Slashdot Mirror


Sony To Expand Commercial Uses of PS3

Sony is considering proposals from commercial distributed computing concerns, mulling over rolling out more Folding@Home-like clients to their PlayStation 3 consoles. Gamasutra reports on a Financial Times article, discussing the future of the system. Because they would be commercial and not charitable organizations, the company is considering some form of compensation for users who would participate. "Sony Computer Entertainment CTO Masa Chatani indicated in an interview that Sony had already received numerous inquiries. 'A start-up or a pharmaceutical company that lacks a super-computer could utilize this kind of infrastructure. We are discussing various options with companies and exploring commercial applications', he said."

68 comments

  1. Like What? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Troll

    Do they mean trying to get people to play with the demo units in commercial locations like Best Buy? Haven't seen one yet... maybe if they paid people.

    1. Re:Like What? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Call me a troll if you want, but I really haven't seen one person playing one of the displays.
      They're all over by the PS2 trying to impress people with how well they can pretend to play air-guitar.

    2. Re:Like What? by Amouth · · Score: 1

      not trolling either - i have seen ONE.. at a best buy.. went to try it out.. it was locked up..

      --
      '...if only "Jumping to a Conclusion" was an event in the Olympics.'
    3. Re:Like What? by Guntram+Shatterhand, · · Score: 1

      Same here. Best Buy has shoved all the PS2 games into this thin aisle to give most of the space to the PS3, including a Guitar Hero II demo machine. And there is always someone at that machine. And since nobody around here can afford a PS3, there are plenty of people in this now-minuscule PS2 aisle, trying to see what's gone on sale and we're always bumping into that Guitar Hero guy.

    4. Re:Like What? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      your my hero! can I touch the glow you emit from the tired meme you spout?

    5. Re:Like What? by renegadesx · · Score: 0

      I haven't met a person yet (face to face, internet doesnt count) that is even considering by one, its like nobody cares, they either already have 360's or Wii's or waiting for the Wii to be in supply. its like nobody cares about the PS3 (mind you this is Australia, usually a very popular Sony territory

      --
      Make SELinux enforcing again!
  2. A way to pay for online purchases? by Stringfellow · · Score: 5, Insightful

    If such a system would allow me to get credit for the work my PS3 does for these corporations, and if I could use said credit to buy downloads, then I can see how this could be a very attractive proposition for gamers and corporations.

    1. Re:A way to pay for online purchases? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      you really would need to think about the impact that this will have on you in financial terms. If all the costs (electricity, bandwidth, time) are greater than what they give you (free download) you'd be getting fucked harder than you already were (by buying a ps3)...

      It might be a bad move.

    2. Re:A way to pay for online purchases? by LordNimon · · Score: 1

      That's probably the best way to do it. I wish MS would do that for Xbox, because the infrastructure is already there. I would then compare the electricity cost (*) vs. the compensation, and if it's a net positive, I'd keep my Xbox on all the time.

      * And for those complaining about burning oil, I want to point out that I get all my electricity from wind power. So the more money I spend on electricity, the more I support alternative energy.

      --
      And the men who hold high places must be the ones who start
      To mold a new reality... closer to the heart
    3. Re:A way to pay for online purchases? by homer_ca · · Score: 5, Informative

      Pretty easy to calculate. A PS3 uses about 180W when it's folding. Assuming electricity costs $0.11/kW/h, it costs $14.25 per month to run it 24/7.

    4. Re:A way to pay for online purchases? by CarnivoreMan · · Score: 1

      I wish I had mod points to give you. That was a splendid informative post.

    5. Re:A way to pay for online purchases? by Greventls · · Score: 1

      But if you were living with your parents or living somewhere were utilities were included in rent, it is free for you to run the thing 24/7. I imagine there is a large portion of the userbase that still loves at home or in a dorm/apartment where electricity is free.

    6. Re:A way to pay for online purchases? by TooMuchToDo · · Score: 1

      Assuming that a fair amount of people purchasing these are kids with well-to-do parents (not many underprivileged youth are going to be shelling out $600 + cost of games for a console), their parents are the ones paying the power bill and so would have little incentive not to keep it running 24/7 if it got them free downloads. I think Sony just stumbled their way onto a great idea.

    7. Re:A way to pay for online purchases? by LoudMusic · · Score: 2, Interesting

      If such a system would allow me to get credit for the work my PS3 does for these corporations, and if I could use said credit to buy downloads, then I can see how this could be a very attractive proposition for gamers and corporations. Absolutely! But why does it take a console to get it going? Are there any PC clients that provide this service already? I've got a few spare CPU cycles here at work that could be adding spare dollars to my PayPal account ;)
      --
      No sig for you. YOU GET NO SIG!
    8. Re:A way to pay for online purchases? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Nicely done. However, what you can't easily calculate are the odds of Sony paying you more than $14.25 per month in exchange for exploiting your free processor cycles.

      I mean, we can figure out pretty easily that they're worse than 1,000,000:1 against, but is it 100,000,000,000:1 or only 10,000,000,000:1? Enquiring minds want to know. :P

    9. Re:A way to pay for online purchases? by KDR_11k · · Score: 1

      Don't forget the wear on the system.

      --
      Justice is the sheep getting arrested while an impartial judge declares the vote void.
  3. Free games! by PFI_Optix · · Score: 1

    I'd sign up.

    Better yet...free console. $600 is a bit steep.

    Hmm...I wonder if someone could make it work that you could get a free console that would only work so long as it was able to process and transmit work units for a commercial application.

    --
    120 characters for a sig? That's bloody useless.
    1. Re:Free games! by CogDissident · · Score: 1

      You know, then Sony would just make their own server farms and make money off of it. And what processing power do you sugguest the system reserve for "running" those pretty pretty games you want it to.

    2. Re:Free games! by rhartness · · Score: 1

      Sorry, that wouldn't work. You would want it to use the system resources only when the application was not playing games. In that case, many user's would probably simply cut off the entire console when they weren't playing games simply to spite the system.

    3. Re:Free games! by amuro98 · · Score: 1

      That would depend on how much you could make.

      If I left the PS3 on overnight (say 10 hours a day), that would still cost me about $10-12/month in electricity alone (I live in California) The compensation from Sony had better be worth in excess of that, otherwise, Sony is making money from me.

      Now then, what's this got to do with games? $600 is an awfully big investment to make up-front for just a few bucks a month profit...

    4. Re:Free games! by PFI_Optix · · Score: 1

      That would be a commercial supercomputer, and those do exist. Sony apparently has no interest in building one.

      --
      120 characters for a sig? That's bloody useless.
  4. Interesting by LoofWaffle · · Score: 0, Redundant

    Given the trememdous (and somewhat underutilized) processing power of the PS3, I'm not surprised. I'd also say that this is a way they can recoup some of the losses they are taking on the console while the Wii appears to outsell them.

    --
    You know, Custer had a plan.
    1. Re:Interesting by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Underutilized? You must be joking!

      They have Real-Time Weapon Switching!
      And Ridge Racer!
      And Historically-Accurate Giant Crabs!

  5. Compensation? by Bieeanda · · Score: 1

    A commercial endeavour would be a more difficult strategically, Mr Chatani admitted, because users would be loathe to let companies use the power of their PS3 Cell processors for free.
    Well, duh. If someone's making money at my expense (bandwidth costs, electricity, wear on components...), as negligible as those expenses might be, I'd want to see some sort of return.

    If Sony really wants to push it though, they'll just include the functionality in a firmware update and claim that the money's going to subsidize new game development. Their online entertainment arm has been pulling that sort of thing with Planetside and Matrix Online for ages now.

    1. Re:Compensation? by physicsnick · · Score: 1

      Shh! Don't give them any ideas!

  6. I'll give them a free idea... by Lumpy · · Score: 1

    Digital signage. a simple ps3 game that simply acts as a mpeg/mpg/bmp/ppt player with playlists and timings with net connectivity will make them rich overnight. most digital signage boxes start at $999.00 and are pretty crappy and can not do HD, you gotta go way higher in price for HD.

    make a $199.00 disc you insert in the cheapie ps3 and can upload content via the ethernet and you have a winner that will overtake the resto f the big names in digital signage overnight.

    --
    Do not look at laser with remaining good eye.
    1. Re:I'll give them a free idea... by benh57 · · Score: 1

      I just got a zensonic Z500 for $299, full HD, HDMI, divx, etc and it's been out for well over a year.
      AppleTV, same price, also HD, also $299.

      These are 'consumer' units, which probably explains the difference in price from commercial 'digital signage' products. But, with the proper media server either could replicate the functionality.

    2. Re:I'll give them a free idea... by Lumpy · · Score: 1

      wow so the zensonic can play a mpg file or playlist of mixed files at a scheduled time as well as Power point files? I need to get one of these!

      thanks!

      --
      Do not look at laser with remaining good eye.
  7. hmm .. just thought of a neat idea for this by Frag-A-Muffin · · Score: 2, Interesting

    If you look at The Xbox360 and it's Live service. You have to pay for it. They should have something like this, where MS gets the money from it, and users who contribute cycles can earn money off their Live services fees! (Probably capped to the cost of the Live service) That seems like it would make the most sense to me.

    Of course, if Playstation 3 isn't charging for online access, then maybe it can be used to earn credits to purchasing stuff.

    And for the Nintendo camp, how about earning those Wii points with contributing cycles! That'd be awesome!

    --

    AirSpeak - http://itunes.com/apps/AirSpeak
    1. Re:hmm .. just thought of a neat idea for this by Ichelo · · Score: 1

      hrmmm, while everyone is at it, they could implement something like this for the pc there are alot more people out there who have a computer and would be willing to use a background client like f@h or seti@home if the were paid for it...

    2. Re:hmm .. just thought of a neat idea for this by KrazeeEyezKilla · · Score: 1

      i doubt that the processor in the Wii would be able to make any useful contribution compared to ps3

    3. Re:hmm .. just thought of a neat idea for this by Frag-A-Muffin · · Score: 1

      i doubt that the processor in the Wii would be able to make any useful contribution compared to ps3

      you're probably right, but, the example was to illustrate the reward :) Wii Points to buy VC games would be an AWESOME reward. That's what I was going for there.

      --

      AirSpeak - http://itunes.com/apps/AirSpeak
    4. Re:hmm .. just thought of a neat idea for this by LordNimon · · Score: 1

      I think Microsoft points would be more reasonable than the Xbox Live service itself. After all, MS Points are already a micropayment system, whereas the Live service is purchased in 1-12 month chunks. I can see getting 1 point for every two hours of computation. That would be about 360 points/month if you ran it 24 hours/day all month long. Any less than that, and it would probably not cover the cost of electricity.

      --
      And the men who hold high places must be the ones who start
      To mold a new reality... closer to the heart
  8. ha! by bloosqr · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I was just talking to someone (in the ECE dept) who had bought a slew of these things for numerical computation last weekend. Its the cell part which apparantly acts as (i think) 128 SIMD processors .. which if you have code that parallelizes well gives you crazy numbers. At this time all he's managed to do is get Linux running and he knows the compiler works.. The math is 32 bit so I am not sure if/how it bleeds over to real numerical work.. Anyway, Its not sony who should be exploiting this, its IBM. IBM knows how to write compilers and IBM knows a lot about scientific/high performance computing. IBM does not know how to sell things cheaply :) However if they can sell these things to Sony for a profit, surely they can figure out how to sell these at a proper price point to poor scientists, who otherwise put PS3s on their grants :)

    1. Re:ha! by ericferris · · Score: 2, Informative

      Not sure about the 128 SIMDs. The PS3's cell processor has 7 so-called SPUs (Synergistic Processor Units), basically coprocessors that work on a 256k separate internal storage. If your code is embarassingly parallel, you can greatly benefit from this architecture.

      The hard-coded floating point unit is single-precision indeed, and doesn't implement the full IEEE floating point spec, which raises eyebrows in the scientific double-precision junky crowd. The individual registers are 128-bit, although they are organized as 4 32-bit words.

      Here is a nice little intro to the beast: http://www-128.ibm.com/developerworks/linux/librar y/pa-linuxps3-1/index.html?ca=drs-

      --
      Fantasy: http://ferrisfantasy.blogspot.com/
    2. Re:ha! by TheThiefMaster · · Score: 1

      Wasn't there a prototype cell blade server at one point?

  9. Cost to run. by Aladrin · · Score: 4, Informative

    They seem to like to ignore the fact that it costs money to run the console. Anyone that has bought their own car understands that it costs money not only for the Gas to make it run (electricity for the console), but there's maintenance as well. The car needs new tires, brakes, and other parts that are in use. The console is not designed to run at 100% CPU 24/7 and will wear out quicker.

    I would guess you could wear out a PS3 in a year by running it 24/7 on this, so that's $600/yr cost right there. I seriously doubt they plan to pay that much.

    Even assuming the console would last forever, the electricity to run constantly it is apparently about $150/yr. http://ps3.ign.com/articles/776/776347p1.html This charts says the national average to run Folding@PS3 is $12.23/month, which is about $150/yr.

    I don't think that they would even pay the $150 in straight cost you incur, let alone for the wear and tear on the console.

    This is a great opportunity to contribute to a cause, but it's an awful idea as a way to make money in your home.

    --
    "If you make people think they're thinking, they'll love you; But if you really make them think, they'll hate you." - DM
    1. Re:Cost to run. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's true, some components might wear out quicker due to 100% usage.

      However, some components might last *longer* due to less thermal cycling involved from having your PS3 working 24/7.

      just something to consider. . .

    2. Re:Cost to run. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Do you have any proof to back this up? (I haven't seen any)
      I don't see why a PS3 should be much different than any other consumer computer. I've gone thru about five generations in a university computer lab (almost 20 years). Generally leaving the systems on 24/7, my perception is that I have fewer problems than on staff computers that get turned off evenings and weekends.

      At any rate, we will know in a year, since several people have purchased them for non-stop folding.

      Your point about the electricity to run a PS3 is true. On the other hand, one PS3 will do the work of at least ten normal computers. I can almost justify the PS3 on electricity savings alone. And I also agree that this is unlikely to develop into a profit center at home, more like a contribution to a good cause. (Let's see: the dehumidifier I usually run in my basement during the summer could be replaced by three PS3s)

    3. Re:Cost to run. by TooMuchToDo · · Score: 1

      As long as the heat is being dissipated properly, you can run the processor damn near close to %100 without casing wear and tear. It's solid state. It's not a drive spinning, it has no moving parts. It's just taking electricty, doing some work, and then dumping out a bunch of heat. There is no "wear and tear" as your example describes.

    4. Re:Cost to run. by nuzak · · Score: 1

      > It's not a drive spinning, it has no moving parts.

      Other than a fan. Running that at full speed 24/7 is sure to wear it right out.

      --
      Done with slashdot, done with nerds, getting a life.
    5. Re:Cost to run. by TooMuchToDo · · Score: 1

      At my day job (Web Hosting), I have several severs with uptimes past the 1500 day mark. These fans haven't died yet =)

    6. Re:Cost to run. by heinousjay · · Score: 1

      Do you really think a PS3 is constructed for constant uptime? It's possible they factored this in while they were designing the console, but it seems unlikely to me.

      Also, I have a computer with a fan that conked out after 1 day. Anecdote cancellation in effect.

      --
      Slashdot - where whining about luck is the new way to make the world you want.
    7. Re:Cost to run. by TooMuchToDo · · Score: 1

      Ok, let's not go with anecdotes and instead go with statistics. We manage roughly 5500-5800 servers at any one time. I belive if I recall correctly we've only had a fan fail once over the course of 6 years.

    8. Re:Cost to run. by throx · · Score: 1

      You're not seriously trying to draw a parallel between a PS3 sitting in someone's entertainment system and a server sitting in an air conditioned and dust-free environment are you? And I certainly hope you're not trying to draw a parallel between the fans used in the PS3's construction (which are selected for low cost, low form factor and therefore high rpm) with those used in a typical server (which are selected for long-term 100% duty cycle use), are you?

      In my couple of dozen or so machines I've had around the house over the last fifteen years, every single one of them has needed cleaning to keep the fans going when I leave them on 24/7. Dust builds up in all corners of the box, chokes up the blades on the heatsinks and seriously reduces the performance of the cooling solution (not to mention creates a fire hazard). I claim my anecdote far more accurate to the situation a PS3 lives in than your pristine server room.

      --

      Fear: When you see B8 00 4C CD 21 and know what it means

    9. Re:Cost to run. by DDLKermit007 · · Score: 1

      Uh, huh, and processors, other components, and PSUs never go out. Solid state components do last longer, they do not however last forever. Oh, and the PS2 does anything BUT dissipate heat correctly. Hell my PC doesn't dissipate heat entirely correctly, and it's put together a hell of allot better, and components still go out.

    10. Re:Cost to run. by poot_rootbeer · · Score: 1

      The console is not designed to run at 100% CPU 24/7 and will wear out quicker.

      Only the moving parts (ie, CPU fan) should wear out appreciably more quickly due to sustained load. The silicon traces aren't going to degrade very much no matter how many electrons you push along them.

      The Slashdot Automobile Analogy proves inadequate once again.

  10. guarantee my $600 machine for life by insanius · · Score: 3, Interesting

    not that i own one, but if and when a good game ever gets released for it, i'm sure i'll buy it.

    if Sony is going to actually ask me leave on my ridiculously power hungry "super-computer" while i'm not playing Socom4, they better at least agree to eat the cost and replace my machine if it fails. not fix, REPLACE. otherwise, why would i want to help "Joe's Rx" use my PS3, broadband connection, and precious power? to make some drug that they're going to charge, if not over-charge, me for when they release it?

    This is a sorry attempt and positive PR. Sony, how about you concentrate on making some games for your VIDEO GAME SYSTEM!!!

  11. Tie it into a hot game by The+Media+Mechanic · · Score: 1, Interesting

    Just like people will give away their passwords in exchange for free chocolate. They should tie their number-crunching into a hot game like GTA IV and people will give away free PS3 cycles, electricity, etc.

    --
    I can throw as many stones as I wish; my house is made of transparent aluminum.
  12. Free nature! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    "Hmm...I wonder if someone could make it work that you could get a free console that would only work so long as it was able to process and transmit work units for a commercial application."

    Hmmm...I wonder how many people will find a way around that so they can get a free console without the obligation?

  13. The Missing ??? by Shadow+Wrought · · Score: 1
    1. Make new high-end console
    2. Charge $600 for it
    3. have other people pay your consumers to leave it on
    4. Actually sell some! [1]

    [1]Since they're selling them at a loss I can't quite justify putting "profit" here. Yet.

    --
    If brevity is the soul of wit, then how does one explain Twitter?
    1. Re:The Missing ??? by unconfused1 · · Score: 0

      Ahem...competitors are selling their consoles at a loss too.

    2. Re:The Missing ??? by Shadow+Wrought · · Score: 1

      I think you mean, competitor. Nintendo is selling their consoles at a profit. And while Microsoft is taking a loss on the 360's, at least for now I believe Sony is taking the greatest loss per unit on their consoles. While I don't know how how long that will last, at least for the time being selling more units will not necessarily translate into profits for them.

      --
      If brevity is the soul of wit, then how does one explain Twitter?
    3. Re:The Missing ??? by singingjim1 · · Score: 1

      Actually, it will. As more and more units roll off the line, efficiencies in the process are realized due to process improvements and better loss/scrap control, cost per unit goes down. And there's the threshold where the slice of R&D pie gets paid off. That's where the ??? turns to profit.

    4. Re:The Missing ??? by Shadow+Wrought · · Score: 1

      Well, I can't say its the first time I was too pedantic for my own good;-)

      --
      If brevity is the soul of wit, then how does one explain Twitter?
    5. Re:The Missing ??? by Dog-Cow · · Score: 1

      Not to be too pedantic, but you most certainly *could* say so. :)

  14. P2P Compensation? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    "Well, duh. If someone's making money at my expense (bandwidth costs, electricity, wear on components...), as negligible as those expenses might be, I'd want to see some sort of return."

    You mean like when someone P2Ps "for profit" content?

  15. Many uses by rlp · · Score: 1

    > mulling over rolling out more Folding@Home-like clients to their PlayStation 3 consoles

    And I hear you can play games on the thing too! Seriously, if Sony wants to market it as a cheap 'supercomputer' they need to offer another form factor. Perhaps a rack-mounted version pre-configured with Linux clustering.

    --
    [Insert pithy quote here]
  16. Re:Sony Kicking Ass As Usual by InsaneGeek · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Ha! Wii is having month long shortages because, while the PS3 sales rate were so overestimated that they now are trying to use that surplus for other things. If the PS3 was kicking as much ass, they would be telling everybody else to go pound sand; because they have so much consumer interest they couldn't chain their supply chain so early in the product's lifespan.

    Because the PS3 is kicking so little ass compared to Sony's expectations they have a glut and are now looking for unusual ways to reduce stocks outside of consumer gaming. It's positive sign when you do that for a mature product that has limited growth potential in it's current markets, it's a bad sign when you do that for a product early in it's lifetime when it's primary market is supposed to be growing quickly.

  17. Translation by Groo+Wanderer · · Score: 1

    Translation:
    We got this mountain of PS3s that aren't selling to save our lives, and if someone in management notices, me might get fired from our cushy jobs. It is now time to blow them out the door somehow or set the warehouse on fire.

                -Charlie

  18. Typical by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Typical Sony thinking.

    "We can't lower the price, so let's figure out a way to raise it."

  19. Cost to create. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    "They seem to like to ignore the fact that it costs money to run the console."

    No different than the "information wants to be free" crowd ignores the fact that it costs money to create content. Everyone has a different blind spot, but always present were money is concerned.

  20. RTFA, stupid by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Read the Financial Times article you stupid son of a bitch, users joining in this program are compensated by Sony.

  21. Check your broadband EULA first by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Check to make sure your broadband EULA covers the commercial use to which you'd be putting your PS3 before signing up.

    Because we all read and abide by our EULAs, right? RIGHT?

  22. Evidently, *you* didn't RTFA, stupid. by Dogtanian · · Score: 1

    Read the Financial Times article you stupid son of a bitch, users joining in this program are compensated by Sony. Please point out exactly where the article states that Sony will "agree to eat the cost and replace my machine if it fails. not fix, REPLACE" it, as the original poster specifically asked.

    Oh.... they didn't? Looks like he wasn't the one who was a "stupid son of a bitch" around here then.
    --
    "Slashdot - News and Chat Sites Deviant". (Click "homepage" link above for details).