Slashdot Mirror


Some MacBook Pro, MacBook Air and Mac Mini Models Will Become Obsolete Next Month, Lose Apple Repair Support (9to5mac.com)

An anonymous reader writes: Apple will add certain MacBook Pro, MacBook Air, and Mac mini models to its list of vintage and obsolete products starting next month, which means the products will lose official Apple repair support through the company's retail stores and authorized resellers. Kicking in on December 31, 2016, the MacBook Pro (15-inch, Early 2011) and MacBook Pro (17-inch, Early 2011) will become vintage and obsolete in all markets where applicable, while the Mac mini (Early 2009) and MacBook (13-inch, Mid 2009) will become obsolete worldwide on the same date.

142 comments

  1. That's nice by ColdWetDog · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Six years is a pretty good run an all. That said, I do wish they would actually update the 2011 17" MBP with the nifty matte screen and the upgradable memory and hard drive bays. Oh, an ports.

    A professional machine.

    Sigh.

    --
    Faster! Faster! Faster would be better!
    1. Re:That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Funny

      You would think for the price premium they could keep supporting their products, but that's not how you become the #1 most profitable company on Earth I guess.

    2. Re:That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2

      I wouldn't mind them having those features in the 2017 models. I'd say, keep the "MacBook Pro" line, but rename it, and then produce a true "pro" line of machines designed for photographers, musicians, and others who will pay the cash for a machine that has the reasonable ports for the job, so one doesn't have to carry a backpack full of dongles and hubs with them everywhere. I would say the Dell XPS 13 and XPS 15 are becoming more "MacBook Pros" than what Apple offers.

      Maybe Apple could at least fix the MBPs, so if one uses by accident more than one USB-C device that charges, some e-fuse doesn't blow, preventing anything from charging the battery (as per a YouTube vid showing someone using multiple chargers... result, the MBP just stopped charging for good.)

    3. Re:That's nice by DogDude · · Score: 4, Informative

      Six years is considered "good" by Apple customers? Really? Do y'all only wear your clothes once and buy new cars every year? Just before posting this (insightful) comment, I just purchased a bunch of refurbished mission critical equipment for our business (workstations and servers), all of which are older than 6 years old, and running OS's that are more than 6 years old (Windows 7 for the workstations). Apple's lack of support is a big reason why we don't use their hardware/software.

      --
      I don't respond to AC's.
    4. Re:That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Better than the iPads we bought here. They EOLed them thing less than 18 months after our last order of them. Funny thing though, they are still covered by Applecare (or whatever they call it) and they have given us replacement units as recently as this month. You got that right, we can get brand new replacement units for damage that occurs to the hardware but someone breaks in via a patched vulnerability in later versions of the OS we can't update to and were stuffed. I would talk about left hand not knowing what the right hand is doing, but I suspect they did so on purpose.

    5. Re:That's nice by mindwhip · · Score: 1

      My £500 laptop is still happily trucking on, at a good clip, with one battery replace and a SSD upgrade (surplus part after a desktop upgrade) doing what I need it to after 8 years... only thing I wish it had was USB3 ports.

      --
      [The Universe] has gone offline.
    6. Re:That's nice by I75BJC · · Score: 1

      Wow! Are people really ignorant of how Technology businesses work? Apple has regularly dropped support for older machines. So has Dell, AT&T, Toshiba, Acer, ASUS, Lenovo, IBM. etc., etc. This is a fact of Life with Technology. Computers aren't refrigerators or washing machines with realistic, functional use measured by decades. Grow UP!

    7. Re:That's nice by UnknownSoldier · · Score: 5, Interesting

      That will never happen. :-(((

      Sadly Apple no longer gives a fuck about us professionals -- you know, people who use their computers day in, day out, for creating content. They would rather everyone use iPads for consuming content.

      Why?

      Before Jobs passed away Tim Cook was responsible for getting Apple's supply chain down from months to days. Apple doesn't want to be holding onto millions of dollars of inventory just sitting there taking up space. This means they remove options and "dumb down" the machines so there is only 1 (or very few) parts. Tim Cook has continued this obsession that it actually has become counter-productive. You can't upgrade a MBP to more then 16 GB of RAM because the RAM is soldered onto the motherboard? WTF.

      Apple also has a hard-on for wireless. My current MBP (Mid 2014) has a whopping 7 ports (2x USB, 2x Thunderbolt, 3.5 digital+analog audio, 1x HDMI, SDXC card) and I LOVE it because I use all of them. Apple TV gen 4 removed the audio port because they want everyone to use WiFi streaming. It doesn't take courage to remove an audio jack on the iPhone, they are a bunch of cowards. Gee, oh look, 2 out of 3 "solutions" are wireless.

      It is a far cry from the days of Jobs when he actually cared about building not only a cosmetic computer and a functional one.

      i.e. When is the Mac Pro going to updated?? It has been over 1075 days!

      The only thing Apple cares about these days is making money whilst they whore our their brand. Apple would rather sell over-priced "Beats" garbage headphones to ignorant customers rather then make quality products for the power user. Those days are LONG dead.

      It is hard to argue against "Oooh, Shiny!" when all they care about is profits.

      Apple is Dead.
      Long Live Apple.

    8. Re:That's nice by Narcocide · · Score: 1

      Really? Do y'all only wear your clothes once and buy new cars every year?

      I know you meant this as sarcasm, but...

    9. Re:That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Problem is that Apple has relegated themselves to a luxury band, as opposed to a bread-and-butter item. Come the next recession, Apple is hosed. I don't -need- a MacBook Pro, in fact a Dell XPS 13 or XPS 15 has a higher PPI screen, more ports, and better specs, in an identical form factor for less. An el cheapo Android device or a Google Nexus or Pixel can suffice for everyday needs. Now that Apple has dumped everything but shinies, I don't have a need for any Apple product in a compute environment, as their competitors have better products for cheaper.

      Apple will feel this fact in a recession.

    10. Re:That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      all of which are older than 6 years old, and running OS's that are more than 6 years old (Windows 7 for the workstations)

      So, your bashing Apple customers while running an unsupported Windows OS!? baw haw haw...

    11. Re:That's nice by __aaclcg7560 · · Score: 1

      Apple will feel this fact in a recession.

      Apple was so successful during the Great Recession that Republicans complained about people dropping their extended unemployment benefits on new iPhones and Macs. It wouldn't surprise me if Apple is even more successful during the forthcoming Trump Recession.

    12. Re:That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Six YEARS? Apple customers are expected to throw away their device and purchase the latest model every six MONTHS. Come on - get with the program!

    13. Re:That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      all of which are older than 6 years old, and running OS's that are more than 6 years old (Windows 7 for the workstations)

      So, your bashing Apple customers while running an unsupported Windows OS!? baw haw haw...

      Windows 7 is still supported until 2020

    14. Re: That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Most people who can (easily) afford a MacBook Pro probably do swap their cars more often than every six years. Honestly, I don't think I've ever kept a car for that long...

    15. Re: That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      "Some people just refuse to think before hitting submit, I guess..."

      With that, you obviously do too

    16. Re:That's nice by Just+Some+Guy · · Score: 2

      all of which are older than 6 years old, and running OS's that are more than 6 years old

      hey it's me ur, um, cto. would you please open that email i just sent you so we can, uh, apply some server patches for you? kthx

      --
      Dewey, what part of this looks like authorities should be involved?
    17. Re: That's nice by unixisc · · Score: 3, Informative

      They could have trade-in programs, w/ the replacement being heavily discounted. The price premium of the obsolete boxes should more than cover the discounts

    18. Re:That's nice by Grishnakh · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I'd say, keep the "MacBook Pro" line, but rename it, and then produce a true "pro" line of machines designed for photographers, musicians, and others who will pay the cash for a machine that has the reasonable ports for the job, so one doesn't have to carry a backpack full of dongles and hubs with them everywhere.

      Why should they bother doing this? It'll just cost them more money to have more machines in their line-up. They can just do what they're doing now, keep the number of options very small, to increase profit, because all those people you mention will just buy the port-less machines anyway, plus the overpriced adapters to go with it. Sure, they might complain, but so what? They're not going to forgo buying a Mac.

      I would say the Dell XPS 13 and XPS 15 are becoming more "MacBook Pros" than what Apple offers.

      Nope, because they aren't Macs, so all those Mac buyers aren't going to even look at them.

      Maybe Apple could at least fix the MBPs, so if one uses by accident more than one USB-C device that charges, some e-fuse doesn't blow, preventing anything from charging the battery (as per a YouTube vid showing someone using multiple chargers... result, the MBP just stopped charging for good.)

      Why should they bother fixing this? Are they losing any sales due to this? Of course not. So there's no point in lifting a finger to fix it. I really don't see the problem here. If some people manage to mess up their MBPs this way, then they'll just have to buy new MBPs (or pay $$$ to get Apple to repair them), which simply increases Apple's profits even more.

    19. Re:That's nice by Grishnakh · · Score: 1

      No, they won't. As the other poster pointed out, during the last big recession, (R) politicians were bemoaning that people were spending their unemployment benefits on new Apple gear. Apple lovers would sell their children if they could to pay for new Apple stuff. In the next recession, I expect Apple to be just as profitable as now, with people going to great extremes to gather the cash for their Apple addictions, including going to all-Ramen diets, starving their children to death (literally), moving into their cars, and becoming criminals. There is simply no end to the extent that an Apple user will go to feed his or her addiction.

    20. Re: That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What are they supposed to do, buy all the parts manufacturers including Samsung and Intel?

      If they can't get parts to fix it because they aren't being fabbed anymore, they can't fucking fix it, can they?

      Some people just refuse to think before hitting submit, I guess...

      You must be psychic. So what you are saying is that Apple does not, in fact, have millions of MLB's just lying around in a warehouse? Yea, I totally believe you. Totes.

      Besides, Apple never really REPAIRS anything. That's why they have millions of these parts lying in a warehouse somewhere...

    21. Re:That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The "professional" part of the MacBook Pro is just the console is pretty good for SSH'ing into a Linux box...

    22. Re:That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Pretty sure you're kidding, but of course, anyone in a business context is already aware that workstations and servers of any brand have a 3-5 year lifespan, after which it is more expensive to support than replace. Or the bit where hardware is usually only 20-30% of the bill for a refresh project, the rest is vendor time and licensing (mostly licensing).

      Would you drive an extra 40kms to get fuel 2c cheaper?

      Six years of official support is excellent for any vendor. HPE, Dell or IBM would already have started selling off spare part inventories to third parties for anything not covered by a full support contract (normal carepacks and warranties only go up to 5 years).

    23. Re:That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      " baw haw haw " ? ?

    24. Re:That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I can still get parts and service for a PC over a decade old. Crapple is shit.

    25. Re:That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Six years sounds like the lifespan of a top-of-the-line Canon or Nikon. Why should a computer be any different? They're all electronic disposables.

    26. Re:That's nice by bn-7bc · · Score: 1

      Just one question: Those ipads that got EOLed, where they the most recent model when they where ordered? Personally I suspecr someon gota deal on a model relesed 2-3 years ago(never underestimate a beancinters abbility to save a niccle only for it to bite you in the ass later)

    27. Re:That's nice by eric31415927 · · Score: 1

      Take your WLAN card out and install a mini PCI express USB 3.0 card.
      Hopefully it'll fit and you can find a way to run a cable out of your laptop.

    28. Re: That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Your refurbished machines are still supported by manufacturer? Which ones? Gotta get my hands on some of those :)

      Not talking about OS since OSX is still supported. I'm talkin about hardware here.

    29. Re: That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You CAN actually stock up on extra parts, but DO try thinking before you post next time, agreed.

    30. Re:That's nice by gumbi+west · · Score: 1

      The XPS has "identical form factor"? Ha! where is the unibody?

    31. Re: That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      people like you are the reason we have an international debt problem.

    32. Re:That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Unless apple creates their own chips they will always be at the mercy of Intel, AMD and Nvidia. Most updates are not here because mainly Intel has not delivered any updates.

      But apparently Apple not updating their hardware every three months is like the end of the world.

    33. Re:That's nice by brantondaveperson · · Score: 3, Informative

      As much as I mourn the loss of USB-A ports, it's not quite the case that you need a bunch of dongles. USB-C is pin-compatible, and what you actually need are different leads. USB-C to USB-mini, for example.

      Unsubstantiated claim of seriously broken USB-C support.... or, maybe, it's actually more like this

    34. Re:That's nice by brantondaveperson · · Score: 3, Insightful

      I would say the Dell XPS 13 and XPS 15 are becoming more "MacBook Pros" than what Apple offers.

      People buy macs because of OSX. This is because Windows, even today, is still horrible.

    35. Re:That's nice by brantondaveperson · · Score: 1

      And so are these macbooks / mac minis. What's going to happen to your eight-year old laptop if its mainboard breaks? Same thing as the macbook, you'll get no joy from the original manufacturer, and you'll hit ebay for a kockoff or new-old-stock replacement, and you'll be happy.

    36. Re:That's nice by XxtraLarGe · · Score: 1

      Six years is a pretty good run an all. That said, I do wish they would actually update the 2011 17" MBP with the nifty matte screen and the upgradable memory and hard drive bays.

      This is my current MacBook Pro. I'd replace it in a heartbeat if they released a new 17" matte screen. I don't really care about the upgradable memory or Hard Drive, as I usually order mine maxed out when I do.

      --
      Taking guns away from the 99% gives the 1% 100% of the power.
    37. Re:That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I converted from Windows 98 to Mac OS 9. I feel in love with OS X because it had the BSD underpinnings. Because of the path Cook has taken the company, my next machine (next year or so) will be a self-built machine running a flavor of Linux or BSD.

      It's been a good run, Apple.

    38. Re:That's nice by tgv · · Score: 1

      I got my Late 2011 15" model almost maxed out, but it was no longer sufficient. I replaced the memory (now 16GB instead of 4GB) and replaced the hard drive with an SSD. It's slower than new machines, but only for CPU heavy tasks; for the rest it runs very smooth. Having the possibility of replacing some components adds to a machine's value, to me at least.

    39. Re: That's nice by whit3 · · Score: 1

      What are they supposed to do, buy all the parts manufacturers including Samsung and Intel?

      Well, no, but it would be nice if the batteries could be replaced, or the OS and other software updated to a more recent version. Third-party and counterfeit batteries for a favorite laptop are ... discomfitting. As is finding that my version of a Safari browser can't ever get an upgrade so my bank will talk to it.

    40. Re:That's nice by Dahamma · · Score: 1

      My Dell 2006 laptop is still going strong (with a self-applied memory upgrade, disk upgrade, and battery swap).

      My 2012 Macbook Pro has had several annoying graphics issues I have not been able to do anything about due to the total pain in the ass steps to required even to try to self-repair anything on it.

      Not to mention that the new replacement MBP is a fucking disaster for any actual "Pros" who made the mistake of buying the previous generation (which was goddamn great HW, if unreliable as shit).

    41. Re: That's nice by arglebargle_xiv · · Score: 1

      What are they supposed to do, buy all the parts manufacturers including Samsung and Intel?

      Which is exactly what vendors who provide long-term support do. That is, they stockpile spare parts, they don't buy the manufacturers.

      Some people just refuse to think before hitting submit, I guess...

      Thinking before posting certainly hasn't stopped you, I see.

    42. Re: That's nice by Plumpaquatsch · · Score: 0

      They could have trade-in programs, w/ the replacement being heavily discounted. The price premium of the obsolete boxes should more than cover the discounts

      They have such a program. It's called ebay.

      Now go tell DELL you want a discount on your new computer because you have a 2 year old DELL. I can hear the laughter from here.

      --
      Of course news about a fake are Fake News.
    43. Re:That's nice by FyRE666 · · Score: 2

      You know, some people say this, but give absolutely no evidence for the assertion. I use a Windows desktop and 2015 Macbook Pro daily (as well as Linux on servers) and honestly prefer Win10 to OSX. The file explorer is much more intuitive for me, it handles multiple displays much better, and obviously there's whole gaming thing.

      I think some Mac fanboys probably haven't used Windows since Win 95, and still think it behaves as badly. It's like me comparing Win10 to OS9 (which was truly terrible - I had to suffer through that!)

    44. Re:That's nice by Plumpaquatsch · · Score: 1

      all of which are older than 6 years old, and running OS's that are more than 6 years old (Windows 7 for the workstations)

      So, your bashing Apple customers while running an unsupported Windows OS!? baw haw haw...

      Windows 7 is still supported until 2020

      "Extended" support. Which means less support, not more, in case you are confused.

      --
      Of course news about a fake are Fake News.
    45. Re:That's nice by Plumpaquatsch · · Score: 1

      The "professional" part of the MacBook Pro is just the console is pretty good for SSH'ing into a Linux box...

      Which you'll need to do because Linux doesn't support the graphics card.

      --
      Of course news about a fake are Fake News.
    46. Re:That's nice by Plumpaquatsch · · Score: 1

      I can still get parts and service for a PC over a decade old. Crapple is shit.

      Replacing the motherboard with something roughly the same size doesn't count.

      --
      Of course news about a fake are Fake News.
    47. Re:That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Thank you for using Windows Botnet.

    48. Re: That's nice by Plumpaquatsch · · Score: 1

      What are they supposed to do, buy all the parts manufacturers including Samsung and Intel?

      Which is exactly what vendors who provide long-term support do. That is, they stockpile spare parts, they don't buy the manufacturers.

      You claim that DELL, HP and others each have a storehouse with CPUs, hard drives etc. all at least 7 years out of production.

      --
      Of course news about a fake are Fake News.
    49. Re: That's nice by stealth_finger · · Score: 1

      What are they supposed to do, buy all the parts manufacturers including Samsung and Intel?

      If they can't get parts to fix it because they aren't being fabbed anymore, they can't fucking fix it, can they?

      Some people just refuse to think before hitting submit, I guess...

      So that's why they run on with years old designs selling at premium prices? They buy up all the parts at once and go through them til they run out then buy a new batch and call it a new design. Is that how it works? I guess the designs are so strict and locked down that there's no such thing as an equivalent part.

      --
      Wanna buy a shirt?
      https://www.redbubble.com/people/stealthfinger/shop?asc=u
    50. Re:That's nice by _merlin · · Score: 2

      They lost me as a customer. I used Macs for decades, but I've switched to Dell Precision for my desktop, and when my 2010 MBP dies, I'm sure as hell not replacing it with a Mac. The transition is a pain in the arse, but I'm not wasting my money on the crap they call pro models these days.

    51. Re:That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      Actually I bought an IdeaPad Yoga 13 from Lenovo, so you could say I switched to Windows because I use it more than my old iMac 27 mainly because I can take it anywhere ... I liked Windows 8 and 8.1 although not as much as OSX ... Now I am switching back to a MBP with TouchBar because although I like Windows 10 too (I upgraded), Microsoft (and Lenovo too) can't fucking get their act together!
      1) Coming back from sleep takes between 0 to 10 minutes for no apparent reason!
      2) Windows genius UX designer decided that you could lock screen rotation in tablet mode as long as you wanted to lock it in portrait mode (WTF!)
      3) Disabling tablet mode does not work
      4) Updates sometime reboot the computer while you are working (too hard to test?)
      5) The computer sometime does not go to sleep when I close it!]
      6) So when the updates kick in during the night and I forgot to plug in, next morning I could not even log in! I had to reboot in safe mode to roll back the updates and reapply them
      7) Intermittent freezes for no apparent reason ... swapping?
      8) Starting in portrait mode sometimes at reboot, I have to reboot 1 or more time to reboot in landscape mode ...
      9) Windows 10 crashed a lot at the beginning, but nowadays it has improved a lot ... thank god
      10) Need rebooting every few days or weird behavior or freezing occurs, that also improves little by little ...
      11) The quality of the building seemed on par with Apple at the beginning but now I would say apple wins comparing with my old PPC macbook pro 17 that lasted me 2 times what the Lenovo did
      12) The trackpad sometimes acts on his own, I got used to it but still have some d'oh moments from time to time
      13) I personally prefer Mac OS to Windows since I had my first Mac book pro in 2004, and after switching back to Windows for almost 4 years, I hated windows up to Windows 8, now it is just that I prefer MacOS though ...
      14) The touch screen is not as useful as the new toucher on my Mac even though if it was nice sometimes to touch directly the screen
      15) The input acted weird sometimes and I could only access the computer only using the touch screen but not the trackpad or the keyboard ?!

      Now, I got my new MBP yesterday, I like it already, although the TB while nice and useful did not sweep me off my feet ;)
      The keyboard is good enough for me, getting used to it already
      The build quality is very nice!
      A bit expensive, but I usually keep my Macs 2 times what I keep my PCs, so only more expensive when I have to pay upfront, not really on the long term, considering I have less problems and less stress ...

    52. Re: That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      Please point out an "equivalent part" that can replace a 2nd generation Core i7. Hint: the only ones are other 2nd generation Core i7s, which Intel discontinued and no longer manufactures.

      Go ahead and try to get an equivalent ThinkPad T520 repaired. Guess how far you'll get with that.

    53. Re:That's nice by Megane · · Score: 1

      I would be happy to see an up-to-date version of my Late-2011 17" (bought in mid-2012 and still going strong), with the replaceable RAM (32GB this time, please!) and full 2.5" SATA. I still don't need that Retina crap (producing a Retina screen that large was probably one of the reasons they killed the 17"), but I would be fine with with SSD and SD card slots instead of the optical drive and Express Card slot. And I am even willing to wait a year or so for Intel to finish making mobile versions of their new architecture.

      I'm really not happy about soldering down RAM and even SSD in their latest top-of-the-line "Pro" models.

      Seriously, this thing is the best Mac I've ever bought new, second would be a G4 "Windtunnel" (4 HD and 2 optical drive bays!) that I got at a CompUSA back in 2002 or so that lasted over 10 years and a re-spackling of the CPU heat sink (which took 15 minutes!) before it suddenly died one day such that it wouldn't even turn on. I haven't had time to rebuild it properly, but I have since acquired two Mac Minis from the 2010-2012 era to replace it. Really, 2011 was the peak of good hardware from Apple. It was also the year that Steve Jobs died.

      --
      #naabhaprzrag, #sverubfr-000, #agi-fcbafberq, negvpyr[pynff*=' negvpyr-ary-'] { qvfcynl: abar !vzcbegnag; }
    54. Re:That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I converted from Mac OS 9 to Windows. I feel in love with Windows because it had the DOS underpinnings.

    55. Re:That's nice by Ash-Fox · · Score: 1

      Windows 7 is still supported

      Not for mainstream, mainstream support ended.

      --
      Change is certain; progress is not obligatory.
    56. Re:That's nice by Ash-Fox · · Score: 1

      then produce a true "pro" line of machines designed for photographers, musicians, and others who will pay the cash for a machine that has the reasonable ports for the job, so one doesn't have to carry a backpack full of dongles and hubs with them everywhere.

      When I annecdotally look at current modern day professionals that get commisioned by the industry, they often seem to be less knowledgable than amateurs who are in the field as a hobby... Since they are the ones with the money and are the ones that have a taste for Apple things, I don't think Apple is targetting the wrong market.

      Do you have any data that shows otherwise?

      --
      Change is certain; progress is not obligatory.
    57. Re: That's nice by Ash-Fox · · Score: 1

      Now go tell DELL you want a discount on your new computer because you have a 2 year old DELL. I can hear the laughter from here.

      I actually have a friend that states he always gets a discount from Dell when he uses a line that he's a long term Dell customer and wonders if they have any discounts for that.

      Now whether or not these were discounts readily available regardless, I don't know.

      --
      Change is certain; progress is not obligatory.
    58. Re:That's nice by antdude · · Score: 1

      Steve Jobs need to be resurrected to bring Apple in shape like he did last time. :P

      --
      Ant(Dude) @ Quality Foraged Links (AQFL.net) & The Ant Farm (antfarm.ma.cx / antfarm.home.dhs.org).
    59. Re:That's nice by Megane · · Score: 1

      4) Updates sometime reboot the computer while you are working (too hard to test?)

      That can happen even with Windows 7 on a desktop, but at least you can (usually) reliably disable automatic updates with Windows 7. Enjoy your Redmond spyware!

      my old PPC macbook pro 17 that lasted me 2 times what the Lenovo did

      They were just called "PowerBook G4". I had two of them and one of the first Intel models, all with the "Aluminum" case. They were freaking horrible. I don't know what was worse, the optical drive going out of alignment with the slot in the case (have to field-strip it to eject a disk), the crappy latch (won't stay closed), or the metal surface that pitted like crazy with the skin oils from my hands. The keyboard key tops wore down badly with my touch-typing, too. My Unibody has some keys messed up now, but not nearly as bad after over four years of daily use. And you're comparing that favorably with your Lenovo?

      12) The trackpad sometimes acts on his own, I got used to it but still have some d'oh moments from time to time

      In my opinion, PC trackpads are universally horrible, just less so lately. To be fair, I think part of the problem was Apple buying up the company making the best trackpads, but I have never failed to be annoyed by the "tap to click" feature (enabled by default in mouse emulation mode, so you have to install a driver to turn it off!) giving rogue clicks.

      If I have to replace my Late-2011-17", I'll probably look into a hackintosh on a higher-end laptop. Between EFI, and Apple using so much standard chipset stuff, there are apparently a few good options out there. Also, I only recently upgraded to 10.9, and it's probably easier to get a hackintosh working two or three versions back.

      --
      #naabhaprzrag, #sverubfr-000, #agi-fcbafberq, negvpyr[pynff*=' negvpyr-ary-'] { qvfcynl: abar !vzcbegnag; }
    60. Re: That's nice by v1 · · Score: 1

      actually they DO. When a machine is about to crest the 3 or 5 year mark, Apple re-evaluates inventory. California (and other places?) have extended consumer protection laws that require them to keep a deeper stock of parts. So all remaining inventory generally goes to CA-only repairs. Parts they have way too much of are sold off and will appear elsewhere. At 10 years, CA laws even admit "you need to buy a new computer now and quit trying to repair that ancient piece of junk".

      Some parts that turn out to be very high demand (usually due to recall or design flaw) dwindle before even the 3 year mark, and Apple will stop selling the parts outright, requiring a return of the bad part for rebuilding. (mostly on motherboards) I recall this also being an issue with the older A/B airport cards. We bought a CASE of them juuuust before Apple put them on the restricted list, and we sold every one. I also had the foresight to order as many imac g5 power supplies as I could get my hands on, and we were selling those for two years after nobody else had any in stock. My manager started out by complaining about why I was stocking up so many of them, "don't worry, we'll sell them!" And we did. And no, we didn't even gouge our customers, the price stayed about the same even long after they had turned into unobtainium.

      --
      I work for the Department of Redundancy Department.
    61. Re:That's nice by UnknowingFool · · Score: 1

      I wouldn't hold MS as some sort of an example of support as none of the last 4 are more than 6 years.

      • Vista: RTM 8 November 2006, EOL Mainstream 10 April 2012
      • 7: RTM 22 October 2009, EOL Mainstream 13 January 2015
      • 8: RTM 1 August 2012, EOL Mainstream 12 January 2016
      • 8.1: 27 August 2013, EOL Mainstream 9 January 2018

      Yes you can pay for extended support that goes past these dates but that's a different animal altogether.

      --
      Well, there's spam egg sausage and spam, that's not got much spam in it.
    62. Re:That's nice by UnknowingFool · · Score: 2

      Only if you pay MS lots of money. If it's a server that's almost $600 per year.

      --
      Well, there's spam egg sausage and spam, that's not got much spam in it.
    63. Re: That's nice by Plumpaquatsch · · Score: 1

      Now go tell DELL you want a discount on your new computer because you have a 2 year old DELL. I can hear the laughter from here.

      I actually have a friend that states he always gets a discount from Dell when he uses a line that he's a long term Dell customer and wonders if they have any discounts for that.

      Now whether or not these were discounts readily available regardless, I don't know.

      DELL always has some discounts - that's why you can never be sure what any of their models will cost tomorrow. He doesn't get them because he buys new shit every year, he gets them because he asks what discounts they have right now. Just ask him if he ever got an discount on exactly the machine he wanted to buy. Or if he ever waited a few days an still got the same (or better) offer for the same machine.

      --
      Of course news about a fake are Fake News.
    64. Re:That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why is wanting to limit waste and preferring to use a piece of hardware until it completely dead, a childish behaviour?

    65. Re: That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You appear to be confused. unsupported != extended support. Whoosh.

    66. Re: That's nice by Ash-Fox · · Score: 1

      Just ask him if he ever got an discount on exactly the machine he wanted to buy.

      Yes, he never shuts up about it gven the opportunity.

      --
      Change is certain; progress is not obligatory.
    67. Re:That's nice by Grishnakh · · Score: 1

      but I have never failed to be annoyed by the "tap to click" feature (enabled by default in mouse emulation mode, so you have to install a driver to turn it off!) giving rogue clicks.

      You're the only other person I've ever met who also hates tap-to-click on touchpads. As far as I can tell, we are the only two people in the entire world who don't like this "feature". Everyone else I've talked to thinks I'm crazy because I disable it.

    68. Re:That's nice by painandgreed · · Score: 1

      You can't upgrade a MBP to more then 16 GB of RAM because the RAM is soldered onto the motherboard? WTF.

      No, you can't upgrade a MBP to more than 16 GB of RAM because it uses a low power type of RAM that is limited to 16GB. (Well, it is soldered on but there are no 32 GB RAM units that could be soldered on.) I can't find anything to argue with in the rest of your post.

    69. Re:That's nice by painandgreed · · Score: 1

      Sorry. I take that back. There are 24 and 32Gb chips. Perhaps not at the datarate the Mac is speced for or some other reason. Still, probably not in type that Apple wants to use, as I can't see them passing up the chance to offer 32 Gb version at 3x the normal price.

    70. Re: That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Ummm ... I hate to break it to you, but washers and dryers now regularly break at the three year mark and it's usually a board that costs more than a new machine.

    71. Re: That's nice by Shirley+Marquez · · Score: 1

      You don't actually need a warehouse of old hard drives. You just replace the drive with a current model. Same for optical drives for the systems that have them. You do need a stock of older CPUs and memory, though.

      When a product really becomes unmaintainable (or unmanufacturable) is when an entire class of component goes out of production. That's why Apple had to stop making the iPod Classic, despite the fact that some people still wanted to buy them; nobody was making those miniature hard drives any more. The wholesale price of flash memory has fallen to a low enough level that Apple could have put an SSD in and continued to make the Classic, except that they charge much higher prices for the same amount of flash in their other product lines, and offering it at a lower price in that iPod would expose the lie of Apple's pricing.

    72. Re: That's nice by Shirley+Marquez · · Score: 1

      If you are an individual trying to get such a system repaired, an appropriate CPU can usually be found as a used part, or it can be salvaged from a broken motherboard that is being sold for parts. A large company like Apple, on the other hand, can't do that; they can't get a sufficiently large and reliable source of repair components.

    73. Re:That's nice by Shirley+Marquez · · Score: 1

      I'm another person who hates it. I've lost too much text by accident because of it. But then I don't really like trackpads at all; whenever possible I use a mouse instead. I'll use the trackpad for casual use on the go but not for any serious computing.

    74. Re:That's nice by Shirley+Marquez · · Score: 1

      Basically, extended support means no new features. (It also means no new versions of Microsoft web browsers but the major third party ones usually continue to offer new versions until the OS goes completely out of support.) Bug fixes, security fixes, antivirus updates, and the malicious software removal updates continue. Users can still safely use systems that are on extended support.

      Microsoft offers a minimum of ten years of support of each OS release, though updating to the most recent service pack is required. (Windows 8.1 is treated as a service pack for 8.0 and the upgrade is therefore mandatory to continue to receive support.) That's quite a few years better than Apple is doing. Support of hardware repairs is another matter, but Windows systems generally contain fewer proprietary components so it's usually possible to continue to repair them for a long time. Desktop systems are especially good in that regard and can generally be repaired for at least ten years - perhaps not with official parts from the manufacturer, but with other parts that will work.

    75. Re:That's nice by Grishnakh · · Score: 1

      For my own computers, I normally use the trackpoint instead (which means I make sure to only buy laptops with trackpoints, namely Dell Latitudes). I do use the touchpad for scrolling though, but that's about it.

      The problem is when I'm expected to use someone else's computer, usually to fix something. Total pain in the ass.

      Good to know there's 3 of us out there though!

    76. Re:That's nice by Shirley+Marquez · · Score: 1

      You don't have to pay for extended support out to ten years, and sometimes longer. (Microsoft guarantees a minimum of ten years, but has lengthened the extended support period for some OSes.) You have to pay after that, as you currently do if you want support for XP or Vista.

      Basically, mainstream support means that the OS continues to get some new features, new versions of bundled Microsoft software like the web browser, and support for new hardware. Extended support means that it doesn't get those things, but still get bug fixes and security updates.

    77. Re:That's nice by Shirley+Marquez · · Score: 1

      I'm not sure that Apple is ever going to update the Mac Pro. The new Macbook Pro falls far short of what some high end users want; even more than the ports, the lack of an option for more than 16GB RAM or a truly high performance GPU are problems and suggest that Apple has abandoned high end design professionals. (Sorry, the Radeon Pro 460, the fastest available GPU, can't even match a GTX 1060, let alone the GTX 1080 that you can get in some Windows laptops.) The Mac Pro is pretty much a system that is ONLY for design professionals.

      The kiosk design and all-proprietary parts are a dead end for that kind of system in any case. It means that the system quickly falls behind competitors and is costly to maintain and upgrade. What Apple should build for that market is a tower that has basically the same hardware as a high end Hackintosh with few or no proprietary Apple components, but with the official Apple seal of approval. Choose a quality motherboard from a major maker (Apple likes to use Xeon processors and ECC memory in the Mac Pro, so perhaps something from a server motherboard maker like Tyan), a standard ATX-style power supply from a major maker, one or two high end NVidia video cards, and off the shelf SSDs, hard drives, and optical drives (yes, some design professionals still need those). Offer single and dual CPU socket systems, memory configurations up to at least 64GB, and multiple terabytes of storage. Apple won't sell vast numbers of them (they also don't sell vast numbers of the Mac Pro) but the people who need a computer like that will be happy.

    78. Re:That's nice by Shirley+Marquez · · Score: 1

      Three months wouldn't be the end of the world. But Apple hasn't updated the Mac Pro for three YEARS. The GPU options, in particular, are seriously behind what is now available. (They also haven't updated the Mac Mini for a while, but that's not a core product for them.)

    79. Re: That's nice by Plumpaquatsch · · Score: 1

      You don't actually need a warehouse of old hard drives. You just replace the drive with a current model.

      Sure. Unless the interface changed too much for it to work,

      --
      Of course news about a fake are Fake News.
    80. Re:That's nice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Windows is missing a bash shell, Unix based userland and toolchain. I use Macs because they are UNIX®.

    81. Re: That's nice by Shirley+Marquez · · Score: 1

      Fortunately, the SATA interface standard has been stable for a long time. Most computers built during the time period we are discussing use it, and drives are still readily available. There were enhancements in going from SATA 1 to 2 and then 3, but they are backward compatible. It's true that you might be forced to install a larger disk drive than the one that originally came with the system because smaller drives are no longer made, but the customer is unlikely to complain.

      At the distant edge of the relevant time period there were still some systems that used PATA drives. Getting those is a challenge now. The problem is easily solved for desktop computers with a PATA-SATA bridge board, but there isn't any space to put such a board in a laptop.

    82. Re:That's nice by brantondaveperson · · Score: 1

      I use windows 7 at work, and OSX at home. Maybe my preference is also in some way related to preferring to be at home, rather than at work.

    83. Re: That's nice by Plumpaquatsch · · Score: 1

      Fortunately, the SATA interface standard has been stable for a long time. Most computers built during the time period we are discussing use it, and drives are still readily available

      Sure. But we are talking about reality here, not what should be. Not to mention that you conveniently ignored the "etc." part.

      --
      Of course news about a fake are Fake News.
  2. Not important by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

    Tim Cook said himself that PCs are dead and people should buy iPads.

    The Mac mini has not been upgraded since 2012, which is proof enough that Apple doesn't care about making computers anymore.

    1. Re:Not important by _merlin · · Score: 2

      The trouble with all this is they still need people to create the content for iPad users to consume. Web content can be published from Windows/Linux easily enough with just some testing on target devices, but they still need a viable app development platform. If they alienate developers badly enough, no-one will want to use a Mac even to develop for iOS. What do they do then? Release tools for targeting iOS while developing on Windows or Linux? Part of their sales pitch has always been the "whole ecosystem" argument. Could they really kill that and still survive? They'd probably be reduced to receiving poorly ported Android apps.

    2. Re:Not important by Roadstar · · Score: 1

      The Mac mini has not been upgraded since 2012, which is proof enough that Apple doesn't care about making computers anymore.

      Yep. There is the 2014 Mac mini, but with the quad core options going away and RAM getting soldered with no justifiable reason (form factor didn't change a bit), it doesn't really count as an upgrade. So the Mac mini has not been upgraded since 2012 indeed :P This is quite annoying as my 2011 mini is starting to get rather old.

    3. Re:Not important by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The trouble with all this is they still need people to create the content for iPad users to consume. Web content can be published from Windows/Linux easily enough with just some testing on target devices, but they still need a viable app development platform.

      I think they envision 90% of content being created by users for sites like Facebook. It's going to be a great version of the web with amateurs producing most everything, let me tell you.

      If they alienate developers badly enough, no-one will want to use a Mac even to develop for iOS. What do they do then? Release tools for targeting iOS while developing on Windows or Linux? Part of their sales pitch has always been the "whole ecosystem" argument. Could they really kill that and still survive? They'd probably be reduced to receiving poorly ported Android apps.

      I'm not sure they really care about the Mac line. I think they feel PCs are too expensive and clunky--and everyone just wants to visit Facebook anyway. The few developers can suffer through a less than optimal experience or code elsewhere--it's such a small market that it doesn't matter to them.

  3. History will repeat itself by Sla$hPot · · Score: 0

    Apple is the old Nokia.
    The new Nokia is the old Apple.

    Bet on it!

    1. Re:History will repeat itself by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Heh, the real Nokia makes routers (Alcatel-Lucent) and management software.

      The company that Apple is looking like is Sony. Before the iPod, Sony had the personal electronics industry down pat. Apple swept them away completely. Apple is in the same spot now, with companies like Samsung, Lenovo, and Huawei poised to eat their lunch.

      At least Sony had other consumer electronics to keep them going, as well as a true professional market. Not so with Apple.

    2. Re:History will repeat itself by MachineShedFred · · Score: 3, Informative

      To be fair, Apple had a true professional market not too long ago. Then they started acting like they knew better than the professionals and started making software and hardware that is not suited to meet the professionals' needs. So the pros went elsewhere.

      At one point, the only two games in town for non-linear video edit were Apple and Avid. Then they dumbed down Final Cut Pro and made sure that it only runs it's best on inferior hardware. This has allowed Adobe Premiere back into the game, because they decided to go all-in with CUDA and Nvidia.

      --
      Slashdot still doesnâ(TM)t support Unicode after it was added to the HTML standard in 1997.
  4. Sure. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Ok, that makes sense.

  5. Obsolete? by 0100010001010011 · · Score: 3, Informative

    will become obsolete worldwide on the same date.

    I have a 2006 MacMini. With iMovie '06 it's still the best front end to a Firewire camcorder I've found. The latest kdenlive dropped Firewire import.

    For basic video editing it still works rather well. Transcoding is slow so I export everything in .dv and convert it on a faster machine.

    Doesn't seem very obsolete to me.

    1. Re:Obsolete? by thebullshitpatrol · · Score: 1, Troll

      >I use legacy software, hardware, and ports, and transfer my data to another computer to transcode it
      >hardware in question is not obsolete because I am comfortable gimping my own workflow

    2. Re:Obsolete? by ELCouz · · Score: 2

      Firewire is obsolete...better hurry to upgrade that camcorder! Follow the Apple trend....!!!

    3. Re:Obsolete? by 0100010001010011 · · Score: 2

      Using it to import even older Legacy stuff. Turns out people put a lot of video on VHS. A Firewire VHS deck is still the most dependable option. Every USB RCA 'digitizer' I've found is made by companies long out of business, has lackluster Windows support to begin with and flat out refuses to work with Linux.

      dvgrab works on Linux but you can't view the tape as it comes in. And as I said kdenlive dropped all firewire support with their latest version and the bug is labeled as "won't fix". So please oracle on the internet, tell me a better, faster and easier way to do the above because the workflow I gave is the best I've found. And easy enough that I can pass off to a 10 year old to do.

      Unless you're volunteering to digitize all this stuff, at which point just give me a shipping address and I'll give you an FTP server to dump it on. It's only a few hundred hours.

    4. Re:Obsolete? by alvinrod · · Score: 1

      >I use legacy software, hardware, and ports, and transfer my data to another computer to transcode it

      That's an amusing point to bring up in a thread about a company that's widely criticized here for being too aggressive with dropping legacy ports.

    5. Re:Obsolete? by R.Mo_Robert · · Score: 2

      will become obsolete worldwide on the same date.

      I have a 2006 MacMini. With iMovie '06 it's still the best front end to a Firewire camcorder I've found. The latest kdenlive dropped Firewire import.

      For basic video editing it still works rather well. Transcoding is slow so I export everything in .dv and convert it on a faster machine.

      Doesn't seem very obsolete to me.

      That's fine--it's just not what Apple means when a product becomes "obsolete," which is a term they use to denote hardware for which they will no longer supply official parts for repair, generally those that were discontinued more than 7 years ago (or 5 for "vintage" products, which means almost the same thing except that there are still parts available in certain circumstances). In many cases their software/OS updates still support these machines, and you're obviously welcome to keep using them as long as you want in any case (though I'd personally avoid putting anything without recent updates on the Internet).

      --
      R.Mo
    6. Re:Obsolete? by elfprince13 · · Score: 1

      http://www.apple.com/shop/prod... is what I used to run Migration Assistant in TDM between a 2008 MBP (with FireWire) and 2013 (with no FireWire). I don't do that much A/V stuff, but is there any reason to expect it wouldn't work for your use case?

    7. Re:Obsolete? by thebullshitpatrol · · Score: 0

      It's just interesting to me that people are so interested in moving the goalposts of "obsolescence".

      >my commodore64 isn't obsolete! I am using it to open a serial console on my 2013 macbook pro right now!
      >imovie 06 works just fine for me!
      >i'll upgrade to thunderbolt when you give me a reason to! all's great here in firewire 400 land!
      >windows XP was the last great operating system!!

      I don't understand how this type of discourse is productive at all. Does the speed of the hardware impede your workflow? Does it have holes that current (and more importantly, FUTURE) products stick into? Can you still receive updates and software for it?

      The funniest part is that this type of discussion is being bred in a thread that is literally about apple saying that they aren't repairing older shit anymore.

      "Obsolete". "We no longer wish to expend resources on making this work."

      Interestingly enough, that's usually how someone decides that their personal hardware is obsolete.

    8. Re:Obsolete? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I've used an analog TV PCI card and it just worked with VLC, much better than the crappy software it shipped with and allows recording to lots of fomats.
      Ran it on an old dual P3 workstation recording raw to disk while a modern machine with GNU/Linux with ffmpeg did the encoding.

    9. Re:Obsolete? by evilviper · · Score: 3, Informative

      dvgrab works on Linux but you can't view the tape as it comes in.

      That's not true at all. Linux has no file locking, so you can quite easily view the video file in real-time as they're being created and extended. A simple tail -F VIDEO.DV | mplayer - should work, though adjusting cache sizes might be necessary for some formats.

      --
      Slashdot gets worse every day... Pipedot: News for nerds, without the corporate slant
    10. Re:Obsolete? by epyT-R · · Score: 2

      https://github.com/umlaeute/v4...
      If kdenlive supports v4l2, this might help. I don't have a dv cam to test this with, but the module builds just fine on my x86_64 kernel 4.8.11 system. All I did was clone with git and type make. Your distro might even have pkgs for it.

  6. Apple is Obsolete by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    So is Microsoft. They just haven't figured it out yet.

    1. Re:Apple is Obsolete by Shirley+Marquez · · Score: 1

      Microsoft is working hard on being non-obsolete. Windows may fade away, but Azure and related cloud-based products will continue. That future Microsoft will be a very different company with a different product line, but the prospects for their continuing existence look good.

  7. Apple retires systems all the time by HBI · · Score: 1

    So what's the issue here, beside the fact that their more modern systems are less appealing than those that are being replaced - looking at MBP with the touch bar and the Macbook with one single port.

    --
    HBI's Law: Frequency of calling others Nazis is directly correlated with the likelihood of the accuser being Communist.
  8. First by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    First

  9. as opposed to Windows 10... by anthony_greer · · Score: 1

    which I have running quite comfortably on a 10 year old PC with an extra DIMM or two of RAM...MacOS is nice and Apple HW is good stuff but the whole myth of Apple HW lasting longer than PC is just that, a myth.

    1. Re:as opposed to Windows 10... by __aaclcg7560 · · Score: 1

      Apple HW is good stuff but the whole myth of Apple HW lasting longer than PC is just that, a myth.

      My 2006 Black MacBook is strong running strong with Mint Linux. You can even run Windows 10 on it (see video link).

      The 8-Bit Guy: Is it Obsolete - The Core Duo MacBook?
      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FJw8aSxEFwQ

    2. Re:as opposed to Windows 10... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Windows 10 is likely what I'll do with my Late 2008 when I upgrade.

  10. recalled units? by TWX · · Score: 1

    What about the ones with the graphics processor recall?

    --
    Do not look into laser with remaining eye.
    1. Re:recalled units? by Just+Some+Guy · · Score: 1

      They fixed mine for free last week. If you think yours might need service, this would be an excellent time to get that done.

      --
      Dewey, what part of this looks like authorities should be involved?
    2. Re: recalled units? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Depends on the type of recall and how attached you are to your hardware... Had a 1st gen iPod nano with a safety recall (batteries catching fire) so it had no expiration date. Threw it in a drawer for a few years and then completed the recall process next time I came across it, getting a 6th gen nano with eight times the storage back because they were looooong out of inventory on 1st gen units.

    3. Re:recalled units? by TWX · · Score: 1

      It's work's. It's already messed up and I had to disable the 3d accelerator drivers. I probably should just take it in and get it fixed.

      --
      Do not look into laser with remaining eye.
  11. So what, why is this even a story? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Products go EOL all the time, 2009 isn't a bad cut off year. It is 2016, and those computers would be cheaper to replace than to fix.

    Is someone going to complain that the Apple ][ is no longer supported? No one in their right mind is going to say yes. On a small scale it would be OK due to old infrastructure that will not change for another 30 years because the systems have to meet a set of requirements that are not standard.

    It doesn't make good business sense to support products at a mass scale for long periods of time. These are not craftsman tools with lifetime warranties.
    A few may promise lifetime warranties, with a big ole asterix next to their statements.

    Despite what you may think, computers are consumable items. And most items will no longer be used after 5 years, and by 10 they are almost gone with the exception of a few. The risk is low if the company makes a decent product.

    Maybe they'll be kind and throw $5 at you for your smashed powerbook.....

    1. Re:So what, why is this even a story? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      Not every story has to be an outrage, this is simply information for an audience who uses technology.

      It's informative, but that's about it. But does it really have to be any more than that?

    2. Re:So what, why is this even a story? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Cheaper to replace than fix? Are you smoking crack again, son?

      $500 for a used, average condition MacbookPro8,1 with an i7 $250-ish for a MLB or display assembly, the two most expensive parts.

      My boss has zero problem flipping MBPro's with plenty of profit. You should get your head out of Tim Cook's ass sometime and take a look around.

    3. Re:So what, why is this even a story? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You must be new here. Editors at Slashdot post Apple stories like this to feed their outrage machine in the comments.

      Even though every single computer reaches EOL sooner than 5 years. Salvage value at 3 years is almost nothing. But facts are meaningless to the Slashdot rage crowd.

    4. Re:So what, why is this even a story? by Malc · · Score: 1

      It's 2011, not 2009. Photography is a serious hobby of mine and as somebody who does all their Lightroom work on an early 2011 17" MBP, I'm not impressed. It's still a really decent machine, and LR doesn't perform noticeably better on my 1 year old work 15" Retina MBP, and in fact quite the opposite due to the screen size. These older Macs are certainly not obsolete from this user's perspective.

      BTW, I'm typing this on a late 2007 15" MBP, which is also a good machine, although I wouldn't run LR on it anymore unless I had to.

  12. Defining Vintage vs. Obsolete by davidwr · · Score: 2

    New: New.

    Current: Still being sold.

    Supported: Supported by a vendor or reliable third party.

    Old but useful: Hey, it runs and it's doing something productive.

    Obsolete: No practical use except as a pile of parts, nobody else wants it, *may* have non-negative scrap value if there isn't anything hazardous in it

    Vintage: There is a sucker out there who thinks it may become collectable someday.

    Collectable: Apple I, single-digit-serial-numbered original Macintosh 128K, etc.

    --
    Knowledge is how to play a game, intelligence is how to win, wisdom is knowing what game to play.
  13. Apple Is Right by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Not supporting a generation of devices has nothing to do with Apple.It has however everything to do with users.Apple buys parts in huge numbers and can keep supplylines open much longer.The value of the device however is getting rapidly smaller.Such a six or seven year old device has very little value.Cost of work and parts can easily surpass the value of the device.

  14. Software kills Macs by mspohr · · Score: 1

    I have a 2010 Macbook Air and it still functions but each successive OSX "upgrade" to the software has made it slower and dumbed it down to the point where it is pretty much useless.
    I finally bought a Chromebook which, even though it only has an ARM processor, is much faster and more responsive than my MacBook. I have it set up to switch to Linux (using Crouton it's just a hot key switch) if I need to do some programming or any bash stuff. (Of course, it was much cheaper... and it's much better... even has a touch screen so can fold it back and use it as a tablet)

    --
    I don't read your sig. Why are you reading mine?
    1. Re:Software kills Macs by kamapuaa · · Score: 1

      Holy shit your modern computer is faster than your six year old computer?

      --
      Slashdot: providing anti-social weirdos a soapbox, since 1997.
    2. Re:Software kills Macs by mspohr · · Score: 1

      Yes! And it cost a lot less and I can do more with it...
      What is really interesting is that it has a relatively low performance ARM processor combined with ChromeOS and gives much better performance than my old Intel based Mac. I guess the old Mac would still be just fine if I hadn't "upgraded" the OSX software. Each update seems to have progressively crippled the performance of the Mac. I guess it's bloat and feature creep. Too bad Apple couldn't have kept the OS simple. I don't really appreciate the new UI (and added "features") and I wonder how much this contributes to the decreased performance.

      --
      I don't read your sig. Why are you reading mine?
  15. A thread about non news by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Every company e.g. Dell etc does the same. The fact that you don't know where the list is simply mean or even if it's published means you'll turn up at their service center and they tell you it can't be repaired that's all.

    The fact you can get independent shops to repair stuff is not the point. There are independent shops who can repair macs too, just not as common thought.

    I mean it's just like servers. Things goes into obsolesence about the same 5-7 years and they stop supporting or sell you shit expensive extended support then cut you off in another 1-2 years.

  16. mainly by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    Hardware, sure. But mainly what breaks is software anyway. Batteries for the laptops. And there are plenty of vendors for the replaceable battery designs like the 17" macbook pro (you bought one with a conformal battery, you bought planned obsolescence, deal with it.)

    Apple could do a much better job. They could stop leaving hugely broken OS versions behind them, only to put out yet another version with new breakage, like 10.12, which :frankly: sucks. Sorry, Frank. The 2008 8-core mac pros, for instance, are still great machines. Fast, superior hardware design, hugely upgradable. But the new OS won't run on them. Not "runs unsupported", even -- just "won't run."

    Apple is not your friend. Apple is not my friend. We are something to monetize. Believe it, because it's the truth.

    1. Re:mainly by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Apple has 'courage.' Do you?

    2. Re:mainly by brantondaveperson · · Score: 1

      Unlike, you know, every other company in the entire world. Plus, selling you hardware in exchange for money, isn't what "monetize" means.

  17. Great by thogard · · Score: 1

    I own a few Mac mini (Early 2009) and once they are no longer supported by Apple, they are subject to a full refund should they fail under the local state laws. There have been many rulings involving full refunds for non-supported white goods with one example of a $400 washing machine failing a few years after the warranty with no ability to repair it and the ruling said something along the lines that "the device was expansive and people expect it to last much longer than the warranty period" with ordered a full refund. Similar cases have resulted in orders for a new product to replace the old unsupported one. Since the current Mac mini is slower than some of the older ones and cost over $1,000 with reasonable memory, I can't see Apple winning let alone arguing that it is "obsolete" or "vintage".

    1. Re:Great by ZenShadow · · Score: 1

      Gotta call bullshit on this.

      No court in its right mind is going to force a manufacturer to repair or refund a failed item that's "a few years out of warranty" without the customer having been the victim of some sort of fraud (which a random out of warranty failure is not). That would be an excellent way of killing small businesses, and not a few large ones (or at least driving them out of the area).

      Unless you want to tell us where you are, and provide citations for the cases in question?

      --
      -- sigs cause cancer.
    2. Re:Great by Ash-Fox · · Score: 1

      they are subject to a full refund should they fail under the local state laws.

      As someone who doesn't live in the US, why do people in the US seem to always mention "local state laws" but then fail to mention the state(s) it relates to?

      This is so common, I have to ask, do people in the US not have lingering feelings that this is likely a disingenuous statement because it lacks basic details that are easily researchable like I do?

      --
      Change is certain; progress is not obligatory.
    3. Re:Great by thogard · · Score: 1

      This happens to be in the state of Victoria in Australia but other states here also have strong consumer protection laws that basically say you can't be selling an unfixable product at a premium and not support it. The same is true for much of Europe as well and the few US states that haven't battered down their consumer protection laws.

  18. Meanwhile in NYC Louis Rossmann smiles. by Pezbian · · Score: 1

    Only Official support has been dropped. They can still be fixed for a price.

    --
    In a world of the blind, the one-eyed man is king--and the two-eyed man is a heretic.
  19. Apple are doing what they have done every year... by PhunkySchtuff · · Score: 2

    Apple are doing what they have done every single year - retiring old models from their supported lineup. Film at 11.

    Every year, a range of Macs pass through the range of support status from "Supported" to "Vintage" to "Obsolete"

    Vintage products are those that have not been manufactured for more than 5 and less than 7 years ago. Apple has generally discontinued hardware service for vintage products in most regions other than the state of California and Turkey.
    Obsolete products are those that were discontinued more than 7 years ago. Apple has discontinued all hardware service for obsolete products with no exceptions. Service providers cannot order parts for obsolete products through Apple.

    https://support.apple.com/en-a...

  20. W7 by ishmaelflood · · Score: 1

    Just got a new laptop off the company. 3 year lease. W7. Yeah, they'll support us. They do that.

    1. Re:W7 by UnknowingFool · · Score: 1

      No your company pays MS lots of money to do that.

      --
      Well, there's spam egg sausage and spam, that's not got much spam in it.
  21. Te bollox by ishmaelflood · · Score: 1

    My 3yo laptop is actually a very useful piece of kit, and according to the supplier who has just attempted to replace it with some more modern POS, he needs it back to sell to someone else. I deduce from that it has a market value>>almost nothing.

  22. After 13 years I'm slowly moving away from Apple by Qbertino · · Score: 2

    I added Apple to my hardware selection of Linux boxes back in 2003.
    I like Apple hardware and the new MB Pro is very neat. The huge touchpad, the awesome keyboard and the retina display are are all very neat things. However, after getting an iBook G4 back in 2003 (cheapes Subnote available at the time), a Mac Mini (cheapest mini PC available at the time) a few years later and an MB Air in 2011 (only ultrabook available at the time (the class "Ultrabook" didn't even exist yet), my new machine will be an generic netbook without any OS preinstalled. I'll install linux on it, as usual with non-Apple hardware.

    Why?

    While Apple is quite neat, I'm increasingly wary of the Apple golden cage and their lock-in. Apple pay built into the new MB Pros doesn't help. Also, Apple products arent' so stand-alone innovative as they used to be and the prices have risen. My new machine, coming this week, will be a 300 Euro Netbook with a quadcore CPU and 10 hours of battery time. Vis-a-vis a minimum of 1700 Euros for the new MB Pro that's just to huge a gap to justify the expense.

    Another prime reason for me to get an OS X machine has disappeared: I used to do professional Flash development. Since Flash is basically dead and it is the first and last prorpietary non-FOSS technology I've ever invested time in, there is no reason for me to keep a system around that runs the Flash IDE. Linux is as flaky and obscure as ever, but it hasn't gotten worse and Java (for my Jetbrains IDE) and Web (for everything I develop today) work just as fine as with macOS.

    Homebrew and other FOSS macOS projects such as iTerm are very neat too, but I still trust compling on pure FOSS OSes more. On my MB Air I'm still running Maveriks, and brew starts complaining about the outdated compiler. Since the MB Air is a little to weak for El Capitan, I'm slowly getting stuck between a rock and a hard place with this.

    I might get an MB Pro again some time in the future, but it would be more for kicks than anything else. They build nice machines, no doubt, but Linux for Pros and ChromeOS for n00bs cover 99.99% of the markets needs and costs roughly a 5th. And with Linux I'll be in control until the day I die. Or at least longer than I would be with Apples neatly bound hard- and software packages.

    My 2 cents.

    --
    We suffer more in our imagination than in reality. - Seneca
  23. Been Apple's policy since the 90's at least by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This has been Apple's policy since at least the 90's. Maybe longer. Interesting this made it as an article to Slashdot.
    https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201624

    Vintage products are those that have not been manufactured by Apple for between five and seven years. Obsolete products are those that were discontinued by Apple more than seven years ago. Apple and Authorized Service Providers make no distinction between obsolete and vintage products outside of Turkey and California.

  24. Too slow to update by slapout · · Score: 1

    When people are making external graphics cards to connect to your laptops, you're not updating your laptops often enough.

    --
    Coder's Stone: The programming language quick ref for iPad