Slashdot Mirror
Tiny Transistors Could Be Used To Track Cash
disco_tracy writes "Banks have long considered placing silicon transistors on currency for security purposes, but the technology was too chunky and intensive for paper bills. Now, tiny low-power organic transistors developed by German scientists could make it possible to really follow the money."
There goes one of the last mediums of semi-anonymous financial transactions.
Motorcycles, Robots, Space Gossip and More!
Why not just use "Where's George" stamps?
"All your currency are belong to us"
Sincerely,
Your government.
So is your currency invalid if you microwave it?
Support my political activism on Patreon.
Ah I love German scientists 3 Always coming up with great things!
What happens when I launder the bills in my pocket?
Some days I get the sinking feeling Orwell was an optimist.
If I was to say, microwave my bills (completely by accident)...would that make them worthless?
Just as long as these chips are not the default method for identifying counterfeits, I could not care less.
The found conclusively that It almost always ends up at strip clubs.
Tiger Blooded Bi-Winning Machine
Wow, you mean up until this point it simply wasn't feasible to track cash? And now science has provided a way? Thanks, amoral German scientists! This is the best gift you've given the world since mustard gas!
Shutting down free speech with violence isn't fighting fascism. It IS fascism!
No? Too simple? Or can OCR software simply not read the serial numbers printed on the notes?
Ah wait. They want to be able to do it clandestinely... I see...
Deleted
Most of our coinage is already worth more than its denomination in raw materials.....so are we proposing to give (low denomination) paper money the same treatment? I can already see black market micro-transistor harvesting businesses. Either that, or hackers and DIYers are going to start modifying them to make the company whose job it is to track such money miserable. This could almost be fun! If it weren't so 1984-esque.... Oh wait, I forgot, we already have "Where's George?", the voluntary version of this...which is basically a toy, and has no real practical use.
Do you really think Congress would pass a law that would allow cash tracking?
Think of the mayhem such a law would create with the current "system" of campaign financing and "political contributions."
Get real. This will never happen.
and put the chip in people's right hand or forehead...
it might upset a few people though (mostly christians)
Politics is Treachery, Religion is Brainwashing
Didn't the Lone Gunmen demonstrate this in one episode?
I highly doubt political contributions and campaign financing are enacted via cash very often.
Motorcycles, Robots, Space Gossip and More!
linux ?
Nullius in verba
never a better time. see you there? remarkable signs we're surviving/winning might be such as spontaneous outbreaks of caring for one another/our young. dissolution of weaponized empires (recycling) might be another. babies without borders et al? track that.
Do you really think Congress would pass a law that would allow cash tracking?
Think of the mayhem such a law would create with the current "system" of campaign financing and "political contributions."
Get real. This will never happen.
Absolutely!
This is why: they don't want to be soft on terror, drugs, crime, and most importantly child molesters. Because we all know that criminals need cash to do their business.
And as far as campaign contributions are concerned, they've been getting around that for decades.
Get real indeed.
Plausible deniability: Foil lined wallet. Microwave your cash every night. Wear a floppy brimmed hat and stoop when you buy the newspaper with a $20 at 7-11. They may scan the bill, but the cameras can't see your face. Your change is off the map. Purchase items of value (guns, jewelry) from private sellers with this cash. Sell the same way. Money laundering is a continuum, from a Cayman Islands corporation to painting a friend's house for cash.
Oh I don't know. Surely there's some way to spin cash-tracking as stopping pedophiles.
GAAH! MY PRINTER IS ON FIRE!!! PUT IT OUT! PUT IT OUT!
...could make it possible to really follow the money
Every day I find myself wanting a personal EMP generator more and more.
XKCD:Xeric Knowledge Comically Dispen
This was possible 5 years ago. RFIDs, anyone?
what about old and beat up bills?
Somebody makes a modest advance in materials science, and it's hyped into an application. Again. The Discovery crowd is notorious for these.
The usual subjects for this class of hype are batteries, displays, and memory devices.
Not only does that not make sense, it actually creates some sort of anti-sense that renders previously understood concepts incomprehensible. I could do algebra before reading your comment, but not anymore.
How about less than a decade ago, and in a modern democratic country by the Prime Minister
Or were you being sarcastic, and I missed it?
---
"I can't complain, but sometimes still do..." Joe Walsh
You're going to see a lot of conspiracy theory nut jobs microwaving their money.
The web sight and voluntary tracking are no doubt a toy.
However it is a thought provoking toy. I bet all bills get scanned at the bank every time they are deposited. Adding OCR for serial numbers has been computationally trivial for at least a decade, standard fonts and all. There is even a valid reason as many batches of counterfeit cash share serial numbers.
Anybody want to bet the bill counting machines are network connected?
Who works at a bank? Clandestine traffic analysis? If they are tracking the bills it's got to generate a decent amount of traffic, especially by the standards of 10 or so years ago. I bet just looking for it is a fire-able offense. You'd need a reason to be looking at the traffic on the segment, then just forget to turn it off for a week or so.
John McAfee 'It was like that time I hired that Bangkok prostitute; to do my taxes, while I fucked my accountant'
if you have done nothing wrong, you have nothing to hide
most effective in the line for the free TSA prostate exam
the preceding comment is my own and in no way reflects the opinion of the Joint Chiefs of Staff
Manufactured with minute amounts of aluminum and gold using a special dry process, each flexible 250-nanometer-thick array only needs three volts to operate.
This is FED attempt at being funny, 'eh?
"I'm a dirty white tomcat, enter my world..."
sounds acceptably effective. do the math; you+me=(:->-+-
Before such tainted cash even hits the streets, you will be able to buy a shielded billfold, or an inexpensive device that fries the tracking chip.
That, or the smart ones among us will make a concerted effort to displace tainted cash with a new money system. Maybe something like the funny money some communities have started using for local businesses.
-Billco, Fnarg.com
If you truly need to follow all significant money movements, simply stop printing paper money. Force everyone to use credit cards and checks. I mean really. We don't do that because it is an invasion of privacy. There is no need to come up with a NEW way to invade our privacy, we already have enough old ways.
excitingthingstodo.blogspot.com
Bitcoin?
Privacy problems aside: So basically these "tiny transistors" are RFID chips?
From TFA:
These low-voltage transistors could one day provide added security or tracking by transmitting information wirelessly to a scanner.
Security for whom btw? For the banks I assume?
kill off all the old people.
You say that like it's a bad thing. Obviously you've never been to South Florida.
the preceding comment is my own and in no way reflects the opinion of the Joint Chiefs of Staff
and how long will it take to roll this out? 10 years when there lot's of old bill with out this?
and what about install scanners all over the place?
finishes as ++, conversely; you+-+-,,me+-+-=+-+-,,,
This is where bitcoin comes in.
the advantage of banknotes is their anonymity, the abstraction to the underlying transaction of real goods and services.
Do you really think Congress would pass a law that would allow cash tracking?
Think of the mayhem such a law would create with the current "system" of campaign financing and "political contributions."
Get real. This will never happen.
They'll just exempt themselves from the law by finding a "legitimate" need for such an exception.
Only terrorists use inoperable cash!
My first Journal Entry ever, in 8 years! http://slashdot.org/journal/365947/aphelion-scifi-fantasy-horror-poetry-webzine
Thieves will hang around in areas with high pedestrian traffic waiting for someone with a lot of money to come along then follow them waiting for a good opportunity to rob them (i.e. somewhere with fewer people around).
Don't all bills have a unique serial number? So they can already be tracked, just scan the number. What difference does it make if it is electronic or not? The only time it's going to be tracked is when it's scanned.
See after I rob a bank I spend the next few weeks going from crap-shack to crap-shack buyin something cheap and loading anon visa cards with the larger bills. Pick carefully, dont pattern and don't be lazy. Easy if somewhat time consuming way to launder money.
They come in the dark, only in the darkest.
Don't these guys need money to buy candy to lure the kids?
It's quite obvious what we should do: ban candy!
If there is a trackable chip in the cash, how long until someone can count how much cash you are carrying as you walk past. $20 in your wallet, another $300 in your money belt - hmmm good target.
I always though that the dollar bill, as opposed to just any money in the world, was made on purpose easy to counterfeit so that it would be used as the de facto worldwide currency.
Yeah, I'm sure the facts that the US economy is by far the largest economy of any single country in the world by a wide margin and the fact that most money is not printed plays no role at all in the dollar being the world's reserve currency. [/sarcasm] The US maintains about $800 billion in circulation at any given time. This amount while large is dwarfed by the amount of money in circulation that is not printed currency. The US GDP is somewhere around $14 Trillion by comparison.
I mean it's only 2 colors (green and black) and the security measures on it are ridiculous (some hair in the paper, are you serious?).
It's not two colors and hasn't been for a very long time if it ever was. Some of the security measures are easy to see so that people can easily weed out the bad quality counterfeits. Others are less obvious to weed out the better counterfeits. If you seriously believe what you are saying you have basically announced your ignorance to the world. There is no bill that can't be counterfeited. The dollar may be easier than some but it's not nearly as easy as you make it out to be. It's estimated that there are about $70 million in counterfeit US bills in circulation at any given time. Compare $70 million with $800 billion.
it indeed dissolves if you forget it in your pants while using the washing mashine
You've never actually washed a dollar have you? They are remarkably durable and are designed to withstand washing. I've accidentally washed bills on numerous occasions and they have invariably come out just fine. A little beat up but fine.
A nice smooth face hammer should do the trick. I believe that was the solution when they started sticking RFIDs in US passports.
O, I don't know. Seems like 12 seconds in the microwave, or under a steam iron, or maybe thru the delicate cycle in the washer would pretty much render these inoperable.
Terrific. And then when you try to pass these inoperable bills at Walmart they'll run them by a scanner to see if they are real and then refuse to accept them as valid currency. Congratulations! You just literally threw away perfectly good money in a fit of paranoia.
Don't all bills have a unique serial number?
Yes but that is relatively easy to copy and relatively difficult to read. It does get read but few organizations have the equipment to do so with any amount of efficiency. Furthermore a serial number is useless without a database to compare it too. A chip could carry actual data beyond simply a serial number.
So they can already be tracked, just scan the number.
Possible in theory but not really in practice for private enterprise. OCR systems are still quite complicated and expensive. Plus having a chip in the currency allows you to do other things besides simply track where the money is without having to have access to a centralized database.
What difference does it make if it is electronic or not?
Efficiency, plain and simple. The goal is to reduce the cost of tracking. Whether the tracking is a good thing or not is another matter..
So how exactly will this work? Don't bills already have serial numbers? How will embedded transistors be any improvement? Unless these German scientists plan on making flexible GPS receivers with flexible batteries. I don't understand how anything like this could have a negative impact on the anonymity of cash transactions unless it is accompanied by legislation requiring individuals to scan/record the "digital serial number" of any bills exchanged. Which would be truly absurd, and could already be done with the already-existing serial numbers.
Have gnu, will travel.
What stops me from cutting out a piece of the transistors. or simply cutting through them? From the picture in TFA looks like it could be easily cut without fucking the money up.
Do you really think Congress would pass a law that would allow cash tracking?
Yes, in a heartbeat.
---- Booth was a patriot ----
Wheres George? (www.wheresgeorge.com) is a game I play that revolves around user input of serial numbers (and denomination/date to form a unique key)
I listen to both RIAA and non-RIAA stuff if I like the music, tangential business/politics nonwithstanding.
The technology is called OCR. You just optically read the serial number off the bill as it's processed. This is hardly a new thing.
I was under the (perhaps mistaken) impression that this is already done when bills go back to reserve banks for the purpose of detecting counterfeiting.
37 bills all with the same serial number would be a touch suspicious.
Politicians don't mind tracking money... after operation Lost Trust in SC while things got a little less open about taking bribes, the amount of it didn't go down. We've setup a system where other organizations campaign on behalf of a politician... other organizations with no cap on how much money they can receive. What they'll do is make tracking their money illegal, while leaving it legal to do so for anyone else.
Nope, that never happens...
Microwave your money!!
Microwave your money for 10 seconds and it's done.
Privacy is terrorism.
You act like you're entitled by some "right" to store your wealth in foldable form ... You don't.
Actually, I do. And that seems to be the thing that folks like you forget these days. The Bill of Rights was not drafted as a piece of legal paperwork to delineate what rights we Americans have. It was drafted to delineate what rights the Federal government has the power to regulate. Anything not given to the Federal government is left to the States and citizens by default.
That means that I do have the right to carry some foldable form of wealth in my pocket unless it is written somewhere that I do not have that right. That means that I have that right and all other rights, left naturally to me by being a human being, unless they are restricted via a legal document somewhere else (like the right to operate a motor vehicle or practice medicine). So unless there is a law that says, "This and this authority are hereby granted the power to limit the types of wealth that can be carried by an individual, as well as which transactions can be carried out with that wealth..." I have they right to do exactly that which you claim I don't. That's why they are called natural human rights. They exist by default, and we contract with the government to limit them as is necessary to keep society functioning properly. That is all the power the government has.
Rights are naturally endowed at the creation of a human being. Oh, and one more thing:
You act like you're entitled by some "right"....
To quote a fellow 'dotter: Rights are not entitlements.
Motorcycles, Robots, Space Gossip and More!
I heard of this idea of attaching a unique hash value to each bill. This technology would use a suspended polymer with an affinity for cellulose. When applied to the bill this would allow unique tracking of the bill by altering its properties.
I heard of this idea of attaching a unique hash value to each bill. This technology would use a suspended polymer with an affinity for cellulose. When applied to the bill this would allow unique tracking of the bill by altering its optical properties. I don't see how this makes it any easier to track money than using ocr.
"hey mister, can you break a twenty?"
Oh hey, now you're spending different bills than the ones from the bank, AND so is the other random guy. And since the publicly stated point of bill tracking is to kill counterfeit and burglary, you know the random guy YOU initiated a bill swap with is exceptionally unlikely to have hot money to hand you. (It's already exceptionally unlikely now, anyway.) You've broken no laws, AND the bills are still as protected against counterfeit and burglary as they were before.
This works best if a lot of people do it, of course (because then at a high level, the data makes no sense). And even better if everyone still makes the completely innocuous purchases with their 'original' (bank-issued, IDs attached to yours) cash - because then a lot of the tracking numbers become outright impossible unless a chunk of the population are teleporting. You can even go out of your way to instigate false teleports by always doing your trades at one end of your commute and your 'legitimate' transactions at the other end.
And of course, if anyone asks a 'teleporter' why their money is so spread out... "oh, someone asked to me to break a twenty for them." "oh, monthly poker night" "I lost my wallet" "I found a bill on the floor" "paid the neighbor's kid to mow the lawn" and so on. Notice these things in the list are already commonplace to begin with? Your own shennanigans will blend into the crowd.
This is far more paranoid a technique than I would probably end up regularly using myself, but it's a gaping flaw in the system that is probably enough to outright prevent tracking individuals through their cash from even being attempted.
This has been stated long ago. The Globalist want to be able to track each individual with a microchip. When you make a transaction your dollars will be tracked by the cash register. The movie Freedom to Fascism speaks about this very invention. Wake up people this is old news. Our dollars probably already have this technology installed. Go to infowars.com and do your homework.