Slashdot Mirror


Yahtzee Deconstructs the E3 Trailer Park

With all the E3 wrap-up and deconstruction flying around Yahtzee has once again done a stellar job of summarizing and unmasking the standard bullshit in his own Zero Punctuation-style review of the E3 "trailer park". Labeling this year as "sequel boulevard" and questioning the lack of any meaningful amount of gameplay footage, this year was almost a universal disappointment. There are rumblings of some improvements next year, perhaps returning things to some small measure of their previous glory, but only time will tell.

46 comments

  1. More humorous is... by Bruiser80 · · Score: 1, Funny

    Escapist Magazine's parody of a Yahtzee fan :-)

    http://www.escapistmagazine.com/videos/view/de-rez/152-Yahtzees-Biggest-Fan

    --
    Arguing with an engineer is like wrestling a pig in the mud. After a while, you realize the engineer enjoys it.
    1. Re:More humorous is... by cmonkey_1973 · · Score: 2, Informative

      Jesus, the De-Rez guys are so eye-piercingly bad at comic timing. First two minutes are watching someone watching Yahtzee's videos and then putting a hat on. There. 2 minutes of your life saved.

      In fact, the rest is a sequence of mistimed and lukewarm overreaction gags. Now go watch something good instead. Enrich your life. You're free!

  2. In general, an amusing fellow by metamechanical · · Score: 5, Informative

    You can find the rest of his reviews here.

    I would specifically recommend Smash Bros. Brawl. Hilarious.

    --
    If I had a nickel for every time I had a nickel, I'd be richcursive!
  3. Whoa by Huntr · · Score: 1

    Not knowing who Yahtzee is and only knowing the dice game by the same name made this article title really, really weird.

    1. Re:Whoa by netsavior · · Score: 4, Funny

      Not knowing who Yahtzee is

      Welcome to the internet!

    2. Re:Whoa by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      mod parent -1: Missed Point, because you rarely know who anyone is on the Internet

    3. Re:Whoa by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Celebrity is fleeting. Enjoy your 15 seconds of attention.

  4. Laugh.. by elemnt14 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    ..for all of his reviews are extremely entertaining, if not informitave. He is unbiased in most of his comments, taking the good with bad in most respects.

    1. Re:Laugh.. by antime · · Score: 1

      I just wish I could turn that new "theme music" into a stick and shove it up his ass.

    2. Re:Laugh.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      UNBIASED??? What have you been smoking

  5. Yahtzee? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Anyone else see the headline and hope it was actually about the game Yahtzee?

    1. Re:Yahtzee? by neokushan · · Score: 1

      No, because that would stab the English language in the face.

      --
      +1 IDisagreeSoHeMustBeATrollOrAnAstroturferOrAShill
  6. Funny, but even more entertaining is.... by Channard · · Score: 4, Funny

    ... the the follow-up video where he replies to critics of the Super Smash Brothers review.

  7. Hilarity and advertising collide.. by Channard · · Score: 1

    .. or at least they did a couple of weeks ago, when Yahtzee did a none too flattering review of Age of Conan. All the while, there was Gamespot style background on the site, promoting.... Age of Conan! Still, he's not been sacked yet, so it looks like folks at The Escapist are a notch above the scumfucks at Gamespot.

    1. Re:Hilarity and advertising collide.. by YukonTech · · Score: 2, Insightful

      He brings more traffic to their site than all their other resources combined. Of course they won't fire him.

    2. Re:Hilarity and advertising collide.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

      That, and he didn't attach a number to his criticism. Companies are naturally more afraid of numbers than words.

  8. Hasbro by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    How long 'till Hasbro asks him to rename himself via cease & desist?

    1. Re:Hasbro by Xtravar · · Score: 1

      It'll happen when he ports his Art of Theft game to Facebook and makes money off of it!

      I manually edited the save files because it was too hard for me. :(

      --
      Buckle your ROFL belt, we're in for some LOLs.
    2. Re:Hasbro by jandrese · · Score: 1

      Well, he already dropped the fair use openings and closings, so it may be only a matter of time.

      --

      I read the internet for the articles.
    3. Re:Hasbro by Uncle+Ira · · Score: 1

      How were those fair use? It's not as if he was making copies of his own CDs to listen to in his car, he was using copyrighted recordings for commercial puroposes.

      As much as I can't stand the new theme music, I do respect him for using original content instead of recycling someone else's work.

  9. E3 is superfluous by christ,+jesus+H · · Score: 1

    E3 is simply no longer necessary. The video game (ops sorry the electronic entertainment) industry is mainly an industry of marketing. That is where most of the money goes, that's were most of the focus goes (anyone who actually works in this industry knows that to be true). It's no secret that if you spend it on marketing, you will make it in sales, to a very large degree regardless of the quality your product reflects (it's a model copied from the Movie industry). To that end an entire sub-industry has emerged that is sometimes laughingly called "press". Most of these "press" outlets (and there are literally thousands and thousands of them) are simply PR arms of publishers or retailers and are in no way independent. So today the average gamers inbox is inundated on a daily basis with "previews", "first looks", "behind the scenes" or "discussions with X developer of x4 the sequel to last years x3". There is an industry underneath an industry that does very well constantly pimping PR releases and fluff pieces from publishers, as a matter of fact the only real issue is getting enough content to pimp.

    E3 is superfluous, because the problem for publishers today is not "getting the word out" it's coming up with enough fake "buzz" to keep feeding their secondary outlets (which turn a pretty penny thank you). E3 just creates yet another (rather pricey) marketing opportunity that demands more content and provides less control. It has no "raison d'être" any more, the gaming market is simply not discerning enough to tell the difference between "real community buzz" and "fake marketing buzz", so there is no benefit to a publisher for taking a risk on E3.

    --
    Ohh spiteful one tell me who to smote and he shall be smolten!
    1. Re:E3 is superfluous by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      christ, jesus!

      You're a little off topic. The article was about YAHTZEE talking about E3. Not E3 itself.

      GAWD... some people.

    2. Re:E3 is superfluous by christ,+jesus+H · · Score: 1

      Yeah I know, I just dont see whats that interesting about another jaded "last angry man" blogger (it makes me sleepy). The web has been chock full o' em' for better then a decade now? The slow death of E3 however, thats something interesting to talk about so I took a chance . . .

      --
      Ohh spiteful one tell me who to smote and he shall be smolten!
  10. Unbiased? by VickiM · · Score: 1

    Well...maybe if you hate RPGs and would pimp out your mom for a FPS with eyecandy and a plot.

    Despite us having very different interests in games, I still enjoy his reviews. They're funny and frank, even if I disagree on which are the best genres.

    1. Re:Unbiased? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Insightful

      He doesn't hate RPGs. He just hates games with mindless repetitive games consisting of mashing the "Fight" button over and over again where your actions make absolutely no difference to the outcome of the game.

      Just because most RPGs happen to match that doesn't mean he hates them. He actually likes a few RPGs that don't follow the same tired pattern of "mash Fight during the battles and watch cutscenes over which you have no influence."

    2. Re:Unbiased? by WhatAmIDoingHere · · Score: 1

      What's the last FPS with a good plot you can think of?

      And I mean a GOOD plot, not "zomg alien demons on mars." Or "kill Koreans for 30 minutes followed by insane alien bullcrap."

      --
      Not a Twitter sockpuppet... but I wish I was.
    3. Re:Unbiased? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Bioshock?

    4. Re:Unbiased? by pdusen · · Score: 1

      Ok, now try one with replay value.

    5. Re:Unbiased? by Joe+Jay+Bee · · Score: 1

      Half-Life.

      Yes, I know, "aliens", but fuck, I don't care.

    6. Re:Unbiased? by Khuffie · · Score: 1

      BioShock?

    7. Re:Unbiased? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Half Life 2 and the sequel episodes are the only games I revisited 5 years later to find that they are more fun, modern and even look better than most newer games. They are really timeless.
      I also enjoyed Stalker and CoD4 and I usually don't like FPS at all, e.g. I found Doom3 and Quake4 to be very boring.

    8. Re:Unbiased? by pdusen · · Score: 1

      Buzz! I'm sorry, wrong answer.

    9. Re:Unbiased? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Just because most RPGs happen to match that

      Isn't a genre defined by what it is made of? If most RPG happen to be about mashing the fight button, isn't it time to admit that the genre is (now) about mashing the fight button?

      Of course, I also have my own idea of what a game should be and do to be called an RPG (for example I think Oblivion was not really an RPG). The problem is that idea exists only in my mind and, obviously, I'm not the one who define what the genre is. I would love to, but as sad as I think it is, I'm not.

    10. Re:Unbiased? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Although I think BioShock was a very good game, better than System Shock 2 (that is after disabling Vita-Chambers and every other cheats that are on by default, including unlimited saves), the truth is BioShock has very little replay value. The game is too scripted and too linear to be played more than once. Your second play-through will be exactly like the first.

    11. Re:Unbiased? by niteice · · Score: 1

      Portal.

      Come to think of it, with Half-Life already being mentioned in this thread, Valve really does have a monopoly on GOOD game design.

      --
      ROMANES EUNT DOMUS
    12. Re:Unbiased? by MBraynard · · Score: 1

      Then what was Oblivion?

  11. Am I the only one by k_187 · · Score: 1, Interesting

    That actually liked this E3? I don't care about the pomp and circumstance. I want to know what's coming out and maybe see a video and/or screenshot or two. I think the bigger problem is that there wasn't much worth showing this year.

    --
    11 was a racehorse
    12 was 12
    1111 Race
    12112
    1. Re:Am I the only one by WhatAmIDoingHere · · Score: 1

      Can you name a game you weren't excited about before E3 that you ARE excited about now?

      The games I've got pre-ordered were announced a while back, and there hasn't really been any step-up in information being released about them for E3.

      --
      Not a Twitter sockpuppet... but I wish I was.
    2. Re:Am I the only one by k_187 · · Score: 1

      Is that E3's fault or rather the fact that there wasn't anything to show? Saying the format is broken doesn't mean much if there was nothing to show in the first place.

      --
      11 was a racehorse
      12 was 12
      1111 Race
      12112
    3. Re:Am I the only one by Uncle+Ira · · Score: 1

      It's a result of E3 being scheduled two months later in the year- mid July is too late to debut a preview command for a holiday release, so there's no point in waiting for E3 to announce your product anymore. Announcements trickled out on their own in the months prior to E3 instead.

      So it is E3's fault for having their conference in July this year.

    4. Re:Am I the only one by Knara · · Score: 1

      E3 this year was the equivalent to hitting "Reload" on Kotaku every 15 minutes, at any other time of the year.

      The whole point of E3 was the spectacle. Remove that, and there's no point.

    5. Re:Am I the only one by notrandomly · · Score: 1

      So the problem was with the timing rather than the format?

  12. Zero Punctuation... by Virtualtaco · · Score: 0

    Always comes out on Wednesday. Post it then...

  13. What about... by ch0ad · · Score: 1

    LittleBigPlanet and Mirrors Edge? Seems he has conveniently brushed over these non sequential titles.

    Also, he complains that the games industry is too corporate, but is the film/tv industry any different? You always have to wade through the sea of commercial crap to reach the idyllic island of media that is actually worth watching/playing/whatever.

    1. Re:What about... by deek · · Score: 1

      Well, to be fair, he does mention Mirror's Edge. It's there, right at the end, in the rolling credits. He says Mirror's Edge looks pretty sweet.

      But you're right, no mention of LBP. I think we can safely assume that no news means good news. So far, I like everything I've heard about it. I'll be a first day buyer.