Slashdot Mirror


Nerds Still More Likely To Get Bullied

trashbird1240 writes "Reports on a recent meta-analysis of bullies and victims found that bullies and victims have similar personality traits, but that bullies tend to do poorly in school, as opposed to those who get bullied. Both bullies and victims are poor social problem solvers, but they resort to different tactics to handle their social ineptitude. To me this represents a huge leap forward in understanding nerd psychology."

37 of 480 comments (clear)

  1. That makes me feel so much better by colinrichardday · · Score: 4, Funny

    That makes me feel so much better about being beaten up.

  2. WHAT?! by Itninja · · Score: 4, Funny

    You means those with little physical prowess and poorly developed social skills are often victims to those with pent-up anger and limited intellects? My god. This is quite a revelation?

    --
    I judt got a nre Kinesis keybiartf so please excusr ant egregiou typos.
  3. The key to not getting beaten up as a nerd by Pojut · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Work out. A lot. Throughout middle school and high school, I was a huge geek (and dressed like one)...but I was also huge. In high school, at only 5'6", I weighed around 200 pounds, and could lift what the varsity football team lifted in the weightroom (and, in some cases, even more.)

    I was a dork, but no one dared fuck with me. A good thing, too...I had no idea how to fight :p

    1. Re:The key to not getting beaten up as a nerd by 0100010001010011 · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Playing the borderline psycho route is also good. (Although these days you'll probably end up on some watch lists.) I can't really point to any single thing I did nor do I remember why they actually thought I was. (I guess critiquing what previous school shooters did wrong in an English paper was one thing...)

      But when I skipped the senior photo in the gym, I guess one of my friends told me some people were joking I was in the rafters with a rifle.

      Top of my class, BSME, going back for my MSME. I think >90% of my class is still at home drinking at the one bar in town and partying like they're still seniors. It's sad, but if they're happy, what ever.

    2. Re:The key to not getting beaten up as a nerd by selven · · Score: 3, Funny

      I was a dork, but no one dared fuck with me

      I'm confused. Is this good or bad?

    3. Re:The key to not getting beaten up as a nerd by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Even the most amazing street fighter who has gotten himself into hundreds of fights can still loose an eye against an amateur. Street fights are not a sport. Various environment props and even weapons are more than likely if the opponent is stupid enough to pick a fight in the first place.

      The best way to win a fight is by never fighting at all.

    4. Re:The key to not getting beaten up as a nerd by geekoid · · Score: 4, Insightful

      You both completely failed at learning jack, and resorted to the threat of violence. NERD FAIL.

      Learn social skills. THAT'S the lesson. They aren't hard and a handful of social cues makes all the difference.

      --
      The Kruger Dunning explains most post on /. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect
    5. Re:The key to not getting beaten up as a nerd by bluefoxlucid · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Aikido is more fun. It's the closest most mortals get to being utterly invulnerable... I don't mean you can win fights because nobody can really hurt you; I mean you don't even have to care.

      It's one thing to bloody someone up, really; but when you pretty much stand there, and just quietly move and draw them along, that's different. Judo works great for this, but it's more aggressive; you react sharply, roll their weight and motion out the way you want, and wind up hurling them spectacularly through the air or locking them hard into a submission. Aikido... the motions aren't combative; you basically take a step out of the way, and lead them to the ground, mainly in ways specifically designed not to injure. It looks like your opponent is just tripping over his own stupidity, rather than getting owned.

      Seriously, who the fuck wants to mess with that? The less aggressive you look while utterly dismissing your opponents, the more confused and frightened people become.

    6. Re:The key to not getting beaten up as a nerd by The+Grim+Reefer2 · · Score: 4, Funny

      I may have been a dorkus malorkus in high school...

      And judging by that sentence not much has changed. ;-)

    7. Re:The key to not getting beaten up as a nerd by Kijori · · Score: 5, Insightful

      I think the biggest challenge in Aikido is finding a club that offers unrestricted sparring. Without that, you can never learn to actually defend yourself.

      I briefly practised Aikido having trained in Sambo and Muay Thai. What shocked me (and caused me to leave every club I joined) was that everything was very slow and everyone always knew what was coming; as a result everyone thought that they were great because they didn't know how little they actually knew. This is in contrast to the other arts I have trained in, where (mostly) free sparring from the very first lesson means that you're acutely conscious of the limitations of what you know.

      If you can find an Aikido club that shares premises with other martial artists and lets practitioners of different arts roll together then I can see Aikido being an effective discipline. Unfortunately this sort of practice, which isn't uncommon for judokas (who often spar with BJJ fighters or crosstrain for MMA), seems to be unheard of in Aikido, at least everywhere I've tried. It's similar to the problems in Karate and Taikwondo - if you don't allow any influence from outside the ecosystem then you can easily end up with an art that is useless when the rules of that ecosystem are removed. (That's not to say Karate or TKD are useless by nature, just that in their modern form they are normally taught by someone who has never learnt the weaknesses of the art. )

    8. Re:The key to not getting beaten up as a nerd by Hatta · · Score: 3, Interesting

      You don't. You socialize with other people, becoming part of the herd. You're less likely to be picked off by a predator then.

      --
      Give me Classic Slashdot or give me death!
    9. Re:The key to not getting beaten up as a nerd by insertwackynamehere · · Score: 3, Insightful

      The problem is that for some people, basic hand to hand to hand fighting or grappling (preferably a bullshit free low fat type such as boxing or jiu jitsu) is preferable because you can pick up the basics quickly and not invest huge amounts of time if you are content with knowing the basics of fighting and self defense but don't find it to be an enjoyable hobby. On the flip side, you can work your entire life to master akido.

    10. Re:The key to not getting beaten up as a nerd by e4g4 · · Score: 3, Informative
      --
      The secret to creativity is knowing how to hide your sources. - Albert Einstein
    11. Re:The key to not getting beaten up as a nerd by Abstrackt · · Score: 3, Insightful

      yes, but bullies are too stupid to learn better.

      That's kinda've the point.

      That's the part I don't understand, since it appears the ones getting bullied may also be incapable of learning better.

      --
      They say a little knowledge is a dangerous thing, but it's not one half so bad as a lot of ignorance. - Terry Pratchett
  4. Re:Hahahahaha by memyselfandeye · · Score: 5, Funny

    No, I'm still mad that the jock who beat me up banged the girl who sat next to me who let me hold her comb. I protected that comb like it was a baby. I cleaned it, I bathed it, and she wouldn't go to prom with me!?!? Then I found out I went an all boys school... talk about awkward.

    In other news... the sky is blue, and the sun is hot.

  5. Re:Animal psychology by AnonymousClown · · Score: 5, Insightful

    So basically, if you can't develop social skills you do what every other animal does: Become a predator. And if you fail at that, you're dinner.

    FTFA:

    Victims share much of same, negative attitude, conflict in the family.

    It looks as though the victims are the other side of the same coin.

    And what's not mentioned in the article is how the ramifications of bullying stick with someone for the rest of their life - there the "mousy ones", the ones without "self confidence", the ones that "don't fit in", etc....

    It wouldn't surprise me the least if many of the permanently unemployed are part of this group. So, I think it costs society too.

    --
    RIP America

    July 4, 1776 - September 11, 2001

  6. Perhaps... by fuzzyfuzzyfungus · · Score: 5, Funny

    We should just issue handguns to everyone over a certain GPA... That seems like a good, solid, American solution to this bullying problem.

    1. Re:Perhaps... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

      Hey, they call us software pirates, right? Give the nerds flintlock pistols. This solves several problems:

      a. They can defend themselves from jocks
      b. They can't go on a rampage and massacre the school
      c. They will have a realistic accessory for their pirate cosplay!

      Somebody give fffungus a metal! And a handgun! :D

    2. Re:Perhaps... by fuzzyfuzzyfungus · · Score: 3, Interesting

      I find the tendency of spree killers toward taking out a bunch of random bystanders along with their intended targets deplorable in the extreme; but I can say completely seriously that if more instances of bullying ended in murder, and fewer in suicide, the world would be a better place.

      Seeing how far you can push somebody wouldn't be such an attractive hobby if the risk of being the guy who pushed them just a little too far were there in the back of your mind...

  7. I think ... by Monkeedude1212 · · Score: 4, Interesting

    That the problem is that people are so hard-wired to find social ineptitude a problem.

    There are times where I wouldn't want to hang out with people because I didn't like the people. At one point (it was between grade 8 and 9) I realized that I could be whoever I really wanted to be, and was not relegated to any kind of social outcast or nerdy clique for the rest of my days. I went out, bought some clothes, got a haircut, and emailed someone I didn't usually hang out with, and asked if they wanted to go Skateboarding. I - however - had never been great at skateboarding. However, this new friend of mine took my motion as a kind gesture and proceeded to teach me a bit so that I could hang out with him and his friends more. He understood that I had wanted to get out of any antisocial tendancies I might have had and wanted to have fun with more friends. Obviously, he was not the bullying type.

    However, after a year or so of this, I began to miss the old things. Playing LAN Starcraft till 5 am, reading Fantasy Novels, and programming. Things I never had time for when there was a party that weekend, movie night at a friends house, or hanging out after class. Eventually, I went back to my old tendancies, and I really didn't care if I was labelled a nerd because I liked being alone a bit more.

    1. Re:I think ... by Attila+Dimedici · · Score: 4, Interesting

      That the problem is that people are so hard-wired to find social ineptitude a problem.

      Social ineptitude is a problem. You are confusing being an introvert (preferring not to spend time with other people) with being socially inept. Not all introverts are socially inept. Sometimes people are labeled "nerds" because they choose to be socially uninvolved. However, the term originally (and in this context) referred to people who wish to be socially involved but are outcasts because they do things that are socially viewed opposite of the way they intend.

      --
      The truth is that all men having power ought to be mistrusted. James Madison
  8. Re:Um... what about NerdBullies? by bsDaemon · · Score: 5, Funny

    I think they call them "channel ops" or "moderators" depending on the context.

  9. This is the loaded term by omar.sahal · · Score: 3, Interesting

    poor problem-solving skills within social situations

    What does this mean, bullies not knowing how to interact are pent up with rage, and take it out on others. There’s one problem with this bullies are very good at reading people. Quite often they can bully under every bodies nose without arousing suspicion. They even have good mechanisms to handle tense situations (like being investigated), they can even lie effectively under these tense situations. How do you think they can get away with it.

    1. Re:This is the loaded term by fuzzyfuzzyfungus · · Score: 4, Insightful

      parents and teacher don't want to address the issue. That's how they get away with it.

      More strictly(at least in my experience), parents and teachers, and admins are actually very interested, with occasional exceptions, in addressing the issue(When I was in school, they were constantly emitting pious anti-bullying PSAs, having observed administrators in an occupational context, their bookshelves and seminar schedules are packed with mentions of the issue, written by assorted well-meaning education Ph.Ds).

      The problem, though, is that they generally aren't willing to face the reality of the issue. They cling to the illusion that, with the right magic words and social niceties and apologies and shit, everyone will just be able to get along and be nice to each other. The fact that "X is a bully" implies "X is a sadistic bastard who derives pleasure from inflicting pain on those weaker than him" was just too unpleasant to enter their analysis of the situation. Oh, no, if we just call in one of X's victims and have them talk over their differences(nice way to let X know who squealed on him, assholes, that isn't going to go badly), we can all come together and sing "kumbaya" in joyous harmony. This basic failure made all their well meaning efforts utterly futile, and not infrequently counterproductive.

      The trouble is, the sort of well-meaning softies who care the most about bullying are the ones who have the greatest difficulty wrapping their minds around the fact that they are dealing with genuinely crafty, vicious people. A bully/victim dynamic is not a "misunderstanding". There is no "talking over" to be done. It is an application of power and violence, just because they can, and because they enjoy it. The sort of person who is all empathic and becomes a guidance counselor or whatever just isn't very well equipped to understand that. They have such a long(and vicerally immediate) history of caring, and feeling other people's pain, that they have difficulty imagining the inner lives of people who don't care, and who enjoy others' pain. Even if told, the abstract model is so alien to their emotional experience that they just can't take it seriously and grapple with its implications to a useful degree....

    2. Re:This is the loaded term by fuzzyfuzzyfungus · · Score: 3, Interesting

      The jury is still somewhat undecided on the born vs. made issue(and that counts; because "made" implies that you might be able to control the supply relatively easily and without doing anything ethically troubling, while "born" is harder); but that doesn't change the fact that some people are Just Bad News, and failure to recognize that is a dangerous mistake. If it is a mistake you are making about a business partner or spouse or something, the consequences can be unfortunate for you.

      If it is a mistake you make when you are supposed to be working on somebody else's behalf, as in the case of school staff, parole boards, and the like; it can have major consequences for others, which makes you either negligent or incompetent.

  10. Stand up for yourself by MetricT · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I was the typical introverted high school nerd (5'4 at the time), and had a 6'5" upper-class psychopath following me around and finding new ways to harass me.

    I talked to my principal over it (God bless you Roger Hood!). He told me next time it happened, kick his ass and he (the principal) wouldn't punish me.

    A few days later at PE we were playing soccer, and whenever I had the ball he would "accidentally" kick me in the leg as hard as he could. For days, it felt like a knife every time I put weight on that foot. Hurt so bad it took my breath away.

    Two days later I spotted him in the hall. I kicked him in the jewels, and laid him flat on the ground. I proceeded to spend the next 3 minutes kicking and punching him in the balls, the sides, the head, anything I could hit. I didn't feel any pain in my foot at all during this. Eventually he was bawling so loud that the girls in a nearby classroom came out and rescued him (and had the gaul to ask why I was picking on the poor psychopath and being such a mean person).

    Two things happened: the psychopath transferred out of the school a week later, and *no one* ever messed with me again.

    I wish we could all get along. But some whack jobs only understand the language of violence, and you have to be willing to speak their language to teach them a lesson.

    1. Re:Stand up for yourself by Killjoy_NL · · Score: 4, Interesting

      I don't know how our dutch schools compare to high schools, but for this story, it is comparable enough.
      I was in my 2nd year and for the first 6 months a group of kids kept teasing, annoying, harassing me, etc. It was horrible.

      I remember being in shop class reaching out for a tool that I needed to continue my work. One of the kids grabbed it after I did and tried to pull it out of my hand, I told that person that I was using it, then the kid spit on my hand.
      That was the moment something snapped in my head, everything went dark, I was smart enough to drop the tool and I said one little thing: "Run."

      The kid knew I was serious and started running, as did I. I jumped over chairs and desks while in pursuit only having one goal, to destroy that person.
      It took 6 people to grab me and hold me against a wall until I calmed down.
      That experience made sure that they didn't bother me anymore but it scared the fuck out of me.
      I have learned more patience, more forgiveness and more understanding since then since I do not want to repeat an episode like that.

      You are correct when some people only understand violence, I wish that was different.

      --
      This is the sig that says NI (again)
    2. Re:Stand up for yourself by Merls+the+Sneaky · · Score: 4, Insightful

      No, very fucking cool. It's what those fuckers deserve. If you pick on those smaller or weaker when you get your balls mashed you deserve it. If you don't want to risk your balls don't pick on those who have no choice but to resort to ball breaking.

    3. Re:Stand up for yourself by Merls+the+Sneaky · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Three minutes of ball kicking is nothing compared to the physical and mental abuse these kids put up with. Try putting up with having shit dumped on you constantly for months or years at a time and tell me you wouldn't snap.

      At least for that guy it only lasted a few minutes, the pain a few days. People who are bullied have to live with the consequences for the rest of their lives.

  11. Re:Confusing social bullshit by COMON$ · · Score: 5, Funny

    put on your robe and wizard hat...

    --
    CS: It is all sink or swim...oh and did I mention there are sharks in that water?
  12. Re:Hahahahaha by Captain+Splendid · · Score: 4, Funny

    I'm not even sure what popping a girl's bra strap means.

    It means you put all your stats into Dexterity.

    --
    Linux, you magnificent bastard, I read the fucking manual!
  13. f the pack by sixtuslab · · Score: 3, Interesting

    The grey uncreative mass is neither smart nor dumb. It packs up like wolves and feeds on the dumbest among itself to feel minutely superior. This causes violent outbursts in the weakest of the mind since its the only way for the feeble minded to protect their deteriorating selfimage. The smart ones are also rejected by the pack. The highest minds seem odd and incomprehensible to the pack and need to be made apart from the maingroup to keep it coherent. While the pack dwells happily in its dull mediocre harmony, the lowest of the mind try to attract the interest of the pack by attacking the other outcasts, the high minds. The smartest ones should somehow make it seem profitable for the pack to guard them or just endure since the relieving outcome is that the high minds shouldn't have any incentive to attract the pack, who are just the right kind of average consumers for the next vc backedup startup to exploit :)

  14. Re:Animal psychology by AnonymousClown · · Score: 5, Insightful

    The kids that got picked on were the small kids with napoleon complexes and would seek out fights.

    I really can't blame the small kids. Size matters in this society. I don't remember if it was Crick or Watson who said this, but when asked if they were for genetic engineering of children, they responded with this (to paraphrase):

    Ninety percent of CEOs are over the height of six feet. A man who's five four and a woman who's five foot even may want something a little more for their kids.

    His point being that tall people have an edge, of course - not that every parent want's their kids to be CEOs.

    I once worked for a guy who insisted that he got where he was by hard work. He was 6' 3", handsome Italian guy who was also a Yale football star who graduated with a degree in Economics - I don't know how well he did. Anyway, business opportunities just came to him - yes, he was a multi-millionaire. I saw his books. He was always telling me that I need to develop some "self-confidence". Easy for him to say.

    When Dave Chappelle was on the "Actors Studio", he kind of chewed out a white guy about the opportunities he got because he was white and he probably never even realized what they were.

    I understand. People are basically primates. The taller you are the better. The whiter you are the better.

    It's not blatant. It's just how folks react towards you on a subconscious level. Blacks do it to other blacks - ever hear of the "brown paper bag" rule?

    Here's an example that's a little more conscious: hot chicks. Everybody kisses the ass of the hot chick.

    --
    RIP America

    July 4, 1776 - September 11, 2001

  15. Re:Hahahahaha by Austerity+Empowers · · Score: 3, Funny

    No that would be opening the bra strap with her facing you. Popping the strap is generally considered clumsy, but a sign of someone who maybe spent his points everywhere but wis or dex.

  16. Re:Animal psychology by TheRaven64 · · Score: 4, Informative

    This is actually interesting from an anthropological perspective. Most pack mammals use a form of mock combat to establish position with the pack. They fight until one individual is defeated, then the winner takes the higher position in the pack hierarchy. This same behaviour is common among children (and some adults, although the 'combat' is typically less physical - adolescents typically do it by trading insults), and is incorrectly diagnosed as bullying.

    When two animals from different pack meet, the combat is more serious. The loser must be completely defeated, rather than just back off. When you see this behaviour in humans, it is real bullying. The aim is not to establish dominance within the pack, because the aggressor does not see themselves as being in the same pack as the victim, so does not have the evolved responses to avoid permanently damaging members of the same pack.

    I only ever encountered the first kind of conflict at school, but I responded as if it were the second kind, which is probably why I never had a problem with bullying. It sounds like you had a similar reaction.

    --
    I am TheRaven on Soylent News
  17. Re:Hahahahaha by genner · · Score: 3, Funny

    No that would be opening the bra strap with her facing you. Popping the strap is generally considered clumsy, but a sign of someone who maybe spent his points everywhere but wis or dex.

    I keep telling you people charisma is not a dump stat!

  18. Re:Hahahahaha by fractoid · · Score: 3, Funny

    I have a friend who put all his points in dexies and now hes like really nervous and energetic and he dont stop talking and moving around all the time and hes like really active I dont think dexies are as good as you think and he certainly doesnt get to touch boobs.

    --
    Rampant carbon sequestration destroyed the Dinosaurs' tropical paradise. I'm here to help repair the damage.