours.

      It's pretty sad when it's unbelievably easier to aquire the game by alternative illegal methods.

    7. Re:This is cool and all.. by TheNumberless · · Score: 1

      I have one. I keep it next to my Virtual Boy. (No, I'm not joking.)

      Nice to meet you :)

  2. No Shadowrun? by wuie · · Score: 3, Interesting

    What's the deal, chummer? No Shadowrun?

    Don't make me come over there and frag some wage slaves!

    1. Re:No Shadowrun? by NexFlamma · · Score: 1

      Sega didn't create Shadowrun, nor do they probably have the rights to it.

      With the new Shadowrun coming out for the 360, I doubt you'll see the Genesis version anywhere outside of an (illegal) emulator any time soon.

    2. Re:No Shadowrun? by FusionDragon2099 · · Score: 1

      Microsoft currently has the exclusive rights to make Shadowrun videogames, according to the official Shadowrun website.

    3. Re:No Shadowrun? by HunterZ · · Score: 1

      http://www.mobygames.com/game/genesis/shadowrun

      The Genesis version of Shadowrun was made by a developer called BlueSky and was published by SEGA, so it should be feasible to re-publish unless Microsoft has control over titles produced before they acquired the rights to the franchise.

      At any rate, it would be make-or-break for me for any Genesis collection.

      Oh well, at least it has Phantasy Star 4, which they didn't manage to port to the GBA to go with the first 3 for some reason (they could have at least released it on its own cart).

      --
      Arguing about vi versus Emacs is like arguing whether it's better to make fire by rubbing sticks or banging rocks.
  3. It's missing some... by Not+Anonymous+Coward · · Score: 1

    Like the Shining Series, Streets of Rage Series, Sonic 3 and Sonic and Knuckles, Zero Wing (For Great Justice!). Honestly, though, I'm still waiting for the Phantasy Star I, II, and IV 3D Remakes... What ever happened to that anyway?

    --
    [VODAK - Apply Directly to the Mouth!] [VODAK - Apply Directly to the Mouth!] [VODAK - Apply Directly to the Mouth!]
    1. Re:It's missing some... by Belgarion89 · · Score: 3, Funny

      IIRC, Zero Wing was never released for the Genesis in the US. Apparantly all our base doesn't belong to Sega.

    2. Re:It's missing some... by famikon · · Score: 1

      Gunstar Heroes!

    3. Re:It's missing some... by NsOmNiA91130 · · Score: 1

      Michael Jackson's Moonwalker. Seriously.

    4. Re:It's missing some... by wed128 · · Score: 1

      It's actually a pretty good game once you get past the rediculousness

    5. Re:It's missing some... by famikon · · Score: 1

      The sad thing is that's true. They even tossed in a mini space flight sim. But there is PLENTY of rediculousness to get past.

    6. Re:It's missing some... by Reapman · · Score: 1

      I beat that game a few times... level design wasn't that bad, especially for the time and hey, killing people by out dancing them, how can you top that?

  4. um by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    So, do we get a /. story with every Capcom Classics Collection, now?

    this one gets slownewsday

  5. What about the Revolution? by Daetrin · · Score: 3, Interesting

    So will the same bundle be available on Nintendo's virtual console? Or will we have to buy each game separately for that format? Or is Sega going to outright renege on the agreement they presumably had with Nintendo to support the virtual console?

    --
    This Space Intentionally Left Blank
    1. Re:What about the Revolution? by Babbster · · Score: 4, Insightful

      What does one thing have to do with the other? I doubt that Sega negotiated any kind of exclusivity with Nintendo for their Wii/Genesis emulation support, and they would be stupid do so unless the money offered by Nintendo was huge.

      Besides, exclusives are bad for gamers.

    2. Re:What about the Revolution? by Daetrin · · Score: 1

      That may be an answer to the last question, but it doesn't address the first part at all. I'm curious what the price point will be for the PS2 collection and how it will compare to the price point on the virtual console version if the collection gets relased for it. Nintendo might not be happy if the Sega collection is cheap enough to make people reconsider purchasing NES and SNES games at whatever pricepoint Nintendo was originally thinking of. On the other hand if it turns out to be cheaper to get on the virtual console, either as a whole or piecemeal, some people might feel a little silly if they jump to get the PS2 version as soon as it comes out. I should keep telling myself that when it does come out :)

      --
      This Space Intentionally Left Blank
    3. Re:What about the Revolution? by Babbster · · Score: 1

      Here's the way I see it from Nintendo's end: For most people, the emulated games available online through the Wii are going to be a bonus. The only people who would buy the Wii specifically for that purpose are those few "hardcore" (wow, overused) retro gamers who won't, for whatever reason, download emulators and ROMs. The only way those people will feel cheated by the service is if a) the downloads just cost too much (anything over $5 a pop should be considered too much) and/or b) the selection of games is limited to those that have already had a recent release on a console they already own (like if the only Sega games available are the ones that are on this Genesis collection and the aforementioned Sonic collection). If those two factors don't come into play, then whether the individual price on the Wii adds up to more than buying them together on the PS2/PSP won't matter much, because most people buy those collections in order to get maybe 5 or 6 games in which they're particularly interested.

      From the Sega side: The cost of releasing these games in the DVD format for PS2 is [obviously] very small. They'll probably end up with a profit just on the initial orders of the collection. So, even if none of the people who get a Wii buy the collection, they're still likely to make a profit on the release.

    4. Re:What about the Revolution? by Daetrin · · Score: 2, Insightful
      The only people who would buy the Wii specifically for that purpose are those few "hardcore" (wow, overused) retro gamers who won't, for whatever reason, download emulators and ROMs.

      And gee, there might be a few of us who look forward to being able to legitemately purchase some of the games that we missed out on back on the first run of the NES and SNES. The fact that they'll be on a real console should make getting together groups of people for multiplayer a lot easier. I've never had much luck convincing other people to play multiplayer games on an emulator. I'm particularly looking forward to MULE which i used to have a lot of fun playing with my friends back in the day.

      I never owned a Sega Saturn and never got very many games for the Sega Genesis so i'm especially looking forward for the chance to play those games. And i'm really hoping that they release whichever version of Bomberman it was that let you have more than four players playing at a time. (How many controllers can the Revolution handle? The fact that it can do four wireless controllers _and_ has four ports for GameCube controllers makes me hope that it will be able to handle at least eight at a time, though admitedly i don't have anything to base that on other than wishfull thinking.)

      --
      This Space Intentionally Left Blank
    5. Re:What about the Revolution? by media_Assassin · · Score: 1
      I'm curious what the price point will be for the PS2 collection ...
      EB Games is listing the PS2 bundle at $19.99, and $29.99 for the PSP.
    6. Re:What about the Revolution? by ShadowsHawk · · Score: 1

      My wife is extremely excited at the prospect of playing old NES games on the Wii. I've actually showed her SMB and a few others in rom form, but she's simply not interested. For her, it's all about the experience of sitting in front of the TV with a classic controller.

    7. Re:What about the Revolution? by poot_rootbeer · · Score: 1

      EB Games is listing the PS2 bundle at $19.99, and $29.99 for the PSP.

      Thirty games for thirty dollars. Or less.

      That means that the market price for retro/classic gaming is moving towards below $1/title. If this trend continues, it may not be much longer that Xbox Live Arcade can get away with charging a whole ten dollars for one 15-year-old game, and should put to rest the worries that the Nintendo Virtual Console pricing scheme will be high enough to discourage potential buyers.

  6. no wonderboy ? by eyegee88 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Too bad they didnt put wonderboy, a real nice classic.

    1. Re:no wonderboy ? by MainframeKiller · · Score: 1

      Wonderboy (1, 2 and 3) were for the Sega Master System, not the Genesis

      --
      http://www.club977.com/ - The 80's Channel!
      Your source for commercial free 80's music!
  7. Gift Idea! by abrotman · · Score: 2, Funny

    I think I know what I'm asking for as a gift for Veteran's Day!!!!

  8. I wonder ... by Tink2000 · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Just how much of this is reaction to the perception of the fan-base that these titles are "abandonware"? I mean, aside from ROMs and old-skool computer geeks, how badly missed are these games, and since they are now coming back in updated format is this simply a way to crack down on emulators and ROM sites?

    I wish they'd release PSI (Master System) and Herzog Zwei (Genesis), myself... good times, good times...

    1. Re:I wonder ... by maynard · · Score: 1

      A bunch of these games were great. I think the issue is not so much that Sega/Sony are attempting to recommoditize abondonware as much as that there is demand for official ports. Perhaps this means a partial return to top down and side scrollers in liu of more 3D mega-games. I've had my fill of 3D gaming, and perhaps the DS success is an example Sony might want to capture as well. JMO...

    2. Re:I wonder ... by kirun · · Score: 2, Interesting

      There are already a load of retro arcade collections available. I own a ton of GBA ones. Most of them are pretty good reproductions, but a few are awkward (like Bubble Bobble needs to zoom out or scroll to get the correct resolution, Robotron doesn't work exactly right because the GBA didn't have enough Fire buttons). I also own Atari Retro Classics DS, which has to be the buggiest, most thrown-together piece of junk I've seen in a long time. I nearly gave it to a jumble sale, but if somebody paid 10p for it, they'd have been ripped off. My absolute favourite is the Game & Watch Gallery, as it has both the originals, and remakes that work, by capturing the spirit of the originals.

      I don't think this is a way to crack down on the sites - abandonware doesn't mean it's legal to copy, it's more of an "ethical" gloss, that you're not denying anyone a sale if the thing actually isn't for sale. There is some genuinely legit stuff- many companies have released their rights to 8-bit home computer games, authors who have released their stuff, and occasional bundle deals like with the HotRod joystick. However, the way the law is at the moment, there is no requirement to actually sell a product to keep copyright, and companies have the legal right to shut down sites should they feel like it.

      It should also be noted that in many cases, it really is basically impossible to get the games legally for an emulator. A few years back, I enquired with a bunch of companies (a) Do you sell collections of your "classic" games, and (b) If I buy one, can I then get matching ROMsets for these games and use the emulator of my choice. Sega pointed me at the SegaPC division, who sent me a note reminding me that piracy is evilwrongnaughtybad. The person I spoke to at Hasbro Interactive hadn't even heard of emulation and didn't understand why I wanted to play the originals over their shiny remakes. Activision had the clue to know what I was asking, and said sorry that their classics-related offerings didn't let me grab the equivalent ROMs.

      --
      I'm scared of numbers that can't be written as a fraction. It's an irrational fear.
    3. Re:I wonder ... by Kohath · · Score: 1

      is this simply a way to crack down on emulators and ROM sites?

      I think it's an attempt to sell games. Just a guess though.

    4. Re:I wonder ... by apathyruiner · · Score: 1

      it really is basically impossible to get the games legally for an emulator

      Well, you could buy/find/make your own dumper, find the carts at a flea market or "jumble sale" and dump them yourself.

      --
      -= I can't think of anything witty, creative, or insightful for my sig, so deal with this. =-
    5. Re:I wonder ... by NexFlamma · · Score: 1

      Agreed. If I could get a full compilation of Phantasy Star 1-4 (hopefully on the DS), I would be the happiest pony in all of ponyville.

    6. Re:I wonder ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      There was a Phantasy Star Collection for GBA that included 1-3.

      I think maybe I must have been one of the few people who bought it. Plans for Phantasy Star 4 either for GBA or PS2 have "been in the works" since 2003 but have always fallen through.

      I'll believe this release of PS4 when it's in my sweaty nerd hands.

    7. Re:I wonder ... by Akaihiryuu · · Score: 1

      I remember Herzog Zwei...it's the earliest RTS game I can ever remember seeing. It beat Dune 2 and Warcraft by something like 5 years. It's not exactly like modern RTS's (you fly a plane around, pick up/drop units, and you have to pick up a unit to give it an order, and there are only like 3 orders - defend, patrol, and attack enemy base)...but it's definitely an RTS, even if you don't have direct control over the units. Very very fun game. I think it should be recognized as one of the first RTS's, even though Dune 2 and Warcraft probably will get credit for refining the genre and kicking it into high gear.

  9. Mixed feelings by BertieBaggio · · Score: 2, Informative

    I'll admit, when I saw this I thought "Excellent, a chance to do what I really want: play the classic games I love, portably". Then I realised that Sony wasn't doing a Good Thing (TM) at all. The Good Thing would be to stop messing with the firmware with every damn update and let the homebrew developers in. Give me the ability to run a Genesis emulator without jumping through contrived hoops (which are really holes in Sony's attempted patching), and without a chance of bricking an expensive piece of kit. Hell, I'd be willing to pay a reasonable amount, say $5-10, to 'unlock' the PSP to do homebrew stuff. I don't think such a move would be morally right (and probably not financially right for Sony, what with support), but I *really* like the old Genesis games.

    As for the game lineup itself... well, it's good, but they could've done better. Golden Axe is plain fun, and Phantasy Star will keep you entertained for quite a while. Sonic 1 and 2 are *excellent*, but they missed the best of the lot: Sonic 3 + Sonic & Knuckles. I can't believe this is by accident. I smell a "Genesis Collection Vol II" in the works.

    Will I buy this collection? Nah. true, it's the right sort of idea -- and multiplayer makes it *almost* worthwhile -- but I just don't agree with either the method or the game choice. So come on Sony, let us use our hardware the way we damn well please, and do what we will with emulators and other nice things.

    (...and while you're at it, let us rip UMD games to memory sticks. Those things are sloooow. kthxbye)

    --
    If all you have is a grenade, pretty soon every problem looks like a foxhole -- MightyYar
    1. Re:Mixed feelings by Babbster · · Score: 1
      As for the game lineup itself... well, it's good, but they could've done better. Golden Axe is plain fun, and Phantasy Star will keep you entertained for quite a while. Sonic 1 and 2 are *excellent*, but they missed the best of the lot: Sonic 3 + Sonic & Knuckles. I can't believe this is by accident. I smell a "Genesis Collection Vol II" in the works.

      Sonic Mega Collection Plus (PS2) has both of the games you mentioned, plus many more. You might be right that they're thinking about doing more classic releases if this one does well, but at least on home consoles classic Sonic is pretty well represented (the GC version lacks a bit, though, compared to the PS2 and Xbox versions of the above-mentioned collection).
    2. Re:Mixed feelings by BertieBaggio · · Score: 2, Informative

      Sonic Mega Collection Plus (PS2) has both of the games you mentioned, plus many more

      I appreciate the sentiment, but this announcement is newsworthy (to me) mainly because of the announcement of these games for the *PSP*. The PS2 is a neat system, but if I'm playing a fixed console, why don't I just fire up the games on my original Genesis (à la Mega Drive over here)? Better still, I can play them on my PC, and take advantage of save states and save state 'hacking' to make the game do interesting things. I can also take screenshots / recordings easier on the PC, and I can store my *entire* game collection in a fairly small space, and take it with me on a USB stick. Plus, I'e seen (though do correct me if I'm wrong) that you need to play game X for Y number of times before you can 'unlock' other games. Artificial restrictions suck. NB I came across this on GameFaqs for some Sonic-related + other classics game collection if you want to look before I'm refuted.

      Now, playing on the PSP is a different matter. It's better than a USB stick since you can play *anywhere*, so long as you have power. I'm sure there are smart homebrew developers that were able to port all the handy features (eg savestates etc) of the PC emulator counterparts. That is exactly the kind of thing I want from my PSP, and part of my rationale for buying one when they came out.

      I guess what irritated me about this collection was: 1) Sony wanting to say "Hey, we're into classic games too!" whilst trying frantically to lock out homebrew developers (wouldn't it be apropos to have a further lock-out firmware update included on the UMD with this collection, mandatory to play the games?) and 2) No Sonic 3 + K :'(

      --
      If all you have is a grenade, pretty soon every problem looks like a foxhole -- MightyYar
    3. Re:Mixed feelings by Babbster · · Score: 2, Informative
      I guess what irritated me about this collection was: 1) Sony wanting to say "Hey, we're into classic games too!" whilst trying frantically to lock out homebrew developers (wouldn't it be apropos to have a further lock-out firmware update included on the UMD with this collection, mandatory to play the games?)

      Wouldn't it be Sega saying that they're "into classic games," given that they're the ones making this game? If Sony is saying anything by trying to lock out emulators, it's "Hey, Sega, we're trying hard to lock PSP users out of emulators so that you and other companies can actually make money off the games you own."
    4. Re:Mixed feelings by BertieBaggio · · Score: 1

      TFA doesn't seem to mention a 'developer' / porter / publisher, but I guess Sega would be a sound guess. You make a good point actually; in a sense, Sony is getting good PR from this both ways.

      To Sega, they can say:"We're good guys. We are putting up roadblocks to try and halt homebrew development, and are keeping the average user away from Genesis emulators. You guys get to rerelease old games and we both make money!"

      To users, they can say:"Hey, look! We have some classic Genesis games officially and easily (for a very reasonable fee) avaliable to play on the PSP! Just like you wanted! See, we're good guys! We told you it would be an innovative console (and you don't need to bother with those so-called 'homebrewers')."

      I say (again): "We paid for it; we own it. Let us do what we damn well like with our hardware."

      --
      If all you have is a grenade, pretty soon every problem looks like a foxhole -- MightyYar
    5. Re:Mixed feelings by merlin_jim · · Score: 1

      appreciate the sentiment, but this announcement is newsworthy (to me) mainly because of the announcement of these games for the *PSP*. The PS2 is a neat system, but if I'm playing a fixed console, why don't I just fire up the games on my original Genesis (à la Mega Drive over here)? Better still, I can play them on my PC, and take advantage of save states and save state 'hacking' to make the game do interesting things. I can also take screenshots / recordings easier on the PC, and I can store my *entire* game collection in a fairly small space, and take it with me on a USB stick.

      You can do all those things on the PS2 today. Action Replay Max includes a USB stick for PS2 Save Games (including a memory manager to copy to/from memory cards), and it can play media files and genesis roms either from USB or DVD drive.

      Picked it up last week from Best Buy for $40. Looking for genesis roms tonight.

      --
      I am disrespectful to dirt! Can you see that I am serious?!
  10. Enough Value Added? by SlashdotOgre · · Score: 2, Interesting

    It ought to be interesting to see if there will be enough bonus features to compete with homebrew emulators. If the price is reasonable ($30 or less) and the games are at least slightly updated (eg. the Sonic Jam or GBA versions of the games), then I'd consider it.

    --
    Sadly, PS/2 was yet another victim of USB, which doesn't care what you plug into it, the electrical slut.
  11. wow! by minus_273 · · Score: 4, Funny

    finally a new original game on the PSP that not a port! oh wait..

    --
    The war with islam is a war on the beast
    The war on terror is a war for peace
  12. Good! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Just when I thought the PSP had more firmware updates than games...

  13. Sega CD Versions? by Conception · · Score: 1

    The article doesn't say if these will be the Sega CD versions or no? Although the Sega CD was a terrible flop and what not, it did make better versions of the genesis games.

  14. Err, why would you buy those on eBay? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    > so I don't have to blow $400+ dollars on ebay to play them.

    Try the Gens emulator plus a ROM. The fidelity of the emulators is excellent and ROMs aren't very hard to find if you can manage to work past a bit of search engine spam. Much better than paying $400, and even if you have copyright hangups, they weren't going to get paid for the copy you bought on eBay, anyhow.

    1. Re:Err, why would you buy those on eBay? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Radiant Silvergun and Panzer Dragoon Saga are Saturn games, and there's no decent Saturn emulation yet.

    2. Re:Err, why would you buy those on eBay? by SirSlud · · Score: 1

      there's no decent Saturn emulation yet

      Your ideas intrigue me and I would like to subscribe to your newsletter.

      --
      "Old man yells at systemd"
  15. Good news but where's my Sonic 3 & Knuckles? by Wiseman1024 · · Score: 1

    This is very good news, and finally we see they're releasing a good number of games, not just 5-6 (pm àst compilations: it's not fun to pay whole price for 5-6 games, older than gramps --great games, but older than gramps-- you already own). The only downside to it is: Where's my Sonic 3 & Knuckles? Goddamn them, they must've thought this through; they'll be releasing another collection with the missing great games. I think they are missing... - Sonic 3 & Knuckles (S&K with Sonic 3 on) - Sonic 1 & Knuckles/Bonus stages (S&K with Sonic 1 on) - Knuckles in Sonic 2 (S&K with Sonic 2 on) - Shining Force 2 (I bet my ass this will be in the next compilation, too great to miss) - Shining Force And I pray to... something that they get a deal to include Wonderboy 5 in Monster World (AKA Monster World 3). They could even throw in Wonderboy 6 (Monster World 4) as a freebie, using DeJap's fine translation.

    --
    I was about to say 13256278887989457651018865901401704640, but it appears this number is private property.
  16. Shinin', shinin', shinin' by tepples · · Score: 1
    It's missing ... the Shining Series

    That's because the Shinin' series is already on PSP.

  17. Re:Good news but where's my Sonic 3 & Knuckles by BertieBaggio · · Score: 1

    Agreed. I was pretty miffed about the lack of S3 & K et al, but the Shining series was a bunch of great games. I spent countless hours playing and replaying the Sonic games and Shining Force 1 -- time unrivalled even by modern games (no I don't play WoW). I'll admit the rest of the games on offer aren't bad, but, as noted above and in other comments, there are some surprising omissions. Makes you wonder - did Sony/Sega listen to the community (or even common sense) when choosing the games for publication on this compilation? Or were they watching their bankroll for "Sega Genesis Collection Volume 2, for PSP, PS2 and PS3" ?

    --
    If all you have is a grenade, pretty soon every problem looks like a foxhole -- MightyYar
  18. Doesn't sound that good to me by Stormwatch · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Altered Beast, Bonanza Bros, Flicky, Gain Ground, Golden Axe, Super Thunder Blade - why the Genesis versions? Port from the better-looking arcade versions.

    Sonic The Hedgehog - again? Sonic Mega Collection was released two years ago!

    Virtua Fighter 2 - gotta be kidding me... release the Sega Ages port instead.

    Phantasy Star series - now here's the most flawed part. It's incomplete, put the first one there too - anything less won't do. And in PS2 and PS3, I sure don't want accuracy: despite the good plots, these games desperately need a massive overhaul! They look crappy, sound horrible, have exceedingly complex labyrinths, characters move and level-up too slowly.

    This compilation is overall very weak. It certainly could use games like Beyond Oasis, Alien Soldier, Gunstar Heroes, Pulseman, Dynamite Headdy, Kid Chameleon, Ranger X, Revenge of Shinobi, Mystic Defender, and the Shining Force series.

    1. Re:Doesn't sound that good to me by Archon · · Score: 1

      Oh crap. "Gunstar Heroes". Now I think I'm going to cry. I loved that game so much.

    2. Re:Doesn't sound that good to me by NexFlamma · · Score: 1

      While I agree with you that it SHOULD include those games, in a perfect world, here in reality, Sega is only legally allowed to put out a compilation of it's own IP's and certain games that it published. Almost all of the games you mentioned aren't Sega properties, and thusly couldn't be included.

      Though, I will heartily agree that we need to see some Shining Force action soon! Preferably a collection that includes all of the Genesis games and the all versions of SF3, including the ones we didn't get here in the US.

    3. Re:Doesn't sound that good to me by Duds · · Score: 1

      A reasomable proportion of the ones you ask for were not published by Sega.

    4. Re:Doesn't sound that good to me by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Revenge of Shinobi should have been in the collection. It's Sega's game, and they put two other Shinobi games in there, which though they are good, Revenge of Shinobi was just awesome.

    5. Re:Doesn't sound that good to me by merlin_jim · · Score: 1

      If you read my other post in this story the Action Replay MAX includes a Genesis emulator for PS2.

      Yes I know I could do it on my PC but gaming in the living room comfortably with my wife in the setting intended for those games sounds much better to me.

      Anyways... thanks for the list of games to try out!!!!!

      --
      I am disrespectful to dirt! Can you see that I am serious?!
  19. Re:Good news but where's my Sonic 3 & Knuckles by Gothic_Walrus · · Score: 1

    Where's your Sonic 3 and Knuckles? In the Sonic Mega Collection Plus, of course. They've got Sonic 3 and Knuckles, the Sonic 1 and Knuckles bonus stage game, Sonic 2 and Knuckles...why, everything you think is missing! And for only $20 to boot!

    Sega isn't run by idiots. Including all of the Sonic games in the package would mean that the incentive for buying the Mega Collection is close to zero. Even if it's an older title, it's still being produced and there's still some level of demand for it.

    In any case, there won't BE another collection, more than likely, because this covers most of the bases as far as notable Genesis titles go. It might not be perfect, but this is easily one of the strongest retro compilations we've seen yet, and anyone who doesn't think it'll sell well is a fool.

    --
    Goo goo g'joob.
  20. Tip: Disable Javascript by winphreak · · Score: 1

    Just to get around the lousy keyword ads.

    Of course, this may be too late, as it's been /.'d

    --
    "I'm a well-wisher, in that I don't wish you any specific harm."
  21. sub-expectado.. by newr00tic · · Score: 1

    Collections such as these won't always meet your expectations; if for nothing else, modern controllers aren't close enough to what the original games used, and so it won't always work that well.

    "Midway Arcade Treasures 2" - Xbox(1):

    Mortal Kombat 2, Mortal Kombat 3, Gauntlet II, Spyhunter II, Xybots, NARC, APB, Cyberball 2072, Timber, Total Carnage, Pit Fighter, Wizard of Wor, Xenophobe, Primal Rage, Arch Rivals, Rampage World Tour, Kozmik Krooz'r, Championship Spirit, Hard Drivin', Wacko.

    -Of these, Timber is "the best;" works well, and is fun. Rampage W.T. actually works with the "modern" controller aswell, but there are limits to how fun that one is over time. - - - Most of the remaining titles doesn't quite work, sorry to say..

    (..evaluated with the "S"-controller series; "small", compared to bulky original controller..)

    --
    A horse can't be sick, you know, even if he wants to.
    1. Re:sub-expectado.. by bVork · · Score: 1

      Well, one difference between the two compilations is that the Sega one will be of Genesis games. The Genesis gamepad is awfully similar to current modern pads (including the PSP's), so the control schemes can stay relatively intact.

      Midway Arcade Treasures 2, on the other hand, contained arcade games. One of the more interesting aspects of arcade games is that developers can experiment with unconventional controls without significantly increasing the price of a cabinet. Sprint, for instance, had a really cool free-spinning wheel. It was a lot of fun to just whip that thing around to turn. There's no way an analog stick can possibly duplicate that control scheme. Another issue with MAT2 was that the emulation on some of the games just wasn't very good. It was impossible to fight Smoke in Mortal Kombat 2, since pressing start opened up the menu screen!

      Hopefully the emulation of these Genesis games is accurate. Knowing Sega, though, I don't expect much. Anyone remember that Genesis compilation on Dreamcast? The one with the absolutely terrible sound? Another issue is the PSP's dpad, which is absolute garbage. Diagonals are next to impossible to perform. Ristar in particular is going to suffer, as a lot of the gameplay was based on grabbing things at angles.

      A final issue, echoed by other posters already, is that some of these games were originally arcade games. Virtua Fighter 2's Genesis port was not very good. I'd much rather see a port closer to the arcade version. Hell, I'd buy a Saturn-level (which was great but by no means arcade perfect) standalone port of VF2 on PSP, without any extras or other games! Thunder Blade and especially the Golden Axe games are also much better in their original arcade incarnations. While I'm ranting, where are the second-party games? Tec(h)nosoft's Thunder Force series (well, 3 and 4) would be a great inclusion, as would Treasure's legendary Gunstar Heroes and Alien Soldier. Sega published a PS2 compilation of Treasure's (non-MacDonalds) Genesis games, so why omit them here?

      And finally, though this is just barely on-topic, Sega needs to grow a brain and re-release Panzer Dragoon Saga on PSP or something. The game goes for $150 or so on eBay and people still buy it at that price. Square figured this out and published Valkyrie Profile: Lenneth on PSP. The original PS1 version goes for over $100 on eBay. Why can't more companies figure this out? If a game goes for over $100 on eBay, it makes sense to re-release it and take advantage of the obviously high demand for the title.

  22. Re:Good news but where's my Sonic 3 & Knuckles by Faylone · · Score: 1

    I'd heard it had Sonic and Knuckles, but I'd NOT heard of the ones that the combo games were included, now I've GOTTA get it! Hyper Sonic is just too damn cool to pass up.

  23. I think I just $*%)#) myself.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    WOW! Giving away my genesis, Sega Master System and all the games as a kid was definitely a mistake, especially since I did so for the Nintendo 64 :-( Add Space Harrier to the disk and I'd camp out for it. Definitely a reason to buy the PSP if you haven't already.

  24. The two I would like by silicon+not+in+the+v · · Score: 1

    As I think someone has mentioned, they have a couple of Shinobi games on there, but not Revenge of Shinobi. Wasn't that widely considered to be one of the best of the series? Also, this falls in my personal favorites--the Streets of Rage games were excellent. The controls of Streets of Rage 2 were just about perfected, and there was a pretty good balance in the four playable characters. (Um, except that Axl had that incredibly awesome sliding uppercut that was da bomb.) That was some pretty good multi-player cooperative game play. I think it had one of the more unusual features I've seen. When you had lost all your lives and were going to continue, you could select which character you wanted to continue the game with.

    Also, I'm not aware of a port yet of my two favorite arcade games. They were the X-Men and Avengers games. They were fairly similar multi-player beat-em-ups, but were a lot of fun. Before you suggest MAME, I'm wondering if they have actually come to any of the newer consoles like XBox, Game Cube, or PS2.

    --
    We may experience some slight turbulence and then...explode. -Capt. Mal Reynolds
  25. Re:Good news but where's my Sonic 3 & Knuckles by Wiseman1024 · · Score: 1

    Where's your Sonic 3 and Knuckles? In the Sonic Mega Collection Plus, of course. Oh, awesome. Then where's my Sonic Mega Collection Plus for PSP? Sega isn't run by idiots. LOL man. I mean it, I laughed in real life, in front of my monitor. If I were editing an encyclopedia and had to do an article of "idiot", I'd ask current and past Sega directors for pictures to illustrate my article.

    --
    I was about to say 13256278887989457651018865901401704640, but it appears this number is private property.
  26. Re:Good news but where's my Sonic 3 & Knuckles by Gothic_Walrus · · Score: 1

    They're included; the catch is that you've got to unlock most of them by playing the games you start out with a set number of times (twenty, I believe).

    Even if those HADN'T been included, though, the compilation is still well worth your $20 if you're a fan of Sonic. :)

    --
    Goo goo g'joob.
  27. Re:Good news but where's my Sonic 3 & Knuckles by Gothic_Walrus · · Score: 1

    Oh, awesome. Then where's my Sonic Mega Collection Plus for PSP?

    You're right - that doesn't exist and probably never will. To be fair, though, I don't believe you mentioned the PSP once in your original post, and because the number of people who own a PSP is very, VERY small compared to the number who own a PS2, I guessed PS2 instead of PSP.

    And regardless of Sega's management mishaps, you've got to admit that it makes zero business sense to remove a product that's still viable and not technologically outdated from the market by replacing it yourself is a boneheaded move. Again, this was written with the PS2 assumption in mind.

    --
    Goo goo g'joob.
  28. Re:Good news but where's my Sonic 3 & Knuckles by Wiseman1024 · · Score: 1

    Yes, I hadn't mentioned the PSP, my bad. Yeah, I own a PSP and despite how wrong not being able to run open sauce on it is, I'm seeing if I can avoid exploiting/modifying it; partly because of the time it takes to learn all that, and partly because I buy my games anyways; that's why I'm very concerned regarding my favourite MegaDrive games for it, I'd like to play them without having to modify it then use an open sauce emulator.

    BTW, replacing a product by a superior product is perfectly acceptable (if only a bit infuriating for people who got the older product), it happens all the time with software.

    --
    I was about to say 13256278887989457651018865901401704640, but it appears this number is private property.